07212020 BUSINESS

Page 1

business@tribunemedia.net

TUESDAY, JULY 21, 2020

$3.98 Hotelier calls for ‘calibrated’ action on COVID surge By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

A HARBOUR Island hotelier yesterday urged the government to adopt “a more calibrated approach” to the surge in COVID-19 infections rather than cut off all commercial transport links to the US. Benjamin Simmons, proprietor of The Other Side and Ocean View properties, told Tribune Business that The Bahamas needed to tackle the issue on an islandby-island basis rather than use “a one-size-fits-all blanket approach” to combat the increase in infections in New Providence and Grand Bahama since the borders opened. He argued that Family Islands with no COVID-19 infections, and which were enforcing all the necessary health protocols, should not be penalised for the issues impacting The Bahamas’ major urban centres. Mr Simmons added that if the Minnis administration had concerns about visitors bringing the virus with them, even if they produced a negative COVID-19 PCR test within the required tenday window, then it could limit the load factors or available seating on incoming commercial aircraft to 50 percent capacity or require smaller planes. “I would have hoped for a bit more of a calibrated approach,” he told this newspaper, “and address the problems where the problems are rather than a one-size-fits-all blanket approach. The Bahamas is not one island. There’s many of them. I think we have to calibrate the response in a manner that fits the geographical reality. “If an island does not have a case, and there are no issues with the way it is handling COVID-19, why cut them off at the knees? We’re hoping there will be that adjustment.... It is what it is. We’re in belly of the snake right now with this virus. We’ll keep on adapting and hope the administration see there’s a way to calibrate the response that allows us to function.” The government’s decision to close The Bahamas’ borders to all commercial air and sea travel from the US with effect from tomorrow

SEE PAGE 6

$3.98

Briland developer ‘side steps’ approval terms By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

A

HARBOUR Island marina project has been accused of “side stepping” conditions imposed on its activities by submitting two different sets of plans to the central and local government authorities. Opponents of the controversial 4M Harbour Island Ltd development, in their second legal action challenging the approvals granted for its construction, are alleging that the plans submitted to the Harbour Island District Council to obtain its building permit were not pre-approved by the Bahamas Environment, Science and Technology (BEST) Commission as required by the government. Br-island Island Responsible Development (BIRD), in its second Judicial Review action, is also claiming that 4M’s marina is larger than the size permitted by BEST and the project’s Heads of Agreement that were signed by both developer and government in March 2018. And it is arguing that

• 4M opponents claim ‘two sets of plans’ submitted • Allege marina expanding beyond govt-set limits • Initiate new Judicial Review to halt development continued construction of the marina’s steel dock structure breaches a Supreme Court order made by Justice Diane Stewart on October 17, 2019, because this “stayed” all activity until 4M obtained the necessary permits from the proper authority in full compliance with established legal procedures. Justice Stewart, in a ruling stemming from BIRD’s first Judicial Review, had “quashed” the site plan approval and other permits granted to 4M and its developer, California-based attorney, Michael Wiener, after all parties agreed the law required that they be approved by the Harbour Island District Council and not the Town Planning Committee. BIRD is now arguing that Justice Stewart’s order has been violated because 4M did not properly obtain the building permit issued by the Harbour Island District Council on April 21,

2020, while the original approval given for the marina’s metal dock structure was quashed by the judge’s October 2019 ruling. The group, which says its members are Harbour Island residents and homeowners, is also alleging that the metal being employed to construct the marina is non-compliant with the project’s Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA). And it claims that 4M is not living up to its own Environmental Management Plan (EMP) by failing to prevent water “turbidity” caused by the dumping of fill material into the marina structure from May 2020. As a result, BIRD’s second Judicial Review is seeking multiple Supreme Court orders and declarations, including that the marina expansion approval and building permit granted by the Harbour Island District Council are “unlawful” on the basis that there was no “proper public

THE government was yesterday warned that Grand Bahama’s private sector will suffer “a lot of casualties” if it implements an island-wide COVID-19 lockdown lasting “beyond a week or two”. Greg Laroda, the Grand Bahama Chamber of Commerce president, told Tribune Business that the Prime Minister’s threat to reintroduce a lockdown by this Friday if the rate of new COVID-19 infections does not improve threatens “a huge setback” for many businesses that had been “limping along” prior to the July 1 border re-opening. With yesterday’s 20 newly-discovered cases making a new lockdown increasingly likely, Mr Laroda urged Dr Hubert Minnis to avoid imposing a “Bimini-type” total

consultation” and they fail to comply with the project’s Heads of Agreement. Its June 30, 2020, action also wants the court to halt the marina expansion at 4M’s Briland Island Residences and Marina project while declaring that all construction activities since Justice Stewart’s October 2019 order are non-compliant with both the EIA and EMP approved by the BEST Commission. Despite informing a spokesperson for Mr Wiener and 4M about BIRD’s second Judicial Review, and seeking the developer’s response, no reply to BIRD’s allegations was received before press deadline last night. However, the group, which has been joined in its Judicial Review bid by Harbour Island resident, Ithalia Johnson-Elison, for the first time reveals details of the Heads of Agreement

SEE PAGE 4

‘Increase subsidy or Bahamasair closes’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

