The first snow of the season fell on Halloween evening. Erik Teder | Collegian
Vol. 147 Issue 10 – November 2, 2023
www.hillsdalecollegian.com
Alumna releases book on Sam Bankman-Fried, FTX
War in Israel
Michigan’s oldest college newspaper
DOJ awards Hillsdale County grant to combat domestic violence By Elyse Apel Digital Editor The Department of Justice’s Office on Violence Against Women awarded Hillsdale County a grant to improve its criminal justice response to domestic violence. The nearly $500,000 grant will include funding for Domestic Harmony’s legal advocate program, and allow Judge Megan Stiverson of the 2B District Court to establish a Domestic Violence Court. Domestic Harmony is a local domestic violence shelter that provides housing, counseling, and legal counseling to Michigan residents in need. “We have to have a coordinated community response to domestic violence,” said Hannah Jordan, executive director of Domestic Harmony. “I’m really passionate about that because change will only happen when you’ve got the whole community on board.” The grant is for the next four years and will allow for a closer handling of domestic violence cases in the county by hiring a dedicated probation officer and case manager for domestic violence, stalking, and misdemeanor-level sexual assault crimes in the county.
See Violence A6
By Sophia Mandt Collegian Freelancer Alumna Elizabeth Bachmann ’21 released her debut book in September about the FTX cryptocurrency scandal. Bachmann cowrote “Crypto Crackup: Sam Bankman-Fried, FTX, and Bankman-Fried’s Weird Island Empire” with Ash Bennington and Artur Osiński. The book explores the rise and fall of FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried, who managed a multibillion-dollar cryptocurrency exchange with his company but was arrested in the Bahamas last year on charges including wire fraud and money laundering, according to CBS News. “It was really crazy to spend the first couple of weeks doing so much research about crypto, Sam, and FTX and what crypto trading even is,” Bachmann said. While at Hillsdale College, Bachmann majored in English and minored in journalism and was the features editor of The Collegian. After graduating from Hillsdale, Bachmann became a writer and editor for First Things magazine before starting her current position as director of production at Encounter Books. Associate Professor of English Dwight Lindley said he thinks the skills students like Bachmann develop at Hillsdale prepare them well for the real world. “I remember working with her on writing papers and she really enjoyed thinking through long theoretical lines of inquiry, so much that I remember thinking ‘is she going to be an English major or a philosophy major?’ She ended
up being an English major, but she has a philosophical mind,” Lindley said. John J. Miller, director of the Dow Journalism Program and one of Bachmann’s former professors, said he remembers her as a great writer who continued to improve after graduation. “I wasn’t surprised to see her name on a book cover, but I didn’t expect it to happen so quickly,” he said. “Elizabeth has a bright future in journalism and publishing, and the release of this new book makes it even brighter.” Bachmann said the book tells the stor y of Bankman-Fried chronologically through straight journalism. “I didn’t think I was going to find this as interesting as I did, but Sam Bankman is this really crazy character,” Bachmann said. “He grew up on the Stanford campus and his parents were professors.” Bachmann said she believed Bankman’s upbringing influenced his actions as the CEO of FTX. “His dad is a professed utilitarian and his mother was a consequentialist and a determinist, and he grew up with utilitarianism as his religion in a sense,” Bachmann said. “I think he’s guilty, but I think that a lot of his motivation to start out was truly altruistic.” Bachmann said the book examines Bankman-Fried’s move toward effective altruism and his attempts to make as much money as possible. Effective altruism, Bachmann said, is a philosophy developed from the writings of Australian philosopher Peter Singer in the 2000s, which says you have an obligation to help others with the goal of
net quantity of happiness. “He was trying to create a secular morality essentially built around rationality, and so he’ll say things like ‘it’s morally wrong not to kill a child that has a disability,’” Bachmann said.
Elizabeth Bachmann ’21 majored in English at Hillsdale College. Courtesy | Elizabeth Bachmann
Bachmann said Bankman-Fried was motivated by these principles from a young age. “In high school, he wrote all these blog posts about how he was utilitarian and how he wanted to maximize happiness in the world,” Bachmann said. Bankman-Fried demonstrated the principles of effective altruism through his early work for animal welfare, becoming vegan and donating 50% of his salary to animal welfare causes after graduating from MIT, according to Bachmann. “The thing about Sam Bankman-Fried is that I think he started out with genuinely good intentions but those intentions became corrupted through fame and power,” Bachmann said. Bachmann said Bankman-Fried focused later in his career on a philosophy within effective altruism called long
termism. “It says rationally there’s going to be more people alive in the future than there are now,” Bachmann said. “If you want to help the most people you need to be thinking about all of the future generations and not the people who are currently alive.” This shift of philosophy marked a shift in Bankman-Fried’s career, according to Bachmann. “He’s following the secular morality where the only barometer of good and evil is pleasure or pain. That’s what effective altruism comes from,” Bachmann said. “It goes to show you that, even for people with the best intentions, without God, without following some higher transcendent law for what is good and evil, human beings get lost.” The book concludes with Bankman-Fried on house arrest in Palo Alto, California. Bachmann said she found being a co-author challenging. “I ended up having two co-authors at the end of the day,” Bachmann said. “And we had very different visions for the way the book was going to be written. That was hard but it taught me a lot about collaborative writing and to be very sure that you know what your coauthor’s vision is.” Bachmann said the process taught her a lot. “I feel like I’m a different person after the book than I was before I wrote the book,” Bachmann said. “It taught me to check my pride about how good a writer I was and realize that as good of a writer as you are in the journalistic world, you have to get stuff right in the first place.”
