November 2nd, 2018 by The Spire

W$1?%*!^0WF/!_?%)*#!Q!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!''''''(.H&;I&4'EJ'EG+F'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:$#'*6(*#/!X9669'-?6*((6!

!"#$%&'!"#$%&'(#$$$$$$$$$

01;$8<'=&&>&"%',??&4#'03"'?.4'@88 62A1"'B1CA1"%'DEE F#=4$)5'.7( ! ! ! "#$%! &'($)*#! +,! ($! (-*! +./! (-*! 0$11*2*! $3 ! (-*! 4$15! 0#$66! -$6(*7! 8(6! "9%815! :**;*<7! =8(-! 9! >9#8*(5! $3 !9'(8>8(8*6!(-#$?2-$?(!(-*!'9%@?6A! B*6@8(*! 1*66C(-9<C39>$#9)1*! =*9(-C *#/!7833*#*<(!*>*<(6!=*#*!@?(!$<!)5! 9!=87*!>9#8*(5!$3 !$#29<8D9(8$<6!3$#! 6(?7*<(6!9<7!(-*8#!39%818*6A 7KH À UVW QLJKW SURGXFHG D GRXEOH 3*9(?#*!$3 !39%815!3#8*<715!9'(8>8(8*6/! 8<'1?78<2!(-*!:$%*<E6!F'*!4$';*5! 29%*!96!=*11!96!G$9#8<2!+H6!0968<$! <82-(A!I-*!=$%*<E6!(*9%!'$%@*(*7! 9298<6(! <9(8$<9115! #9<;*7! J$6($<! 0$11*2*!8<!(-*!49#(!0*<(*#/!$33*#8<2! D KLJK SURÀ OH PDWFK XS IRU IDPLOLHV ($!*<K$5!96!(-*5!9##8>*7!$<!'9%@?6A! 'HVSLWH WKH À QDO VFRUH EHLQJ LQ ID >$#!$3 !(-*!>868(8<2!(*9%/!9!3?<!(8%*! =96!-97!)5!911A ! ! ! ! I-*! 0968<$! <82-(/! =-8'-! =96! 3*9(?#*7! 8<! (-*! 4$29<! )911#$$%/! @#$>87*7!9<!9''$%%$79(8<2!9(%$C 6@-*#*! 3$#! 39%818*6! ($! *<K$5A! L(?C 7*<(6! 9<7! @9#*<(6! 918;*! '$%@*(*7! 8<!29%*6/!6?'-!96!(*M96!-$17!N*%!96! =*11!96!#$?1*((*A!O*$@1*!=*#*!9)1*!($! WUDGH LQ WKHLU FKLSV IRU UDIÁ H WLFNHWV =8(-! @#8D*6! 6?'-! 96! 9! :8<26! $>*#! :$#'*6(*#!283(!'9#7A! !!!!L9(?#795!%$#<8<2!@8';*7!?@!#82-(! =-*#*!"#8795!<82-(!1*3(!$33/!6(9#(8<2! =8(-! (-*! 0#?697*#6! P298<6(! 09<'*#! QR! #?<A! P11! 3?<76! #986*7! 3#$%! (-*!

*>*<(! =*<(! ($! (-*! SQCTH! 0$<<*'C (8$</! =-8'-! 3$'?6*6! $<! *9#15! 7*(*'C (8$<!$3 !'9<'*#A! ! ! ! ! L$%*! *>*<(6! =*#*! *M'1?7*7! $#! (-*8#! @9#(8'8@9(8$<! 78%8<86-*7! 7?*! ($! (-*! 8<'1*%*<(! =*9(-*#A! O9#;8<2! $<! "#*6-%9<! "8*17! =96! @#$-8)8(*7! 7?*! ($! (-*! ($##*<(891! #98<! 3#$%! (-*!

(-*8#! 6*'$<7! >8'($#5! $3 ! (-*! 6*96$<! =8(-!9!Q,CSH!=8<!$>*#!V*-82-A!49@C @*<8<26! $<! (-*! 4$>91! =96! 9)1*! ($! @#$'**7/! 9<7! 39%818*6! =*#*! 9)1*! ($! *<K$5! 7*'$#9(8<2! (-*8#! $=<! @?%@C ;8<6A !!!&(-*#!*>*<(6!(-9(!$''?#*7!$>*#!(-*! '$?#6*!$3 !L9(?#795!=*#*!(-*!"9'?1(5!

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À UVW \HDU VWXGHQW 0L '-9*19!"9#86!6987/!![F!#*9115!*<K$5*7! 8(!)*'9?6*!8(!911$=*7!%*!($!8<(*2#9(*! %5! -$%*! 183*! =8(-! %5! '$11*2*! 183*A! F(!=96!2#*9(!($!8<(#$7?'*!911!%5!'$1C 1*2*! 3#8*<76! ($! %5! 39%815! 9<7! =96! 9! =$<7*#3?1! $@@$#(?<8(5! ($! %*#2*! G"7.7$A2$;B'$O'$?PQR$ %5!183*!9(!-$%*!=8(-!4$15!0#$66A\ )DPLOLHV JDWKHU IRU EUHDNIDVW LQ WKH À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

M$7A8$7A2#'?4.;'01;$8<'=&&>&"%

(&)#***********************+' ,-$"$."#*****************/' 0&1234&#******************5' 677-81"2*****************9

)+#1.'7-$@,2$,-5$ MB'5#$.7$D0$L,+: +7.$NB#4.'7-4 :17&'K

@#AB-C'-*$."#$ D2."$7E $3#9#(4#$ 3,1'46 :17&'L

F79#6A#($DB4'1$ G'1C4 :17&'5

G"7.7$A2$S'6$>#,."#(4.7-$?PPR

!"9%818*6!*<K$5!)#*9;396(!8<!J#$$;6CX?11*75A

G"7.7$A2$;B'$O'$?PQR$

P1@9'96!>868(!R8%)911!`?97A

G"7.7$A2$;B'$O'$?PQR$

0#?697*#6!'*1*)#9(*!9!2$91A

)**&+,-./$ 0-,(1"2$3#'*-4$ ,4$056'-'4.(,.'7-$ 87-.(79#(4',++2$3#: &+,1#4$;#'-<$='."$ >(#-1"?4

G"7.7$A2$S'6$>#,."#(4.7-$?PPR$

L=**(!I#*9(6!3$#!691*!9(!(-*!49#>*6(!"*6(A

:17&'F G"7.7$A2$;B'$O'$?PQR$

"#A!J$#$?2-6!@#*687*6!$>*#!X966A!

G"7.7$A2$;B'$O'$?PQR$

"#8*<76!6%81*!3$#!(-*!'9%*#9!7?#8<2! [49@@*<8<2!8<!(-*!"8*17-$?6*A\!

G"7.7$A2$S'6$>#,."#(4.7-$?PPR$

I-*!X9#'-8<2!J9<7!@1956!8<!!!!! 0#$66#$976A

;,++:7E:>,6#($ 87B42$HIJK$0B."7($ G76#(,-.<$G(767.#$ F#=$L77C :17&'+G G"7.7$A2$T,17A$LB11'$?PQR$

I-*!#98<!'$?17<E(!;**@!(-*!4$15!0#$66! '$%%?<8(5!3#$%!*<K$58<2!(-*!3*6(8>8(8*6a

G"7.7$A2$;B'$O'$?PQR$

I-*!O?#@1*!R*5!L$'8*(5!-9<76!$?(!'$%@1*%*<(9#5!@?#@1*!)926! 7?#8<2!#*286(#9(8$<A!

L(?7*<(6!(*6(!$?(!(-*8#!@$;*#!6;8116!7?#8<2!0968<$! _82-(A!

The Spire

''''''''E

NEWS

November 2, 2018

N23%&"2'[.H&4";&"2'@##.C$12$."'N&"12&'N&7;&"2 7+,6 :((. ,1 7+( 6*$ 6(1$7( ,QWHUQDO 5HRUJDQL]DWLRQ I-*!L*<9(*!@966*7!LGCSQT]!8<!9!S]C+C+!>$(*/!=-8'-!1987!($!#*6(!(-*! @$68(8$<!$3 !B*@?(5!:-8@!8<!(-*!J5CV9=6!$3 !(-*!LZPA!F<6(*97/!X8;*! 0-9#19!N+S!=811!<$=!6*#>*!96!(-*!L*#2*9<(!9(!P#%6!$3 !(-*!L*<9(*/! $>*#1$$;8<2!)811!9?(-$#6-8@!$3 !911!L*<9($#6!(-86!5*9#A!P6!8<78'9(*7!)5! WKLV RXU Ã&#x20AC; UVW LQWHUQDO UHRUJDQL]DWLRQ RI WKH \HDU WKH 6HQDWH ORRNV WR FRQWLQXH WR DIÃ&#x20AC; UP RXU OHJLWLPDF\ DQG UROH DV QRW RQO\ WKH HOHFWHG >$8'*!$3 !(-*!6(?7*<(!)$75!$<!'9%@?6/!)?(!96!9!'-*';!$<!(-*!dM*'?(8>*! $3 !(-*!L(?7*<(!Z$>*#<%*<(!P66$'89(8$</!96!=*11A!I-*#*!86!6(811!%?'-! ($!7$/!6$!6(95!(?<*7a

562 6SRWOLJKW I-86!=**;/!=*!)*29<!$?#!=**;15!GL&!L@$(182-(!3*9(?#*/!-82-182-(8<2! (-*!8<8(89(8>*6!9<7!*C)$9#76!$3 !7833*#*<(!GL&E6!*>*#5!=**;!8<!4$29<! 2XU Ã&#x20AC; UVW 6SRWOLJKW ZDV 3D[ &KULVWL ZKRVH FR FKDLUV VSRNH RI (-*8#!%8668$<!($!(9';1*!866?*6!$3 !6$'891!K?6(8'*!)$(-!-*#*!$<!(-*!4811! 9<7!916$!8<!(-*!:$#'*6(*#!'$%%?<8(5A!I-*5!6@$;*!($!(-*!0-9%)*#! #*29#78<2!9<!?@'$%8<2!(#8@!($!BA0A/!=-*#*!SQ!4$15!0#$66!6(?7*<(6! =811!9((*<7!9!I*9'-CF<!3$#!L$'891!h?6(8'*!9<7!1$))5!(-*8#!0$<2#*668$<91! #*@#*6*<(9(8>*6!)*3$#*!(-*!%87(*#%!*1*'(8$<6A &RQÃ&#x20AC; UPDWLRQ RI &OHUNV 7KH 6HQDWH SURXGO\ DSSRLQWHG DQG FRQÃ&#x20AC; UPHG RXU VL[ FOHUNV RI WKH +HS.!C!+HSY!9'97*%8'!5*9#A!0$<2#9(?19(8$<6!9<7!=*1'$%*!($!0$<<$#! X'_*#<*5/!Z#9'*!X$##866*5/!4*1*<9!L9)$/!R9#(*#!L*8(D/!X9228*!&)*#/! 9<7!09518*!:-8(*687*a!V*(E6!2*(!($!=$#;a

1H[W 0HHWLQJ 0$%*!K$8<!?6!8<!4$29<!QSY!<*M(!L?<795/!_$>*%)*#!T/!9(!.bSQa!:*! '9<E(!=98(!($!6**!5$?!(-*#*A

! ( N R ! R \ R 6' UM@([6

D,..$W7+E#$'4$,$8+,44$7E $PJPJ$4#-,.7(R$8"#1C$A,1C$=##C+2$E7($67(#$%#-,.#: VSHFLÃ&#x20AC; F XSGDWHV DQG LQLWLDWLYHV WR PDNH VWXGHQW OLIH HDVLHU RQ WKH +LOO 0&_IP0I!iLb )))*?1C&I..>*C.;XMUN&"12& !"#21741;P'Y#71ZAC#&"12& #71#&"12&Y7*A.8<C4.##*&%3

N"1-#A.2#'04.;'2A&'M$88

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

G"7.7$A2$;B'$O'$?PQR$

G"7.7$A2$;B'$O'$?PQR

0HPEHUV RI D SDQHO GLVFXVVLRQ VSHDN RQ Â´5DFH 6ODYHU\ DQG ,QVWLWXWLRQDO 0HPEHUV RI WKH 6SLUH HGLWRULDO ERDUG UHFHQWO\ SDUWLFLSDWHG LQ D MRXUQDOLVP 0HPRU\ LQ +LJKHU (G Âµ ZRUNVKRS ZLWK 7LP %UHVKQDKHQ Â¶ DQG 'DYH 1RUGPDQ

