business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 6, 2018
$4.99 Potter’s Cay threat to ‘tax and security’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Arawak Port’s top executive yesterday sounded a renewed alarm over the risk to “national security” and tax revenue posed by the continued landing of international cargo at Potter’s Cay. Michael Maura, writing in the BISX-listed port operator’s just-released 2018 annual report, said it was in “ongoing” talks with the Ministry of Finance to address a problem that “undermines” the Government’s security and revenue objectives. “The company’s [Arawak Port Development Company’s] 2018-2019 budget also considers the continued landing of international origin cargo at Potters Cay,” Mr Maura told shareholders. “Discussions are ongoing with the Ministry of Finance in the hope of addressing the issue in the near future. This activity undermines national security, public treasury revenue collection objectives, health and safety standards and the cost of living.” Mr Maura’s comments reiterate a similar warning made in APD’s annual report several years ago regarding potential security and tax evasion loopholes at Potter’s Cay, which is supposed to be for domestic cargo and passenger traffic. While some observers may argue that APD’s concerns are motivated by self-interest, and a desire to secure more income and dominate the market, the agreement that created it in 2011 effectively gives it a 20-year exclusivity on commercial shipping and container facilities on New Providence. And Potter’s Cay lacks many of the security measures needed to prevent the smuggling of contraband, such as drugs and firearms, into The Bahamas, plus ensure that the Ministry of Finance receives all due revenue on goods imported into The Bahamas. Mr Maura, meanwhile, served notice that APD will continue to pursue its interest in the cruise port management contract and its liquefied natural gas (LNG) bunkering partnership with New Fortress Energy during the current financial year that closes at
SEE PAGE 3
$5.05
$5.03
Ministry ‘flagrantly abused’ multiple Bahamian singers By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
A
N ex-beauty queen has accused the Ministry of Tourism of “flagrantly abusing” Bahamian singers with a “take what we want, don’t pay and deny” approach to
Bahamian singers, according to documents filed in the federal south Texas court, include Angelique Sabrina, who performs the National Anthem on NB12 at midnight every night, and Sketch Carey. Ms Sherman and her record company, AK Fortyseven Records, claim that the legal discovery
THE Grand Lucayan’s chairman was yesterday locked in meetings over the “extravagant” voluntary separation payments demanded by the two unions representing the resort’s staff. Michael Scott told Tribune Business he was negotiating with representatives for both the Bahamas Hotel Managerial Association (BHMA) and Commonwealth Union of Hotel Services and Allied Workers (CUHSAW) over staff compensation claims that he described as “high”. He declined to be drawn further, but his remarks indicate there is a major gap between the Grand Lucayan’s government-appointed board and the two unions over the total value of the pay-off due to the estimated 200 workers who want to leave. “We’ve received offers from them, and we’re in negotiations,” Mr Scott told this newspaper of the unions’ submissions. “Their offers are extravagant, high,
and we’re in negotiations.” He confirmed that he was due to meet Obie Ferguson, the Trades Union Congress (TUC) president who is representing the BHMA, late yesterday in a bid to narrow the gap between the two sides. Pleasant Bridgewater, the attorney and former PLP MP, is acting for the CUHSAW union, whose members are the Grand Lucayan’s line staff.
The payouts for Grand Lucayan staff who wish to leave were due to begin in late October/early November, but the ongoing negotiations over the two sides’ differences mean this timeline has likely been pushed back. Mr Scott, who heads Lucayan Renewal Holdings, the Government-owned special purpose vehicle (SPV) created to hold the resort,
nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net
SEE PAGE 3
SEE PAGE 4
* Resort chair locked in union talks * Major gap over staff separation cost * Any repairs ‘much less’ than $10-$12m
THE GRAND Lucayan Hotel in Freeport, Grand Bahama.
