business@tribunemedia.net
TUESDAY, MARCH 8, 2022
$5.37
$5.57
$5.37
$5.52
Fishermen’s fury over poaching ‘slap in face’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net FUMING fishermen yesterday slammed a Supreme Court verdict, which effectively imposed just a one-month sentence on four Dominicans, as “a slap in the face” for those battling illegal poaching. Paul Maillis, the National Fisheries Association’s (NFA) secretary, told Tribune Business the verdict was “unconscionable” and “disheartening” for both Bahamian fishermen and the authorities given that it means foreign poachers - who rammed a Royal Bahamas Defence Force (RBDF) vessel in their
• Dominicans effectively sentenced to one-month in prison • No fines despite ramming Defence Force in escape bid • ‘Disheartening’ verdict bad message to other offenders desperation to escape - will only have spent a total six months in prison. While affirming that he has “the utmost respect” for the judiciary and legal system, he argued that the sentences - which imposed no fines - “send a message to
poachers throughout the Caribbean and Latin America that The Bahamas does not take poaching seriously and you can get away with a very light sentence” if caught. Disclosing that he had been present as an observer in Justice
Bernard Turner’s court for the sentencing hearing, Mr Maillis said the outcome suggested that the tougher poaching fines/convictions brought into law by the Fisheries Act 2020 had been in vain. Arguing that public resources, namely the country’s fisheries resources upon which thousands and livelihoods depend, deserve the same protection as private property, he added that it seemed as if foreign criminals received lighter sentences than Bahamians who committed similar offences. And the NFA secretary said the most ironic aspect of the case was that it had been brought before the Supreme Court, as opposed
SEE PAGE FOUR
CLAY SWEETING
Tax cuts ‘off table’ as energy crisis solution Bahamas ‘struggling with By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Bahamas has no short-term solutions for combating soaring energy and gas prices, a major fuel supplier’s chairman warned yesterday, adding that tax cuts were likely “off the table”. Sir Franklyn Wilson, FOCOL Holdings chairman, told Tribune Business that there was little to nothing that The Bahamas can do to offset forces outside its control as global oil prices as measured by the Brent crude index at one point struck $139 per barrel yesterday. That mark, which was reached on fears that the US, Europe and the western world might impose an embargo on Russian oil and gas supplies over the latter’s invasion of Ukraine, was just shy of the all-time high of $147.50 per barrel achieved in July 2008. While prices scaled back after German and UK leaders dampened down concerns of a Russian
• Sir Franklyn: Claims of quick fix ‘defy me’ • But government gasoline taxes ‘wild card’ • ‘No fiscal headroom’ to ease coming pain cut-off, Bank of America analysts were reported as projecting that global oil prices could strike as much as $200 per barrel - record, uncharted territory - if Vladimir Putin’s major industry and economic earners was to be sanctioned. While Bahamian businesses and households, already struggling to revive from COVID-19’s economic
IDB chief hails BPL fuel hedging impact By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Inter-American Development Bank’s (IDB) president yesterday hailed the impact of Bahamas Power & Light’s (BPL) fuel hedging strategy despite doubts on whether it remains in place. Mauricio Claver-Carone, in a roundtable discussion with Caribbean media, did not directly answer a Tribune Business question as to whether the hedging initiative it developed with the former Minnis administration remains in place. But, with oil yesterday briefly hitting $139 per barrel, he said the savings it generated were “starting to look even more attractive”. “What we did in The Bahamas, for the first time, is an energy hedging instrument. The hedge is done by these instruments. We’ve learned a lot from it,” Mr ClaverCarone said. “I won’t speak to whether any country has maximised it, but the impact for The Bahamas is that it has been able to mitigate the impact of [rising] energy prices thanks to that. “As we sit here, and looking at today’s $130-$131 oil, some of that hedging starts to look even more attractive and was perhaps [future-telling] in that regard. It shows we need to get better at and innovate in that way. It’s definitely had an impact, definitely helped to mitigate these prices.” It remains unclear, though, whether BPL’s fuel hedging strategy remains in place following the events of last week when the state-owned electricity monopoly was forced to retract an announcement of
SEE PAGE SEVEN
the execution’ in corruption fight By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
SIR FRANKLYN WILSON devastation, are bracing for the worst, not all will be negatively impacted by soaring gasoline and energy prices. The Public Treasury, in particular, could see a revenue windfall given that the gasoline industry’s tax structure is based on a percentage rather than fixed mark-ups. While wholesale suppliers such as FOCOL (which operates as Shell) and gas station operators have their price-controlled margins fixed at
SEE PAGE EIGHT
IMF calls for ‘tax spending budget’ By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE International Monetary Fund (IMF) has urged The Bahamas to develop an annual “tax expenditure budget” to better identify revenue leakages and assess the economic impact of its spending. The Washington DC-based Fund’s recommendation was disclosed in the Fiscal Responsibility Council’s (FRC) assessment of the 2021-2022 Budget and the Davis administration’s supplemental version, which noted that it can help improve the fairness and efficiency of a country’s tax system. “The IMF has made recommendations for the development and tabling of an annual tax expenditure budget, along with the estimates of revenue and expenditure, with the objective of enhancing the budgetary process by facilitating a more comprehensive assessment of the Government’s spending within the economy, both direct and indirect, and the resulting impacts of policy priorities and outcomes,” the Council said.
“Tax expenditure budgets aid in exposing possible avenues of revenue leakage, and can spur improvements in the equity and efficiency of a tax system.” The Council’s disclosure of the “tax expenditure budget” proposal came just before its report said The Bahamas’ consumptionbased tax system made it difficult for the Government to target fiscal policy where it is needed. The report was also released just days before the Prime Minister is due to present the mid-year Budget to the House of Assembly tomorrow. The Council, in its analysis, said successive administrations had reduced capital spending to limit the size of the fiscal deficit, and questioned whether the lower outlays are sufficient to support infrastructure build-out and economic growth. “The 2021-2022 Budget and medium-term projections demonstrate a reduction in capital expenditure to 2 percent of GDP in fiscal year 2022-2023 and fiscal year 2023-2024. The reductions are necessary to achieve the improved fiscal balances
SEE PAGE SEVEN
THE Bahamas is “struggling with the execution” of anti-corruption safeguards, governance reformers are warning, with accountability and transparency “aspirational” rather than real concepts. Matt Aubry, the Organisation for Responsible Governance’s (ORG) principal, told Tribune Business in a recent interview that The Bahamas lacks an “integrated anti-corruption” strategy that pulls all such legislative and regulatory reforms together in a co-ordinated package capable of combating graft. Chester Cooper, deputy prime minister and minister of tourism, investments and aviation, and some of his Cabinet colleagues have foreshadowed changes to the Public Disclosure Act but this law - which focuses on declarations of wealth, income and assets by ministers, MPs and top civil servants - is viewed by Mr
MATT AUBRY Aubry as not wide enough to capture the low level, every day corruption that most Bahamians have to deal with. Speaking after the US government, in its recent International Narcotics Control Strategy Report, urged The Bahamas to move forward with longplanned governance reforms, the ORG executive said: “Accountability and transparency continue to be aspirational terms. They have to be actual
SEE PAGE EIGHT