11092016 business

Page 1

WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 9, 2016

business@tribunemedia.net

$4.10

$4.14

$4.14

Wells blasts LOI ‘unfounded claims’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

MP never gave Stellar Energy ‘encouraging reply’

Renward Wells has denied giving “an encouraging reply” to the $600-$650 million waste-to-energy proposal at the centre of the Letter of Intent (LOI) controversy, which caused his dismissal from the Government. The Bamboo Town MP, in a November 7 defence to Stellar Energy’s allegations, said he was seeking to strike out the group’s “unfounded claims” against him through multiple legal technicalities. He also argued that the claims relating to the LOI were “not actionable in law”, even if the document was found to be binding on the Government.

By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

$40m rights issue result unknown 2 months later

Bank of the Bahamas was yesterday slammed for its latest failure to make timely disclosure to shareholders, having failed to provide the market with the outcome of its $40 million rights issue since it closed two months ago. The troubled BISX-listed institution, which is thought to have lost more than $120 million over its past three financial years, is also late in filing its annual statements. Given that its financial yearend is end-June 30, Bank of the Bahamas is supposed to file and publish its audited financial statements by October 31 each year - a date that is 120 days post yearend, in compliance with BISX’s rules. But the commercial bank, which is majority-owned by the Government, has both failed to

And audited financials miss 120-day release Investor: ‘They’re not held to the same standard’ do this or publish any notice confirming that it has received an extension from the stock exchange for the publication of its audited financials. Holland Grant, BISX’s chief operating officer, declined to go into specifics, but hinted that Bank of the Bahamas should be making material public filings soon. “The issuer is required to make a disclosure, and you should be See pg b2

Govt ‘run amok’ if PM unaware of $2.1bn proposal By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net The Democratic National Alliance’s (DNA) leader yesterday said Prime Minister Perry Christie was allowing his government “to run amok” if he had no knowledge of the $2.1 billion Chinese farming/fisheries proposal. Branville McCartney told Tribune Business he could not believe that Mr Christie was unaware of the proposal being floated and discussed by the Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries and the Bahamas’ ambassador to China given the amount of Crown Land involved. Pointing out that the Prime Minister was responsible for Crown Land, and its grant and leasing, Mr McCartney suggested it was inconceivable that V Alfred Gray and/or Paul ‘Andy’ Gomez had not first discussed the proposal with Mr Christie. “He needs to step down if he doesn’t know what’s going on in his government,” the DNA leader told Tribune Business. “These guys are running amok around him. “The Prime Minister must have known. Land is in his portfolio. He signs off on that. When they came up with this 20,000 acres of Crown Land, they must have discussed it with the Prime Minister. “No minister thinking of doing this type of deal

Aims to overturn ‘irregular’ $727m default entry

Seeks ‘strike out’, invoking legal technicalities

PM urged: ‘Put your foot down’ on BOB woes

Bran: PM must have known due to Crown Land

Branville McCartney with a foreign entity would do it without discussing it with the Prime Minister and Cabinet of this country. They can’t take the Bahamian people for fools every time.” The Government was plunged into controversy after Mr Gray confirmed he had given the ‘go ahead’ for Mr Gomez to seek $2.1 billion in capital investments from a Chinese state-owned development fund. The proposal was for a 100 company joint agriculture/fisheries venture owned 50/50 by the Chinese and Bahamians, involving 10,000 acres of Crown Land on Andros. That acreage was to expand to 20,000 if certain performance See pg b4

Govt denies Allen was its ‘agent’ in LOI controversy Says Wells acted illegally in signing waste-energy deal

Says all LOI allegations ‘not actionable in law’

Mr Wells’s position, which has been obtained by Tribune Business, gives little clue as to why he signed the LOI, especially given that the Government’s separate defence to Stellar’s claims (see other Page 1B See pg b4

$4.14

Stellar knew LOI ‘repudiate’ from get-go By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

Renward Wells

Capital access not guaranteed by end to exchange control By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net Bahamian businesses will not be guaranteed access to capital even if the financing pool is broadened by exchange control liberalisation, private sector representatives have warned. Gowon Bowe, the Bahamas Chamber of Commerce and Employers Confederation’s (BCCEC) chairman, and businessman Sir Franklyn Wilson, agreed that Bahamian businesses would face the same stringent qualifying conditions whether they approached foreign or domestic financial institutions. Sir Franklyn, the Sunshine Holdings and Arawak Homes chairman, told Tribune Business that the $51 million contraction in bank lending to the private sector during the first nine months of 2016 did not necessarily reflect a reluc-

Sir Franklyn: ‘Bankable proposals’ key here, abroad Chamber chief: Credit profile doesn’t change But could be ‘tremendous boost’ to economy tance to extend credit. Instead, he suggested it could indicate a lack of “bankable proposals” being submitted by Bahamian businesses, meaning they were producing unrealistic business plans, offering too little collateral or showing no sign of generating cash flow to service the debt. “The fact that commercial bank lending to the private See pg b4

The Government is denying that an exCabinet Minister and businessman were acting as its “agents or servants” over the $600-$65 million waste-to-energy project at the centre of the Renward Wells Letter of Intent (LOI) controversy. The Attorney General’s Office, in its draft defence to Stellar Energy’s $727.364 million damages claim, refuted the group’s allegation that Algernon Allen and Frank Forbes, the businessman/accountant heading Sigma Holdings, were acting as “facilitators” for the project on the Government’s behalf. “The actions and direct involvement of the fourth and fifth defendants [Mr Allen and his law firm, and Mr Forbes and Sigma] were not agents and/or servants of the Government of the Bahamas,” the defence, Algernon Allen entered on behalf of the Attorney General and Ministry of Works and Urban Development, said. This directly contradicts Stellar’s ‘statement of claim’, which described Messrs Allen and Forbes as “belonging to the very inner circle of Prime Minister Perry Gladstone Christie”. The waste-to-energy group’s lawsuit effectively alleges that Mr Allen and Mr Forbes were trading on their relationship with the Prime Minister and access to him, holding out their involvement as Stellar’s legal adviser and honorary chairman, See pg b3


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.