Tribune Business Reporter
SEE PAGE 5
process over their claim resulted in the Ministry of Tourism admitting it had no licensing deal or other agreement in place allowing it to use these artists’ songs in its promotional campaigns that market The Bahamas to the world. “Discovery in this
Grand Lucayan payout demands ‘extravagant’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
By NATARIO MCKENZIE
told Tribune Business in late October that it would likely cost the Government between $2m-$3m to finance the voluntary departures of the 150 workers who were then seeking to leave the resort. That number is thought to have increased to around 200 since, but Mr Scott put both unions on notice then
SKETCH CAREY paying for use of their songs. Khiara Sherman, the former Miss Bahamas Universe-turned-songstress, is alleging that her ongoing copyright violation claim has exposed “a pattern and practice” where the Ministry of Tourism has failed to pay multiple local artists for use of their intellectual property. Other impacted
VAT reassurance ‘final impetus’ for $100m expansion PALM Cay’s chief executive yesterday said recent value-added tax (VAT) “assurances” by the Government had served as the “final impetus” to kick-start its latest $100m expansion. Rob Batchelor, Palm Cay’s chief executive, told Tribune Business that the southeastern New Providence community’s One Marina residences had been delayed roughly six weeks until the Government reaffirmed the sector’s “zero rating” and developers’ continued ability to reclaim their VAT input costs. “I was at a meeting with the deputy prime minister and other developers about five or six weeks ago,” Mr Batchelor recalled, “where we collectively were assured that the construction industry would continue to be VAT zerorated, and that there were a number of changes being put in place across the finance and tax ministries to help developers and ensure we can claim our VAT returns going forward, but also that we would have the support to reclaim VAT refunds from the past. “We got those assurances. That was effectively the final impetus to allow me to get at the funding that I had already put in place. We delayed by about six weeks. We just needed that assurance. We got that assurance and we are confident now, and hence we have started the build-out.” Real estate developers had previously expressed concern that the 2018-2019 budget’s tax policy changes made it impossible for them to recover VAT paid on their input (construction/ development) costs. This was based on the Government’s decision to revert back to the old ten percent stamp duty structure for real estate transactions, and abandon the previous stamp duty/ VAT split, which developers interpreted as making real estate sales “VAT exempt”. As a result, they had feared this would leave them unable to “net off” or offset the VAT paid on construction materials - and the likes of contractor, engineer and architect bills - against the “output” tax whenever a property is sold. Palm Cay’s One Marina residences, designed by
ANGELIQUE SABRINA
KHIARA SHERMAN
$5.05
MICHAEL SCOTT
Arawak Port beats profit target by 9% By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Nassau Container Port’s 2019 first quarter profits beat target by nine percent despite projections that full-year net income will be down by more than $1m compared to the prior year. Arawak Port Development Company (APD), the port’s BISX-listed operator, revealed the better-thanexpected bottom line for the three months to end-September 2018 - even though container cargo volumes and revenues were down - in its annual report published yesterday. The improvement came despite APD executives adopting a “conservative” approach to budgeting and financial forecasting for the current 2019 financial year, citing numerous potential local and international
* Despite Q1 revenue and cargo drop-off * Full-year profit forecast to fall by over $1m
THE NASSAU Container Port, Arawak Cay. headwinds to economic activity that could impact import volumes. Besides the value-added tax (VAT) increase “curbing consumer spending for the foreseeable future”, the port operator said other development/construction projects were unlikely to fully replace the import activity associated
with the rush to complete Baha Mar’s construction and full opening. Michael Maura, APD’s chief executive, also warned that the US-China “trade war”, with both countries’ tariffs increasing the price of consumer goods, and the upward spike in global oil prices represented further
challenges for the Bahamian economy and cargo volumes. “For the 2019 fiscal year, we are budgeting gross revenue of $30.996m (2018 actual: $31.532m) or two percent less than the prior year’s actual gross revenue,” APD said of the 12 months to endJune next year. “Net income is projected to be $7.41m or $1.195m less than the 2018 actual net income of $8.605m. “Our net income is currently nine percent or $178,800 over budget as at September 30, 2018... Nassau Container Port’s (NCP) TEU (twenty-foot equivalent unit) volumes as at September 30, 2018, are tracking one percent under
SEE PAGE 5