Junior Jack Cote, Hannah Cote ’23, and freshman Max Cote (left to right) pose for a photo. Courtesy | Hannah Cote
By Elizabeth Troutman Editor-in-chief Hillsdale College legacies do not benefit from priority admissions, Senior Director of Admissions Zachary Miller said. “We do not weigh someone’s application differently because they’re a legacy,” Miller said. “It is truly on the merits of the student’s application without any consideration or ranking for that.”
Though siblings, children, and grandchildren of Hillsdale alumni enrich the student body, Miller said, the admissions department does not give them an advantage over other candidates who seek to get past the college’s 20% acceptance rate. In June, the Supreme Court ruled against the use of racial preferences in college admissions. Soon after, a civil rights group filed a lawsuit to challenge legacy admissions at
Harvard University. Since then, debate has raged over the fairness of favoring applicants with family connections. If a court prohibits legacy admissions in the future, as in the affirmative action ruling in SFFA v. Harvard and SFFA v. UNC, it would not affect Hillsdale, Miller said. “You have to take into consideration simply the student and their fit, their accomplishments, and what they bring to
concerns for Passages trip By Elyse Apel Digital Editor
in order to be consistent with the values that are taught at Hillsdale, the admissions process should be as objective as possible.” Freshman Max Cote is the fourth sibling in his family to attend Hillsdale. Mason Cote graduated in 2019, Hannah graduated in 2023, Jack is a junior, and their mom, Shanna Cote, has worked for the college for almost seven years. “Definitely having three siblings going to Hillsdale helped me understand some of the application process and even why to apply early decision,” Cote said. Sophomore Sophia Widmer agreed having two sisters connected to the college made her admissions process smoother. Her sister Emma is a senior and Sam graduated in 2021. “Since Hillsdale recruits based on such different qualities, it was really helpful to have two older sisters who went through it and also were already acclimated to the campus culture,” Widmer said.
The Passages student trip to Israel is still planned for this winter — even as war continues to rage in the region — but organizers warn it won’t happen if intense fighting continues between Hamas and the Israeli Defense Forces. “Safety is paramount,” said Jeffery “Chief ” Rogers, associate dean of men and a trip organizer. “I do not think it will go because the IDF has said that this incursion into the Gaza Strip is going to take some time, and we aren’t going to have people on the ground while that is going on.” The trip is sponsored by the Philos Project and the Museum of the Bible Foundation. Since 2015, Passages trips have taken hundreds of Hillsdale students to Israel, visiting sites such as Jerusalem, Bethlehem, and the Sea of Galilee. “The Passages trip is a wonder,” said Paul Rahe, professor of history and another trip organizer. “It is an inexpensive way for Christian college students at Hillsdale and elsewhere to visit the Holy Land and to get a read on Israeli-Palestinian relations.” Rahe also said he doubts the trip will happen. “In my opinion, the trip planned for this year will not take place,” Rahe said. “Things may settle down a bit by the end of December, but the danger will be great.” Rahe said his daughter, who attends the University of Chicago, was supposed to spend the winter in Egypt. “I have told her to withdraw,” Rahe said. “Now is not the time for Americans to travel in the Arab world.” According to the latest Passages update, leadership believes Israel will be safe for travel by the end of the year. “There is growing consensus in the Israel Defense Forces briefings that Israel’s operation in response to the Hamas terror attacks will last approximately one month and that Israel could be safe again for educational travel near the end of the year,” said Harrison Kone, Passages’ director of recruitment. “We remain optimistic for a quick end to the war.” Don Westblade, assistant professor of religion and a trip organizer, said some students have chosen to drop out of the trip. He added he will trust Passages’ decision.
See Legacy A2
See Passages A2
Hillsdale admissions does not take family connections into account the table as a potential student for Hillsdale College,” Miller said. “Other schools might have different priorities, and that’s up to them. But we want to create the best class of students regardless of where they come from, regardless of their background.” Miller says the rejection of legacies seems to have increased over the past five to 10 years. “That’s again what makes it really hard, because we’re not growing the enrollment, and we have more and more applications,” Miller said. “We have to say no to a lot of those. So it seems like every year there’s a lot of those cases that are hard letters to send, hard phone calls to take.” Though senior Caroline Holmes’ younger brother was rejected by admissions, she said she is glad the college does not consider legacy status in the application process. “I am a firm believer in the blind admissions process and think that every student should be admitted based on strict merit as opposed to family status, money, race and gender, etc.,” Holmes said. “I think that
raises safety