VEE $ 8,6&B4:$ P<! 8<($M8'9(*7! 3#*6-C %9<!7#*66*7!96!9!V8%*!:-8(*!019=! '911*7!@?)!693*!8<!786(#*66!=-*<!6-*! '$?17!<$(!1$'9(*!-*#!3#8*<76!8<!(-*! 6*9!$3 !:-8(*!019=!'197!?<7*#'1966C %*<A N3"%1<J',C2.I&4'EF !"#$ ;79,+:! L*>*#91! 91@9'96! 6@$((*7! #$9%8<2!(-#$?2-!'9%@?6A! >'**#:$3XE VDIH UHVSRQGV WR D Ã&#x20AC; UH DODUP VHW RII E\ DQ XQLGHQWLÃ&#x20AC; HG "822*! SST! #*687*<(! 3$#! (-*! 6*'$<7! (8%*!8<!9!=**;A!_$!)9'$<!=96!1$6(! 8<!(-*!@#$'*66A

G"7.7$A2$@,9#2$%B++'9,-$?PQR $ $ 'U 0DULR (Q]OHU VSRNH RQ KLV H[SHULHQFH RQ WKH 9DWLFDQ 6ZLVV *XDUG 3"%&4':.-&'W.A"':138'!!*''

G"7.7$A2$S'6$>#,."#(4.7-$?PPR$

:.&2'UA&"'UA&"'#-&1>#'1#'1'-142'.? '2A&'=.4>$"7'=4$2&4'N&4$&#'."'RA34#V %1<J',C2.I&4'+G*

$$!"#$%&'(#$6(?7*<(!<*=6@9@*# !!!!0$11*2*!$3 !(-*!4$15!0#$66 !!!!O?)186-*7!=**;15!68<'*!SY+Q

! "#$%&'(# LV D QRQ SURÃ&#x20AC; W QRQ SDUWLVDQ VWXGHQW ! @?)18'9(8$<!$3 !(-*!0$11*2*!$3 !(-*!4$15!0#$66A! !"#$%&'(#!86!786(#8)?(*7!3#**!$3 !'-9#2*!($!911!6(?7*<(6/!39'C ?1(5/!6(933/!9<7!*%@1$5**6!$3 !(-*!8<6(8(?(8$<A

@88<#."'(.&"$C>QJ'B.II<'R3SS$.'')5'.7(4:'-:8"'#E $ -DFNLH &DQQRQ (WKDQ %DFKDQG 6RÃ&#x20AC; D 0DLHWWD .DWH 0F/DXJKOLQ F#=4$)5'.7(4 2OLYLD 3DQ 6SHQFHU &DURQ 0DJJLH &RQQROO\ +HQU\ 1RH V&'-'7-4$)5'.7(4 0DJJLH )ODKHUW\ %LDQFD 0LFFROLV /XNH :DOVK >#,.B(#4$)5'.7(4 $QQLH +HQWVFKHO 0DULR 0LFDOOLI &KULV 6KDNHVSHDUH )**&+,-.$)5'.7(4 %LOO\ )LW]SDWULFN 0DJJLH )ODKHUW\ -DFNLH +DUW 0DFNOLQ .RUWHEHLQ 3DWULFN :DUHKDP %&7(.4$)5'.7(4 (PLO\ .XOS %#-'7($87&2$)5'.7( +RSH *RRGPDQ 3DPHOD .RWH $QQD 0RUULV 6DUDK 2Â·5RXUNH 5HEHFFD 7UHGZHOO 87&2$)5'.7(4 +XL /L 8"'#E $G"7.7*(,&"#( .LP )HWKHUVWRQ -DFRE %XFFL 'DYH\ 6XOOLYDQ =RH 3HWLW G"7.7*(,&"#(4 /XNH 'RXJKW\ %LDQFD 0LFFROLV 0DU\ .DWH &XQQLQJKDP W#A$)5'.7(4 :4.?&##.4'N2&H&'T$"&I&47''>,1B+.2$059'47( 'HDQ 0LFKHOH 0XUUD\$$>,1B+.2$059'47( 'HDQ %UHQGD +RXQVHOO 6XOOLYDQ >,1B+.2$059'47(

O1*96*!977#*66!'$##*6@$<7*<'*!($b $$$$!"#$%&'(# !!!!!OA&A!J$M!c+P !!!!!0$11*2*!$3 !(-*!4$15!0#$66 !!!!!S!0$11*2*!L(#**( !!!!:$#'*6(*#/!XP!HS,SHC+cYQ 6;1$8P'6@8#*e2A-$15'#$66A*7? =&I#$2&P'-'6@8#*A'$%

! $!97>*#(86*!8<$!"#$%&'(#/ I !!!d%981b!!6@8#*e2A-$15'#$66A*7? !!!O-$<*b!fQH.g!+YcCS+.c

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Ã&#x20AC; FH LQ +RJDQ I-*!$@8<8$<6!*M@#*66*7!=8(-8<!(-*!<*=6@9@*#!9#*!<$(! <*'*669#815!(-$6*!$3 !(-*!0$11*2*!$3 !(-*!4$15!0#$66A!!I-86! <*=6@9@*#!86!@#8<(*7!)5!0$%%?<8(5!_*=6@9@*#!0$%C @9<5A!!G*@#$7?'(8$<!$3 !9<5!@9#(!$3 !(-86!@9@*#!86!)5!@*#C %8668$<!$3 !!"#$%&'(#!$<15A

NEWS

The Spire

November 2, 2018

@88&7&%'M12&'U4$;&':4.;-2#'U1;-3#V=$%&' 5HVSRQVH 'W1C>$&'U1""."'DEG 8"'#E $F#=4$)5'.7( !!!I-*!0$11*2*!$3 !(-*!4$15!0#$66! '$%%?<8(5! #*'*8>*7! 9! #*@$#(! $3 ! 922#9>9(*7! )9((*#5! 9<7! 9669?1(! 9298<6(! 9! 6(?7*<(/! '$%%8((*7! 8<! (-*!*9#15!%$#<8<2!-$?#6!$3 !&'($C )*#! +]A! I-*! #*@$#(! '$<(98<*7! 3*=! VSHFLÃ&#x20AC;FV RI WKH LQFLGHQW ZKLFK LV '?##*<(15! ?<7*#! 8<>*6(829(8$</! )?(! 8(!787!87*<(835!(-9(!(-*!9669?1(!=96! 911*2*715!%$(8>9(*7!)5!)896!9298<6(! (-*! >8'(8%E6! 6*M?91! $#8*<(9(8$</! 9<7!($$;!@19'*!)*(=**<!019#;!9<7! J#$$;6CX?11*75!#*687*<'*!-9116A! !!!F<!(-*!7956!3$11$=8<2!(-*!#*1*96*! $3 !(-86!#*@$#(/!6*>*#91!%*%)*#6!$3 !

(-*!97%8<86(#9(8$<!9<7!(-*!'9%@?6! '$%%?<8(5! #*6@$<7*7/! 8<'1?7C 8<2! O#*687*<(! G*>A! O-818@! VA! J$#C $?2-6/! LAhA/! B*9<! X8'-*1*! X?##95/! WKH &KDSODLQÂ·V 2IÃ&#x20AC;FH DQG 6*$ F<!(-*8#!>9#8$?6!1*((*#6!($!(-*!'$%C %?<8(5/!(-*5!977#*66*7!(-*!<**7!($! ['$%*! ($2*(-*#! ($! '$<7*%<! 9'(6! $3 ! 8<($1*#9<'*! 9<7! >8$1*<'*/! 9<7! ($!6?@@$#(!(-$6*!%$6(!933*'(*7!)5! #*'*<(! 8<'87*<(6/\! 96! 6(9(*7! )5! "#A! J$#$?2-6A! ! ! ! &<! I?*6795/! &'(A! cH/! (-*! 0$1C 1*2*! -*17! 9! >8281! $<! (-*! 4$>91/! ($! @#95!8<!6$1879#8(5!9<7!$33*#!6?@@$#(! ($!(-$6*!=-$!-9>*!)**<!>8'(8%6!$3 ! 786'#8%8<9($#5! >8$1*<'*A! "#A! J$#C $?2-6! 916$! 9<<$?<'*7! (-9(! (-*#*!

=811! )*! 9! ['$%%?<8(5C=87*! 8<8(89C (8>*\! 8%@1*%*<(*7! 6$$</! 8<! $#7*#! ($!'$<(8<?*!($!977#*66!(-*6*!866?*6A! !!!I-86!#*@$#(!'9%*!K?6(!7956!93(*#! %?1(8@1*! $(-*#! 8<'87*<(6! $3 ! <$(*! 9'#$66! (-*! '$?<(#5A! &<! "#8795/! &'(A!+,/!:96-8<2($<!_9(8$<91!09C (-*7#91! 8<(*##*7! (-*! #*%98<6! $3 ! 9! 5$?<2!295!%9</!X9((-*=!L-*@9#7/! =-$! =96! %?#7*#*7! 8<! 9<! 911*2*7! 9'(!$3 !-9(*!+H!5*9#6!92$A!I-*!3$1C 1$=8<2! 795/! SS! h*=86-! 8<78>87?916! =*#*! 6-$(! 9<7! ;811*7! 8<! (-*! I#**! $3 ! V83*! L5<92$2?*! 8<! O8((6)?#2-/! O*<<651>9<89A! ! ! ! [:*! 9#*! 8<! 9! (8%*! $3 ! 8<'#*96C 8<2!8<($1*#9<'*/!-9(*!9<7!)82$(#5/\! =#$(*! J$#$?2-6A! [:*! %?6(! 9<7!

=*!=811!'$<(8<?*!(-*!-9#7!=$#;!$3 ! )?8178<2!9!'9%@?6!'$%%?<8(5!(-9(! <$(!$<15!(#*9(6!*9'-!$(-*#!=8(-!*%C @9(-5! 9<7! #*6@*'(! )?(! 916$! 6(9<76! 8<!6$1879#8(5!9298<6(!-9(*!9<7!8<($1C *#9<'*A\! ! ! ! L(?7*<(6! 6**;8<2! *M(#9! 6?@C @$#(! 3$11$=8<2! (-*6*! 8<'87*<(6! 9#*! *<'$?#92*7! ($! #*9'-! $?(! ($! (-*! 0$?<6*18<2! 0*<(*#/! (-*! 0-9@198<E6! 2IÃ&#x20AC;FH RU 3XEOLF 6DIHW\ 7KRVH =8(-!9<5!8<3$#%9(8$<!6-$?17!'$<C (9'(!O?)18'!L93*(5A !!!I-*!L@8#*!=811!'$<(8<?*!($!#*@$#(! $<! (-*! $<2$8<2! #*6@$<6*! ($! (-86! 8<'87*<(A

(OHFWLRQ 'D\ DQG D *XLGH WR 0$ %DOORW ^3&#2$."#

6RÃ&#x20AC;D 0DLHWWD Â· F#=4$)5'.7(

! ! ! _*M(! I?*6795/! _$>*%)*#! ,! =811! %9#;! d1*'(8$<! B95/! 96! >$(C *#6!9'#$66!(-*!'$?<(#5!-*97!($!(-*! @$116A!"$#!X9669'-?6*((6!#*687*<(6/! *9#15!>$(8<2!)*29<!$<!&'($)*#!++! 9<7!=811!*<7!$<!"#8795/!_$>*%)*#! +A! X9669'-?6*((6! #*687*<(6! >$(8<2! >89!9)6*<(**!)911$(!6-$?17!)*!6?#*! ($! %981! (-*8#! )911$(6! )9';! ($! (-*8#! '8(5! $#! ($=<! -911! 96! 6$$<! 96! @$6C 68)1*/!96!911!)911$(6!%?6(!)*!#*'*8>*7! )5!(-*!(8%*!(-*!@$116!'1$6*!$<!d1*'C (8$<! B95! 8<! $#7*#! ($! )*! '$?<(*7A! "$#!(-$6*!X9669'-?6*((6!#*687*<(6! =-$! =811! )*! (#9>*18<2! ($! >$(*! 8<! @*#6$</!911!@$116!8<!(-*!6(9(*!=811!)*! $@*<!3#$%!]bHH!9A%A!($!.bHH!@A%A! ! ! ! "$#! X9669'-?6*((6/! (-*#*! 9#*! (-#**! )8<78<2! 6(9(*=87*! m?*6(8$<6! 9@@*9#8<2! $<! (-*! )911$(! (-86! 5*9#A! 9RWLQJ \HV RQ WKH Ã&#x20AC;UVW EDOORW m?*6(8$<! =$?17! '#*9(*! 9! 19=! 18%C 8(8<2! -$=! %9<5! @9(8*<(6! '9<! )*! 96682<*7! ($! *9'-! #*286(*#*7! <?#6*! 8<! X9669'-?6*((6! -$6@8(916! 9<7! '*#(98<! $(-*#! -*91(-! '9#*! 39'818C (8*6A! F3 ! @966*7/! (-*! @#$@$6*7! 19=! =$?17! (9;*! *33*'(! 8<! h9<?9#5! $3 ! +HSYA!W$(8<2!<$!$<!m?*6(8$<!$<*! =$?17!%9;*!<$!'-9<2*!($!(-*!'?#C #*<(!19=6A! !!!P7>$'9(*6!3$#!9!5*6!>$(*!'198%! (-9(!)$(-!@9(8*<(!693*(5!9<7!m?91C 8(5!$3 !'9#*!=811!8%@#$>*!83 !<?#6*C @9(8*<(!#9(8$6!9#*!*<9'(*7!)*'9?6*! <?#6*6!=811!)*!9)1*!($!6@*<7!%$#*! (8%*! =8(-! *9'-! @9(8*<(A! O#$@$C

