business@tribunemedia.net
FRIDAY, JUNE 19, 2020
$3.72
$3.73
$3.80
$3.23
Aggregate miner targeting ‘Pure insanity’ if Andros investor ‘full’ $125m Andros spend ignores Freeport
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
A
N AGGREGATE mining and land reclamation development, featuring a $15m-$20m first phase investment and creation of 35 jobs, is among three “very different and separate projects” currently targeting North Andros. Cameron Symonette, The Symonette Group’s chief executive, is one of the principals behind the Bahamas Materials Company Ltd project that was presented to the North Andros District Council on June 9 as part of an extensive feedback and consultation process. The presentation, a copy
• Symonette Group chief in proposal • One of three eyeing developments • 35 first-phase jobs, could rise to 100
of which has been obtained by Tribune Business, reveals that Mr Symonette and his prospective partners plan to mine for calcium carbonate (limestone) on a 5,500 acre “brownfield” site featuring now-unused Water & Sewerage Corporation wellfields in North Andros. The extracted rock would then be crushed and screened at a purposebuilt plant before being exported by sea to either Florida or New Providence for use by the construction industry in a variety of
construction applications. However, the presentation goes beyond mere aggregate mining to explore how the land could be reclaimed, and repurposed, for other productive use such as real estate once all the rock has been extracted. Bahamas Materials Company is proposing a corporate structure where a subsidiary, Morgan’s Bluff Development Group Ltd, would ultimately take back all the land and offer its shares to Bahamians in a bid to create wealth and
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
ownership opportunities. Seeking to capitalise on the government’s urgent search for economic diversification amid the devastation inflicted by the COVID-19 pandemic, the Bahamas Materials Company proposal suggests it could ultimately employ more than 100 Bahamians and take its investment to over $125m at full buildout. Potential production is estimated at 500-700 tons, with all mining carried out
SEE PAGE 4
Budget’s missed opportunity for progressive tax reforms By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE 2020-2021 budget represents a missed opportunity to kickstart talks on progressive reforms such as personal and corporate income taxes, a University of The Bahamas (UoB) economics lecturer is arguing. Rupert Pinder told Tribune Business that The Bahamas needed to move away from its regressive consumption-based taxation structure, centred on VAT and import tariffs, given that it disproportionately impacts poorer Bahamians by consuming more of their income than higher earners. Suggesting that COVID19 had created an ideal opening to initiate reform discussions that was not taken up by the budget, Mr Pinder said there was some scope to increase tax
• Economist: Put income/corporate tax ‘on table’ • Calls for expanding base, not raising rates • ‘No way around’ new and/or raised taxes revenues once the economy recovers given that they have traditionally fallen below the 20 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) threshold recommended as a minimum by international agencies such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF). However, he quickly pointed out that increased revenues could be generated by broadening the tax base rather than increasing rates. The UoB lecturer pointed to Barbados as one example of this, noting that it had responded to the European Union’s (EU) demands to end so-called “ring fencing” by extending corporate income tax
Ex-US diplomat in 25,000 acre Andros venture By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
A $5M commercial faming venture that involved a former US ambassador to The Bahamas was yesterday identified as one of three competing investment proposals targeting North Andros. Documents obtained by Tribune Business name Ned Siegel, an ex-US ambassador to this nation under George W Bush’s administration, as a partner in an “American-Bahamian partnership” seeking to lease 25,000 acres of land from
the Crown and Bahamas Agricultural and Industrial Corporation (BAIC) in the Twin Lakes area on Andros. Mr Siegel did not return Tribune Business’s call seeking comment yesterday, and several sources suggested he may no longer be involved with a project that is thought to have been formally submitted to the Bahamas Investment Authority (BIA) for the necessary government approvals last year. It is thought that the project has stalled in the approvals process, with
SEE PAGE 5
IT: Bahamas needs 15-year overhaul completed in five By YOURI KEMP Tribune Business Reporter ykemp@tribunemedia.net THE Bahamas and wider Caribbean must complete a 15-year transformation in just five years to catch up with the developed world in information technology (ICT), a local provider is arguing. Scott MacKenzie, chief executive of Cloud Carib, told Tribune Business: “The Grand Bahama technology hub was structured to aid in the development of Grand Bahama and The Bahamas from a technology perspective. I think the drive now is
to formulate a programme, a national strategy and programme. “From an education perspective let’s be realistic. The users are the future and in order to instill true modern day ICT practices throughout the region, it’s generational change. Our generation, we can make things happen today, but those are all short-term gains. So unless you put a programme in place that, over the next two or three generations, is really going to elevate the entire region and make it globally competitive,
SEE PAGE 7
beyond just its domestic economy to the offshore sector as well. By increasing the number of entities subjected to this tax, Mr Pinder said Barbados created a “win-win proposition” for its domestic economy as the broader base enabled it to lower the rates for businesses in this area without any drop in total revenues. Several Bahamian private sector sources have privately suggested to Tribune Business that this nation needs to follow Barbados’ example and increase taxation on its international business sector, with some even going so far as to suggest that corporate income
taxes need to be considered as the present structure is not working. Mr Pinder, meanwhile, acknowledging that COVID-19’s economic devastation meant tax reforms will have little near-term impact, added that he was unable to see The Bahamas escaping the need to introduce new and/or increased taxes to combat its growing deficit and debt burden once the pandemic’s worst effects are over. KP Turnquest, deputy prime minister, told this newspaper earlier this week that it was “too early” to talk about the need for such
SEE PAGE 7
A PROMINENT QC yesterday argued it would be “pure economic insanity” if the government permits a US billionaire philanthropist to develop a free-trade zone on Andros instead of basing his project in Freeport. Fred Smith QC, the Callenders & Co attorney and partner, told Tribune Business that The Bahamas will be “reinventing the wheel” if it fails to direct Dr Patrick Soon-Shiong to a city “where everything is set up for him” in terms of the infrastructure required to support his ambitions. Responding to revelations of the cancer drug inventor’s Andros plans, Mr Smith said: “My view is that it is pure economic insanity for the government to even contemplate this kind of project in other parts of The Bahamas when Freeport is lying fallow and simply needs investment directed its way. “This is nothing more than political will to make Freeport succeed. Creating this proliferation of competing anchor projects throughout the rest of The Bahamas dilutes Freeport’s economic impact, and creates a governance challenge will greatly impacting the culture, environment and society in these very small islands. “Freeport is sitting here waiting for just this kind of investment. Please can you direct such a legitimate investor to Freeport where everything is set up for him. You don’t have to reinvent the wheel. The Government continues to try and reinvent the Freeport wheel
FRED SMITH QC elsewhere without success rather than make the existing wheel turn.” Dr Soon-Shiong, who was said by Forbes to have a net worth of $6.9bn as at March 2020, would appear to be the sort of legitimate, bona fide investor that The Bahamas needs to attract to reignite its economy and employment in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. A part-owner of the Los Angeles Lakers, and owner and executive chairman of the Los Angeles Times and The San Diego UnionTribune newspapers, he also seem to have the financial wherewithal necessary to both acquire the Grand Bahama Port Authority (GBPA) and fulfill the vision for Freeport that is set out in the Hawksbill Creek Agreement. And Freeport, a city created for 300,000 persons, already possesses much of the roads, lands and other infrastructure required by Dr Soon-Shiong for a free trade zone plan based on value-added manufacturing, eco tourism and medical clinic/tourism. Locating to The Bahamas’ second city would likely significantly reduce the infrastructure build-out costs associated
SEE PAGE 4