business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 12TH, 2019
$4.52 GB Power suffers $23m Dorian blow By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net HURRICANE Dorian’s catastrophic winds and storm surge have inflicted a $23m blow on Grand Bahama Power Company, its Canadian owner revealed yesterday. Emera, unveiling its 2019 third quarter results, disclosed that Grand Bahama’s electrical utility provider is facing a $12m repair bill to totally restore its transmission and distribution (T&D) system following the category five storm’s passage. It added that GB Power will also have to cover the $5m insurance policy deductible for its 50 megawatt (MW) Peel Street generation plant, which was inundated with storm surge flooding likely to render it inoperable for several months. The figures revealed by Emera back previous assertions by Dave McGregor, GB Power’s chief executive, that damage to the utillity’s transmission and distribution network would be “substantially less” than the near-$28m cost incurred to rebuild it following Hurricane Matthew in October 2016. However, the financials also disclose that GB Power and its parent recorded a $6m earnings hit on the back of reduced sales due to Dorian knocking out electricity supply for several days after it struck in early September. However, GB Power was said to have restored supplies to all customers whose properties were passed fit to receive energy by end-September 2019. This meant that 16,000 clients, or 84.2 percent of the utility’s customer base, were receiving service within one month of the storm’s passage. “On September 1, 2019, Hurricane Dorian struck Grand Bahama Island as a Category 5 hurricane, causing significant damage across the island. Emera’s 2019 third quarter earnings decreased by approximately Cdn$16m ($0.07 per common share), compared to the 2018 third quarter, as a result of the impact of the hurricane,” Emera’s corporate filings revealed. “GB Power’s earnings decreased by $6m for the quarter due to reduced
SEE PAGE 2
$4.57
A FORMER Opposition leader yesterday said the probe into bribery allegations involving the Defence Force’s new $150m fleet had “absolutely vindicated” concerns she first raised five years ago. Loretta Butler-Turner told Tribune Business that “Bahamians should be very concerned as to where this goes” since it “can leave quite a blemish on the country’s reputation” should the claims ultimately be proven true. The former Cabinet minister and MP spoke out after The Tribune confirmed that Bahamian law enforcement authorities have been co-operating with Dutch investigators probing whether the Netherlandsbased manufacturer of nine Royal Bahamas Defence
$4.60
Parliament ‘must get serious’ on corruption Aliv: Yields DAMIAN BLACKBURN
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
T
HE bribery probe involving the Defence Force’s $150m fleet “speaks volumes” about the need for Parliament to take the anti-corruption fight “as seriously as the country”, governance reformers urged yesterday. Matt Aubry, the Organisation for Responsible Governance’s (ORG) executive director, told Tribune Business that the Dutch investigation into whether such payments were made provided “further proof” of why his group and others were pushing so strongly for the government to move forward with a package of stalled anti-graft Bills. While praising the Ministry of Finance for releasing the draft Public Procurement Bill 2019 for consultation, Mr Aubry reiterated that it was “critical” for the government to move the Integrity Commission Bill and the creation of an ombudsman’s post through Parliament as rapidly as possible. Suggesting that politicians
• Defence Force bribery probe ‘speaks volumes’ • ‘Further proof’ of need for stalled legislation • Govt corruption ‘serious’ for 90% of Bahamians
MATT AUBRY may be out of step with how the Bahamian people view this issue, he pointed to an ongoing ORG survey where 65 percent of respondents ranked government corruption in The Bahamas as “extremely serious”. Another 26 percent rated it as “serious”, meaning that more than nine out of every ten persons view it as a major problem. Some 74 percent of replies voiced optimism that corruption in The Bahamas can be “substantially reduced”, while 83 percent agreed that
ordinary Bahamians “can make a difference” in the battle against practices that the prime minister himself estimated cost this nation’s economy several hundred million dollars annually. Warning that perception was everything, Mr Aubry said incidents such as the Defence Force claims could undermine the progress The Bahamas has made in “changing” its image when it came to corruption - especially where the private sector and civil society were concerned. Reiterating that nothing had been proven in relation to the Defence Force contract, he told Tribune Business: “This goes back to our most recent history and is further proof of why we’ve been advocating so strongly for anti-corruption legislation like the Integrity Commission Bill. “This speaks volumes to the need for the upcoming Public Procurement Bill, and would involve the