<*<(6!916$!9#2?*!(-9(!(-86!19=!'$?17! '9%@982<! '$<(#8)?(8$<6! 9<7! *MC 3$#'*! -$6@8(916/! *6@*'89115! (-$6*! @*<78(?#*6A!d66*<(89115/!(-86!9%*<7C $=<*7! )5! =*91(-5! '$#@$#9(8$<6/! %*<(! =$?17! 6**;! ($! $>*#(?#<! (-*! ($!@?(!%$#*!%$<*5!($=9#76!78#*'(! 08(8D*<6!i<8(*7!'96*A!W$(8<2!<$!$<! @9(8*<(!'9#*A! (-86!m?*6(8$<!=$?17!<$(!*6(9)186-!9! ! ! ! 0$<>*#6*15/! $@@$<*<(6! $3 ! (-86! '$%%8668$<A! @#$@$6*7! 19=! '198%! (-9(! 8(! =$?17! !!!P7>$'9(*6!3$#!9!5*6!>$(*!%98<C $>*##87*! <?#6*6E! @#$3*668$<91! (98<! (-9(/! '$<(#9#5! ($! (-*! 7*'868$<! K?72*%*<(! 9<7! =$?17! <$(! 1*97! ($! 8<! 08(8D*<6! i<8(*7/! '$#@$#9(8$<6! )*((*#!@9(8*<(!'9#*A!I-*5!916$!966*#(! 6-$?17!<$(!-9>*!(-*!69%*!0$<6(8C (-9(!@9(8*<(!=98(!(8%*6/!*6@*'89115!8<! (?(8$<91! #82-(6! 96! -?%9<! )*8<26A! *%*#2*<'5! I-*5! '$<C # $ $ % 6 /! (*<7! (-9(! = $ ? 1 7! 0 8 ( 8 D * < 6! 7#96(8'9115! i<8(*7! -96! 8 < ' # * 9 6 * A! 1*7! ($! ?<C X$#*$>*#/! *m?91! #*@C $@@$<*<(6! #*6*<(9(8$<! % 9 8 < ( 9 8 <! 3$#! (-*! 9>C (-9(! '$%C *#92*! '8(8C @ 1 5 8 < 2! D*</! =-$! =8(-!(-*6*! ' 9 < < $ (! G"7.7$A2$;B'$O'$?PQR$ < ? # 6 * C N[@'4&C&"28<'A&8%''1'H.2$"7'4&7$#2412$."'C1;V 7 $ < 9 ( *! @9(8*<(!#9C -1$7"'2.'&"C.3417&'<.3"7&4'7&"&412$."#'2.'H.2&* (-*! 19#2*! (8$6!=$?17! 6?%6! ($! EH D VLJQLÃ&#x20AC;FDQW Ã&#x20AC;QDQFLDO EXUGHQ '9%@982<6!(-9(!'$#@$#9(8$<6!'9<A! *6@*'89115! 3$#! 6%911*#! -$6@8(916! !!!P7>$'9(*6!3$#!9!<$!>$(*!$<!m?*6C =-8'-!%95!)*!3$#'*7!($!'1$6*!96!9! (8$<! (=$! 9#2?*! (-9(! *6(9)186-8<2! #*6?1(A!P6!6%911*#!8<6(8(?(8$<6!$3(*<! 9! '$%%8668$<! ($! =#8(*! 9! #*@$#(! 6*#>*! (-*! 6(9(*E6! %$#*! >?1<*#9)1*! $<! (-86! 866?*! 86! 9! =96(*! $3 ! )$(-! '$%%?<8(8*6/! $@@$<*<(6! $3 ! m?*6C (8%*!9<7! %$<*5/! )*'9?6*!08(8D*<6! (8$<!$<*!9#2?*!(-9(!8(!=$?17!78697C i<8(*7! 86! 6*((1*7! 19=! 7*(*#%8<*7! >9<(92*!(-*!%$6(!<**75!8<!X9669C )5!(-*!L?@#*%*!0$?#(A!P%*<78<2! '-?6*((6A! (-*! 0$<6(8(?(8$<! #*m?8#*6! 6?@@$#(! ! ! ! I-*! 6*'$<7! X9669'-?6*((6! )91C 3#$%!(=$!(-8#76!$3 !(-*!L*<9(*!9<7! 1$(!m?*6(8$<!=$?17!'#*9(*!9!'8(8D*<6! +RXVH DV ZHOO DV UDWLÃ&#x20AC;FDWLRQ E\ '$%%8668$<! ($! '$<687*#! 9%*<7C $?(!$3 !QH!6(9(*6A!I-?6/!$@@$<*<(6! 8<2!(-*!i<8(*7!L(9(*6!0$<6(8(?(8$<! %98<(98<! (-9(! 9! 0$<6(8(?(8$<91! ZLWK UHJDUGV WR FDPSDLJQ Ã&#x20AC;QDQFH 9%*<7%*<(! $>*#(?#<8<2! 08(8C 19=! 9<7! @$(*<(891! #*2?19(8$<6! ($! D*<6! i<8(*7! 86! <*9#! 8%@$668)1*! ($!

9'-8*>*/! 9<7! (-9(! '#*9(8<2! 9! '$%C %8668$<!=$?17!(-*#*3$#*!)*!9!=96(*! $3 !(8%*!9<7!#*6$?#'*6A !!!W$(8<2!5*6!$<!(-*!(-8#7!9<7!196(! )911$(! m?*6(8$<! =$?17! ;**@! 8<! @19'*! 9! 19=! 682<*7! 8<! +HS,! =-8'-! @#*>*<(6! 786'#8%8<9(8$<! 9298<6(! (#9<62*<7*#!@*$@1*!8<!@?)18'!@19'C *6/!6?'-!96!)9(-#$$%6/!#*6(9?#9<(6/! 9<7!6($#*6A!P!<$!>$(*!=$?17!#*@*91! (-86!19=A! ! ! ! O#$@$<*<(6! $3 ! m?*6(8$<! (-#**! '198%! (-9(! 68<'*! (-86! 19=! ($$;! *3C 3*'(/!(-*#*!-96!)**<!<$!8<'#*96*!8<! 693*(5! 8<'87*<(6! 8<! @?)18'! @19'*6/! 9<7! (-9(! (-*! 19=! @#$(*'(6! (#9<6C 2*<7*#! @*$@1*! =-$! $3(*<! 39'*! 786'#8%8<9(8$<! 9<7! -9#966%*<(A! &<! (-*! $(-*#! -9<7/! 97>$'9(*6! 3$#! 9! <$! >$(*! $<! (-86! m?*6(8$<! '198%! (-9(! 6*M?91! @#*79($#6! 9#*! 9)1*! ($! 298<!9''*66!($!@19'*6!18;*!=$%*<E6! 1$';*#! #$$%6! 9<7! )9(-#$$%6! )*C '9?6*!$3 !(-86!19=A!I-*5!916$!966*#(! (-9(!(-*#*!86!<$!=95!($!786(8<2?86-! )*(=**<!9'(?91!(#9<62*<7*#!@*$@1*! 9<7!%*<!68%@15!1$$;8<2!($!*M@1$8(! (-*!19=A ! ! ! &?(! $3 ! (-*! (-#**! )911$(! m?*6C WLRQV WKH Ã&#x20AC;UVW KDV UHFHLYHG WKH %$6(! 9((*<(8$<! 8<! (-*! =**;6! )*C 3$#*! (-*! *1*'(8$<! 9<7! 6**%6! ($! )*! (-*! %$6(! '$<(#$>*#6891A! P! #*'*<(! J$6($<! Z1$)*! @$11! 3$?<7! (-9(! QY! @*#'*<(! $3 ! 18;*15! >$(*#6! 6987! (-*5! 9#*!9298<6(!<?#6*C@9(8*<(!#9(8$6!9<7! =811!>$(*!<$A!I-86!'$%*6!96!9!6-9#@! 6-83(! 8<! $@8<8$</! 96! >$(*#6! @$11*7! 8<! L*@(*%)*#! =*#*! Q+! @*#'*<(! 8<! 39>$#!$3 !(-*!)911$(!8<8(89(8>*/!'$%C

:#<CA.8.7<':4.?&##.4'@)14%&%'EG+F'U14&&4' 7HDFKLQJ 0HGDO .DWH 0F/DXJKOLQ Â· F#=4$)5'.7( !!!O#$3*66$#!J?;9(;$/!O#$3*66$#!$3 ! O65'-$1$25/!B86(8<2?86-*7!O#$3*6C VRU RI (GXFDWLRQ DQG $IÃ&#x20AC;OLDWH RI Z*<7*#/! L*M?918(5/! 9<7! :$%*<E6! L(?78*6/! =96! 9=9#7*7! (-*! +HS.! B$<91! hA! J?#<6! NTY! 09#**#! I*9'-C 8<2!X*791!9(!(-*!O#$>$6(E6!977#*66! 28>*<!)5!B*9<!X9#29#*(!"#*8K*A!I-*! %*791/! =-8'-! -$<$#6! [1$<2C(*#%! (*9'-8<2!*M'*11*<'*/\!86!9=9#7*7!($! 9!39'?1(5!%*%)*#!=-$!-96!7*>$(*7! -86!$#!-*#!183*(8%*!($!(*9'-8<2!6(?C 7*<(6! 9(! 4$15! 0#$66A! I-*! 9=9#7!

#*'8@8*<(!86!6*1*'(*7!(-#$?2-!<$%8C <9(8$<6!)5!6(?7*<(6!9<7!2#$?@6!$<! '9%@?6/! 9<7! 8(! 911$=6! (-*! 0$11*2*! ($! -82-182-(! (-*! '$%%8(%*<(! 9<7! 7*78'9(8$<! $3 ! 8(6! %$6(! @9668$<9(*! 9<7!7*78'9(*7!39'?1(5!%*%)*#6A !!!&>*#!(-*!'$?#6*!$3 !-*#!T+C5*9#! (*<?#*!9(!4$15!0#$66/!J?;9;($!-96! 7*>$(*7! -*#! '9#**#! ($! #*6*9#'-8<2! '$2<8(8>*! 7*>*1$@%*<(/! 2*<7*#C #$1*!7*>*1$@%*<(/!9<7!6$'891!'$2C <8(8$<!8<!*9#15!'-817-$$7A!L-*!916$! 6(?78*6!1*97*#6-8@/!9<7!-$=!@*$@1*! FDQ OHDUQ WR EH PRUH FRQÃ&#x20AC;GHQW DQG *33*'(8>*!1*97*#6A ! ! ! ! 4*#! 6(?7*<(6! 695! (-9(! -*#! *<C

