business@tribunemedia.net
THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 15, 2018
$4.99
‘Way too early to celebrate’ BOB’s 199% profits rise By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A PROMINENT Bank of The Bahamas (BOB) shareholder yesterday warned it was “way too early to celebrate” its 199 percent first quarter profits increase as multiple concerns remain. Darron Cash, pictured, the former Free National Movement (FNM) chairman, told Tribune Business that “the jury is still out” on whether the BISXlisted institution can sustain a performance that saw net income near-triple to $1.966m for the three months to end-September. He described BOB’s loan book quality, with 28.92 percent or $101.648m of the net portfolio in default at end-June 2018, as likely “the greatest risk” to achieving consistent profitability.
SEE PAGE 4
THE Ministry of Finance’s top official was yesterday “fairly confident” that the new business licence regulations can be adjusted to achieve the Government’s goals without being “onerous” for business. Marlon Johnson, speaking to Tribune Business after a grilling from Bahamas Institute of Chartered Accountant (BICA) members over the demand for bank account details to accompany filings by companies generating less than $10m in annual turnover,
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
T
HE Government was yesterday accused of “disrespecting” the web shop industry by setting an arbitrary end-of-week deadline to resolve their differences over the five percent patron tax. Wayne Munroe QC, the attorney representing the Island Game and Paradise Games chains, told Tribune Business that the Government seemed determined “not to consult our clients” with the industry yet to receive a response to its recommendations on the draft rules that will govern the stamp duty levy on customer deposits and over-the-counter lottery ticket sales. He and his fellow attorney, Alfred Sears QC, who is acting for Sebas Bastian’s Island Luck group, both submitted their responses to the Government’s first draft of the rules before end-October but have
said “poor bookkeeping habits” had prompted the Government to take this measure. Responding to growing private sector concerns that the regulations, enacted on May 30, amount to “overkill” and unnecessary “red tape” given that business licence fees are calculated solely on top-line turnover, Mr Johnson said the imminent publication of guidance notes will help to ease these fears. “What we have done, and will do very shortly, is to publish the clarifying notes that will outline what
SEE PAGE 7
Bahamas’ WTO membership is ‘no fait accompli’ By NATARIO MCKENZIE
Tribune Business Reporter
nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net THE Government’s chief World Trade Organisation (WTO) negotiator yesterday said The Bahamas’ accession was no “fait accompli”, telling accountants: “I’m not tied to any outcome.” Zhivargo Laing, the former Cabinet Minister, told attendees at the Bahamas Institute of Chartered Accountants (BICA) conference: “It’s either the case that this works to the benefit of The Bahamas or we
$5.05
Web shop QC slams govt for ‘disrespect’
Top official confident of business licence ‘happy medium’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
$5.03
ZHIVARGO LAING decide that we don’t do it; it doesn’t make sense. Why should we do any reform that does not enure to the benefit of this economy? “It makes no sense just
SEE PAGE 7
* Munroe: AG adopting ‘wrong attitude’ * Sector waits fortnight on ‘patron tax’ reply * ‘Nowhere else’ are gaming houses tax collector
WAYNE MUNROE QC
heard nothing since. Unable to determine whether there have been any adjustments based on the industry’s recommendations, the two-week silence was broken on Tuesday when Carl Bethel QC, the Attorney General, warned that the legal battle between government and web shop industry would resume unless the two sides
resolved their patron tax differences by week’s end. Mr Munroe said this showed that the Government was treating one of its largest tax-paying industries in “a very curious way”, and accused Mr Bethel of adopting “the wrong attitude” by setting what amounts to an ultimatum. He argued that The Bahamas was the only nation
$4.82
Top official: Shoddy accounting justifies new licence regime By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
where gaming operators were being transformed into tax collectors on the Government’s behalf, suggesting that “nowhere else in the world” is direct taxation - namely the five percent stamp duty levy - imposed on players and patrons. Describing the renewed tension as “unfortunate”, Mr Munroe told Tribune Business: “Alfred [Sears] would have sent the attorney general his response on October 26, and I sent him my response after that to the draft rules. “I pointed out little things: There were references to stamp tax in the rules, when the Act refers to stamp duty. I also pointed out that the proposal for rounding up and down led up to interpretation
THE Ministry of Finance’s top official yesterday defended the new business licence regulations on the basis that too many companies’ financial statements “do not stand up to scrutiny”. Marlon Johnson, pictured, the financial secretary, said this was the Government’s rationale for requiring businesses earning up to $10m annually to produce a financial statement confirming their top-line turnover together with accompanying certified bank statements. Mr Johnson’s comments at the Bahamas Institute of Chartered Accountants (BICA) conference were met with strong push back from attendees, who described the bank accounts demand as an “invasion of privacy” and too onerous a demand for Bahamian small
SEE PAGE 5
SEE PAGE 3