February 22, 2019

9ROXPH ;&9, 1XPEHU ''''''0&R4314B'YY\'Y;+9'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!T4'.%21%'-!?)22).5(2%112!

:N@'Q&7$"#'Y;+9FY;Y;'Z1V-1$7"':&1#."

!"#$%&'!"#$%&'(#$$$$$$$$$

(&)#***********************+' ,-$"$."#*****************/' 62=1"'Q1[=1"%'IYY 1502! %7%.104#! 02! 640#6! 14! 1('#! 4(1A! K! 15%!.7)22!02!0#!644/!5)#/2A!F5)1L2!15%! :)2!2%%C0#6!15%!9'%20/%#.*A 0#12$)3'.4( 150#C!=*!%M9%'0%#.%!)2!E'%20/%#1!:077! 64)7!)31%'!)77-!'0651OP ! ! ! F5%! =421! 0=94'1)#1! 29%%.5%2! 43 ! 0&1234&#******************5' KHOS PH WR JHW WKLQJV GRQH HIÃ&#x20AC; FLHQWO\ !!!F5%!90.1('%!34'!15%!@7)22%2!43 !GHG+! 15%!#0651!.)=%!0#!15%!2%.4#/!&74.C-! 677-81"2*****************9 !!!"#!$%&'()'*!+,-!.)#/0/)1%2!34'!15%! #%M1! *%)'! &(1-! *4(! C#4:-! 15%! 415%'! DQG ZHUH VLJQLÃ&#x20AC; FDQWO\ FOHDUHU )2! 15%! )(/0%#.%! :)2! 0#1'4/(.%/! 14! :-.42#*********************+; 50657*! .48%1%/! 9420104#2! :0150#! 15%! ;1(/%#1! <48%'#=%#1! >224.0)104#!

9'%2%#1%/! 15%0'! 0/%)2! )#/! )290')104#! )1! 15%! )##()7! ?%%1! 15%! @)#/0/)1%2A! B%2901%! 29%)C0#6! 14! )! 2=)77! .'4:/-!

21(/%#12!1'0%/!15%0'!&%21!14!9'4=41%!

15%0'!.)#/0/).*!5%)/0#6!0#14!15%!%7%.D 104#2-!:50.5!:077!&%!49%#!4#!$%&'(D DU\ 7KLV ZDV WKH Ã&#x20AC; UVW WLPH WKH @4DE'%20/%#1! .)#/0/)1%2! 9'%2%#1%/!

15%0'!97)134'=2!)1!)!2.5447!%8%#1A 7KH Ã&#x20AC; UVW SHRSOH WR VSHDN ZHUH WKRVH UXQQLQJ IRU FODVV RIÃ&#x20AC; FHU SRVLWLRQV LQ )2.%#/0#6! 4'/%'-! 3'4=! *4(#6%21! 14!

47/%21A!F5%!@7)22!43 !GHGG!.)#/0/)1%2! '%9'%2%#1%/!)!=)I4'01*!43 !15%!29%)CD %'2! 0#! 1502! &74.C-! 9'4/(.0#6! 15'%%! .)#/0/)1%2!34'!15%!.7)22!9'%20/%#.*!)2! :%77!)2!=(71097%!9%497%!8*0#6!34'!15%!

RIÃ&#x20AC; FHV RI 7UHDVXUHU DQG 6HFUHWDU\ ! ! ! @(''%#1! @7)22! 43 ! GHGG! E'%20/%#1! >#6%74! @)'&4#%! 294C%! )&4(1! 15%!

SURVSHFWV RI WKH Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDU HOHFWLRQ 2)*0#6-!JKL=!744C0#6!34':)'/!14!54:!

15%0'! 49104#2! 34'! GH+QDGHGH! @4D 3UHVLGHQWV 7KH Ã&#x20AC; UVW SDLU WR VSHDN :)2!@5'0210)#!R%)7&(14!)#/!@)'470#%!

S)&0#2C0A! T015! S)&0#2C0! .4=97%10#6!

5%'!2%=%21%'!):)*-!R%)7&(14!9'%2%#1D %/!15%0'!'%2(=%2!)2!:%77!)2!15%0'!9470D .*!4&I%.108%2!0#!)!.4#.02%!=)##%'A ! ! ! >31%'! 502! 29%%.5-! R%)7&(14! 294C%! )&4(1! 54:! 5%! &%70%8%/! 15%! #0651! :%#1-! 21)10#6-! JK! 154(651! 01! :%#1! :%77A!KL=!'%)77*!)99'%.0)108%!43 !)77!15%!

9%497%! 15)1! :%! 5)8%! 15)1! .)=%! )#/!

2):!(2AP !!!>//0104#)77*-!R%)7&(14!7)0/!4(1!502! )#/!S)&0#2C0L2!64)72!03 !15%*!)'%!%7%.1D %/-!2)*0#6-!J"('!2746)#!02!U@4==01D 1%/!14!@4==(#01*-L!)#/!:%!)'%!'%)77*!

I(21!)77!)&4(1!5%)'0#6!3'4=!/033%'%#1!

5"4.42$647(.#28$49 $:,(4+'-#$;,<'-2='$>$:"('2.',-$?#,+<7.4@$A,('#$B,*+4'(#$>$B,..$C4+9#D 9%'29%.108%2-! 5%)'0#6! 3'4=! /033%'%#1! <=&':N@'68&[2$."#')$88'R&'=&8%'G4.V'X."%1B\'Y]YT'2=4.37=''?&%"&#%1B\'Y]Y5* 840.%2!4#!.)=9(2A!?)C0#6!2('%!15)1! :%!5%)'!3%%/&).C!3'4=!)2!=)#*!9%4D 1:4!.)#/0/)1%2!)'%!&415!.)9)&7%!)#/! )2! 15%! 34'=%'! 9'4/(.%/! 4#7*! 4#%! 97%!)2!:%!.)#AP K! 150#C! 15%*L'%! &415! 6'%)1! 6(*2A! N4! .)#/0/)1%! 34'! %).5! 9420104#! )#/! 15%! +H ZHQW RQ WR DGG VSHFLÃ&#x20AC; F SROLF\ =)11%'! 54:! 15%! %7%.104#! 1('#2! 4(1-! 7)11%'!9(1!34'15!4#7*!4#%!21(/%#1!:54! ;%%!:N@\!9)6%!c

Q1R$"#^$FH&18R32.'_'X178.$4&F?.8G&'@"".3"[&'Z.FE4&#$%&"2$18'Q$%# C&22&4'.G '!"2&"2'04.V'Q1R$"#^$FH&18R32. !!!T%-!@)'470#%!S)&0#2C0!)#/!@5'0210)#!

R%)7&(14-! )'%! %M.01%/! 14! )##4(#.%!

4('! .)#/0/).*! 34'! .4D9'%20/%#12! 43 !

15%! ;1(/%#1! <48%'#=%#1! >224.0)D 104#!)1!15%!@477%6%!43 !15%!V47*!@'422A! T%!5)8%!&415!.5%'025%/!4('!10=%!)1!

V47*!@'422-!)#/!)2!.4D9'%20/%#12-!:%! :077!21'08%!14!.4#10#(%!0=9'480#6!15%!

V47*! @'422! %M9%'0%#.%! 34'! .(''%#1! )#/!3(1('%!21(/%#12!)70C%A !!!T%!&%70%8%!4('!:0/%!')#6%!43 !.)=D SXV H[SHULHQFHV PDNH XV TXDOLÃ&#x20AC; HG IRU WKLV SRVLWLRQ $V Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDU VWXGHQWV :%!&415!2%'8%/!)2!%M%.(108%!.)&0#%1!

0#1%'#2! 34'! 15%! ;<>! D! @)'470#%! 34'! @4==(#0.)104#2! )#/! @5'0210)#! 34'! @4==(#01*! R%7)104#2A! B('0#6! 5%'!

24954=4'%! *%)'-! @)'470#%! 2%'8%/! )2!

15%! B0'%.14'! 43 ! @)=9(2! )#/! ;<>! ;%'80.%2-! 9'480/0#6! 5%'! 15%! 4994'D 1(#01*!14!)/84.)1%!34'!21(/%#12!:015! /0%1)'*!'%21'0.104#2!)#/!=)0#1)0#!15%! .)=9(2! 25(117%! )#/! ;)3%! R0/%! 9'4D 6')=2A! @)'470#%! 5)2! )724! :4'C%/! )2! )!R%20/%#1!>22021)#1-!:50.5!608%2!5%'!

21'4#6!0#20651!0#14!15%!#%%/2!43 !'%20D /%#.%! 5)772! 4#! .)=9(2A! ?4'%48%'-! @5'0210)#!5)2!&%%#!)!=%=&%'!43 !15%!

0HQ·V 6ZLP 7HDP VLQFH KLV Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDU )1! V47*! @'422-! )#/! 5%! 97)#2! 14! (2%!

502!%M9%'0%#.%!)2!)!21(/%#1D)157%1%!14! &%!)!21'4#6!)/84.)1%!34'!V47*!@'422!

21(/%#1D)157%1%2A !!!K#!)//0104#!14!4('!;<>-!R%20/%#.%!

W03%-! )#/! 21(/%#1D)157%1%! %M9%'0%#.D %2-! :%! 5)8%! )724! %#6)6%/! :015! V47*! &URVV Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDU WUDQVLWLRQ SURJUDPV S415!43 !(2!5)8%!&%%#!;(==%'!<)1%D :)*2!"'0%#1)104#!W%)/%'2!)#/!@5'02D WLDQ VHUYHG DV D 3DWKÃ&#x20AC; QGHU IRU WKH E)2294'1!E'46')=!15'4(65!>.)/%=D 0.! ;%'80.%2! )#/! W%)'#0#6! R%24('.%2A! >2!9)'10.09)#12!43 !21(/*!)&'4)/-!15%!

N%:! X4'C! ;%=%21%'! E'46')=! )#/!

15%!T)250#614#-!BA@A!;%=%21%'!E'4D

6')=-!:%!)'%!)724!%)6%'!14!:4'C!:015!

15%!@%#1%'!34'!@)'%%'!B%8%749=%#1-!

15%! YABA! E4:%'! @%#1%'! 34'! W0&%')7! $UWV LQ WKH :RUOG DQG WKH 2IÃ&#x20AC; FH RI ;1(/*! >&'4)/! 14! 0=9'48%! )..%22! 14!

4994'1(#010%2! 34'! #%1:4'C0#6! )#/!

0#1%'#25092! 34'! 15%! N%:! X4'C! )#/!

T)250#614#! 2%=%21%'! 9'46')=2! D! )2! :%77! )2! 0=97%=%#1! 21(/%#1! 3%%/&).C! ).'422!)77!9'46')=2A ! ! ! T%! )'%! %M1'%=%7*! 9'4(/! )#/! 34'D 1(#)1%! 14! 5)8%! 9)'10.09)1%/! 0#! 15%2%! %M9%'0%#.%2! )1! V47*! @'422-! )#/! :%!

DUH FRQÃ&#x20AC; GHQW WKDW WKHVH HQJDJHPHQWV .)#!5%79!(2!&%11%'!2%'8%!15%!21(/%#1! &4/*A!>2!.4D9'%20/%#12-!:%!:077!:4'C! :015!.477%6%!)/=0#021')14'2-!21(/%#12-!

3).(71*-! )7(=#0! )#/! 15%! <'%)1%'!

T4'.%21%'!.4==(#01*!14!5%79!&(07/!)! .)=9(2!.4==(#01*!15)1!02!0#.7(208%-! '%29%.13(7! )#/! )..%910#6! 14! )77A! T%! :077!)/84.)1%!34'!.5)#6%2!0#!15%!@47D 7%6%L2! %#80'4#=%#1)7! 2(21)0#)&0701*!

9').10.%2!0#!&415!'%20/%#.%!5)772!)#/! /0#0#6! 74.)104#2A! T%! :)#1! 14! :4'C! ZLWK WKH 2IÃ&#x20AC; FH RI 5HVLGHQFH /LIH )#/!V4(20#6!14!%M974'%!:)*2!14!0=D 9'48%! 15%! Z()701*! 43 ! '%20/%#.%! 5)772! )#/!=)0#1)0#!1')#29)'%#.*!0#!15%!433D .)=9(2!54(20#6!)9970.)104#!9'4.%22A! T%! :077! :4'C! 14! %#2('%! )! 2=4415!

1')#20104#! /('0#6! 15%! $0%7/! V4(2%! '%#48)104#!9'4.%22-!)2!01!&%.4=%2!15%! #%:!R%.'%)104#![!T%77#%22!@%#1%'A ! ! ! >&48%! )77-! :%! )'%! .4==011%/! 14!

5%)'0#6! 3%%/&).C! /('0#6! 4('! .)=D 9)06#-!)#/!:%!:%7.4=%!0/%)2!4'!2(6D 6%2104#2!'%6)'/0#6!)#*!022(%!9%'1)0#D 0#6!14!703%!)1!V47*!@'422A!T%!:4(7/! &%!54#4'%/!14!2%'8%!15%!V47*!@'422! @4==(#01*!14!15%!8%'*!&%21!43 !4('! )&07010%2-!)2!*4('!;<>!.4D9'%20/%#12A ;0#.%'%7*@)'470#%!S)&0#2C0!)#/ @5'0210)#!R%)7&(14

C&22&4'.G '!"2&"2'04.V'X178.$4&F?.8G& ! ! ! T%-! \)'0%! WA! ?)6704'%! )#/! ?)1D 15%:!BA!T473%-!)'%!0#.'%/0&7*!%M.01%/! )#/! 9'4(/! 14! )##4(#.%! 4('! .)#/0D /).*! 34'! 15%! @4DE'%20/%#12! 43 ! 15%! @477%6%!43 !15%!V47*!@'422!;1(/%#12! <48%'#=%#1!>224.0)104#A ! ! ! "('! 10=%! 4#! 15%! V077! 5)2! &%%#! (#0Z(%A!]).5!2.5447!*%)'!5)2!&'4(651! #%:! .5)77%#6%2-! &(1! 1502! *%)'-! 15%! .5)77%#6%2!15)1!5)8%!9'%2%#1%/!15%=D 2%78%2!14!4('!.4==(#01*!5)8%!&%%#! =4'%! )99)770#6! 15)#! )#*! 0#! '%.%#1! =%=4'*^! )! 5%0#4(2! W<SF_`! 5)1%! .'0=%-!.4#10#(%/!)#10DW<SF_`!)#/! ').0)7!0#147%')#.%-!2%M()7!)22)(71-!2%MD XDO DEXVH« :H Ã&#x20AC; QG WKH FRQVLVWHQF\ 43 ! .49*D)#/D9)21%! %=)072! 3'4=! 15%! @477%6%! )/=0#021')104#! /02)9940#1D 0#6-! *%1! .)=9(2! '5%14'0.! .4#21)#17*! /%=)#/0#6!=4'%!).104#!3'4=!1542%!

0#! .5)'6%! )7:)*2! .4=%2! 3(77D.0'.7%-! :015!)#415%'!%=)07A!T%!)'%!3'(21')1D %/A!F502!02!#41!4('!V47*!@'422A !!!S(1!:%!5)8%!2%%#!15%!'%2070%#.%!43 !

4('!.)=9(2!.4==(#01*!1502!*%)'A!K#!

10=%2!43 !)/8%'201*-!:%!5)8%!)77!.4=%!

WRJHWKHU WR Ã&#x20AC; JKW EDFN DQG PDNH 4('! 490#04#2! 5%)'/-! 3'4=! 15%! &')8%!

9(&70.)104#2!43 !a;%M()7>22)(71"#D F5%V077-!14!15%!]N<><]!;(==01-!

14!15%!bB%=)#/?4'%!201D0#A!T%!&%D 70%8%!0#!15%!94:%'!43 !21(/%#1!840.%2A !!!K1!02!34'!15)1!'%)24#!:%!/%.7)'%!4('! .)#/0/).*!14/)*A!T%!&%70%8%!15)1!:%! )'%!:%77D%Z(099%/!14!).1!)2!*4('!@4D E'%20/%#12!15'4(65!)!.4=&0#)104#!43 ! :5)1!:%!&'0#6!14!15%!1)&7%%-!#41!4#7*! :015! 48%'! 34('! *%)'2! 43 ! .4=&0#%/! ;<>! %M9%'0%#.%-! &(1! )724! 3'4=! %MD 9%'0%#.%2!)2!&%0#6!)#!R>-!0#!@>;>-! )#/!415%'!R;"L2!)#/!?;"L2A!T%!&%D 70%8%!0#!4('!(#0Z(%!0/%#1010%2!15)1!:%!

XVH WR GHÃ&#x20AC; QH RXUVHOYHV 7RJHWKHU ZH )'%!4#%!1%)=-!)#/!)'%!.4==011%/!14!

1('#0#6!4('!0/%)2!0#14!).104#!34'!9)7D

9)&7%!.5)#6%A ! ! ! K3 ! %7%.1%/-! :%! :077! %M9)#/! 15%! @)&0#%1!)#/!(#01%!:015!15%!;%#)1%!14! :4'C! )2! )! 1%)=! 0#! 4'/%'! 14! %M9)#/!

15%! .4==(#0.)104#! &%1:%%#! 15%!

DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ VSHFLÃ&#x20AC; FDOO\ WKH 2I Ã&#x20AC; FH RI 7LWOH ,; &RXQVHOLQJ &HQWHU B%9)'1=%#1! 43 ! E(&70.! ;)3%1*-! )#/!

3UHVLGHQW·V 2IÃ&#x20AC; FH DQG \RXU HOHFWHG 21(/%#1! '%9'%2%#1)108%2! 14! =)0#1)0#! )..4(#1)&0701*A! T%! :077! 70)02%! :015!

WKH 2IÃ&#x20AC; FH RI 6WXG\ $EURDG WR HQ 2('%!15)1!3(1('%!9)'10.09)#12!)'%!#41!

7%31!:)010#6!34'!)!/%.0204#!:%%C2!9)21!

15%0'!/%.0204#!/%)/70#%A!T%!:077!:4'C! :015!15%!B%)#2!14!'%2478%!)!#(=&%'!

43 !022(%2-!0#.7(/0#6!0#.'%)2%/!.4('2%! .)9).01*! )#/! /033%'%#1! %#'477=%#1!

10=%2A! T%! :077! :4'C! :015! $).07010%2!

14!.44'/0#)1%!)!2=)'1%'!(2%!43 !W(15!

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

5%'%-!:%!&%70%8%!01!02!4('!1('#!14!7%)8%!

4('! =)'C! 4#! V47*! @'422! 34'! 3(1('%!

21(/%#12A!K1!02!)!10=%!34'!.5)#6%A!T%-! \)'0%!W%%!)#/!?)11!T473%-!:4(7/!&%!

5(=&7%/!&*!15%!4994'1(#01*!14!2%'8%! )2!*4('!@4DE'%20/%#12A !!!T%!)'%!/'%)=%'2-!:%!)'%!&%70%8%'2-! )#/! :%! )'%! ).50%8%'2A! T%! )'%! "#%!

V47*!@'422A \)'0%!WA!?)6740'%!)#/ ?)115%:!BA!T473%

0&V0.'E4&#F &"2#'+52='@"F "318'KW17$"1' X.".8.73&#P E17&'Y

@'C&22&4'2.'2=&' 6%$2.4#D'E=$8.#F .-=B'E4.G&##.4' H&#-."%# E17&'/ ?=12I#'$"':&&F 8.#JD'K<=&'L12&' M'N$O&P E17&'5

)**&+,-./$<=&' >&14'?$2=.32'@' :".)'A1B E17&'U

Q1#&R188',-&"#' :&1#."')$2=' :)&&-'.G 'S+T' Q1B8.4 E17&'+;

The Spire

''''''''Y

NEWS

February 22, 2019

:23%&"2'N.O&4"V&"2'@##.[$12$."':&"12&':&7V&"2 7+,6 :((. ,1 7+( 6*$ 6(1$7( :3RFZ.VV$22&&'M-%12&#'

&RQÃ&#x20AC; UPDWLRQ +HDULQJV

F5%!R;"!.4==011%%!6)8%!)#!(9/)1%!4#!15%!:4'C!15%*!5)8%!&%%#! /40#6!48%'!15%!9)21!:%%C!)#/!9'%2%#1%/!15%!R;"!294170651^!>(102=! >:)'%#%22A!F5%*!0#34'=%/!(2!43 !15%!6'%)1!:4'C!15)1!15%*!/4!)#/!)77!

43 !15%!%8%#12!15%*!5421A!F5%!;S@!6)8%!)#!(9/)1%!4#!:5)1!.7(&2!15%*!

6')#1%/!=4#%*!14!48%'!15%!9)21!:%%CA!F5%!;">@!(9/)1%/!(2!4#!15%0'! ?)'.5!?)/#%22!9(&!#0651!)#/!)!/'%22!/'08%!15)1!15%*!)'%!97)##0#6A!

7KH 6HQDWH FRQÃ&#x20AC; UPHG &D\OLH :KLWHVLGH ¶ DQG -RKQ /DUVHQ ¶ WR 547/!5065%'!9420104#2!0#!15%!%M%.(108%!&')#.5!/(%!14!.5)#6%2!0#!15%! .)&0#%1A!>31%'!7021%#0#6!14!15%0'!%M9%'0%#.%!)#/!.'%)108%!0/%)2-!15%!;%#D DWH ZDV FRQÃ&#x20AC; GHQW LQ WKHLU DELOLWLHV &RQJUDWXODWLRQV WR ERWK ;149!&*!V46)#!d+Q!4#!;(#/)*-!$%&'()'*!Gf15!34'!4('!#%M1!2%2204#!)1!

S P

Q$88# $4('!&0772!:%'%!9)22%/!1502!:%%C-!0#.7(/0#6!15%!0#1'4/(.104#!43 !)#!4#D .)=9(2!:0/%!'%3%'%#/)-!)!21(/*D):)*!70)024#-!15%!.4D9'%20/%#12!5)80#6!

29412!0#!15%!Y%2(01!;1(/%#1!<48%'#=%#1!>770)#.%-!)#/!0#84780#6!15%!

2IÃ&#x20AC; FH RI 6WXGHQW ,QYROYHPHQW

B,**'#$F<#($JKK$'2$."#$57<+'6$H99,'(2$:+#(=$49 $."#$%#-,.#D$:"#6=$<,6=$1##=+8$ IRU PRUH 6HQDWH VSHFLÃ&#x20AC; F XSGDWHV DQG LQLWLDWLYHV WR PDNH VWXGHQW OLIH HDVLHU RQ WKH L'++D$

! ( : < ! < M < 6' ZL@(N6

@"NF>@F!g;^ )))*G1[&R..^*[.V]LZ:&"12& !"#21741VD'c#71d=[#&"12& #71#&"12&c7*=.8B[4.##*&%3

0&V0.'E4&#&"2#'+52='@""318'KW17$"1'X.".8.73&#P .DWH 0F/DXJKOLQ ¶ 0#12$)3'.4( ! ! ! "#! $%&'()'*! +c! )#/! +f-! /4hD %#2! 43 ! 21(/%#12! 6)15%'%/! 0#! 15%!

V46)#! S)77'44=! 34'! V47*! @'422L! 2%8%#1%%#15! )##()7! 9%'34'=)#.%!

43 ! JF5%! i)60#)! ?4#4746(%2AP! 6SRQVRUHG E\ WKH 6*$ 2IÃ&#x20AC; FH RI B08%'201*-!R%7)104#2509!E%%'!]/(.)D 14'2-!)#/!V@!$%=0#021!$4'(=!)#/! /0'%.1%/! &*! W0hh0%! $7*##! U+Q! )#/! <').%! S('C%! UG+-! 15%! )77D3%=)7%!

254:!.4#2021%/!43 !+j!=4#4746(%2A! K#! 70%(! 43 ! 10.C%1! 9'0.%2-! /4#)104#2! :%'%! .477%.1%/! 34'! >&&*L2! V4(2%-!

D QRQSURÃ&#x20AC; W LQ :RUFHVWHU WKDW SUR 80/%2! 25%71%'-! )334'/)&7%! 54(20#6-! )#/! 2(994'1! 2%'80.%2! 14! 54=%7%22-! &)11%'%/-!)#/!74:D0#.4=%!:4=%#A ! ! ! JF5%! i)60#)! ?4#4746(%2P! :)2! :'011%#! &*! 97)*:'0651! )#/! ).108021! ]8%! ]#27%'-! :54! :'41%! 15%! 97)*!

0#! +QQe! 14! J.%7%&')1%! 15%! 8)60#)P! )#/! 14! 5%79! %#/! 8047%#.%! )6)0#21! :4=%#! )'4(#/! 15%! :4'7/A! ]#27%'! .4=907%/! 0#34'=)104#! 3'4=! 0#1%'D 80%:2!15)1!25%!.4#/(.1%/!:015!GHH! :4=%#!).'422!)!:0/%!29%.1'(=!43 ! )6%2-!').%2-!6%46')950%2-!)#/!2%M()7!

4'0%#1)104#2A! F5%! 90%.%2! %M974'%! .4#2%#2()7! )#/! #4#D.4#2%#2()7!

2%M-! 2%M! :4'C-! )#/! 21'(667%2! :015! &4/*! 0=)6%-! )=4#6! 415%'! '%7)1%/!

15%=%2A! K#! GHHe-! F5%! N%:! X4'C! F0=%2!.)77%/!15%!97)*!J9'4&)&7*!15%! =421! 0=94'1)#1! 90%.%! 43 ! 947010.)7!

15%)1%'!0#!15%!7)21!/%.)/%AP !!!F502!*%)'L2!JF5%!i)60#)!?4#4D 746(%2P!%M974'%/!)#!%Z()77*!/08%'2%!

2%1! 43 ! 15%=%2A! $'4=! 24954=4'%2!

>##%! S4'h#%'! )#/! ?0250%! ?).*L2! 14! 2149! 50/0#6! =%#21'()104#A! F5%! &415! 0#! 2(994'1! 43 ! )#/! 0#! 9'4D 94:%'3(7!J?*!i)60#)!T)2!?*!i07D 415%'! 1%210=4#0)72! kJF4! F%77! X4('! 1%21! 43 ! 15%! =4#4746(%2-! 34774:%/! ;14'*-P! :50.5! 15%! 254:L2! /%&(1A! "#%! )7(=! %8%#! /%90.12! 15%! ZURWH ´0\ Ã&#x20AC; UVW UHDFWLRQ ZDV GLVEH 74#6! )#/! 024D OLHI WKHQ RXWUDJH DQG Ã&#x20AC; QDOO\ YHU\ 7)10#6! 9'4.%22! /%%9! /02)9940#1=%#1A! K#! 294#24'D 43 ! '%94'10#6! 0#6-! 9(&70.0h0#6-! )#/! %#/4'20#6! ')9%! 14! V47*! 1502! 9'%2%#1)104#-! V47*! @'422! 5)2! @'422L! F017%! )&)#/4#%/! 012! '%9(1)104#! 34'! 5065! ,; 2IÃ&#x20AC; FH DQG 21)#/)'/2-!/%.%#.*-!)#/!8)7(%2!)#/!

JE0)#4! E7)*D 0#21%)/! 24(651! 14! I(2103*! 012! 2('D 0#6-P! :50.5! '%#/%'! 14! 15%! (#9'0#.097%/! U#%:! %M974'%2! )! .(71('%-LP! )..4'/0#6! 14! ]70h)&%15! *4(#6! 60'7L2! T)7C%'L2!;9'0#6!GHHG!90%.%!0#!F5%! Ã&#x20AC; UVW H[SHUL V47*!@'422!?)6)h0#%A %#.%2! :015! ! ! ! B%2901%! 1502! &%0#6! 15%! 2%8%#D 5"4.4$:47(.#28$49 $A'M$G#."#(2.4-$JKKD KHU VH[XDOLW\ 1%%#15! 01%')104#! 43 ! 15%! J?4#4D 0DJJLH &RQQROO\ ¶ SHUIRUPV LQ ´7KH 9DJLQD 0RQRORJXHV µ :%'%! 2(&=01D 746(%2P!)1!V47*!@'422-!.4D/0'%.14'!

1%/! )#4#*D W0hh0%! $7*##! 150#C2! 15)1! 15%*! 5)/!

7)6%P!k)!.4=907)104#!43 !1%210=4#0%2! =4(27*A! )! 9)'10.(7)'7*! 29%.0)7! =%)#0#6! 1502!

43 ! S42#0)#! :4=%#! 2(&I%.1%/! 14! !!!T5%#!JF5%!i)60#)!?4#4746(%2P! *%)'A! F5%! 254:! 144C! 97).%! 4#7*! )!

UDSH FDPSV WR VRSKRPRUHV $QQD ZHUH Ã&#x20AC; UVW $)#14hh0! )#/! @)*70%! T501%20/%L2! 9%'34' =%/!

507)'04(2! J?*! >#6'*! i)60#)P! k)! )1!

V47*! .4=%/0.! ')#1! )&4(1! 15%! 0#I(210.%2! @'422!

0#!

ZURXJKW DJDLQVW WKH YDJLQD WR VH GHHG-! 15%! #04'! ?Y! B0)4L2! 6(12*! 9'%2%#1)104#! @477%6%! '%D 43 !/033%'%#1!1*9%2!43 !2%M()7!=4)#D .%08%/!&).CD 0#6!0#!JF5%!T4=)#!T54!W48%/!14! 7)25! 3'4=! ?)C%! i)60#)2! V)99*-P! 15%! =4#4D 2 1 ( / % # 1 2!

746(%2! %70.01%/! )! 8)'0%1*! 43 ! '%).D )#/! )7(=#0!

104#2! 3'4=! 15%! )(/0%#.%DD')#60#6! :54! &%D 3'4=!1%)'2!14!5*21%'0.)7!7)(651%'A 70%8%/! 15)1! ! ! ! F5%! 9%'34'=)#.%! )724! 0#.7(/%/! 15%! =4#4D 15'%%! =4#4746(%2! 15)1! :%'%! 2(&D 746(%2! :%'%!

5"4.4$:47(.#28$49 $A'M$G#."#(2.4-$JKKD =011%/! )2! 1%210=4#0)72! 3'4=! 15%! 144! 8(76)'!

