business@tribunemedia.net
THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 11, 2021
$4.37
$4.37
$4.15
$4.01
opponents: BPC’s Super Value cuts Sunday Oil$200,000 demand will hours on 25% sales drop knock out legal action
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
S
UPER Value has slashed Sunday shopping hours after sales “dropped off 25 percent”, its principal revealed yesterday, adding: “They aren’t coming to show off their church hats any more.” Rupert Roberts told Tribune Business that the chain, and its Quality Supermarket affiliate, have adjusted store hours in response to “drastic changes in consumer shopping habits” due to COVID-19 and associated restrictions. Disclosing that Sunday, which was the last day to enjoy an easing of
• Roberts: ‘Drastic change in shopping habits’ • Former top day off 50% if no ‘double stamps’ • Estimates ‘one-third of people having it tough’
RUPERT ROBERTS pandemic-related measures, had previously been Super Value’s busiest sales day prior to the global health crisis, Mr Roberts said he believed business
would be down 50 percent were it not for the company’s “double stamps” promotion. Disclosing that payroll would exceed sales revenue if Super Value/Quality’s 13 stores retained their preCOVID-19 Sunday hours, he added that early closures have been staggered according to consumer demand for the past three to four weeks. While “inner-city” stores are closing at between 1-2pm on Sundays, Super Value’s Winton store in
eastern New Providence is now shutting at 3pm and Golden Gates at 5pm, although Cable Beach is remaining open to 8pm. Super Value and Quality’s outlets typically closed preCOVID at times such as 3pm and 7pm. But, striking a more optimistic note, Mr Roberts yesterday said predictions that sales would have fallen off by 20-25 percent at this stage of the pandemic have yet to materialise. While
SEE PAGE 9
‘Reinvent’ agriculture for $190m import cut By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE Bahamas can slash $190m off its food import bill only if it completely “reinvents” the business model for its shrinking agriculture sector, the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) has disclosed. The multilateral lender, in a series of reports tabled in Parliament yesterday, exposed just how far The Bahamas is from realising ambitions to boost domestic production and food security by revealing that a 15 percent annual growth rate is required to recover agricultural production capacity lost to Hurricane Dorian in September 2019. The category five storm’s impact worsened a decline in annual sector output that fell below $30m in 2018, with the
• Overhaul’s long road as sector output under $30m • Three-year 15% growth needed to recoup Dorian hit • Over 70% of current farmer crop over 60 years-old IDB report’s author, Carlos Puig Esteve, revealing that real value added by the industry fell by more than 183 percent between 1995 and 2017. “In order to expose the challenge for the country, and considering that the agricultural sector has lost at least one-third of its agricultural production capacity as a result of Hurricane Dorian, the reconstruction effort would need to reach 15 percent annual growth over the next three years to return to its 2018 production level,” the IDB report, which was completed in December 2019, said.
Govt to plug genetic exploitation loophole By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net THE government yesterday moved to finally plug a loophole that has enabled foreign exploitation of The Bahamas’ biological and genetic resources without this nation earning a cent. The Biological Resources and Traditional Knowledge Bill, tabled in the House of Assembly by Romauld Ferreira, pictured, minister of the environment and housing, seeks to establish a regulatory, permitting and revenue-sharing regime
with companies seeking to research and exploit this nation’s marine genetic resources. The legislation thus aims to close a gap identified in an Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) report,
SEE PAGE 8
‘Sea change’ for national finances
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
THE Ministry of Finance’s top official last night said reforms tabled in the House of Assembly yesterday represent “a sea change” in the way the government manages the public finances. Marlon Johnson, the acting financial secretary, told Tribune Business that the Public Debt Management Bill and Public Finance Management Bill
SEN KWASI THOMPSON will require the government to “measure our performance and output” on the fiscal front through strengthened reporting as
SEE PAGE 7
“Maintaining this growth rate of 15 percent over the next five years (through to 2027) would double the country’s agricultural output in eight years. Such an objective would be ambitious but achievable, and possibly be surpassed if the appropriate incentives to facilitate investments in improved technologies, greenhouses and polytunnels were facilitated in the short-term while focusing on young people.’ The study repeatedly focused on The Bahamas’ aged population of existing farmers, some 70 percent of whom were said to be aged 60-plus, and with an absence of successors and/or younger
enthusiasts to take over their business. “The decline in the number of farmers has been significant, from 4,246 in 1978 to 800-1,000 maximum in 2019, of which 70 percent are older than 60 years, which represents an immense challenge since the sector does not attract young farmers,” the IDB report said. The governmentappointed Economic Recovery Committee (ERC) also referred to similar growth targets in its summary report, and there are indications that the
SEE PAGE 8
By NEIL HARTNELL Tribune Business Editor nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
OIL exploration opponents yesterday admitted they will have to halt their challenge to Bahamas Petroleum Company’s (BPC) drilling approvals if it succeeds with its $200,000 “security for costs” demand. Joe Darville, executive chairman of Save the Bays, and secretary of Waterkeepers Bahamas, the two environmental groups behind the Judicial Review, conceded that they lack “sufficient liquid assets” to pay this sum should the Supreme Court grant BPC’s request. “The applicants have succeeded in fundraising to begin this action, and are actively seeking further funding to allow them to continue the action to trial,” Mr Darville, referring to Save the Bays and Waterkeepers Bahamas, said. “Notwithstanding that Save the Bays has substantial assets in the form of the costs certificates detailed, neither Waterkeepers Bahamas nor Save the Bays have sufficient liquid assets currently nor are they likely to be able to raise the same before the upcoming trial) to set $200,000 aside by way of security for costs. “I can confirm that if the security for costs application succeeds, this action will certainly have to be stayed because Waterkeepers Bahamas and Save the Bays will be unable to raise sufficient sums by that date to both fund its continuation of the action and provide a significant sum in security for costs.” So-called “security for costs”, which require that a party to a Supreme Court case lodge a performance bond in escrow to
JOE DARVILLE cover the other side’s legal fees, has been increasingly employed as a procedural tactic or weapon in a bid to effectively price-out public interest litigants from the justice system before the merits of their action are heard. Given that BPC earlier this week abandoned and plugged its Perseverance One exploratory well, and announced no commercial oil quantities had been found, there was some doubt over whether the oil explorer would persist with its “security for costs” demand and opposition to the Judicial Review action as it has already completed what it set out to achieve. The filing of Mr Darville’s affidavit yesterday suggests it is persisting, with the environmental activists especially keen for the Judicial Review’s merits to be heard so that the court can provide clear guidance on which permits and approvals future oil wells must obtain, and the processes they must follow. Among the most critical issues to be determined are whether oil wells need to obtain site plan approval under the Planning and Subdivisions Act, and an excavation permit under the Conservation and Protection of the Physical
SEE PAGE 6