Mystery solved Diane Dunn searched for her long-lost harp for 40 years before rediscovering it at Hillsdale College. B4
‘Eumenides’ Hillsdale’s Tower Players present classic Greek theater with “The Eumenides” this week. B1
Clown sightings Citizens and students dressed as clowns roamed Hillsdale’s campus, resulting in police investigation. A6 Thousands gather Friday at the Suburban Collection Showplace Friday in Novi, Michigan, to hear Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump speak. Facebook
Michigan’s oldest college newspaper
Vol. 140 Issue 6 - 6 October 2016
www.hillsdalecollegian.com
Trump excites thousands of supporters at Michigan rally By | Breana Noble and Tim Pearce News Editor and Assistant Editor
ness,” Trump said to the supporters who had stood in line waiting for hours in the rain. “We’re taking on big media. And it’s not pretty.” Attempting to win MichNOVI, Mich. — Republican presidential nominee Donald igan’s 16 battleground elecTrump demanded an end to toral votes, Trump, during his fifth visit to the Great Lakes the political inState since the Republifluence of specan National Committee cial interests and convention in July, enmedia lies before couraged backers to vote thousands at a Nov. 8. Trump portrayed rally last week. Democratic presidential “Our campaign is taking on big busi-
nominee Hillary Clinton as a Washington, D.C., “insider,” bought out by special interest groups to support policies that lose American jobs. Clinton leads Trump by 5 percent in Michigan, according to a Sept. 28 poll of likely voters by Fox 2 Detroit and Mitchell Research and Communications. Trump criticized Clinton for accepting million-dollar donations from corporations and funds for the Clinton Foundation from foreign countries while serving as secretary of state for President Barack Obama. “If she gets the chance, she will put the Oval Office up for sale,” Trump said. “The large corporations, who support terrible trade deals that ship your jobs overseas, they’re donating
to Hillary Clinton. Follow the money.” Special interest groups, Trump said, have encouraged deals that led to the loss of manufacturing jobs in America. He specifically condemned
“He spoke on what is near to my heart.” the North American Free Trade Agreement and the Trans-Pacific Partnership, an agreement that Hillary Clinton praised while in the Obama administration though now says she would veto. “It used to be you made the cars in Flint, and you couldn’t
drink the water in Mexico,” Trump said. “Today, the cars are made in Mexico, and you can’t drink the water in Flint.” Meanwhile, outside, a small group of people protested Trump’s speech. “I am very political, and I have never been so appalled,” said Susan Matthews, 62, of Wolverine Lake. “A corpocracy is certainly how this country is run now.” But inside, rally attendees — wearing “Make America Great Again” hats, carrying Trump signs and flags, and chanting “USA! USA!” — said Trump’s message resonated with them. “He spoke on what is near to my heart,” said James Czellar, 51, of Redford Township, who was laid off from the automotive industry. “For me, the rac-
ism and crap, the whole thing is a sham. The media needs to let people think for themselves.” Dominic Jakabowski, 16, said even though he can’t vote, he convinced his family and friends to attend the rally. “I like that Donald Trump speaks the truth, speaks his mind,” he said. “That’s what we need in Washington. The unconstitutional action of Barack Obama and government officials have created the current political climate.” While messages combating big business and media attracted many, some said Trump didn’t speak enough on another growing institution. “He covered a lot of points and there was good crowd response,” s a i d See Trump A2