V47*! @'422! @4==(#01*A! Jg9! 15%! )#/! 0#)9D $QQH %RU]QHU ¶ DQG 0LVKLH 0DF\ ¶ SHUIRUP ´0\ 9DJLQD :DV XB'W$8817&*P ;7%%8%-P!:'011%#!)#/!9%'34'=%/!&*! 9 ' 4 9 ' 0 ) 1 %! >##0%! V%#12.5%7! U+Q-! 02! )! 290'01%/! 14! &%! 9%'D )#/!3(##*!%M)=0#)104#!43 !15%!2106D 34'=%/!)1!)!@)15470.!2.5447A!?)#*! :%%C!)31%'!cdH!V47*!@'422!21(/%#12! =)!2(''4(#/0#6!9%'04/2!)#/!)!.)77! 0=9)2204#%/! %=)072! )#/! 7%11%'2-! 5%7/! )! 1:4D/)*! J;01DK#P! 4(120/%! $$!"#$%&'(#$21(/%#1!#%:29)9%' !!!!@477%6%!43 !15%!V47*!@'422 !!!!E(&7025%/!:%%C7*!20#.%!+QGd E7%)2%!)//'%22!.4''%294#/%#.%!14^ $$$$!"#$%&'(# !!!!!EA"A!S4M!cG> !!!!!@477%6%!43 !15%!V47*!@'422 !!!!!+!@477%6%!;1'%%1 !!!!T4'.%21%'-!?>!H+e+HDGcQd

@88B#."'(.&"$[^`\'Q.RRB'<3aa$.\'b1[^$&'Z1""."'')3'.4(2E'-E:"'#9 $ &DUROLQH $KHDUQ (WKDQ %DFKDQG 6RÃ&#x20AC; D 0DLHWWD .DWH 0F/DXJKOLQ 0#12$)3'.4(2 ,8$O$1'E1"\'X177$&'Z."".88B\'L&"4B'(.&\'N41[&'X1""$"7\'HB&"'Z$"#^$\'<B8&4'Z=4$#2$1"#&"'F&'-'4-2$)32D 0DJJLH )ODKHUW\ %LDQFD 0LFFROLV .HOO\ *DOODJKHU %ULGJHW )ODKHUW\ /XNH :DOVK G#,.7(#2$)3'.4(2 @""$&'L&"2#[=&8\'X14$.'X$[188$G\':141=',IH.34^&\'Z=4$#':=1^&#-&14&\'b1[^#."':^&88&B')**&+,-.$)3'.4(2 Q$88B'0$2a-124$[^\'X177$&'081=&42B\'b1[^$&'L142\'E124$[^'?14&=1V''%&4(.2$)3'.4(2 (PLO\ .XOS %#-'4($:4&8$)3'.4( 6V1$8D'290'%a6A547*.'422A%/( +RSH *RRGPDQ 3DPHOD .RWH $QQD 0RUULV 6DUDK 2·5RXUNH 5HEHFFD 7UHGZHOO :4&8$)3'.4(2 ?&R#$2&D'5.290'%A.4= L3$'C$':"'#9 $5"4.4*(,&"#( .LP )HWKHUVWRQ -DNH %XFFL 'DYH\ 6XOOLYDQ =RH 3HWLW 5"4.4*(,&"#(2 %LDQFD 0LFFROLV 0DU\ .DWH &XQQLQJKDP (PLO\ 3HOOHJULQR C#<$)3'.4(2 !F4!)/8%'102%!0#$!"#$%&'(#/ E4.G&##.4':2&O&'W$"&R&47''G,67+.8$H3I'24( !!!]=)07^!!290'%a6A547*.'422A%/( 3KRQH

A&1"'X$[=&8&'X3441B$$G,67+.8$H3I'24( A&1"'Q4&"%1'L.3"#&88':388$O1"'G,67+.8$H3I'24(

E'%20/%#1!R%8A!E50709!WA!S4'4(652L! 2IÃ&#x20AC; FH WR SURWHVW ZKDW WKH\ FDOOHG 15%! @477%6%L2! 274:! )#/! (#2)1023).D 14'*!'%294#2%!14!)77%6%/!2%M()7!)2D 2)(71!)77%6)104#2!)6)0#21!E50742495*!

E'43%224'!@5'021495%'!>A!B(210#A! ! ! ! JK! 150#C! 15%! =4#4746(%2! :%'%! %M1'%=%7*! 0=94'1)#1! 1502! *%)'! 14! .4#10#(%!15%!.4#8%'2)104#2!4#!F017%! ,; DQG FRPLQJ WR WHUPV ZLWK ZKDW 15%!).1()7!.(71('%!43 !1502!.)=9(2!02-! )2!49942%/!14!:5)1!9%497%!150#C!01!

02A! <').%! )#/! K! :%'%! 15'077%/! :015!

15%!5065!1('#4(1!&415!#06512!43 !15%!

254:-!)#/!:%!150#C!15)1!15%!;01DK#! )#/! .(''%#1! .)=9(2! .70=)1%! :%'%!

5(6%!0#!6%110#6!9%497%!14!.4=%!14!)!

254:!15%*!=0651!#41!5)8%!)11%#/%/! #4'=)77*-P!$7*##!2)0/A !!!F5%!.)#/0/#%22!)#/!8(7#%')&0701*!

43 !15%!=4#4746(%2!)#/!1%210=4#0D )72!54#4'%/!&415!15%!/08%'2%!%M9%D '0%#.%2! 43 ! 21(/%#12! )1! V47*! @'422! )#/!15%!.4=&0#%/!%334'12!43 !1542%! )11%=910#6!14!&%11%'!:5)1!=)#*!2%%! )2!15%!14M0.!)#/!/)#6%'4(2!.(71('%!

2(''4(#/0#6!2%M()7!5)')22=%#1!)#/! )22)(71! 4#! .)=9(2A! $7*##! )//%/-!

JK1! :)2! 54#%217*! 2(''%)7! )1! 10=%2-! :)1.50#6! )77! 43 ! 15%2%! :4=%#! 9%'D 34'=A!>77!43 !15%=!:%'%!24!1)7%#1%/! )#/! 5)/! 24! =(.5! 9)2204#! 34'! 15%!

VKRZ 'LUHFWLQJ GHÃ&#x20AC; QLWHO\ FKDQJHG =*! 9%'29%.108%! 4#! 15%! 254:-! )#/!

5%79%/!=%!14!5)8%!)!&')#/!#%:!)9D 9'%.0)104#!34'!)77!43 !15%!90%.%2!V47*! @'422! 1*90.)77*! 0#.4'94')1%2! 0#14!

UF5%!i)60#)!?4#4746(%2-L!)#/!54:!

15%*!)77!97)*!0#14!)#/!&(07/!433 !43 !

4#%!)#415%'AP

! "#$%&'(# LV D QRQ SURÃ&#x20AC; W QRQ SDUWLVDQ VWXGHQW !

9(&70.)104#!43 !15%!@477%6%!43 !15%!V47*!@'422A! !"#$%&'(#!02!/021'0&(1%/!3'%%!43 !.5)'6%!14!)77!21(/%#12-!3).D (71*-!21)33-!)#/!%=974*%%2!43 !15%!0#2101(104#A !"#$%&'(#$:%7.4=%2!7%11%'2!)#/!49D%/2!3'4=!012! '%)/%'2A! E7%)2%! 0#.7(/%! *4('! #)=%-! )//'%22-! 1%7%954#%! #(=&%'-! )#/! %D=)07! )//'%22A! N4! 2(&=02204#2! :077! &%!

9'0#1%/! )#4#*=4(27*A! ! >77! 2(&=02204#2! =)*! &%! %/01%/!

34'!.4#1%#1-!)#/!=(21!&%!'%.%08%/!&*!15%!;(#/)*!9'04'!

14! 9(&70.)104#A! !"#$ %&'(#$ '%2%'8%2! 15%! '0651! #41! 14! 9(&D 7025!)#*!7%11%'!4'!.4#1%#1!/%%=%/!4&I%.104#)&7%!4'!:50.5! /4%2!#41!=%%1!15%!%/014'0)7!21)#/)'/2!43 !15%!#%:29)9%'A! W%11%'2!=)*!&%!=)07%/-!%D=)07%/-!4'!&'4(651!14!!"#$%&'(#$ RIÃ&#x20AC; FH LQ +RJDQ F5%!490#04#2!%M9'%22%/!:0150#!15%!#%:29)9%'!)'%!#41! #%.%22)'07*!1542%!43 !15%!@477%6%!43 !15%!V47*!@'422A!!F502! #%:29)9%'!02!9'0#1%/!&*!@4==(#01*!N%:29)9%'!@4=D 9)#*A!!R%9'4/(.104#!43 !)#*!9)'1!43 !1502!9)9%'!02!&*!9%'D =02204#!43 !!"#$%&'(#!4#7*A

NEWS

The Spire

February 22, 2019

Z.VV$22&&':&&^#'2.'@%%4&##'04&&%.V'.G ' 6`-4&##$."'."'Z1V-3# &DUROLQH $KHDUQ ¶ :"'#9 $0#12$)3'.4(!!! ! ! ! ;0#.%! 15%! 29'0#6! 43 ! GH+j-! V47*! @'422! 5)2! &%%#! :4'C0#6! 14! )/D /'%22! 15%! #%%/! 34'! )! .477%6%D:0/%!

25)'%/! 9507424950.)7! 21)1%=%#1!

4#! $'%%/4=! 43 ! ]M9'%2204#A! F502! #%%/! )'42%! 3'4=! )! '%294#2%! 14! .'02%2! =)#*! .477%6%2! )#/! (#08%'D 2010%2! :%'%! 3).0#6! '%6)'/0#6! .4#D 1'48%'20)7! 6(%21! 29%)C%'2-! 2(.5! )2!

15%! 9'41%212! )1! g@! S%'C%7%*! 48%'! )#! )99%)')#.%! &*! '0651D:0#6! .4=D =%#1)14'! ?074! X0)##49474(2A !!!K#010)7!:4'C!4#!15%!21)1%=%#1!&%6)#!

0#!7)1%!GH+j-!)#/!&*!15%!29'0#6!GH+,!

2%=%21%'! )! .4==011%%! 43 ! 3).(71*-!

21)33-!)#/!21(/%#12!:)2!34'=%/A!F5%! $'%%/4=! 43 ! ]M9'%2204#! @4==01D 1%%!02!.4D.5)0'%/!&*!i0.%!E'%20/%#1!

34'! ;1(/%#12! >33)0'2! )#/! B%)#! 43 ! ;1(/%#12!?0.5%7%!?('')*!)#/!B%)#!

34'!B08%'201*-!]Z(01*!)#/!K#.7(204#! >=01! F)#%I)A! "15%'! .4==011%%! =%=&%'2! 0#.7(/%! B4#)7/! S')#/-!

E'43%224'!43 !E47010.)7!;.0%#.%-!>/'0D )#!@).54!U+Q-!@4DE'%20/%#1!43 !15%! ;1(/%#1! <48%'#=%#1! >224.0)104#-! ?07%2!@)5077-!;9%)C%'!43 !15%!$).(71*! )#/!E'43%224'!43 !].4#4=0.2-!?%'D %/015! @4470/6%! U+Q-! @4DE'%20/%#1!

43 ! 15%! ;1(/%#1! <48%'#=%#1! >2D 24.0)104#-!>/%70#%!<(10%''%h!U+Q!43 !

15%! ;1(/%#1! <48%'#=%#1! >224.0)D 104#-! S'%#/)! V4(#2%77D;(7708)#! 43 !

WKH 2IÀFH RI 6WXGHQW ,QYROYHPHQW E)(7! K'025-! B%)#! 43 ! ;1(/%#1! >3D 3)0'2-! ?)'*&%15! \%)'#2! S)''%11! 43 !

WKH &KDSODLQ·V 2IÀFH 0DU\ 5RFKH E'43%224'! 43 ! R%70604(2! ;1(/0%2-! $'4=!:N@\!9)6%!+ 4&I%.108%2! 3'4=! :%77#%22! 14! 2)3%1*! .4#.%'#2-!2)*0#6!15)1!J>!.4(97%!43 !

022(%2! :%! )'%! '%)77*! 744C0#6! 14! 0=D 97%=%#1-! :015! 15%! $0%7/! V4(2%! %2D 9%.0)77*! :015! 15%! :547%! '%#48)104#!

9'4.%22-!l02m!=)C0#6!2('%!15)1!03 !:%! #%%/! 14! 9('.5)2%! #%:! %Z(09=%#1-! :%!/4!15)1!4'!=48%!/033%'%#1!%Z(09D =%#1! 14! /033%'%#1! 29).%2A! F5%'%L2! )724!)!741!43 !/44'2!)#/!5)77:)*2!4#! ])2*!;1'%%1!%29%.0)77*!15)1!5)8%!#4!

VZLSH IRU WKH PDOH ÁRRU VR PDNLQJ 2('%!:%!.)#!6%1!2:09%2!15%'%A!R%)77*! )#*150#6!15)1!9%497%!5)8%!4#!15%0'! =0#/2!:%!)'%!49%#!14-!:%L'%!744C0#6!

34':)'/! 14! 5%)'0#6! 3'4=! )2! =)#*!

>##!;5%%5*-!E'43%224'!43 !S04746*-! )#/! $'A! Y0=! ;14'=%2-! ;AYA-! E'43%2D 24'!43 !].4#4=0.2!)#/!>..4(#10#6A ! ! ! "#! $%&'()'*! +G-! B%)#! F)#%I)!

2%#1! )#! %=)07! 14! 15%! %#10'%! V47*! @'422! .4==(#01*! )##4(#.0#6!

WKH ÀUVW GUDIW RI WKH )UHHGRP RI ]M9'%2204#! ;1)1%=%#1-! :50.5! %=D 95)20h%2! 15%! @477%6%L2! J).)/%=0.! .4==(#01*! )#/! .477%.108%! 9('2(01!

3%%/&).C! 4#! 15%! /')31A! F5%2%! 702D 1%#0#6! 2%2204#2! 34774:! 15%! ;<>D VSRQVRUHG ÀVKERZO GLVFXVVLRQ 4#! $'%%/4=! 43 ! ]M9'%2204#A ! ! ! JT%! )'%! 97%)2%/! 14! 5)8%! '%D .%08%/! 24=%! 3%%/&).C! )&4(1! 15%! /')31! 21)1%=%#1! 80)! 15%! %=)07! )#/!

15'4(65! 15%! 0#010)7! 7021%#0#6! 2%2D 204#2-P! 2)0/! B%)#! ?('')*A! JF5%!

3%%/&).C! 012%73 ! 02! '%)22('0#6! 0#!

5"4.4$<8$L7'$N'$OKP C$#2&"$"7'#&##$."#')$88'$"[.4-.412&'2=&'O$&)#'.G '#23%&"2#\'G1[382B\'1"%'#21GG ')=&"' %41G2$"7'2=&'#=14&%'-=$8.#.-=$[18'#212&V&"2'."'04&&%.V'.G '6`-4&##$."*

43 ! C#4:7%/6%-! (#/%'21)#/0#6-! )#/!

1'(15-P! )2! :%77! )2! 15%! J8)7(%2! 43 !

3'%%/4=-! =(1()7! '%29%.1! )#/! .0D YLOLW\ µ 7KH VWDWHPHQW DIÀUPV WKH '0651! 43 ! .4==(#01*! =%=&%'2! 14! %#6)6%! 0#! 15%! 3'%%! %M.5)#6%! 43 !

0/%)2-! :507%! )6)0#! %=95)20h0#6!

15%! 0=94'1)#.%! 43 ! V47*! @'422L! ).)/%=0.! )#/! '%70604(2! 8)7(%2A ! ! ! >//0104#)77*-! F)#%I)L2! %=)07! )##4(#.%/! )! 2%'0%2! 43 ! 7021%#D 0#6! 2%2204#2! 34'! =%=&%'2! 43 ! 15%! .)=9(2! .4==(#01*! 14! 9'480/%!

15)1! #41! 4#7*! /4! 4('! .)=9(2! .4#D 2101(%#12! .)'%! )&4(1! 1502! 1490.-! &(1! )724! 15%*! )'%! 9'480/0#6! 154(6513(7!

3%%/&).C! '441%/! 0#! 4('! =02204#! )#/!:54!:%!)'%!)2!)#!0#2101(104#AP 7KH ÀUVW WZR OLVWHQLQJ VHVVLRQV 5%7/!4#!F5('2/)*-!$%&'()'*!+f!)#/!

F(%2/)*-!$%&'()'*!+Q-!:%'%!49%#!14! )77!21(/%#12-!3).(71*!)#/!21)33-!:507%!

15%! '%=)0#0#6! 15'%%! :077! &%! %M.7(D 208%! 14! %).5! '%29%.108%! 6'4(9A! F5%!

21)33D4#7*!2%2204#!:)2!5%7/!4#!$'0D /)*-!$%&'()'*!GG-!:507%!15%!3).(71*D

9%497%!)2!:%!.)#AP ! ! ! F5%! 2%.4#/! 1%)=! 14! 21%9! (9! 14!

15%!94/0(=!:)2!\)'0%!?)6740'%!)#/! ?)115%:!T473%-!:015!)!3'0%#/!2(&D 2101(10#6!0#!34'!?)11!/(%!14!502!.4=D 97%10#6!)!2%=%21%'!)&'4)/A!?)6740'%! /%708%'%/!)!50657*!%#%'6%10.!29%%.5-!

1%770#6!15%!214'*!43 !5%'!21'(667%2!4#!

15%!V077!:507%!)724!9'4=410#6!6'%)1D %'!%Z()701*!)#/!)..%91)#.%!)=4#621!

15%!V47*!@'422!.4==(#01*A ! ! ! @4==%#10#6! )31%':)'/2! 4#! 5%'!

9%'34'=)#.%-! \)'0%! 2)0/! JK! 150#C! 14#0651!:%#1!6'%)1A!K!150#C!15)1!%8D %'*150#6!:%!5)/!14!2)*!:)2!8%'*!:%77!

294C%#AP !!!K#!15%!2)=%!:)*!15)1!R%)7&(14!'%D

21)1%/!502!9420104#-!?)6740'%!433%'%/! )!/0'%.1!Z(41%!4#!5%'!)#/!5%'!'(#D #0#6!=)1%L2!9470.*!4&I%.108%2^!J"('! =)0#! 64)7! 02! .4==4#! 6'4(#/A! T%!

3%%7! )2! 03 ! .4==(#01*! 02! )! &06! 9)'1!

43 ! :54! :%! )'%! )1! V47*! @'422-! &(1! :%!5)8%#L1!'%)77*!&%%#!/40#6!=(.5! )&4(1! .4==(#01*A! K! (#/%'21)#/!

15)1!V47*!@'422!5)2!/4#%!)!741!34'!

4(120/%! :4'C-! &(1! :%! 5)8%#L1! &%%#! À[LQJ ZKDW LV ZURQJ ZLWK XV 2QH 43 !15%!150#62!15)1!:%!5)8%!#410.%/!

48%'!15%!*%)'2!02!15%!2%9)')104#!l0#! \0=&)77m! )#/! 54:! :%! )'%! )7:)*2!

9)0'%/! )6)0#21! %).5! 415%'! )#/! :%! /4#L1! 70C%! 15)1A! ;4! :%! 2)0/! 15)1! )2! .(''%#1! 7%)/%'2! :%! :4(7/! 70C%! 14!

4#7*! 2%2204#! :077! &%! 5%7/! ?4#/)*-! $%&'()'*!Gd!3'4=!fDd!9A=A!0#!V4D 6)#!cHd-!)#/! 15%!21(/%#1D4#7*!2%2D 204#!:077!&%!5%7/!T%/#%2/)*-!$%&'(D )'*!Gj!3'4=!eDj!9A=A!0#!V46)#!fH,A ! ! ! K#! )//0104#! 14! 15%! 7021%#0#6! 2%2D 204#2-! =%=&%'2! 43 ! 15%! $'%%/4=!

43 ! ]M9'%2204#! @4==011%%! :077! &%! =%%10#6!:015!2%8%')7!7%)/%'2509!)#/!

648%'#)#.%! 21'(.1('%2! ).'422! 15%! .)=9(2-! 2(.5! )2! 15%! ;1(/%#1! W03%! @4==011%%-!>.)/%=0.!<48%'#)#.%! @4(#.07-! E'%20/%#1L2! ]M1%#/%/! @)&0#%1-! ;1(/%#1! <48%'#=%#1! >2D 24.0)104#-!15%!?02204#!)#/!K/%#101*! @4==011%%-!>.)/%=0.!B%9)'1=%#1! @5)0'2-! F'(21%%2-! ?)#)6%=%#1!>/D 8024'*! <'4(9-! )#/! ;1(/%#1! >33)0'2!

B0'%.14'2-! 34'! )//0104#)7! 3%%/&).CA ! ! ! >1! 15%! .4#.7(204#! 43 ! 15%! '%D 80%:! 9'4.%22-! 15%! .4==011%%! %M9%.12! 14! &'0#6! )! '%802%/! 21)1%D =%#1! 34'! %#/4'2%=%#1! 14! 15%! ;<>! )#/! 15%! $).(71*! >22%=&7*! &%34'%! 15%! %#/! 43 ! 15%! 2%=%21%'A ! ! ! J"('! 549%! 02! 15)1! 21(/%#12-!

3).(71*! )#/! 21)33 ! :077! &'0#6! 15%0'! /08%'2%! 9%'29%.108%2! 14! 1502! .4#D 8%'2)104#A!F5%!.4==011%%!:077!.4#D 20/%'! )77! 3%%/&).C! .477%.1%/-! )#/! =)C%! .5)#6%2! )2! #%.%22)'*-P! 2)0/!

B%)#! F)#%I)A! J"('! 549%! 5)2! )7D :)*2!&%%#!34'!1502!14!&%!)!.)=9(2! :0/%! 25)'%/! 21)1%=%#1-! 24! :%! :077!

744C! 34'! )#! %#/4'2%=%#1! 43 ! 15%! '%802%/! 21)1%=%#1! 3'4=! 15%! ;<>! )#/! 15%! $).(71*! >22%=&7*! 14:)'/!

15%! %#/! 43 ! 15%! .(''%#1! 2%=%21%'AP

7%)/!&*!%M)=97%2A!?)11-!&%0#6!3'4=! )!/033%'%#1!20/%!43 !15%!.4==(#01*-! )#/!K-!&%0#6!3'4=!)!/033%'%#1!20/%!43 !

15%!.4==(#01*-!(2!.4=0#6!146%15%'!

02! I(21! 1'*0#6! 14! =)C%! 01! 4#%! V47*! @'422-!70C%!4('!2746)#AP !!!!F5%!'%21!43 !15%!#0651!2):!)!9)D ')/%! 43 ! 21(/%#12! '(##0#6! 34'! 15%! ;%#)1%!=)'.5!(9!14!15%!94/0(=!0#! )#!)11%=91!14!6)'#%'!2(994'1!3'4=!

1542%!0#!15%!)(/0%#.%!15)1!:%'%!21077!

OHIW :KLOH HQWKXVLDVP RQ WKH ÀUVW ÁRRU PD\ KDYH EHHQ ORZ WKHUH LV .%'1)0#7*! )#! %M.010#6! ').%! )5%)/! 0#!

15%!;<>A

Q.4.37=#'Z."2$"3&#':$2F!"'H&#-."#& 6RÀD 0DLHWWD ¶ 0#12$)3'.4( !!!"#!F(%2/)*-!$%&'()'*!+G-!$)15%'!

S4'4(652! 2%#1! 4(1! )! .)=9(2! :0/%! %=)07!0#!:50.5!5%!4(170#%/!15%!@47D 7%6%L2!97)#2!34'!012!U@)=9(2!@70=)1%! >.104#! ;1%92AL! $0'21-! 5%! =%#104#%/!

15)1! =%=&%'2509! 34'! 1:4! 6'4(92-!

15%!B08%'201*-!]Z(01*!)#/!K#.7(204#!

E7)##0#6!<'4(9!)#/!15%!;%M()7!R%D 29%.1!)#/!@4#/(.1!E7)##0#6!<'4(9!

KDV EHHQ ÀQDOL]HG DQG WKDW SODQV :077! &%! 2(&=011%/! &*! &415! 6'4(92! #4! 7)1%'! 15)#! >9'07! +dA! >11).5%/!

0#!15%!%=)07!)'%!70#C2!14!)!9)6%!4#!

15%! V47*! @'422! :%&201%! 34'! &415!

6'4(92-! :50.5! 0#.7(/%2! 15%0'! =)#D /)1%2! )#/! )! 3(77! 7021! 43 ! 15%0'! =%=D &%'2509A!F502!02!9)'1!43 !)!7)'6%'!:%&!

9)6%! 15)1! V47*! @'422! 7)(#.5%/! 4#! $%&'()'*! +G! :50.5! 4(170#%2! 15%! ).104#! 21%92! 15%! @477%6%! 02! 1)C0#6! '%7)1%/! 14! .)=9(2! .70=)1%A! $)15%'!

S4'4(652! )724! )##4(#.%/! 15)1! &*! ?)'.5! +-! 5%! :077! 2%#/! 15%! .477%6%! .4==(#01*!502!#%M1!(9/)1%!'%6)'/D 0#6!15%!'%80%:!43 !15%!@477%6%L2!.70D =)1%-!21'(.1('%2-!)#/!9470.0%2!:50.5! )'%!(#/%'!15%!/0'%.104#!43 !E507!@)1D )#h)#4!43 !V477)#/![!\#0651A! ! ! ! T015! '%6)'/2! 14! 2%M()7! =02.4#D /(.1!9470.*!)#/!9'4.%/('%2-!$)15%'!

S4'4(652! 21)1%/! 15)1! )! '%80%:! :077! &%60#! 7)1%'! 1502! =4#15A! V%! 21)1%/!

15)1! 15%! '%80%:! JAAA:077! &%! .44'/0D #)1%/! &*! )! .4==011%%! 43 ! 3).(71*-!

21(/%#12!)#/! )/=0#021')14'2-! :4'CD 0#6! :015! )#! %M1%'#)7! %M9%'1AP! V%! )724! =%#104#%/! 15)1! 5%! :4(7/! &%!

JAAA:4'C0#6! :015! E'43%224'! ?07%2! @)5077-! ;9%)C%'! 43 ! 15%! $).(71*-! 14! %#2('%!15)1!15%!:4'C!43 !15%!)/!54.! .4==011%%!%21)&7025%/!&*!15%!>.)D /%=0.! <48%'#)#.%! @4(#.07! 02! 0#D .7(/%/!0#!1502!'%80%:AP ! ! ! ! $)15%'! S4'4(652! .4#10#(%/-!

JE'48421! $'%0I%! :077! )2C! 15%! ><@!

)#/!15%!)/!54.!.4==011%%!14!.4#D 20/%'! Z(%2104#2! '%6)'/0#6! 0#1%'0=! =%)2('%2!14!&%!9(1!0#!97).%!9%#/0#6! )#!0#8%2106)104#!43 !)!3).(71*!=%=D &%'! )#/! 2)#.104#2! 15)1! )'%! )99'4D 9'0)1%! 34'! 3).(71*! =%=&%'2! 34(#/! '%294#20&7%! 34'! 8047)104#! 43 ! 4('!

2%M()7!=02.4#/(.1!4'!/02.'0=0#)14D '*!5)')22=%#1!9470.0%2A!;5%!4(170#%/!

1502!21%9!)#/!415%'2!0#!)#!%=)07!14!

3).(71*! *%21%'/)*AP! >! 70#C! 14! 5%'! %=)07! :)2! 0#.7(/%/! 0#! $)15%'! S4'D 4(652L!4:#!%=)07A!K1!5)2!20#.%!&%%#!

(974)/%/!14!15%!V47*!@'422!:%&201%! (#/%'!15%!@)=9(2!@70=)1%!9)6%A! ! ! ! ?%=&%'2! 43 ! 15%! )/=0#021')104#! )#/!21(/%#1!&4/*!)'%!)724!:4'C0#6!

146%15%'! 0#! 4'/%'! 14! 20=9703*! 54:!

15%! ;%M()7! ?02.4#/(.1! E470.*! )9D 9%)'2!4#70#%A!>//0104#)77*-!)77!3).(7D 1*!)#/!21)33 !:077!'%.%08%!=)#/)14'*!

0#D9%'24#!1')0#0#6!1502!2%=%21%'!'%D 6)'/0#6! 2%M()7! )#/! /02.'0=0#)14'*!

5)')22=%#1A!;1(/%#12!:077!)724!5)8%!

15%!49104#!14!)11%#/!20=07)'!1')0#0#6!

2%2204#2A! ! ! ! R%6)'/0#6! 15%! '%.%#1! 201D0#! 5%7/!

RXWVLGH KLV RIÀFH IURP )HEUXDU\ fDd-! $)15%'! S4'4(652! =%#104#%/!

15)1! =%=&%'2! 43 ! 15%! ]M%.(108%!

F%)=! )'%! /02.(220#6! .4==(#0.)D 104#! )#/! /02.742('%! 022(%2! '%7)10#6!

14! 9'%2%#1! )#/! 9)21! 0#8%2106)104#2! :015!21(/%#1!7%)/%'2!43 !15%!201D0#A! ! ! ! F5%! )/=0#021')104#! 02! 97)##0#6!

14! 9421! )! $>_! 4#! 15%! #%:! :%&D 201%! )&4(1! Z(%2104#2! '%.%08%/! 3'4=!

21(/%#1!7%)/%'2!)2!:%77A!$0#)77*-!$)D 15%'!S4'4(652!9'480/%/!)#!(9/)1%!

4#!15%!.)=9(2!.70=)1%!2('8%*2!34'!

21(/%#12-! 21)33-! )#/! 3).(71*-! :50.5! :077!&%!'%7%)2%/!(94#!15%!'%1('#!43 !

15%! .)=9(2! .4==(#01*! 3'4=! 15%! ?)'.5!&'%)CA

3

<L@<I:' (6?:'<,' X6 0#12$%.4('#2$9(4M$ H(47-3$."#$C4(+3 62=1"'Q1[=1"%'IYY 0#12$)3'.4( :1234%1B\'0&R*'+e :2*' E&2&4#R347\' H3##$1D! F502!

9)21! :%%C%#/-! )! &(07/0#6! 0#! ;1A! E%1%'2&('6! .477)92%/-! 9'4=910#6! )! 2%)'.5! )#/! '%2.(%! 49%')104#A! ]0651*D20M!9%497%!5)/!9'%804(27*! &%%#! %8).()1%/! &%34'%! 15%! .47D 7)92%-! )#/! %=%'6%#.*! 2%'80.%2!

34(#/!#4!&4/0%2!(#/%'!15%!'(&D &7%A !

E.42F13FE4$"[&\' L1$2$D! B(%! 14!

8047%#1!21'%%1!9'41%212!15)1!.4(7/!

15'%)1%#!15%!708%2!43 !14('0212-!++c!

802014'2!5)8%!&%%#!%8).()1%/!)2!)!

2)3%1*! 9'%.)(104#A! F5%! /%=4#D 21')104#2! )'%! )#10D648%'#=%#1! 0#! #)1('%-! 0#.7(/0#6! =)'.5%2! )#/!

VHWWLQJ FDUV RQ ÀUH :3"%1B\'0&R*'+5 ! (&)'A&8=$\'!"%$1D!"#%!/)*!)3D 1%'! 012! 7)(#.5-! 15%! i)#/%! S5)')1! ]M9'%22! &'4C%! /4:#A! F5%! 1')0#!

