11082022 BUSINESS

Page 1

business@tribunemedia.net

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 8, 2022

$5.95

$5.97

$6.07

$5.62

CCA’s $2.4m to firm run by son of top PM adviser • Payments made at height of Baha Mar dispute • Sir Baltron says: ‘I acted with complete integrity’ • Denies any link to Notarc Group ‘at that time’

By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net CHINA Construction America (CCA) paid $2.4m to a company run by the son of Sir Baltron Bethel, senior policy adviser and lead Baha Mar negotiator for Perry Christie, when the dispute over the mega resort was at its peak. The payments to Notarc Management Group, whose chief executive is Leslie

Bethel, are revealed in documents filed last Friday with the New York Supreme Court as the multi-billion dollar legal battle between CCA and Baha Mar’s original developer, Sarkis Izmirlian, resumed with a vengeance. Both Sir Baltron and his son yesterday denied that CCA’s payments to Notarc Management Group influenced the former’s stance towards the dispute and its participants, or his advice to the Government and its actions, after Mr Izmirlian

‘I told you so’: $100m Lucayan sale collapses By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Grand Lucayan’s former chairman last night said “I told you so” after the Government admitted the resort’s $100m sale has collapsed and it is now seeking an alternative purchaser. Michael Scott, who headed Lucayan Renewal Holdings under the former Minnis administration, told Tribune Business he had been informed several weeks ago that the deal with Electra America Hospitality Group was in trouble as its current Board begins “active discussions” with an unnamed replacement. He accused the Davis administration of making the same mistake as its predecessor, which he served, by effectively putting the cart before the horse

• Resort board ‘in active talks’ with new buyer • Electra blames inflation, credit market woes • ‘Nobody will spend $250m without airport’

GRAND LUCAYAN

and failing to address the Dorian-devastated Grand Bahama International Airport with more than a “band aid” solution. Asserting that regaining US pre-clearance status was key, given the need to deliver sufficient stopover visitors to guarantee the Grand Lucayan buyer a return on their investment, Mr Scott told this newspaper that “nobody is going to invest $250m (or $300m as Electra America had promised) unless they have an assurance on the airport”. Julian Russell, the Grand Lucayan’s current chairman, promised to call back when contacted by Tribune Business but never did before press time last night. However, in a statement, Lucayan Renewal Holdings said Electra America had blamed

SEE PAGE B4

Chinese saw Baha Mar as ‘state-owned assets’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net BAHA Mar’s Beijingowned contractor and major financier were already treating the mega resort project as “stateowned assets” prior to finally ousting Sarkis Izmirlian as the project’s developer.

Documents filed on Friday in the New York State Supreme Court, as the $2.25bn legal battle between Baha Mar’s original developer and main contractor heats up yet again, reveal how China Construction America (CCA) and the China Export-Import Bank plotted together to ensure Mr Izmirlian was removed.

The “meeting minutes” from a September 28, 2015, encounter at the China Export-Import Bank’s conference room in Beijing also raise questions over whether the process to sell Baha Mar in early 2016 was effectively a sham given that the two Chinese state-owned entities had already agreed that they would “give priority to

Chinese companies” in the search for a buyer. True to their word, Hong Kong-headquartered Chow Tai Fook Enterprises (CTFE) was selected as the new purchaser, with all parties who entered the open bidding process run by the Deloitte & Touche receivers ultimately rejected by China ExportImport Bank, which had

SEE PAGE B5

Tourism: Concern Nicole will ‘dampen’ winter start By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net ABACO’S Chamber of Commerce president yesterday voiced fears that Nicole will “dampen” vital Thanksgiving tourism business while arguing that the storm’s emergence

reinforces the need to renew the Dorian-related tax break as is. Daphne DegregoryMiaoulis told Tribune Business the sub-tropical storm, which could pass through Grand Bahama and the northern Bahamas as a Category One hurricane, was poised to strike

“at a bad time” because Abaco was “starting to feel” the increase in tourism ahead of the peak winter season’s start that is traditionally marked by Thanksgiving in late November. Acknowledging that she will miss the storm because she is off-island, she added:

“For those that are left on Abaco I’m sure everyone is feeling very anxious. The reports I am getting are that people are obviously taking this very seriously. There has been talk of possible evacuation, but I don’t know if that would

SEE PAGE B3

SIR BALTRON BETHEL

LESLIE BETHEL

filed for a Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in summer 2015. That move ultimately proved futile and led to his ouster as the $4.2bn project’s developer. Sir Baltron told Tribune Business he had acted “with complete integrity and objectivity” on the Government’s behalf in helping to resolve the Baha Mar controversy,

and there was no connection or interaction between himself and Notarc “at that time”. Leslie Bethel, meanwhile, asserted that claims of anything untoward over the $2.4m payments were “political mischief”, and that they were “unrelated” to anything to do with Baha Mar.

SEE PAGE B6

Nicole ‘unnecessary evil’ amid reinsurance fears By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A BAHAMIAN insurer yesterday branded subtropical Storm Nicole “an unnecessary evil we don’t need” as he voiced fears that claims payouts could be impacted by the country’s European Union (EU) blacklisting. Anton Saunders, RoyalStar Assurance’s managing director, told Tribune Business that “we don’t need another Dorian” as he warned that German reinsurers may be forced to cut their claims payouts to Bahamian hurricane victims by 15 percent unless there is a rapid adjustment to that nation’s laws. Three German reinsurers - Munich Re, Hanover Re and R & V Re - are among the biggest partners for Bahamian and Caribbean underwriters, but that country has enacted a law designed to deter its citizens

and companies from doing business with so-called ‘tax havens’. Inclusion on the EU’s blacklist, as has just happened to The Bahamas, will see a nation caught by Germany’s criteria. Mr Saunders explained to this newspaper that Germany’s new law, which takes effect from New Year’s Day 2023, could result in reinsurers having to withhold up to 15 percent of the claims payout to Nicole victims if any of these are still outstanding at that date. Warning that The Bahamas is “running out of time” to address the issue with Germany, Mr Saunders said of Nicole: “This is something that we can’t control but don’t really need at all given the other challenges we have in this market right now. It’s an unnecessary evil that we don’t need.” Besides the German reinsurance issue, Mr Saunders

SEE PAGE B5


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
11082022 BUSINESS by tribune242 - Issuu