business@tribunemedia.net
MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 10, 2018
$4.90 Top negotiator: WTO ‘won’t hurt’ this economy
THE Bahamas’ newly-appointed chief negotiator yesterday pledged this nation “cannot join the WTO on terms that injure” its economy or any major industries. Zhivargo Laing, pictured, who replaces Raymond Winder, sought to reassure the private sector and Bahamian public that the Government would only become a full World Trade Organisation (WTO) member if the accession terms can produce “a net gain” for the country. The former Cabinet minister, who first submitted The Bahamas’ application for full membership back in 2001 under the then-Ingraham administration, also promised there was “no reason to fear” that WTO membership would result in an increased tax burden for consumers or businesses. Speaking at a press conference to announce his appointment, Mr Laing said the need to eliminate or reduce numerous Customs duty lines merely meant a “shift” in where the Government obtained its revenues from - not an increase. And, in response to arguments that The Bahamas should delay accession until it “puts its house in order” through energy and “ease of doing business” reforms, Mr Laing argued that WTO membership would provide a “platform” to achieve these goals by forcing this nation to modernise its economy. The Bahamas has already submitted its goods and services “offers” to the WTO Secretariat ahead of the “Third Working Party” meeting on this nation’s accession bid, which is scheduled to take place in Geneva on September 21. The Bahamian delegation, headed by Mr Laing and Brent Symonette, minister of financial services, trade and industry and immigration, will go through this nation’s positions and negotiate with both WTO officials and members of the working group - countries that have an interest in trading with this nation, such as the US, Canada, European Union
SEE PAGE 5
$4.94
Food store VAT exceeds forecast by double digits By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
$4.91
F
OOD stores’ early 12 percent VAT collections have exceeded predictions by double digits, with Super Value’s owner admitting: “We were all wrong about breadbasket sales.” Rupert Roberts told Tribune Business that VAT “zero rated” food products were up to 30 percentage points below forecast as a percentage of total sales, resulting in supermarkets collecting significantly more Treasury revenue that forecast during the first six weeks of the 2018-2019 fiscal year. He revealed that Super Value collected “54 percent more VAT than expected” for July, before the bread basket foods’ “zero rating” took effect. And tax
* ‘We were all wrong on bread basket sales’ * Super Value up 54% in July; 33% early August * Roberts: No govt credit reliance a ‘God send’
RUPERT ROBERTS revenues collected from consumers during the first two weeks of August, after the VAT exemption took effect, were 33 percent up
year-over-year. These figures contrast sharply with Mr Roberts’ prediction to Tribune Business on July 20, 2018, that the “zero rating” of “bread basket food items would slash Super Value’s VAT take by two-thirds He based this on the estimate that at least 50 percent of Super Value’s product range would be VAT-free, and suggested this could apply to 100 percent of “Mom and Pop” food stores’ inventory, given that they typically sold only breadbasket items. However, Mr Roberts conceded that his and industry predictions that breadbasket
A 50-STRONG Bahamian investor group says its “reimagination” of Nassau’s cruise port and downtown will fulfill demands “that we move away from cookie cutter proposals with no sense of place”. Gerald Strachan, founder, president and chief executive of Culture Village (Bahamas), told Tribune Business in a statement that the group’s proposal for reviving both Prince George Wharf and the surrounding area would focus
GERALD STRACHAN
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
though, that the Government’s plan to put Prince George Wharf’s management out to bid through a public tendering process might result in any request for proposal (RFP) seeking to copy Culture Village (Bahamas) ideas by mandating that all offers have a a similar “Bahamianisation” flavour. “To date we have been
SEE PAGE 7
SEE PAGE 5
SEE PAGE 4
* Cultural Village group’s ‘sense of place’ focus * Will serve as downtown Nassau ‘catalyst’ * Concern plan will ‘inform’ govt RFP on development consistent with this country’s heritage. Speaking after this newspaper revealed the group had submitted a proposal to the Government to take over the cruise port’s management and operation, Mr Strachan said the project team included “award-winning” architects and designers from London, Hong Kong and Orlando who will work with Bahamian counterparts. He expressed concern,
‘Go no further than have to’ over EU Bill
THE financial services industry wants The Bahamas “not to go further than it has to” in meeting Europe’s anti-tax avoidance demands and averting a potential “blacklisting”. Michael Paton, pictured, a former Bahamas Financial Services Board (BFSB) chairman, told Tribune Business that the sector will meet today to assess and draw-up its collective concerns over legislation to address the European Union’s (EU) “economic substance” and “ring fencing” requirements. The industry then plans to submit the issues raised over the Commercial Entities (Substance Requirements) Bill 2018 to the Government by week’s end, with Mr Paton questioning why September 19 appeared to be such “a hard and fast date” to have the legislation tabled in the House of Assembly. Acknowledging that “the timelines are very constrained” for The Bahamas to pass, and enact, the legislation before the EU’s year-end deadline for compliance, the Lennox Paton attorney and partner said he expected changes will be made to the bill over the next nine days. “There is going to be an industry-hosted forum on Monday [today] to get feedback, and go over feedback, in relation to the bill,” Mr Paton said. “There’s been quite a flow
items would account for 50 percent of sales had proven widely inaccurate to-date. He suggested the true proportion could be less than 20 percent, meaning consumers are purchasing more VATable grocery products. He added that the breadbasket percentage could even be as low as 15 percent in locations such as Abaco, due to the high number of second home owners, renters and yachters who were likely less VAT-conscious than Bahamians when it came to their shopping patterns. Mr Roberts also revealed
Cruise port proposal ditches ‘cookie cutter’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
$4.94
Benchmark crypto tie-up ‘marriage made in heaven’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net BENCHMARK (Bahamas) last night hailed its newly-formed threeway alliance as “a marriage made in heaven” that will help position this nation as a leader on blockchain and crypto currency. Julian Brown, the BISXlisted firm’s chief executive and president, said the company’s second financial technology (Fintech) deal within a week meant it was “in the leading pack” on developing a platform to
* BISX firm unveils second alliance * Wants to ‘spearhead’ regulatory regime * As Central Bank warns Bahamians facilitate peer-to-peer trading in digital currencies and initial coin offerings (ICOs). Benchmark (Bahamas) announced it has signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with Dragon Industries, the provider of crypto currency and blockchain solutions for the entertainment industry, and the
DragonExchange (DGRx). It can now put this together with the exclusive Bahamian licence for a blockchain/digital peerto-peer financial trading and processing exchange, which it obtained last week from UK-based Charteris, Mackie, Baillie & Cummins (CMBC), “to take this new frontier forward”. Mr Brown said
Benchmark hoped to rapidly convert the MoU with DragonExchange into “an operating understanding”, with talks having already started and attorneys working on the necessary legal documents, ahead of an imminent meeting between the two sides in the UK. He described Benchmark’s three-way tie-up
JULIAN BROWN as “fantastic”, as it linked CMBC as technology provider and platform architect with DragonExchange, which has already raised
SEE PAGE 6