5)2! )! 149! 29%%/! 43 ! +HH! =95-! =)C0#6! 01! K#/0)L2! 3)21%21! 1')0#A! F5%! 5065! 29%%/! 5%79%/! 254'1%#!

15%!1'09!3'4=!N%!B%760!14!i)')D #)20!&*!15'%%!54(''2AA X."%1B\'0&R*'+U !

Z1"R&441\'@3#2418$1D'$4774:0#6! )!.*&%')11).C!)6)0#21!15%!>(21')D 70)#! 9)'70)=%#1! 4#! $%&'()'*! ,-!

E'0=%! ?0#021%'! ;.411! ?4''024#! '%94'1%/! 15)1! 15%! .4(#1'*! &%D 70%8%/! )! 34'%06#! #)104#! :)2! &%D 50#/!15%!)11).CA!F502!#%:2!.4=%2! )1! )! .'010.)7! 10=%! 4#! 15%! 674&)7!

21)6%-!:015!.*&%'2%.('01*!&%.4=D 0#6!=4'%!43 !)!.4#.%'#!%).5!)#/! %8%'*!/)*A <3&#%1B\'0&R*'+9 !

E14$#\' 041"[&D' $4774:0#6! 15%!

8)#/)702=!43 !)!Y%:025!@%=%1%'*-!

154(2)#/2!43 !9%497%!6)15%'%/!14!

254:!2(994'1!34'!15%!74.)7!Y%:025! @4==(#01*A!F5%!')77*!:)2!4'6)D #0h%/! &*! 947010.0)#2! 0#! )#! %334'1!

14!.4=&)1!)#10D;%=0102=A !

A14' 6#' :1811V\' <1"a1"$1D! >! @50#%2%! &(20#%22! :4=)#! :)2!

2%#1%#.%/!14!+d!*%)'2!43 !I)07!34'!

15%!2=(6670#6!43 !%7%95)#1!1(2C2!

0#14!>20)A!"8%'!15%!.4('2%!43 !5%'!

U.)'%%'-L! 15%! :4=)#! 1')#294'1%/!

15%!1(2C!43 !48%'!cdH!%7%95)#12A

Q-94(M,.'4-$647(.#28$49 $."#$0#1$R4(=$ !'M#2S$ ."#$ C,++$ %.(##.$ T47(-,+S$ ,-3$ :00D

The Spire

!!"

!"#$#%$&

OPINIONS

February 22, 2019

!""#$%&'#('%")#!'*+",'-#.)"#/%0,10,2# .)3*,+#4&56*-777

?)<,--,+)-%)-(,)@0#-%+&A) B(#4%&%"(=)B+%C,&&%+)1,&"%$0& <*++=)>*(%%$, 9)3:"--3)#&,+#;3)5")#4%&0)5&,#3: # 9%0<3-36%= !!N4-<!&<40!,-!&!.4(($<$!5&+!&=&90! &! 5$7&($! 628/$-2! 24(/! 7$! 2%&2! %$+!

O%,(464*%9! *+45$664+! =&6! *8+681 ,-<! %$+! +47&-2,.&((90! $'$-! 6%4=1 ,-<! 8*! &2! %$+! *&+212,7$! G4>:! B! 24(/! %$+! B! =48(/! %$(*! %$+! /4! =%&2$'$+!

6%$!=&-2$/0!(,3$!,-,2,&2,-<!&!54+7&(! ,-'$62,<&2,4-:!A82!6%$!6&,/!6%$!G862! =&-2$/!-$'$+!24!6$$!%,7!&<&,-:!E4!

B! /,/! &! /,+$.2$/! +$&/,-<6! =,2%! %$+! ,-!2%$!6&7$!68>G$.2!$-&>(,-<!%$+!24! /+4*!%,6!.48+6$:!B2!/,/!-42!.%&-<$!

2%$! =4+(/0! >82! ,2! =&6! =%&2! 6%$! =&-2$/:!J-/!,-!79!*+45$66,4-0!79!

628/$-26!&+$!79!6$.4-/!*+,4+,29: ! ! ! P9! 2%,+/! *+,4+,29! ,6! 79! .41 =4+3$+6:! B-! E*+,-<! QRST! &! 628/$-2!

EURXJKW D 7LWOH ,; FKDUJH DJDLQVW D O+45$664+:! U?$+$&52$+! D2%$! O+45$61 VRU µ , KDYH EHHQ WROG , FDQ·W XVH -&7$6! $'$-! ,5 ! 2%$9! %&'$! &(+$&/9!

EHHQ PDGH SXEOLF 7KH 3URIHVVRU =&6!+&,6$/!24!&-!&/7,-,62+&2,'$!*462:!

7KH 7LWOH ,; LQYHVWLJDWLRQ ZHQW 4-! 54+! QR! 74-2%60! /8+,-<! =%,.%! %$! .4-2,-8$/! 24! 2$&.%! &! +$/8.$/!

6.%$/8($!UB!=&6!24(/!<$-/$+$/!*+41 QRXQV DUH RND\ 7KH LQYHVWLJDWLRQ 548-/!%,7!.8(*&>($!&-/!,-!E$*2$71 >$+!QRSV!%$!=&6!+$74'$/!5+47!2%&2! *4620! *82! 4-! &! 4-$! 6$7$62$+! ($&'$!

UE*+,-<!QRSWX0!&-/!*+4%,>,2$/!5+47!

DGYLVLQJ LQGHSHQGHQW VWXG\ 7KDW LV %4=!2%,-<6!6244/!54+!548+!74-2%6: 7KHQ RQ 7KXUVGD\ -DQXDU\ #4+.$62$+! P&<&C,-$! *8>(,6%$/! &-!

DUWLFOH RQ WKH FDVH 7KH MRXUQDOLVW .4--$.2$/! 2%,6! 624+9! =,2%! 2%&2! 45 !

F&7$6! I%+,62,$0! &..86$/! 45 ! %&',-<!

6$)8&(! +$(&2,4-6! =,2%! 78(2,*($! 781 VLF VWXGHQWV 7KH DUWLFOH FODLPHG 2%$!O+45$664+!=&6!&..86$/!45 !6$)81 &(,C$/! .4-'$+6&2,4-60! <,',-<! <,5260!

7&3,-<! ,-&**+4*+,&2$! .477$-260!

VXJJHVWLQJ ´GULQNVµ DQG ´GDWHV µ &-/! 2%$+$>9! 7&3,-<! 2%$! 628/$-2! '$+9!8-.4754+2&>($!&-/!,-2$+5$+,-<! =,2%!%$+!&.&/$7,.!=4+3: ! J! .&6.&/$! 45 ! $'$-26! 54((4=$/:!

1H[W 7XHVGD\ WKH $FDGHPLF *RY1 $+-&-.$! I48-.,(! &--48-.$/! 2%$!

54+7&2,4-! 45 ! &! 68>.477,22$$! 24! &//+$66! 2%$! *+45$664+@6! D+$*+$%$-1 VLEOHµ DFWV +XQGUHGV RI SRVWHUV &**$&+$/! ,-! E2$,-! /,+$.2,-<! 6281 GHQWV WR ´*RRJOH 3URIHVVRU 6H[XDO 0LVFRQGXFW µ 7KDW HYHQLQJ WKH 3UHVLGHQW SXW KLP RQ LQGHÀQLWH ($&'$0!6$'$+,-<!%,7!5+47!&((!.4-2&.2! =,2%! ?4(9! I+466! 628/$-26! 4+! *$+1 64--$(0! *+$6$-2! 4+! *&620! *$-/,-<!

LQYHVWLJDWLRQ RI ´QHZ DOOHJDWLRQV µ P4+$! *462$+6! =$+$! *82! 8*! &22&.31 ,-<! 2%$! O+$6,/$-2@6! /$.,6,4-! &6! ,-1 &/$M8&2$:!Y$>+8&+9!"!24!Z!/$74-1 62+&24+6! .&(($/! 54+! 2%$! O+45$664+@6!

VXPPDU\ ÀULQJ DQG UHYRFDWLRQ 45 ! %,6! /$.&/$14(/! 2$&.%,-<! &=&+/:!

E28/$-26! =%4! %&/! -$'$+! 7$2! %,7!

FDOOHG D ´SUHGDWRUµ DQG D ´PRQ1 VWHU µ 5HPHPEHU QR VWXGHQWV RU 5&.8(29! .48(/! %&'$! &-9! 3-4=($/<$!

24!68**4+2!2%$6$!G8/<7$-26!$).$*2!

2%$!&+2,.($:![$2&,(6!45 !2%$!.47*($21 $/!,-'$62,<&2,4-!&-/!2%$!8-,-'$62,1 JDWHG ´QHZ DOOHJDWLRQVµ DUH FRQÀ1

/$-2,&(:! /HW·V EH FOHDU LQGHÀQLWH OHDYH 7$&-6! 2%&2! 2%$! O+45$664+! ,6! >$1 LQJ ÀUHG MXVW QRW ÀUHG DOO DW RQFH 7KH VXPPDU\ ÀULQJ RI D WHQXUHG *+45$664+! 4-! 2%$! >&6,6! 45 ! .%&+<$6!

2%&2! %&'$! -42! >$$-! 58((9! ,-'$62,1 <&2$/! ,6! &-2,2%$2,.&(! 24! *+,-.,*($6!

45 !/8$!*+4.$66!&-/!=48(/!(,3$(9!>$! ,(($<&(:! A82! =%9! &((! 2%,6! 5866! &>482! ÀULQJ WHQXUHG SURIHVVRUV" %HFDXVH LI WHQXUHG SURIHVVRUV FDQ EH ÀUHG 4+!686*$-/$/!=,2%482!/8$!*+4.$660! &-94-$! .&-! >$:! B-! 2%,6! .&6$! 2%$+$!

ZDV GXH SURFHVV ZKHQ WKH 7LWOH ,; LQYHVWLJDWRUV KDG WKH DFFXVHU &..86$/0!5&.260!&-/!=,2-$66!/$*46,1 WLRQV LQ IURQW RI WKHP 7KH\ MXGJHG 2%$!O+45$664+@6!&.26!-42!24!=&++&-2!

2$+7,-&2,4-:! !!!\4=!B!%&'$!647$!M8$62,4-6:!B6!

WKH SXEOLVKHG DUWLFOH WUXH" 6HYHUDO =47$-!2&-<$-2,&((9!,-'4('$/!,-!2%$! ,-'$62,<&2,4-! %&'$! =+,22$-! ($22$+6!

62&2,-<! 2%&2! 2%$! &+2,.($! ,6! &2! ($&62!

PLVOHDGLQJ 7KLV LV QRW D UHÁHFWLRQ 4-!2%$!&..86,-<!628/$-2H!+$7$7>$+!

2%$! &+2,.($! =&6! =+,22$-! >9! &! G48+1 -&(,62:! ! B! 796$(5 ! %&'$! -4! *$+64-&(!

3-4=($/<$!$,2%$+!=&9:!A82!68**46$! $'$+92%,-<!,-!2%$!&+2,.($!,6!&..8+&2$:!

7KDW ZRXOG PHDQ WKH SURIHVVRU =&6!-$'$+!&..86$/!45 !*+4*46,2,4-1 ,-<! 2%$! 628/$-20! 45 ! 248.%,-<0! 4+!

2+&/,-<! <+&/$6! 54+! 6$)8&(! 5&'4+6:! ,I ´GULQNVµ DQG ´GDWHVµ ZHUH GLV1 FXVVHG WKH\ QHYHU KDSSHQHG 7KLV /4$6! -42! 7$&-! 2%$! O+45$664+! /,/!

-42! >+$&3! 48+! +8($6! 4+! %&+7! 2%$!

LQWHUHVWV RI WKH VWXGHQW 7KH 7LWOH

,; LQYHVWLJDWLRQ DOUHDG\ IRXQG WKDW %$!/,/:!A82!647$!5$$(!2%$!=&6!*8-1 ,6%7$-2! 5&+! 244! =$&30! &-/! .&((! %,6! .4-2,-8,-<!24!2$&.%!=%,($!>$,-<!,-1 YHVWLJDWHG ´KRUULI\LQJ µ :HOO ZKDW ,6! 2%$! +,<%2! *8-,6%7$-2! 54+! =%&2! %$!/,/!]!-42!2%$!*+$/&24+!I%+,62,$0!

-42! 2%$! 7,6.+$&-2! =%4! *8-.%$/! &!

628/$-2!(&62!Y&((!]!>82!2%,6!O+45$61 VRU" ,W LV SRVVLEOH WKDW WKH PDJD]LQH DUWLFOH FDXVHG ´QHZ DOOHJDWLRQVµ WR &+,6$!]!,2!.$+2&,-(9!.&86$/!*&62!6281 /$-26! 24! .47$! 54+=&+/! 24! /$5$-/!

2%$!O+45$664+!]!>82!&+$!2%$!-$=!&(1 ($<&2,4-6!45 !&!.%&+&.2$+!2%&2!G862,59!

686*$-6,4-! >$54+$! >$,-<! ,-'$62,1 JDWHG" , KDYH EHHQ WROG E\ IDFXOW\ 2%&2!2%$!/$<+$$!45 !',4(&2,4-!,6!,71 *466,>($!24!&/G8/,.&2$!&-/!64!/4$6!

-42!7&22$+:!#48(/!&-94-$!(,3$!2%&2!

62&-/&+/!&**(,$/!24!%,6!4+!%$+!4=-!

FDVH" 6LPSO\ SXW DUH ZH VD\LQJ WKDW &-9! 5&.8(290! 62&550! 4+! 628/$-20! &.1 FXVHG RI DQ\ 7LWOH ,; YLRODWLRQ RI &-9! 6$'$+,290! 6%48(/! >$! 686*$-/$/!

EHIRUH DQ\ LQYHVWLJDWLRQ" ! ! ^-! 2%$! Y+,/&9! &52$+! 2%$! /$71 4-62+&2,4-! $-/$/0! &-42%$+! 2$-8+$/!

O+45$664+!68//$-(9!.&7$!24!>$!4-!

OHDYH QRW ´SXWµ RQ OHDYH , ZDV LQ1 62+8.2$/X:!?$!=&6!+$M8,+$/!24!',6,2! ?87&-! L$648+.$6! 8-/$+! $6.4+20!

3$*2! 5&+! 5+47! 628/$-260! 2%$-! $)1 *$(($/!5+47!.&7*86!&-/!54+>,//$-!

24! .4-2&.2! ?4(9! I+466! *$+64--$(!

RU VWXGHQWV SDVW RU SUHVHQW 7KH SDWWHUQ RI WKHVH ´GLVDSSHDULQJVµ ,6! -4=! >$.47,-<! .($&+_! 6877&+9! +$74'&(! &-/! 686*$-6,4-H! -4! 4-$! ,-! 2%$! .4778-,29! 7&9! 3-4=! 2%$!

*+$.,6$!.%&+<$6H!2%$!/,6&**$&+$/!,6! *+4%,>,2$/!5+47!.4-2&.2,-<!&-94-$! &2!?4(9!I+466H!&-/!&-9!*8>,.!6$(51 /$5$-6$!>9!2%$!&..86$/!,6!&!-$=!451 IHQFH D ´UHWDOLDWLRQµ RU D YLRODWLRQ RI FRQÀGHQWLDOLW\ <RX FDQ *RRJOH I&2.%1QQ:X !!!B2!,6!%&+/!24!&'4,/!2%$!.4-.(86,4-!

WKDW WKH $*&·V GHFLVLRQ WKH SRVW1 $+60! 2%$! O+$6,/$-2@6! /$.,6,4-0! &-/!

2%$!/$74-62+&2,4-!=$+$!-42!.&86$/!

E\ WKH 7LWOH ,; LQYHVWLJDWLRQ QRU E\ 5&.8(29!4+!628/$-2!/$(,>$+&2,4-0!-4+! >9!-$=!.%&+<$6!4+!$'$-!2%$!4+,<,-&(!

WZR \HDU ROG FRPSODLQW 7KH\ DUH 2%$!+$68(2!45 !&!624+9!&**$&+,-<!,-!&!

PDJD]LQH 7KDW LV SXEOLFLW\ :KLFK OHDGV WR P\ ÀQDO TXHV1 2,4-:! [4! =$! =&-2! 24! %&'$! +8($6! &-/! *+4.$/8+$6! >9! =%,.%! 5&.8(290!

62&550!&-/!628/$-26!%4(/!$&.%!42%$+! &..48-2&>($0! *+42$.2! 2%$76$('$6!

5+47! 6$)8&(! 7,62+$&27$-2! &-/!

IURP SXEOLF YLOLÀFDWLRQ WUHDWLQJ DFFXVHUV DQG DFFXVHG ZLWK UHVSHFW" 7KDW PLJKW EH FDOOHG ´MXVWLFH µ -XV1 2,.$! ,6! .4--$.2$/! =,2%! 6$$3,-<! 2%$!

WUXWK ZKLFK KDSSHQV WR EH P\ ÀUVW *+,4+,29!]!$'$-!&>4'$!79!628/$-26@! ,-2$+$6260! >$.&86$! 2+82%16$$3,-<! ,6! =%&2!2%$9!-$$/!5+47!7$:!E40!6%&((! =$! %&'$! &! 6962$7! >&6$/! 4-! 2+82%1 VHHNLQJ LQVWHDG RI UXPRU" 2U GR =$!=&-2!24!2&3$!&-42%$+!62$*!/4=-!

2%$! +4&/! 24=&+/! >$.47,-<! K'1 HUJUHHQ 6WDWH &ROOHJH" <RX FDQ *RRJOH WKDW WRR

N&++9!I&%44-$ O+45$664+! &-/! Y4+7$+! I%&,+7&-!

45 !O%,(464*%9

'(%)*+,)',)-%).,/#0,)'(%)(*&)-(,) 1#2(-)-%)3*456 !!!

7+*/,)8*$$#$2)9:; (60,03,-#8+0'3)#

! ! #$! %&'$! &((! $)*$+,$-.$/0! *&+1 2&3$-! ,-0! 4+! %$&+/! 45 ! /,6.+,7,-&1 2,4-! ,-! 48+! 64.,$29! 24/&9:! ;-54+1 28-&2$(90! ,2! ,6! 647$2%,-<! 2%&2! 62,((! '$+9!78.%!$),626!&-/!,6!+$($'&-2!24! $'$+94-$0! =%$2%$+! =%,2$0! >(&.3! 4+! &-9! 42%$+! $2%-,.,29:! ?4=$'$+0! =$! &+$-@2! &6! 5&7,(,&+! =,2%! /,6.+,7,-&1 2,4-!24=&+/6!=%,2$!*$4*($!&6!=$!&+$! =,2%! /,6.+,7,-&2,4-! 24=&+/6! >(&.3! *$4*($:!A(&.3!*$4*($!%&'$!&!%,624+9!

45 ! >$,-<! ,-62,282,4-&((9! /,6.+,7,1 -&2$/! &<&,-62! 54+! -42%,-<! $).$*2!

2%$!.4(4+!45 !2%$,+!63,-:!A82!B!+$&/! &-! $)2+$7$(9! .4-2+4'$+6,&(! 4*,-1 ,4-!*,$.$!2%&2!B!=&6!54+=&+/$/!2%$!

42%$+! /&9! 2%&2! 4*$-$/! 79! $9$6! 24! <$-$+&(,C&2,4-!&6!&!=%4($!&-/!24!2%$!

5&.2!2%&2!79!8-/$+62&-/,-<!45 !=%&2!

2%$6$!,668$6!&+$!&-/!=%4!2%$9!+$5$+!

WR PD\ EH ÁDZHG DQG VNHZHG 7KLV &+2,.($! =&6! &! +$&.2,4-! 24! 2%&2! 45 ! &! .4(($<$!628/$-2!=%4!=+42$!&!*,$.$! $-2,2($/! DE%48(/! #%,2$! A496! E2,((!

EH $OORZHG WR 7DON"µ DQG GHVFULEHG 2%$! -&28+$! 45 ! 2%$! &+2,.($! ,-! =%,.%!

2%$! &82%4+! 62+4-<(9! 68<<$62$/! 2%&2! =%,2$!7&($6!=,2%!-&7$6!(,3$!DF&3$0!

RU &KDG RU $OH[µ VKRXOGQ·W EH DO1

(4=$/!24!$)*+$66!2%$,+!4*,-,4-6!&6!

2%$9!&+$!244!*+,',($<$/!&-/!-&++4=1 7,-/$/:! #%,($! B! .&-! 8-/$+62&-/!

2%$!&82%4+@6!$)*$+,$-.$6!5$$(,-<!8-1 /$++$*+$6$-2$/! &-/! 452$-! 8-%$&+/! ,-! %$+! .4(($<$! .(&66+44760! B! 548-/! %$+!&+<87$-2!24!>$!*44+(9!5+&7$/:!

B!/4!>$(,$'$!=$!.&-!($&+-!5+47!=%&2!

6%$!,6!2+9,-<!24!6&90!%4=$'$+0!,-62$&/!

45 ! ($&+-,-<0! B! =&6! 4'$+=%$(7$/! >9! %$+! &-2&<4-,62,.! (&-<8&<$:! E%$! ,6-@2! $)*+$66,-<! &! ($&+-$/! 4*,-,4-! >&6$/! 4-! +$6$&+.%! 4+! 7&-9! /,51 5$+$-2! *$+6*$.2,'$60! >82! 2&3,-<! %$+! 4=-! $)*$+,$-.$! &-/! <$-$+&(1 ,C,-<! ,2! &6! >$,-<! 2+8$! 45 ! $'$+94-$:! !!!!!#%,($!B!2+8(9!>$(,$'$!2%&2!*+$G1 8/,.$! &-/! /,6.+,7,-&2,4-! ,6! 62,((! &! %8<$! *+4>($7! ,-! 48+! 64.,$290! &-/! =%,($!2%$!&82%4+!7&9!%&'$!%&/!$)1 *$+,$-.$6!=,2%!=%,2$!7$-!2%&2!*+41 '43$/! 2%,6! 3,-/! 45 ! &-<$+! &-/! %&1 2+$/0!B!/4-@2!>$(,$'$!2%$!.4++$.2!=&9!

24! &//+$66! ,2! ,6! 2%+48<%! &22&.3,-<! <+48*6!45 !*$4*($!<$-$+&(,C$/!>&6$/!

4-!2%$,+!-&7$6!4+!2%$!=&9!,-!=%,.%!

WKH\ ZHUH UDLVHG 7KHVH JHQHUDO1 ,C&2,4-6! &+$! 6,7,(&+! 24! 7&3,-<! &61 687*2,4-6! &>482! *$4*($! >&6$/! 4-!

2%$! .4(4+! 45 ! 2%$,+! 63,-:! #+,2,-<! &6! &!>(&.3!=47&-!>82!6*$=,-<!62$+$41 29*$6!45 !=%,2$!.4(($<$!7$-!6%48(/!

>$! +$.4<-,C$/! &-/! .4-6,/$+$/! 24! >$!=+4-<0!G862!&6!=+,2,-<!&6!&!=%,2$!

7&-!&-/!<$-$+&(,C,-<!>(&.3!=47$-! &6! &! =%4($! 6%48(/! >$! .4-6,/$+$/! =+4-<:! A42%! &+$! ,-%$+$-2(9! >,<1 42$/0!,((1,-54+7$/!*$+6*$.2,'$6!&-/! +,63!/4,-<!$)&.2(9!=%&2!2%,6!.4(($<$!

628/$-2! /,/H! 28+-,-<! 7&-9! *$4*($! &=&9! 5+47! %$+! =+,2,-<! &-/! 5&,(,-<!

24! <$2! %$+! 7$66&<$! &.+466! 24! $'1 $+94-$:! A9! =+,2,-<! %$+! *$+6*$.2,'$! ,-!&!=&9!2%&2!6$+'$/!24!,-54+7!4-! %$+! *$+64-&(! $)*$+,$-.$! =,2%! .$+1 2&,-!,-/,',/8&(60!&-/!-42!24!&22&.3!&! <+48*0! 6%$! 7&9! %&'$! >$$-! &>($! 24! &'4,/!78.%!45 !2%$!>&.3(&6%!6%$!+$1 .$,'$/:!?4=$'$+0!2%$+$!,6!&!*4*8(&1 2,4-!2%&2!68**4+26!2%,6!.4(($<$!6281 /$-2@6!4*,-,4-!2%&2!6%$!,6!-42!,-!5&.2! +&.,620! >$.&86$! D-4! ,-62,282,4-! %&6! $'$+! >8,(2! &! 6962$7! &+48-/! /,6$-1 5+&-.%,6,-<! 4+! 7&+<,-&(,C,-<! =%,2$!

PHQ µ ZKLFK LV WUXH %XW LVQ·W WKLV 7&3,-<! /,6.+,7,-&2,4-! &! /48>($!

VWDQGDUG" :KLOH LW LV D KLJKO\ FRQ1 2+4'$+6,&(!,668$0!,6!2%$!+,<%2!=&9!24! &//+$66! ,2! -42! <$22,-<! ,-'4('$/! 64! &6! -42! 24! +,63! 7&3,-<! &-94-$! 8*1 VHW RU DQJU\" :H VKRXOG EH XSVHW &-/! &-<+9! =%$-! ,2! .47$6! 24! &-9!

3,-/! 45 ! -$<&2,'$! <$-$+&(,C&2,4-:!

E40!,-!2%,6!=&90!=$!.&-!($&+-!5+47!

2%$!&82%4+@6!*4,-2!45 !',$=!&-/!%$+!

SHUVRQDO DSSURDFK WR WKH LVVXH 7KH 4*,-,4-!2%&2!2%,6!628/$-2!$)*+$66$/!

6%48(/! 7&3$! *$4*($! &6! .4-.$+-$/! &-/!,-58+,&2$/!&6!,2!=48(/!%&'$!,5 !&! =%,2$!7&-!%&/!>$$-!=+,2,-<!&>482!

EODFN FROOHJH VWXGHQWV 7KH DUWLFOH .4-/$7-6! 5+$$! 6*$$.%! =%$-! ,2! .47$6!24!&!.$+2&,-!<+48*!45 !*$4*($! &-/!,6!,-.+$/,>(9!%9*4.+,2,.&(:!I+,21 ,.6!=%4!.477$-2$/!4-!2%$!&+2,.($! *462$/!4-(,-$!6&9!%$+!4*,-,4-6!&+$! &6!8-4+,<,-&(!&6!6%$!&6687$6!=%,2$! >496@! 4*,-,4-6! &+$:! B5 ! 2%,6! &+2,.($! %&/!>$$-!=+,22$-!>9!&!=%,2$!*$+64-! $66$-2,&((9!.47*(&,-,-<!&>482!>(&.3!

7$-0! 79! 4*,-,4-! &-/! 79! 5$$(,-<6! =48(/! +$7&,-! $)&.2(9! 2%$! 6&7$:! !!!!!#%,($!B!&7!,-!-4!=&9!/$-91 ,-<! 2%&2! 2%$! &82%4+! 45 ! 2%,6! &+2,.($! %&6! $)*$+,$-.$/! +&.,67! 4+! %&6! 6&2! ,-!.(&66!=,2%!=%,2$!7$-!=%4!.(&,7!

24! 8-/$+62&-/! 2%$! >(&.3! J7$+,.&-! $)*$+,$-.$0! 2%$6$! &+$! *$+64-&(! $-1 .48-2$+6! =,2%! ,-/,',/8&(! 7$-:! #$! .&-@2!2&3$!&!+&.$0!&!<$-/$+!4+!&!.(&66!

45 !*$4*($!&-/!&6687$!2%&2!2%$9!&+$!

DOO WKH VDPH 7KDW OHDGV XV LQWR D '$+9! /&-<$+486! &+$&:! K'$+94-$!

6%48(/! %&'$! 2%$! +,<%2! 24! >$! %$&+/! &-/!$'$+94-$@6!4*,-,4-!%&6!'&(8$!-4!

7&22$+!2%$,+!<$-/$+0!+$(,<,4-!4+!&-9!

RWKHU GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ IHDWXUH 7KHUH &+$!=%,2$!7$-!&-/!=47$-!=%4!&+$!

2%48<%258(! &-/! $/8.&2$/! &-/! *41 (,2$0!G862!&6!2%$+$!&+$!>(&.3!7$-!&-/! =47$-! =%4! &+$:! A82! >9! /,6.+,7,1 -&2,-<! &<&,-62! &! <$-/$+! &-/! 63,-! .4(4+0! &((! 2%46$! *$4*($! &+$! (87*$/! ,-!=,2%!2%$!/,6+$6*$.258(0!,-.4-6,/1 $+&2$0! 7,6,-54+7$/! 45 ! 2%$! =4+(/:!!

A9! =+,2,-<! &>482! %$+! 4=-! $)*$+,1 $-.$! =,2%! /,6.+,7,-&2,4-! 4+! ,<-41 +&-.$!,-!.4(($<$0!2%,6!628/$-2!.48(/! %&'$!4*$-$/!%$+!.(&667&2$6@!$9$6!24!

2%$!>,&6$6!&-/!62$+$429*$6!2%&2!62,((! $),62!&2!6.%44(:!A82!,-!79!4*,-,4-0!

6%$! =$-2! &>482! ,2! ,-! $-2,+$(9! 2%$! =+4-<!=&9!&-/!.&7$!455 !648-/,-<! &6! 8-,-54+7$/! &-/! )$-4*%4>,.! &6!

6%$! >$(,$'$6! 2%$! DI%+,6$60! L9&-60!

2OLYHUV DQG 6HDQVµ RXW WKHUH DUH ;(2,7&2$(90!48+!<$-$+&2,4-!-$$/6!86!

24!($&/!2%$!+$62!45 !2%$!=4+(/!,-!64('1 ,-<! 2%,6! *+4>($70! 64! /$74-,C,-<! &-/! *(&.,-<! >(&7$! 4-! $&.%! 42%$+! =,((!4-(9!<8&+&-2$$!2%&2!=$@((!-$'$+!

74'$!*&62!48+!/,55$+$-.$6:!A9!8-,1 59,-<! &-/! 54.86,-<! 4-! 2%$! <4&(! &2! %&-/! =%,.%! ,6! $M8&(,29! 45 ! 4**4+1 28-,29! &-/! *$+64-&(! +$6*4-6,>,(,290! =$! .&-! .$($>+&2$! 48+! /,55$+$-.$6! ,-! &! =&9! 2%&2! 8-,2$60! -42! /,',/$6:!!

5

The Spire

OPINIONS

February 22, 2019

´5RPDµ DQG ´ -XO\µ $ 5HYLHZ RI 7ZR 1HWÁL[ )LOPV !!!

K%JJ=)3FLL#%)D:M 8+0'3)>0,>4%0":

1HWÁL[ PDGH D ELJ VSODVK LQ 7KH FRPSDQ\ KDV FRQWLQ1 8$/! 24! *+4'$! 2%&2! ,2! .&-! +$($&6$!

