business@tribunemedia.net
THURSDAY, JULY 11, 2019
$4.55 ‘Tax on society’: 75% of workers have no pension
BAHAMIANS face paying “another tax on society” to support the near-75 percent of workers not covered by an employersponsored pension plan, a leading investment banker has warned. Michael Anderson, pictured, RoyalFidelity Merchant Bank & Trust’s president, told Tribune Business that the Central Bank’s latest private pensions survey had again highlighted the need for Bahamians to “start sooner rather than later” when it came to building savings for their retirement. He said the survey, which found that just 25.7 percent of Bahamian workers were covered by an employersponsored plan in 2017, underscored the urgency with which this nation needed “to make inroads into what will be a significant problem in the future”. Mr Anderson added that Bahamians with either insufficient or no retirement
SEE PAGE 5
A
RCHITECTS have warned the government it is “losing millions of dollars” annually in VAT and other taxes through “unscrupulous” practices by consultants working on construction projects. The Institute of Bahamian Architects (IBA), in a February 2019 report submitted to the Ministry of Finance, said the Public Treasury as well as local professionals were not getting their due share because much of the work - especially on large-scale foreign direct investment (FDI) projects - was being performed offshore. The presentation, which has been seen by Tribune Business, argued that this was being aided by “unscrupulous licensed” Bahamian professionals who merely “stamped” plans and drawings locally - something that the IBA argued was a breach of the Professional Architects Act. “The Bahamas government loses millions of dollars from architectural and related consultancies on projects every year,” the IBA told the
‘Big jump’ over VAT realty submissions By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE government’s requirement that all documents for “stamping” on New Providence be submitted via e-mail from August 1 was yesterday described as “a big jump” by practitioners. Attorneys, speaking on condition of anonymity, questioned whether 20 days was sufficient time for everyone to come to grips with the electronic submission of conveyances and associated
paperwork to the Department of Inland Revenue. Yet that transition time is much greater than that allowed for islands other than New Providence, where all documents requiring “stamping” - whether under the Stamp Act or the value-added tax (VAT) now being imposed on real estate transactions - were supposed to be submitted electronically from July 1. The details are contained in “procedures for the VAT stamping” of conveyances
SEE PAGE 6
National debt in $30m FALL
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
THE Bahamas’ national debt has seen its first quarterly decline for years as it fell by just over $30m during the three-months to end-March 2019 thanks to a small budget surplus. The Central Bank’s quarterly review for the period, published this week, disclosed: “At end-March, the national
$4.61
Architects: Millions lost by ‘unscrupulous’ practices By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
$4.59
debt - inclusive of contingent liabilities - declined by $30.1m (0.4 percent) over the prior quarter to $8.186bn, but strengthened by $277.3m (3.5 percent) visà-vis March 2018.” One quarterly decline does not represent a trend, and the level of increase over the prior year indicates much more work remains to be done, but the quarterly
SEE PAGE 4
• Leakages shown to Finance ministry • Electronic link to building control urged • Institute: ‘Closer to 200 days’ for build permit Ministry of Finance. “Foreign/non-Bahamian licensed architects do majority of high-end projects in The Bahamas. This is despite the fact that none of these projects are beyond the abilities/scope of Bahamian architects. “The majority of Bahamian architects have been educated/trained in the US/Canada/UK like most of the foreign architects who illegally practice here. It is facilitated by unscrupulous licensed Bahamian architects (illegally stamping) and the Building Control Department in contravention of the Professional Architects Act.” The IBA presentation argued that this resulted in “significant tax and VAT losses to the government”. Pointing to the areas of leakage, it said business licence and VAT revenues were lost as the majority of the work and associated fees were performed by foreign architects based outside The Bahamas. And only “small fees” were earned by
Bahamian architects who merely stamped documents, which the IBA argued further reduced tax payments to the Public Treasury. Citing Ocean Club Estates on Paradise Island as an example to illustrate the potential revenue losses and leakages to the Ministry of Finance, the IBA said architects’ fees were typically ten percent of the construction costs. On a $5m home these would be $500,000, with the associated VAT payment standing at $62,500. While there is no evidence that any of the “unscrupulous” practices cited by the institute have occurred with any Ocean Club Estates home construction, its example added: “On average there are approximately five residences built every year in Ocean Club, which would result in VAT revenue of $312,500. “If the whole Bahamas is taken into consideration, including the private islands and numerous highend communities it can be seen that a significant portion of VAT is (potentially)
lost” on architects fees alone. The IBA said its figures did not take into account other professional consultants normally associated with such projects. Gustavus Ferguson, the IBA’s president, told Tribune Business that the Institute had wanted to show K P Turnquest, deputy prime minister and minister of finance, the “many ways” in which it believed the government was losing significant revenue associated with professional consultancy fees on multi-million development projects. “We wanted to speak to him as to how the country is losing revenue,” Mr Ferguson added of the presentation. “The country is losing revenue on many different fronts, and we’d looked at it in many different ways. “We gave him [Mr Turnquest] many different scenarios as to what’s happening now. We gave him estimates for revenue loss. All of that we presented to the Ministry of Finance.”
SEE PAGE 5
$4.61 Citibank to head BPL refinancing of up to $550m By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net CITIBANK has been selected as the lead adviser for the $450m-$550m mega financial restructuring of Bahamas Power & Light (BPL), Tribune Business has been informed. Geoff Andrews, chairman of the special purpose vehicle (SPV) that is key to the refinancing of BPL’s multiple legacy liabilities, confirmed both the choice and size of the planned capital raising when contacted by this newspaper. “They have been selected as the preferred bookrunner,” the former Deloitte & Touche accountant and partner said. “All of the respondents gave great proposals, and we had great meetings with them, but at the end we felt Citibank was the best prepared and qualified to lead us in the process. “The other institutions are large and well-qualified. It was a very tough decision to make, but we felt Citibank was the best choice.” Citibank had to beat off competition from rival bidders who included Goldman Sachs and a partnership between Credit Suisse and CIBC FirstCaribbean. Mr Andrews, who previously said more than three institutions were interviewed for the contract to act as financial adviser, placement
SEE PAGE 4