Issue 7

Page 1

Record The Horace Mann

OCTOBER 25TH, 2019 || VOLUME 117, ISSUE 7

RECORD.HORACEMANN.ORG

HORACE MANN’S WEEKLY NEWSPAPER SINCE 1903

The Mann, the myth, the legend

The Record explores the history of the men whose names we use daily: Horace Mann, Tillinghast, Pforzheimer, and Prettyman Abby Beckler and Henry Owens Staff Writers “Horace Mann is undeniably the greatest name in the history of American education,” Head of School Dr. Tom Kelly wrote. For the school to be named after a great educator may seem fitting - in many ways, Mann’s values as an educator align with the school. But as a promoter of public education, Mann may have not supported a private institution such as ours. As an educator, lawyer, and politician, Mann established Massachusetts’ public school system in the middle of the 19th century that served as a model of public education for many other states. Mann strongly believed in the availability of free education as well as the quality of faculty in the public school system. His vision of what an education should entail is in many ways aligned with the school’s current goal, which is “to prepare a diverse community of students to lead great and giving lives,” according to the school’s mission statement. Although the school is named after him, Mann was never involved with the school directly, as it was founded nearly three decades after his death. The school was originally named The Model School in the early 1890’s, but school administrators decided to change the name because it seemed vague as to what the school was in fact modelling, according to “The First Hundred Years” by English teacher Harry Bauld and co-author Jerome Kissinger. Nicolas Murray Butler, president of Columbia University for 43 years, founded The Model School as a coeducational experimental and developmental unit of Teachers College, Columbia University, according to the school’s website. When the school was first created, many assumed “that Horace Mann was the name of its principal and director,” as Butler receiving many letters addressed to “Mr. Mann.” Even though Mann was not directly involved in the school, he is still an important historical figure. The Middle Division (MD) curriculum includes a brief unit on Mann at the very beginning of seventh grade, where students use primary sources to form an argument as to whether Mann would have approved of the school. “Students often have very strong arguments why he wouldn’t necessarily approve of his name being used for the school,” MD History Department Chair John McNally said. “Horace Mann is, first of all, an amazing visionary, but it’s pretty clear that he’s very much against private schools as a way to draw away from the resources of public schools and also draw away the talent from public schools.” For his side of the discussion, Logan Scharlatt (7) wrote that Mann would not approve of the school today. In his paper, Scharlatt mentioned that while the school’s core values support Mann’s ideas, the limited size of the student body and the high financial burden of tuition are reasons as to why Mann would not like the school, he said. The Upper Division (UD), unlike the MD, does not work Mann into the official curriculum. Some classes, however, do cover some of the Mann’s contributions to education. In UD History Teacher Dr. Ellen Bales’ 10th grade US History class, students read and discuss case studies in order to delve further into certain topics, including the rise of public education in the United States, where they discuss Mann’s influence. For Eliza Bender (12), these case studies allowed for her to gain a more in depth understanding of Mann and public education in this country, she said. Because of Mann’s importance to the school, the class was able to learn about Mann’s accomplishments that are often overlooked in textbooks, Bender said. Many students believe that Horace Mann should be discussed in history classes throughout high school, not just because he is the school’s namesake, but because of his profound impact on the American education system.

see Historical profiles on pg. 4

Alum talks with students about carbon dividend plan Henry Owens Staff Writer

Alexander Posner ’13 talked to students on Monday about carbon dividends, a proposed idea for the fight against climate change. Posner is the President of Students for Carbon Dividends (S4CD), a national coalition dedicated to promoting the ultimate passage of federal carbon dividend legislation. He delivered his presentation twice, first to an ethics class and later to a small group of students interested in the movement. He was invited by Roey Nornberg (12) and Belle Beyer (12), who have been working with S4CD for several months to establish a chapter of the organization at the school. To start his presentation, Posner explained some of the nuances of climate change. He said that warming is inevitable, and the only question is how

extreme it will be. Although the worst case scenario may be only several degrees of warming, that scenario is analogous to a bed ridden person having a fever several degrees above normal, Posner said. “I’m going to remember that forever because it just it stuck with me so much,” Tiger Moreno (12), a member of the ethics class to which Posner presented, said. “He was making us think of the Earth as another human being. I think it was a really great image to paint.” “I thought it was really interesting the way that he framed this situation and the urgency of it,” Paul Wang (12) said. “The way he used analogies when speaking was both hilarious and effective.” “We will do three things in response to climate as a species,” Posner said. “We will adapt to some of it, we will prevent some of it, and we will suffer.

All three are going to happen. The mix is up to us.” After painting a clear picture of just how extreme the climate problem is, Posner introduced the idea of carbon dividends. The carbon dividends plan has two parts: first, a tax on carbon that will gradually increase over time, and second, a rebate that gives the money from the tax directly back to the American people. Because this proposal would put a price on carbon, slow the greenhouse effect, not increase the size of government, and result in a net profit for a majority of Americans, it is the most widely supported piece of climate policy, Posner said. Carbon dividends have been endorsed through a statement backed by the largest number of economists in American history, according to the S4CD website. “I was completely sold on how he presented this whole carbon tax idea,”

Moreno said. “What was very convincing for me was when he was talking about how bipartisan it is.” One main goal of S4CD is to ensure the political viability of the carbon dividends plan. “You can have most wondrous plans on paper,” Posner said. “If you don’t have political viability, you are accomplishing nothing.” One primary achievement of the group has been establishing a coalition in support of the plan that consists of over 100 college groups, both liberal and conservative. All of the support from economists and colleges will be used to lobby in favor of the policy when Congress votes on the issue in 2021. “I think it’s very inspiring, all the work that [Posner]’s doing and his passion towards making the world better,” Wang said. Beyer and Nornberg have been talking to Posner since April about expanding S4CD to include high school

students. “We are trying to launch a national movement of high schoolers in support of this plan,” Nornberg said. “The first thing we want to do is to get different student leaders across New York City, and then maybe New York State, and get as many student leaders to sign up to support this plan as we can.” A statement with the support of high schoolers from across the country could help push the legislation in 2021, Beyer said. “Carbon dividends is a bipartisan plan,” she said. “So it doesn’t matter whether you’re Republican or Democrat or how extreme your views are; it’s something that we can all unite behind.” “Horace Mann students are movers and shakers, and solving climate change is no exception,” Posner said. “It’s exciting to see HM students leading on this important effort.”


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.