RM@RDN'(6=N' 72 0( F#=4$%.7('#4$E(76$ 0(7B-5$."#$W7(+5 W1C>$&'U1""."'DEG 8"'#E $F#=4$)5'.7( RA34#%1<J',C2*'EL @%%$#'@I1I1J'62A$.-$1V'd(-8$@89E6! SDUOLDPHQW KDV DSSRLQWHG WKH Ã&#x20AC;UVW IHC %91*! @#*687*<(/! L9-1*C:$#;! U*=7*A! P1(-$?2-! (-*! @$68(8$<! 86! @#8%9#815! DV D FHUHPRQLDO Ã&#x20AC;JXUHKHDG KHU DSC @$8<(%*<(! @$8<(6! ($! 2#*9(*#! 2*<7*#! *m?918(5!8<!d(-8$@89A! 04$%1<J',C2*'E] &RORPER 6UL /DQND I-*!'$?<(#5! 3*11!8<($!'#8686!96!O#*687*<(!X98(-#8@9C 19! L8#86*<9! #*%$>*7! (-*! @#8%*! %8<C 86(*#/! G9<81! :8';#*%*68<2-*/! 3#$%! RIÃ&#x20AC;FH UHSODFLQJ KLP ZLWK D FRQWURC >*#6891! @$@?186(! 9''?6*7! $3 ! -?%9<! #82-(6!9)?6*6A! N1234%1<J',C2*'E5 :$22#I347AJ':&""#<8H1"$1V'F<!=-9(! 86! )*18*>*7! ($! )*! (-*! %$6(! 7*9715! 9<(8C6*%8(8'! 9((9';! 8<! (-*! i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cA 5LR GH -DQHLUR %UD]LO J#9D81!>$(C *#6!-9>*!*1*'(*7!@$@?186(!h98#!J$16$C <9#$/!=-$!-96!@#*6*<(*7!-8%6*13 !96! (-*! 6$1?(8$<! ($! (-*! #*'*<(! @$18(8'91! 9<7!*'$<$%8'!6(#83*!8<!J#9D81A! R3&#%1<J',C2*'KG

6HRXO 6RXWK .RUHD I-*! '$?#(6! -9>*!#?1*7!(-9(!9!h9@9<*6*!'$%@9<5! %?6(!'$%@*<69(*!R$#*9<!%*<!=-$! =*#*! 3$#'*7! ($! =$#;! 9(! (-*! 39'($#5! '$?#928<2!9<7!9''*668)1*!9@@#$9'-! #9)1*!%$%*<(6!9(!4$15!0#$66!-9>*! 7?#8<2! :$#17! :9#! I=$A! "$?#! %*<! 86!=-9(!%9;*6!-*#!6(9<7!$?(!96!9<! )**<! =$#;8<2! =8(-! 6(?7*<(6A! L-*! =811!*9'-!#*'*8>*!9)$?(!n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iALA! 6$81A! 7*6'#8)*7! -*#! 96! 9! @#$3*66$#! =-$! #*'*8>8<2!(-*!9=9#7/!J?;9;($!6987/! "$#!(-86!*M*'?(8>*!$#7*#!($!)*!>9187/! 86!9)1*!($![7**@15!'$<<*'(!=8(-!-*#! [F!9%!6$!-?%)1*7!9<7!(-#811*7!l!F! I#?%@!=$?17!-9>*!($!'$<(*<7!=8(-! 6(?7*<(6\!9<7![@?6-!(-*%!$?(687*! 3**1!(-9(!=-9(!F!#*@#*6*<(!=8(-!(-86! (-*!ST(-!P%*<7%*<(/!=-8'-!'9<<$(! $3 ! (-*8#! 9'97*%8'! '$%3$#(! D$<*6! 9=9#7! 86! (-*! *M'*11*<'*! $3 ! *>*#5C )*!9%*<7*7!)5!@#*687*<(891!9'(8$<A 9<7!3$6(*#!$@*<!9<7!75<9%8'!'$%C $<*!$<!(-*!39'?1(5A!F!9%!-?%)1*7! %?<8'9(8$<! (-9(! 6*(j6k! -*#! '1966*6! ($!)*!#*@#*6*<(8<2!*>*#5)$75A\ X-E7(6,.'7-$ 17B(.#42$ 7E $ ."#$ F#=$ Y7(C$ 9@9#(!3#$%!$(-*#6A\ !'6#4$,-5$."#$W,4"'-*.7-$G74.R$ !!J?;9;($!6987!(-9(!-*#!%$6(!%*%$C

The Spire

!!Q

>9$)$()0

OPINIONS

November 2, 2018

,--'./0*'!*/-+',*1)-$*&'2+-'3/#$4#$5' 2+%1$)'607"1&888

/(01&$)&23")0*"1$()4&25%&253%"1&(6 & 23789,0&:)1$;23")0#%)<%3&=3(9(0"*& >*$?$"&=")&,-@ 6/#-9 '!"#$#%$&'()#*%+

'' ' ' A%&! A.06:! +)6(#(,$.+$(2#! (,! /0..&#$18!,&&>(#5!$2!+)<+#/&!,$&:,! $%+$! 6+8! 01$(6+$&18! )(,.&5+.)! $%&! $.+#,5&#)&.! /2660#($8! (#! ($,! &#7 $(.&$8-! 1&+<(#5! $%2,&! ;%2! ()&#$(38! +,! $.+#,5&#)&.! /26:1&$&18! <01#&.7 +41&! $2! )(,/.(6(#+$(2#9! G//2.)7 (#5! $2! $%&! R&;! S2.>! A(6&,-! $%&! 'HSDUWPHQW RI +HDOWK DQG +X PDQ 6HUYLFHV ++6 LV ´FRQVLGHU LQJ QDUURZO\ GHÀ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µ 1HZ <RUN 7LPHV

*2-! ($! /26&,! +,! #2! ,0.:.(,&! $%+$! RJ\µ DEFQHZV JR FRP ,Q RWKHU 6&-!(,!62.&!$2!$%&!L0&,$(2#O!;%+$! A.06:!;201)!/2#$(#0&!%(,!:+$$&.#! ;2.),-! $%&! ,&C! 820I.&! +,,(5#&)! +$! 40,(#&,,!(,!($!23 !$%&(.,!%2;!:&2:1&! 23 ! +$$&6:$(#5! $2! &.+,&! U4+6+I,! 4(.$%!(,!#2$!$%&!,+6&!+,!820.!5&#7 /%22,&!$2!()&#$(38Y!"$I,!+,!4+/>;+.)! OHJDF\ +RZHYHU ZKDW 7UXPS·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À QLWLRQ ZKLFK LV %+<&! XS! 2.! XX! /%.262,26&,! 2.! RIÀ FH DQG WKLV LQLWLDWLYH ZRXOG ;(1)18! (#+//0.+$&! +#)! 1(6($&)! $2! $%+$!:&2:1&I,!/%.262,26&,!(#<+.(7 2#18! :.2<()&! $.+#,:%24(/! (#)(7 VD\ WKH OHDVW GRHV QRW QHJDWH WKH DEO\ GHÀ QH WKHLU JHQGHU µ 7KLV LV <()0+1,!62.&!(#/&#$(<&!$2!)(,/.(6(7 <&.8! &C(,$&#/&! 23 ! $.+#,! :&2:1&-! 23 !/20.,&-!+!3+1,&!#2$(2#9!A%&!/0.7 #+$&! +#)! +40,&! $.+#,! :&2:1&9! ! G,! #2$! $2! 6&#$(2#! ,/(&#/&9! G//2.)7 .&#$!+)6(#(,$.+$(2#!(,!3+1,(38(#5!,/(7 ($! ,$+#),-! $.+#,5&#)&.! (#)(<()0+1,! LQJ WR 'U -DVRQ 5DIIHUW\ RI +DV HQWLÀ FDOO\ VXSSRUWHG QRWLRQV DQG +1.&+)8! %+<&! &C$.&6&18! %(5%! .+$&,! EUR &KLOGUHQ·V +RVSLWDO LQ 5KRGH 3+/$,!.&5+.)(#5!;%+$!5&#)&.!(,-!+#)! 23 ! ,0(/()&-! +#)! +.&! 3.&L0&#$18! $%&! ",1+#)-! ?5&#)&.! 52&,! 4&82#)! 4(217 KRZ LW LV GHÀ QHG 7KH OXQDF\ IRU <(/$(6,! 23 ! 40118(#5-! ;2.>7:1+/&!

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`aI,9!"!+6!#2$!,0.&! ;%(/%!(,!;2.,&O!$%+$!$%&!A.06:!+)7 6(#(,$.+$(2#! ,&&6,! 24,&,,&)! ;($%! &.+,(#5!U4+6+I,!1&5+/8!2.!$%+$!$%&8! ,(6:18!)2!#2$!/+.&!+420$!$%&!<&.8! .&+1!,/(&#/&!+#)!>#2;1&)5&!$%+$!;&! #2;!%+<&!(#!20.!:2,,&,,(2#9!b($%&.! ;+8-!($!(,!+#2$%&.!0,&1&,,!+#)!%+.67 301! :21(/8! 6&+#$! $2! +::&+1! $2! $%&! 12;&,$! 4+,&! 23 ! A.06:! ,0::2.$&.,! +#)!$2!)(,$.+/$!3.26!$%&!.&+1!/.(,(,! $%+$! ;&! 3+/&! +,! +! #+$(2#! )(<()&)! ;($%! +! )8,30#/$(2#+1! 52<&.#6&#$9!

A%B7)C$)#&15%&!+15&(6 &D%?%30%&D"E$08& !"##$%&'())(**+&,-. !"#$#%$&'()#*%+' ! ! ! ! ! "#! $%&! '#($&)! *$+$&,-! $%&.&! (,! +! /01$0.&! 23 ! +$$.(40$(#5! +/$,! 23 ! %+$&! 2.! )(,)+(#! +5+(#,$! +! /26607 #($8!$2!.+/&-!.&5+.)1&,,!23 !$%&!.+/&! 23 ! $%&! )(,/.(6(#+$&)! /2660#($89! 0RUH VSHFLÀ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À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

2.! ?K10&! J(<&,! H+$$&.9@! A%&! ?G11! J(<&,@!:&.,:&/$(<&!(,!62.&!23 !+!)(,7 :0$&!23 !$%&!62<&6&#$!+,!+!;%21&-! ;%(1&!$%&!?K10&!J(<&,@!:&.,:&/$(<&! +.50&,!$%+$!$%2,&!;%2!60.)&.!1+;! HQIRUFHPHQW RIÀ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Á DZHG +#)! <&.8! )+#5&.20,9! "#! 2.)&.! $2! 62<&! 32.;+.)! +#)! %+<&! :21($(/+1! +#)! ,2/(+1! :.25.&,,! +,! +! #+$(2#-! ;&! 60,$! +//&:$! $%&! .&+1! :.241&6,! +,! B0,$! $%+$O! .&+19! P+/(,6! (,! .&+1-! +#)! .&<&.,&! .+/(,6! (,! 23$&#! +! ;+8! (#! ;%(/%! ;%($&! :&2:1&! $.8! $2! %()&! $%&!.&+1($8!23 !$%(,!.+/(,6!+#)!6+.7 5(#+1(=+$(2#! (#! $%&! '#($&)! *$+$&,9! A%(,!/2#/&:$!(,!)&$.(6&#$+1!$2!$%&! :2,,(4(1($8! 23 ! )&<&12:6&#$! +#)! /%+#5&-! ,26&$%(#5! $%+$! $%(,! /20#7 $.8! ,2! )&,:&.+$&18! #&&),! +#)! ;(11! /2#$(#0&!$2!#&&)!32.!6+#8!)&/+)&,9

&&&&&+&&&&

OPINIONS

The Spire

November 2, 2018

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

#()#! /4#%%1! 2#$.$! ;! #05! *#$! 0<(1@ (*,!*%!5$5(40*$!+,/$1- !*%!0!'9+<$.! %- ! 5(--$.$'*! 04*(8(*($/! 2#(1$! /*(11! +0('*0('(')!+,!0405$+(4!/*0'5(')6 ! ! ! ! A-*$.! -011! %.($'*0*(%':! ;! -$1*! LQYLJRUDWHG WR EHJLQ P\ À UVW \HDU %- ! 4%11$)$! 2(*#! 0! -$.8%.! *#0*! /9.@ &0//$5!0',!$34(*$+$'*!;!-$1*!('!+,! KLJK VFKRRO \HDUV +RZHYHU DV WKH $0.1,!/*0)$/!%- !*#$!/$+$/*$.!<$)0'! *%! &0//! +$! <,:! ;! 20/! +$*! 2(*#! 0/@ /()'+$'*! 0-*$.! 0//()'+$'*! 2#(4#! '$4$//(*0*$5! +,! 2#%1$! *(+$! 0'5! $'$.),6!;!20/!9'0<1$!*%!&0.*(4(&0*$! ('!*#$!2#%1$!#%.(=%'!%- !419</!0'5! $8$'*/!*#0*!#9')!%8$.!B%9'*!C0('*! D0+$/6! A*! *#$! .$01(=0*(%'! *#0*! *#$!

