12042018 BUSINESS

Page 1

business@tribunemedia.net

TUESDAY, DECEMBER 4, 2018

$4.80

$4.82

Legal battle to restart on web shop taxation By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

T

HE Government and web shops will resolve their dispute over the industry’s “sliding scale” tax structure in the courts, it was revealed yesterday, despite making progress on the “patron tax”. Wayne Munroe QC, who represents the Island Game and Paradise Games chains, told Tribune Business that both sides “identified one area where we have to go to court” when they met yesterday in a bid to narrow differences over the industry’s new taxation structure. He identified this “area” as the “sliding scale” taxation structure imposed on web shop operators in the 2018-2019 budget, where they are to be taxed at a progressively higher rate the more “taxable revenue” they earn.

* Parties ‘limiting’ fight to ‘sliding scale’ * QC: Clients believe no taxes owed * But ‘progress’ made on patron tax

WAYNE MUNROE QC Mr Munroe’s account was backed by Carl Bethel QC, the attorney general, who told this newspaper that it was “unlikely” that the Government and web shops would be able to completely avoid the resumption of their legal battle.

CARL BETHEL QC He added that yesterday’s discussions had focused on trying to “limit” the areas in dispute while ensuring that the Government still received due tax revenues from the sector pending the Supreme Court’s verdict in the litigation.

Mr Munroe, though, revealed that his web shop clients believe no taxes are currently owed by any operator. He based this on a combination of the Government repealing the old tax structure in the budget, but then failing to properly replace it because it used incorrect language to describe the basis for the “sliding scale” taxation. While the Government has subsequently corrected this by tabling amendments to the Gaming Act’s regulations in the House of Assembly and Senate, these have not been given effect through an appearance in the Government’s Gazette. Mr Munroe also pointed

SEE PAGE 5

$4.56

$4.66

Give Bahamians ‘first rights’ over BTC outsourcing By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE prime minister was yesterday urged to ensure Bahamians “have first rights” on all outsourcing opportunities at the Bahamas Telecommunications Company (BTC) if downsizing continues. Dino Rolle, pictured, the Bahamas Communications and Public Officers Union’s (BCPOU) president, told Tribune Business he also requested that the Government use its 49 percent equity stake and three BTC board seats to improve any future voluntary separation packages that may be offered to the carrier’s staff. Mr Rolle said he made his requests at the side of yesterday’s meeting between the prime minister and multiple trade union leaders, as he warned that the BCPOU will “not sit on our hands for ever” if its grievances

are not resolved. He reiterated that BTC and its chief executive, Garfield “Garry” Sinclair, appear “not to be interested” in addressing union calls to negotiate new industrial agreements along with concerns over job losses stemming from the possible outsourcing of the country’s call centre to other nations. “One of the things we expressed to the prime minister was that if the company wishes to continue its downsizing they have to revisit the formula of the old VSEPs (voluntary separation packages) since much has changed in the country since they were first implemented in 2011,” Mr Rolle told Tribune Business, “and Bahamians should have first rights to any outsourcing.” He added that the BCPOU’s efforts to “get

SEE PAGE 5

Airbnb’s October Unions give PM month to avoid ‘national strike’ bookings up 50% By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net STOPOVER tourist visitors to The Bahamas increased by 7.4 percent over the first three quarters of 2018 with the Central Bank forecasting “continued economic strengthening” through year-end. The regulator, unveiling October’s monthly economic developments report, said Baha Mar’s full opening and improved economic performance/ confidence in key tourism source markets was fuelling

expansion in The Bahamas’ largest industry. Despite a firming in inflation to 1.75 percent for the year to August, due to a combination of VAT rate hike and spiking global oil prices that were felt in higher energy and gasoline prices, the Central Bank said external factors continued to maintain the economy’s momentum/ In particular, The Bahamas saw a 50.5 percent year-over-year growth in short-term vacation rental bookings via Airbnb compared to 2017, although

SEE PAGE 4

By NATARIO MCKENZIE and NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Reporters TRADE union leaders yesterday warned the prime minister he has a month to resolve multiple labour disputes otherwise “he’s going to have a national strike on his hands”. Paul Maynard, the Bahamas Electrical Workers Union’s (BEWU) president, told Tribune Business that he was “just dumbfounded” by the magnitude of the problems exposed by other public sector union leaders during their morning meeting with Dr Hubert Minnis. Suggesting that “threequarters of the problem” stemmed from “a lack of respect” shown to trade unions by various government agencies, Mr Maynard

* 80% of unions have filed trade disputes * Slam ‘lack of respect’ by govt agencies * Call on Minnis to ‘read the riot act’

PAUL MAYNARD urged the prime minister to summon the relevant chairmen and vice-chairmen and “read them the riot act”. He was backed by Bernard Evans, the National Congress of Trade Unions

BERNARD EVANS (NCTU) president, who yesterday said 80 percent of trade unions have current trade disputes that have yet to be resolved. With Bahamian industrial relations “in terrible shape”,

the BEWU president said Dr Minnis yesterday realised for the first time the extent of the “devastating situation” confronting his administration unless immediate action was taken. He added that while damaging industrial action, including strikes and labour withdrawals, can still be avoided, the Ministry of Labour has “got work to do” within a very limited period of time. “Really and truly the kind of problems other unions in this country have is just

SEE PAGE 6

Hotel union: We ‘won’t talk much longer’ with Atlantis

By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

THE hotel union will “not talk for much longer” in seeking a resolution to its dispute with Atlantis, its president yesterday pledging: “We won’t allow them to dictate to us.” Darrin Woods, pictured, the Bahamas Hotel, Catering and Allied Workers Union (BHCAWU) chief, told Tribune Business that an “emergency meeting with shop stewards” will be called after the two sides made little progress in narrowing their differences during yesterday’s meeting at the Department of Labour. He revealed that John Pinder, director of labour, had asked Atlantis to reverse implementation of its new “12 point” disciplinary system - one of the two issues that sparked the dispute. Resort executives,

* Calls ‘emergency meeting’ with shop stewards * And warns that ‘go slow’ next possible step * Says little progress in yesterday’s talks

ATLANTIS PARADISE ISLAND

though, said they needed more time to assess the request and “asked for an extension until Friday”. Mr Woods, arguing that Atlantis stuck to the position it adopted at last Thursday’s meeting, said the resort wanted to

effectively “have its cake and eat it” by seeking to introduce the new disciplinary system without first negotiating with the union to have it incorporated into their industrial agreement. The union’s 5,000 members are already on a “work-to-rule” at Atlantis and other major New

Providence hotels, and Mr Woods warned that “a go slow” will be the next step should leadership and members decide further action is necessary. He promised that the union will “exercise its rights under the Industrial Relations Act” while talks are ongoing, and said it was “not going to rule out” further industrial action - including a strike/withdrawal of labour - if efforts to resolve the dispute with Atlantis prove unsuccessful. While those comments may send a chill throughout the resort/tourism industry ahead of the upcoming key Christmas season, Mr Woods reiterated that the

SEE PAGE 7


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.