YOUR LOCAL ACCESS TO INTERNATIONAL MARKETS.
business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, OCTOBER 9, 2018
$4.90
$4.93
$4.86
Mortgage chief: ‘Doing nothing not an option’
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
T
HE Bahamas Mortgage Corporation’s (BMC) chairman says “doing nothing is not an option” with the struggling lender having just five years to escape hitting a $110m debt mountain. Patrick Ward told Tribune Business he felt there was “sufficient time to salvage”
Storm insurance eyed for fisheries, farming sectors By NATARIO MCKENZIE
Tribune Business Reporter
nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net A CABINET minister says he will hold talks with the Caribbean Disaster Emergency Management Agency (CDEMA) on providing “sector-wide” hurricane insurance for Bahamian farmers and fishermen. Michael Pintard, minister of agriculture and fisheries, who is presently in Barbados attending the Caribbean Week of Agriculture, told
SEE PAGE 7
* Five years to avoid $110m debt crash * Mortgage Corp chair: ‘It can be salvaged’ * But warns Bahamians: It affects all of us
the corporation’s financial position and avoid calling for a Treasury-funded bailout that would result in it “becoming a burden to the taxpayer”. Stressing that it was important for all Bahamians to understand the
wider ramifications of the Mortgage Corporation’s troubles, Mr Ward said “fundamental issues have been kicked down the road for far too long” by successive administrations. He emphasised, though, that “there is no thought that
Underfunded public pensions bigger than national economy By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE underfunding of The Bahamas’ public sector pensions “poses a serious long-term challenge” because these liabilities are collectively larger than this nation’s economy. The Inter-American Development Bank (IDB), in latest Caribbean Quarterly Bulletin, warned that
the Government’s National Insurance Board (NIB), civil service and stateowned enterprises (SOE) retiree commitments collectively equal 160 percent of Bahamian gross domestic product (GDP). This means their total value is greater than annual Bahamian economic output, and the IDB report warned their underfunding is set to be exacerbated as the ratio of retirees to workers
the Bahamas Mortgage Corporation will not honour its obligations” to investors holding its bond debt, pledging that the Government-owned lender will “start acting decisively” to address its woes. To correct its multiple
* ‘Serious challenge’ at 160% of GDP * ‘Low social returns’ dragging on growth increases as persons live longer. “Current pension liabilities appear to pose a serious long-term challenge,” it said. “Liabilities for government pensions, which include coverage for public entities and social security commitments, are roughly 160 percent of GDP, and some agencies, including the International Monetary Fund (IMF), indicate those commitments are
cornertrader.com
$4.89 Use Disney to ‘rewrite old cruise model’
problems, particularly its loan portfolio’s 47.28 percent arrears rate, Mr Ward said the corporation’s management and board were still working to “flesh out” the details of a strategic plan that aimed to transform its financial fortunes. He added that recent homeowner evictions and
LIGHTHOUSE POINT By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
currently underfunded. “There appears a strong need for a contributory scheme to ease the burden that will soon be exacerbated as the retirement population grows to 41.6 per 100 workers by 2060... Work is needed on reforming the public servants pension system and restricting any further escalation of the contingent liabilities of state-owned enterprises.” The report echoes previous warnings by both the IMF and IDB, each expressing concern over The Bahamas’ growing social and retirement “ticking timebomb” as a result of chronic under-funding for both NIB and civil service pensions. The IDB, in its 2018-2022
THE “largest investment in South Eleuthera for generations” could give The Bahamas a chance to “rewrite an outdated 20-year-old cruise model”, a prominent businessman believes. Thomas Sands, emphasising that he was speaking as a private citizen, and not as the Eleuthera Chamber of Commerce’s president, told Tribune Business that “balance” was required in the debate over Disney Cruise Line’s planned acquisition of the 700-acre Lighthouse Point property. Arguing that neither the project’s advocates or opponents had been totally accurate with their information to-date, Mr Sands said the long-term, sustainable economic development that South Eleuthera craves must be matched with environmental preservation. He added that despite multiple Bahamian efforts to revive the area’s economy, it had to be acknowledged that it had “been in recession close
SEE PAGE 7
SEE PAGE 5
SEE PAGE 4
Privy Council vindicates Bahamasair personnel By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
OCEANVIEW TOWNHOUSE
ALBANY
INVITING LUXURY VILLA 3-STOREY | 4 BR | 4/2 BATHS | 6,706 SF | OCEAN VIEWS LUXURY FINISHES | MEGA-YACHT MARINA | RESORT AMENITIES WEB: 34933 OFFERED AT $4,750,000. Lana.Rademaker@SIRbahamas.com • 242.457.0406
SIRbahamas.com t 242.322.2305
Member of The Bahamas MLS
BAHAMASAIR’S maintenance staff were yesterday vindicated by the highest court in the Bahamian judicial system, which ruled they were not to blame for an April 20, 2007, plane crash. The London-based Privy Council, in reinstating the original Supreme Court verdict by then-chief justice, Sir Michael Barnett, found Canadian aircraft parts designer/manufacturer, Messier-Dowty, responsible for the landing gear collapse suffered by one of Bahamasair’s Dash-8 aircraft when it arrived in Governor’s Harbour, Eleuthera. As a result, it rejected the company’s allegation that “poor maintenance” by Bahamasair staff was responsible for a crash which impacted 48 passengers plus flight crew on the plane.
* Foreign supplier to blame for ‘07 crash * Rejects ‘poor maintenance’ allegation * Appeal Court ‘fundamentally wrong’ The Privy Council ruling, which also restored a $3.5m damages award against Messier-Dowty and in favour of the national flag carrier’s insurers, was highly critical of the “fundamentally wrong approach” taken by the Court of Appeal in overturning Sir Michael’s original ruling. It found the Court of Appeal had breached a key judicial rule, which stipulates that all appeal courts should be reluctant to interfere with “findings of fact” by trial judges - who will have read all the documents, and observed the behaviour of witnesses under crossexamination - unless there is a compelling reason to do so, such as the discovery of
fresh evidence. Ruling that Sir Michael was entitled to reach his conclusions, the Privy Council said there was no cause for the Court of Appeal - led by appeal justice Jon Isaacs - to re-examine the evidence anew as it had done. The Supreme Court, in its original October 2014 ruling, found that “negligence” by Messier-Dowty, which manufacturer and supplied the landing gear on the Dash-8, had caused its collapse. Apart from problems in manufacturing the actual part, Sir Michael also found the Canadian firm had failed to inform Bahamasair that the “damper ring” - a key component in the landing
gear - suffered from “fragmentation” problems. “Sir Michael Barnett found that the landing gear was inadequate for the number of times that it was required to perform,” the Privy Council judgment said yesterday. “He found further that Messier, despite knowing that the landing gear was inadequate, had failed to warn Bahamasair of that inadequacy. “He awarded Bahamasair the sums which they had claimed for the loss of the aircraft and the cost of the investigation. The Chief Justice also rejected a claim by Messier that the failure of the landing gear was due to
SEE PAGE 6