%&$'(')! 4#0&*$.! *%! +,! E9('*$/@ /$'*(01!4%11$)$!40.$$.!20/!'%*!<1%/@ VRPLQJ DV LW VKRXOG , ZDV WHUULÀ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

!!!!7'$!%- !*#$!+%/*!80190<1$!*#(')/! WKDW P\ À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

(+&%.*0'4$! %- ! '%*! 1(+(*(')! ,%9.@ /$1- !*%!%'$!(5$0!%- !0'! $3&$.($'4$6! ! ! ! ! ! G#0')$! (/! %-*$'! +$*! 2(*#! 0! 4%++0'5(')!*.$&(50*(%'!0/!&$%&1$! 0.$! 9'/9.$! %- ! 2#0*! *%! $3&$4*6! ;'@ 5(8(5901/!+9/*!-$$1!+%.$!0&&.%04#@ 0<1$! *%! 4#0')$! 0/! (*! %-*$'*(+$/! <.(')/! 0<%9*! &%/(*(8$! 4#0')$/! 2#(4#! 011%2! -%.! ).%2*#! 0'5! *#$! '$$5$5! 05?9/*+$'*! %- ! $3&$4*0@ *(%'/6! G#0')$! /*0'5/! 0/! *#$! %+@ '(&.$/$'*! -%.4$! ('! /%4($*,! 2#(4#! (/! $8$.10/*(')! 0'5! .$/(/*0'*! *%! 0116!

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Á H[LYH GHVLUH WR VKXW GRZQ WKRVH 2(*#!2#%+!%'$!5(/0).$$/:!<9*!*.()@ )$.! 20.'(')/! 0.$! /%! 4%9'*$.&.%@ 594*(8$! 0'5! '%'/$'/(401! *#0*! *#$,! GHVHUYH VSHFLÀ F FULWLFDO DWWHQWLRQ "#0'F-911,:! ;! #08$! '%*! 0**$'5$5! 0! 410//! ('! 2#(4#! *.())$.! 20.'(')/! 2$.$! (//9$5:! <9*! ;! 5%! <$1%')! *%! 0! )$'$.0*(%'! %- ! 4%11$)$! /*95$'*/! 0*! 2#%/$! /4#%%1! *#$! &#$'%+$'%'! (/! 011!*%%!4%++%'6! $ WULJJHU ZDUQLQJ LV À UVW DQG -%.$+%/*!8$.,!.0.$1,!4011$5!-%.6!7'! À UVW JODQFH RQH PD\ WKLQN WKDW LQ D /4($'4$!4%9./$!2#$.$!).0&#(4!(+0)@ $.,!2%915!<$!5(/49//$5!%.!/#%2':!0! *.())$.! 20.'(')! +0,! <$! '$4$//0.,6! C9.$1,:!0!&.%-$//%.!2%915!'%*!20'*!

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À FXOW WR GLVFXVV !!!!!;'*$.$/*(')!*%!'%*$:!#%2$8$.:! 0.$!#%2!-$2!410//$/!('!*#$!A405$+,! 5$01!2(*#!*.91,!*.())$.@('594(')!.$@ 04*(%'/6! P0+$1,:! *#$.$! /(+&1,! 0.$! '%*! +0',! 410//$/! ('! *#$! A405$+,! *#0*! 2%915! .$&$0*$51,! 0'5! *#%.@ %9)#1,! 5(/49//! *%&(4/! *#0*! 4%915! 04*9011,!*.())$.!0!&#,/(%@$+%*(%'01! .$04*(%'6! "#%9)#! *#$! -%11%2(')! +0,! .(')! 9'/,+&0*#$*(4:! (- ! *#$! À HOG LQ ZKLFK D VWXGHQW LV PDMRU (')! 5%$/! -.$E9$'*1,! 055.$//! *%&(4/! %- !/$3901!8(%1$'4$:!0<9/$:!$*46:!*#$'! WKH VWXGHQW À QGV KLPVHOI LQ PRUH %.!1$//!*#$!/0+$!&104$!0/!*#$!E9$0/,! /*95$'*! ('! *#$! /4($'4$! 410//6! "#0*! (/:!0!5(/4(&1('$!Q!1(*$.011,!4$0/$/!*%!

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

)$.!20.'(')/!0.$!*#$!5(/4(&1('$/!*#0*! 0.$!/9&&%/$5!*%!<$!#$1&(')!/%4($*,! /%18$! /$$+(')1,! ('*.04*0<1$! (//9$/6! C%:! 2#0*! $304*1,! 0.$! -.$$! /&$$4#! 058%40*$/! 4011(')! -%.! ('! 4.(*(4(=@ (')! *.())$.! 20.'(')/M! ;.%'(4! 01/%! (/!*#$!-04*!*#0*!%'!+0',!40+&9/$/:! (*! (/! /*0*(/*(4011,! 9'1(F$1,! *#0*! *#$/$! *%&(4/!0.$!<$(')!055.$//$5!('!0!20,! *#0*! (/! ('/$'/(*(8$! *%! #(/*%.(4011,! +0.)('01(=$5!).%9&/6!WA!XYZ[!V4%'! -RXUQDO :DWFK VWXG\ À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·V 3LHFH ´+RZ 7ULJ

JHU :DUQLQJV DUH +XUWLQJ 0HQWDO +HDOWK RQ &DPSXV µ LQ 7KH $W 10'*(4!-%.!5$*0(1/!%'!#%2!/%+$!/*9@ 5$'*/! 4011! -%.! *.())$.! 20.'(')/! <$@ -%.$!.$05(')!N"#$!\.$0*!\0*/<,6O! !!!!!"%!<$!41$0.:!%.*#%5%3,!2(*#('! 0!5(/4(&1('$!(/!'%*!('#$.$'*1,!('8(5(@ %9/:! '%.! (/! (*! 9'(E9$! *%! *#$! *#.$$! À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

="6"5$234#8&@A+&B"2$: ?#&?/3(5"$&@+3-M&@FLFM& :3ED"#3:&7$(0&3-"&/(66"8":&(7 & 9($/":3"$M&4#/6ED4#8&3-"&=(66"8"& (7 &3-"&!(6%&=$(::M&:328"D&2& D"0(#:3$234(#&2824#:3&K#43"D& <323":&4#P(6P"0"#3&4#&3-"&S4"3O #20&92$G&T"PG&<R($D:&4:&:-(R#& :1"2J4#8&23&3-"&1(D4E0&DE$4#8& 3-"&D"0(#:3$234(#G

7KH &ROOHJH·V À UVW VHDO FUHDWHG 4#&3-"&@UV>:&2#D&E:"D&E#346&@UL+G ,--'".%*%&'/%0+*1&2'%3 '*.1'4%--151'%3 '*.1' 6%-2'4+%&&7',+/.#81&'9$)':"1/#9-'4%--1/*#%$&' ".%*%'59--1+#1&;

C$(3":3&-"6D&(#&/201E:&4#&3-"&@FA>:G&H"05"$:&(7 &3-"&I62/J& <3ED"#3&K#4(#&-"6D&02#%&1$(3":3:&3-$(E8-(E3&3-"&@FL>:&2#D& @FA>:M&/2664#8&7($&"NE26&3$"230"#3&(7 &266&:3ED"#3:G&I<K&/"6O "5$23":&3-"4$&+>3-&2##4P"$:2$%&#"Q3&R""J"#DG

FEATURES

The Spire

'%"+4*%A

November 2, 2018

B31%Q[%*&!4A$=&_$=VA

;*4A"<%*&3E &+)%&F%%VX 2334&!(55(6#(17(&89:

O((,A37&B3%7$=VW&@IJ -.#)/+0#10!"#$%

HQJDJLQJ '"13*$+%&NEE:;"QR4A&8%A+"4*"7+X& 7KH )O\LQJ 5KLQR 03Q%+3>7X&.DLOXD +DZDLÂ·L &&& )DYRULWH (SLVRGH RI WKH 2IÃ&#x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Â´,VDEHOÂµ '"13*$+%&!31$%X&1DWLRQDO 7UHDVXUH '"13*$+%&;33(&M%"7A&Z*$7VX&,FHG SHS! '"13*$+%&637#\O*+$A+X&]5LYHUÂµ E\ /HRQ SHUPLQW ODWWH %ULGJHV C%"A+&'"13*$+%&;33(&M%"7A&Z*$7V&+3& '"13*$+%&HU^U&6)3>AX&5HDO +RXVHZLYHV !"V%X&3HDQXW %XWWHU 3URWHLQ VPRRWKLHV RI 1HZ <RUN 9HHS $UUHVWHG 'HYHO! 234*&!"7+*"X ,WÂ·OO DOO ZRUN RXW RSPHQW N7%&H)$7#&234&F34(<&;)"7#%&"+& '"13*$+%&!%"(&37&;"QR4AX&)HQZD\ 03(,&;*3AAX&)LQLVK WKH FRQVWUXFWLRQ 2SHQLQJ 'D\ LQ .LPEDOO DOUHDG\ '"13*$+%&_*3E%AA3*&"7<&F),9&X&3URIHV! VRU (ULF )OHXU\ +HÂ·V KLODULRXV DQG VXSHU

;*4A"<%*A&3E &+)%&F%%VX F)%*%&"*%&+)%,&73>9

'3*Q%*&;*4A"<%*&3E &+)%&F%%V&b4($"&Z@O#3A+$73&@./&=)%=V%<& 3EE & )%*& 0;& M4=V%+& ($A+& $+%Q& "7<& R%*E3*Q%<& <4*$7#& "& I/& AR3+&>$+)&_"4($7"&!"*+$7&@.I&+)$A&>%%Vc

!"##$%&'(")%*+,&-./ !"#$% &'$()*+$,&-.#)/+ &&&&&1RYHPEHU LV RIÃ&#x20AC;FLDOO\ XSRQ XV DQG ZKDW EHWWHU ZD\ WR FHO! HEUDWH WKH ODVW IXOO PRQWK RI WKH IDOO VHPHVWHU WKDQ ZLWK D QHZ SOD\OLVW" +HUH LV D VDPSOH VHOHF! WLRQ RI ZKDW , ZLOO EH OLVWHQLQJ WR WKLV ZHHNHQG

IDQV RI WKH EDQG ZLOO Ã&#x20AC;QG VLPL! ODULWLHV WR Â´6RPHERG\ (OVH Âµ D KLW IURP WKH EDQGÂ·V ODVW DOEXP EHFDXVH ERWK VRQJV LQFOXGH EULJKW GDQFHDEOH EDFNJURXQG WUDFNV FRPELQHG ZLWK PHODQ! FKRO\ O\ULFV ,W LV D VRQJ WKDW FDQ PHDQ GLIIHUHQW WKLQJV LQ GLIIHU! HQW PRPHQWV LWÂ·V JRRG IRU D OLVWHQ RQ D )ULGD\ QLJKW EODVWHG IXOO YROXPH IURP D GRUP URRP

0"1%& 234& 51%*& 6%%7& +)%&8"$79&:&;*%%<%7=%& ;(%"*>"+%*&8%1$1"(

P33<7$#)+& B& P3& :& O*$"7"& P*"7<% $OULJKW , FDQQRW LQ JRRG IDLWK SOXJ DQ $ULDQD *UDQGH EUHDNXS VRQJ ZLWKRXW LQFOXGLQJ DQ RGH WR 'DYLGVRQ ,Q DQ DO! EXP Ã&#x20AC;OOHG ZLWK ORYH VRQJV QR! WDEO\ WKH RQH PLQXWH LQWHUOXGH OLWHUDOO\ QDPHG Â´SHWH GDYLG! VRQ Âµ , UHFRPPHQG UHOLYLQJ WKH VWDUW RI WKHLU UHODWLRQVKLS ZLWK Â´*RRGQLJKW 1 *R Âµ 7KH VZHHW VRQJ DERXW D GHYHORSLQJ FUXVK OLIWV LWV FKRUXV IURP ,PRJHQ +HDSÂ·V VRQJ Â´*RRG! QLJKW DQG *R Âµ DQG ZLOO UHPLQG \RX RI WKH GD\V ZKHQ *UDQGH DQG 'D! YLGVRQÂ·V VRFLDO PHGLD SRVWV ZHUH ERWK XELT! XLWRXV DQG QDXVHDWLQJO\ FXWH

