12132019 BUSINESS

Page 1

business@tribunemedia.net

FRIDAY, DECEMBER 13, 2019

$4.56

$4.57

‘No clue’ over $300 minimum wage hike

$4.65

$4.65

Governance reformer: $210 minimum wage can’t meet living cost By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

T

HE Chamber of Commerce’s top workforce specialist yesterday revealed he has “no clue” where the director of labour’s assertions about a $300 weekly minimum wage originated from. Peter Goudie, who is also the National Tripartite Council’s vice-chairman, told Tribune Business he “did not appreciate” John Pinder wrongly suggesting that body had been discussing the issue of a public sector minimum wage hike “for some time”.

• Never discussed by National Tripartite Council • ‘I don’t know where John Pinder coming from’ • Vice-chair: Issue will only be ‘reviewed’ in ‘20

Speaking after the council met yesterday, Mr Goudie said it had not discussed the minimum wage - and its potential increase - since 2015, and he did not foresee any increase for either the public or private sector “at the moment” as the matter will only be reviewed next year. He pointed out that the council, which is the primary authority for addressing all PETER GOUDIE

JOHN PINDER

SEE PAGE 4

Blacklisting: Ex-AG fears others will follow France By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

AN EX-ATTORNEY general yesterday warned that France’s “blacklisting” of The Bahamas may entice other countries to follow suit, and urged this nation to seek US help in defending its interests. John Delaney, principal of the Delaney Partners law firm, told Tribune Business that the French government was likely “trying to score political points at the expense of places like The Bahamas” with its most recent action. Suggesting it was trying to impress voters through the perception of cracking down on tax cheats, Mr Delaney said countries such as France incurred “little cost to themselves” by targeting The Bahamas and other small states who

• ‘Little cost’ to targeting The Bahamas • Use US as counterweight, nation told

JOHN DELANEY suffered tarnished reputations and a potential loss of business as a result. While the French action was unlikely to have much actual impact upon the financial services industry and broader economy, he added that the international services hub model could

Customs won’t accept ‘garbage information’

By YOURI KEMP Tribune Business Reporter ykemp@tribunemedia.net A TOP Customs official yesterday warned its new system will not accept “garbage information” as a Bahamian firm unveiled software designed to smooth the Click2Clear user’s experience. Information Specialists Bahamas (ISL), a software development company, yesterday demonstrated at Customs’ headquarters its SWIM solution that is designed to ease the declaration process and related hassles endured with the

Electronic Single Window (ESW) system. Jasmine Hudson, superintendent of Customs and lead administrator for the system, said of ISL’s solution: “All businesses and individuals that import goods must be registered on the single window, and this system is one of the systems that allows the process of submitting your declarations to us to be more easier and smoother. “We have companies that are presently using this system, and systems similar to this, and it has made

SEE PAGE 5

Bahamas ‘too profitable’ for an RBC exit By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

A FORMER finance minister yesterday voiced optimism that The Bahamas is “too profitable” for Royal Bank (RBC) and its Canadian rivals to abandon following their eastern Caribbean exit. James Smith, also an exCentral Bank governor, told Tribune Business that RBC and Scotiabank were unlikely to leave this nation and the other major regional territories given the greater earnings, product ranges and business activities on offer.

Speaking after RBC yesterday confirmed it was following the latter’s lead by selling its business operations in seven smaller Caribbean nations to a consortium of local banks, Mr Smith suggested none of the three Canadian-owned banks (CIBC FirstCaribbean retains that status for the moment) are likely to depart “any time soon”. “They have no interest in leaving The Bahamas,” he argued. “I say this because The Bahamas has always been rather profitable for them, and the range of

SEE PAGE 6

ill-afford any hit to its “general standing” especially given its two-decade long effort to meet ever-evolving global standards. “My greater concern would be other jurisdictions following suit,” Mr Delaney told Tribune Business. “The French action, in and of itself, is of limited impact. It just tarnishes, though, and it’s not nice to have a major country put us on their blacklist. “It’s disparaging and not good for business, but in terms of having an impact and difficulties getting in the way, it’s of less concern. It’s more about reputation. It’s not helpful or desirable for a major jurisdiction to be blacklisting us from a PR perspective and general

standing, whether in financial services or as a country that is engaged in international trade. “We don’t wish to have these things said about us, particularly when we’ve gone to great lengths to operate in a manner that is compliant with international standards. It’s just extremely disconcerting and very unhelpful in terms of The Bahamas doing international business, and there doesn’t appear to be anything fair in the way France has gone about it.” Several financial industry contacts have suggested it is ironic that France should “blacklist” The Bahamas now given that all its

SEE PAGE 4

A GOVERNANCE reformer yesterday argued it is impossible to live on a $210 weekly minimum wage because “the Bahamian cost of living is too high”. Robert Myers, the Organisation for Responsible Governance’s (ORG) principal, told Tribune Business that the oft-recurring debates over the minimum wage exposed the “socio-economic challenge” created by high electricity costs and taxes. “You can’t live on $210 per week,” he said. “When VAT was put up from 7.5 percent to 12 percent, I don’t know how you can live on $210 a week. Based on today’s socio-economic challenges that wage is too low, but one of our problems is that the Bahamian cost of living is too high. “The higher your costs of living are, the more people are pulling away from our shores who are seeking a higher quality lifestyle at lower costs. I can assure you that during conversations around the dinner table that I’ve been privy to, people have been saying the cost of living is too high - especially for the elderly living off their pensions and savings.” Suggesting that the only exemptions from the minimum wage should be for summer students and temporary workers employed for a specific period of time, Mr Myers said this issue was separate and apart from his concerns over escalating government costs and bureaucracy. He said he was becoming “worn out” by the failure to seriously discuss productivity and efficiency reforms in the public sector. “What still baffles my mind is they are not talking about accountability and efficiency in the public sector,” Mr Myers said of policymakers and politicians. “Increasing

the minimum wage is one thing, but we’re not hearing anything about productivity. “We’re still paying the money and getting lousy service. If we’re paying higher taxes and fees to the government and getting incredible service, that’s more palatable. But when you’re paying higher taxes and getting lousy service it’s not tolerable. The discussion with then unions and others should be how to improve efficiency and productivity, which means we do more with less. “We should have been having that conversation 40 years ago, but at the very least we need to be having it now given the grave fiscal challenges the country faces. I’m worn out by the endless discussion on how to increase costs and taxes without any discussion of increasing productivity and efficiency and lowering costs. It’s tiresome,” he added. “They always take the easy route and continue to kick the can down the road. That can only happen for so long, and we’re approaching a dangerous fiscal position. There seems to be a lot of conversation about how it’s going to increase costs and taxes and everything else, and very little on how to increase efficiency, quality of services and productivity. That’s what hurts.” Mr Myers reiterated that ORG was ready to work with the Government and public sector on ways to improve transparency and accountability, and renewed his call for The Bahamas to pass legislation similar to New Zealand’s State Sectors Act. Calling on permanent secretaries, department heads and leaders of state-owned enterprises (SOEs) to take the lead in the absence of any government directive, he said: “Everybody knows the problems; let’s get on with it. Take the initiative. If the government won’t, maybe the public sector will.”


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.