DPD]LQJ FRQWHQW 7ZR 1HWÁL[ 74',$6! 2%&2! B! 6&=! ,-! QRSV! =$+$! /,+$.2$/! >9! 5&,+(9! =$((13-4=-! /,1 +$.24+60! J(54-64! I8&+4-@6! *&66,4-!

SURMHFW ´5RPDµ DQG 3DXO *UHHQ1 JUDVV·V KLVWRULFDO GUDPD ´ -XO\µ !!!!!B!=&6!/,6&**4,-2$/!=,2%!L47&:!

J(54-64! I8&+4-! ,6! 4-$! 45 ! 79! 5&1 '4+,2$!74/$+-!/,+$.24+60!,5 !-42!79!

IDYRULWH +LV ÀOP ´*UDYLW\µ LV %,2!4+!7,66!=,2%!647$!*$4*($:!?4=1 HYHU ZKHQ , ÀUVW VDZ LW LQ WKHDWHUV >&.3!,-!QRSb0!B!=&6!&>64(82$(9!7$61 7$+,C$/!>9!,26!624+90!*$+54+7&-.$60! &-/! $6*$.,&((9! ,26! 6*$.,&(! $55$.260! &-/!B!.4-2,-8$!24!(4'$!,2!24!2%,6!/&9:! ,W ZDVQ·W XQWLO DIWHU , VDZ ´*UDYLW\µ 2%&2! B! =&2.%$/! 647$! 45 ! %,6! 42%$+!

74',$6:!?,6!QRRc!/9624*,&-!6.,$-.$! ÀFWLRQ ÀOP ´&KLOGUHQ RI 0HQµ LV &+<8&>(9! 4-$! 45 ! 79! 5&'4+,2$! 74'1 ,$6!+$($&6$/!,-!2%,6!.$-28+9:!J-/!%,6! ÀOP ´< 7X 0DPD 7DPELHQµ ,6!&-!$-<&<,-<!.47,-<1451&<$!624+9:!

B!=&6!$)*$.2,-<!647$2%,-<!45 !2%&2!

FDOLEHU ZKLOH ZDWFKLQJ ´5RPDµ J-/!6,-.$!I8&+4-!/,+$.2$/0!=+42$0! *+4/8.$/0!$/,2$/0!&-/!6$+'$/!&6!2%$!

FLQHPDWRJUDSKHU IRU WKLV ÀOP P\ $)*$.2&2,4-6! =$+$! %,<%:! B-62$&/0!

B! =&6! >4+$/! >9! ,2! &-/! %&/! 2+48>($!

<$22,-<!2%+48<%!,2:!B!=&60!%4=$'$+0! &**+$.,&2,'$!45 !=%&2!B!=&6!(443,-<! &2:!K'$+9!6%42!(4436!(,3$!,2!.48(/!>$!

5+&7$/!,-!&!786$87:!J6!&(=&960!%$! /4$6! &-! 8->$(,$'&>($! G4>! 7&--,-<!

2%$! .&7$+&:! ?$! *+4'$6! 9$2! &<&,-! =%9! %$@6! 2%$! &>64(82$! >$62! (,',-<! /,+$.24+!24!%&-/($!&!.&7$+&0!42%$+!

2%&-! E2$'$-! E*,$(>$+<:! I8&+4-! ,6! =,2%482! &! /48>2! 2%$! 3,-<! 45 ! 2%$!

(4-<! 2&3$:! ?4=$'$+0! $'$-! 62$((&+!

2$.%-,M8$! .48(/-@2! 6&'$! &-! 8-&*1 *$&(,-<! &-/! 8-,-2$+$62,-<! 624+9:!

7KH FKDUDFWHUV ZHUH GU\ DQG IUDQN1 (90!I8&+4-!/,/!2%$!>$62!%$!.48(/!24! *&66!2%,6!74',$!455 !&6!&!=4+3!45 !&+2: !!!!B!&(64!2%48<%2!,2!=&6!&!7,62&3$!

E\ &XDURQ WR VKRRW WKH ÀOP LQ EODFN &-/!=%,2$:!J-/!-40!,2@6!-42!>$.&86$!

B!/4-@2!(,3$!>(&.3!&-/!=%,2$!74',$6:! d8,2$! 2%$! 4**46,2$0! ,-! 5&.2:! ?4=1 $'$+0!2%$!74',$!2&3$6!*(&.$!/8+,-<!

2%$! SWTR6! &-/! ,6! 68**46$/! 24! >$! >&6$/! 4-! I8&+4-@6! .%,(/%44/:! B6! %$!$)*$.2,-<!86!24!>$(,$'$!2%&2!%,6!

FKLOGKRRG ZDV LQ EODFN DQG ZKLWH" 7KH PRYLH PLJKW KDYH IDUHG PXFK >$22$+!,5 !=$!6&=!2%$!',>+&-2!.4(4+6!

RI V 0H[LFR &LW\ :H GHÀQLWH1 (9! <42! 2%&2! ',>$! 5+47! 2%$! 648-/6!

45 ! 2%$! 62+$$26! 45 ! P$),.4! I,29:!

J6! 54+! 2%$! 624+90! 2%$+$@6! -42!

PXFK WR VD\ 7KH GLDORJXH LVQ·W 2+&-654+7&2,'$0! ,2@6! 8-,7&<,-&1 2,'$0! &-/! ,2! (&.36! *+4548-/-$66:!

B! -$'$+! =48(/! %&'$! 2%48<%2! 2%&2!

I8&+4-0! 4-$! 45 ! 2%$! >$62! .,-$7&21

,.! 624+92$(($+6! &(,'$! 24/&90! .48(/! .+&52! 68.%! &-! 8-,-2$+$62,-<! 624+9:! :KLOH , GLGQ·W OLNH ´5RPDµ , &7!62,((!*,.3,-<!,2!24!=,-!A$62!O,.1 WXUH LW ZRXOG EH WKH ÀUVW IRUHLJQ ODQJXDJH ÀOP WR WDNH WKLV SUL]H

I8&+4-! 6%48(/! $'$-! =,-! 54+! A$62! [,+$.24+! U,2! =48(/! >$! %,6! 6$.4-/!

ZLQ IROORZLQJ KLV ZLQ IRU ´*UDY1 LW\µ ,Q PRVW \HDUV ´5RPDµ ZRXOG GHÀQLWHO\ KDYH D KDUG WLPH ZLQQLQJ A$62! O,.28+$:! A82! 2%,6! 9$&+0! =,2%!

68.%! 6(,7! .47*$2,2,4-0! B! =48(/!

UDWKHU VHH ´5RPDµ ZLQ DV RS1 *46$/! 24! 74',$6! (,3$! DA4%$7,&-!

5KDSVRG\µ ´5RPDµ LV QRW DQ DZ1 58(!74',$0!,2!G862!/,/-@2!<+&>!7$!,-!

2%$!6&7$!=&9!2%&2!,2!6$$76!24!%&'$! <+&>>$/! 2%$! 78(2,28/$! 45 ! 64.,$29: !!^'$+!=,-2$+!>+$&30!B!.%$.3$/!482!

DQRWKHU 1HWÁL[ PRYLH WKLV RQH GLUHFWHG E\ 3DXO *UHHQJUDVV FDOOHG ! ´ -XO\µ ZKLFK LV DERXW WKH \4+=&9! 2$++4+! &22&.36:! ?4=! 2%,6!

74',$! +$.$,'$/! 68.%! (,22($! &22$-1 WLRQ EDIÁHV PH 3DXO *UHHQJUDVV ,6! *+4>&>(9! -42! &2! 2%$! 6&7$! .&(,1 >$+! 45 ! J(54-64! I8&+4-0! >82! %,6!

SDVW ÀOPV KDYH EHHQ ERWK FULWL1 .&((9! &-/! .477$+.,&((9! 68..$6658(:!

7KLV LV DOVR QRW KLV ÀUVW KLVWRULFDO ÀOP KLV ÀOP ´8QLWHG µ DQG KLV ÀOP ´&DSWDLQ 3KLO1 OLSVµ DUH ERWK RXWVWDQGLQJ KLVWRUL1 .&(! /+&7&6:! ?4=$'$+0! B! 2%48<%2!

WKDW ´ -XO\µ ZDV WKH EHVW PRYLH B! %&/! 6$$-! >9! %,7! &-/! ,2! =&6! 2%$!

>$62!74',$!B!6&=!,-!QRSV:!Y4+!2%46$! =%4!/4-@2!3-4=!4+!+$7$7>$+0!2%$! ÀOP·V WLWOH LV D UHIHUHQFH WR WKH -XO\ QQ-/0!QRSS!\4+=&9!2$++4+! &22&.360! ,-! =%,.%! &! 5&+1+,<%2! 2$++4+,62! 86$/! &! .&+! >47>! 24! >(4=! 8*! &! *4+2,4-!

45 ! L$<G$+,-<63'&+2&($20! 2%$! $)$.81 2,'$! <4'$+-7$-2! M8&+2$+! 45 ! \4+1 =&90!&-/!2%$-!*+4.$$/$/!2=4!%48+6!

ODWHU WR RSHQ ÀUH DW D VXPPHU FDPS RQ WKH LVODQG RI 8WR\D LQ 7\ULI1 MRUGHQ %XVNHUXG 7KH FDPS ZDV 4+<&-,C$/! >9! 2%$! J;Y0! 2%$! 9482%! /,',6,4-! 45 ! 2%$! +8(,-<! \4+=$<,&-! /DERXU 3DUW\ 7KH H[SORVLRQ NLOOHG HLJKW SHRSOH DQG LQMXUHG 7KH 68>6$M8$-2! 6%442,-<! &2! 2%$! 6871 7$+! .&7*! 3,(($/! TT0! ,-.(8/,-<! bb! .%,(/+$-! 8-/$+! 2%$! &<$! 45 ! SV:!

7KLV PRYLH GRHV QRW KROG EDFN 7KH ÀUVW PLQXWHV RU VR RI LW =%,.%! /,6*(&96! 2%$! .&+-&<$! 2%&2!

2$++4+,62! J-/$+6! A$%+,-<! A+$,',3!

U*(&9$/! >9! J-/$+6! [&-,$(6$-! N,$X! .477,260! ,6! /,628+>,-<! 24! =&2.%:! *UHHQJUDVV VKRRWV WKHVH VHTXHQFHV ,-!68.%!&!=&9!2%&2!,2!7&3$6!2%$!&8/,1 $-.$!*&+&-4,/0!&6!,5 !=$!&+$!4-!2%&2! ,6(&-/!=%$+$!2%$!&22&.36!2&3$!*(&.$:! ^-.$!2%$!&22&.36!&+$!4'$+!&52$+!2%$! ÀUVW WKLUG RI WKH PRYLH ZH ZRXOG $)*.$.2! 24! (46$! ,26! .47*468+$0! &6!

ZH KDYH QR LGHD ZKDW *UHHQJUDVV .48(/! *466,>(9! /4! =,2%! ,2! =,2%! &-! %48+!&-/!%&(5 !($52!,-!,2:!B-62$&/0!,2!

3$$*6!,26!.47*468+$!&-/!28+-6!,-24! &! .47>,-&2,4-! 45 ! &! 2+,87*%! 45 !

2%$!6*,+,2!74',$!&-/!&!($<&(!.48+21 URRP GUDPD 7KH WULXPSK RI WKH VSLULW HOHPHQW RI WKH ÀOP OLHV LQ WKH >&(&-.$! 45 ! e,(G&+! ?&-66$-! U*(&9$/!

7&62$+58((9! >9! 2$$-! &.24+! F4-&6!

6WUDQG *UDYOL RQH RI WKH WHHQDJH 68+','4+6!=%4!6855$+6!(,5$12%+$&2$-1 ,-<!,-G8+,$6!&2!2%$!%&-/6!45 !A+$,',3:! ?&-66$-! ,6! %&8-2$/! >9! 2%$! &22&.36!

DQG , WKLQN *UHHQJUDVV GRHV D <+$&2! G4>! 45 ! 6%4=,-<! %,6! *&+&-4,&! &-/! 2+&87&! 2%+48<%! %,6! +$.4'$+9: B!=&6!*&+2,.8(&+(9!,7*+$66$/!=,2%!

-RQ 2LJDUGHQ ZKR SOD\V *HLU /LS1 *$62&/0! 2%$! (&=9$+! =%4! A+$,',3! *$+64-&((9! 6$($.2$/! >&6$/! 4-! N,*1 *$62&/@6!*&62!/$5$-6$!45 !&!\$41\&1 C,:!#$!6$$!%4=!N,**$62&/@6!*$+64-&(! (,5$!&-/!74+&(!',$=6!&+$!&55$.2$/!>9! /$5$-/,-<! A+$,',3:! B! 2%,-3! ,2@6! 4-$!

RI WKH EHVW HOHPHQWV RI WKH ÀOP ,Q FRQFOXVLRQ , GHÀQLWHO\ KDG /,55$+$-2! +$&.2,4-6! 24! =%$-! B! 6&=! ´5RPDµ DQG WR ZKHQ , VDZ ´ -XO\µ 2QH , YHU\ PXFK OLNHG DQG 4-$!B!/,/-@2!(,3$!64!78.%:!B!/,/-@2!$)1 SHFW ´ -XO\µ WR EH QRPLQDWHG IRU &-9!^6.&+60!&6!,2!+$.$,'$/!'$+9!(,22($! &22$-2,4-:!?4=$'$+0!B!2%,-3!,2@6!2%$!

EHVW PRYLH RI $V IRU ´5RPDµ =%,($!B!/,/-@2!(,3$!,20!B!=48(/-@2!>$! *&+2,.8(&+(9!7&/!,5 !,2!=4-!A$62!O,.1 28+$! &2! 2%$! ^6.&+6! 2%,6! =$$3$-/:

3(,)B,+C,/-)K*4*$/,)K,-I,,$)1,&-)*$0)1#2%+)-(#&)G"+#$2)K+,*5) N,$+=)O%,)D:: (60,03,-#8+0'3) !!!!!E*+,-<!>+$&3!,6!5&62!&**+4&.%1 ,-<! &-/! ?4(9! I+466! 628/$-26! =,((! >$!<,52$/!=,2%!-,-$!/&96!5+$$!5+47! .(&66$6!&-/!5+47!2%$!62+$66$6!45 !2%$! &.&/$7,.! /&9:! J6! &! +$68(20! &! -$=1 548-/!*+4>($7!*+$6$-26!,26$(5_!!%4=!

6%48(/! =$! 7&3$! >$62! 86$! 45 ! 2%,6!

QHZIRXQG WLPH" )UDQWLFDOO\ ORRN1 ,-<! 4'$+! -42$6! 5+47! 2%$! 6$7$62$+!

VR DV QRW WR ORVH WKH ÀQHO\ JURZLQJ 747$-287!2%&2!%&6!>$$-!>8,(/,-<!

RYHU WKH ZHHNV" 7KURZLQJ FDXWLRQ 24! 2%$! =,-/! &-/! &((4=,-<! +$62! &-/!

UHOD[DWLRQ WR WDNH IXOO IRUFH" 2U VRPHZKHUH LQ EHWZHHQ" !A9!>8,(/,-<!&!6*+,-<!>+$&3!$)*$1

+,$-.$! =%,.%! ,6! .47*46$/! 45 ! *&+2! +$62! &-/! *&+2! +$',$=,-<! 2%$! =4+3! /4-$! ,-! 2%$! 6$7$62$+! 64! 5&+0! =$! .&-! >$62! $M8,*! 48+6$('$6! 54+! 2%$! +$62!45 !2%$!6$7$62$+:!L$&/,-<!4'$+! *&62! -42$60! /4,-<! *+&.2,.$! *+4>1 ($76! 4'$+! .$+2&,-! 6$.2,4-6! =%$+$! \RX PD\ IHHO XQFRQÀGHQW DQG +$&/,-<! 2%$! 2$)2>443! 54+! 2%$! 6$.1 2,4-6! 948! &+$! .4'$+,-<! &52$+! >+$&3! &+$! <+$&2! =&96! 24! 62+$-<2%$-! 948+!

3-4=($/<$!&-/!*+,7$!948+6$(5 !54+!

2%$! +$62! 45 ! 2%$! 6$7$62$+:! E*+,-<! >+$&3! &(64! <+&-26! 628/$-26! 2,7$! 24! ,-'$62,<&2$! 4**4+28-,2,$6! 54+! =%&2!

24! /4! &52$+! ?4(9! I+466:! L$6$&+.%1 ,-<! ,-2$+-6%,*6! 54+! 2%$! 6877$+0! '&+,486! *+4<+&76! &2! ?4(9! I+4660!

DQG FDUHHUV LQ \RXU ÀHOG RYHU WKLV

>+$&3!=,((!5&.,(,2&2$!/$.,6,4-6!.47$! &**(,.&2,4-! 2,7$:! J//,2,4-&((90! ,2! ,6! ,7*4+2&-2! 24! -42$! 2%&2! &.&/$7,.! &/',6,-<!54+!2%$!Y&((!QRSW!6$7$62$+! >$<,-6!G862!&52$+!2%$!.4-.(86,4-!45 !

VSULQJ EUHDN 6R UHÁHFWLQJ RQ ZKDW 948!=48(/!(,3$!24!.4-2,-8$!=,2%!,-!

2%$! -$)2! 6$7$62$+! &-/! =%&2! -$=! .(&66$6!948!=48(/!(,3$!24!2+9!=48(/!

7&3$! 948! 74+$! 4+<&-,C$/! 54+! =%$-! 2%$! &/',6,-<! *$+,4/! >$<,-6: ! Y4+! 2,7$! 6*$-2! &=&9! 5+47! &.&1 /$7,.60! 2&3,-<! 2,7$! 24! $-<&<$! ,-!

948+! (4.&(! .4778-,29! *+4',/$6!

FRXQWOHVV EHQHÀWV IRU UHVW DQG UHOD[DWLRQ *RLQJ IRU D KLNH DW &! -$&+>9! 2+&,(0! ',6,2,-<! 948+! 4(/! %,<%! 6.%44(0! &-/! 7$$2,-<! =,2%!

4(/!5+,$-/6!&+$!*+4/8.2,'$!=&96!24!

6*$-/! 2,7$! ,5 ! 948! *(&-! 4-! >$,-<! %47$:!Y4+!2%46$!62&9,-<!4-!.&7*86!

54+!>+$&30!$)*(4+$!'&+,486!>8,(/,-<6! &-/!6*426!4-!.&7*86!948!7&9!-42!

KDYH VHHQ EHIRUH 7KLV ZLOO JLYH \RX &! -$=! *$+6*$.2,'$! 4-! 2%$! .&7*86! &-/!948!7&9!/,6.4'$+!&!-$=!628/9!

6*42! 4+! &! *+,'&2$! *(&.$! 24! /$.471 *+$66!/8+,-<!2%$!+$7&,-/$+!45 !2%$!

9$&+:! P4+$4'$+0! 2%,6! =$$3! &(64! <,'$6! 628/$-26! =%4! %&'$! -42! %&/!

2%$! .%&-.$! 24! ',6,2! #4+.$62$+! 2%$! .%&-.$!24!$)*(4+$!&-/!,-2$+&.2!=,2%!

48+!-$&+>9!.,29:!?4=$'$+0!,5 !948!&+$!

(443,-<!24!62&9!,-!2%,6!6*+,-<!>+$&30! ÀQGLQJ D QHZ VHULHV RU PRYLH WR ZDWFK RQ 1HWÁL[ DQG GLVFRYHULQJ 2%$! *$+5$.2! >4&+/! <&7$! 24! *(&9! =%$-! 948! &+$! >&.3! &2! ?4(9! I+466!

&+$! 58-! &-/! +$(&),-<! 4*2,4-6! &(64:!!

E*+,-<! >+$&3! *+4',/$6! 628/$-26! =,2%! &! -$$/$/! ,-2$+7,66,4-! /8+1 ,-<! 2%$! 6$7$62$+:! J(2%48<%! 2%$! .+8.,&(! >&(&-.$! 45 ! .+&.3,-<! 4*$-!

2%$!>4436!24!3$$*!2%$!7$-2&(!.4>1 =$>6! &2! >&9! &-/! +$.48*,-<! +$62!

948! 7&9! %&'$! (462! &2! 2%$! $-/! 45 !

2%$!6$7$62$+!,6!,7*4+2&-20!2%$!>&(1 &-.$! ,6! >$62! /$2$+7,-$/! 4-! &-! ,-1 /,',/8&(! >&6,6:! ?4=$'$+! 948! $($.2!

24! 6*$-/! 6*+,-<! >+$&30! >$! 68+$!

24! %&'$! 58-0! 6*$-/! 2,7$! /4,-<!

2%$! 2%,-<6! 948! $-G490! &-/! +$G8'$1 -&2$! 54+! 2%$! +$62! 45 ! 2%$! 6$7$62$+:! !

'(*-)E%F)G(%F40)H$%I)?J%F-)<%$2).#&-*$/, 1=,$)>#$&5#)D:: (60,03,-#8+0'3) ! ! ! ! ! D\40! =$@+$! &.28&((9! <4,-<! 24!

VWD\ WRJHWKHU µ , VDLG ZLWK D FRQ1 ÀGHQW VPLOH 3ULRU WR OHDYLQJ IRU .4(($<$0!B!=&6!&63$/!=%&2!79!>491 5+,$-/! &-/! B! =$+$! *(&--,-<! 24! /4!

WLPH DQG WLPH DJDLQ 7KLV TXHVWLRQ ,6!4-$!2%&2!,6!8-&'4,/&>($!=%$-!948! &+$! ,-! &! +$(&2,4-6%,*! /8+,-<! 948+!

6$-,4+!9$&+!45 !%,<%!6.%44(:!B5 !948! %&'$-@2! <,'$-! ,2! 78.%! 2%48<%2! 4+!

948! G862! &+$-@2! 68+$! 9$20! 2%,6! M8$61 2,4-!.&-!7&3$!948!5$$(!(,3$!&!/$$+! ,-! %$&/(,<%26:! J! +$(&2,4-6%,*! ,6! &! %8<$!.477,27$-2!2%&2!2&3$6!2,7$0!

(4'$0! 8-/$+62&-/,-<0! .4778-,.&1 2,4-0! &-/! 7462! 45 ! &((_! %&+/! =4+3: 7R EHJLQ WKLQNLQJ DERXW =%$2%$+! 948@+$! 8*! 54+! >$,-<! 4-$! %&(5 ! 45 ! 2%$! .%&(($-<$! 2%&2! ,6! (4-<! /,62&-.$0! 948! -$$/! 24! (443! &2! 2%$!

5&.26:!B5 !948!&+$!<4,-<!24!62&9!=,2%!

\RXU VLJQLÀFDQW RWKHU WKH\ QHHG 24!7&3$!948!+$&((9!%&**9:!\42!G862!

3,-/!45 !%&**90!-42!G862!647$2,7$6! %&**90! >82! 2+8(9! %&**9:! `$$*! ,-!

7,-/! 2%&2! 948! =,((! (,3$(9! -42! >$!

6$$,-<! 2%$7! &6! 78.%! &6! 948! 86$/!

240! =,2%! 647$! .48*($6! 6$$,-<! $&.%!

42%$+!$'$+9!5$=!=$$36!4+!74-2%6:!

N8.3,(90! 79! >495+,$-/! &22$-/6! ;-,4-! I4(($<$! ,-! E.%$-$.2&/9!

1HZ <RUN :KLOH +RO\ &URVV DQG ;-,4-! &+$! 4-(9! Q! %48+6! &=&90! 2%$!

WRWDO WULS WLPH RQ D *UH\KRXQG EXV LV KRXUV 7KH FRVW LV DERXW =%,.%!&(2%48<%!,2!6$$76!(,3$!&!67&((! &748-20! &//6! 8*:! K'$-! 2%48<%! =$! &+$! +$(&2,'$(9! .(46$0! =$! 8681 &((9! 6$$! $&.%! 42%$+! 4-.$! &! 74-2%0! &-/! &(2$+-&2$! =%4! 7&3$6! 2%$! 2+,*: ! ! ! ! ! J(2%48<%! =$! 6$$! $&.%! 42%$+!

4-.$! &! 74-2%0! 2%,-<6! 62,((! &+$-@2!

HDV\ 7KHUH DUH WLPHV ZKHQ ,·OO EH 482! =,2%! 79! 5+,$-/60! &-/! B@((! %,2! &! =&((!45 !6&/-$66!>$.&86$!B@7!(4-$(9:!

B2!,6!%&+/!24!>$!=,2%482!2%$!*$+64-!

948!(4'$0!&-/!,2!,6!,7*4+2&-2!24!&(1 =&96! .4778-,.&2$! 948+! 5$$(,-<6!

24! 2%$! 58(($62:! #%$-! B! &7! 5$$(,-<! /4=-0! B! 2$)2! %,7! 4+! .&((! %,7! &-/! =$!2&(3!,2!2%+48<%0!&-/!2%$-!B!28+-!

24!79!&7&C,-<!>$62!5+,$-/6:!B!/4-@2! %&'$! 2%$6$! 747$-26! 45 ! 6&/-$66!

244!452$-0!>82!=%$-!B!/40!B!(443!24!

79! 4=-! 62+$-<2%! &-/! 2%$! (4'$! 45 !

2%46$!.(46$62!24!7$:!B5 !948!=&-2!24! >$! ,-! &! (4-<1/,62&-.$! +$(&2,4-6%,*0!

948! 7862! &(=&96! *82! 948+! %&**,1 -$66!&-/!=$((!>$,-<!,-!2%$!6*42(,<%2:!

B2!,6!43&9!24!>$!6&/!647$2,7$60!>$1 .&86$!24!>$!6&/!,6!24!>$!%87&-:!B2! ,6! -42! 43&9! 2%48<%0! 24! /,6.4--$.2!

948+6$(5 !5+47!948+!.4(($<$!$)*$+,1 $-.$! &-/! .(46$! 948+6$(5 ! 455 ! 5+47!

HYHU\RQH EXW \RXU VLJQLÀFDQW RWKHU =%4! ,6! -42! $'$-! *%96,.&((9! =,2%!

948:! B2! ,6! ,7*4+2&-2! 2%&2! 948! &+$! &(=&96! %&**9:! ?4=! .&-! 948! 7&3$!

647$4-$! $(6$! %&**9! ,5 ! 948! .&-@2!

EH KDSS\ \RXUVHOI " <RX FDQ QHYHU +$(9!4-!647$4-$!$(6$!54+!948+!%&*1 *,-$660!&(2%48<%!&-!4..&6,4-&(!&-/!

(4',-<! 6%48(/$+! 24! .+9! 4-! ,6! 43&9: !!!!!;*!8-2,(!2%,6!*4,-20!B@'$!-$<($.21 $/!24!7$-2,4-!2%$!7462!,7*4+2&-2! &6*$.2! 45 ! >$,-<! ,-! &! (4-<1/,62&-.$!

UHODWLRQVKLS 7UXVW LV HVVHQWLDO #,2%482!2+8620!2%$!+$(&2,4-6%,*!=,((! >$! -42%,-<:! P9! >495+,$-/! &-/! B! 2+862! $&.%! 42%$+0! 7$&-,-<! 2%&2! =$! /4-@2!6*9!4-!$&.%!42%$+@6!64.,&(!7$1 /,&!&..48-260!=$!2$((!$&.%!42%$+!$'1 $+92%,-<0!&-/!&(=&96!7&3$!68+$!2%&2!

2%$+$! &+$! -4! 6$.+$26:! J((! $742,4-6! &-/!,668$6!&-/!$-.48-2$+6!7862!>$!

482! 4-! 2%$! 2&>($:! B5 ! 948! 5$$(! 2%&2!

948! %&'$! 647$2%,-<! 24! %,/$! 5+47! \RXU VLJQLÀFDQW RWKHU RGGV DUH 948! 6%48(/-@2! >$! ,-! 2%$! +$(&2,4-1 VKLS <RX VKRXOG DOZD\V PDNH VXUH 2%&2!948!&+$!>$,-<!%4-$62!&-/!5&,+: 0\ ÀQDO ZRUG RI DGYLFH LV 4-$! 2%&2! <4$6! %&-/! ,-! %&-/! =,2%!

>$,-<! %4-$62! &-/! 5&,+:! [4:! \42:!

I%$&2:! B5 ! 948! 5$$(! (,3$! 948! =&-2!

24! 6$$! 647$4-$! $(6$0! ,77$/,&2$(9!

EUHDN XS ZLWK \RXU VLJQLÀFDQW 42%$+:! I%$&2,-<! ,6! -$'$+! &..$*21 &>($:!A$,-<!(4-$(9!,6!-42!&-!$).86$!

DQG QHLWKHU LV EHLQJ GUXQN 7KLV /4$6-@2!&**(9!24!(4-<!/,62&-.$!+$(&1 2,4-6%,*6!4-(90!>82!24!&-9!+$(&2,4-1 6%,*:!A+$&3,-<!8*!=,2%!647$4-$!,6!

948+! >&6,.! +,<%2! &-/! ,6! +$6*$.258(! &-/! /$.$-2:! I%$&2,-<! ,6! /$7$&-1 ,-<!&-/!%8+258(!&-/!-$<($.258(:![4!

-42!.%$&2!8-/$+!&-9!.,+.8762&-.$6: 7R DOO UHDGLQJ WKLV , KRSH WKDW $'$+92%,-<! =4+36! 4820! &-/! B! 8+<$!

948! 24! >$! %&**9:! J(=&96! 7&3$!

68+$! 24! .4778-,.&2$! =,2%! &-/!

EH UHVSHFWIXO WR \RXU VLJQLÀ1 .&-2! 42%$+0! &-/! &(=&96! 7&3$! 68+$!

2%&2! 948! &+$! >42%! (,',-<! 948+! >$62! (,'$6! =%$-! 948@+$! 24<$2%$+: O:E:! ?,! F4$9a! B! 7,66! 948a

6

The Spire

OPINIONS

February 22, 2019

B+,S!&/*+&)B+,0#/-#%$& 3=4,+)>(+#&-#*$&,$)9:; (60,03,-#8+0'3) ## ###7KH 2VFDUV LV HYHU\ ÀOP ORYHU·V E8*$+!A4=(:!B2@6!2%$!74',$!$'$-2!45 !

2%$!9$&+0!&!/&9!45 !.$($>+&2,4-!54+!&((!

NLQGV RI ÀOPV IRUHLJQ DQLPDWHG VKRUW ÀOPV DQG WKH WHDPV EHKLQG 2%$! .&7$+&! &6! =$((! &6! ,-! 5+4-2:!

Y+47! 2%,6! =+,2$+@6! *$+6*$.2,'$0! ,2! /4$6-@2!+$&((9!7&22$+!=%4!=,-6H!6$$1 LQJ ÀOPV DQG SHRSOH UHFRJQL]HG 54+! 2%$,+! =4+30! =%$2%$+! 2%&2! >$!

2%+48<%!&!-47,-&2,4-!4+!&-!&.1 28&(!=,-0!,6!.&2%&+2,.:![4$6!2%&2!