+DYH \RX HYHU VHHQ WKH UDLQ" , KDYH 6R PXFK UDLQ LQ IDFW WKDW P\ +RO\ &URVV IDP! LO\ ZHHNHQG WDLOJDWH ZDV FDQFHOOHG 0\ IDPLO\ DQG , DOPRVW GURZQHG ZKLOH WUXGJLQJ LW WR RXU EDFNXS SODQ OXQFK DW 6KUHZVEXU\ 6WUHHW QRW M3)%Q$"7& 8)"RA3<,&& D EDG VHFRQG RSWLRQ :&S4%%7T&O+&C$1%&O$< 7KLV ZHHNHQG DOVR 7KH 4XHHQ ELRSLF SUHGLFWV ORWV RI UDLQ! Â´%RKHPLDQ 5KDSVRG\Âµ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Ã&#x20AC;OP RFFXUV ZKHQ 0HU! DOVR LQFOXGHG O\ULFV DERXW UDLQ $ULDQD *UDQGH DQG 3HWH 'D! FXU\ FRPHV EDFN WR WKH EDQG DI! LQ VXE GHJUHH WHPSHUDWXUHV YLGVRQÂ·V ZKLUOZLQG IRXU PRQWK WHU OHDYLQJ WR SXUVXH D VROR FD! WKHQ , FRXOG UHDOO\ LGHQWLI\ ZLWK URPDQFH LV GRQH DQG LW VRXQGV UHHU DQG WKH EDQG SOD\V D VHW DW WKH PHWDSKRU SUHWW\ Ã&#x20AC;QDO VKH UHWXUQHG WKH /LYH $LG 7KH Ã&#x20AC;OPÂ·V VRXQGWUDFN HQJDJHPHQW ULQJ 'D! LQFOXGHV WKH EDQGÂ·V DFWXDO /LYH ?+@A& B3+& C$1$7#& D?E & ?+@A& B3+& YLGVRQ JDYH KHU DIWHU WZR ZHHNV $LG SHUIRUPDQFH VR OLVWHQHUV F$+)&234G&:&H)%&IJKL RI GDWLQJ DQG FODLPHG FXVWRG\ DQG YLHZHUV FDQ H[SHULHQFH RI WKHLU SHW SLJ 3LJJ\ 6PDOO] 4XHHQ DV LI WKH\ ZHUH LQ WKH 7KLV LV WKH Ã&#x20AC;IWK VLQJOH UHOHDVHG ,Q OLJKW RI $ULDQDÂ·V WRXJK \HDU DXGLHQFHU& LQ DGYDQFH RI WKH 0DQFKHVWHU , ZLOO EXPS WKLV VRQJ LQ VROL! (QJODQG EDVHG EDQGÂ·V XSFRP! GDULW\ ZLWK KHU +RSHIXOO\ VKH LQJ DOEXP Â´$ %ULHI ,QTXLU\ LQWR EHOLHYHV LQ ZKDW VKH SUHDFKHV 2QOLQH 5HODWLRQVKLSV Âµ VHW WR EH LQ WKLV HPSRZHULQJ EUHDNXS UHOHDVHG RQ 1RYHPEHU WK VRQJ WKDW GHFODUHV KHU D Â´ZLOG Â´,WÂ·V 1RW /LYLQJ ,I ,WÂ·V 1RW RQHÂµ WKDW LV Â´EHWWHU RII ZLWKRXW :LWK <RX Âµ LV D SHUIHFW H[DPSOH KLP Âµ RI ZKDW 7KH GRHV EHVW

_%%R&!,&;*$[X&C%),&`.J 03Q%&+3UUU M$"7="&!$==3($A& a"+%(,7&_%+%*A37 7/;5#<$.&64&=(>>#$&'<("$+)4

,V %LDQFD DQG .DWHO\QÂ·V URRP DOZD\V WKLV FOHDQ RU LV WKLV MXVW OHIWRYHU IURP IDPLO\ ZHHNHQG"

The Spire

FEATURES

November 2, 2018

29#1#&4#EC(<*0&M1"3/1B&>1/#9/1B&N99";1#$3 !"#$%#&'"%%()"*&+,!"#$%&"'()*+$,& !!! /DVW )ULGD\ WKH ,WDOLDQ 6WXGLHV 'HSDUWPHQW ZHOFRPHG $OJHULDQ ELOLQJXDO QRYHOLVW $PDUD /DNKRXV IRU D OHFWXUH H[SODLQLQJ ´ZK\ LPPLJUDWLRQ LV WKH PRVW H[FLWLQJ H[SHULHQFH LQ OLIH µ /DNKRXV·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À YH ODQ JXDJHV %HUEHU KLV QDWLYH WRQJXH $UDELF )UHQFK ,WDOLDQ DQG (QJ OLVK $W DJH KH ZURWH KLV À UVW ERRN LQ $UDELF ´7KH %XJ DQG WKH 3LUDWH µ ZKLFK ZDV SXEOLVKHG DJDLQ IRXU \HDUV ODWHU LQ ,WDOLDQ 6LQFH WKHQ /DNKRXV SXEOLVKHG ´&ODVK RI &LYLOL]DWLRQV 2YHU DQ (OHYD WRU LQ 3LD]]D 9LWWRULRµ ´'LYRUFH ,VODPLF 6W\OH LQ 9LDOH 0DUFRQLµ ´'LVSXWH RYHU D 9HU\ ,WDOLDQ 3LJOHWµ DQG ´7KH 3UDQN RI WKH *RRG /LWWOH 9LUJLQ LQ 9LD 2UPHDµ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À QLWLRQ LQ RUGHU WR GLVFXVV D WRSLF +H GHÀ QHG LPPLJUDWLRQ DV WKH ´DFWLRQ RI FRPLQJ WR OLYH

LQ D IRUHLJQ FRXQWU\ µ 7KLV ZDV DQ LQWHUHVWLQJ LQWURGXFWLRQ WR KLV DUJXPHQW IRU LPPLJUDWLRQ DQG KH IROORZHG ZLWK KLV VL[ UHDVRQV DV WR ZK\ LPPLJUDWLRQ LV WKH PRVW H[FLW LQJ H[SHULHQFH LQ OLIH ./#*($&-0&'(1/&2%3"($ ,Q H[SODLQLQJ WKH SRVLWLYLW\

LPPLJUDWHG WR 1HZ <RUN DJDLQ KH KDG WR OHDUQ D QHZ ODQJXDJH DQG FXOWXUH IRU WKH VHFRQG WLPH $FFRUGLQJ WR /DNKRXV KH KDV KDG WKUHH OLYHV DQG WZR V\PEROLF GHDWKV 7KH VHFRQG SDUW RI WKH PHWDSKRU LV WKH ´GHDWKµ RI WKH SUHYLRXV OLIH +H SURYLGHG WKH H[DPSOH RI ZKHQ KH ZHQW EDFN

À YH ODQJXDJHV DQG ZULWHV LQ WZR PRUH ODQJXDJHV VHUYHV DV D FOHDU UHDVRQ IRU LPPLJUDWLRQ $FFRUG LQJ WR /DNKRXV ODQJXDJH LV SRZHU ,W FUHDWHG D VSHFLDO FRQQHFWLRQ EHWZHHQ KLP DQG KLV IDWKHU GXULQJ KLV FKLOGKRRG :KHQ /DNKRXV LPPLJUDWHG WR ,WDO\ KH VSHQW WZR PRQWKV OHDUQLQJ ,WDOLDQ VR WKDW

F1#$*"3"($&C#18&D(1E&"$3(&A#*G *"($ H3#I&#D#I&J1(9&$/;#3"5/&A/(A)/ K/5/1&;"5/&<A :LWK WKLV LQVSLUDWLRQ KH WROG WKH DXGLHQFH DERXW VRPH RI KLV GUHDPV $W DJH /DNKRXV UHDG *XVWDYH )ODXEHUW·V ´0DGDPH %RYDU\ µ ZKLFK PDGH KLP UHDOL]H KLV GUHDP ZDV WR EHFRPH DQ $UD ELF ZULWHU KH DFKLHYHG WKLV GUHDP DW DJH ,Q $OJHULD EHFDPH WRR GDQJHURXV IRU /DNKRXV WR DFKLHYH KLV GUHDPV DV KH ZDWFKHG IULHQGV G\LQJ LQ FLYLO ZDU KH ZRXOG QRW ZDLW IRU WKLV IDWH :KHQ KH PRYHG WR ,WDO\ KH KDG D GUHDP RI EHFRPLQJ D ELOLQJXDO ZULWHU DQG EHJDQ ZULWLQJ ERRNV LQ ERWK ,WDOLDQ DQG $UDELF +H À UVW ZURWH ´&ODVK RI &LYLOL]DWLRQV 2YHU DQ (OHYDWRU LQ 3LD]]D 9LWWRULRµ LQ $UDELF EXW GHFLGHG WKDW KH ZDQWHG WR JLYH KLV ,WDOLDQ FKDUDFWHUV DQ ,WDOLDQ YRLFH 7KXV KH UHZURWH WKH ERRN WR DFKLHYH WKLV GUHDP )LQDOO\ KLV FXUUHQW GUHDP LV D ZRUN LQ SURJUHVV WR EHFRPH D WULOLQJXDO ZULWHU DGGLQJ (QJOLVK WR WKH OLVW +H KRSHV WR DFKLHYH WKLV GUHDP LQ WKH QH[W IHZ \HDUV

29#1#&4#EC(<*&*A(E/&3(&@()I&Q1(**+&N3#)"#$&H3<8"/*&>/A#139/$3&#?(<3&3C/&A(*"3"5/&#*A/%3*&(J &C"*&"99";1#3"($& 3(&29/1"%#, -,%&$"'.(,/ (0#1#'+2"$()%&,3#

RI LPPLJUDWLRQ KH VDLG WKDW WKH GHÀ QLWLRQ FRQWDLQHG WKUHH ZRUGV RI PRYHPHQW ´DFWLRQ µ ´FRP LQJ µ DQG ´OLYH µ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·V SUHYLRXV OLIH +H UHODWHG WKLV WR KLV RZQ OLIH LQ KH ZDV ERUQ LQ $OJHULD ,Q KH LPPLJUDWHG WR ,WDO\ WKLV ZDV KLV VHFRQG ELUWK EHFDXVH KH GLG QRW NQRZ WKH ODQJXDJH KH ZDV OLNH D EDE\ UHOHDUQLQJ KRZ WR OLYH LQ D QHZ FXOWXUH )LQDOO\ LQ KH

WR $OJHULD IRU WKH À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

./#*($&L0&'(1/&>/9(%1#%I /DNKRXV· À QDO UHDVRQ LV WKDW LPPLJUDWLRQ WHVWV WKH WUXWKIXO KH FRXOG IXOO\ LPPHUVH KLPVHOI LQ QHVV RI D GHPRFUDF\ $FFRUGLQJ WKH FXOWXUH 7KLV DOORZHG KLP WR WR /DNKRXV UHVSHFWLQJ PLQRULWLHV ZULWH D ERRN LQ ,WDOLDQ ZKLFK ZDV LV WKH EHVW FKHFN IRU GHPRFUDF\ D UHZDUGLQJ H[SHULHQFH EHFDXVH RI ,PPLJUDQWV XVXDOO\ PRYH IURP WKH KDUG ZRUN WKDW KH LQYHVWHG LQWR SRRU FRXQWULHV WR ULFK GHPRFUD OHDUQLQJ WKH ODQJXDJH :KLOH KH FLHV 7KHVH GHPRFUDFLHV·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´+XPDQ EHLQJV $PDUD /DNKRXV À QLVKHG KLV QHHG GUHDPV WKH ZD\ À VK QHHG GLVFXVVLRQ ZLWK D IHZ SDVVDJHV ZDWHU µ ,W LV QDWXUDO IRU KXPDQ IURP KLV QRYHO ´'LVSXWH 2YHU EHLQJV WR KDYH GUHDPV KRZHYHU D 9HU\ ,WDOLDQ 3LJOHW µ ZKLFK VRPH DUH PRUH ZLOOLQJ WR PDNH VXPPHG XS WKH LPPLJUDQW H[SHUL WKHP D UHDOLW\ /DNKRXV SURYLGHG HQFH WKDW UHÁ HFWHG KLV RZQ $W KLV VL[ IRXQGDWLRQV RI GUHDPV WKH HQG RI WKH FRQYHUVDWLRQ KH UHPLQGHG WKH DXGLHQFH WKDW KH LV 7"$8&#&?";&5"*"($ D QRYHOLVW EXW WKDW KH XVHV KLV OLIH @#5/&#&;((8&A)#$0&81/#9"$;&"*& H[SHULHQFH DQG LGHDV WR UHOD\ KLV A1#%3"%#) PHVVDJH LQ À FWLRQ 7(1;/3&3#)/$3B&?/)"/5/&"$&C#18& D(1E

:KDW·V 1HZ 7R 1HWÁ L[ LQ 1RYHPEHU O((8&M"))&@<$3"$;& P<)"/&#$8&P<)"# FC/&!#))#8&(J &!<*3G /1&H%1<??*B&#&Q(/$& !1(3C/1*&#$3C()(;I& H"R3//$&Q#$8)/*

7KH VL[WK DQG À QDO H/#*($&L&(J &FC/&O1/#3& G&*/#*($&(J &@(<*/&(J & !1"3"*C&!#E"$;&HC(D Q#18* H/R&#$8&3C/&Q"3I0&FC/& '(5"/ H%#1I&'(5"/&,&S&6

EGGPLANT

The Spire

November 2, 2018 !!!!!!!!!"