Proceeds of Crime Act - legislation that has been passed and needs to be passed... Parliament needs to take it as seriously as the rest of the country sees it.” The proposed Integrity Commission Bill would repeal and replace the current Public Disclosure Committee, establishing a comprehensive and independent anti-corruption body to reform anti-corruption policy, investigate issues of corruption, administer public disclosure and educate the public. Mr Aubry yesterday said the Ombudsman Bill, which would create a post to resolve disputes the public has with government agencies, also needed to be moved forward. He added that ORG’s survey, conducted to coincide with the imminent launch of its National Integrity Campaign, had also found that 78.8 percent of respondents
SEE PAGE 2
80% of Dorian-hit assets uninsured
By YOURI KEMP
UP TO 80 percent of private homes and businesses devastated by Hurricane Dorian were uninsured, the deputy prime minister revealed yesterday, creating an unsustainable burden for the state. K Peter Turnquest, opening the annual Accountants Week conference, said the failure to properly insure meant that a “significant loss” event would likely transfer the costs of rebuilding and restoration to the government and Bahamian taxpayer. He described this as “neither tenable nor budgeted for”, and a trend that could threaten both The Bahamas’ fiscal stability and its sovereign credit rating if the government was forced to pick up an increasing proportion of restoration costs that should be borne by the private sector. “Initial assessments of
• DPM warns of ‘untenable exposure’ for state • Tells Nassau residents: ‘It can happen to you’ • Calls for ‘disaster relief clauses’ in loans
K PETER TURNQUEST uninsured risk in this storm are high: As high as 80 percent,” Mr Turnquest said. “The gap between the
coverage and exposure is being put to the government as a social responsibility, which gives us a significant
Loretta: The Bahamas ‘should worry’ on Defence Force deal By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
$4.60
• Feels ‘absolutely vindicated’ by Dutch probe • Urges full ‘co-operation’ with investigators • Govts must be ‘diligent on value for money’
LORETTA BUTLER-TURNER Force (RBDF) ships paid bribes to secure the deal and similar contracts with other Caribbean countries. She yesterday said the late Bernard Nottage, then-minister of national security, and other members of the former Christie administration had been “very dismissive” when
she voiced fears that the deal with Damen Shipyard Group (DSG) was overpriced - especially since it was paying more for fewer vessels than the last Ingraham government had sought to order. Mrs Butler-Turner, in particular, argued at the
time that $8m was “unaccounted for in terms of costs” although Mr Nottage subsequently said this had been set aside to cover any unanticipated change in the project’s scope of works. Now, urging the government to be “very cooperative” with the Dutch investigation, Mrs ButlerTurner said it needed to apply greater scrutiny when dealing with large multimillion dollar contracts with international vendors to ensure nothing untoward happens. With the Defence Force fleet claims following swiftly behind the $300,000 Bahamas Electricity Corporation
SEE PAGE 4
exposure from a budgetary point of view. “The failure to adhere to building codes has aided in catastrophic destruction, and will likely lead to higher insurance premiums, further challenging home ownership for many.” Pointing to the tendency for Bahamians to cut corners and “tip the person” to look the other way in order to speed up the process, he encouraged persons to do it right first time and properly invest in their home’s infrastructure so that risk was reduced and insurance premiums kept affordable. Mr Turnquest said 87.6 percent of the $580m damages and losses incurred
SEE PAGE 6
up by 10% in one year By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net ALIV’S top executive yesterday revealed that per customer revenue yields have increased by ten percent over the past 12 months as the mobile operator moves to “reinvent the store experience”. Damian Blackburn, speaking as the upstart provider celebrated its third birthday, told Tribune Business that the Cable Beach store set to open via a “soft launch” this week will reveal much of its thinking in relation to the new concept. Confirming that Aliv is continuing to invest “north of $10m” annually in network and store improvements, excluding the extra $6m spend for Hurricane Dorian restoration, Mr Blackburn said the mobile provider is targeting earnings before interest, taxation, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) “to the tune of” $2m for its current quarter notwithstanding the storm’s impact. Disclosing that this will be achieved by generating $20m in projected revenues for the three months to end2020, Mr Blackburn said this would represent a quarter-over-quarter increase on the $18m top-line that was achieved in the previous period despite Dorian. The storm pushed that quarter’s EBITDA into “slightly negative” territory. He added that Aliv was trying to strike the correct “balance” between burying fibre-optic cable in the ground and offering wireless solutions when it came to its Abaco network restoration post-Dorian, adding that both options are being “carefully evaluated”. “ARPU (average revenue per subscriber) is in the right place,” Mr Blackburn said. “We have ARPU at $39. Each customer is spending on average $39 a month. There is nothing better to tell you you’re
SEE PAGE 2