Wall Street Journal excludes Hillsdale from rankings By | Breana Noble News Editor In the first U.S. college rankings from The Wall Street Journal and Times Higher Education, Hillsdale College wasn’t included because it neither accepts federal student loans nor collects racial information on its students and faculty. The data for the rankings comes from the College Scorecard, a website maintained by the U.S. Department of Education that provides indicators about the cost and value of institutions across the country on which Hillsdale also doesn’t appear. Hillsdale was added to the Education Department’s Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System, or IPEDS, which supplies information to the College Scorecard, in the fall of 2015, after negotiations with the department. The college, however, remains missing from the scorecard because it isn’t a Title IV institution, meaning it doesn’t accept government money. “It is assumed by people in the government and academic institutions that everybody takes federal money and everyone tracks and shares racial data,” Director of Institutional Research George Allen said. “Those two things, which Hillsdale refuses to do, have become universal standards most people don’t even think about.” On Sept. 28, The Wall Street Journal printed a 12-page section devoted to the rankings developed by Times Higher Education, a London-based magazine for postsecondary education news. Times Higher Education took into consideration colleges’ resources, engagement, outcomes, and environment. For each institution, a graduate’s ability to repay student debt accounted for 7 percent of its score in the rankings. The data came from the College Scorecard because it is the only
publicly available database with information on earnings and debt repayment for almost all U.S. universities, a Times Higher Education representative said in an email. It chose to use repayment of loans in its criteria because U.S. college debt stands at $1.3 trillion and affordability of attending college is a main concern for many families, the representative said. Student and faculty racial and ethnic diversity accounted for 3 percent of colleges’ scores. This information came from IPEDS. Including that data helps students understand whether they will find themselves in a diverse, supportive, and inclusive environment, according to Times Higher Education. Hillsdale’s mission statement states it will educate “irrespective of nation, color, or sex,” so the college doesn’t record any information about the race of students and faculty. “These are categories of information we either do not have or do not have and think it shameful to collect,” Provost David Whalen said in an email. “So, the WSJ has apparently accepted as meaningful criteria for ranking things in which Hillsdale does not engage on principle.” Hillsdale was not the only college excluded from the rankings. The military academies don’t have student loan repayment statistics because all students attend for free, so they weren’t included either, Wall Street Journal reporter Doug Belkin said in an email. To appear on the list, colleges also had to have more than 1,000 students with 20 percent or less taking online-only courses. “It’s ridiculous,” Professor of History Paul Rahe said. He added that the incoming freshman class’s test scores are the same as those attending places like the University of
See IPEDS A2
The city of Hillsdale installed the new “historic Hillsdale” welcome sign Friday on M-99. Hillsdale College purchased the marker to replace the 20-year-old “It’s the people” sign. Evan Carter | Collegian Follow @HDaleCollegian
After teaching at Hillsdale College for more than 14 years, Professor of History Burt Folsom announced he will retire after the fall semester in December. Hillsdale.edu | Courtesy
Folsom to retire in December By | Thomas Novelly Editor-in-Chief
After teaching on entrepreneurship, new deal policies, and economic history for more than 14 years, Hillsdale College Professor of History Burt Folsom is announcing he will retire in December. “One of my goals in teaching was that I would know when I should retire before my students knew it,” Folsom said with a laugh. “I think I’ve accomplished that goal. You need to set a good example here for people to not hang out past their prime.” The college hired Folsom in 2002, and he has taught as the Charles F. Kline chair in history and management since 2003. He will turn 69 years old in November and will retire several weeks later. During his retirement, Folsom said he plans to write and speak on college campuses about his work. President Larry Arnn said he will miss Folsom’s presence on campus. “Burt is the first professor hired, after I came to the college,” Arnn said in an email.