#$%!&''()*+,!! !"#$%&'(#)*$%+,'('-+.$/+0# 1+*3.$7!8%9'+:!*:!1;<9+9:,3*,9/+!=/+,3/> ?%3:9*))7!8%()*.%:!@%9+A!B9,$!C3%+.$4: &*,/+!DE!=/+;9<%+,! 67*,$'2$,"#$%+4-#! !!!!! ´$W À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À FHU ´7HQ %$/,%! /,! 4'5&0%! '1*! '>5/%(! '(! (#*$1!A/$>$,7!&/$,(:!"#*1*D%!'!2*13! 1*'>!(#1*'(!/6 !$,%011*4($/,:U!C#*,! $,(*12$*)*-.!5*5A*1%!/6 !(#$%!*M8 (1*5$%(! )$,7! 4$(*-! 50>($&>*! 1*'8 %/,%!6/1!(#*$1!-$%%'($%6'4($/,!)$(#!

(#*! '-5$,$%(1'($/,:! _,*! %/014*! )#/!)$%#*-!(/!1*5'$,!',/,35/0%! ]A0(! )/1*! (#*! 0,5$%('+'A>*! 6'8 ($70*%!/6 !'!Y$5A'>>!='&('$,^!%'$-! (#'(!(#*!0,$J0*!6*'(01*!X)#*1*!(#*! &05&!%(/&%!)/1+$,7!/,!(#*!#/,*3!

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

5'$,('$,*-! (#'(! (#*3! )*1*! 4/,8 60%*-! A3! (#*! %(0-*,(! A/-3D%! 1*'48 ($/,:!XGD5!T0%(!%'3$,7.!)#*,!)*D1*! 4#'17$,7!*M/1A$(',(!1'(*%!/,!`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

/6 !'0(#/1$(3!(/!-/!*2*13(#$,7!(#*3! 4/0>-! (/! 5'+*! %01*! J0**1! &*/&>*! 6*>(!%'6*K!%*,-!/0(!',!*5'$>:!G!+,/)! )#'(! %/5*! /6 ! 3/0! 5'3! A*! (#$,+8 $,7K! G%,D(! (#'(! '! >/(! (/! '%+! &*/&>*! $,! &/%$($/,%! /6 ! '0(#/1$(3! (/! -/L! G! 5*',.! 0%0'>>3! )*! 7*(! *5'$>%! 6/1! /,>3!(#*!5/%(!$5&/1(',(!$,6/15'8 ($/,:! G.! #/)*2*1.! (#$,+! ('+$,7! (#*! 2*13!-1'%($4!%(*&!/6 !%*,-$,7!/0(!',! HPDLO LV YHU\ MXVWLÀ HG ZKHQ VXFK D #/11$A>*!',-!410*>!#'(*!41$5*!)'%! 4'11$*-! /0(:! "#*! ,*M(! -'3! '6(*1! 1*'-$,7!(#1/07#!(#*%*!*5'$>%.!G!6*>(! %/! 1*>$*2*-! )'>+$,7! '1/0,-! 4'58 &0%:!"#*!6//(A'>>!&>'3*1!E!(#*!%'5*! /,*!(#'(!(/>-!5*!'>>!7'3!&*/&>*!7/! (/!#*>>!53!%/&#/5/1*!3*'1!E!4'5*!

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

/6 ! '&&>'0%*! (/! (#*! #$7#*1! 0&%! $,! (#*! '-5$,$%(1'($/,! 6/1! -/$,7! %/! 504#! (/! &1/(*4(! (#*! J0**1! %(08 -*,(%!'(!H/>3!=1/%%:!G!53%*>6 !6**>! %/! $,41*-$A>3! 71'(*60>! (#'(! G! '5! /,!'!4'5&0%!(#'(!4'1*%!%/!-**&>3! 'A/0(!(#*$1!RSF"!4/550,$(3!(#'(! (#*3!'1*!)$>>$,7!(/!%*,-!',!*5'$>: 93!%$,4*1*%(!71'($(0-*:!

J,4:!#$%!=*,*)9+*!K9+%!L9M%3N!1+;!J,4:!=/<9+'! ,/!@/)7!=3/::N D*)%!D/0*.I 8+..$9':$;(+072 !!! !!!!C*D2*!'>>!#*'1-!/6 !(#*!6'5/0%! ='('>$,'!C$,*!9$M*1:!!P/&0>'1$O*-! A3!(#*!abbc!4/5*-3!X;(*&!F1/(#8 *1%.U!(#*!*2*,(!$%!5'1+*(*-!'%!X(#*! >'17*%(! #*>$4/&(*1! >*'%$,7! *2*,(! $,! (#*!C*%(*1,!H*5$%&#*1*:U!!H/)8 *2*1.!5/%(!&*/&>*!-/,D(!+,/)!(#'(! (#*!*2*,(.!'>(#/07#!+,/),!6/1!A*8 $,7!$,!'!5/2$*.!$%!'4(0'>>3!2*13!1*'>! ',-!(#$%!3*'1D%!*-$($/,!)$>>!A*!('+8 $,7!&>'4*!1$7#(!#*1*!'(!H/>3!=1/%%Q ! ! ! ! ! [*&.! 3/0! 1*'-! (#'(! 1$7#(.! (#*! ='('>$,'! C$,*! 9$M*1! )$>>! A*! #'&8 &*,$,7!/,!/01!4'5&0%!]/1!%>$7#(>3! RII LW DQG LW ZRQ·W EH WKH À UVW WLPH *$(#*1d! (#*! *2*,(D%! #/%(! %*>*4($/,!

4/55$((**!#'%!4#/%*,!H/>3!=1/%%! IRU KDQGOLQJ DOO WKH GLJQLÀ HG SHR %*2*1'>!($5*%!/2*1!(#*!3*'1%:!!"#*! &>*!)#/!)$>>!'>5/%(!4*1('$,>3!A*!'(8 4 / 5 5 $ ( ( * *! #'%! 1*>*'%*-! '! %('(*5*,(! %'38 $,7! (#*3! >/2*! #/%($,7! (#*! 5$M*1! '(! H/>3! =1/%%! -0*! (/! X(#*! %(0-*,(! A/-3D%! &'%%$/,! 6/1! %/4$'>$O$,7.! (#*! %4#//>D%! & $ 4 ( 0 1 * % J 0 *! %*(($,7.!',-!(#*! &'1+$,7!>/(!T0%(! /66 ! 4'5&0%! (#'(! $%! %**58 $,7>3! &*16*4(!

(*,-$,7:U!!G,!6'4(!H/>3!=1/%%!$%!(#*! /,>3!&>'4*!(#$%!*2*,(!#'%!A**,!#*>-! /(#*1! (#',! ='('>$,'!G%>',-! /6 !4/01%*: F0(! (#'(D%! ,/(! '>>.! '%! $,! (#*! &'%(.!(#*!*,($1*! %(0-*,(! A/-3! )$>>! A*! $,2$(*-! (/! '((*,-! ',-! ,*()/1+! )$(#! (#*! 5/%(! $58 &/1(',(! &*/&>*! $,! (#*! #*>$4/&8 (*1! $,-0%(13:!! W2*13/,*! $%! *M&*4(*-! (/!

-1*%%!'44/1-$,7>3d!(#$%!$%!(#*!='('8 >$,'! C$,*! 9$M*1! '6(*1! '>>.! ',-.! '%! '>)'3%.!'4(!'%!'&&1/&1$'(*>3!',-!1*8 %&*4(60>>3!'%!&/%%$A>*:!!"#*!*2*,(!$%! *M(1*5*>3!#$7#!4>'%%.!)#$4#!4',,/(! A*!*5&#'%$O*-!*,/07#.!%/! I%! /6 ! 1$7#(! ,/)! $(! $%! 0,-*4$-*-! )#*,! *M'4(>3! (#*! *2*,(! )$>>! ('+*! &>'4*.!A0(!$(D%!A'%$4'>>3!'!70'1',(**! $(!)$>>!A*!/,!',!0&4/5$,7!;'(01-'3! $,! V/2*5A*1! 5/%(! >$+*>3! A*6/1*! "#',+%7$2$,7! A1*'+:! ! ?01(#*1! -*8 ('$>%!)$>>!A*!1*>*'%*-!%//,Q!!@/,D(! 5$%%!/0(!/,!(#$%!'5'O$,7!*2*,(Q

The Spire

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À YH +9)==6$:XC!;'D!+'-R%!6)J$!=3:J$%( =366>!1-+!'#!;$3#C!%#$)9!166(/01! @$-%$9!T$V39@D:!2'D:)-:C!#$!', ! 3!FP>FYBF>ZYP>U!:%3%!6)-$!63:%!;$39C! ID:%!.'%!@6$39$+!%'!9$:D*$!493@%)@$> !!!!!!?J3;C!:'!%#$!8399)'9:!39$! .')-.!%'!@34!',, !%#$!%#9$$(4$3%!

SPORTS

November 2, 2018

?%@("#%A8"%B'""/8")%1'2/$(#C D(6'%E8F5/5

-$E%![D-$>!0D%!&)%#!TD93-%!3-+! WKH 'DOODV 0DYHULFNV· À UVW VHYHQ @'*=)-3%)'-!', !:J)66:!%'!)*43@%! "#'*4:'-!='%#!4'%$-%)366;!,3@( .3*$:C!T'-@)@!):!3<$93.)-.!FG>U! %#$!.3*$!)-!3!-D*=$9!', !&3;:>! )-.!,9$$!3.$-@;!-$E%!:D**$9C!)%R:! 4')-%:!4$9!.3*$!%'!.'!36'-.!&)%#! 'RQFLF LV PRVW GHÀ QLWHO\ RQ WKH &'9%#&#)6$!%'!%3J$!3!6''J!39'D-+! Q>P!9$='D-+:!3-+!U!3::):%:!_-D*( 6'&!$-+!', !%#$!/01R:!3%#6$%)@):*! %#$!9$:%!', !%#$!8$:%$9-!2'-,$9( =$9:!%#3%!'-6;!:)E!9''J)$:!#3<$!$<$9! :4$@%9D*C!=D%!#$!D%)6)L$:!#):!:)E( $-@$!3-+!:$$!&#'!*).#%!=$!3=6$! $OD36$+!'<$9!3!,D66!:$3:'-XC!3-+!;$%! ,''%(:$<$-C!FFG(4'D-+!,93*$!%'! %'!+$%#9'-$!%#$!@#3*4:!+'&-!%#$! )%!):!%#$!:%;6$!)-!&#)@#!#$!):!+')-.! #):!3+<3-%3.$!)-!'%#$9!&3;:>!T'-( 9'3+>!H!4')-%!;'D!%'!3!-D*=$9!', ! )%C!-'%!ID:%!%#$!93&!-D*=$9:C!%#3%! @)@!'<$9@'*$:!#):!63@J!', !$E46'( 9):)-.!:%39:! :)<$-$::!&)%#! 39'D-+!%#$! *'9$! 6$3.D$!&#'! -D3-@$+! @3-!#$64! ='+;!*'<$( *3J$!%#):! *$-%:>!"#$! :$3:'-!3-! 9''J)$!D:$:! $-%$9%3)-)-.! 3!<3:%!3993;! '-$!+$:4)%$! RI Á RDWHUV 5'6+$-! :@''4:C!=366! 7%3%$R:!@'-( ,3J$:C!3-+! %)-D$+!9$).-! +$@$4%)'-! ', !%$99'9>! %'!:6)%#$9! \'D-.!.D-:! 39'D-+!%#$! :D@#!3:![3;( @'D9%!3-+! :'-!"3%D*C! .$%!=D@J$%:! T'-'<3-! ,9'*!$<$9;! V)%@#$66C! 6$<$6!', !%#$! T$<)-! Á RRU 1RW 0''J$9C!0$-! '-6;!@3-!#$! 7)**'-:C! D:$!%#):!=3.! /)J'63! ', !%9)@J:! /,#%#'0#1$%-&4'#. '7-8)!"*9 ['J)@C!3-+!3!.6D%!', !'%#$9! %'!.$%!%'! 0DYHULFNV URRNLH /XND 'RQFLF JRHV XS IRU D EDVNHW =D9.$'-)-.!:%D+:!39$! #):!:4'%:C! À OOLQJ ER[ VFRUHV RQ D T'-@)@!='3:%:!)-@9$+( -).#%6;!=3:):>!]'&$<$9C!-)44)-.! ):!.39-$9)-.!%#$!*':%!3%%$-%)'->! )=6$!<):)'-!%#3%!4D%:!#):!%$3**3%$:! '-!%#$!#$$6:!', !%#$:$!$:%3=6):#$+! T'-@)@!93-J:!-$39!%#$!%'4!', !%#$! )-!4':)%)'-:!%'!:@'9$>!1:!:'*$'-$! D4(3-+(@'*$9:!):!%#$!76'<$-)3-! 6$3.D$!)-!4'%$-%)36!3::):%:!4$9!.3*$! ZKR LV QRW WKH Á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À FLHQW SHUIRUPDQFH IURP +'*)-3-@$X!J-'&->!"#9'D.#'D%! -3-@$C!T'-@)@!',,$9:!3!D-)OD$! WKH À HOG VKRZLQJ WKDW \RX GRQ·W

