business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, MARCH 31, 2020
$4.38
RUPERT ROBERTS
Super Value chief eyes overtime ease via new measures By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net SUPER Value’s principal yesterday voiced hope that new shopping restrictions will “work better than what’s happening now” and enable him to reverse a 20 percent increase in overtime payroll. Rupert Roberts told Tribune Business that the Prime Minister’s COVID-19 related plan for every household to designate a single shopper, and introduce a schedule where that person can only shop on certain days, would enable customers to spend more time in stores. Emphasising that he was “100 percent in favour” of already-enacted social distancing measures, the Super Value chief said sales at some of his larger stores had dropped by between five to ten percent compared to the prior week due to customers having to queue in-line before they can enter. “I hope that works better than what’s happening now,” Mr Roberts said of the new measures unveiled by Dr Hubert Minnis on Sunday evening. “Our sales are actually off in the big stores because people can’t get into shop. It’s different areas, but it’s five to ten percent down in the big stores. Winton seemed to be the exception. They did a little more. “The other big stores couldn’t get the sales in. The social distancing has really slowed down the rate of shopping, but I’m not surprised. I expected the sales to go down this week, not because they were panicked shopping, but the customers have been there and couldn’t get in. At Cable Beach on Sunday they were line up the whole length of the shopping centre from Super Value to Wendy’s. “We are spreading them out, and it’s half the spend it used to be as they cannot get the shopping in. The wait is too long. Right now it’s going to slow. They’re lined up and they just cannot shop. We’re not going to do the sales with restricted shopping that we did with unrestricted shopping.”
SEE PAGE 3
$4.39
$60m pay plan needs ‘marriage’ for success
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
T
HE government was yesterday urged to “marry health with economics” to maximise the “phenomenal gesture” of its $60m bid to safeguard up to 10,000 jobs through tax credits and deferrals. Robert Myers, the Organisation for Responsible Governance’s (ORG) principal, told Tribune Business that the complete lockdown imposed upon many businesses meant they would enjoy little benefit from the initiative unveiled yesterday by K Peter Turnquest, deputy prime minister. While acknowledging that the government was showing “a real willingness to help companies and employees stay alive” amid the COVID-19 pandemic, Mr Myers argued that the combination of tax deferrals and credits “doesn’t make sense” unless his businesses were allowed to operate at closer to 50-60 percent of their revenue-earning capacity. And he added that the deferral element, which could amount to a
• Tax credit/deferrals ‘phenomenal gesture’ • But govt must combine health, economics • Chamber raises concerns over benefits
ROBERT MYERS maximum of $300,000 for qualifying businesses, still represented a “significant liability” that companies ultimately will have to pay back to the government since it has only been postponed not forgiven. Mr Myers said such a liability was especially concerning given the uncertainty over how long, and deep, the COVID-19 pandemic and associated lockdown will be, coupled with the inability of many businesses to earn any revenue during this time. The ORG chief was not alone in his questions over
a government initiative targeted at medium-sized to large Bahamian enterprises. Mr Turnquest yesterday said it was intended to provide “payroll support”, and incentivise qualifying companies to retain up to 10,000 Bahamian jobs rather than temporarily lay them off amid the pandemic. He explained that the three-month initiative could provide qualifying firms with up to $600,000 split equally between a combination of tax credits and deferrals. Those companies with outstanding business licence fee payments and VAT receipts will be able to withhold payment and, in return, receive a maximum of $200,000 per month. Some $100,000, or 50 percent, will come in the form of a non-reimbursable tax credit. And the other $100,000 will be “deferred” until January 2021, when it will have to be repaid in a series of 12 monthly instalments throughout the year.
