‘It’s the people’ City council, BPU, and local residents discuss placing the former town motto on the water tower. A6
Michigan’s oldest college newspaper
Pig-human chimera Scientists can harvest organs from pig-human chimeras created by stem cells. But are we playing God with bioethics? A4
Vol. 140 Issue 16 - 2 February 2017
Wilder turns 150 “Little House on the Prairie” enthusiasts will celebrate their favorite author on Tuesday at 7 p.m. in the Heritage Room. B1
www.hillsdalecollegian.com
Students find revived hope in the pro-life cause at March for Life
Chairs are put up on the bar at Broad Street Downtown Market, following the business’ closure Monday. Thomas Novelly | Collegian
Back taxes buckle Broad Street Numerous restaurants looking to replace former market and tavern By | Thomas Novelly Editor-in-Chief Unable to overcome more than $18,000 in back taxes and consistently high operating costs, Broad Street Downtown Market and Tavern officially closed its doors Sunday, despite numerous attempts to rebrand itself in the past four years. “We were served with a foreclosure notice. It was posted on the door when I arrived for work on Monday morning,”
Juniors Michael Howard and Nainoa Johsens, sophomore Roberta Briggs, junior Peter Flynn, and sophomore Kathleen Russo parade on Constitution Avenue for the March for Life. Josephine von Dohlen | Collegian
By | Josephine von Dohlen Collegian Reporter From the Washington Monument down the National Mall, hundreds of thousands of people peacefully marched bearing signs expressing prolife sentiments in Washington, D.C., Jan. 27. Approximately 85 Hillsdale College students and graduates participated in the 44th annual March for Life, protesting the 1973 Roe v. Wade Supreme Court decision that legalized abortion in the United States. Crowds chanted “Pro-life,” as Seminarians and priests praid the rosary. Church groups sang hymns, while students carried signs as they marched down Constitution Avenue in the 42-degree, windy weather. Professor of German Fred Yaniga, Hillsdale Students for Life’s faculty adviser, has attended six trips to D.C. for the march. But this march was different, he said. “The element of hope has always been there, but the reality today was that we will likely be able to change things,” Yaniga said. “That is the biggest difference from all marches.” Sophomore Kathleen Russo, Hillsdale Students for Life events coordinator, walked alongside her fellow peers bearing the Hillsdale College Students for Life Banner. Several marchers recognized Hillsdale’s name throughout the duration of the march, giving thumbs-up and shouting, “Go, Hillsdale!” “I felt a little bit of awe,” Russo said. “You can’t see how many people are marching with you, because of the crowds and all the people that have been streaming past you.” A rally prior to the march sponsored by the March for Life organization featured several pro-life speakers. Most notably, Vice President Mike Pence addressed those attending the rally with the message that “life is winning again in America.” “It is no more evident in any way than in the historic election of a president who stands for a stronger America, a more prosperous America, and a president who I proudly say stands for the right to Follow @HDaleCollegian
life, President Donald Trump,” Pence said. The march comes days after Trump signed an executive order reinstating the Mexico City Policy, which prevents foreign aid funding organizations providing abortions worldwide, on Jan. 23. Following the president’s lead, the House of Representatives passed a permanent extension of the Hyde Amendment, prohibiting taxpayer funded abortions the next day. “This administration will work with Congress to end taxpayer funding of abortion and abortion providers,” Pence said. “And we will devote those resources to health care services for women across America.” This year’s march set a record of attendance, according to the March for Life’s Facebook page. Junior Nainoa Johsens is spending the semester in Washington, D.C., through the Washington-Hillsdale Internship Program. He is interning with the Susan B. Anthony List, a pro-life organization dedicated to the election of pro-life legislators, and has spent the past few weeks in preparation for the march for Life by attending events with pro-life legislators who traveled to the capital for the event. “There’s a lot more excitement about this year’s march, because of the new direction for the country,” Johsens said. “We expected the largest participation thus far.” Because of the snow that began to sweep over the city of Hillsdale just hours before the scheduled departure of the group to D.C., the two busloads of students arrived at the Allan P. Kirby Jr. Center for Constitutional Studies and Citizenship later than expected, so students did not attend church services prior to the rally and march. Nonetheless, students proudly marched, holding signs with the words, “We are the Pro-Life Generation” and “#LifeCounts.” “So many kids want to come and do this, and they don’t get much out of it for themselves,” Russo said. “At the end of the day, this is a demonstration of what Hillsdale teaches us.”
