business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, JUNE 26, 2018
$4.80
Graycliff chief hits out over Tobacco Bill * WOULD PUT CIGAR MAKER ‘OUT OF BUSINESS’ * BILL’S PROVISIONS ‘ABSOLUTELY DREADFUL’ By NATARIO MCKENZIE
Tribune Business Reporter
nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net A PROMINENT Bahamian cigar manufacturer and hotelier yesterday warned that “absolutely dreadful” legislative reforms will “put us out of business” if implemented. Paolo Garzaroli, Graycliff Cigar Company’s president, hitting out at the Tobacco Control Bill 2017, told Tribune Business: “The law will basically put us out of business if they try and implement it.” He cited the numerous “absolutely dreadful” restrictions imposed on retailers as outlined in the Bill, and urged the government to reconsider legislative proposals now circulated for stakeholder feedback. “We can’t do promotional events. The government calls us and says: ‘Hey, why don’t you bring your cigar roller and let people see we make cigars here?’ We can’t do that. Ninety per cent of the stuff that we do we won’t be able to,” said Mr Garzaroli of the Bill’s consequences. “If someone is in the out islands - it happens all the time - and they say can you send me a box on the boat or the plane, we can’t do that. If they buy them, we can’t ship it to them. They would have to go to a store, pay them, and I would have to ship it to the store. “It would be illegal. It’s a $100,000 fine and a year in prison for a firsttime offence, and then $250,000 or five years for a second-time offender and continues to go up. It’s ridiculous. If it was cigarettes I could understand that, but it’s not cigarettes; it’s cigars. Persons would not be allowed to touch a cigar until they pay for it.” Mr Garzaroli was highlighting a section of the Bill which states that: “A person shall not, for consideration, cause a tobacco product to be delivered or sent by mail unless the
SEE PAGE 4
$4.82
$4.75
Budget’s sacrifices can’t be ‘one-sided’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
T
HE government must “make the same sacrifices” it is demanding of Bahamian taxpayers, a top accountant yesterday warning that past lax spending habits will no longer be “tolerated”. Craig “Tony” Gomez, the Baker Tilly Gomez accountant and partner, told Tribune Business that the government needed to show it will match the increased tax burden imposed on the Bahamian people by eliminating wasteful and unnecessary expenditure. While acknowledging that the budget’s tax hikes were “necessary” to fill a $400m financial hole, Mr Gomez said the government could demonstrate it was fulfilling its side of the bargain in tangible ways such as cutting back on the number of “red-plated” vehicles seen on the roads at the weekend. He added that the public
* Govt must match VAT hike with waste cut * Accountant points to ‘red plate’ car usage * Public sector can’t be immune from hardship
CRAIG GOMEZ
sector could not continue to be immune from the hardships felt by private sector workers, such as hotel employees already facing reduced work weeks as summer approaches, arguing that “the pain” from the VAT rate increase and other measures needed to be shared equally.
Emphasising that the government now needed to fulfill its pledges of full fiscal transparency and accountability, Mr Gomez said it had to deliver the benefits it promised from its fiscal consolidation plan to Bahamians in ways they can see and feel. The Baker Tilly partner also warned against using the projected $400m VAT revenue increase to simply increase government spending, as the former Christie administration had done, and echoed other observers in pointing out that The Bahamas cannot tax its way to growth. Mr Gomez argued that the government needed to lay out a clear, achievable near-term growth plan, adding that any further hike in the VAT rate within the next three years would be unacceptable to Bahamian taxpayers.
Yet he backed assertions by KP Turnquest, deputy prime minister, that The Bahamas is one major hurricane away from financial disaster, with the government possessing “no wiggle room at all” should a Hurricane Matthew-type event occur. “With regards to the budget, my own view is that it is necessary,” Mr Gomez told Tribune Business. “Not everyone is going to agree, but if you’re comparing it to a home budget where you’re asking everyone in the home to make a sacrifice, not everyone is going to be happy but it is being done for the good of all. “The government, by virtue of passing the budget, has taken on the responsibility of carrying it out for the benefit of The Bahamas
SEE PAGE 3
Small businesses urged: delay lay-offs to October By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net SMALL businesses were yesterday urged to delay lay-offs until October, a sector consultant revealing over one-third of his clients are eyeing immediate cutbacks amid VAT-related “panic”. Mark A Turnquest told Tribune Business that while start-ups needed to make “some serious adjustments to their business model” in response to the imminent VAT rate hike, they should avoid “jumping to conclusions” that downsizing was inevitable. He revealed that 40 percent of his small business clients were faced with having to absorb the 60 percent rate increase themselves, as they fall below the $100,000 annual turnover threshold that mandates they become VAT registrants. As non-registrants they are unable to charge VAT to consumers, but are still faced with paying the same levy on their inputs. This means the VAT rate
$4.91 Govt urged: ‘Stop running aviation industry by crisis’
