business@tribunemedia.net
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 30, 2020
$3.98
$4.03
$3.92
$3.95
Grand Lucayan deal woe as February reopen eyed By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
* Resort can’t become ‘wasting asset’ * Chair’s ‘no faith’ in ‘bad’ Holistica deal * Board mulls options; awaits KPMG review
T
he Grand Lucayan’s Board is mulling a February 2021 re-opening in a bid to prevent the resort from becoming a “wasting asset” amid the growing uncertainty surrounding its potential sale. Michael Scott QC, chairman of Lucayan Renewal Holdings, the Governmentowned vehicle that owns the resort, told Tribune Business he and the Board were “considering a number of options” as it awaits the results of the KPMG probe into the merits of the revised ITM Group/Royal Caribbean deal. Confirming this newspaper’s exclusive revelations of last week, Mr Scott said he personally views the
THOMPSON sale to the duo’s Holistica partnership as “a bad deal” that does not create sufficient immediate benefits for the Bahamian people after the commercial terms were watered down due to COVID-19. KPMG and its accounting team have been hired to provide an independent opinion on whether this is the case, but the Lucayan chairman said he did “not
ACTIVISTS: STUDY EXPOSES OIL’S ‘ROLL OF THE DICE’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net OIL exploration opponents yesterday said their demands for a drilling halt are justified by a study showing The Bahamas must match almost 60 percent of US offshore crude output to fully offset all economic risks. Fred Smith QC, the Callenders & Co attorney and partner, told Tribune Business that the report produced for his clients, the Our Islands, Our Future coalition, exposed why the Government’s decision to give Bahamas Petroleum
Company (BPC) the go-ahead was such “an astonishingly irresponsible roll of the dice”. The study, by Sea Change Economics, said The Bahamas would likely need to produce more than 403.553m barrels of oil annually - should commercial quantities be found beneath its seabed - to match the combined annual $7.89bn contribution to national gross domestic product (GDP) by the tourism and fisheries industries. Those two sectors are thought to be the industries most at risk from any
SEE PAGE 6
COVID TESTING SYSTEM’S PROVIDERS AWAIT PAYMENT By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A CABINET minister last night disclosed that the COVID-19 visitor testing system’s providers have yet to be paid as the Government determines the most efficient mechanism for getting funds to them. Dionisio D’Aguilar, minister of tourism and aviation, told Tribune Business that monies collected from the $40 per head Health Travel Visa were currently “sitting in an account” with Bahamian digital payments
provider, Kanoo, waiting for instructions on how it will be disbursed. Responding to questions from Fred Mitchell, he said the Opposition senator can “rest assured I am guarding the people’s money to ensure we get the best possible deal” for getting it to providers such as the Health Travel Visa scheme’s insurer, the former Atlantic Medial Insurance that is now known as CG Atlantic Medical & Life. Adding that he “invited” scrutiny, and has “nothing
SEE PAGE 7
have any faith in it” as the sale conditions stand now. Suggesting that his views were shared by other Board members, Mr Scott said he was pushing for KPMG to complete its review within “the next couple of weeks” with the directors now looking at “other viable options” for the Grand Lucayan’s future in case the ITM Group/Royal Caribbean deal fails to materialise. “The Board is considering a number of options including opening the hotel some time in February,” he told Tribune Business. “It’s always very hard for a hotel
property to sit their fallow as a wasting asset. One has to think carefully about this, but it doesn’t help the economic situation of the country, and of Freeport, to have it sitting there as a wasting asset.” Other sources, speaking on condition of anonymity because they were not authorised to talk publicly, said the Board was proposing to recommend to the Government that it re-open the Grand Lucayan on February 1 next year following its summer closure in anticipation the ITM Group/ Royal Caribbean deal would have closed by now.
The phased termination of the remaining 208-strong workforce began in June, with total termination packages since the Government acquired the Grand Lucayan in September 2018 likely to cost taxpayers more than $11m. Now the Government/ Lucayan Renewal Holdings face the prospect of having to hire at least some of those staff back if it follows through on a February 2021 re-opening in a bid to revive at least something of a stopover tourism product for Freeport amid the ravages of COVID-19. Much may yet hinge on the KPMG
review’s outcome. “KPMG is doing a review of the merits or otherwise of the Bahamas Port Investments (ITM/Royal Caribbean) proposal, which I view as a bad deal, so that we can have independent evidence that either supports or does not support that proposal. “I don’t personally have any faith in it, and one has to think laterally and consider other options, and look at another sale or lease options.” Mr Scott declined to give details on why the revised ITM/Royal Caribbean offer was “a bad
SEE PAGE 3