business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 7, 2017
$4.37
$4.29
$4.29
$4.29
Auto dealers: ‘God help us’ if 30% fall persists By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
N
ew car dealers yesterday expressed “grave concern” over the 31.17 per cent third quarter sales decline, warning: “God helps us if this trend continues into 2018.” Fred Albury, the Bahamas Motor Dealers Association’s (BMDA) president, told Tribune Business it was “not a pretty picture” in the industry, with the recent Car Show - normally a sales booster - proving “quite depressing”. And he made a call, likely to be controversial in some quarters, for the Government to further tighten regulations on used car imports, expressing concern that the Bahamas could become a “dumping ground” for aged vehicles that ultimately become an environmental and health hazard. Mr Albury likened autos more than 10 years-old to “flat screen TVs and microwaves”, suggesting that they were just as easily discarded when they broke
* BMDA chief: Car Show ‘quite depressing’ * ‘Grave concern’ if Q3 trends persist * Bahamas ‘dumping ground’ fears down, and added that the Government was missing out on a significant revenue raising opportunity. “There’s a tremendous concern,” he told Tribune Business of the near onethird drop in new car sales for the three months to end-September 30. “Sales are down considerably. “We’re not sure if this is because of the hurricane situation [Irma and Maria], and people got scared and tightened up. But it is of grave concern going forward. “If this trend continues, God help us in 2018. We’ll see the demise of some of these dealers. Either we’re going to fade away or become a used car dealer like everyone else, bring in cars under my personal name, sell them on the side of the road and not pay any taxes.” Mr Albury’s latter comment was made partially ‘tongue in cheek’, but
there was little disguising the concerns over the new auto industry’s continuing inability to rebound from the 2008-2009 recession almost a decade later. The 31.17 per cent third quarter sales decline wiped out the 6.7 per cent increase enjoyed in the 2017 first half, pushing year-to-date sales for the first nine months down by 7.42 per cent compared to 2016 figures. Mr Albury said BMDA members had been anticipating a recovery every year for the past four-five years, but none had yet materialised. “I’m keeping my fingers crossed that was due to the hurricanes out there,” he said of the third quarter plunge. “It’s not a pretty picture out there; not a pretty picture at all. “We had the Car Show a couple of weeks ago, and there was a lot of window shopping, but very few
[sales] materialised up there. We’re still following up on it, and there is some activity; people came in and looked, got invoices, spoke to the banks and have to follow up on documents. “But it’s nowhere where it was a few years ago,” Mr Albury continued. “It was quite depressing up there to see an industry that I’ve helped to build for all these years, and the business, to see it slipping away. “There’s not much you can do about it. We’ll have to see what 2018 brings around for us, but I don’t think it’s going to be much better than 2017. I think everyone is just in the mode of trying to keep their doors open and heads above water.” The BMDA president expressed scepticism over whether Baha Mar’s full opening in 2018, and
SEE PAGE 5
CRUISE ships at Prince George Wharf in New Providence.
Top cruise port operator eyes Nassau takeover By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE world’s largest cruise port operator is in talks with the Government to take over management and operations at downtown Nassau’s Prince George Wharf. The approach by UKbased Global Ports Holding was confirmed by its potential joint venture partner, BISX-listed Arawak Port Development Company (APD), in its 2017 annual report. APD, the Nassau Container Port’s (NCP) operator, said the two companies planned to add “additional berths and facilities” to the Bahamas’
* GLOBAL PORTS HOLDING IN PRINCE GEORGE WHARF TALKS * IN JOINT VENTURE WITH BISX-LISTED APD * ARAWAK PORT TARGETS LNG, 15-ACRE BUY busiest cruise port if the Minnis administration gave their project the go-ahead. Work will begin in the 2018 first half if all approvals are received, with APD confirming it had decided to “pursue the partnership” with a company that generated almost $115 million in full-year revenues for 2016.