“I personally helped the department to recruit him, and I have been glad of it every day. For that reason, I am unhappy to see him retiring but proud for him, too. He will be an important man in his new life, and I hope and expect him to stay connected to the college in many ways. ” Since joining the history department 14 years ago, Folsom has written four books, some of which are co-written with his wife, Anita Folsom: “Urban Capitalists,” “New Deal or Raw Deal?,” “FDR Goes to War,” “A Republic – If We Can Keep It,” and “Death on Hold.” Folsom said he was able to write those books because of an agreement he made with the administration several years ago. He would teach full time in the fall each year and return to his Atlanta, Georgia, home to write during the spring and summer. Folsom wrote all four of those books after he turned 60, and despite publishing so much in a short span, he said he isn’t putting down the pen anytime soon. During his retirement, Folsom said he plans
to write one more installment in his series of books analyzing New Deal policies. “When I hit 60, I knew there was a lot I had to do that hadn’t been done,” Folsom said. “There is still a book on Truman I want to write because the 1948 election presaged the politics of the day. The whole welfare state was coming in. That election has never been commented on adequately, so I have two books on Roosevelt and this book on Truman would serve as the trilogy to cap it off.” Folsom published several of his books through the Young America’s Foundation, where he is a frequent lecturer for the conservative activism organization based near Washington, D.C. Folsom also served as the faculty adviser for Hillsdale’s chapter of Young Americans for Freedom. YAF President junior English Hinton said Folsom raised the chapter’s reputation and replacing him will not be easy. “He’s easily one of the favorite speakers at all the conferences,” Hinton said. “He’s
so encouraging and friendly. I think it speaks a lot about his impact on campus, when students at national YAF events envy us because he is a teacher at Hillsdale.” Folsom’s current students said they couldn’t believe he was retiring and will miss the excitement and enthusiasm he brought to all his classes. “What is wonderful about Dr. Folsom is that despite having taught these topics many times over, he continues to be energetic in his delivery,” junior Lauren Renslow said. “Today, he said that he was ‘high off Dr. Pepper.’ It’s funny to think of him retiring because he seems to have enough fuel to keep teaching for many more years.” Members of Hillsdale’s history department also said they would miss seeing Folsom’s energy and passion during his lectures. “Dr. Folsom is a scholar of national repute, and one of the wisest and most enthusiastic teachers we have ever had here,” Professor of History Thomas Conner said. “More than that, he is a wonderful colleague, an e x - See Folsom A2
Polls and parties: Patrick Cadell defines today’s Democrats
-Compiled by Joshua Lee Patrick Caddell is an American in high school, I was able to do public opinion pollster and for- exit polling for the elections in mer political film consultant in Jacksonville, Florida. My dad the Jimmy Carter White House. helped get my results called A regular Fox News contributor, out at the Democrats’ election Caddell has served as a con- night watch party in the counsultant to various movies and ty court house. The races that television shows, including the election were very close, and I serial drama “The West Wing.” was right on all of them, which Caddell spoke Monday in Phil- was insane. I just called them, lips Auditorium on “The Demo- not knowing it was within the crat Party Today,” as part of the margin of error, but I turned Center for Constructive Alter- out to be right. It turned out to natives seminar on Democrats be a big deal at the election parand Republicans. ty, and the local newspaper did How did you get started in a piece on me, calling me “Mr. polling and political consult- Prediction.” Then this fellow, ing? Brad Shultz, who eventually In high school, I had to do became speaker of the Florida a math project, and I had just House, hired me to do polling gained an interest in politics analysis for him. So, to do the the year before. That year, the analysis, I hired my classmates, news networks called the gov- and we covered most of the ernor’s race for the first time, local elections in Florida. Our using precinct polling. Around analysis was always right, and 7:30 p.m., they called the Flor- everyone couldn’t believe it. ida governor’s race against my Around this time, The Washcandidate, the Democrat, and I ington Post had affiliates in was stunned and fascinated be- Miami and Jacksonville, and I cause they were right. would help them call the races I decided I would build a on election nights. From there, model to do the same thing I officially started my polling for a bunch of local elections. and consulting business. This was 1967, and as a junior You crafted a strategy to help www.hillsdalecollegian.com
Patrick Cadell, pollster and political film consultant for the Carter administration, spoke in Phillips Auditorium Monday on “The Democratic Party Today” for the Democrats and Republicans Center for Constructive Alternatives seminar. Madeline Barry | Collegian
Jimmy Carter win the presidency and were called the “best pollster in the business.” What advice do you have for those considering political consulting? While I was a college student at Harvard in the Institute of Politics, my business did well in Florida, which later gave me jobs in Ohio. This led to a job in the George McGovern presidential campaign in 1972, when I was only 21. This was the beginning of my national staging,
and, even though we lost 49 states, it turned out pretty well for me because it later got me a job with the Jimmy Carter campaign. I was part of a small group advising Jimmy Carter that convinced him of using a restoring-trust message to unify the nation. Many years later I told him, “I finally figured it out, Mr. President. You had all us young guys helping you because we were the only ones young enough See Cadell A3 Look for The Hillsdale Collegian