A night at the Palace Cafe Open all night on the weekend, the Palace Cafe sees a variety of patrons looking for pancakes, coffee, and conversations. B3
Michigan’s oldest college newspaper
A new take on ‘Citizen Kane’ Orson Welles’ movie about a tortured businessman’s famous last words were featured in this week’s Center for Constructive Alternatives seminar. B1
Vol. 140 Issue 21 - 9 March 2017
www.hillsdalecollegian.com
Change in research stipends
Murphy wins Everett oratory competition
Grace DeSandro | Collegian
College reduces research stipends to save money By | Kristiana Mork Collegian Reporter Hillsdale College’s science departments reduced stipends for six-week summer research this year by $400-$1,000 for faculty and students. Stipends dropped from $2,500 per researcher to $2,100 for each faculty member; $1,800 for every participant in the Laboratory for Advanced Undergraduate Research Education Adapted for Talented and Extraordinary Students, or LAUREATES, Program; and $1,000 for other students. The decrease comes as a result of the departments not receiving funds from the college’s general budget, said Christopher VanOrman, dean of the nat-
ural sciences and professor of chemistry. The stipends come from interest on the college’s endowment, which totals $87,000, VanOrman said. For the past few years, however, the sciences have received up to $63,000 from the general budget to use toward stipends, he said. This year, that expense was cut from the budget to save money, VanOrman said. “Everyone always wants more money, but we’ll make the cuts work,” said Lee Baron, natural sciences chairwoman and professor of chemistry, “We are very thankful for the funding we have.” VanOrman credited President Larry Arnn and John Cer-
Sophomore Andres Torres and freshman Jordan Monnin synthesize derivatives for unknown identification. Madeline Barry | Collegian
vini, vice president for institutional advancement, for raising most of the money for scientific research. “They’ve raised enough money that the interest from the endowment every year is $87,000,” VanOrman said. “That’s well over a million raised, and we’re just working with the interest from that.” But some students said the smaller stipend may put a financial strain on those who need to make money during the summer. “Research is basically your job,” senior biochemistry major Gabriela Wong said. “It’s hard to spend six weeks researching and then go home to try to find a job for another six weeks before school starts.” Plus, the rural Hillsdale community lacks many supplementary jobs students can do while at the college for their research, she said. Before the LAUREATES Program, however, students would camp on their friends’ couches to do summer research at Hillsdale, Baron said. Now, students are fortunate to receive any stipend, she said. Senior biochemistry major Emily Nelsen performed her research at Aurora St. Luke’s Medical Center in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. She said the decrease in stipend could get
Citgo gas station closes Broad Street Downtown Market and Tavern’s previous owner recently closed the doors to another business, resulting in 14 employees losing their jobs. A6
Hillsdale students to look for ways to fulfill their research requirement off campus. “Sometimes students get too complacent,” Nelson said. “It’s easy to say, ‘Oh, I’ve had this professor, I’ll just stay here and do my research with them, too.’ Hopefully, the funding cuts will encourage students to look for opportunities outside of Hillsdale.” Whether studying chemistry, biology, biochemistry, physics, or psychology, every Hillsdale College science major must complete a summer research project to graduate. “Research is a big part of your science education,” VanOrman said. “Wherever you are looking, you should go to a program that is going to have you do some research projects.” Hillsdale’s LAUREATES Program gives 20 students based on their class and GPA each year the opportunity to do a six-week, one-on-one research project with a Hillsdale faculty member and a stipend. Students typically present their research proposals in the fall of their junior year, conduct research during the following summer, and present their results during the fall of their senior year. The research Hillsdale students do helps them get into
By | Emily Blatter Collegian Reporter Sophomore Ryan Kelly Murphy won the 2017 Edward Everett Prize in Oratory and $3,000 for her speech about judicial review Tuesday. Freshman Michelle Reid won second place and $2,000, and freshman Joel Meng took third, winning $1,000. “The most important thing in discerning a winner is who argued most convincingly and had the most evidence, because it’s the historical content, it’s the evidence, that wins us over in the end,” said Don Tocco, a friend of Hillsdale College and an Everett oratory competition judge. “But even with the evidence, you have to have the personal conviction, the enthusiasm, the passion, the energy on the stage to drive that into the audience.” Murphy, Reid, and Meng were among five finalists selected to compete in Tuesday’s last round of competition, along with sophomore Joshua Hoover and junior Kyle Huitt. Roughly 70 people attended to hear the contestants discuss the topic “Is the Supreme Court the final arbiter of the Constitution?” “I want to present what I have to say to the best of my ability with the most articulation, while being persuasive,” Murphy said. “It’s just a whirlwind when you’re up there. You kind of zone everything out, even the audience, and you’re just focused on getting your message out in a powerful way.” Murphy argued that constitutional interpretation is the role of the people and the states rather than the Supreme Court. “The Supreme Court is not the ultimate arbiter of the Constitution,” Murphy said in her speech. “The idea of it as ultimate arbiter actually conflicts with the idea of our government as a democratic republic.” Reid argued that the Supreme Court is the Constitution’s just and rightful arbiter, citing Alexis de Tocqueville and others. She said the Supreme Court defends the rights of the citizens, protecting them from laws that violate their rights. “I didn’t really have expectations going in,” Reid said about participating in the competition. “It went by so fast. It was a lot less intimidating doing it than I thought it would be.”