* Adviser: one-third of clients eye cuts * ‘Panic’ over imminent VAT rate hike * Rise adds to costs, many can’t net-off increase to 12 percent will raise their own costs, and Mr Turnquest said 90 percent of his non-VAT registrant clients were already contemplating layoffs in response. He disclosed that he had advised against such a knee-jerk response, and instead was urging small businesses to hold off until October to allow time for the VAT rate increase’s impact on consumer spending and the wider economy to work its way through. “My clients are unhappy with the VAT increase because they said it was too short notice, and for the small business under $100,000 it is an additional business expense for them,” Mr Turnquest told Tribune Business. “Forty percent of my clients are under $100,000. It is a major impact. They have to absorb all that 4.5 percentage point extra cost,
and the expense associated with that. Of those, 90 percent of them indicated their staff complement will be reduced. If they can’t see where to make ends meet, MARK A they will have to lay-off TURNQUEST on their beststaff. selling products “I told them: Try not to and services; lay-off people even if you tight inventory managehave to put them on half ment and a focus on buying weeks,” Mr Turnquest con- in bulk to lower costs. tinued. “I also told them “I have spoken to a lot of not to do anything until my clients, and told them October; don’t jump to that they have to make some conclusion. serious adjustments to their “They’re panicking about business model by doing next week [VAT increases their best to reduce costs,” from July 1]. I told them to he revealed. “They have to wait. I have all my clients buy in bulk and, to manage looking to October as a costs, focus on high-flypotential turn to determine ing products and services how we move forward, and they can sell - the frequent looking at the cost structure sellers. “I told them to minimise of their organisations.” Mr Turnquest said he had any slow-selling stock, and advised entrepreneurs and they have to manage their small business start-ups to inventory very, very proacmitigate the budget’s VAT tively because of the costs increase in other ways, prinSEE PAGE 4 cipally through focusing
By NATARIO MCKENZIE
Tribune Business Reporter
nmckenzie@tribunemedia.net A BAHAMIAN aviation executive yesterday questioned the government’s plan for the sector again, and urged: “stop governing by crisis.” Sky Bahamas chief executive, Randy Butler, pictured, was responding to statements by minister of tourism and aviation, Dionisio D’Aguilar, who confirmed to Tribune Business that Bahamasair’s lenders have again been asked to defer principal repayment on its $120m loan for another year, as there was simply “no headroom” in the 2018-2019 budget to accommodate such outlays. Mr Butler told Tribune Business: “all this underscores is the fact that there needs to be a national plan for this industry. What is the future of Bahamasair? What is the vision for the airline, and how will the privateowned airlines factor into it all? We have to stop this governing by crisis; reacting when things happen but not having a plan for the industry.” He recalled statements by then-Deputy Prime Minister Philip Davis, who on the heels of a Bahamasair pilot strike back in December 2014 stated that stakeholders needed to realise the airline was “no longer an essential service”. Still, the Christie administration authorised the $120m loan in 2016 to reequip Bahamasair’s fleet and refinance its existing debt, replacing its Dash-8 planes with five ATR turbo prop aircraft. Interest (debt servicing) costs on the loan are understood to run close to $10m per annum. “Is it an essential service? Bahamasair doesn’t go to most of the Family Islands but is taking Bahamians to Florida every day for shopping trips,” Mr Butler said. “There really should be a master plan for Bahamasair. Right now, they could only operate with subsidies. There has to be a goal and a vision. You have to get people to buy-in, and you have to measure the performance.”
Retailers given until end-august for VAT pricing adjustments By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net BAHAMIAN retailers have until August 31 to adjust prices for the 12 percent VAT, with top government officials yesterday expressing confidence that the transition will “not disrupt” commerce. Marlon Johnson, the Ministry of Finance’s acting financial secretary, told Tribune Business that the extra two months was a “reasonable” extension that will allow large retailers with thousands of shelf and inventory items to reprice - more time to meet the budget’s requirements. “This is just because we know there are retailers that have hundreds, if not thousands, of items to go
through,” he explained of the August 31 deadline. “They will be required to put signage throughout their establishments that the correct VAT will be assessed at the counter and on consumers’ receipts. “That gives them time to make the changes they have to. We have ‘big box’ retailers and supermarkets that have thousands of items to reprice. There’s some who will get it done in time, but we want to be mindful of the necessary changes they have to go through. We felt it would be reasonable to them.” The VAT transition “guidance notes” were finally released to the Bahamian private sector at the weekend, giving various industries and individual businesses just one week
* TRANSITION GUIDANCE RELEASED WITH WEEK TO GO * TOP FINANCE OFFICIAL CONFIDENT ‘NO DISRUPTION’ * NO REAL ESTATE ESCAPE ON ‘EXEMPT’ STATUS to comply with the “fine details” of the budget’s requirements before the 12 percent VAT rate comes into being on July 1. Confirming the extra two-month transition granted to Bahamian retailers, the “transition notes” state: “If you conduct business as a retailer there are some challenges that we
MARLON JOHNSON know that you will face in the repricing of items displayed for sale immediately after the coming into effect of the new VAT rates. “You would be allowed to take any of the following measures until August 31 or otherwise as stated by the [VAT] comptroller. Although we expect you to exert every effort to ensure that your pricing is in keeping with the dictates of the VAT Act 2014 as amended,
SEE PAGE 3