business@tribunemedia.net
WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 16, 2020
$3.98 Briland developer slams ‘laughable’ cruise ship claim By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A HARBOUR Island development and its opponents yesterday renewed battle over allegations the project will impose further strain on the destination’s already overloaded water and electricity infrastructure. 4M Harbour Island, the Briland Club developer, slammed Br-Island Responsible Development Association (BIRD) for “laughable” claims it plans to bring cruise ships to its project as the two sides intensified their fire ahead of Friday’s Town Planning Meeting on the project’s second Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA).’ Arguing that the latest assertions “indicate a heightened level of desperation on the part of our detractors”, 4M and its principal, Michael Wiener, said in a statement that while the project would tie-in to the Bahamas Power & Light (BPL) and Water & Sewerage grids as mandated by law it would generate its own water and energy. Despite pledging that it has $3m worth of generators and electrical equipment on Harbour Island, capable of producing three megawatts (MW) of power with the possibility of being expanded to five MW in later phases, the developer’s arguments were met with scepticism by BIRD. A spokesperson for the group, denying all knowledge of any claims linking 4M to bringing cruise ships to the island, confirmed that the extra electricity and water load potentially being generated by the 63 planned residences at the Briland Club was a major concern on the basis it had not been adequately addressed in the latest EIA. They revealed that BIRD has now started a petition on change.org to lobby the Department of Environmental Planning and Protection (DEPP) not to issue 4M’s environmental clearance approvals “until such time as an infrastructure feasibility study is completed for the island and made publicly available for review, and until such time as the concerns expressed by the public are taken into account and incorporated into the development’s plans”. Firing the first salvo, 4M said: “It has been brought to our attention that more misinformation concerning 4M Harbour Island Ltd’s development is being spread by opponents. The latest round of misinformation to hit the rumor mill is that Briland Club intends to bring cruise ships to Harbour Island, and its development will run only off the already-strained water and electrical grids of Harbour Island. “Nothing could be further from the truth. Briland Club is unaware of (and not involved with) any effort to bring cruise ships to Harbour Island. The mere thought is laughable and indicates a heightened level of desperation on the part of our detractors.”
SEE PAGE 3
$3.98
$4.02
Investigation demanded over China’s alleged BTC ‘spying’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
A
“SERIOUS investigation” was demanded yesterday into allegations that China has exploited the Bahamas Telecommunications Company’s (BTC) mobile phone network to spy on US citizens. BTC, which is 49 percent owned by the government, told Tribune Business in a statement it was “carefully reviewing” claims - first published in the Guardian newspaper in the UK - that state-owned Chinese communications providers had used its systems to conduct surveillance on Americans roaming on their mobile phones in The Bahamas. “Across all the markets where Cable & Wireless Communications (CWC) operates, including The Bahamas, we continuously monitor our networks and have robust security policies and protocols in place
• Carrier ‘carefully reviewing’ surveillance claims • Mobile network ‘used to eavesdrop’ on Americans • National security and economic fears ‘if true’
BTC HEADQUARTERS to protect the data of our customers. We take our commitment to data protection seriously, and are carefully reviewing the information in the Guardian article,” BTC said. Other CWC subsidiaries in the Caribbean, especially Barbados, were also identified as major sources of these alleged breaches which - if true - have huge national security and
economic implications for The Bahamas, as well as its ability to safeguard the personal data and civil liberties of both its own citizens and US visitors that make up 85 percent of its tourism market. The assertion that major security vulnerabilities exist in the Bahamian telecommunications system was based on a report by Gary Miller, a US former mobile
THE Bahamas National Trust’s (BNT) president last night said its rejection of the proposed $580m South Abaco project shows “we are definitely not swayed” by a developer’s donation pledges. Eric Carey told Tribune Business that the Trust’s stance proved it will not “cut short our approach or high environmental standards in fully reviewing” the Tyrsoz Family Holdings development despite its principal promising to donate $1m to aid its efforts to approve the Abaco National Park. Acknowledging that many may have viewed Ra’anan “Ronnie” BenZur’s offer as “a quid pro quo” to ensure the BNT’s support, Mr Carey vehemently rejected this interpretation. While conceding that it would have to work with the developer if the government approved
ERIC CAREY the project, he said “our choice” was that it not proceed given its location in an area of extreme environmental sensitivity. “People thought there was a quid pro quo arrangement,” Mr Carey explained of Mr Ben Zur’s offer, “but no. If the development gets approval it will be in close proximity to the Abaco National Park, and we will
