09152017 business

Page 1

business@tribunemedia.net

FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 15, 2017

$4.25

$4.29

$4.30

DPM not ruling out income tax By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

Turnquest: ‘We must consider all options’

THE Government has not ruled out implementing an income tax, the Deputy Prime Minister revealing yesterday: “We have to consider all options.” K P Turnquest, who is also minister of finance, told Tribune Business there had been no internal discussions within the Ministry of Finance or wider government to-date on the possibility of introducing an income tax in the Bahamas. He added, though, that the Minnis administration had “taken note” of this week’s recommendation by the International Monetary Fund (IMF)

Progressive tax system among Govt goals Disaster ‘sinking fund’ eyed for 2018-2019 Public pension reform ‘can’t be kicked down road’ that it should consider a lowrate income tax to replace revenue that will be lost as import duty rates fall.

The Fund also suggested it would be a fairer form of taxation, and Mr Turnquest yesterday said that the Government wanted a tax system that was “progressive rather than regressive” to relieve the burden on lower income Bahamians. “Certainly, we have to consider all options,” he said of the IMF’s income tax recommendation. “However, to-date no such discussion has been had by the Government, and we’ve not had that internal discussion in the Ministry of Finance. “We take note of the recommendation by the IMF, and as we go forward we will be looking at adaptations that are See PG B4

JAMES SMITH

RAY WINDER

Income tax ‘hard sell’ in Bahamas By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net INCOME tax will be “a hard sell” in the Bahamas, a former finance minister predicted yesterday, warning: “This country was built on tax evasion.” James Smith, also a former Central Bank governor, told Tribune Business that the Bahamas needed to be “very careful on the way forward” should it explore the International Monetary Fund (IMF) recommendation to implement a low-rate income tax. He was backed by Raymond Winder, Deloitte & Touche (Bahamas) managing partner, who said income tax should not be viewed ‘in isolation’ as solely a revenue-raising mechanism. Arguing that any tax reform should bring wider

Ex-minister: ‘Country was built on tax evasion’ Accountant warns on financial services impact Doesn’t rule tax out, but needs ‘holistic’ approach benefits, Mr Winder said introducing an income tax could have unintended negative consequences especially for a Bahamian financial services industry that has consistently marketed its ‘no tax’ platform. The accountant, disclosing that he was “not surprised” at the IMF’s See PG B5

BISX criticised: ‘Not a productive exchange’ By NATARIO MCKENZIE Tribune Business Reporter nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net THE Bahamas International Securities Exchange’s (BISX) low equity listings and trading volume are “not the sign of a productive exchange”, a financial analyst charged yesterday. Richard Coulson, a panellist at a Securities Commission conference, argued that while BISX’s creation 18 years ago was “a noble start”, it had not been a success. “Out of hundreds of [Bahamian] companies only 20 of them have chosen to list their ordinary shares on BISX, the last one being Arawak Port Development five years ago; since then, nothing,” Mr Coulson said.

Analyst: Exchange not successful Chief executive hits back “Out of those 20 companies, four of them struggle to survive. Many of them trade only once or twice a week, and days when there are no trades are frequent. That is not the sign of a productive stock exchange.” Mr Coulson added that since 2009, 30 companies have listed on Jamaica’s junior market, a facility that BISX has long planned but been unable to create. Keith Davies, BISX’s chief executive, speaking on the same panel, said it was “a personal choice” to list See PG B2

A BAHAMIAN non-profit organisation has injected $15-$20 million into south Eleuthera’s economy since 2008, and is now setting its sights on expansion. Shaun Ingraham, One Eleuthera Foundation’s co-founder, yesterday said the non-profit and entities like it could become a “third pillar” of the Bahamian economy by growing their social enterprise activities. Speaking at a press conference to preview next week’s Eleuthera Business Outlook conference, Mr Ingraham said the Foundation was assessing how its model could be “scaled up” and replicated on other islands and throughout the Bahamas. “We estimate that the impact for south Eleuthera from 2008 has been close to $15-$20 million,”

BUSINESSMEN SLAM IMF’S ‘DISASTROUS’ INCOME TAX PLAN ‘Don’t talk to us’ until Govt reforms Warn proposal can’t be seen ‘in vacuum’ Fear it would be ‘destructive’ to business By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

DPM PETER TURNQUEST

Non-profit’s $15-$20m boost for Eleuthera By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

$4.30

One Eleuthera Foundation eyes expansion Sees social enterprise as ‘third pillar’ Looking at ‘scaling up’ model for other islands he said. “That’s a small group of people from the island coming together to make things better. “We are on the ground every day, looking to bring this out, and see what works and what doesn’t work. We’ve hired 60 people, and are moving from start-up to scale up.” Mr Ingraham said the Foundation was now reviewing its See PG B5

BAHAMIAN businessmen yesterday slammed the IMF’s income tax proposal, demanding: “Don’t even talk to us about more taxation until the Government’s cleaned its house.” Robert Myers, a principal with the Organisation for Responsible Governance (ORG), blasted the idea of new and/or increased taxes as “short-sighted and irresponsible” given the Bahamas’ present economic and fiscal condition. Warning that an income tax would only further weigh down already-overburdened Bahamian businesses, Mr Myers described the IMF’s proposal as akin to ROBERT MYERS “putting the cart before the horse” because the Government has yet to curb its spending and deliver on promised fiscal reforms. The IMF, in its statement on the Article IV consultation with the Bahamas, called on the Government to implement a “low rate income tax” to both improve taxation system fairness and replace revenue lost as Customs tariffs are slashed. The Bahamas has to cut, or eliminate, many tariff rates as part of its international trade commitments, but Mr Myers warned it was dangerous to implement an income tax “in a vacuum” where just one factor is considered. “I think it’s irresponsible and shortsighted,” he told Tribune Business. “The See PG B4


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.