business@tribunemedia.net
FRIDAY, JULY 20, 2018
$4.94
$4.99
$4.94
Super Value chief eyes 2/3 VAT collection slash
$4.94
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
S
UPER Value’s owner yesterday predicted that the supermarket chain’s VAT take will be slashed by two-thirds once the “breadbasket” food exemptions take effect on August 1. Rupert Roberts, pictured, told Tribune Business that the government will have to earn its forecast $400m increase in VAT revenues from industries other than food retail, suggesting it was unaware just how much of the sector’s inventory fell into the soon-to-be
* Predicts VAT-free breadbasket to boost sales * Tax take falls 28% in first week post-rate rise * But warns breadbasket line-up ‘oversaturated’ “zero rated” breadbasket category. He revealed that at least 50 percent of Super Value’s
product range VAT-free, and this could apply cent of “Mom
would be suggested to 100 perand Pop”
food stores’ inventory, given that they typically sold only “breadbasket” items. Mr Roberts said his
business had experienced a top-line decline similar to that of rival AML Foods, with Super Value’s groupwide sales dropping by 5.7 percent in the week immediately following the 12 percent VAT’s introduction. This resulted in a 28 percent week-over-week
decline in VAT collected on the government’s behalf, but Mr Roberts told this newspaper he expected the supermarket chain’s sales to increase - rather than decrease - once the “breadbasket” zero rating kicked
SEE PAGE 4
Attorney considers Privy DPM’s ‘social unrest’ fear appeal on $120k verdict over govt spending cuts By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A BAHAMIAN attorney yesterday said he plans a Privy Council appeal, costs permitting, over a verdict reaffirming that he must pay $120,000 to a pair of foreign investors. Andrew Allen, son of former finance minister Sir William Allen, told Tribune Business he is “sticking” to his position that he was due 20 percent of the appraised value of an Abaco land parcel despite contrary findings by both the Supreme Court and Court of Appeal. A prolific letter writer to the Bahamian media, Mr Allen told Tribune Business
* EX-MINISTER’S SON ‘STICKING’ TO 20% DEAL * APPEAL COURT FINDS ARGUMENT ‘RED HERRING’ * NEITHER SIDE WINS ON ABACO LAND DISPUTE that his potential appeal to the judicial system’s highest court now depends on how the Court of Appeal awards costs between himself and US investors, James Fogle and James Powell. He spoke out after this week’s Court of Appeal verdict gave neither party
Govt mulling over adding property tax on light bills By NATARIO MCKENZIE
Tribune Business Reporter
nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net THE government is forecasting a three percent inflation increase this year as a result of the VAT rate hike, and examining whether to collect real property tax by adding it to light bills. KP Turnquest, the deputy prime minister, in an address to the Rotary Club of Old Fort on Wednesday night, said: “In our modelling, we anticipate about a three percent increase in inflation in the first year, levelling back down to about one percent in the years after, which was the
same exact result from the introduction of VAT. Those people who are preaching doom and gloom, again the empirical data doesn’t support that.” He conceded that the administration and collection of real property tax needed to be modernised, with the government exploring creative ways to simplify the process - such as adding the tax on to taxpayers’ light bills. Acknowledging the significant real property tax arrears, which some estimates leg at $500-$600m, Mr Turnquest said: “We
SEE PAGE 4
Bahamas trade deficit over $3bn By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Bahamas’ annual trade deficit expanded by 19 percent to over $3bn in 2017, as this nation’s merchandise import bill expanded by more than $500m. The Annual Foreign Trade Report, released this week by the Department of Statistics, revealed that imports continued to expand at a faster rate than The Bahamas’ goods exports. Imports jumped by 18.6
percent, compared to 2016, rising from $2.932bn to $3.478bn, while exports expanded by 17.5 percent - albeit from a much lower starting point - rising from $402.715m to $473.335m. “Data on merchandise trade for the year 2017 shows that the value of commodities imported into The Bahamas totalled $3.5bn, resulting in an increase of 18.6 percent between 2016 and 2017,” the report found, noting that imports increased by $475.4m. “The balance of
SEE PAGE 5
a complete victory. While the US investors’ attorney, Damian Gomez QC, conceded that a previous $274,000 award against Mr Allen over another land parcel could not stand because of an earlier settlement, the three judges unanimously upheld a verdict requiring the latter to pay the lesser $120,000 sum. Sir Michael Barnett, acting appeal judge, in delivering the verdict said it related to a “somewhat complicated”, messy real estate deal involving three tracts of land on Abaco’s No Man Cay - a cay near Treasure Cay that features swimming pigs.
SEE PAGE 6
By NATARIO MCKENZIE
Tribune Business Reporter
nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net THE government will spark “social unrest” if it cuts public spending too rapidly and deeply, the deputy prime minister has warned, as he attacked “ridiculous” pre-election job contracts. K Peter Turnquest, addressing the Rotary Club of Old Fort on Wednesday evening, conceded that the government was stuck with an “inflated” civil service wage bill in the short-term given that extensive cuts would lead to massive unemployment and a “tremendous economic shock”. With the civil service wage bill at around $750m,
* CAN’T SLASH SERVICES, BENEFITS ‘OVERNIGHT’ * WOULD CAUSE ‘MAJOR ECONOMIC SHOCK’ * SLAMS ‘RIDICULOUS’ PRE-ELECTION JOB DEALS and health insurance and pension contributions adding a further $65m and $100m, respectively, the public sector’s human resources presently cost taxpayers over $900m. Mr Turnquest conceded there was “more we need to do”, and that the cost of
K PETER TURNQUEST government is “too high” and must be brought down to a sustainable level. He said much of that cost revolves around various fixed commitments such as rent and the public sector wage bill.
SEE PAGE 3