business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, MAY 2, 2017
$4.20
$4.30
Civil society unites to halt legislative ‘panic’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net Fourteen Bahamian civil society organisations have joined forces to push for a standard public consultation process over new laws and investment projects, describing this as “a critical piece of the puzzle for good governance”. The Organisation for Responsible Governance (ORG), in a joint position paper with groups such as Our Carmichael and reEarth, said the absence of a properly-defined consultation paper undermined both government transpar-
Fourteen groups call for standard public consultation Absence ‘not serving Bahamas’ best interests’ Labour law controversy exposed flaws ency and the basis of the Bahamas’ democracy. “This lack of straight-forward, transparent and proactive processes for public
consultation does not support a positive and factbased dialogue to establish policies designed to best serve the general interest of the nation,” the civil society groups warned. “Instead, it can make policy-making efforts contentious and oppositional. It also breeds a culture of pessimism and detachment of the Bahamian people, reinforces the growing public mistrust of government and discourages civic participation in the democratic processes of the nation.” Rick Lowe, an executive with the Nassau Institute, one of the signatories to the position paper, told
Tribune Business that the recent controversy over the Government’s proposed labour law reforms highlighted “the panic” that can be caused by ill thoughtout legislation that is introduced without warning. “Everybody went into a panic,” he recalled. “The Government only heard one side of the argument before proceeding. There didn’t seem to be a sense of balance to the way they approached it.” Following a week of intensive, frantic negotiations, the Christie administration ultimately amended its proposed Employment See pg b5
Baha Mar Heads show ‘Bahamians paying for deal’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net Opposition politicians yesterday argued that Baha Mar’s newly-released Heads of Agreement confirms “the Bahamian people are the ones paying for this deal”, and the $101.5 million creditor payout, via tax breaks granted to the project’s new owner. K P Turnquest, the FNM’s deputy leader, told Tribune Business that the Christie administration’s agreement with Chow Tai Fook Enterprises (CTFE), signed on April 25, revealed “the true cost of this deal” for the taxpayer. “First you have the indirect costs given up until 2019, and then the direct cost that’s involved in terms of contributing to the severance payments and causing this deal to happen,” he said of the tax breaks and incentives granted to CTFE. “I can’t ever begrudge Bahamians being made whole, but we must be honest with the Bahamian when we are talking about who is paying for the severance payments and creditors. It’s the Bahamian people through the concessions granted. It may not be a direct payment from the Treasury, but it’s revenue given up.” Mr Turnquest was backed by Branville McCartney, the Democratic National Alliance’s (DNA) leader, See pg b4
VAT, transfer tax breaks ‘finance creditor payouts’ Bran, KP slam CTFE deal as ‘complete giveaway’ Vital revenue for cash-strapped Treasury foregone
Baha Mar Resort
Fears over Baha Mar infrastructure costs By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net Fears were raised last night that the Government’s Heads of Agreement with Baha Mar’s new owner may have exposed taxpayers to a multi-million dollar infrastructure bill, after it waived obligations imposed on the original developer. An attorney with See pg b5
Branville McCartney
kp Turnquest
New deal releases CTFE from financing obligation Concern taxpayers, public must foot the bill Casino tax incentives to cover CTFE operating losses
$4.30
$4.28
Insurer 16-17% ahead of target if no Matthew By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A Bahamian general insurer yesterday said it would have beaten 2016 profit forecasts “by 16-17 per cent” had it not been for Hurricane Matthew, which blew gross claims 69.4 per cent higher than its previous record. Tom Duff, Insurance Company of the Bahamas (ICB) general manager, told Tribune Business that if its $2.8 million share of those gross losses was ‘written back in’, the company’s performance would have been flat compared to 2015. However, Mr Duff said ICB was especially encouraged that its balance sheet had emerged “relatively unscathed” from the record loss event for both itself and the wider Bahamian insurance industry, with net equity just shy of $30 million at year-end 2016. He added that Matthew had been “the perfect storm” in terms of its path, which took the Category Three/Four hurricane near New Providence and Free-
Storm blows ICB to $61m gross losses record Claims 69% higher than previous mark; share $2.8m Top executive sees ‘halt’ to property rates slide port - its two areas of greatest risk exposure. Looking ahead, Mr Duff said the relatively weak economy and tight disposable incomes will make it hard for Bahamian property and casualty underwriters to increase gross written premiums, ICB’s having fallen by 1.4 per cent yearover-year in 2016. However, he suggested that ICB and its competitors could be helped by Hurricane Matthew, as losses associated with the event were likely “to halt any further softening” in Bahamian property See pg b4
Exuma ‘deserted island’, says $100m Fyre Fest lawsuit By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net The negative Fyre Festival fall-out intensified yesterday as a Hollywood celebrity attorney described Exuma as a “dangerous, deserted island” in a lawsuit seeking $100 million in damages from the organisers. Mark Geragos, who has See pg b4
Claims attendees suffered ‘false imprisonment’ Even though it admits ‘Sandals down the road’ Dangerous animals id’d; it’s Exuma’s swimming pigs