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)” submitted by Mr Ben Zur, and added: “The proposed development will directly reduce the quality and quantity of habitat available for bonefish, Bahama parrots, and numerous other commercially and culturally important species. “This threat is compounded by the proposal’s economic shortcomings, which could undermine the project’s success, leaving large areas of pristine terrestrial and marine ecosystems decimated. While the proposal includes plans to mitigate some environmental damages, these measures are not enough to justify the environmental
SEE PAGE 7
SEE PAGE 6
network security executive, who was said by the UK Guardian to have “spent years analysing mobile threat intelligence reports, and observations of signalling traffic between foreign and US mobile operators”. Miller and his business, Exigent Media, a cyber threat research firm, have published two reports that detail how BTC’s mobile phone system was purportedly used in a “coordinated attack” on US cellular phone numbers by Chinese state-owned mobile providers. The first report, Far from home - active foreign surveillance of US mobile users, argued that international roaming - the practice whereby Bahamians use a
SEE PAGE 6
• Stands in ‘direct opposition’ top $580m project • Rejects ‘quid pro quo’ notion on South Abaco • Argue that ‘size and scope’ simply don’t fit have no choice but to work with the developer, but our choice is this development does not take place because the size and scope do not fit with what is in place in Abaco. “We are definitely not swayed by any amount of money in the project proposal to cut short our approach, our high environmental standards, in reviewing this project.” Mr Carey spoke out after the BNT, in a statement, said it had joined the Sustainable South Abaco coalition in “direct opposition” to the Tyrsoz Family Holdings project obtaining the necessary environmental approvals to proceed as is. The environmental watchdog body said its decision was based on a “thorough review of the
No protest ‘ducking’ by oil drill ship ENVIRONMENTAL activists yesterday said they were “extremely concerned” that time is rapidly running out to halt Bahamas Petroleum Company (BPC) after its drilling ship “ducked” their welcome. Joseph Darville, of the Coalition to Protect Clifton Bay (Save the Bays), told Tribune Business that his preparation of banners at Freeport Harbour proclaiming the group’s opposition to oil exploration in Bahamian waters had been in vain after the Stena IceMAX anchored well out to sea between the Berry Islands and Grand Bahama. “They ducked our protest,” he said. “They had word there would be marine and land protests, and decided it would be better to anchor out there between the Berry Islands and Grand Bahama.” However, a source familiar with BPC’s plans said there had been no “ducking” as there had never been any intention of the Stena IceMAX coming into Freeport. Mr Darville, meanwhile, said there had been significant air and sea activity with a helicopter and boats frequently racing between Freeport and the drilling ship to deliver both men and equipment. A support ship was also said to be present offloading drilling gear. With time now against the activists to stop BPC’s plans, given that it intends to begin drilling its first exploratory well in waters 90 miles west of Andros on Sunday - just four days away - Mr Darville added: “We have it in the court. It’s up to the judge to give us a hearing but we’re hoping we’ll be able to get a stay before they actually begin drilling. “I am extremely concerned but, even at the last hour, if the dictum given by the court is to cease drilling they have to stop. Even at the last hour, or 11th hour, they have to stop drilling if the court dictates such.”
BNT ‘definitely not swayed’ by developer’s $1m pledge By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
$3.98
Taxpayers ‘sacrifice’ to pay Water Corp wages By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
A CABINET minister last night reminded the Water & Sewerage Corporation’s two unions the utility “loses money every day” after they moved to cut-off all contact with its chairman and general manager. Desmond Bannister, deputy prime minister and minister of works, told Tribune Business both the middle management and line staff needed to see the wider picture and appreciate that “there will be Bahamians who cannot eat and feed their families this Christmas” as they launched “stage one” of
• Minister tells unions: Others won’t eat at Xmas • Comes as ties severed with chair, top manager • Union chief warns over ‘three stage’ action
DESMOND BANNISTER
ADRIAN GIBSON
DWAYNE WOODS
their industrial action. He added that he planned to meet leaders from the Water & Sewerage Management Union (WSMU) and
Bahamas Utilities Services & Allied Workers Union (BUSAWU) tomorrow after the two, in a joint statement entitled “enough is enough”,
called on their members to block all phone calls from Adrian Gibson, executive chairman, and Elwood Donaldson, the general manager.
Besides severing communications with the state-owned utility’s top management, the two unions took their non-cooperation further by urging members to “immediately exit all Water & Sewerage Corporation What’s App chat groups” and “turn in all cell phones” belonging to the utility. Such action, if union members follow through, threatens to paralyse the corporation’s operations over the Christmas season as senior management will not be able to communicate or issue instructions to the junior executives and line staff.
SEE PAGE 10