Sophomore Ryan Kelly Murphy won the 2017 Edward Everett Prize in Oratory Tuesday, for her speech on judicial review. Matthew Kendrick | Collegian
Meng also argued that the Supreme Court is the most effective way to arbitrate the Constitution, citing research showing that most Supreme Court rulings are unanimous and that disapproval of the court fluctuates widely in both parties. “For all its flaws, the Supreme Court remains the best way to arbitrate the Constitution,” Meng said. “If you want to know what Americans think of the Supreme Court, it depends when, not who, you ask…People aren’t really paying attention to the quality of legal rulings. They care about whether the court went their way.” Meng said he was well aware of the audience during his presentation. He said he had special concern about one judge’s opinion — President Larry
See Everett A3
See Research A2
Enactus’ ChargerX ride-sharing app drives forward in development By | Jo Kroeker Opinions Editor After running into some roadblocks in app development, Enactus members said they plan to launch their ride-sharing service app, now named ChargerX, in midApril. Senior Tucker Phillips, co-president of the entrepreneurship club, said finding an app developer fluent in English and charging reasonable prices delayed the group’s plans. American app developers were too expensive, and overseas developers didn’t always speak English fluently enough, Phillips said. Eventually, the group found an overseas developer meeting all the requirements and able to code the app within 40 days. Despite the obstacles with app development, the club has
developed a price model and is moving forward with the app’s design. The cost to travel within Hillsdale will be $3.50 for the first rider and that price per person will decrease with every additional passenger. With four passengers, each person would pay less than $2, Phillips said. He, however, discouraged having only one rider, especially for longer trips like to the Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Airport in Romulus, Michigan. Under Enactus’ price model, a rider in a full car would pay around $17 to go to the airport — which is cheaper than the college shuttle, which charges $60. Phillips said the goal is that the Hillsdale Ride Board will be unnecessary once Enactus launches the app. Drivers will be able to register within minutes using the
app by providing their name, social security number, and photos of their proof of insurance. Drivers can connect the app to Venmo and CashApp accounts or set up direct deposit, and riders can schedule future rides and send messages. Enactus has also had to address faculty concerns regarding insurance. Starting March 21, people who drive for ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft in Michigan have to pay a monthly premium on their car, after the state passed comprehensive legislation on insurance regulations for limousines, taxis, and ride-sharing services in December. Phillips said insurance will be the drivers’ responsibility, recommending the optional personal injury protection, which protects the driver, in addition to the required personal property protection,
which protects the rider. The group has also commissioned junior Zane Miller to design the app icon. He is using blue and orange, the app’s theme colors, and the “X” in the app’s name, which is short for “Express.” Miller, who has experience in graphic design, said he was excited to expand his professional portfolio while on campus. Phillips said Enactus has an aesthetic shell — just the interface — designed for presentation for the upcoming March 27 competition against other Enactus clubs. Phillips and his clubmates are handling the app and the legal questions of the project with the help of faculty and advisers, he said. “It might sound like we’re stagnant,” Phillips said, “but we’re clipping along.”
ChargerX Follow @HDaleCollegian
www.hillsdalecollegian.com
Ultimate Lawn Care and Tree Service workers finish the job that nature started Wednesday, after wind gusts up to 60 mph took down the top of a tree in front of the Chi Omega sorority house. Breana Noble | Collegian Look for The Hillsdale Collegian