SEE PAGE 4
ARAWAK PORT PREDICTS GB POWER BUY-OUT’S THREAT NEAR-$3M PROFIT FALL TO ‘PREFERENTIAL TAX BENEFITS’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net ARAWAK Port Development Company (APD) was 11 per cent ahead of profit projections for its 2018 first quarter, despite forecasting a near-$3 million decline for the full-year. The BISX-listed Nassau Container Port (NCP) operator revealed in its annual report that it continues to outperform its internal budget, with revenues, margins and container throughput volumes also ahead of expectations for the three months to end-September 2017. “Our net income is currently 11 per cent or $211,600 over budget as at September 30, 2017, and
* BUT NET INCOME 11% AHEAD FOR Q1 * CARGO, MARGINS AND REVENUE BEAT FORECAST * 2017 PROFITS EXCEEDED TARGET BY 127% we continue to see a steady import of used vehicles from Asia and storagerelated income,” APD told shareholders in its newlyreleased report. “NCP’s TEU (twentyfoot equivalent unit) volumes as at September 30, 2017, are tracking 1 per cent over budget. Total revenue as at September 30, 2017, is tracking about 2 per cent over budget.” APD has adopted conservative financial forecasts following a record-setting 157 per cent profit increase in its 2017 financial year, which was aided by the one-off recovery of almost $1.1 million
in Baha Mar-related storage fees and rent through the project’s construction resumption. Cargo volumes were also boosted by construction imports related to Hurricane Joaquin and Matthew rebuilding efforts, and bulk vehicle imports that came through the Arawak Caybased port. APD is projecting a 26.4 per cent year-over-year profit decline for the 12 months to end-June 2018, with revenues falling 2 per cent in comparison to 20178’s $32.551 million. “For the 2018 fiscal year,
SEE PAGE 6
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE $35 million GB Power buy-out was yesterday branded “financially catastrophic” for Bahamian investors, an outspoken QC arguing they will will “lose their preferential tax position”. Fred Smith QC, the Callenders & Co attorney and partner, told Tribune Business that minority ICD Utilities shareholders who decided to exchange their shares - in whole or in part - for Emera Depository Receipts (DRs) would relinquish the ‘no tax benefits’ provided by Freeport’s Hawksbill Creek Agreement (HCA). Pointing out that DR holders would be exposed
* QC: INVESTORS WILL LOSE FREEPORT BENEFITS * STILL DRAFTING JUDICIAL REVIEW CHALLENGE
FRED SMITH to the 25 per cent Canadian withholding tax on any dividends, and currency fluctuations against the US dollar, he again urged Emera to offer ICD Utilities shareholders shares in GB Power itself.
This would require the 19.6 per cent Bahamian minority to receive one GB Power share for every two ICD Utilities shares, but Archibald Collins, the latter’s chief executive, said this option was “never considered” amid Emera’s determination to streamline the utility’s ownership structure into a single shareholder. Mr Smith, though, argued that Bahamian shareholders opting for DRs, in addition to facing taxation/currency risks, will also lose the current advantages provided by GB Power not having
SEE PAGE 3
‘PUT OUR HOUSE IN ORDER’ BEFORE WTO By NATARIO MCKENZIE Tribune Business Reporter nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net
* NATION MUST REMOVE ‘HANDCUFFS’ ON BUSINESS * REFORMER CITES HIGH INTEREST, EXCHANGE CONTROL * OTHERWISE LOCAL FIRMS AT ‘TOTAL DISADVANTAGE’
THE Government was yesterday urged to “put our house in order first” and remove the competitive disadvantages facing Bahamian businesses prior to joining the World Trade Organisation (WTO). Robert Myers, a principal with the Organisation for Responsible Governance (ORG, told Tribune Business that the Bahamas would “not be ready” to accede to full WTO membership unless the Government enabled local businesses to compete on a ‘level playing field’ with foreign rivals. He identified the relatively high cost of capital (interest rates) for Bahamian businesses, and exchange control restrictions, as key obstacles
that needed to be relaxed before this nation opened its markets and industries to foreign companies. “We’re not ready for it until such time that government can remove the competitive hurdles out of the way of Bahamian businesses ahead of that accession, otherwise you are going to put Bahamian businesses and services at a complete disadvantage to foreign ones,” Mr Myers told Tribune Business. “Due to the restrictive nature of our banking, our debt is regionally higher; exchange control prohibits us from being able to function effectively or efficiently in other nations; and you are essentially making it easier for foreigners to have
foreign accounts than locals to have foreign accounts and operate in local jurisdictions. The banking interest rates, complexity and exchange control are two huge hurdles.” Mr Myers was speaking after Tribune Business revealed that the Minnis Cabinet has approved an “aggressive” push for the Bahamas to become a full WTO member by 2019. Brent Symonette, minister with responsibility for trade and industry, confirmed to Tribune Business that the WTO process was among the Minnis administration’s priorities as it seeks to re-position the Bahamian economy for growth via liberalisation and deregulation.
Mr Myers, meanwhile, said, is the Bahamas’ ease and cost of doing business was another obstacle to the ability of its economy, and companies, to compete in a rules-based trading environment. “You have to be very careful that you put your house is order before you allow others to come into the Bahamas and compete,” he told Tribune Business. “It is the movement of goods and services. It is important for us to be in an advantageous position. To do so otherwise is just going to jeopardise Bahamians and their ability to compete. “I think that there is a tremendous amount of opportunity for Bahamians to go out and compete. There is a tremendous opportunity for Bahamians to go out and expand their
SEE PAGE 3