7$&-! =%&2$'$+! =,-6! ,6! &8241 PDWLFDOO\ WKH ´%HVW 3LFWXUHµ RI WKH \HDU" 1R ,I ZH ORRN EDFN 2%+48<%!^6.&+!%,624+90!647$!45 !

WKH JUHDW ÀOPV GLG QRW ZLQ RU $'$-! <$2! &! -47,-&2,4-_! QRRS_!

J!E*&.$!^/966$90!O69.%40!E,-1 <,-@! ,-! 2%$! L&,-0! L&<,-<! A8((0!

I,2,C$-! `&-$0! #,C&+/! 45 ! ^C0!

J*4.&(9*6$! \4=0! B2@6! &! #4-1 GHUIXO /LIH HWF 7ZR RI FLQ1 HPD·V ÀQHVW GLUHFWRUV 6WDQOH\ `8>+,.3!&-/!J(5+$/!?,2.%.4.30!

-$'$+! =4-:! P&+2,-! E.4+6$6$! &-/!Y+&-.,6!Y4+/!I4**4(&!$&.%!

4-(9! %&'$! 4-$! 54+! /,+$.2,-<:! #%,($! &+2! ,6! 68>G$.2,'$! &-/! 2%$!

J.&/$79! %&6! &! 5&((,>($! 6962$70! ,2!,6!62,((!58-!&-/!$).,2,-<!3$$*1 LQJ WUDFN RI WKH ÀOPV WKDW FRPH RXW RI WKH PDMRU ÀOP IHVWLYDOV ,-!J8<862!&-/!E$*2$7>$+!&-/!2+91 ,-<!24!*+$/,.2!=%4!=,((!.47$!%47$! =,2%! 2%$! <4(/! 2+4*%9! &-/! =%46$!

-&7$! =,((! >$! *82! ,-! 2%$! %,624+9! >4436:! #,2%! 2%&2! 6&,/0! 2%$! ^6.&+6! &+$!2%,6!E8-/&90!64!B!=,((!2+9!24!*+$1 /,.2! 647$! 45 ! 2%$! 7&G4+! .&2$<4+,$6! >&6$/! 4-! =%&2! B! 2%,-3! =,((! =,-0!

-42!-$.$66&+,(9!=%&2!B!=&-2!24!=,-:!

KHUH ´%ODFN 3DQWKHUµ JDUQHULQJ WKH ÀUVW DQG ZRUWK\ QRPLQDWLRQ RI LWV JHQUH 6SLNH /HH·V ÀOP ´%ODF.1 ..ODQVPDQµ LV D WULXPSK DQG KLV ÀUVW ÀOP WR EH QRPLQDWHG LQ WKLV .&2$<4+90!=%,.%!,6!+$&((9!62+&-<$!,5 !

948! 2%,-3! &>482! ,2:! ?4=! /,/! D[4!

7KH 5LJKW 7KLQJµ RU ´0DOFROP ;µ PLVV WKH PDUN" /LNH , VDLG WKH $FDGHP\ LV IDOOLEOH ´5RPDµ LV WKH .($&+!5+4-2+8--$+0!64!$)*$.2!2%,6!24!

2&3$!%47$!2%$!>,<!*+,C$:!B!=48(/!&(64!

QRW EH VXUSULVHG LI ´*UHHQ %RRNµ

GHUIXO ÀOP KH ZDV QHYHU LQ WKH GLV1 .866,4-! 8-2,(! 2%$! -47,-&2,4-6! &-1 QRXQFHPHQW RQ -DQXDU\ QG 7KH J.&/$79! *+4>&>(9! 2%48<%2! 2%&2!

VLQFH ´$ 6WDU LV %RUQµ LV WKH IRXUWK ,2$+&2,4-! 45 ! 2%$! 6&7$! 624+9! 2%&2!

I44*$+!,6!8-=4+2%9!4+!647$2%,-<:!

B! 6$$! =%$+$! 2%$9@+$! .47,-<! 5+470! >82! B! /,6&<+$$:! J(54-64! I8&+4-! ,6!

4-!&!%42!62+$&3!&52$+!=,--,-<!A$62!

'LUHFWRU IRU KLV ÀOP ´*UDY1 LW\ µ VR SODFH \RXU EHWV RQ KLP

2OLYLD &ROPDQ ´7KH )DYRXULWHµ 6DP (OOLRWW ´$ 6WDU LV %RUQµ <DOLWL]LD $SDULFLR ´5RPDµ 0HOLVVD 0F&DUWK\ ´&DQ <RX B! +$&((9! %&'$! -4! ,/$&! =%9! E&7!

(YHU )RUJLYH 0H"µ 5RFNZHOO LV KHUH RYHU 7LPR1 2%$$! I%&(&7$2! 54+! DA$&82,58(!

7KUHH ZD\ UDFH EHWZHHQ &ORVH %R\ µ $OL KDV WKLV LQ WKH EDJ EXW *DJD DQG &ROPDQ ,I , ZHUH RQ B! =48(/! (4'$! ,2! ,5 ! [+,'$+! <42! ,2:!

2%$! J.&/$790! B! =48(/! 8-/48>21 HGO\ FKRRVH /DG\ *DJD IRU KHU !+#2#$*4)G/+,,$"4*=A VLQJLQJ ´6KDOORZ µ 7KH $FDGHP\ Y,+62!L$54+7$/ =,((! *+4>&>(9! <4! =,2%! 2%$! '$2$+&-!

7KH )DYRXULWH =%4!%&6!6,)!-47,-&2,4-6!>82!C$+4! *UHHQ %RRN =,-6:! B2@6! 3,-/! 45 ! (48690! >82! 2%&2@6! e,.$ L47& 7KLV LV 3DXO 6FKUDGHU·V ÀUVW VFUHHQSOD\ QRPLQDWLRQ $'$+!&-/!2%,6!,6!2%$!<89!=%4!

ZURWH ´7D[L 'ULYHUµ DQG ´5DJLQJ %XOO µ +H SUREDEO\ 6%48(/! =,-! 2%,6! .&2$<4+90!

EXW LW·V JRLQJ WR ´7KH )D1 YRXULWH µ :KHUH LV ´(LJKWK *UDGHµ DW $FDGHP\" ?0*"-,0)G/+,,$"4*=A A(&.```(&-67&,I %HDOH 6WUHHW &RXOG 7DON &DQ <RX (YHU )RUJLYH 0H" A&((&/!45 !A862$+!E.+8<<6 J!E2&+!,6!A4+-

RU ´%ODF...ODQVPDQµ VZLSHG ,20! 2%48<%:! A82! =%$+$@6! DB5 ! A$&($!

6WUHHW &RXOG 7DONµ RU ´)LUVW 0DQµ" K,&-).#+,/-%+)O%P#$,,&A $OIRQVR &XDURQ ´5RPDµ 6SLNH /HH ´%ODF...ODQVPDQµ <RUJRV /DQWKLPRV ´7KH )DYRX1 ULWHµ $GDP 0F.D\ ´9LFHµ 3DZHO 3DZOLNRZVNL ´&ROG :DUµ

K,&-)B#/-F+,)O%P#$,,&A A(&.3!O&-2%$+ A(&.```(&-67&A4%$7,&-!L%&*64/9 *UHHQ %RRN 7KH )DYRXULWH J!E2&+!,6!A4+L47& e,.$

E4! 2%,6! .&2$<4+9! ,6! 647$2%,-<:!

6SLNH /HH JHWV KLV ÀUVW QRPLQDWLRQ KHUH ZKDW DQG VR GRHV <RUJRV N&-2%,7460!2%$!,/,469-.+&2,.!/,+$.1 WRU EHKLQG ·V ´7KH /REVWHUµ &-/! QRST@6! D`,((,-<! 45 ! &! E&.+$/!

'HHU µ 7KH UHDO VXUSULVH KHUH LV WKH &>6$-.$!45 !A+&/($9!I44*$+!54+!%,6!

ZRUN RQ ´$ 6WDU LV %RUQ µ +RZ #%,($! 2%$! J.&/$79! 4-(9! .%46$! GRHV WKH ÀOP JHW HLJKW QRPLQDWLRQV $,<%2! -47,-$$6! 482! 45 ! &! *466,>($! EXW RQH RI WKHP LVQ·W WKH GLUHFWRU" 2$-!2%,6!9$&+0!2%$+$!,6!&!(42!24!(4'$! #%,($! O&=(,34=63,! 7&/$! &! =4-1

K,&-)?/-%+)O%P#$,,&A &KULVWLDQ %DOH ´9LFHµ L&7,! P&($3! 1! DA4%$7,&-! L%&*1 VRG\µ %UDGOH\ &RRSHU ´$ 6WDU LV %RUQµ 9LJJR 0RUWHQVHQ ´*UHHQ %RRNµ #,(($7! [&54$! 1! DJ2! K2$+-,29@6! *DWHµ 7KLV LV D SUHWW\ VWDFNHG FDWHJRU\ >82! ,2! ,6! +$&((9! &! 2=41=&9! +&.$! >$1 2=$$-! I%+,62,&-! A&($! &-/! L&7,!

P&($30!=,2%!A+&/($9!I44*$+!5&((,-<! >$%,-/0!54+!647$!+$&64-!8-3-4=-!

24! 7$:! A&($! &-/! P&($3! &+$! >42%!

2+&-654+7&2,'$! ,-! 2%$,+! +4($6! &-/! B! %4-$62(9! =48(/-@2! 7,-/! $,2%$+! 45 !

2%$7!=,--,-<0!>82!B!*+$5$+!A&($!>9! &! 67&((! 7&+<,-:! ?4=$'$+0! B! 2%,-3!

2%$! ^6.&+6! =,((! <4! =,2%! P&($3: K,&-)?/-+,&&A *OHQQ &ORVH ´7KH :LIHµ /DG\ *DJD ´$ 6WDU LV %RUQµ

K'$-! ,5 ! E*,3$! N$$! (46$6!

2%$! /,+$.2,-<! &-/! *,.28+$! .&2$<4+,$60! %$@6! <42! 2%,6!

868&((9! 2%$! =&9! 2%,-<6! =4+3:! P&91 RQH LQ WKH EDJ ´6FUXJJVµ LV D ZHO1 >$! 2%$! J.&/$79! 6%48(/! =&2.%! DJ! .47$! $-2+9! &-/! ,2@6! &! +$&(! 6%&7$!

6WDU LV %RUQµ DJDLQ ,W·V DOVR NLQG WKDW ´%HDOH 6WUHHWµ LV QRW LQ WKH 45 !&!6%4.3!-42!6$$,-<!K7,(9!A(8-2! A$62! O,.28+$! /,6.866,4-! &-974+$:!

54+! *(&9,-<! P&+9! O4**,-6! %$+$:! !-(,+) P*Q%+) /*-,2%+#,&A K,&-)GF""%+-#$2)?/-+,&&A &LQHPDWRJUDSK\ ´5RPDµ 0DULQD GH 7DYLUD ´5RPDµ (GLWLQJ ´9LFHµ $P\ $GDPV ´9LFHµ P86,.&(! E.4+$! 1! DB5 ! A$&($! E2+$$2!

L$<,-&! `,-<! 1! DB5 ! A$&($! E2+$$2! &RXOG 7DONµ &RXOG 7DONµ %HVW 6RQJ ´6KDOORZµ , ZRXOG (PPD 6WRQH ´7KH )DYRXULWHµ *82!&((!45 !79!.%,*6!4-!2%,6X 5DFKHO :HLV] ´7KH )DYRXULWHµ J-,7&2$/! Y,(7! 1! E*,/$+1P&-_!

B-24!2%$!E*,/$+1e$+6$ L$<,-&! `,-<! &((! 2%$! =&9:! O44+!

J79!J/&76:!

ZDV D JUHDW \HDU IRU ÀOP -4! 7&22$+! =%4! =,-6! 4-! E8-/&9:!

K,&-)GF""%+-#$2)?/-%+A !

J/&7! [+,'$+! 1! DA(&.```(&-61 PDQµ 0DKHUVKDOD $OL ´*UHHQ %RRNµ 5LFKDUG ( *UDQW ´&DQ <RX (YHU )RUJLYH 0H"µ 6DP 5RFNZHOO ´9LFHµ

>F4-#R*-#$2)*)>F4-F+,)%C )?"*-(=A) .,P*$0#$2)8%+, 8*22#,)>%$$%44=)D:; (60,03,-#8+0'3) ! ! ! ! ! #$$36! %&'$! *&66$/! 6,-.$! 2%$! %,624+,.0!?4(9!I+466!6,21,-!2%&2!4.1 .8++$/!&63,-<!2%$!5&.8(29!45 !2%$!.4(1 ($<$!54+!74+$!450!=$((f!$'$+92%,-<:!

P4+$! 2+&-6*&+$-.90! 74+$! &.2,4-0!

74+$!,-2$+&.2,4-0!&-/!74+$!G862,.$:!

J(2%48<%!2%$!6,21,-!=&6!&!/,+$.2!+$1 6*4-6$!24!O+45$664+![862,-@6!6$)8&(!

7,6.4-/8.2! &-/! 2%$! =&9! 2%$! &/1 7,-,62+&2,4-! %&-/($/! ,20! 2%$! ,7*(,1 .&2,4-6!45 !2%$!6,21,-!=$+$!74+$0!&2! ($&62!,-!79!4*,-,4-:!B2!7&/$!7$0!&6! &!628/$-20!+$&(,C$!2%&2!2%,6!=&6!4-$!

RI WKH ÀUVW HYHQWV RI WKLV FDSDFLW\ 64! =,/$(9! &22$-/$/! >9! ?4(9! I+466!

628/$-26:!Y4+!&!6.%44(!2%&2!>+&-/6!

,26$(5 ! &6! &! 64.,&(1G862,.$! 4+,$-2$/! .4778-,290! =%9! /4! 64! 7&-9! 45 !

WKH VWXGHQWV VHHP WR EH ÀQH OLYLQJ LQ D FXOWXUH RI DSDWK\ RQ FDPSXV" 7KLV GRHV QRW DSSO\ WR HYHU\1 4-$!>9!&-9!7$&-6H!2%,6!6.%44(!%&6!&! .4+$!<+48*!45 !628/$-26!=%4!.+$&2$! &-/! .8(2,'&2$! 64.,&(! G862,.$! 74'$1 PHQWV RQ FDPSXV 7KHVH DUH WKH 3,-/6! 45 ! 628/$-26! =%4! /+$=! 7$!

WR WKH VFKRRO LQ WKH ÀUVW SODFH DQG 2%$!6,21,-!+$7,-/$/!7$!2%&2!B!%&'$!

5&(($-!',.2,7!24!2%$!&*&2%$2,.!-4+7!

74+$!452$-!2%&-!B!=48(/!(,3$!24!&/1 7,2:!B2!%&6!>$.47$!64!-4+7&(!&-/!

-&28+&(! 24! ,<-4+$! 2%$! 2%,-<6! 2%&2! %&**$-!>42%!4-!.&7*86!&-/!,-!2%$! =4+(/!2%&2!-$$/!24!>$!/$&(2!=,2%!&-/! =$,+/!4+!42%$+!24!<$2!,-'4('$/!&-/!

2+9! 24! 7&3$! &! /,55$+$-.$! &74-<62!

(426! 45 ! 64.,&(! .,+.($6! 4-! .&7*86: <HV DQ LPSUHVVLYH QXPEHU RI 628/$-26! '4(8-2$$+! =,2%! <+48*6! (,3$! EO;[! 4+! IAN0! >42%! =4-/$+1 58(! *+4<+&76! =,2%! 7&-9! /,55$+$-2!

4*2,4-6! 24! <$2! 62&+2$/! =,2%! 64.,&(!

G862,.$:! ?4=$'$+0! &22$-/,-<! &! 6,2$! ,-! #4+.$62$+! 4+! '4(8-2$$+,-<! =,2%! <+48*6!2%&2!.47$!24!.&7*86!4-.$!

4+!2=,.$!&!=$$3!,6!-42!$-48<%:!e4(1 8-2$$+,-<! ,6! &! <+$&2! 62&+2,-<! *4,-20! >82! 64.,&(! G862,.$! .&--42! 62&+2! &-/! $-/!=,2%!,2:!#$0!&6!&!.&7*860!%&'$!

24! 62$*! 8*! &-/! 6*$&3! 4820! +$<&+/1 ($66! 45 ! 2%$! +$*$+.866,4-6! 5+47!

48+! *$$+6:! B-! 4+/$+! 24! 62&+2! .&+,-<! &>482! 2%$! ,7*4+2&-2! 2%,-<60! =$! %&'$! 24! 624*! .&+,-<! &>482! =%&2!

48+! 5+,$-/6! 2%,-3:! E4! =%&2! ,5 ! ,2! ,6! =$,+/! 24! &22$-/! &! Y$7,-,62! Y4+87!

PHHWLQJ" ,I \RX FDUH DERXW LW 7&3$! 948+! '4,.$! %$&+/! &-/! 62&+2! &22$-/,-<!7$$2,-<6a!B2!,6!%,<%!2,7$! =$! 624**$/! 28+-,-<! &! >(,-/! $9$: 7KHUH DUH RSSRUWXQLWLHV IRU ($&/$+6%,*! &-/! 68**4+2! $'$+91 =%$+$! 4-! .&7*86:! E2&+2! +$&/,-<!

I41J--48-.$7$-2! $7&,(60! 62&+2! <4,-<! 24! 7$$2,-<6! &-/! &22$-/,-<! /,6.866,4-6:! A$.47$! &-! LOK! 4+!

DQ 03( UXQ IRU 6*$ RU DWWHQG &! .(8>! 7$$2,-<! 45 ! 647$2%,-<! 2%&2!

LQWHUHVWV \RX *HW LQYROYHG PDNH 948+!'4,.$!%$&+/0!>$.&86$!=$!&+$!64! *+,',($<$/!24!&22$-/!2%,6!6.%44(!&-/! %&'$!&!'4,.$!&2!&((:!A+,-<!&!5+,$-/!24!

7&3$! 948! 5$$(! 74+$! .4754+2&>($0!

4+!$'$-!>$22$+0!<4!&(4-$!&-/!2&(3!24!

647$4-$!-$=!&2!&!7$$2,-<!4+!/,61 FXVVLRQ 7KH PRVW FKDQJH KDSSHQV =%$-! =$! 62$*! 482! 45 ! 48+! .471 54+2!C4-$6!&-/!,-24!2%$!8-3-4=-: !!!!!B2!,6!2,7$!24!624*!($22,-<!48+!,-1 ER[HV RYHUÁRZ ZLWK HPDLOV ZH DUH G862!<4,-<!24!/$($2$!=,2%482!>42%1 $+,-<! 24! 4*$-:! E$$,-<! 2%$! 28+-482! &2! 2%$! 6,21,-! 7&/$! 7$! +$&(,C$! 2%&2! ?4(9!I+466!628/$-26!&+$!=,((,-<!24!

7&3$!&!/,55$+$-.$H!=$!G862!-$$/!24! +$7,-/!48+6$('$6!=%9!=$!&+$!%$+$!

LQ WKH ÀUVW SODFH DQG ZKDW LW PHDQV 24! >$! &! 7$7>$+! 45 ! 2%$! .47781 QLW\ WKDW LV ´IRU DQG ZLWK RWKHUV µ !!!!!!!!!

FEATURES

The Spire

7

7"'53*"0

February 22, 2019

L)'5Q0%6>%.""#/09% R-)"%<'5"%S%&6A"T%

G*30'2"*%/4 %5)"%L""F9 0#1"'(2,,3"4(567

!"##$%&'##'()"*%+,, !"#$%&"'()*+$,&

:'((6"%7#')"*5$%+,; -.+"/ (!"#$%&"'()*+$,&

M>"%5)6>(%$/3%8/3#2%1)'>("%'5% <G9%($%!.%'($%:!

7'A/*65"%-N%.)/89%"h%.!*+:6</="5/8>9%S+34$%5(%:8!ZL 7'A/*65"%J//F9%"OA!T16%5!7/:! :'?/*9%W$+6/5/D$?8!F'($/6+4!=(102 b+7%-2!R/:0'3!W%(%:5/3! +%5!

7'A/*65"% @156A656"0% !6=I'##% 6>A/#A"2%6>% ="'#9% />%1'=B309% Z+03+;$(! =/4+%(?!/7 !

Y:%'I7'5(! ='+3(5!W%(%:!

7'A/*65"% '30!W'168!

0B/5%/>% =(10%3(5!7/:!

1'=B309%=(@! b+7%8!TFKL R/5%D$95!

7'A/*65"% 7'A/*65"% :/A6"9%%%%%% /44O1'=B30% "Y:+'395! *"05'3*'>59% =/3;#$%!4/77%%!

7'A/*65"%%% E1;!

0/>(9% ./="%0='##% "=$'62 5)6>(0%5)'5% 6/.-2!b'0?! ='F"%$/3*% 8.,$,(9,%&$"'4(,/ (0#1"'(2,,3"4(:67 *';'8!Y:'06%?!

2'$%I"55"*9% F//D%: T%0!T/5%!Y6'4I!#%'!

7'A/*65"%06>("*C(*/3B9%!&/(!

76*05%5)6>(%$/3%2/%8)">%$/3% Z166+;'3!

8'F"%3B9%D:'?% ./>(%5)'5%$/3%)'A"%1/=B#"5"#$% P'05%5)6>(%$/3%2/%I"4/*"%(/6>(% ="=/*6D"29%"#$%!Q($%:!=+0%-2!

5/%I"29!='?!";//0!3+;$(-!(/!E?! &1;$!R'4IE'38!c'4!V7:/3! ://EE'(%!'30!(14I!$+E!+3@!

7'A/*65"%1/#/*9%W1:D6%E 7'A/*65"%B#'1"%$/3%)'A"%5*'A"#"2% 7'A/*65"%0B/*50%5"'=9%='3!d+%;/!

5/9%Y1%3/5!L+:%58!L:;%3(+3'! >6%%(!eLL>f K/#"O=/2"#9%&1;$!R'4IE'3!

7'A/*65"%1#'00%5'F">%'5%</#$% ./="5)6>(%$/3%#//F%4/*8'*2%5/% G*/009%&%<:%.!Y+<6%g!Q60!#%5('2 8)">%$/3%(/%)/="9%=D%30+3;!

E%3(! (+E%!.+($!E?!3+3%!5+<6+3;5@!

H=I'**'006>(%<G%:/=">59% 7'A/*65"%="=/*$%'5%<G9%%B,B! S$%3%,%:!5/E%/3%!'5I5!.$'(!

1HUI JXQ FDSWXUH WKH ´ÁDJµ K9E!;/+3;!(/!0/!.+($!'!D$+6/5/D$?!

0%;:%%@!

J*'((6>(%K6()509% QG SODFH ÀQDO2 +5(5!+3(:'E1:'6!0/0;%<'66!ANOC L/*20%5/%#6A"%I$9%"K(!;%(5!<%((%:8!

4/160!<%!./:5%-

;%:8!<1(!.+($!6/,%!%,%3@-!

D@E@!

7KH ÀOP LV GLUHFWHG E\ *HRUJH "#$%!=$/D6+7(%:5-!S%0@8!Z':4$!AN]! #+6E'38! R:@8! .+($! '! 54:%%3D6'?! <?! =$/.+3;5!'(!B!'30!X!D@E !!!!"#$%!&'(%!)!*+,%-!./.%0!'10+2 L10:%?! S%665@! =('::+3;! LE'306'! %34%5!6'5(!7'668!'30!+(95!:%(1:3+3;!(/! =(%3<%:;! '30! T%;+3'! &'668! +(! .'5! "F:'U?!T+4$!L5+'35($%!<+;!54:%%3!+3!=%%6/5!#$%'(:%!/3! :%6%'5%0!6'5(!7'66!(/!4:+(+4'6!'446'+E@! !>:+@8!Z':4$!AA!'30!='(@8!Z':4$!AB]! >:+0'?8!>%<@!AA8!'30!='(1:2 =$/.+3;!'(!C!D@E@!!

0'?8!>%<@!AB8!'(!C!D@E@! !! !!#$%!E/,+%!7/66/.5!=('::!

"Z':?! ^1%%3! /7 !

F':(%:8! '! (%%3';%! ;+:6! =4/(5-! S%0@8! Z':4$! .$/! .+(3%55%5! ($%! D/6+4%!

AC]! =$/.+3;5! '(! B! 5$//(+3;!/7 !$%:!13':E%0!

'30!X!D@E@!

4$+60$//0! 7:+%308! G$'6+6@! =('::! $'5! (/! 0%4+0%! <%2 ">+:5(! Z'3-! >:+@8! (.%%3! ($%! 5'7%(?! /7 ! 5('?2 Z':4$! AP! '30! ='(@8! +3;! H1+%(! '30! 5D%'I+3;!

Z':4$! BN]! =$/.+3;!

1D! ';'+35(! ($%! +3J15(+4%! '(!C!D@E@!!!!!

D6';1+3;!$%:!4/EE13+(?@ " S + 0 / . 5 - S% 0 @ 8!

7KH ÀOP UHÁHFWV D LD:+6!B]!=$/.+3;5!'(!

D'+3716! 41::%3(! :%'6+(?8!

B!'30!X!D@E@ <1(!+(!:%715%5!(/!5$?!'.'?! %9,%&$"'4(,/ (";<&"''=9,=%> ! "F:%%0! KK-! >:+@8!

7:/E!($%!31'34%5!/7 !($'(! @='>2#'%.5">I"*(%05'*0%6>%R-)"%<'5"%S%&6A"XT :%'6+(?@! K(! D:%5%3(5! '! 3%.!

LD:+6! [! '30! ='(@8!

D/+3(! /7 ! ,+%.! 7/:! D%/D6%!

LD:+6! \]! =$/.+3;! '(! .$/! $',%! /36?! %,%:! :%'0!

C!D@E@! '</1(!D/6+4%!<:1('6+(?!+3!($%!3%.5@! #$%!54:%%3+3;!+3!=%%6/5!+5!7:%%!'30!

LE'306'! =(%3<%:;! D/.%:7166?! /D%3!(/!($%!4/EE13+(?@!

"Q3! #$%! Y'5+5! /7 ! =%_-! S%0@8!

D/:(:'?5! =('::95! ;:+%7 ! '30! :';%!

5+/3! 7/:! ($%! E':;+3'6+U%08! 5'7%(?! LD:+6!ON]!=$/.+3;5!'(!B!'30!X!D@E@@ 7/66/.+3;! G$'6+695! E1:0%:8! '5!

7/:! ($%! 7%':7168! '30! $/D%! 7/:! ($%! .%66!'5!$%:!'<130'3(!6/,%!7/:!$%:! $/D%6%55! 4'3! <%! 7/130! +3! '3! 132 "*:%%3! Y//I->:+@8! LD:+6! OA! '30!

7'E+6?8! 7:+%3058! '30! 4/EE13+(?@! 0%3+'<6?!0':I!(+E%@!!V,%3!<%?/30! ='(@8!LD:+6!OB]!=$/.+3;!'(!C!D@E@ $V 6WDUU ÀQGV DQG UDLVHV KHU YRLFH WKHVH UHODWLYHO\ FRQFUHWH EHQHÀWV !!!!!

5$%!4:%'(%5!$/D%!7/:!4$'3;%@! ($+5! 5%:,+4%! '65/! 0%E/35(:'(%0! "K7 ! Y%'6%! =(@! F/160! #'6I-8! S%0@8! !!!!!>%'(1:+3;!</($!;1(!D134$%5!'30! ($'(! <?! '4(+,%6?! 6%':3+3;! 7:/E! LD:+6!A`]!=$/.+3;5!'(!B!'30!X!D@E@! <%66?!6'1;$58!E/E%3(5!/7 !0+,+5+,%! ($/5%! .+($! 0+77%:+3;! :%6+;+/15!

KDWH DQG XQLI\LQJ ORYH WKH ÀOP <'4I;:/13058! %'4$! +30+,+01'6! 4'3! "=D+0%:2Z'3]! K3(/! ($%! =D+0%:2 5(:+I%5! '3! +34:%0+<6%! %E/(+/3'6! '4$+%,%!'!;:%'(%:!130%:5('30+3;!/7 ! a%:5%->:+@8!LD:+6!A\!'30!='(@8!LD:+6! <'6'34%@! M%(! /3%! %E/(+/3! <+305! ($%! 130%:6?+3;! 5+E+6':+(+%5! .+($+3! AC]!=$/.+3;!'(!C!D@E@!

LW DOO WRJHWKHU SDVVLRQ ,W·V D ÀOP $1E'3!3'(1:%!/3!'!;6/<'6!54'6%@ E'0%! <?! D%/D6%! .$/! 4':%! 0%%D6?! "#$%! >',/1:+(%-! S%0@8! Z'?! O]!

DERXW ZKDW WKH ÀOP VD\V DQG KRZ =$/.+3;5!'(!B!'30!X!D@E@! +(!5'?5!+(@!

-)"%.""#/0%.1)"23#"%4/*%5)"%*"05% !!!!#$%!E/,+%!+5!<'5%0!/3!($%!ANOC! /4 %5)"%$"'*%60%'0%7/##/809% ">'3('5(+4! Y%'5(5]! #$%! F:+E%5! /7 ! ?/13;!'016(!3/,%6!<?!L3;+%!#$/E2 *:+30%6.'60-!>:+@8!Z'?!B!'30!='(@8!

'5@! #$/E'5! <%;'3! .:+(+3;! ($%! "L!W:+,'(%!S':-8!S%0@8!>%<@!AC!'(! Z'?!`]!=$/.+3;!'(!C!D@E@ <//I!'7(%:!($%!ANNP!D/6+4%!5$//(2 B!'30!X!DE!!!!! +3;!/7 !Q54':!*:'3(8!.$%3!5$%!.'5! "L!=(':!+5!Y/:3-8!S%0@8!Z':4$!OB! 5(+66!+3!4/66%;%@!#$/E'5!5'+0!/7 !($%! '(!B!'30!X!DE .:+(+3;!D:/4%558!"K!.'3(%0!(/!E'I%! "V+;$($! *:'0%-8! >:+@8! Z':4$! O[! % 51:%!K!'DD:/'4$%0!+(!3/(!J15(!+3!'32 '30!='(@8!Z':4$!O\]!=$/.+3;!'(!C!

U""B%:$%G*6I9%@#3=>6%V;WE ?,1"($,===

F'3!?/1! (%66!5/E%! /7 !15!.%3(! i'<:/'0i!22j

Z';;+%!>6'$%:(?

F':/6+3%!>:%?

G'?6'!#17/ Y%($!Q9Y:+%3 Z%;!LD/5(/6+0%5 b+,!>%::+4I

k22 Q3!F:15'0%:! #+E%ll

8

The Spire

FEATURES

February 22, 2019

:"()'>%:'*F#"%J'I$%Y.)/8"*Z%7"A"* J*62("5%7#')"*5$%+,V !"#$%&"'()*+$,& D#$9."*(@A"()<+',*"(,/ (E%+$' !!!!K7 !?/19:%!'3?($+3;!6+I%!E%8!?/1:! %,%:?! .'I+3;! E/E%3(! ($%5%! D'5(!

