Finding friends and souvenirs Longtime Hillsdale residents Bill and Elsie Hayward have visited more than 40 countries and brought back dozens of souvenirs. B4
Michigan’s oldest college newspaper
‘Winter is coming’ Art faculty members Barbara Bushey and Doug Coon present the collaborative exhibit “Winter is Coming.” B1
Vol. 140 Issue 7 - 20 October 2016
Warrant issued for man who fled traffic stop The brother of the fugitive says he violated his temporary release from prison because he is awaiting surgery. A6
www.hillsdalecollegian.com
College sent racial data on student athletes to NCAA By | Thomas Novelly Editor-in-Chief
Grace DeSandro | Collegian
Wikimedia Commons
Trump leads among Hillsdale students
Johnson makes strong showing followed by independent McMullin By | Thomas Novelly and Breana Noble Editor-in-Chief and News Editor With 19 days until the national election, Hillsdale College students favor presidential candidate Donald Trump. Of 493 respondents, a Collegian survey found that more than 43 percent are planning to cast their ballots for the Republican Party’s nominee. That is comparable to the 41 percent he gets nationally among likely voters in a four-way race, according to Rasmussen Reports. Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton, however, is polling at 42 percent nationally, far surpassing the 6 percent pledging their vote to her at Hillsdale. Sophomore Garrison Grisdale said he is voting for Trump and wasn’t surprised that the Republican nominee didn’t receive an overwhelming majority on one of the most conservative college campuses in America. “I don’t think Hillsdale is an accurate representation of America as a whole,” Grisdale said. “Hillsdale is very unique. In the wake of WikiLeaks, this is feeling very much like an ex-
istential election for America. It is about the people versus the elites, Americanism versus globalism. I don’t think many Hillsdale students will go and change their minds on Trump before election, but I think Americans as a whole will probably come out for him.” Many not supporting Trump are looking to Libertarian presidential nominee Gary Johnson, who received more than 20 percent of the votes on campus. Behind him, independent Evan McMullin took more than 11 percent. “I think if McMullin came in earlier, he’d be ahead of Johnson at Hillsdale,” Classical Liberal Organization President junior Noah Weinrich said, noting that the Libertarian candidate is pro-abortion rights and has made gaffes on foreign policy. Associate Professor of Economics Charles Steele said when it comes to the actual election, voting for a third party is futile. “They don’t have a chance,” he said. Yet, some students might have had enough with the presidential election. More than 10 percent of respondents said they would either only vote
down ticket or wouldn’t participate in the election at all this year. Weinrich said he found these results concerning, especially from those who aren’t planning to vote at all, given that the Senate could go to the Republicans or Democrats after this election. Finishing out the survey results, the Constitution Party’s Darrell Castle received 2 percent, Green Party candidate Jill Stein earned 1 percent, Emidio Mimi Soltysik of the Natural Law Party garnered less than 1 percent, and 4 percent chose “other.” Steele noted that write-in, independent candidate Laurence Kotlikoff was not included in the survey. “He is, without question, the single best candidate for getting the budget under control,” Steele said. As for Trump, Weinrich said he understands many at Hillsdale are voting for him reluctantly, believing Clinton would be a worse president. “But I think it’s disappointing,” Weinrich said. “One of the criticisms of President Bill Clinton is his impurities, but Trump is doing the exact same thing if not worse.”
Weinrich said he thinks given Hillsdale students’ conservative leanings, the number voting for the Republican Party’s candidate is low compared to past elections. “He still doesn’t have a majority here,” Weinrich said. “I think that’s encouraging.” However, Professor of Politics Thomas West, who has endorsed Trump, said he thinks students’ hesitancy to voice support for the GOP candidate is dangerous for America. “What I get in class is a very strong sense that Trump supporters don’t want to talk publicly about their support for him because they don’t want to make their friends mad,” West said. “It’s the most interesting and important election of my lifetime. I don’t think there are more than a small percentage of students who recognize that. This is the future of America we are talking about. Hillary is the most criminal, corrupt, and most evil candidate to probably ever run for the presidency. And the idea that people on this campus would throw away their vote to not oppose her is shocking to me.”
Dow in sheriff race again, after Parker violates Hatch Act By | Nathanael Meadowcroft Senior Writer
After losing in a landslide in the Aug. 3 primary, Tammy Dow is running as a write-in candidate for Hillsdale County sheriff because primary-winner Lt. Tim Parker violated a federal election law. According to an Oct. 6 letter from Erica S. Hamrick of the Office of Special Counsel, an independent federal agency, Parker violated the Hatch Act during the primary election. He wore his sheriff ’s uniform in photos on his campaign’s Facebook page and billboards, which was a violation. “Once OSC informed Lt. Parker of his violation, he immediately took steps to come into compliance with the law by removing photographs in which he appears in uniform from his campaign billboards and his official campaign Facebook page,” said Hamrick, the OSC’s Hatch Act Unit deputy chief. “Lt. Parker has been advised that should he engage in activities prohibited by the Hatch Act in the future, OSC would consider it a knowing and willful violation of the law that could result in disciplinary action.” Despite numerous requests for comment, Parker did not speak to The Collegian. Dow said a big reason she reentered the race was because Parker violated the Hatch Act. Follow @HDaleCollegian
Despite losing in the primary election, Tammy Dow is running for Hillsdale County as a write-in candidate. Tammy Dow | Courtesy
Dow announced her candidacy on her campaign Facebook page on Sept. 26 and spent time at the Hillsdale County Fair letting voters know they have a second option on Nov. 8. “Parker is not the man to lead this county. I am the person that should lead this county,” Dow said. “From anywhere from the way we treat our people to the way we treat our animals, there’s so much to be done. If you want the same thing that you’ve gotten for the last 20 years, then Parker is your person.” Dow had not run for an elected office before this past summer’s primaries. In the Aug. 3 primary, Parker won with 4,534 votes (67 percent), followed by 1,428 votes for Jon-Paul Rutan (21 percent) and 798 votes for Dow (less than 12 percent).
