business@tribunemedia.net
THURSDAY, APRIL 1, 2021
$4.81
$4.81
PI entrepreneur makes ‘let’s go PM’ challenge
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
T
HE entrepreneur behind the proposed $2m restoration of Paradise Island’s lighthouse yesterday said he is “throwing down the gauntlet” to the government, and urged: “Let’s go prime minister.” Toby Smith, principal of Paradise Island Lighthouse & Beach Club Company, told Tribune Business he was turning the minister of tourism’s call for Bahamians to develop tours and attractions “of scale” back at the Minnis administration with his own challenge for it to “take your feet off the necks
• Urges govt: ‘Take feet off Bahamian necks’ • Says held-up project answers minister’s call • ‘Time to put up or shut up’ over local support of Bahamians and let us thrive”. Emphasising that he was not criticising Mr D’Aguilar, who he said “gets it”, Mr Smith said he has been trying for 3,274 days to get just such a project past the “hoops and hurdles” constantly placed in his way by a government bureaucracy that continually favours foreign investors over their Bahamian counterparts. Reiterating that his
SEE PAGE 6
LIGHTHOUSE at Paradise Island.
$4.5m investor recovery derailed by perfect storm By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net A $4.5m recovery for long-suffering investors in a Bahamas-based investment fund structure has been derailed by a combination of Hurricane Dorian, COVID-19 and the loss of a major tenant. Myles Culmer, director of BDO Bahamas’ advisory services, confirmed in recent e-mailed replies to Tribune Business questions that he and fellow liquidators face having to start afresh on one of the major compensation sources for investors in the Olympus Univest fund which collapsed almost 16 years ago owing some $471m. That source is the majority 50.4 percent equity interest in Premier Real Estate Investment Corporation, the former BISX-listed
• Dorian damage hits Premier Commerical value • Compounded by Oxyanos’ move to exit lease • Wait goes on for long-suffering 2,000 investors real estate investment trust (REIT), whose commercial property portfolio has gradually shrunk to just the one Freeport office complex it owns presently. That stake is held by Mosaic Composite, the major investment counterparty for Olympus Univest. Both entities are now controlled by Mr Culmer and his co-liquidators from Richter Advisory in Canada, who have been repeatedly frustrated in their attempts to maximise the value of this holding and convert it into liquid cash for the benefit of investors. Previous reports by the liquidators estimated this
Oil explorer: ‘Funds fled’ after activists launched challenge By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Bahamas Petroleum Company (BPC) was forced to seek additional funding for its Perseverance One well after “funds fled away from us” due to the legal challenge launched by environmentalists. Simon Potter, the company’s chief executive, in a March 30, 2021, interview with Proactive London revealed that the Judicial Review initiated by Save the Bays and Waterkeepers Bahamas had “created the perfect storm” that forced the oil explorer to seek an additional $19m in financing from
SIMON POTTER an institutional investment fund managed by Lombard Odier Asset Management. That move angered a number of existing BPC shareholders, who argued that it would serve to dilute the value of their holdings
SEE PAGE 5
Cruise tourism is ‘resoundingly’ not for Harbour Island By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
ELEUTHERA’S Chamber of Commerce president has warned the Ministry of Tourism that Harbour Island “resoundingly” believes Crystal Cruises is “the wrong model” for its destination. Thomas Sands, in an e-mailed communication to Janet Johnson, head of the Tourism Development Corporation, said: “Further to your communication requesting feedback from the Eleuthera Chamber of Commerce related to the proposed Crystal Cruises stopover to Harbour Island, please note that our membership
across Eleuthera (from north to south, resident and non-resident) have voiced their concern regarding the proposal. “The resounding sentiment is that this is the wrong model for the Harbour Island destination. Specifically, there are logistical concerns (related to how to safely get passengers on and off the ship, particularly during rough seas); infrastructural concerns (given the likely increase in street traffic, increase in garbage, etc); and concerns that the economic benefit would not compensate for
SEE PAGE 9
would realise between $4m-$5m, expanding the mere $10.7m recovered for Olympus Univest investors to-date by almost 50 percent and lessening the blow - albeit modestly from what was seen at the time as a black mark for the Bahamian financial services sector. However, confirming that such ambitions have again - at least for the moment been dashed - Mr Culmer told this newspaper: “As you are aware both Hurricane Dorian and the COVID-19 pandemic have had devastating impacts on Grand Bahama’s economy, and these effects have been
felt throughout the country. “We have thus far been unsuccessful in selling Mosaic’s equity stake in Premier Commercial, but The Mosaic joint official liquidators are continuing in their efforts to either monetise or enhance the value of Premier’s last remaining property - all in an attempt to realise upon same while marketing the controlling shares of Premier.” While Premier Commercial sold the two former Caribbean Bottling properties it owned in 2016, liquidators’ reports obtained by Tribune
SEE PAGE 9
$4.85
$4.85
Activists get $200k for BPC hearing but there’s a catch By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
OIL exploration opponents were last night faced with having to seek the Supreme Court’s permission for more time despite raising the $200,000 to cover Bahamas Petroleum Company’s (BPC) legal costs. Fred Smith QC, the Callenders & Co attorney and partner, told Tribune Business he was “aghast” at the oil explorer’s refusal to co-operate in overcoming The Bahamas’ strict bank account opening procedures so that the “security for costs” could be secured in compliance with the Supreme Court’s orders. He argued that BPC’s decision to decline an extension for his clients, Save the Bays and Waterkeepers Bahamas, showed that it was “obsessed with striking out” the activists’ Judicial Review challenge and was using the “security for costs” demand as a tactic to achieve this. Asserting that BPC would have agreed to an extension “if they were really interested in having security for their costs”, Mr Smith said the oil explorer - which recently failed to strike commercial quantities of oil in Bahamian waters with its Perseverance One well had “waited until the 59th minute of the 11th hour for time to run out” to decline co-operation. An e-mail from Adrian Hunt, an attorney and partner at Graham, Thompson & Company, the law firm acting for BPC, responded to Mr Smith’s requests by saying: “We have received instructions and can confirm that our clients are not prepared to agree the extension.”
FRED SMITH QC That e-mail was sent at 11.07am yesterday, which was one day after the March 30, 2021, deadline set by Justice Petra HannaAdderley for the activists to produce the $200,000 bond to cover BPC’s costs so that the substantive issues raised by their Judicial Review challenge can be heard. The environmentalists now face having to go back before the Supreme Court to argue their case for an extension of the March 30 deadline to April 15. This point has been reached despite Mr Smith and his law firm, Callenders & Co, reaching out to BPC’s attorneys from Monday, March 29, confirming their clients have raised the $200,000 and seeking help in overcoming The Bahamas’ Know Your Customer (KYC) rules. Mr Smith, according to documents filed with the Supreme Court, wrote to Leif Farquharson on Monday, March 29, telling him: “We have been informed by our clients that they have raised the full $200,000 through various fund-raising efforts internationally, and that these funds are currently being transferred to Callenders. “Given the onerous KYC and administrative requirements of our banks, we foresee some delay
SEE PAGE 8