the LION’S
R AR
Non-Profit Organization U.S. Postage PAID Boston, MA Permit No. 54523
Volume 30, Issue 5 140 Brandeis Road Newton Centre, MA 02459
Newton South High School’s Student Newspaper · Newton, MA · Established 1984 · January 22, 2014
APT attacks Newton history curriculum for anti-Semitism, Saudi-funded propaganda Nathaniel Bolter & Sasha Kuznetsov Sr. News Editors
The dispute over allegations of antiSemitism in the Newton Public Schools’ (NPS) history curriculum has escalated recently in light of continued protests and actions by the organization Americans for Peace and Tolerance (APT). Americans for Peace and Tolerance, founded by Charles Jacobs, a political activist and co-founder of the educational Zionist organization The David Project, has led the effort against NPS in recent months, issuing statements and advertisements accusing the Newton history curricula of anti-Semitism. On Friday, Dec. 13, APT received syllabi from 9th and 10th grade Newton history teachers, which they had requested under the Freedom of Information Act. Jacobs said APT had run the advertisements, which urged readers to contact Mayor Setti Warren and School Committee vice-Chair Matt Hills using their provided phone numbers and emails, in the fall of 2013 to educate the community. Several instances of misinformation, however, were found in these ads. The alleged anti-Semitism first came up in 2011 when a South freshman, who requested not to be named, complained to her father that she had been assigned an article falsely claiming that Israeli soldiers killed Arab women. “I did not know if that was true or not because I did not ever hear about that, but I just wanted to make sure, so I asked my dad ‘Do our soldiers actually kill and torture Arab women?’ My dad said ‘No, of course that’s not true; where did you hear that?’” the student said. “He got really upset because he did not want me thinking — because I almost did think — that that’s what happened.” The student’s father met with history teacher Jessica Engel, history department head Jennifer Morrill and Principal Joel Stembridge to request that the passage that had concerned his daughter be removed. The passage, part of an essay in a binder of resources called The Arab World Studies Notebook (AWSN), was subsequently removed from the curriculum, but not as a result of the parent’s complaint, according to Morrill. “In the early 90s, we were moving to a point in education where we were trying to not just teach about Europe. We were try-
Left to right: Dennis Hale, Charles Jacobs and Ahmed Mansour, directors of Americans for Peace and Tolerance, the group challenging the history curriculum.
Public Domain
In December, APT received syllabi, which it requested under the Freedom of Information Act, from 9th and 10th grade history teachers.
ing to have a more multicultural education, and teachers were looking for good sources. The Arab World Studies Notebook came into Newton Public Schools when we were looking for more sources to teach parts of the world that we hadn’t taught well before. [Now] there’s so much good stuff out there, [so] we didn’t need it anymore,” Morrill said. “It was outdated; there were parts of it that were biased … as a resource it was no longer needed.” This incident captured the interest of APT, which took out advertisements in the Boston Herald, Newton Tab, Metro Boston, Jewish Advocate and Boston Globe in the fall of 2013 identifying several texts, handouts and maps in the Newton curriculum, claiming that they perpetuate anti-Semitism. Hills, however, says these claims are invalid. “Every single allegation and accusation … they have brought up in their periodic attacks over time have been a complete distortion of what the material actually reads. Words are inserted, words are left out, words are fabricated altogether or the context is not given in a way that completely distorts the meaning,” Hills said. “This is not an example of very controversial material being taught and we are defending our right to teach it, this is an example of a group with an agenda … looking to score very cheap points on
very, very distorted pieces of information.” Two Newton temples have also rebuffed APT’s claims, and three Jewish advocacy groups, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), Combined Jewish Philanthropies (CJP) and the Jewish Community Relations Council (JCRC), released a joint statement decrying the efforts of APT. “Based on a careful review of the materials at issue by ADL and JCRC, there is substantial reason to believe that the allegations made in the ad are without merit. The ad misinterprets certain elements of the materials and lacks reasonable context,” the statement read.
Several claims in APT’s advertisement contain quotations that are taken out of context, altering their meaning. The ad cites a handout entitled “A World Where Womanhood Reigns Supreme” and accuses it of teaching lies in saying “Miniskirts and plunging necklines represent oppression.” The ad omits the first half of the sentence, which reveals that this is not what the author is asserting — rather, it is the opinion of several Muslim women whom the author is depicting. The author is informing, not proselytizing. ANTI-SEMITISM, 3
Library renovation in planning
page
4
INSIDE THIS ISSUE:
Global Update The Roar’s briefing on everything from the Sochi Olympics to Ukraine.
page
5
SNAP Challenge Freshman Jake Meisel writes about eating on $45 a week.
page
10
1 in 1,800
Junior Naomi Bergelson is this month’s 1 in 1,800 student.
page
19
NEWS 2 GLOBAL 5 EDITORIALS 6 OPINIONS 9 CENTERFOLD 12 FEATURES 15 SPORTS 20