THE deputy prime minister yesterday said the government was “running as fast as we can” to support Bahamians and the private sector with more than $100m in COVID-19 financial aid. K Peter Turnquest urged the private sector to have patience with the newlyunveiled $60m tax credit/ deferral package to assist medium and large-sized Bahamian enterprises as the details are still being worked out ahead of its April 8 launch. He told Tribune Business that the Ministry of Finance would have to “work out a mechanism” for companies who have already paid their annual business licence fee to participate amid concerns that they would be
To qualify, companies must employ a minimum 25 persons and commit to retaining 80 percent of staff that were present prior to the COVID-19 crisis. “The net effect of this initiative is that, for some businesses, the government will be paying the salaries of half of their employees for the next three months and providing them with the cash flow to pay the remainder,” Mr Turnquest said. “The government is budgeting some $60m in revenue foregone over the next three months to facilitate this initiative, of which $30m will be effectively provided by the government to pay the full salaries of Bahamians over the period. “The ministry anticipates that some 200 medium and large-sized entities will take advantage of this initiative that will support the retention of some 10,000 jobs over the next three
SEE PAGE 5
Nygard asset transfer ‘alarming’ for lenders By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net PETER Nygard’s “alarming response” to the crisis engulfing his global fashion empire was to threaten to transfer its assets to a new company just one day after stepping down as its chairman. The flamboyant Lyford Cay resident’s plan to save his 52 year-old business from “the self-admitted worst financial crisis in its 52-year history”, and potentially leave creditors out to dry, is detailed in court documents filed by the Nygard Group’s stunned lenders who successfully petitioned the Canadian courts to place it into receivership. Robert Dean, White Oak Commercial Finance’s executive vice-president and head of risk management, alleged in a March 23, 2020, affidavit that Mr Nygard’s fashion retail and distribution conglomerate had been
• Lyford Cay resident planned new company • Just one day after resigning as chairman • Group fighting bankruptcy since 2019
PETER NYGARD teetering on the verge of “bankruptcy” since last year without lenders stepping in to provide funds. He accused Mr Nygard of being personally “obstructionist and uncooperative” as Richter Advisory, the financial consultants appointed by White Oak and Second Avenue Capital Partners, its fellow lender, attempted to uncover his empire’s true financial
position and address multiple alleged breaches of the $40m credit facility they had made available to Nygard Group. Revealing that Mr Nygard’s business, which he owns 100 percent, features more than 30 companies some of which are domiciled in The Bahamas, Mr Dean alleged that White Oak/Second Avenue appeared on the scene as a “replacement lender” when Bank of Montreal headed for the exit. “Prior to entering into the credit agreement with the lenders, the Nygard Group was financed by Bank of Montreal (BMO) pursuant to a $35m revolving facility,” he said. “By the summer of 2019, the Nygard Group was in default of the BMO
DPM: ‘Govt running as fast as we can’
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
$3.93
• COVID-19 assistance breaches $100m mark • $60m tax credit/deferral plan being finalised • Losses likely ‘more dire’ than $1bn forecast
K PETER TURNQUEST excluded from an initiative designed to provide payroll support to qualifying firms. With the “do nothing” alternative simply not an option given the extent of the economic hardship COVID-19 threatens to inflict on Bahamian workers
and businesses, Mr Turnquest said the government was doing its best to save jobs and companies within the limitations posed by its post-Hurricane Dorian fiscal constraints. “We’re trying to help here,” he told this newspaper. “The alternative is to do nothing. It’s absolutely a fluid situation, uncharted, and we have to do the best we can. There are things that have to be adjusted along the way, and as resources become available and not available. “We’re trying to give ourselves some time to work out the details [of the $60m tax credit/deferral plan]. We’re running as fast as
we can. This is a constantly evolving situation, and by the time we roll it out next week we will have most of the details worked out.” Mr Turnquest’s comments came as the private sector questioned how lockeddown businesses, unable to earn any revenue after the government enacted its emergency powers, will be able to benefit from the tax credit/deferral initiative he disclosed yesterday to the House of Assembly. The deputy prime minister, though, suggested that the $60m plan had been deliberately targeted at businesses with larger
SEE PAGE 5
facility, after having suffered material losses from its operations in its fiscal years 2018 and 2019. “It entered into a forbearance agreement as of September 6, 2019, which provided for an additional $7m demand loan that was advanced against certain owned real estate assets. The forbearance agreement provided for an expiry date of November 30, 2019, which could be extended to December 31, 2019. “Given the Nygard Group’s continued financial losses, BMO was not willing to negotiate a further extension of the BMO forbearance agreement. As a result, BMO informed the Nygard Group that it
SEE PAGE 5
$4.46 Bahamas must ‘keep economic patient alive’ By YOURI KEMP Tribune Business Reporter ykemp@tribunemedia.net THE Fiscal Responsibility Council’s chairman yesterday said the Government needs to “keep the patient alive” and prevent the COVID-19 crisis from collapsing the Bahamian economy. Kevin Burrows told Tribune Business he felt the government has sufficient capacity to relinquish $60m of income over the next three months to incentivise as many as 200 medium to large-size businesses to retain up to 80 percent of their staff via its tax credit and deferral initiative. “Yes, I do believe the government has the fiscal space to forego $60m over the next three months in order to retain some economic capacity to pay future taxes when the crisis abates. This is the same decision being made by governments globally,” he said. “The US just approved a $2tn dollar fiscal stimulus – that’s about ten percent of their GDP and 40 percent of their federal budget. Sixty million dollars for The Bahamas, well under one percent of GDP and 2.5 percent of our budget, pales in comparison, even taking into account our lower borrowing capacity. Mr Burrows affirmed: “We need to make sure the economic patient remains alive, then figure out how to adjust afterwards. Whether the pay back period beginning in January is realistic, well, we will see. “Assuming the global and local economy starts to re-open say by the end of June, then six months’ forbearance before beginning repayment seems reasonable. If the economy cannot support it then I’m sure the date will be extended – that’s the nature of managing under uncertainty. “I expect to see a global debt monetisation the likes of which was unimaginable just a month ago – the very nature of government debt will change. One silver lining is that we are not in this alone; the solution will need to be a global one.” John Rolle, the Central Bank governor, told Tribune Business yesterday: “I know that if it is one branch of government that would be focused on sustainability it would be the Ministry of Finance, because we work very closely with them on the fiscal projections and, particularly right now, in
SEE PAGE 3