7%.! 0'?5! $'5! <%%3! 4/351E%0! <?! ($/1;$(5! /7 ! Z%;$'3! Z':I6%95! hMF! <'<?! 5$/.%:! %_(:',';'3U'@!

R15(!('I%!'!E/E%3(!(/!:%6+5$!+3!%,2 %:?!./30%:716!0%('+6!/7 !($+5!%,%3(]! ($%!d14$%55!/7 !=155%_!+5!;/+3;!/3!

D ÀYH GD\ EDE\ VKRZHU EHQGHU LQ h%.! M/:I! F+(?! .+($! $%:! 4%6%<:+(?!

7:+%305@! #$+5! 5/1305! 6+I%! '! d+53%?!

F$'33%6! Q:+;+3'6! Z/,+%! ($'(! K! 0:%'E%0! 1D! +3! E+006%! 54$//6! /:! '! :'134$?! 4/E%0?! 5('::+3;! '66! /7 ! ?/1:! 7',/:+(%! 4/E+4! '4(:%55%5! '30!

DQ 61/ VZHHWKHDUW LQ KHU ÀUVW ÀOP :/6%@! K9E! 5%:+/156?! $/D+3;! +(! E/:%!

46/5%6?! :%5%E<6%5! ($%! 6'((%:8! <1(!

K! '551E%! ($'(! ^1%%3! V6+U'<%($! ./160!D:%7%:!'!E/:%!W*!(:+D@!='06?8! ($%!41::%3(!+37/:E'(+/3!'</1(!($+5! ?%':95! <+;;%5(! %,%3(! +5! 0+5'DD/+3(2 LQJO\ VSDUVH EXW ,·OO ÀOO \RX IHOORZ Z':I6%2+(%5!e0/!.%!6+I%!($+5!Z':I6%!

L:E?8!?%5!/:!3/nf!+3]

!!!!K(!.'5!:%D/:(%0!/3!#1%50'?8!>%<2 :1':?!OP8!ANOP!($'(!Z%;$'3!Z':I6%!

VHFUHWO\ ÁHZ WR 1HZ <RUN WR FHO2 %<:'(%! $%:! <'<?! 5$/.%:! .+($! 7:+%305@! a%:?! ,';1%@! a%:?! %_4+(+3;@! #$%! D$:'5%! ´VHFUHWO\ ÁHZ WRµ LV RQH ($'(!K!$/D%!(/!<%!'55/4+'(%0! .+($! /3%! 0'?@! =1<5%H1%3(! :%D/:(5! %_D6'+3%0! ($'(! 5$%!

'4(1'66?! '::+,%0! +3! ($%! 4+(?! ($+5! D'5(! .%%I%30! '30! 4%62 %<:'(%0! ($%! 5$/.%:! (/0'?@!

S$'(!+5!($%!D/+3(!/7 !'!A`2 $/1:!3%.5!4?46%!+7 !K9E!3/(!

QRWLÀHG RI WKH 'XFKHVV RI =155%_95! .$%:%'</1(5! +3! '! (+E%6?! E'33%:nl! =$%! 5D%3(! $%:! .%%I%30! +3! ($%! 4+(?! <:134$+3;8! 6134$+3;8! '30! ,+5+(+3;! E15%1E5! e#$%! #+;! ./160!<%!5/!D:/10f@!Y1(!($%! :%'6!E/E%3(!e'30!K9E!51:%! +(!.'5!'!E/E%3(f!/441::%0! /3!>%<:1':?!OP@ !!!!*%3%:'6!4/35%3515!+5!($'(! ÀIWHHQ JXHVWV ZHUH LQ DWWHQ2 0'34%8! 4%6%<:+(?! 5(?6+5(! '30! Z':I6%!

Y>>! R%55+4'! Z16:/3%?! '30! ($%!

*1+33%55!S/:60!T%4/:0!&/60%:!7/:! 6/3;!<%%3!7'54+3'(%0!<?!($%!7:+%302 E/5(!.%00+3;!:%4%D(+/35!W:+?'3I'! 5$+D! <%(.%%3! Z%;$'3! '30! =%:%3'!

F$/D:'! ':%! D:%51E%0! '((%30%%5@! '30!$',%!'!6/(!(/!5'?!'</1(!+(8!<1(!

K966! 5',%! ($'(! 7/:! '3/($%:! ':(+46%@! L<+;'+6! =D%34%:8! $%:!=1+(5!4/25(':!.'5!5D/(2 (%0! '::+,+3;! '(! ($%! Z':I! &/(%6!o($%!5%((+3;!7/:!($+5!

E/31E%3('6!%,%3(!o!.+($!

Z%;$'38! ($15! 5$%! .+66! /<2 ,+/156?! <%! +3! '((%30'34%! '(! ($%! D':2('?! eb/3;! 6+,%! =1+(5llf@! K9E! 5%30+3;! ($+5! ':(+46%! (/! Z%;$'395! D%/D6%!

L=LW8! '30! $/D%7166?! ($%?!

ZLOO ÀQG LW WR EH IDYRUDEOH DQG VHFUHWO\ Á\ PH WR WKH D':(?@ ! ! ! ! )37/:(13'(%6?8! '(! ($%! (+E%! /7 ! .:+(+3;! ($+5! ':2 (+46%8! ($%:%! ':%! 3/! E/:%!

0%('+65! (/! <%! 7/130! '</1(! ($%!<'<?!5$/.%:!(/!%30!'66! <'<?! 5$/.%:5@! &/.%,%:8!

-,%&$"'4(,/ (<,<'%F#&=9,1 e$/D%7166?f! '66! 0%('+65! .+66! :'*F#"%05"BB6>(%/35%6>%]^GX <%!:%,%'6%0!<?!($%!(+E%!($+5! +5!D:+3(%08!5/!K9E!;/+3;!(/!

Z?!;1%5(!/7 !$/3/:!+5!/<,+/156?!($%! %30! ($+5! D+%4%! .+($! E?! E/5(! .+60!

6%;%30':?! =%:%3'! S+66+'E5@! K! $',%! D:%0+4(+/35! '</1(! Z%;$'395! 4%62

%<:'(+/3!'30!$/D%!($'(!K9E!0%%E%0! '!D5?4$+4!+3!($%!3%':!71(1:%]!LE'6!

F6//3%?!.'5!+3!'((%30'34%!'30!5$%! <:/1;$(!'!</((6%!/7 !F'5'E+;/5!(%2 H1+6'@!=%:%3'!S+66+'E5!'30!Z%;$'3!

Z':I6%! <%6(%0! /1(! "=$'66/.-! 01:2 +3;! I':'/I%! $/1:! e?%58! ($%:%! .'5! '! I':'/I%! $/1:f@! W:+?'3I'! F$/D:'! $'30%0! /1(! (+4I%(5! (/! ($%! R/3'5!

Y:/($%:5! :%13+/3! (/1:@! ='E'3($'!

Z':I6%8! '! :%'626+7%! %,+6! 5(%D25+5(%:8! (:+%0! (/! <:%'I! +3! <1(! .'5! 5(/DD%0! <?! 5%41:+(?@! K(! .'5! 6'(%:! :%,%'6%0! ($'(! 5$%! .'5! E+490! 1D! '30! /3! '3!

130%:4/,%:!E+55+/3!7/:!QGl!E';'2 U+3%@! Z/5(! +ED/:('3(6?8! Z%;$'3! $'0!'!6/,%6?!(+E%!5+DD+3;!E/4I('+65!

'30!D:%(%30+3;!5$%!.'5!/3%!/7 !($%! =%_! '30! ($%! F+(?! ;+:65@! L6($/1;$8!

5$%! '30! Z16:/3%?! 0+0! ;%(! +3(/! '3! ':;1E%3(!/,%:!.$+4$!/7 !($%E!.'5! ($%!"F'::+%-!/7 !($%!;:/1D@

@%,;V\%M01'*%J'##/5%76>'#%[*'45 :'((6"%7#')"*5$%+,; -.+"/ (!"#$%&"'()*+$,& ?#'(@<+A+,A'(,A(B,C+"' !!!!!#$%!PO5(!L4'0%E?!L.':05!':%!5%(!(/!'+:!($+5!1D4/E+3;! =130'?8!>%<:1':?!A`($8!'(!($%!d/6<?!#$%'(%:!+3!b/5!L3;%6%5@!

7KH VKRZ ZLOO EH WKH JUDQG ÀQDOH WR DQ DZDUGV VHDVRQ WKDW $'5!5%%3!E/:%!0+5/:;'3+U%0!4$'/5!($'3!E?!0/:E!://E!01:2 LQJ ÀQDOV ZHHN 7KHUH DUH D FRXSOH QRWDEOH VFUHZ XSV , FDQ E%3(+/3!+3!'3(+4+D'(+/3!/7 !($%!5$/.!2!+(5!$/5(6%5523%55!'30! ($%!5/4+'6!E%0+'!1D:/':!/,%:!41((+3;!/1(!4%:('+3!'.':05!

7:/E!($%!6+,%!<:/'04'5(8!(/!3'E%!'!7%.!2!<1(!K!.+66!+32 5(%'0! 7/415! /3! ($%! '.':05! '(! $'30@! ! &%:%! +5! '! ;1+0%! (/!($%!<+;!'.':05!/7 !($%!3+;$(8!'30!E?!.%662%014'(%0!

D:%0+4(+/35! /3! ($%E! '66! e($'3I58! ='3('8! 7/:! E?! LZF! ;+7(!4':0f@!

J"05%U6153*"9! h/E+3%%5]!"Y6'4I!W'3($%:8-!"Y6'4GIG6'35E'38-"#$%! >',/1:+(%8-! "L! =(':! K5! Y/:38-! "a+4%8-! "Y/$%E+'3!

T$'D5/0?8-!"*:%%3!Y//I-!

L)/%L6##%L6>]!*:%%3!Y//I L)/%G/3#2%L6>9!T/E' .)/3#2%L6>8%6>%=$%"05""="2%/B6>6/>]!L!=(':!+5!Y/:3 !!!!!#$%!Y%5(!W+4(1:%!'.':0!+5!.+0%!/D%3@!K7 !?/1!4/35+0%:!

D ÀOP·V ORQJ WHUP LPSDFW ERWK FRPPHUFLDOO\ DQG FULWL2 4'66?8!($%3!($%!/36?!(./!4/3(%30%:5!5$/160!<%!"L!=(':!+5!

Y/:3-!'30!"Y6'4I!W'3($%:-@!!&/.%,%:8!($%!'.':05!5%'2 VRQ KDV EHHQ NLQG WR QHLWKHU SRSXODU ÀOP DQG WKH DFDGHP\ ./30%:5!.$?!'10+%34%5!3/!6/3;%:!.'(4$!($%!4%:%E/3?@!F:+(+2 FDOO\ SDQQHG ÀOPV OLNH WKH SUREOHPDWLF ´*UHHQ %RRNµ RU WKH 4/3(:/,%:5+'6! e<1(! '0E+((%06?! 713f! "Y/$%E+'3! T$'D5/0?-!

VHHP OLNH WKH\ FDQ VOLGH LQ DQG ZLQ WKLV FDWHJRU\ 1HWÁL[·V "T/E'-!./3!($%!YL>#L!'30!d+:%4(/:95!*1+60!L.':08!<1(!

K9E! 3/(! 51:%! ($%! '4'0%E?! .+66! '.':0! ($%! 5(:%'E+3;! 5%:,+4%! .+($!($%!D:%5(+;+/15!.+3!J15(!?%(@!

J"05%@15/*9 h/E5]! F$:+5(+'3! Y'6%8! "a+4%-m! Y:'06%?! F//D%:8! "L! =(':! K5!

Y/:3-m! S+66%E! d'7/%8! "L(! V(%:3+(?95! *'(%-m! T'E+! Z'6%I8!

"Y/$%E+'3!T$'D5/0?-m!a+;;/!Z/:(%35%38!"*:%%3!Y//IL)/%L6##%L6>]!Z'6%I L)/%G/3#2%L6>]!Y'6% .)/3#2%L6>]!F//D%: !!!!!!&Q#!#LGV!LbVT#]!Z'6%I!+5!J15(!6+D25?34+3;!^1%%3!

5/3;5!K!0/!($'(!;%((+3;!:%'0?!7/:!46'55!%,%:?!0'?@!R15(!I+00+3;!

22!I+30!/7 !22!$%95!;:%'(!'5!>:%00+%8!<1(!/($%:!D%:7/:E'34%5!+3!

9,%&$"'4(,/ (?%A$"&(?#&&+'

:"_%5*$6>(%5/%86##%'%G//B"*%86>%6>5/%"`605">1"

($+5!4'(%;/:?!':%!E14$!E/:%!31'34%0!'30!E16(+26'?%:%0 J"05%.3BB/*56>(%@15*"00 h/E5]!LE?!L0'E58!"a+4%-m!Z':+3'!0%!#',+:'8!"T/E'-m!T%2 ;+3'!G+3;8!"K7 !Y%'6%!=(:%%(!F/160!#'6I-m!VEE'!=(/3%8!"#$%! >',/1:+(%-m!T'4$%6!S%+5U8!"#$%!>',/1:+(%L)/%L6##%L6>]!G+3; J"05%[6*"15/*9 L)/%G/3#2%L6>]!S%+5U h/E+3%%5]! =D+I%! b%%8! "Y6'4GIG6'35E'3-m! W'.%6! W'.2 .)/3#2%L6>]!'3?!/7 !'7/:%E%3(+/3%08!/:!VEE'!=(/3% 6+I/.5I+8!"F/60!S':-m!M/:;/5!b'3($+E/58!"#$%!>',/1:+(%-m! !!!!G+3;!5$/160!.+38!'30!K!$/D%!5$%!0/%5@!M%(!"#$%!>',/1:+(%-!

L67/35/!F1':/38!"T/E'-m!L0'E!Z4G'?8!"a+4%</'5(5! (./! ;:%'(! D%:7/:E'34%5! 7:/E! S%+5U! '30! =(/3%! ($'(!

L)/%L6##%L6>]!F1':/3 ':;1'<6?!E'I%!($%!E/,+%@!Z?!7',/:+(%!2!;%(!+(l!2!54%3%!7:/E!'!

L)/%G/3#2%L6>9!b'3($+E/5 ANOX!E/,+%!.'5!S%+5U95!$%':(<:%'I+3;!D6%'!(/!^1%%3!L33%! .)/3#2%L6>]!b'3($+E/5 DW WKH FOLPD[ RI WKH ÀOP DQG 6WRQH·V SHUIRUPDQFH DUJXDEO\ 4'::+%5!($%!%3(+:%!3'::'(+,%!':4!/7 !($%!E/,+%@!

J"05%@15*"009 h/E5]!M'6+(U'!LD':+4+/8!"T/E'-m!*6%33!F6/5%8!"#$%!S+7%-m! J"05%.3BB/*56>(%@15/* Q6+,+'! F/6E'38! "#$%! >',/1:+(%-m! b'0?! *';'8! "L! =(':! K5! h/E5]! Z'$%:5$'6'! L6+8! "*:%%3! Y//I-m! L0'E! d:+,%:8!

Y/:3-m!Z%6+55'!Z4F':($?8!"F'3!M/1!V,%:!>/:;+,%!Z%n"Y6'4GIG6'35E'3-m! ='E! V66+/((8! "L! =(':! K5! Y/:3-m! T+4$2 L)/%L6##%L6>9!F6/5% ':0!V@!*:'3(8!"F'3!M/1!V,%:!>/:;+,%!Z%n-m!='E!T/4I.%668!

L)/%G/3#2%L6>]!*';' "a+4%.)/3#2%L6>]!#$%?!'66!0%5%:,%!+(!$/3%5(6?

L)/%L6##%L6>]!L6+ !!!!K9E!5%:+/15@!#$%?9:%!'66!:%'66?!;:%'(!D%:7/:E'34%5@!K(95!$':0! L)/%G/3#2%L6>]!V66+/(( (/!D+4I8!<1(!K!./16039(!<%!51:D:+5%0!+7 !F/6E'3!5D6+(!($%!*';'g .)/3#2%L6>]!V66+/(( F6/5%!,/(%!7/:!$%:!(1:3!'5!^1%%3!L33%!+3!"#$%!>',/1:+(%@-! !!!!!V66+/((!+5!'3!130%:0/;8!<1(!($%!54%3%!.$%:%!$%!<'4I5!/1(!/7 !

($%!0:+,%.'?!4:?+3;!+5!5/!;//0!K!$',%!(/!5$/1(!+(!/1(@!

M*6(6>'#%.1*"">B#'$ h/E5]!"#$%!>',/1:+(%8-!d%</:'$!d',+58!#/3?!Z4h'E':'m! ">+:5(!T%7/:E%08-!W'16!=4$:'0%:m!"*:%%3!Y//I8-!h+4I!a'62 6%6/3;'8!Y:+'3!F1::+%8!W%(%:!>'::%66?m!"T/E'8-!L67/35/!F1'2 :/3m!"a+4%8-!L0'E!Z4G'?

L)/%L6##%L6>]!#$%!>',/1:+(%!

L)/%G/3#2%L6>]!>+:5(!T%7/:E%0 .)/3#2%L6>]!#$%!>',/1:+(% !!!!Y/!Y1:3$'E95!"V+;$($!*:'0%-!.'5!5$/4I+3;6?!531<<%0! <?!($%!L4'0%E?!($+5!?%':8!'30!K!($+3I!($'(!4/160!$',%! ./3!($+5!?%':m!+3!+(5!5(%'08!"#$%!>',/1:+(%-!.'5!$%':(2 <:%'I+3;8!7133?8!'30!D:/,/4'(+,%@!#$%!;1?!.$/!.:/(%! "#'_+!d:+,%:-!'65/!.:/(%!">+:5(!T%7/:E%0-!5/!E'?<%! ($%!L4'0%E?!.+66!(/55!W'16!=4$:'0%:!5/E%!6/,%@! @2'B5"2%.1*"">B#'$ h/E5]! "#$%! Y'66'0! /7 ! Y15(%:! =4:1;;58-! R/%6! F/%3! 8!

V($'3! F/%3m! "Y6'4GIG6'35E'38-! F$':6+%! S'4$(%68! d',+0! T'<+3/.+(U8! G%,+3! S+66E/((8! =D+I%! b%%m! "F'3!

M/1!V,%:!>/:;+,%!Z%n8-!h+4/6%!&/6/74%3%:!'30!R%77 !

S$+((?m! "K7 ! Y%'6%! =(:%%(! F/160! #'6I8-! Y'::?! R%3I+35m!

"L!=(':!K5!Y/:38-!V:+4!T/($8!Y:'06%?!F//D%:8!S+66!>%(2 (%:5 L)/%L6##%L6>]!F'3!M/1!V,%:!>/:;+,%!Z% L)/%G/3#2%L6>9!#$%!Y'66'0!/7 !Y15(%:!=4:1;;5 .)/3#2%L6>]!F'3!M/1!V,%:!>/:;+,%!Z% !!!!!#$%!L4'0%E?!6/,%5!($%!F/%3!<:/($%:58!5/!Y15(%:! =4:1;;5!4/160!5H1%'I!/1(!'!.+38!<1(!Z%6+55'!Z4F':($?95!0:'2 E'!'</1(!7/:;%:!b%%!K5:'%6!0%5%:,%5!+(@! [/13=">5'*$ h/E5]!">:%%!=/6/8-"&'6%!F/13(?!#$+5!Z/:3+3;8!#$+5!V,%2 3+3;8-!"Z+30+3;!($%!*'D8-"Q7 !>'($%:5!'30!=/358-!"TY*8L)/%L6##%L6>]!TY* L)/%G/3#2%L6>9!!Z+30+3;!($%!*'D .)/3#2%L6>9!TY* L!0/4!'</1(!TY*!0%5%:,%5!5/E%!6/,%8!3%%0!K!5'?!E/:%n! @>6='5"2%7"'53*" h/E5]! "K34:%0+<6%5! A8-! "K56%! /7 ! d/;58-! "Z+:'+8-! "T'6D$!

Y:%'I5!($%!K3(%:3%(8-!"=D+0%:2Z'3]!K3(/!($%!=D+0%:2a%:5%8L)/%L6##%L6>]!=D+0%:2Z'3]!K3(/!($%!=D+0%:2a%:5% L)/%G/3#2%L6>]!K34:%0+<6%5!A .)/3#2%L6>]!!=D+0%:2Z'3]!K3(/!($%!=D+0%:2a%:5% !!!!!L!=D+0%:2a%:5%!.+3!5%%E5!'6E/5(!+3%,+('<6%!'(!($+5!D/+3(8!

'30!+(!5$/160!<%!22!($%!E/5(!:%4%3(!+(%:'(+/3!/7 !($%!7:+%306?!

3%+;$</:$//0! .%<256+3;%:! +5! '! ;'E%24$'3;%:! 7/:! </($! ($%!

'3+E'(%0!7%'(1:%!4'(%;/:?!'30!($%!51D%:$%:/!;%3:%@!>13!7'4(! $ 6SLGHU 9HUVH ZLQ ZRXOG EH WKH ÀUVW IRU 6RQ\ 3LFWXUHV '3+E'(+/3@!#$%!/36?!D/(%3(+'6!4/3(%30%:!!+5!K34:%0+<6%5!A8!'30! ($'(!.+3!./160!<%!'!E'J/:!1D5%(!4/35+0%:+3;!=D+0%:2a%:5%95!

4:+(+4'6!'30!4/EE%:4+'6!'446'+E@!

EGGPLANT

The Spire

February 22, 2019 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

#$%!&''()*+,!! !"#$%&'(#)*$%+,'('-+.$/+0# 7,80%+,!9%*),$!:;:<!-$*,!=28!>%%0!,2!?+26!@A28,! ,$%!@BCDEF!E8,A5%*G 1%H%!7,2A3 6(17# !!!D23%!6#0!#,!2!$#3%5!#.%!4%%.! .%&2)/3%$6! 2((%-)%5! 46! )*%! ,%-%.)! #0)4,%2@! #( ! ZKFVYE'! #.! -217 SXV" <RX PD\ EH HQWLWOHG WR À QDQ -/2$! -#1=%.'2)/#.;! 4%-20'%! )*#'%! =%#=$%! -2..#)! *%2,! 4,#@%9! +/)*! )*%!')2,)!#( !)*%!'=,/.&!'%1%')%,;!/)! '%%1'!2'!)*#0&*!%3%,6!'/.&$%!=%,7 '#.!#.!-21=0'!*2'!4%%.!/1=2-)7 %5! 46! ZKFVYE'9! [#8! 6#0! 126!

4%! 2'@/.&;! 8*2)! /'! IZKFVYERJ! ZKFVYE! ')2.5'! (#,! Z0)#12)/-!

K.(%-)/#.! F%$2)%5! )#! V#3%,)6! 2.5!

Y3%,2$$!E%1#&,2=*/-9!K)!/'!2!3%,6! '%,/#0'! -#.5/)/#.! )*2)! 2((%-)'! \! =%,-%.)! #( ! 2$$! Z1%,/-2.'9! A-/7 %.)/')'! 2,%! 0.'0,%! *#8! )*%! D#$6! ",#''!-21=0'!/'!24$%!)#!#3%,-#1%! )*%! #55'! 2.5! 4%2)! )*%! .2)/#.2$! =%,-%.)2&%9! K)! Q0')! &#%'! )#! '*#8! )*2)!8%!2'!2!-21=0'!-2.!4%-#1%!

1#,%9

!!!!![#8;!6#0!126!4%!2'@/.&!6#0,7 '%$(;!8*2)!-2.!K!5#!)#!23#/5!)#!(2$$7 /.&!3/-)/1!)#!)*%!ZKFVYE' #0)4,%2@R! +%$$! )#! ')2,);! 5#! 6#0! #8.!2.6!=,#50-)'!125%!46!2!(,0/)!

-#1=2.6R!"$/./-2$!,%'%2,-* *2'! '*#8.! )*2)! /.5/3/502$'! 8*#! #8.! #.%! #,! 1#,%! (,0/)!-#1=2.6!=,#57 XFWV DUH À YH WLPHV 1#,%! $/@%$6! )#! -2)-*!

ZKFVYE'! N"*%( ! ]! +#,@';! ^_\`O9! Y.%! #( !)*%!1#,%!/1=2-)7 (0$! ')2)/')/-'! '*#8'! )*2)! /.5/3/502$'! 8*#!

(2$$!/.)#!2!*/&*%,!)2<!

4,2-@%)! 2,%! 10-*!

1#,%! '0'-%=)/4$%! )#! #4)2/./.&!ZKFVYE'!

2'! )*%/,! a4,#@%?! -#0.)%,=2,)'! N>6!

F##112)%;! ^_\bO9! K! (#,! #.%! 21! '*#-@%5! )*2)! /.5/3/502$'! 8/)*! 2!

10-*!1#,%!5/'=#'24$%!/.-#1%!2,%!

24$%!)#!/.3%')!/.!c\d_!*%25=*#.%'9!

Z'! D#$6! ",#'';! )*%! '*/./.&! 4%27 -#.!#( !*#=%;!(2$$'!/.)#!)*%'%!-2)7 %&#,/%';!/)!'*#0$5.?)!4%!'0,=,/'/.&! )*2)!2!&,%2)!.014%,!#( !=%#=$%!#.!

-21=0'! *23%! )*/'! ),0$6! /.(%-)/#0'!

5/'%2'%9!! !!!!!+*2)!2,%!'#1%!'61=)#1'!2.5!

-#.5/)/#.'!#( !ZKFVYE'R!Y.%!#( ! )*%!1#')!&$2,/.&!'61=)#1'!/'!)*2)! )*#'%!/.(%-)%5!-2.!.#!$#.&%,!a*%2,!

4,#@%9?!C*/'!/'!'0-*!2!'-2,6!5/'%2'%!

4%-20'%! /)! 2((%-)'! )*%! =%,-%=)/#.!

#( ! '#0.5! 823%'! 46! 5/')/.&0/'*7 /.&!)*%!=/)-*!2.5!(,%G0%.-6!(,#1! '#1%#.%! 8*#! *2'! ZKFVYE'!

2.5! '#1%#.%! 8*#! 5#%'! .#);! -2)7 %&#,/e%5! 2'! a4,#@%9?! C*%! -#.5/7 )/#.! 2$'#! /1=2-)'! '#-/2$! 4%*23/#,!

2'! )*#'%! 8/)*! )*%! 5/'%2'%! )%.5! )#!

-#.&,%&2)%!)#&%)*%,!/.! #,5%,! )#! =,%3%.)! -#.7 )2-)! 8/)*! )*%! a4,#@%9?!

P#,!.#8;!/)!'%%1'!)*2)! )*%! #0)4,%2@! #( ! )*%!

5/'%2'%! 2.5! /)'! %((%-)'!

2,%! *2,5! )#! )%$$9! Y.! )*%!#.%!*2.5;!/)!#((%,'!

2! */&*%,! G02$/)6! #( ! '#0.5! (#,! 10'/-! 2.5!

-2$$';!40)!#.!)*%!#)*%,! *2.5! /)! 5#%'! '%%1! )#! )0,.!=%#=$%!/.)#!24'#7 $0)%!)##$'9!!!!! !!!!!C#!'=%2@!(,#1!2!=%,'#.2$!=%,7 '=%-)/3%;! K! (#0.5! )*2)! )*/'! #0)7 4,%2@! 82'! '=,%25/.&! 10-*! 1#,%! ,2=/5$6! 8/)*/.! )*%! =2')! 1#.)*9! K)!

/'!2!),2&%56!)*2)!K;!2!1%,%!Z3%,2&%!

U#%! 0'/.&! 8/,%5! *%25=*#.%';! -2.! .#! $#.&%,! -#110./-2)%! 8/)*! 16!

4%$#3%5! (,/%.5'! 2'! K! (2$$! /.)#! )*%! a4,#@%?! 5%1#&,2=*/-! 8/)*! 8*/-*! )*%! 5/'%2'%! =,%3%.)'! -#110./7 FDWLRQ $V , UHÁ HFW RQ P\ H[SH ,/%.-%;!K!21!*#=/.&!(#,!2!-0,%!)#! )*/'!28(0$!-#.5/)/#.9!K?3%!'%%.!)##!

12.6!&##5!=%#=$%;!.#!$#.&%,!24$%! )#! 0'%! 8/,%5! *%25=*#.%';! (2$$/.&!

3/-)/1! )#! )*%! =%%,! =,%''0,%! #( !

ZKFVYE'!2.5!4%-#1/.&!Q0') 2.#)*%,! =%,'#.! /1=2-)%59! F%7 '%2,-*%,'!2,%!'*#8/.&!=,#1/'%!(#,!

2!-0,%!2'!/)!'%%1'!)*/'!/'!#.$6!2 ),%.5! 2.5! =%#=$%! 8/$$! &%)! '/-@! #( ! *23/.&! )8#! 5#.&$%'! *2.&/.&! #0)! #( !)*%/,!%2,'9!V%,*2='!#.%!526; 8%! 2'! 2! '#-/%)6! 8/$$! 4%! (,%%! (,#1!

ZKFVYE'9

#$%!=%*5!-.,$28,!*!7+26!F*I -.)).*/!*+0!12$+32+!45263%5 !12100+3$4"+5&* !!!!!! ! ! ! ! ! "#$$%&%'! #( ! )*%! +#,-%')%,! "#.'#,)/01! *23%! 4%%.! (#,-%5!

6%2,! 2()%,! 6%2,! )#! -$#'%! (2-/$/)/%'!

2.5!-2.-%$!-$2''%'!50%!)#!/.-$%17 %.)! 8%2)*%,9! :0);! )*/'! 2-25%1/-!

6%2,!1/&*)!4%!)*%!%<-%=)/#.9!>/.7 /12$! '.#8(2$$! *2'! #--0,,%5! 2.5! /)! 5#%'.?)! $##@! $/@%! )*2)! /'! &#/.&! )#! -*2.&%! 4%(#,%! A=,/.&! :,%2@!

-#1%'!2$#.&9!B/3%.!)*%'%!-/,-017 ')2.-%';! 251/./'),2)#,'! 2)! C*%! "#$$%&%! #( ! )*%! D#$6! ",#''! *23%!

-#1%! )#&%)*%,! 2.5! 0.2./1#0'$6!

5%-/5%5! )#! 5%'/&.2)%! 2)! $%2')! #.%!

-$2''!526!)*/'!'%1%')%,!2'!2!'.#8!

5269! +%! 5%-/5%5! )#! )2@%! )#! )*%! '),%%)'! 2.5! &20&%! =%#=$%?'! #=/.7 /#.'!#.!)*%!2..#0.-%1%.)9

! ! ! ! ! E/,%-)#,! #( ! D#0'/.&;! F62.!

