business@tribunemedia.net
WEDNESDAY, JULY 20, 2022
$6.92
$6.97
$6.96
$7.27
Realtors optimistic ‘hottest market in 40 years’ survives By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net REALTORS are closely scrutinising whether “the hottest market The Bahamas has seen in 40-plus years” can survive rising global headwinds as they seek to maintain revenue increases of up to 79 percent. Tim Rodland, managing partner and broker at Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate MCR Group Bahamas, yesterday told Tribune Business he was hoping the 2022 second half will produce a repeat of the 79 percent and 49 percent yearover-year revenue increases seen during the first and second quarters, respectively, despite growing uncertainty and fears for the US economy’s health and that of the world. Acknowledging that “every day there’s something new”, with the US and other major economies hiking interest rates to dampen inflation now at 40-year highs, in addition to the post-COVID supply chain bottlenecks and Russia’s ongoing invasion of Ukraine, he added that he was “monitoring the
CHUB CAY
TIM RODLAND
• And revenue rises of up to 79% endure • Rising US rates, uncertainty pose threat • ‘We’ll ride wave for as long as we can’
GAVIN CHRISTIE
JOHN CHRISTIE
situation” closely for any signs that could produce a slowdown in Bahamian real estate demand. Meanwhile Gavin Christie, Corcoran CA Christie’s managing partner, told Tribune Business he was confident the market will sustain its postCOVID surge “over the next six to 12 months” with his firm having enjoyed sales volume increases of greater than 50 percent for 2021 and this year to-date. Predicting that The Bahamas will “weather the storm very, very well” if a crisis emerges from rising recession concerns,
he said this nation will be aided by the past 24 months’ sales surge that had reduced real estate inventory available for sale by 20-30 percent compared to pre-COVID levels. Noting that it remains a “seller’s market”, Gavin Christie added that this supply shortage will help keep prices stable and high. He was backed by his namesake John Christie, HG Christie’s president and managing broker, who said the Bahamian real estate market has “a lot of counterweight”
SEE PAGE B5
COVID restrictions help ex-airline chief avoid jail
Tourism hopeful major strike damage avoided
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
THE Bahamian tourism industry was yesterday hopeful that widespread, long-lasting damage from the Airport Authority strike may have been avoided even though most of the agency’s employees still failed to show for work. Robert Sands, the Bahamas Hotel and Tourism Association’s (BHTA) president, told Tribune Business that if “normal business” resumes today at Lynden Pindling International Airport (LPIA) then the sector will start to believe that the worst-case scenario has been averted in terms of reputational fall-out for the country’s standing as a prime travel destination. However, Peter Rutherford, the Airport Authority’s acting general manager, confirmed the majority of workers at both LPIA and in the Family Islands seemingly defied a
COVID restrictions literally provided a get-out-of-jail route for a former airline principal who successfully overturned a one-month prison sentence for contempt of court. Justice Indra Charles, in a June 8, 2021, verdict committed Albert Rolle, who headed the now-defunct Cat Island Air Company, to the Bahamas Department of Corrections after he failed to pay a $135,000 judgment debt. However, the Court of Appeal ruled that Mr Rolle was saved by the former Minnis administration’s COVID travel restrictions which prevented him from travelling to Nassau from Cat Island to attend the hearing - which was held on the same day the verdict was rendered. Noting that the Supreme Court’s rules for contempt hearings require the matter to be heard in “open court”, and that those subject to such proceedings are allowed to give evidence on their behalf, the Court of Appeal said no evidence was presented to show Mr Rolle could attend by other means such as a virtual hearing - even though this was being commonly used in the Bahamian judicial system. With the Emergency Powers (COVID-19 Pandemic)(Management and Recovery)(North Andros, Central Andros, and Cat Island Lockdown)(Amendment )(No. 3) Order 2021 extended to June 14, 2021, just two days before the contempt hearing, the Court of Appeal found: “The effect of this order was to prohibit travel into and out of Cat Island during that period except for specified emergencies..... “The judge ought to have known of the restrictions on travel from Cat Island as Parliament passed and gazetted the regulations. The respondent cannot show that alternative arrangements were in place at the hearing to allow for the participation of [Mr Rolle] and that the court communicated this to [him]. In these circumstances, the judge went on and dealt with the motion for contempt, denying the first appellant an opportunity to take part in the hearing of his contempt matter.” As a result, Mr Rolle’s one-month sentence at the Bahamas Department of Corrections was set aside. The contempt hearing arose after Elma Bain sued him and Cat Island Air in a bid to recover $135,000. They failed to file a defence to the action, resulting in Ms Bain obtaining