BAHAMASAIR’S chairman yesterday warned the airline will “close down” without an increase in taxpayer subsidies after its top-line was cut by $22m due to Hurricane Dorian and COVID-19. Tommy Turnquest, pictured, speaking after the national flag carrier was ordered to cease commercial flights into the US, told Tribune Business that revenues for the 2020 financial year that just closed at endJune were likely to be down 24 percent year-over-year from $92m to $70m. With taxpayers already pumping an eight-figure sum annually into Bahamasair to keep it flying prior to COVID-19, Mr Turnquest said “you don’t have to be a rocket scientist” to realise that a further cash call on the Public Treasury beyond the $19m provided in the

• National flag carrier’s revenues off $22m • Flying just six into Orlando pre-lockdown • Govt decides ‘aggressive’ cut back for it

2020-2021 budget will be forthcoming. He added, though, that the government’s decision to halt all the carrier’s commercial flights into Florida as a means to prevent Bahamians bringing COVID-19 home could actually end up saving the airline money. Bahamasair’s chairman

said the airline had been poised to “aggressively” cut back its services into Orlando with effect from yesterday, given that it had been transporting just six passengers both ways in its 60-70 seater ATR planes. Acknowledging that the prime minister had effectively “made the decision” for Bahamasair, Mr Turnquest said it may “be 2021” when the airline returns to Florida if the state fails to get its COVID-19 outbreak under control before year-end. He explained that the carrier appeared poised to lose four of the five months it relies upon to minimise Bahamian taxpayer exposure, with the only peak traffic period remaining in

‘Many casualties’ feared if GB put into lockdown By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

$4.00

• Chamber chief warns on ‘huge setback’ • Urges govt to avoid ‘Bimini-type’ closure • ‘Serious, serious impact, if lasts fortnight shutdown given the “severe impact” this would have on The Bahamas’ second largest population centre. Should the government have to follow through with implementing its plan, he urged it to allow persons to continue grocery shopping and performing other essential tasks rather than “confine persons to their homes”. “We were limping along, and looking forward to the reopening of the borders and relaxation of the restrictions put on a number of businesses not considered essential and not allowed to open during the lockdown,” Mr Laroda told this newspaper. “To be hit with this is

disappointing. We obviously understand and sympathise with the prime minister’s position, having to balance the health of the nation with the economic recovery. We’re hoping, I guess, that a complete lockdown doesn’t have the same meaning for Grand Bahama as it did for Bimini. We feel that type of lockdown will really have a severe impact on the island.” Mr Laroda said Grand Bahama businesses and residents would be able to “live for a period of time” with a 24-hour curfew that allowed persons to shop for groceries, but added: “I wouldn’t like to see us have a complete lockdown of persons confined to their residences.

“We were struggling and limping up to the point of the borders being opened back up. Is a lockdown going to be the end of the world? I don’t think so. We’re resilient, and we’ll recover, but it’s a huge setback right now. ‘I’m sure a few of the businesses hoping the economy would be open right now to help them recover, as a result of this, we may end up losing a few more businesses than we have already done,” Mr Laroda continued. “If this is what it takes to get everything under control and learn to live with this virus, because it’s not

SEE PAGE 5

2020 being the November/ December period containing the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays. “Bahamasair would have a boom for five months, and those five months are what carries Bahamasair for the year,” Mr Turnquest said, referring to Easter and the June-August summer period. “For October, November and December last year, Grand Bahama and Abaco were out of the mix because of Hurricane Dorian. We estimate probably a loss of around $8m as a result of that shortfall. Then we were in lockdown in mid-March with the COVID-19 virus.” Bahamasair previously estimated that it lost $10.5m

SEE PAGE 5

$4.00 Offshore banks: 65% report no COVID impact By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net SOME 65 percent of Bahamas-based international banks have suffered “little or no financial impact” from COVID-19, the Central Bank revealed yesterday, marking the sector as one of the few to emerge relatively unscathed to-date. The regulator, unveiling a survey of 71 licensees, said some 47 respondents said they had sustained minimal if any impact from the pandemic and the Bahamian economy’s near-three month lockdown. But, while the fall-out had been “manageable”, the Central Bank said the industry continued to face ongoing uncertainty amid the global struggle to combat the virus. “In response to the question on assets growth/ structure, provisioning or profitability, 47 supervised financial institutions (SFIs) (65 percent) responded that the pandemic has had little or no financial impact,” the Central Bank reported. “For the minority of respondents reporting an impact, eight SFIs (11 percent) cited concerns with loan loss provisioning or asset devaluation, while 16 SFIs (24 percent) expressed concerns with revenue (fee/ interest income) or growth potential. One SFI reported concerns with both.” The regulator added: “The COVID pandemic’s impacts on internationally active SFIs have so far proven manageable. Many respondents, however, noted the unknown nature of emerging risks, especially market risk (chiefly interest rate risk). “In some cases, movements had an offsetting impact (one revenue stream increases while another revenue stream decreases - for example, increased transaction fee revenue versus decreased interest income.” All 72 Bahamas-based bank and trust companies who responded to the Central Bank’s survey confirmed that their overseas parent groups were able to provide them with liquidity support should it become necessary. “When asked ‘what are the key economic/business challenges faced by your institution arising from the COVID-19 pandemic’, 21 SFIs (29 percent) responded

SEE PAGE 6


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.