B,2.);! 82'! G0#)%5! /.! ,%&2,5! )#! )*%'%!=$2.'H!IC*2)?'!2!,%-/=%!(#, 5/'2')%,9J!:0);!#)*%,'!/.!)*%!-#17 10./)6!*23%!%$/-/)%5!5/(7 (%,%.)! ,%'=#.'%'9! K32.2! #( !L#8%,!M/142$$?'!D27 42.%,#'! 82'! #3%,*%2,5!

'26/.&;! IA.#8! 526'! 2,%! )*%! 4%');! K! 5#.?)! *23%!

2.6! =,#4$%1! 8/)*! )*/'! '#$0)/#.9J! ! C*%! $%257 %,! #( ! )*%! -*2,&%! (#,! 2! =,%7'-*%50$%5! '.#8! 526!

N8*%)*%,!)*%,%?'!'.#8!#,! .#)O;! P,9! :#,#0&*';! %<7 =$2/.%5!)*2);!I8%!2$826'! )%$$! #0,! -21=0'! -#110./)6! )#!

2'@!1#,%!2.5!4%!1%.!2.5!8#1%.! (#,!#)*%,';!8%$$!K!)*/.@!8%!-2.!2$$!

2&,%%! &/3/.&! %3%,6#.%! 2! '=#.)27

.%#0'! 526! #(( ! /'! )*%! 4%')! 826! )#!

5#!)*2)9J!+*%.!2'@%5!)#!%$24#,2)%! #.!*/'!G0#)%;!:#,#0&*'!,%'=#.57 %5;! I$##@;! 8%! 2$$! Q0')! 82.)! 2! 526!

!!!!!!!T.'0,=,/'/.&$6;!0.$/@%!)*%!(2-7 0$)6! 2.5! ')2((;! ')05%.)'! *23%! *25!

2$1#')!%.)/,%$6!=#'/)/3%!,%'=#.'%'! )#! )*%! =$2.9! +%! )2$@%5! )#! U0./#,;!

V2)!>0$$%,6;!8*#!,%7 12,@%5;! I2***! W'/-X! $##@'!$/@%!2.!%<),2 ./&*)! )#! &#! #0)9! K! $#3%! )*%! /5%29! K! Q0')! *#=%! K! 5#.?)! (2$$!

5#8.! 2.6! */$$'9J! Y)*%,'! )#0)%5! )*%! À QHU GHWDLOV OLNH KDY /.&!1#,%!)/1%!)#!5#! *#1%8#,@! #,! -2)-*!

0=!#.!10-*!.%%5%5! ,%')9!D#8%3%,;!)*%,%! #(( !#.!2!,2.5#1!C0%'5269!"#1%! 8%,%!'#1%!5/''%.)%,'9!A#=*#1#,%! #.9!+*2)!%$'%!5#!6#0!82.)!1%!)#! U#%! E#%,,! *25! 2! 1#,%! -6./-2$!

'26RJ!P,2.@$6;!8%!2)!)*%!S&&=$2.)! 3/%8;!'26/.&;!I*#)!)2@%;!40)!'.#8!

-#0$5.?)!2&,%%!1#,%9 526'! 2,%! '#! #3%,,2)%5;! 8%! 5#.?)!

.%%5!2.69J !!!!!Y3%,2$$;!2&,%%!8/)*!/)!#,!.#);! )*/'!/'!)*%!5/,%-)/#.!)*%!-#$$%&%!/'! &#/.&9!Y.%!-2.!#.$6!8#.5%,H +*%,%! 5#%'! /)! ')#=R! +*#?'! )#!

'26! 8%! 5#.?)! *23%! )8#! #,! )*,%%! =,%7'-*%50$%5! '.#8! 526'! /.! )*%!

(0)0,%R! ! A#1%! ,25/-2$! /5%2$/')'! *23%! %3%.! '0&&%')%5! 12@/.&! 2!

I'.#8! 526J! 4%-#1%! )*%! 5%(20$)! (,#1!)*%!4%&/../.&!#( !)*%!'%1%'7 )%,! 0.)/$! '=,/.&! 4,%2@;! 2.5! #.$6! #.!,2,%!#--2'/#.'!*23%!2!I'-*##$!

5269J!K.!)*%!%.5!)*%'%!5/'-0''/#.'!

2,%!Q0')!#.%!%<21=$%!#( !)*%!4,/$7 $/2.)! /..#32)/#.! &#/.&! #.! /.! #0,!

-#110./)6;!2.5!8%!'*#0$5!2$$!2=7 =,%-/2)%!/)9

C2,/*+3!C2AA%5I J*5.2!J.K*))%L !MNN 89',1( !!!!!![%8!S.&$2.5?'!L2,&%')!P0,7 ./)0,%!')#,%!aF#)12.'?!-$2/1'!)*2)! )*%6! *23%! 4%%.! ,#44%59! +%! '%.)! #0,! )#=! ,%=#,)%,! )#! &%)! '#1%! /.7 (#,12)/#.! #.! )*%! -2'%9! C#1/')*%!

C*%/(U#.%'!'=#@%!8/)*!)*%!12.2&7 %,!#( !F#)12.'!)#!&%)!*%,!)2@%!#.! )*%!12))%,H

)0,%! -#$$%-)/#.! *2'! 4%%.! ')#$%.9! )*2)!1/&*)!/1=$%1%.)!'#1%#.%!/.! )*2)! '/1=$%R! Z,%! 6#0! '26/.&! F#)7 E#!6#0!*23%!2.6!-21%,2'!0=!)*2)! )*%!-,/1%R 12.'!')#$%!)*%!(0,./)0,%!(,#1 1/&*)! *23%! -20&*)! )*%! )*/%3%'! /.! )*%/,!#8.!')#,%R 2-)/#.R A0e2..%H! Z4'#$0)%$6! .#)g! +*6!

A0e2..%H! +%$$! 6%';! 8%! 5#! 40)!

8#0$5!8%!5#!)*2)R )*%6! 2,%! Q0')! (#,! '*#8! '#! 8%!

5/5.?)!2-)02$$6!,%-#,5!8*#!')#$%!

C#1/')*%! C*%/(U#.%'H! >264%! #0,!1%,-*2.5/'%9 )*%!=,%''0,%!#( !4%/.&![%8!S.7 &$2.5?'! 4/&&%')! (0,./)0,%! ')#,%!

C#1/')*%! C*%/(U#.%'H! K?1! .#)! &#)!)#!6#09!+*#!%$'%!8#0$5!,#4!

'0,=,/'%59! C*#'%! )*/.&'! ,%2$$6!

6#0,!(0,./)0,%!8/)*!2!&2.&!(,#1!

5#.?)!%3%.!'%%1!8#,)*!/)!,/&*)R "2.252R

C#1/')*%! C*%/(U#.%'H! D%$$#9! f#0!

2,%!)*%!12.2&%,!#( !)*%!')#,%!-#,7 ,%-)R A0e2..%H! +%$$! /.! */.5'/&*)! 8%! '*#0$5!*23%!Q0')!'=%.)!)*%!1#.%6!

A0e2..%H!D%$$#;!6%'!)*2)!/'!-#,,%-)9! (#,!,%2$!-21%,2'9 >6!.21%!/'!A0e2..%9 C#1/')*%! C*%/(U#.%'H! D23%! )*%!

C#1/')*%! C*%/(U#.%'H! f#0! 2,%! =#$/-%! '2/5! )*2)! )*%6! *23%! (#0.5!

-$2/1/.&! )*2)! *2$( ! #( ! 6#0,! (0,./7 DQ\ À QJHUSULQWV RU RWKHU HYLGHQFH

)*%! )*/%3%'! )*2)! ,2.'2-@%5! 6#0,! ')#,%!/.!0.5%,!)*,%%!*#0,'R A0e2..%H! +*#%3%,! 5/5! )*/'! *%/7 .#0'! 5%%5;! Q0')! @.#8! )*2)! )*%,%! /'! .#)*/.&! 6#0! -2.! 5#! )#! 4,/.&!

5#8.! )*%! '#0$! #( ! )*/'! -/)69! F#)7 12.'! 4,/.&'! 0=*#$')%,6! Q#6! 2.5! À QDQFLDO REOLJDWLRQV WR VR PDQ\ (21/$/%'9

C#1K')*%!C*%/(U#.%'H![%<)!)/1%;! '#1%! 1/&*)! '26! (#,! 6#0! )#! 0'%! 2!

-*2/.%5!$#-@!/.')%25!#( !40.&%% A0e2..%H!C*%6!*23%.?)!(#0.5!2.6! !A0e2..%H!K?3%!.%3%,!%3%.!4%%.!)#! -#,5'! )#! '%-0,%! )*/'! =$2-%! 0=9! K! 4%'/5%'! #0,! #8.! =,/.)'9! K.! (2-);! "2.252g!D#8!8#0$5!K!@.#8!)*2)! &0%''! 8%! 8/$$! .%3%,! @.#8! 8*#!

2--#,5/.&!)#!)*%!=#$/-%!1#')!#( )*%6!*23%!(0,./)0,%!)*%,%R -#11/))%5! )*/'! =##,! 5h-#,! 40,7 )*%! %3/5%.-%! /'! =/$/.&! 0=! 2&2/.')! &$2,69 0'g C#1/')*%!C*%/(U#.%'H!Y*!4%$/%3%!

1%;!)*%6!5#!.#89!K'!)*%,%!2.6)*/.&!

C#1/')*%!C*%/(U#.%'H!"#0$5!/)!4%! )*2)!6#0!8#0$5!$/@%!)#!'26!)#

10

The Spire

678$#9

SPORTS

February 22, 2019

:"9*;"33(<7*=9(6*"98=()%#+( 6>**7(#8(?@A(:"438$

G''BH$-<;$!14>A+!)#*4+!P42-'34!-23! L-/!Q>S&9-2!-23!D$>'-2!)*&242C! X&*$+/! -+! -! <*-3;-/$! /*-2+:$*C! "#$!

G;+/42! Q-+$'?! .&/#! &: ! 9#&0! #4/! "#$! )*;+-3$*+! 94''! >$*/-42'(! 04++! /$-0! 94''! '&&A! :&*! 1*&3;>/4&2! &;/!

9$''! &I$*! CR66! '-+/! +$-+&2?! %&'(! D-22(!,-*'&A?!9#&!94''!.$!&;/!:&*! &: !V;24&*!Y-2$!%$3-(-!-23!+&1#&B !!!!!"#$!%&'(!)*&++!,-+$.-''!/$-0! &URVV ZDV SLFNHG WR Ã&#x20AC; QLVK WKLUG /#$! ($-*! 3;$! /&! "&00(! T&#2! +;*B 0&*$!H4-0!DI&*-A?!9#&!1&+/$3!-! &1$2$3! 4/+! 5678! +$-+&2! 94/#! :&;*! <-0$+! 3&92! 42! =->&?! "$@-+?! '-+/!

9$$A$23?!:->42<!&:: !-<-42+/!-!,-(B ORU WHDP WKDW LV UDQNHG Ã&#x20AC; IWHHQWK LQ /#$! >&;2/*(C! "#$! )*;+-3$*+! +;:B :$*$3! -! :&;*! <-0$! +9$$1?! +/*;<B <'42<! /&! A$$1! ;1! 94/#! /#$! #4<#B 1&9$*$3!.-/+!/#$!,$-*+!+#&9>-+$3!

-''! 9$$A$23! '&2<C! D$+14/$! /#$! *$+;'/+! -<-42+/! &2$! &: ! /#$! >&;2B /*(E+! /&1! >';.+?! /#$! )*;+-3$*+! -*$! .'&&042<! 94/#! 1*&04+$! /#4+! +$-B +&2!-23!94''!.$!'&&A42<!/&!+;*1*4+$! +&0$!/$-0+!-+!/#$(!>&2/42;$!/#$4*! /*41!3&92!+&;/#?!94/#!-!+$*4$+!/#4+!

9$$A$23! -<-42+/! FG,! :&''&9$3! +,#%#'-#.$%/&%'#1 '2#,#30-$#&&4-#5 .(! -! +/*$/>#! &: ! <-0$+! 42! H&;4+4B LH=%8$(&"#&+*$MB*9%1="#*B(+%##*$(N%3*4(I%O%=19#8=(>*=#(4"$B("1"%=9#(#+*(:"438$(:*"$9(3"9#(>**'*=BK -2-! &I$*! +1*42<! .*$-A?! #4<#'4<#/$3! .(! -! +#&93&92! 94/#! J&C! 5! HKFC!! ! ! ! ! ! H&&A42<! .$(&23! /#$! 2$@/! :$9!

9$$A+?! /#$! )*;+-3$*+! -*$! -40$3! -/!

0-A42<! -! *;2! :&*! -2&/#$*! L-/*4&/! 42! /#$! '$-<;$! .(! -! /$-0! &: ! 9*4/B <$*(C! U2! #4+! V;24&*! >-01-4<2?! ,-*B RCZ6!WPG!42!-!*$'4$I$*!*&'$!'-+/!($-*C H$-<;$!/4/'$!M/#$!/$-0!9&2!/#$!L-/*4B $*+!-/!)&''$<$!,-+$.-''!D-4'(C!!"#$! '&A!1&+/$3!-2!42>*$34.'$!7CN5!WPG! !!!!!"#$!)*;+-3$*+!-40!/&!401*&I$! &/!H$-<;$!"&;*2-0$2/!-23!$-*2$3! /$-0!:$-/;*$+!-!I$/$*-2!'42$;1?!-23! '-+/! +$-+&2?! 9#4>#! '$3! /#$! 2-/4&2! ODVW VHDVRQ·V IRXUWK SODFH Ã&#x20AC; QLVK LQ -!.43!/&!/#$!J)GG!"&;*2-0$2/!42! #-+! -! 1-*/4>;'-*'(! +/*&2<! *&/-/4&2?! :&*! -! +/*$/>#C! %$! 94''! +4/! &;/! /#4+! /#$!'$-<;$?!#-I42<!<&2$!V;+/!77B7Z! 567NOC!!H$3!.(!-!1-4*!&: !L*$+$-+&2! :*&2/$3! .(! +$24&*! +/-*/42<! 14/>#$*+! ($-*! -23! 1'-(! 2$@/! ($-*! :&*! =-A$! 42! L-/*4&/! H$-<;$! 1'-(C! "#$! '$-<;$! !"#$%&'()"$*+",(-./ !"#$%&'()*%#$

:-I&*4/$!4+!;23&;./$3'(!G*0(?!>&0B 42<!&:: !-!3&042-2/!567[!+$-+&2!.(! <&42<!7[BN!42!'$-<;$!1'-(!-23!RNB5Z! &I$*-''?!-23!#4<#'4<#/$3!.(!.4<!942+! &I$*!'-*<$B>&2:$*$2>$!+>#&&'+!+;>#!

-+! Q4>#4<-2?! Q-*('-23?! -23! J)!

K/-/$C!"#$!,'->A!\24<#/+!94''!*$/;*2!

0&+/!&: !/#$4*!'42$;1?!-23!/#$4*!+/-*/B 42<!*&/-/4&2!:$-/;*$+!+$I$*-'!+$24&*!

I$/$*-2+C! "#$! &/#$*! /$-0! 14>A$3!

WR Ã&#x20AC; QLVK DKHDG RI +RO\ &URVV ZDV 1DY\ ZKR DOVR Ã&#x20AC; QLVKHG D VWURQJ 7[BN! 42! /#$! '$-<;$C! %&9$I$*?! /#$(! #-I$!'&+/!0;'/41'$!.-/+!42!/#$!043B 3'$!&: !/#$!'42$;1?!-23!-*$!42!-!0&*$!

I;'2$*-.'$! 1&+4/4&2! /#-2! G*0(C !!!!!P&;2342<!&;/!/#$!L-/*4&/!H$-<;$!

L*$+$-+&2!1&''!.$#423!%&'(!)*&++!

-*$! ,;>A2$''?! H$#4<#?! -23! H-:-(B $//$?! *$+1$>/4I$'(C! =#4'$! G*0(! #-+! $+/-.'4+#$3! 4/+$': ! -+! /#$! :-I&*4/$!

42! /#$! '$-<;$?! %&'(! )*&++! '&&A+! /&! <-42! +&0$! 0&0$2/;0! $-*'(! 42! /#$! 2&2B>&2:$*$2>$! +>#$3;'$C! U: ! /#$! 567]B7N! 4+! -2(! 4234>-/&*! M%)!

3$:$-/$3! FK)?! F)! P4I$*+43$?! -23!

FQ-++O?!A$(!942+!$-*'(!&2!0-(!(4$'3! +;>>$++!42!'$-<;$!1'-(!-23!.$(&23C

0*=-9("=B()8,*=-9(C$"&'("=B(2%*3B(:8#+( !3"&*(D#+("#(!"#$%8#9 (0"11%*(23"+*$#4(5./ !"#$%&'()*%#$

RI DQG Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDU (PLO\ !!!!!"#$!%&'(!)*&++!Q$2E+!"*->A!-23! \&;:&+! $-*2$3! -! 1$*+&2-'! *$>&*3! X4$'3!/$-0!1'->$3!]/#!-/!/#$!)#-0B 42!/#$!7666!0$/$*!*->$!94/#!-!7R/#! 14&2+#41! -+! 9$''?! 9#4>#! 9-+! /#$4*! !!!!!"#$!%&'(!)*&++!=&0$2E+!"*->A! 1'->$!/40$!&: !R_67_7ZC!K$24&*!G'$@! KLJKHVW Ã&#x20AC; QLVK DW WKH LQGRRU FKDP -23! X4$'3! /$-0! +#-//$*$3! 0;'/41'$! );*/42! .*&A$! 1$*+&2-'! *$>&*3+! 42! 14&2+#41+! +42>$! 567^C! "#$(! -'+&!

1$*+&2-'! *$>&*3+! '-+/! 9$$A$23! -/! .&/#! /#$! '&2<! V;01! -23! /#$! 566! #-3!/#$4*!:-4*!+#-*$!&: !1$*+&2-'!*$B /#$! L-/*4&/! H$-<;$! U23&&*! )#-0B 0$/$*!3-+#?!a;-'4:(42<!:&*!/#$!W-+/B >&*3+!+#-//$*$3!&I$*!/#$!9$$A$23C! 14&2+#41+!#$'3!-/!/#$!J-I-'!G>-3B $*2! )&''$<$! G/#'$/4>! )&2:$*$2>$! K&1#&0&*$!S-.$!L4$1$*<$3$+!-23! $0(!42!G22-1&'4+?!

T;24&*! X*$3B Q-*('-23C! "#$!

34$! %-''&*-2! )*;+-3$*+! +>&*$3! .&/#! .*&A$!

ZRC]]! 1&42/+! -23! /#$4*! &92!

1'->$3! +4@/#! &;/! *$>&*3+! 42! &: ! /$2! /$-0+! -/! /#$! ^66! 0$B /#$!0$$/C! /$*! *->$?! 94/#! !!!!!T;24&*!)-*&'42$!

L4$1$*<$*3$+!

X*$(!*-2!-!1$*+&2B 1'->42<! 76/#!

-'! .$+/! ^[C8! +$>B 94/#! -! /40$! &23+! 42! /#$! Z66! &: ! 7_6^_8R! 0$/$*! *->$?! 1'->B -23! %-'B 42<! 75/#! &I$*-''!

ORUDQ Ã&#x20AC; Q -/! /#$! >#-014&2B 4+#42<! +&&2! +#41C! K$24&*! H-;B / # $ * $ - : / $ *! *$2! P-+0;+! -'+&!

94/#! -2! 77/#! .*&A$! -! 1$*+&2-'!

1'->$!/40$!&: ! *$>&*3! 42! /#$! ^66!

7 _ 6 ] _ 6 6 C! +,#%#'-#.$%/&0'#1 '2#,#30-$#&&4-#5 K & 1 # & B PHWHU UDFH Ã&#x20AC; QLVK 42<! 42! N/#! 1'->$! 687+8,8$*(64B=*4(0&E8="3B(73"&*B(F$B(%=(#+*(+%1+(GH,7("#(#+*(!"#$%8#(I*"1H*( 0 & * $!

J+",7%8=9+%79K 94/#! -! /40$! &: !

Q 4 > # - $ '!

7_7]_^7! +$>&23+?!

L 4 > # - (!

ZKLOH Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDU '$3! /#$! \$'+$(!`E%-*-!-'+&!*-2!-!1$*+&2-'! MW)G)O! )#-014&2+#41+! 42! /#$! )*;+-3$*+! 42! /#$! /*41'$! V;01! 94/#! .$+/!42!/#$!+-0$!$I$2/!94/#!-!/40$! :&*0$*!94/#!-!^C[N!0$/$*!V;01!-23! -! +$>&23! 1'->$! +#&942<! &: ! 7ZCNN! &: ! 7_7[_57C! P-+0;+?! X*$(?! -23! Ã&#x20AC; QLVKLQJ WKH ODWWHU UDFH LQ PHWHUV 'DQ 'HPSVH\ SODFHG Ã&#x20AC; IWK `E%-*-!9$2/!&2!/&!*;2!/#$!Z@Z66! +$>&23+C!);*/42!-'+&!1'->$3![/#!42! 42!/#$!#4<#!V;01!94/#!-!'$-1!&: !7C[8!

0$/$*!*$'-(!*->$!'-/$*!&2!K;23-(!-:B /#$! ]6! 0$/$*! 3-+#! 94/#! -! /40$! &: ! 0$/$*+C! K$24&*! ,*-23&2! "#&*2#4''!

WHUQRRQ DORQJ ZLWK Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDU 0LOO\ NC[[!+$>&23+C!`/#$*!)*;+-3$*+!#-3! 1'->$3! +4@/#! 42! /#$! ]6! 0$/$*! 3-+#!

2·%ULHQ 7KH JURXS SODFHG Ã&#x20AC; IWK 2&/-.'$! +#&942<+! -/! /#$! )#-014B 94/#!-!/40$!&: ![_Z7!+$>&23+?!-23!+$B 94/#!-!/40$!&: !R_^Z_88C!K&1#&0&*$! &2+#41! -+! 9$''! B! +&1#&0&*$! G.B 24&*!G'$@!W+>-3-!1'->$3!]/#!42!/#$!

K(32$(! Q>D&2-'3! 1'->$3! R*3! 42! .4$! Q&A9;-#! 1'->$3! Z/#! 42! /#$! %$1/-/#'&2!94/#!Z?^N8!1&42/+C!"#$! /#$! #4<#! V;01! 94/#! -! 1$*+&2-'! *$B +#&/!1;/!94/#!-2!W)G)Ba;-'4:(42<! Z@[66! 0$/$*! *$'-(! /$-0! :$-/;*42<! >&*3!&: !7C]^!0$/$*+C! /#*&9!&: !7RC^R!0$/$*+?!-23!+&1#&B Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDUV :LOO +RUQ\DN DQG &RUH\ !!!!!"#$!*$>&*3+!3432E/!+/&1!/#$*$?! PRUH &KULVWD -D\ 0RRUH TXDOLÃ&#x20AC; HG \;0-0&/&! -23! +&1#&0&*$+! L$B $4/#$*!BB!+&1#&0&*$!Q-*42-!Q->\B :&*! W)G)+! 94/#! -! 1$*+&2-'! .$+/! /$*!Q4/>#$''!-23!%-(3$2!UI-//+!*-2!

422&2! 1&+/$3! -! 1$*+&2-'! *$>&*3B DQG VHFRQG SODFH Ã&#x20AC; QLVK RI PH Ã&#x20AC; QLVKLQJ LQ WK SODFH RYHU .*$-A42<!/40$!42!/#$![66!0$/$*!*->$! /$*+!42!/#$!1&'$!I-;'/C -''C!"#$!Z@Z66!0$/$*!*$'-(!/$-0!&: !

"#&*2#4''?!L4$*1$*<$*3$+?!%-''&*-2?!

DQG Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDU :LOO +RUQ\DN KDG D +$-+&2!.$+/!/40$!&: !R_56_^[?!$-*2B 42<! /#$0! ^/#! 1'->$! &I$*-''C! "#$!

34+/-2>$! 0$3'$(! *$'-(! >&01*4+$3!

RI VRSKRPRUH 3HWHU 0LWFKHOO Ã&#x20AC; UVW ($-*!)&*$(!\;0-0&/&?!-23!V;24&*+!

,&..(! ";bb4&! -23! T-A$! J$9/&2! *-2! -! +$-+&2! .$+/! 76_R6_]RC! ,&/#! )*;+-3$*!/$-0+!'&&A!-#$-3!/&!2$@/!

9$$A$23E+!,F!H-+/!)#-2>$!Q$$/C!

J"7*(J8B()*9#(P"$,8H#+( 6*"(QH33(:*"&+(R$*"(S8H9*( 2<N(NTUC VDWA(28$(SJ(J"7*()**' Q&3$*2?!L'$-+-2/!%&;+$?!K'$$1+!^?!=4BX4!U2/$*2$/?!

D4*$>"c?!H-23B'42$!L#&2$?!Gd)?!%$-/?!=-+#$*d D*($*?!Q&3$*2!\4/>#$2!-23!,-/#?!%-*39&&3!-23!

"4'$!X'&&*+?!J4>$!e-*3?!)4*>;'-*!D*4I$9-(?!G01'$!

L-*A42<?!D$+4*-.'$!K&;/#!&: !P&;/$!5[!H&>-/4&2?! %-': !Q4'$!

)"3'(#8(6*"(QH33(:*"&+("=B(#8(N*B(2"&*( L"&'-9(678$#9(:"$X S"9(:**=(N*=#*B(<H#(28$(S834(J$899(J"7*M 6*=%8$()**'(28$(08$*(C+"=(@/(P*"$9K(`/#$*!"40$!

L$*4&3+!U2!G1*4'dQ-(!G'+&!GI-4-.'$

N*=#"39(2$8,(J833*1*(6#HB*=#9(R$*(:8#+( Y"3H*B(R=B(R77$*&%"#*BK(!3*"9*(J"33(J+$%9( "#(ZD@[\(DW[]AAAA(8$(*,"%3(&#$"'"9^"83K&8,

The Spire

SPORTS

February 22, 2019

11

U:R(R33]6#"$()**'*=B(N*&"7 J+"$3*9(_$H,9%*'(5./ !"#$%&'()*%#$

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`A'-B -2/4>41-/$3! -+! /#$! '$-<;$! #-+! .$$2! !!!!!J&9?!9$!0&I$!&2/&!/#$!.4<<$+/! '$-<;$E+!.4<<$+/!+/-*+!-23!+/-*/$3!&:: ! #&0-! )4/(! "#;23$*E+! 3;2A! &I$*! /-A42<!0&*$!-23!0&*$!/#*$$+C!"#$! $I$2/! &: ! /#$! 9$$A$23_! /#$! ->/;-'!

94/#!-2!$@>4/42<!P4+42<!K/-*+!<-0$! &2! X*43-(! 24<#/C! "#$! 0-/>#;1! &: ! "$-0!FKG!-23!"$-0!=&*'3!+-9!-!

0-++4I$! &::$2+4I$! &;/1;/?! 1;2>/;B -/$3!.(!H-A$*+!+/-*!-23!<-0$!QcL! .\OH .X]PD ZKR Ã&#x20AC;QLVKHG ZLWK 1&42/+C! G:/$*! >&2+$>;/4I$! 942+! .(! "$-0! =&*'3! -23! /#$! -334/4&2! &: ! &2$! &: ! /#$! '$-<;$E+! 0&+/! $@>4/42<!

1*&+1$>/+?!H;A-!D&2>4>?!/#4+!<-0$!

1*&04+$3! $@>4/$0$2/C! U/! 3$'4I$*$3!

ZLWK D Ã&#x20AC;QDO VFRUH RI ZLWK "$-0! FKG! >&042<! &;/! &2! /&1C! L#4'-3$'1#4-! N]$*+E! +/-*! ,$2! K40B 0&2+!-23!H-;*4!Q-*AA-2$2!&: !/#$! )#4>-<&!,;''+!+/;::$3!/#$!+/-/!+#$$/?! >&0.4242<!:&*!Z8!1&42/+?!9#4'$!/#$! ,&+/&2! )$'/4>+E! T-(+&2! "-/;0! -23!

G/'-2/-! %-9A+E! "*-$! e&;2<! #4/! -! >&0.42$3! 75! /#*$$B1&42/$*+! -23! /&/-'$3! ^^! 1&42/+! &2! /#$! 24<#/C! ! ! ! ! ! K-/;*3-(E+! KA4''+! )#-''$2<$?!

6#.$%/&0'#1 '7!8'9#):0 "#*$$BL&42/! )&01$/4/4&2?! -23!

L8*(S"$$%9(8` (:$88'34=(;*"#(8H#(+8,*#8>=(+*$8(6#*7+*=(JH$$4(%=(#+*(C+$**]!8%=#(J8,7*#%#%8=K D;2A! )&2/$+/! :&''&9$3! /#$! /&2$! +$/! .(! /#$! P4+42<! K/-*+! <-0$! -23!

3$'4I$*$3! +&0$! 42>*$34.'$! #4<#B '4<#/+C! U2! /#$! KA4''+! )#-''$2<$?! 9$! K#-a;4''$! `EJ$-'C! D4-''&! 1;2>/;B Ã&#x20AC;QDOLVWV LQFOXGHG 6WHSKHQ &XUU\ RI G''BK/-*! <-0$! :$-/;*42<! "$-0! S4B ZHUH WUHDWHG WR D WKULOOLQJ VHPL Ã&#x20AC;QDO -/$3! /#$! -'*$-3(! 401*$++4I$! 3;2A! /#$! S&'3$2! K/-/$! =-**4&*+?! ,;33(! -224+!-23!"$-0!H$,*&2C!=#4'$!S4B 0-/>#;1!.$/9$$2!"*-$!e&;2<!-23! .(! #-2<42<! :*&0! /#$! *40! .(! #4+! %4$'3! &: ! /#$! K->*-0$2/&! \42<+?! -224+! G2/$/&A&;201&! 9-+! 943$'(!

H;A-!D&2>4>?!/9&!2-0$+!9#&!94''! $'.&9! 42! -! c42>$! )-*/$*! /*4.;/$C! -23! T&$! %-**4+! &: ! /#$! ,*&&A'(2! 0&>A$3! :&*! #4+! 1&&*! 3*-:/42<!

