05292020 BUSINESS

Page 1

business@tribunemedia.net

FRIDAY, MAY 29, 2020

$3.27

$3.27

Inland Revenue urged: Probe $68m ‘tax gap’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

T

HE government’s financial watchdog has urged the Department of Inland Revenue (DIR) to be more aggressive in probing discrepancies of up to $68m between a company’s VAT and business licence fee turnover. The auditor-general’s report for the 2016-2017 fiscal year, tabled in Parliament this week, called on the government’s main revenue collecting agency to “follow up and investigate” more rapidly when glaring anomalies were exposed in

• Massive VAT, business licence discrepancies • Big group’s ‘under-reporting’ cost $5.1m VAT • Firm’s turnover $43m higher than certified

TERRANCE BASTIAN, auditor-general.

tax returns and filings. Although the annual turnover (sales) reported by a company for VAT and business licence purposes should be the same, the report revealed that one major Bahamian corporate group - identified only as “taxpayer D” - submitted filings showing a $68.06m difference between the two. While its business licence filing reported annual turnover of $188.767m, its separate VAT filings pegged

this at just $120.707m. The difference was unexplained in the report, with the auditor general calling for the Department of Inland Revenue’s enforcement unit to undertake a “field audit” of “taxpayer D”. Finding that the turnover “variances” had resulted in a large Bahamas-based conglomerate “underreporting” the VAT it should have paid by $5.1m,

SEE PAGE 8

PM puts web shops in ‘dice roll’ dilemma By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net TWO Bahamian web shop operators must now “roll the dice” on whether to proceed with their legal action against the Prime Minister after he re-opened the industry less than 24 hours after its filing. Wayne Munroe QC, the attorney for Paradise Games and TIG Investments, trading as The Island Game, told Tribune Business that he was now awaiting instructions from his clients on how to proceed after Dr Hubert Minnis announced that the domestic gaming sector can re-open its locations with effect from this coming Tuesday. The duo had previously asked him to file litigation challenging the legal validity

• Re-opens sector 24 hours after action filed • QC now awaiting clients’ instructions • Says not all staff to return immediately

WAYNE MUNROE QC of both the government’s Emergency Powers regulations and the way they were allegedly used to single out the gaming industry as the only one unable to offer curb side service to clients, thereby forcing all operators

Shoppers urged: ‘Rebuild country from within’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

BAHAMIANS were yesterday urged to “rebuild our country from within” and “think twice” about spending money abroad as the prime minister gave the goahead for the retail sector’s full re-opening. Egan Kemp, president of Eunison Company, the Shoe Depot parent, told Tribune Business it was “hugely important” that retailers such as his be allowed to open their stores to customers even if COVID-19 health protocols result

in reduced volumes. Having already “terminated half of my staff”, Mr Kemp said he would bring back all remaining employees immediately until he obtained a better understanding of how much consumer demand remains in the pandemic’s wake. Also hailing the government’s decision to introduce a two-week “backto-school” VAT holiday to relieve the financial stress on hard-pressed consumers, Mr Kemp pleaded with Bahamians to shop at home and keep dollars circulating

SEE PAGE 9

DPM: GB airport will be restored ‘to former glory’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE deputy prime minister yesterday pledged that the government is still committed to acquiring Grand Bahama International Airport and “restoring it to its former glory”. K Peter Turnquest, speaking at a post-Budget press conference, said the Minnis administration was still in talks with the current joint venture owners, Hutchison Port Holdings and the Grand Bahama Port Authority (GBPA), to take over the facility and rebuild

it following the catastrophic damage inflicted by Hurricane Dorian. “We are still in discussions with the owners of Grand Bahama International Airport for the eventual transfer to the government with the objective of restoring it to its former glory with a new terminal, taking into account the level of storm surge it has suffered in past hurricanes,” Mr Turnquest said. “Yes, we do intend to go forward with the transfer of the airport to the government and invest in that facility to get it up and

SEE PAGE 11

to close their stores for another two weeks. Mr Munroe said his clients will now have to weigh the prospects of their action’s success, and the potential damages they could earn, against the possibility of failure as well as the costs associated with that. He added that much would likely depend on their calculation of lost profits/earnings, which he estimated would likely take five to eight days to compile. His comments came after the prime minister announced that gaming houses can again re-open as part of “phase three” in

his recovery plan, saying: “Gaming Houses will be allowed to open with physical distancing and sanitisation protocols, effective this coming Tuesday.” Dr Minnis’ move came less than 24 hours after Mr Munroe filed the Notice of Motion initiating legal action against the prime minister, in his role as the “Competent Authority”, and Carl Bethel QC, the attorney general, on behalf of The Island Game and Paradise Games. As promised, the action’s first bid is to seek a Supreme

SEE PAGE 11

$3.28

K PETER TURNQUEST

$3.23

MARLON JOHNSON

Taxation out even if no recovery by end-2021 By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE government yesterday ruled out new and/or increased taxes to cure its fiscal woes even if the Bahamian economy has failed to recover from COVID-19 by winter 2021. K Peter Turnquest, deputy prime minister, speaking at a post-budget press conference, said that while further “interventions” would be necessary if the economy failed to rebound from the pandemic within the next 18 months these did not include greater taxation. Reiterating the government’s belief that increased taxes cannot be imposed on an already-struggling economy, given that it would simply become further depressed, Mr Turnquest again voiced optimism that The Bahamas will enjoy a “relatively quick” recovery that will have started to take root in time for the 2021 New Year and peak winter tourism season. “We are confident we will see an economic recovery relatively quickly,” he said. “Certainly, by January 2021 we should start to see a recovery in tourism numbers, which is our main economic driver. If we get to fall/winter 2021, and don’t see the kind of results we anticipate we will have another set of decisions to make, but I don’t think taxation is the answer.

“You can appreciate that if the economy slows down, adding new taxation does not help us, so we will have to look at other interventions. We do not anticipate that will be needed.” Many observers believe that the government will have no choice but to introduce new and/or increased taxes in the medium term, once the Bahamian economy has recovered from COVID-19, due to the massively increased debt burden it is taking on. The $1.327bn fiscal deficit projected for 2020-2021 is forecast to be followed by a further $813.4m in 20212022. When combined with the $773.7m worth of “red ink” now predicted for the current 2019-2020 fiscal year, the government will have increased its direct debt - which will break the $10bn mark in 2021-2022 by $2.9bn in just three years. This is forecast to produce a 15.5 percent, or more than $58m, increase in The Bahamas’ debt servicing (interest) costs over three years. The interest bill just to service the national debt is forecast to rise from $377.052m to $435.498m by the 2022-2023 fiscal year, further cementing its place as the largest and most costly line item in the government’s annual budget. Mr Turnquest, though, reiterated the government’s belief that The Bahamas can grow its way out of the

SEE PAGE 9


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.