business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, JULY 26, 2022
$6.92
$6.97
$6.96
$7.27
Gov’t hires Rothschild for $11.8bn debt help • Move could lead to ‘massive refinancing’ • Deal to focus on debt costs, management • To give ‘credibility’ in telling Bahamas story
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Government has hired Rothschild & Co, a major global financial group, to advise on what could become a “massive refinancing” of much of the country’s $11.8bn national debt, it was revealed yesterday. Multiple well-placed sources, speaking on condition of anonymity because they were not authorised to talk publicly, confirmed to Tribune Business that the Davis administration has engaged a firm with some 3,800 employees spread across 40 countries to help navigate the way forward after Hurricane Dorian and COVID19 sparked a debt blow-out that
worsened already-deepening fiscal woes. This newspaper was told that Rothschild & Co, in its capacity as the Government’s independent debt adviser, will have multiple tasks and responsibilities. These include “figuring out how to manage” The Bahamas’ international foreign currency debt exposure, both reducing the cost (interest payments) on outstanding bonds and minimising the rates demanded by investors on future issues. Its executives will also be charged with selling The Bahamas’ post-COVID recovery progress to the international markets amid the belief that this will be more credible coming from Rothschild & Co, which knows the investors and
players as a participant itself, than the Government. “They speak to each other and speak the same language,” one contact said of Rothschild and the global markets. Several sources, meanwhile, said Rothschild & Co may ultimately be tasked with leading a major refinancing of both The Bahamas’ existing and international foreign currency debt. This, they added, might involve making The Bahamas’ domestic debt available to overseas investors by listing it on an international exchange - a move that would enhance liquidity by increasing the debt buyer pool and, potentially, bring yields down. This, though, would require some nimble relaxation of The Bahamas’ existing exchange control regulations. It would
Auto dealers: Sales ‘20% higher’ if we had supply By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net BAHAMIAN auto dealers yesterday said industry-wide sales would be “20 percent higher” than the actual 159 year-over-year increase for 2022 to-date if vehicle supplies matched pre-COVID levels. Operators spoken to by Tribune Business described the sector as facing a glass half-full situation, with overall sales for the first half up 23.6 percent year-over-year and trending towards levels attained in 2019 prior to the pandemic’s arrival.
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
• But sector’s sales for 2022 first half increase 159 to 833
BEN ALBURY
• Dealer reports 95% of shipment ‘pre-sold’ before arrival One dealer revealed that, of the supply he is receiving, some 95 percent of vehicle shipments are pre-sold before they even arrive in The Bahamas. Ben Albury, the BMDA’s president, told Tribune Business that “you really need a crystal ball to
function” due to the difficulty in predicting when, and how many of the initial vehicle order, would arrive in this nation. He added that manufacturers had warned supply chain disruption, and the resulting imbalance between inventory availability and demand in The Bahamas, will likely last for another 12-18 months until end2023 at least.
SEE PAGE B4
‘No further hiccups’ over Lucayan deal By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Opposition’s leader last night voiced concern that “there are no further hiccups” with the proposed Grand Lucayan sale with the extension to the buyer’s 60-day due diligence MICHAEL PINTARD period set to expire this week. Michael Pintard told Tribune Business that the Free National Movement (FNM) was “concerned” about the Electra America Hospitality Group deal’s status in the absence of any updates from the Davis administration, adding that his party was “once again hopeful that the project will succeed”. When the latest Grand Lucayan deal was unveiled in early May, Chester Cooper, deputy prime minister, said Electra America had agreed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the Government and was to pay a $5m deposit once a
SEE PAGE B4
GRAND LUCAYAN
Fidelity chair: Global recession risk ‘high’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A BISX-listed bank’s chairman has branded 2021 “the comeback year we all hoped for” after his institution cut loan loss provisions by almost $19m due to borrowers becoming current with their obligations again post-COVID. However, Scott Elphinstone, writing in Fidelity Bank (Bahamas) just-released 2022 annual report, said the post-pandemic recovery prospects for both the commercial lender and wider Bahamian economy are facing rising global economic headwinds from 40-year high inflation and other factors. He warned that the prospect of major countries
SEE PAGE B5
Attorney must pay $165k over ‘forged’ bank drafts
• Industry ‘needs crystal ball to function’ with product delay
However, manufacturing capacity shortages and supply chain bottlenecks have left virtually all Bahamas Motor Dealers Association (BMDA) members - albeit perhaps at different times - with insufficient auto inventory to meet market demand.
also mean that the price of the Government’s Bahamian dollar denominated debt would no longer be fixed, as it is currently, even though such a move would result in it being acquired by foreign investors paying foreign currency. It is unclear whether the Government or Central Bank would entertain what, in The Bahamas’ context, would be a drastic reform. “Apparently the Government has retained them as consultants for some sort of massive debt refinancing. They’ve been retained as consultants on the issue,” one source said of Rothschild & Co. Another added: “They have a fantastic plan that they have
falling into recession in 2023 was “high”. “I am encouraged that my optimism that the 2021-2022 winter tourist season would be back to near normal actually happened,” he told shareholders. This had a significant positive effect on the performance of the economy of the Commonwealth of The Bahamas, which impacted favourably the financial performance of Fidelity Bank (Bahamas). While the effects of the COVID-19 crises still linger, 2021 can only be thought of as the comeback year we had all hoped for. “The conservative provision for loan losses established as of December 31, 2020, proved
SEE PAGE B6
A BAHAMIAN attorney has been ordered to pay Scotiabank some $165,000 after his business account became overdrawn due to two bank drafts that were discovered to be “forgeries or counterfeit”. Justice Indra Charles, in a July 22, 2022, verdict rejected Glendon Rolle’s claim for loss and damages as a result of what he alleged was the commercial bank’s “breach of fiduciary duty and/or negligence”. While finding that Scotiabank (Bahamas) was indeed negligent in protecting itself from risk, as it allowed the two bank drafts to clear and be credited to Mr Rolle in less than the 15 days stipulated by its own processes, she found the attorney was bound by the contract he signed when opening the account. This specifically stated that neither Scotiabank, nor its directors, officers
and employees, can be held liable for “a forged, unauthorised or fraudulent use of services, cheque or instruction”. As a result, Justice Charles found the bank could credit a client’s account without a bank draft or cheque clearing first, and was thus entitled to recover the overdrawn sum from Mr Rolle. And she ruled that the attorney, who trades as Lord Ellor & Company (Ellor is Rolle spelled backwards), had blundered in any event by failing to file a defence to Scotiabank’s counter-claim. As a result, the bank was “entitled to have final judgment entered in its favour” for the $165,000 overdrawn sum claimed - plus a monthly $15 overdraft fee that has accrued over almost five years - regardless of the final verdict. Justice Charles’ verdict gives no indication as to who was responsible for the “fraudulent” CIBC
SEE PAGE B5