'4A$'(! .$! 1-4*$3! /#*&;<#&;/! /#$4*! D$224+! K04/#! T*C! *$>$4I$3! -! <$2B J$/+C!G:/$*!#4//42<!/$2!42!-!*&9!/&! -.4'4/4$+! -:/$*! /-A42<! #4+! /$-00-/$! >-*$$*+! -+! /#$(! 9$*$! /*-3$3! :&*! $*&;+! 1$*:$>/! +>&*$! 94/#! #4+! 3;2A! TXDOLI\ IRU WKH Ã&#x20AC;QDO URXQG PDQ\ \#*4+! Q433'$/&2! &I$*! &2$! &: ! /#$! $->#!&/#$*!&2!3*-:/!24<#/!'-+/!T;2$C! &I$*! D9(-2$! =-3$?! 9#4'$! *&&A4$! 9$*$! >*&9242<! K/$1#! /#$! >#-014B '$-<;$E+!.$+/?!G2/#&2(!D-I4+?!94/#! e&;2<!9-+!-.'$!942!-23!0&I$!&2! Q4'$+! ,*43<$+E! R]6! 3;2A! 9$-*42<! &2C!,;/!$I$2!+/-*/42<!&:: !242$B:&*B WKH Ã&#x20AC;UVW SLFN RI WKH UHVHUYH URXQG WR D Ã&#x20AC;QDO PDWFKXS ZLWK -D\VRQ 7DB H-**(!T&#2+&2E+!V$*+$(!9-+!&2$!&: ! 242$! 42! /#$! >#-014&2+#41! *&;23! -23!H$,*&2!T-0$+!9-+!0&>A$3!:&*! /;0C!U/!-11$-*$3!/#-/!e&;2<!9&;'3! /#$! 24<#/E+! 0&+/! 401*$++4I$! :$-/+C! 9-+2E/! $2&;<#! /&! /&1! %-**4+E! 1$*B #4+!>'$-*!*$>*;4/0$2/!<&-'+!94/#!#4+! .$! -.'$! /&! 9-'/b! /&! -! I4>/&*(! ;2/4'! !!!!!"#$!"#*$$BL&42/!)&01$/4/4&2!4+! :$>/!1$*:&*0-2>$!:*&0!/#$!0&2$(! /$-0! 2$-*'(! $2/4*$'(! 0-3$! ;1! &: !

"-/;0E+! #-':B>&;*/! #$-I$! -''&9$3! -'9-(+!&2$!&: !/#$!24<#/E+!0&+/!$@B .-''! *->AC! %-**4+?! 9#4'$! 2&/! ($/! -! 401$2342<! :*$$! -<$2/+?! /#4+! <-0$!

+/4''!3$'4I$*$3!-!I$*(!$@>4/42<!1*&3B ;>/C! `2'(! &2$! ($-*! -:/$*! /#$! G''B K/-*! 3*-:/! :&*0-/! 9-+! 42/*&3;>$3?! /#4+! ($-*E+! 3*-:/! 9-+! /$'$I4+$3! -23! :$-/;*$3! /9&! +1$>4-'! -334/4&2+! :*&0! /#$! >&004++4&2$*! B! D9-(2$! =-3$! -23! D4*A! J&94/bA4?! /9&! &: ! /#$!'$-<;$E+!<*$-/$+/!'$<$23+C!"$-0!

S4-224+! V;01$3! &;/! /&! -! 7RB1&42/! '$-3!$2342<!/#$!#-': !94/#!-!'$-3!&: !

8^B[5C! "$-0! H$,*&2! *&-*$3! .->A! 3;*42<!/#$!+$>&23!#-': !&2!/#$!.->A! &: !-!R6B7R!1&42/!*;2!#4<#'4<#/$3!.(!

L&*/'-23E+! D-04-2! H4''-*3! +#&9B 42<! &:: ! #4+! '404/'$++! *-2<$?! #4/B /42<! -! +$*4$+! &: ! /#*$$+! 42>';342<! -! .;bb$*.$-/$*! :*&0! /#*$$Ba;-*/$*+! &: !/#$!>&;*/C!"#$!<-0$!9-+!>#-*B ->/$*4b$3! .(! 4/+! 0-2(! /#*$$+?! -+! /#$! /$-0+! >&0.42$3! /&! .*$-A! /#$! G''BK/-*! *$>&*3! &: ! ^Z! 94/#!

-! V-9B3*&1142<! ]5! 0-3$! /#*$$+C! !!!!!"$-0!H$,*&2!9-+!-.'$!/&!*-''(!

EDFN IURP WKHLU SRLQW GHÃ&#x20AC;FLW WR FRPSOHWH WKH FRPHEDFN ZLWK D Ã&#x20AC;B 2-'!+>&*$!&: !7N[B7]ZC!G+!;+;-'?!42!

-!<-0$!9#4>#!+$$+!'4//'$?!4: !-2(!3$B :$2+$?! /#$! +>&*$! &: ! /#$! <-0$! 9-+!

-+/*&2&04>-'?! $@>$$342<! $I$2! /#$! .$//42<! &I$*d;23$*! 0-*A! &: ! R7^!

1&42/+!.(!2$-*'(!R6!1&42/+C!S&'3$2!

K/-/$E+!\$I42!D;*-2/!9&2!QcL!&: ! /#$! <-0$! 94/#! #4+! R7! 1&42/+! '$-3B 42<!#4+!/$-0!.(!-!943$!0-*<42C!S4B -224+! G2/$/&A&;201&E+! R[B1&42/! $::&*/! 9-+! 42! I-42?! .;/! #$! -23!

K/$1#! );**(! 9$*$! -.'$! /&! >&22$>/! :&*!&2$!&: !/#$!.$+/!.;>A$/+!&: !/#$! <-0$!94/#!-!.&;2>$B1-++!-''$(B&&1C!

I"a(I8>B8>=b(0*=(2"33(#8(Y*$,8=#c(:H# )8,*=(E8,%="#*(%=(T"94()%= L"&'%*(S"$#(5@W !"#$%&'()*%#$ !!!!!`2!K-/;*3-(?!X$.*;-*(!7]?!/#$!

Q$2E+!-23!=&0$2E+!H->*&++$!/$-0+!

9$2/!7B7!94/#!-!8BN!'&++!-/!c$*0&2/! :&*!/#$!0$2!-23!-!56BR!#&0$!I4>B /&*(!:&*!/#$!9&0$2!-<-42+/!)$2/*-'! &RQQHFWLFXW 6WDWH -XQLRU PLGÃ&#x20AC;HOGB $*! D-2! `E)&22$''! 9-+! 2-0$3! /#$!

L-/*4&/! H$-<;$! X->$&:: ! K1$>4-'4+/! &: !/#$!=$$A?!<&42<!7^B7N!:*&0!/#$! f?! *$>&*342<! -! 1$*+&2-'B.$+/! C[[5!

942242<!1$*>$2/-<$C!X&*!/#$!9&0B $2?! +$24&*! -//->A$*! \$$'(! )&22&*+!

OHG WKH &UXVDGHUV ZLWK Ã&#x20AC;YH JRDOV -23!&2$!-++4+/!:&*!-!>-*$$*B#4<#!+4@!

1&42/+?!9#4'$!-'+&!2-..42<!+4@!3*-9! >&2/*&'+C !!!!"#$!0$2E+!>&2/$+/!9-+!-''!-.&;/! /#$! >&0$.->A! :&*! /#$! )*;+-3$*+C! $IWHU JRLQJ GRZQ LQ WKH Ã&#x20AC;UVW a;-*/$*?! V;24&*! >-1/-42! K$-2! Q;'B '-2$(! 1;/! #4+! /$-0! &2! /#$! .&-*3!

ZLWK DQ DVVLVW IURP Ã&#x20AC;UVW \HDU DWB /->A$*!=4''!K1-2<$2.$*<C!K1-2<$2B .$*<! >*-3'$3! /#$! .-''! :*&0! .$#423!

WKH QHW EHIRUH Ã&#x20AC;QGLQJ 0XOODQH\ >;//42<! /#*&;<#! /#$! 0433'$! 9#&! +>&*$3! $-+4'(C! =4/#! 76_57! *$0-42B LQJ LQ WKH Ã&#x20AC;UVW KDOI 6SDQJHQEHUJ +2-<<$3!-!c$*0&2/!1-++!42!043-4*?! :-A$3!-!1-++!-23!2-4'$3!/#$!<&-'!:&*!

KLV Ã&#x20AC;UVW VFRUH RI WKH GD\ 7KH &UXVDGHUV VFRUHG Ã&#x20AC;YH WLPHV

42!/#$!+$>&23!#-':?!.$<42242<!043B 9-(! /#*&;<#! /#$! /#4*3! a;-*/$*!

9#$2! V;24&*! -//->A$*! T;+/42! H(2+B A$(!+2;>A!#4+!9-(!/#*&;<#!-!>*&93! &: ! 3$:$23$*+! /&! <$/! &2! /#$! .&-*3C! K1-2<$2.$*<! $23$3! /#$! a;-*/$*!

94/#!-!>*$-+$!*&''!<&-'!:&*!#4+!+$>B &23C! Q;''-2$(! >-14/-'4b$3! &2! :-2B /-+/4>!)*;+-3$*!1-++42<!:&*!#4+!+$>B

5_67!/&!<&!42!/#$!>&2/$+/?!Q;''-2$(!

PDGH D SDVV WR MXQLRU PLGÃ&#x20AC;HOGHU )&22&*!=-'3*&2!9#&!*411$3!-!<&-'! :*&0!&;/+43$!/#$!>4*>'$C!=#4'$!%&'(! )*&++! 0-3$! -! /*$0$23&;+! $::&*/!

-23!-!2$-*!>&0$.->A!I4>/&*(?!4/!9-+!

2&/!$2&;<#!/&!/-A$!3&92!c$*0&2/C! "#$! )*;+-3$*+! &;/B1$*:&*0$3! /#$! )-/-0&;2/+!7[B7]!42!<*&;23!.-''+!

X-**$''! >-;+$3! /9&! /;*2&I$*+C! gU/!

9-+2E/! /#$! *$+;'/! 9$! 9-2/$3! .;/! /#$*$! 9$*$! -! '&/! 1&+4/4I$+! 9$! >-2! /-A$! -9-(! :*&0! 4/! -23! '$-*242<!

1&42/+!/#-/!94''!#$'1!;+!<*&9?h!+-43! ,-.4-AC!g=$E*$!0&I42<!42!/#$!*4<#/!

34*$>/4&2! -23! V;+/! #-I$! /&! /-A$! 4/! &2$!<-0$!-/!-!/40$Ch ! ! ! ! ! "#$! 9&0$2E+! +43$! 9-+! -! )*;B

Ã&#x20AC;HOGHU $XGUH\ 0DQGDUR RSHQHG ;1! /#$! +>&*42<! 94/#! 5_R^! 042;/$+!

JRQH LQ WKH Ã&#x20AC;UVW IROORZHG E\ WZR <&-'+!:*&0!)&22&*+?!-2&/#$*!Q-2B GDUR PDUN DQG D Ã&#x20AC;UVW FROOHJLDWH JRDO IURP VRSKRPRUH PLGÃ&#x20AC;HOGHU 6\GQH\ ,*-2/C!G:/$*!/#$!,';$!D$I4'+!<&/!&2! /#$!.&-*3!/94>$?!4/!9-+!-''!)*;+-3B HUV WKURXJK WKH UHVW RI WKH Ã&#x20AC;UVW ZLWK JRDOV IURP MXQLRU PLGÃ&#x20AC;HOGHU %U\Q &DUUROO Ã&#x20AC;UVW \HDU DWWDFNHU -RUG\Q $UDNHOLDQ KHU Ã&#x20AC;UVW FROOHJLDWH JRDO

Ã&#x20AC;UVW \HDU PLGÃ&#x20AC;HOGHU -ROLH &UHR DQG VRSKRPRUH PLGÃ&#x20AC;HOGHU &DWKB $*42$!S;-2>4C!)&22&*+!&1$2$3!;1! /#$! +$>&23! #-': ! 94/#! -! +>&*$! /#-/! '$3! /&! $4<#/! +/*-4<#/! )*;+-3$*! /-'B OLHV ,Q DGGLWLRQ WR &RQQRUV· Ã&#x20AC;YH JRDOV VRSKRPRUH PLGÃ&#x20AC;HOGHU ,]]\ S*-2/! $23$3! /#$! 3-(! 94/#! -! #-/! /*4>A?!9#4'$!)*$&?!)-**&''?!G*-A$'4-2!

-23!Q-23-*&!-''!*$>&*3$3!/9&C!"#$! )*;+-3$*+! 56B<&-'! <-0$! 9-+! /#$4*! Ã&#x20AC;UVW VLQFH D YLFWRU\ RYHU /DB :-($//$!&2!Q-*>#!8?!567RC!U2!-334B /4&2!/&!/#$4*!+>&*42<!1*&9$++?!%&'(! )*&++!&;/+#&/!)$2/*-'!)&22$>/4>;/!

ZNB76!-23!*$>&*3$3!RZd^6!<*&;23! +,#%#'-#.$%/&0'#1 '2#,#30-$#&&4-#5 .-''+C! `2! /#$! <-0$?! )&22&*+! +-43?!

6*=%8$("##"&'*$(_**34(J8==8$9(>"9(=",*B(#+*(!"#$%8#(I*"1H*(R##"&'*$(8` (#+*()**'K gK-/;*3-(! 9-+! -! <*$-/! &11&*/;24/(! :&*!;+!/&!>&0$!/&<$/#$*!:&*!-!#;<$!

942!-23!>&2/42;$!/&!.;4'3!&;*!/$-0! &23! <&-'?! :&''&9$3! -! 042;/$! '-/$*! -23! &;/+#&/! /#$0! R]BRRC! T;24&*! +-3$*! 3&042-/4&2! /#$! $2/4*$! 9-(! >#$04+/*(Ch .(!-! +43$-*0! +#&/! -23! +>&*$!:*&0! <&-'4$! T&2-/#-2! "$+&*&! 0-3$! 7R! WKURXJK ZLWK Ã&#x20AC;YH VWUDLJKW JRDOV LQ +$24&*!-//->A$*!D*$9!,-.4-AC!=4/#! +-I$+!-23!+$24&*!3$:$2+$0-2!Q-//! WKH Ã&#x20AC;UVW WHQ PLQXWHV -XQLRU PLGB !!!!!!!

12

The Spire

SPORTS

February 22, 2019

0*=-9(:"9'*#;"33()%=(<O*$(:H&'=*33( <O*$9+"B8>*B(;4(C>8(S8,*(I899*9 :%334(2%#d7"#$%&'(5./ 6,*/1 '!"#$%&'()*%#$ ! ! ! ! ! D$+14/$! -! 9$$A! 42!

9#4>#! /#$! %&'(! )*&++!

Q$2E+! ,-+A$/.-''! /$-0!

14>A$3! ;1! 1$*#-1+! 4/+!

0&+/!401&*/-2/!942!&: ! /#$! +$-+&2?! -! 2-4'.4/$*! &I$*! L-/*4&/! H$-<;$B '$-342<! ,;>A2$''?! /#$! )*;+-3$*+!

M7ZB7Z! &I$*-''?! ^B76! L-/*4&/!

H$-<;$O! :$''! /&! /#$! >$'B '-*! &: ! /#$! >&2:$*$2>$!

94/#! #&0$! '&++$+! /&! )&'<-/$! -23! ,&+/&2!

F24I$*+4/(C! =#4'$! %)! >&;'3! /#$&*$/4>-''(! +/4''! $-*2! -! /&1B+4@! +$$3! :&*! /#$! L-/*4&/! H$-<;$! "&;*2-0$2/! -23! /#$!

DFFRPSDQ\LQJ Ã&#x20AC; UVW *&;23! .($?! 4/+! >#-2>$+!

-*$!<*&942<!42>*$-+42<B '(! +'40! 94/#! V;+/! /#*$$! *$<;'-*! +$-+&2! <-0$+! *$B 0-4242<! :&*! /#$! )*;+-3$*+C !!!!!%&'(!)*&++!#&+/$3!)&'<-/$!M7NB 76! &I$*-''?! 8B^! LHO! '-+/! =$32$+B 3-(?! X$.*;-*(! 7R?! :&*! /#$! /$-0+E! Ã&#x20AC; UVW PHHWLQJ RI WKH VHDVRQ 7KH P-43$*+! ;+$3! -! +$>&23B#-': ! 1;+#! /&! $+>-1$! =&*>$+/$*! 94/#! -! NZBN6!

I4>/&*(C! K&1#&0&*$! 1&42/! <;-*3! )-'$.! S*$$2! '$3! /#$! )*;+-3$*+!

ZLWK DQ HIÃ&#x20AC; FLHQW SRLQWV HLJKW RI QLQH IURP WKH Ã&#x20AC; HOG WKUHH RI :&;*!:*&0!/#*$$B1&42/!*-2<$O?!9#4'$! Ã&#x20AC; UVW \HDU JXDUG 7XFNHU 5LFKDUGVRQ 1->$3! /#$! .-'-2>$3! )&'<-/$! -/B /->A!94/#!56!1&42/+!-23!+4@!-++4+/+C! ! ! ! ! )&'<-/$! $+/-.'4+#$3! -! 5]B57! '$-3! 0439-(! /#*&;<#! /#$! &1$2B 42<! 1$*4&3?! .;/! %&'(! )*&++! ;+$3!

-! 7NB^! *;2! /&! /-A$! >&2/*&'! &: ! /#$! <-0$!-23!9$2/!&2!/&!#&'3!-!R8BRN! -3I-2/-<$! -/! /#$! 42/$*04++4&2! -:B WHU D EDFN DQG IRUWK Ã&#x20AC; UVW KDOI RI .-+A$/.-''C! H-/$*! &2?! /#$! P-43$*+! #$'3!-!+4@B1&42/!'$-3!42!/#$!+$>&23! #-':?! .;/! %)! ;+$3! -2&/#$*! $@1'&B +4I$! *;2?! /#4+! /40$! -2! 77B6! +1;*/?! /&!/-A$!-!^NB^5!'$-3C!G:/$*!)&'<-/$! /4$3! /#$! <-0$! -/! ]5! -14$>$! 42+43$! Ã&#x20AC; YH PLQXWHV D EXFNHW E\ *UHHQ -23! -! /#*$$B1&42/$*! :*&0! +&1#&B 0&*$! 942<! T->&.! S*-234+&2! 1;/!

WKH &UXVDGHUV EDFN DKHDG E\ Ã&#x20AC; YH ! ! ! e$/?! 94/#! %&'(! )*&++! &2! /#$! .*42A! &: ! -2! -''B401&*/-2/! I4>B /&*(! &I$*! /#$! /#4*3B.$+/! /$-0! 42! /#$! >&2:$*$2>$?! )&'<-/$! 1*&I$3!

4/+! 0$//'$! .(! <&42<! &2! -! 8B7! *;2?! /-A42<! /#$! '$-3! &2! -! /#*$$B1&42/$*! .(! V;24&*! :&*9-*3! P-1&'-+! UI-2-B ;+A;+?!&2$!&: !/#$!>&2:$*$2>$E+!/&1! +>&*$*+C! "#$! P-43$*+! ;+$3! >';/>#!

IUHH WKURZ VKRRWLQJ LQ WKH Ã&#x20AC; QDO 0&0$2/+! /&! +$-'! /#$! *&-3! I4>/&*(C! !!!!S*-234+&2!>#411$3!42!7R!1&42/+?! Ã&#x20AC; YH UHERXQGV DQG WZR DVVLVWV 9#4'$! +&1#&0&*$! <;-*3! 1&+/$3!

-! 9$''B*&;23$3! +/-/'42$! &: ! 75!

SRLQWV Ã&#x20AC; YH ERDUGV IRXU DVVLVWV -23! /#*$$! +/$-'+C! `2$! A$(! /$-0! +/-/4+/4>_! )&'<-/$! 9$2/! 7RB:&*B78! :*&0! /#$! :*$$! /#*&9! '42$?! 9#4'$! %)!&2'(!<&/!/&!/#$!'42$!V;+/!+$I$2! /40$+?!0-A42<!:&;*!&: !4/+!-//$01/+C !!!!!"#$!)*;+-3$*+!*$.&;23$3!:*&0! /#$! )&'<-/$! '&++! 9$''! 94/#! -! +/-/$B 0$2/! N5BN7! 942! &I$*! ,;>A2$''!

M7NB8! &I$*-''?! 77BR! LHO?! /#$! >'-++! ! ! ! ! ! e$/?! -2! ;2'4A$'(! #$*&! +/$11$3! -! *;2! &: ! /#$4*! &92! /&! /-A$! -! RNB >&;'3!<&!-!'&2<!9-(!42!3$/$*04242<! &: !/#$!'$-<;$?!'-+/!K-/;*3-(?!X$.*;B ;1! &2! /#$! $2+;42<! 1&++$++4&2! /&! 58! '$-3! #$-342<! 42/&! /#$! .*$-AC +$$342<!:&*!/#$!L-/*4&/!H$-<;$!"&;*B -*(!7]!-/!/#$!%-*/!)$2/$*C!"#$!942! *$I$*+$! /#$! )*;+-3$*+E! :&*/;2$+C! !!!!!=#4'$!%&'(!)*&++!#;2<!-*&;23! 2-0$2/C!,;/'$*!9-+!/#$!&2'(!&/#$*! )*;+-3$*! 42! 3&;.'$B34<4/+?! +>&*42<! 7NC! X4*+/B($-*! <;-*3!

T&2-+!%-*1$*!'$3!,F!94/#!55!

1&42/+?!9#4'$!V;24&*!:&*9-*3!

Q-@! Q-#&2$(! >#411$3! 42!

77! 1&42/+! -23! 75! *$.&;23+C! !!!!!"#$!)*;+-3$*+!/*-I$'!/&! ,$/#'$#$0?!L$22C?!/#4+!K;2B 3-(! /&! /-A$! &2! H$#4<#C! "#$! /9&! /$-0+! '-+/! :->$3! &2!

T-2;-*(!8!-/!/#$!%-*/!)$2/$*!

42!=&*>$+/$*C!"#$!Q&;2/-42! %-9A+! /&&A! /#-/! >&2/$+/! 42!

-! 88B8Z! &I$*/40$! I4>/&*(?! &2$! &: ! 0-2(! >'&+$! 3$:$-/+! :&*!/#$!)*;+-3$*+!42!>&2:$*B $2>$! 1'-(! /#4+! +$-+&2C! %&'(! )*&++! 1;/! ;1! ^8! 1&42/+! 42!

WKH Ã&#x20AC; UVW KDOI RI WKDW FRQWHVW .;/! >&;'3! 2&/! #&'3! &:: ! H$B #4<#!M7NB[!&I$*-''?!76BZ!LHOC! S*$$2!'$3!%)!94/#!-!>-*$$*B #4<#!5^!1&42/+?!9#4'$!+$24&*! +,#%#'--#.$%/&0'#1 '2#,#30-$#&&4-#5 <;-*3!H-2>$!"$V-3-!+>&*$3!R]?!<&B 6*=%8$(&*=#*$(L*+4O*(2384B-9(;%1(1",*("1"%=9#(:e(>"9(=8#(*=8H1+(`8$(#+*(>%=K 42<! 76B7Z! :*&0! /#*$$B1&42/! *-2<$?! /&!'$-3!/#$!H$#4<#!>&0$.->AC!"#$!

Q&;2/-42! %-9A+! >;**$2/'(! +4/! 42! +$>&23!1'->$!42!/#$!L-/*4&/!H$-<;$! +2-11$3! -! /9&B<-0$! '&+42<! +/*$-A! K&1#&0&*$! :&*9-*3! Q-//! X-9?! IRU WKH Ã&#x20AC; UVW IHZ PLQXWHV RI WKH +/-2342<+?! +&! -! <&&3! 1$*:&*0-2>$!

DQG FDPH RQ WKH KHHOV RI D Ã&#x20AC; YH 9#&! #-3! 04++$3! #4+! &2'(! /#*$$! +$>&23! #-':?! ,F! 9$2/! &2! -! 7^B5! :&*! /#$! )*;+-3$*+! 94''! <4I$! /#$0! <-0$! +/*$/>#! 42! 9#4>#! %)! 9$2/! +#&/! -//$01/+! &: ! /#$! <-0$! 1*4&*! *;2!/&!'$-3!^]BR[!94/#!/$2!042;/$+! IXUWKHU FRQÃ&#x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

M+$I$*-'! &: ! /#&+$! >&042<! :*&0! 2$@/! 1&++$++4&2! /&! >-1! #4+! 3&04B $01#-/4>! 3;2A+O?! $4<#/! *$.&;23+?! 2-2/!+$>&23!#-': !-23!+$-'!/#$!942! /#*$$! -++4+/+?! -23! /9&! .'&>A+! 42! :&*! %&'(! )*&++! 42! :*&2/! &: ! -! $;B &2$!&: !#4+!.$+/!<-0$+!&: !/#$!+$-B 1#&*4>! >*&93! -/! /#$! %-*/! )$2/$*C +&2C! "#$! 942! $23$3! ,;>A2$''E+! ! ! ! ! S*-234+&2! -;<0$2/$3! X'&(3E+! Ã&#x20AC; YH JDPH ZLQQLQJ VWUHDN DQG ZDV .4<! <-0$! 94/#! 7N! 1&42/+?! S*$$2! +RO\ &URVV· Ã&#x20AC; UVW ZLQ RYHU WKH %L FKLSSHG LQ DQG Ã&#x20AC; YH DVVLVWV DQG +&2!+42>$!/#$!567]!L-/*4&/!H$-<;$! ,;/'$*!>&2/*4.;/$3!77!1&42/+!&: !#4+!

7RXUQDPHQW 4XDUWHUÃ&#x20AC; QDO URXQG &92C! K$24&*! >$2/$*! J-/$! K$+/42-?! ! ! ! ! ! ,;>A2$''! '$3! .(! /#*$$! -/! #-':B &2$! &: ! /#$! >&2:$*$2>$E+! 1*$04$*! /40$! -:/$*! >&22$>/42<! &2! +4@! 1'-($*+?!'$3!,;>A2$''!94/#!7N!1&42/+! /#*$$B1&42/$*+! 42! /#$! &1$242<! -23! 7^! *$.&;23+C! e$/?! K$+/42-?!

1$*4&3?! .;/! /#$! )*;+-3$*+! >-0$! Q->A$2b4$?! -23! +&1#&0&*$! <;-*3! &;/! &: ! /#$! <-/$+! #&/! 42! /#$! +$>B T400(! K&/&+! $->#$3! >&;<#$3! ;1! &23! #-': ! /&! /-A$! /#$! '$-3! 94/#! -2! Ã&#x20AC; YH WXUQRYHUV FRQWULEXWLQJ RI 77BR! *;2C! %&9$I$*?! X'&(3! 14>A$3! ,;>A2$''E+! 5R! /&/-'! <4I$-9-(+?! /#$! ;1! #4+! :&;*/#! :&;'! /#*$$! 042;/$+! 0&+/! %&'(! )*&++! #-+! :&*>$3! 42!

42/&! /#$! +$>&23! 1$*4&3! -23! 9-+! -2(! <-0$! /#4+! +$-+&2C! "#$! )*;B *$+4<2$3! /&! /#$! .$2>#! :&*! +$I$*-'! +-3$*+! 343! 2&/! +#&&/! 9$''! :*&0!

042;/$+?! 9#4>#! >&42>43$3! 94/#! -! WKH Ã&#x20AC; HOG EXW JRW WR WKH IRXO OLQH 75B5! +1;*/! :*&0! ,;>A2$''! /&! *$B 5]! /40$+?! >&2I$*/42<! 78! &: ! /#&+$?! /-A$!/#$!'$-3?!-!+4@!1&42/!-3I-2/-<$C -! 34::$*$2>$B0-A$*! /#-/! -'+&! 1;/! ! ! ! ! %&'(! )*&++! #$-3! >&->#! ,4''! 0-2(! &: ! ,;>A2$''E+! .$+/! 1'-($*+! )-*0&3(! <-0.'$3! .(! *$B42+$*/42<! 42!:&;'!/*&;.'$!42!/#$!+$>&23!#-':C X'&(3!42/&!/#$!<-0$!94/#!77_57!*$B !!!!!%&'(!)*&++!>&;'3!2&/!*43$!/#$!

0-4242<?!-23!/#$!I$/$*-2!>$2/$*!*$B 0&0$2/;0!&: !K-/;*3-(E+!+4<2-/;*$!

9-*3$3!#4+!>&->#E+!:-4/#!.(!+>&*42<! I4>/&*(! 42/&! Q&23-(E+! /4'/! -<-42+/!

7^!&: !#4+!<-0$B#4<#!78!1&42/+!42!/#$! I4+4/42<! ,F?! -! 34+14*4/42<! N6B]6! Ã&#x20AC; QDO WHQ PLQXWHV LQFOXGLQJ VHYHQ '&++! /#-/! +$2/! %)! /&! /#$! .&//&0!

42!-!*&9!-/!&2$!1&42/C!X'&(3E+!1;/B &: ! /#$! L-/*4&/! H$-<;$! +/-2342<+C! .->A?! -23B&2$?! 0&0$2/;0B+942<B ,F!M75B7]!&I$*-''?!^B76!LHO!&92+!

LQJ GXQN JDYH +& D Ã&#x20AC; YH SRLQW OHDG /#$!/4$B.*$-A$*!&I$*!/#$!)*;+-3$*+!

94/#!/9&B-23B-B#-': !042;/$+!/&!<&C! -:/$*! +9$$142<! /#$! +$-+&2! +$*4$+C! <HW WKH Ã&#x20AC; QDO IHZ PLQXWHV IHOW D$+14/$! -2&/#$*! .4<! 24<#/! :*&0!

'4A$!-!*$>;**42<!24<#/0-*$!/&!+&0$! )OR\G SRLQWV UHERXQGV Ã&#x20AC; YH %)!:-2+!-+!,;>A2$''!>'-9$3!.->AC! .'&>A+O?! /#$! "$**4$*+! #&/! +#&&/42<! "#$! )*;+-3$*+! .'$9! -! '-/$! '$-3! -23!*$.&;2342<!-3I-2/-<$!1*&I$3!

-<-42+/!)&'<-/$!$-*'4$*!42!/#$!9$$A?! /&&! 0;>#! :&*! /#$! )*;+-3$*+C WKH WHDP·V Ã&#x20AC; IWK FRQIHUHQFH ORVV E\ !!!!!,F!<&/!&;/!/&!5RB7]!'$-3!043B Ã&#x20AC; YH SRLQWV RU OHVV 6R ZKHQ VHQLRU ZD\ WKURXJK WKH Ã&#x20AC; UVW KDOI EHIRUH <;-*3! \40.-'! Q->A$2b4$! 3*4''$3! -! %)! ;+$3! -2! 77BR! *;2! /&! /-A$! -! <&B-#$-3!/#*$$B1&42/$*!94/#!7^!+$>B &2$B1&42/! '$-3! 94/#! +4@! 042;/$+! &23+!'$:/!/&!1;/!,;>A2$''!;1!.(!/9&?! '$:/! 42! /#$! &1$242<! 1$*4&3C! %&9B 4/!:$'/!-''!/&&!:-04'4-*!:&*!%&'(!)*&++C! $I$*?! /#$! "$**4$*+! -2+9$*$3! 94/#!