a Jan. 27 statement on Broad Street’s Facebook page said. “This was for back taxes. That bill has been taken care of.” At the time of publication, according to the city and county clerk’s offices, Broad Street has yet to pay three years of back taxes. On Tuesday, the county clerk’s records showed that for 2014 and 2015, the downtown market and tavern owed nearly $10,800. The city of Hillsdale, which handles the most recent year’s taxes,
showed the establishment owes more than $8,000 for 2016. In a staff meeting on Sunday, owners and management at Broad Street informed employees that they were all being let go immediately. Former Broad Street general manager Cindy Paterson-McCoy said the news was devastating. “I have been there six years and I have worked 70-plus hours a week,” Paterson-McCoy said. “I love Broad Street
Tavern & Underground. I am let down and very heartbroken.” According to the Hillsdale County Clerk’s office, no lawsuits have been filed by employees or owners in the wake of the restaurant’s sudden closure. Jason Walters, manager of the the Hillsdale Municipal Airport and the owner of JWA consulting group, said the Broad Street owners called his
See Broad Street A6
Trump nominates Gorsuch to SCOTUS
Professors, students hopeful for nominee to replace Scalia
By | Jessie Fox Sports Editor When President Trump nominated Judge Neil M. Gorsuch on Tuesday to fill the Supreme Court seat left vacant by the death of Justice Antonin Scalia, Hillsdale College students and faculty expressed cautious approval for the jurist whose originalist philosophy and conservative tilt liken him to Scalia himself. Most recently a federal appeals court judge in Denver, Gorsuch previously clerked for Associate Justice Anthony Kennedy and former Associate Justice Byron White. Leaders from all corners of the Republican Party have come out in favor of Trump’s nominee, including Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul and Texas Sen. Ted Cruz. If confirmed, Trump’s nominee would restore the 5-to-4 split between conservatives and liberals on the court. Assistant Professor of Politics Adam Carrington said Gorsuch seems not only a “first-rate mind” and “first-rate writer” but also a nominee who could appease voters who chose Trump solely on his promise to nominate a Scalia-like justice. “The early indications of his record show that Gorsuch would be a textualist,” Carrington said. “He would be someone dedicated to a form of originalism that a lot of peo-
ple that were wanting a Scalia prototype would want. It seems like they’ll be very happy with that.” Senior Bridget DeLapp, former intern for Michigan Supreme Court Justices David Viviano and Joan Larsen, said she was immediately impressed with Gorsuch’s record and roster of supporters. “It gives you confidence that a lot of these strong conservative leaders are so adamantly in favor of him, and looking at his record, he seems to be a strict constitutionalist, which is what we want,” DeLapp said. “You never want partisan judges. You want judges who are going to believe in the rule of law over the rule of emotion.” Professor of Politics Thomas West, however, said Gorsuch’s Ivy League education — graduating from Harvard Law School the same year as former President Barack Obama — and his Episcopalian faith raise red flags in terms of his conservative values. West said outside of Gorsuch’s opposition to assisted suicide, there is not much on the nominee’s personal views of right and wrong. “He has a background that makes me wonder, ‘Is this guy actually any kind of conservative at all?’” West said. “To me, he’s a big question mark.” In a ruling last August, Gorsuch argued that the Chevron Doctrine, which says courts
are supposed to defer to federal agencies when interpreting vague or ambiguous laws defining their responsibilities, should be reconsidered. “To me that’s a positive, because I think that’s what it’ll take to restore Republican government in America,” West said. “The judiciary and the bureaucracy need to stop trying to change what Congress has legislated and instead follow it.” Junior Adrienne Carrier, an economics major, said she was pleased but surprised by Trump’s nomination of Gorsuch over Judge Thomas Hardiman of the Third Circuit Court of Appeals. “Hardiman was little more typical of the narrative that Trump had been trying to push and maybe a little more sympathetic to Trump’s supporters,” Carrier said. “Although the nomination of Gorsuch may be part of the Trump administration’s goal to overturn a lot of the Washington agencies. That could be very valuable and consistent with Trump’s policies that are pro-business and anti-Washington.” Now, Gorsuch, previously a federal appeals court judge in Denver, must meet the 60-vote threshold needed in the Senate replace Scalia. Some Democrats have promised to oppose Trump’s nominee, after Senate Republicans refused for nearly a year to consider Obama’s
President Donald Trump nominated Judge Neil M. Gorsuch to the U.S. Supreme Court Tuesday. Wikimedia Commons
choice for Scalia’s successor. “I don’t know how much of a fight there will be — although there always is one,” Carrington said. “This pick doesn’t change the composition of the court, so I could see Democrats saving some of their powder for if someone retires and could actually flip the ballots.” West said the real battle in America will have to do with the elected branches, not the judiciary. “Conservatives generally vastly overestimate the importance of the judiciary,” West said. “So, in the end, what I’m hoping for is that he’s not crazy. If his attitude is judicial restraint and that Congress should be respected when they pass laws, and the Constitution’s text should be paid attention to, then that’s good.”
Members of the Hillsdale College football team joined the cheerleading team on Saturday to put on a spirited half-time performance, during the men’s basketball matchup against Ohio Dominaican University. Matthew Kendrick | Collegian
www.hillsdalecollegian.com
Look for The Hillsdale Collegian