SEE PAGE B5
Verdict threatens resort’s $100k private club model • Chub Cay challenges ‘free access’ ruling • ‘Substantial implications’ for property law • And winning homeowners want even more By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
ROBERT SANDS
KEITH BELL
Supreme Court ruling that ordered them to return to work and imposed an injunction on all forms of industrial action on the basis it was illegal. “Just 60 percent of the employees on the Family Islands returned to work, and in Nassau some 80 percent didn’t show up for work yesterday. The contingency is holding up and is doing a lot better than it was on Monday,” he added of arrangements that have seen police and Defence Force officers replace
Airport Authority personnel on tasks such as body and baggage screening. “Most employees have not returned. They remain out despite the injunction. However the contingencies in place are sufficient and handling the volumes.” Mr Sands, meanwhile, said social media monitoring by the BHTA and its members “indicates there wasn’t much chatter” over the past two days from passengers complaining about
A BAHAMIAN resort developer yesterday moved to overturn a Supreme Court ruling that threatens to undermine the $100,000 “entry fee” business model for its private club by giving nearby homeowners free access to multiple amenities. Chub Cay Realty, in papers filed with the Court of Appeal, is asserting that the June 8, 2022, ruling by Justice Indra Charles that effectively grants nonmember homeowners and their guests - including potential vacation rental clients - “free use of the private club facilities” without paying a cent in membership fees or towards their upkeep. The developer, which is owned by Texan billionaire George Bishop, is alleging that the verdict “is an abuse of the judge’s power to act judiciously” by giving the three Chub Cay homeowners who brought the claim “the benefit of the free use of the facilities of the exclusive club without any financial burden”. Justice Charles described her ruling as “no doubt a ground-breaking judgment” for The Bahamas, as the action initiated by three homeowners - all non-members of the Chub Cay Club - raised “a novel question” as to whether a 2004 Grant of Easement gave them the right to access and use facilities regardless. She ultimately found in favour of the trio - Richard and Pamela Escobar, Charles Vose and a corporate entity, Msairnsea LLC - by granting the declaration they desired, namely that they have the same access as that enjoyed by club members and hotel guests to the
SEE PAGE B2
SEE PAGE B3
By NEIL HARTNELL and YOURI KEMP Tribune Business Reporters
Union leader: ‘Hot spots’ will not become eruption By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A TRADE union leader yesterday pledged that workplace “hot spots” will not erupt into full-blow strikes or industrial action, adding: “We are working around the clock to find a happy medium.” Obie Ferguson, the Trades Union Congress (TUC) president, told Tribune Business his goal is to avoid “taking to the streets” as much as possible by finding “common ground” between the umbrella union, its affiliates and employers via negotiation. While unable to speak directly to the Airport Authority strike action, as the Bahamas Public Services Union (BPSU) is not a TUC
OBIE FERGUSON affiliate, he added that this was unlikely to be a summer of union/labour discontent provided all sides negotiate in good faith and focus on issues rather than personalities.
“There are a number of industrial agreements that are outstanding, and we are working assiduously to ensure the affiliates of the TUC, the unions that fall into that category, that they are working with the Government to get those matters resolved,” Mr Ferguson told this newspaper. “There may be some hot spots, but in my humble opinion I will try to ensure we keep them focused on issues and not personalities. When negotiations become issues of personality, they tend not to get resolved.” Besides an industrial agreement for the Bahamas Nurses Union, Mr Ferguson said other outstanding matters involving TUC affiliates include both the Bahamas Doctors Union (BDU), which represents
the junior doctors, and the Consultant Physicians Staff Association (CPSA) that looks after their more senior counterparts. The Public Managers Union (PMU) has also yet to conclude an industrial deal for the National Insurance Board’s (NIB) middle management staff, while the Bahamas Educators Managerial Union (BEMU) is also in negotiations trying to resolve concerns arising from the implementation of its registered agreement’s terms. “What we are trying to do, as opposed to taking to the street, and I’m not saying we wouldn’t do that if it became necessary, but the objective is to find common ground between the
SEE PAGE B5