“I really wasn’t used to what it takes,” Dow said. “I don’t think we got out there enough.” To increase her chances in the general election, Dow and some of her supporters have gone door to door letting voters know they can write her name under Hillsdale County Sheriff on Election Day. “The door-to-door is probably the most grassroots part of it at this point,” Dow said. But Dow said word of mouth has been the biggest boost. “People have just had enough,” Dow said. “They don’t want the same thing they’ve had for 20 years. That’s what they’re telling me.” Dow said some of her goals as sheriff would be to have “better interaction” with the community and put more emphasis on animals. “We need to take care of them and be responsible for our own strays,” Dow said. Dow also said she wants to take on drugs, with both enforcement and drug programs. “We need to reach out and get more programs going for these drug users,” Dow said. “There has to be help for them locally. We need to get more community involvement.” Dow would also seek to better communication between departments and EMS. “I get that complaint all the time from the fire department, that the sheriff ’s department deputies and the sheriff ’s de-
Lt. Timothy Parker violated a federal law, when he wore his official uniform in connection with his campaign, according to the U.S. Office of Special Counsel Hatch Act Unit. Timothy Parker | Courtesy
partment, in general, tries to take over their scenes,” Dow said. “Fire is a very specific thing, and they do a very good job. We are lucky to have the firefighters that we have. All that takes is communication, education, and being willing to figure out exactly what’s wrong between the departments and fix it.” Dow said she thinks many of Parker’s voters in the primary will flip to her side in the general election. Parker’s name will be the only name printed under Hillsdale County Sheriff on the Nov. 8 ballot, but Dow believes voters will write her name on line below his. “We need something different,” Dow said. “I am just much better suited for that job.”
www.hillsdalecollegian.com
Despite publicly stating that it has never collected or recorded racial data on any of its students, Hillsdale College’s administration has submitted information on the race of all student athletes through the athletic department since joining the NCAA in 1990. Last week, college administrators discovered that for twoand-a-half decades, Hillsdale has complied with an NCAA requirement mandating that coaches collect and submit athletes’ race and gender information in order to complete a mandatory Demographics and Sports Sponsorship form, Athletic Director Don Brubacher said. The president’s office is discussing a variety of actions, ranging from seeking an exemption from this NCAA rule to more far-reaching measures, such as reevaluating the college’s athletic affiliation with the NCAA, said Chief Staff Officer Mike Harner, who is also the associate coach for men’s golf. President Larry Arnn said he didn’t wish to comment until he had all the facts regarding the compliance process and had discussed the college’s options with other administrators. “There is pressure for us to violate the mission of the college, and we resist that with all our might,” Arnn said, adding that he plans to research a multitude of options to fight against the mandate. At its founding in 1844, the college promised to offer an education to all “irrespective of nation, color, or sex.” In the years since, the college has defended these principles in court, and its historic refusal to accept public funding is based in part on an unwillingness to count students by their race. Last year, The Collegian broke the news that the U.S. Department of Education excluded Hillsdale from its College Scorecard in part because of its failure to record the racial information of its students. “We have never collected, that is, we have not collected this data for more than 170 years,” Arnn told The Collegian at the time. In an interview with The Wall Street Journal last year, Arnn said, in reference to keeping track of students’ races, “It’s hugely better if you can just ignore all that stuff, and we can.” Brubacher said the NCAA requires the athletic department to submit numerous forms every year, many of them requesting racial information on student athletes. While he said the college has
The NCAA requires Division II student athletes to submit personal information every year, including their race and gender identity. Wikimedia Commons
avoided filling out race information for some of the forms, the Demographics and Sports Sponsorship form doesn’t allow for that. “It is my understanding that there are some other NCAA forms where the college has developed methods to avoid submitting information regarding the race of students,” Brubacher said. “The athletic department has not, up to this point in time, found a method to avoid providing racial information on the Demographic and Sports Sponsorship form.” The NCAA’s Demographics and Sports Sponsorship form exists for two reasons, according to Brubacher: to record the number of scholarships allocated to student athletes that verify the Chargers as a Division II athletic program as well as gather race and gender data for the NCAA’s research on graduation rates and injury studies. Brubacher, as well as administrators in the president’s office, said it’s unclear if students are aware of this or how the coaches gather the information. While student athletes may not have known that their race is being recorded, all student athletes are required to fill out a student-athlete statement, NCAA form 16-3B, which includes the same racial information that the coaches collect and send to the NCAA. Brubacher said the consequences for not submitting the required paperwork are extreme. “If we do not submit the Demographics and Sports Sponsorship form, then we are barred from national championship play for all sports,” Brubacher said. “And if a student doesn’t sign the 16-3B release form, which allows for the NCAA to have access to the agreed information, such as race, then they are ineligible to play. If these are a requirement for NCAA membership and we do not submit these forms, then our athletic program changes dramatically. It has a huge impact on our student athletes.” S e nior Matt See NCAA A2
The Charger defense takes down a Walsh University receiver during the September matchup. Rachael Reynolds | Collegian Look for The Hillsdale Collegian