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À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

@"()'G#")%:48"2)%H8(FG(4%I>"8($>% J5289#"%KL)2

%./**0%1/234'2"/56%7,+,*-. '!"#$%&'()*%#$

À UVW \HDU 6LPRQ %HFKHU DQG MXQLRU ^DJ3!V)6)+93.'<)@!366!:@'9$+!,'9!%#$! 29D:3+$9:>! 2'-.93%D63%)'-:! 39$! )-! !^$%R:!%3J$!3!6''J!3%!#'&!]'6;!29'::! '9+$9!%'!:$-)'9:!?&$-!1L93JC!0'=( 3%#6$%)@:!%$3*:!)-!3@%)'-!#3<$!=$$-! ,39)-.!9$@$-%6;>

$-R:!7'@@$9!%$3*!_P(BFX!&9344$+!D4! )%:!:$3:'-!&)%#!3!F(B!6'::!%'!^$#).#! 3%!#'*$!63:%!K9)+3;>![D-)'9!,'9&39+! 2396;!K63#)<$!:@'9$+!#$9!%$3*(=$:%!

%'! 0$-%6$;! 63:%! K9)+3;! -).#%! )-! 836%#3*>! 7'4#'*'9$! +$,$-:$*3-! K93-J)$! 0')$! -$%%$+! 3! @39$$9(#).#! %&'! .'36:C! ,$66'&! :'4#'*'9$! +$(

18829'** "#$!]'6;!29'::!K''%=366!%$3*!_F( QX! *3+$! 3! :%3%$*$-%! =;! +$,$3%)-.! `3%9)'%! ^$3.D$! ,'$! ^$#).#! PQ(G! 63:%! &$$J$-+! )-! 8'9@$:%$9C! V3::>! "#$!29D:3+$9:!4D%!'-!3!.9$3%!+):( 463;!,'9!%#$!]'6;!29'::!@'**D-)%;! '-! K3*)6;! 8$$J$-+C! 36%#'D.#! %#$! *'-:''-($:OD$! @'-+)%)'-:! J$4%! *':%!,3-:!,9'*!3%%$-+)-.!%#$!.3*$>! [D-)'9! 9D--)-.! =3@J! T'*)-)@! 2'( L)$9!@399)$+!%#$!=366!FU!%)*$:!,'9!3! FDUHHU KLJK \DUGV DQG D WRXFK +'&-! $-! 9'D%$! %'! `3%9)'%! ^$3.D$! /,#%#'0#1$%-&%'#. '2#,#340$#&&50#6 ?,,$-:)<$!`63;$9!', !%#$!8$$J!#'-( &RQJUDWXODWLRQV WR DOO VHQLRU VWXGHQW DWKOHWHV ZKR DUH À QLVKLQJ WKHLU FDUHHUV WKLV IDOO '9:>! [D-)'9! V)6$:! 16$E3-+$9! 3++$+! \DUGV RQ FDUULHV 6HQLRU 5$',, ! 83+$! @'*46$%$+! $).#%! ', ! BF! 43::$:! ,'9! BAP! ;39+:! 3-+! ,'D9! %'D@#+'&-:> =;!039:)@C!";6$9!0$66C!V3:'-!09D*( À IWK JRDO RI WKH VHDVRQ &RQJUDWX ,$-:$*3-! ^'.3-! V)66)J$-! :@'9$+! *$%%C!b')-!]'D6)#3-C!5399$%%!^$3( 63%)'-:!%'!:$-)'9:!b**3!5D9@#)$JC! KLV À UVW FDUHHU JRDO DQG À UVW \HDU :855#" #;C!a>[>!`63@$C!3-+!]$-9;!7%D%L!'-! V$.3-! ^3&6'9C! 7%$4#3-)$! ^D-+C! ,'9&39+!V3%%!0399;!3++$+!3-'%#$9C! 3@@'*46):#$+! @39$$9:>! "#):! .9'D4! ^)6;!`D@@)3C!1-.!7$:6)I3C!23::)$!7;( #):!%#)9+!.'36!', !%#$!:$3:'->!"#$;! "#$!]'6;!29'::!V$-R:!7'@@$9!%$3*! #$64$+! 6$3+! %#$! 29D:3+$9:! %'! %#$! *'-+:C!3-+!239'6)-$!83663@$> %3J$! '-! dA! `9'<)+$-@$! 2'66$.$! 3%! _A(Z(UX! .D%%$+! 'D%! 3! A(F! <)@%'9;! `3%9)'%!^$3.D$!K)-36!63:%!;$39>!"#$! #'*$! %#):! 73%D9+3;! -).#%! 3%! ceGP! '<$9! 19*;! 63:%! 7D-+3;! 3%! #'*$! WHDP ZLOO À QLVK LWV VHDVRQ WKLV 6DW ;5#%&856#0 `>V>! 8'*$-R:! H@$! ]'@J$;! _G(c(FX! '-! 7$-)'9! T3;>! 7$-)'9! a>[>! `63@$C! D9+3;! -).#%! 3%! ^$#).#>! "#$! 8'*( V$-R:! H@$! ]'@J$;! _B(UX! ,$66! c(U! ,$66! P(B! %'! dQ! 0':%'-! 2'66$.$! 3%!

#'*$! 63:%! K9)+3;! -).#%>! K)9:%(;$39! ,'9&39+! 7'**$9! a'::! :@'9$+! %#$! 6'-$!.'36>!"#$!-$E%!-).#%C!%#$;!,$66! %'!V$99)*3@JC!P(G>! <*)#=>#"# K)$6+! ]'@J$;! _A(BUX! ,$66! )-! '<$9( %)*$! U(A! %'! fD)--)4)3@! '-! 7$-)'9! T3;>! V$-R:! 3-+! &'*$-R:! 9'&)-.! @'*4$%$+! 3%! %#$! `9)-@$%'-! 2#3:$! a$.3%%3>! g'66$;=366! _Q(BZX! 9)+$! 3! %&'(.3*$!&)--)-.!:%9$3J!3,%$9!9'3+! <)@%'9)$:! 3%! ^$#).#! 3-+! 0D@J-$66>! 9ROOH\EDOO À QLVKHV WKH VHDVRQ ZLWK ,'D9! *'9$! #'*$! *3%@#$:>! V$-R:! 3-+! &'*$-R:! @9'::! @'D-%9;! ='%#! @3*$! )-! c%#! 3%! %#$! `3%9)'%! ^$3.D$! 2#3*4)'-:#)4:>! 2'-.93%D63%)'-:! WR MXQLRU -HQQD *DVSLUULQL IRU À Q ):#)-.!)-!:$@'-+!463@$!&)%#!3!%)*$! ', ! FBePG! '<$9! %#$! QJ! @'D9:$! 3-+! $39-)-.! 29D:3+$9! ', ! %#$! 8$$J! #'-'9:>! 0'%#! %$3*:! &)66! @'*4$%$! )-! %#$! /211! /'9%#$3:%! a$.)'-36! -$E%!&$$J$-+>!8'*$-R:!:&)**)-.! 3-+!+)<)-.!&'-!%#$!8'9@$:%$9!2)%;! H-<)%3%)'-36! &#)6$! %#$! V$-R:! %$3*! %''J!:$@'-+>!8'*$-R:!5'6, !463@$+! BG%#! 3%! %#$! ^$#).#! H-<)%3%)'-36! &#)6$!V$-R:!5'6, !463@$+!:$@'-+!)-! 3! %9)(%'D9-3*$-%>! 2'-.93%D63%)'-:! %'!366!:$-)'9:h

The Spire

SPORTS

November 2, 2018

:4#FG/F$%8F%:(55#))C%;)%;2%B8"2>%;2M N'56*/F%O8"2#9#/F%7,!"#$%&'()*%#$ !!!!!!8)%#!%#$!9$@$-%!3++)%)'-!', ! %#$! iZG! *)66)'-! ^D%#! 1%#6$%)@! 2'*46$E!%'!%#$!]'6;!29'::!@3*( 4D:C!&#)@#!)-@6D+$+!-$&!@'3@#$:R! RIÀ FHV ZHLJKW URRPV EDVNHWEDOO @'D9%:C! 3! #'@J$;! 9)-JC! :&)**)-.! SRROV DQG DQ LQGRRU WXUI À HOG )%! :$$*:! 3449'49)3%$! %'! @'-:)+$9! :4$-+)-.! )-! @'66$.$! 3%#6$%)@:! 3-+! &#$%#$9! %#$! )-@9$3:$! )-! +'6639:! %93-:63%$:! %'! .9$3%$9! :D@@$::>! ?-! 3<$93.$C!:@#''6:!)-!%#$!`'&$9!K)<$! @'-,$9$-@$:! :4$-+! *)66)'-:! ', ! +'6639:! 3--D366;! '-! 3%#6$%)@:! 3-+! '-$! *)66)'-! '-! 9$@9D)%)-.! 36'-$>! 8)%#! -$&! "g! +$36:C! @'-%)-D'D:! 9$<$-D$! 3-+! @'-%)-D$+! ,D-+93):( )-.C! %#$:$! :@#''6:! 39$! 3=6$! %'! 36( 6'@3%$! *'9$! *'-$;! %'&39+:! 3%#( OHWLFV VSHFLÀ FDOO\ WKHLU ELJJHVW 9$<$-D$! =D)6+$9:! :D@#! 3:! ,''%=366! 3-+!*$-R:!3-+!&'*$-R:!=3:J$%=366>! ! ! ! "#$! *$3:D9$! ', ! :D@@$::! ,'9! @'66$.)3%$! 3%#6$%)@! +$439%*$-%:! @'*$:!)-!%#$!,'9*!', !%#$!T)9$@( %'9R:! 2D4C! &#)@#! 3&39+:! 3%#6$%( )@:! +$439%*$-%:! 4')-%:! =3:$+! '-! À QLVKHV LQ 1&$$ FKDPSLRQVKLSV 3-+! *$+)3(=3:$+! 4'66:>! ^''J)-.! DW WKH WRS À QLVKHUV VLQFH WKH &XS :%39%$+! )-! BZZUC! %#$9$! 39$! :'*$! =).! :4$-+$9:! 6)J$! `$--! 7%3%$! &#'! À QLVKHG DQ DYHUDJH RI WK LQ WKH SDVW À YH \HDUV ZKLOH VSHQGLQJ D @'*=)-$+! 3<$93.$! ', ! iF>F! *)66)'-! SHU \HDU RU *HRUJLD ZKR À QLVKHG 3-!3<$93.$!', !BU%#!3-+!:4$-%!iF>P! *)66)'-!4$9!;$39>!\$%C!:@#''6:!+'-R%! -$@$::39)6;! #3<$! %'! $*4%;! %#$)9! =3-J!3@@'D-%!%'!3@#)$<$!%#$:$!#).#! À QLVKHV 6WDQIRUG ZKR KDV DYHU DJHG À UVW SODFH LQ WKH 'LUHFWRU·V 2D4!$<$9;!;$39!):!ID:%!%#$!Ac%#!=).(

.$:%! :4$-+$9! &)%#! ID:%! '<$9! i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e! &#3%! *3J$:! %#$:$! :@#''6:! @#3*4)'-:#)4! 344$393-@$:W! "#$)9! ):! $::$-%)366;! -'-($E):%$-%! )-! *':%! :'! :D@@$::,D6! +$:4)%$! :4$-+)-.! @'3@#! 0'=! 836:#! 3%%9)=D%$:! )%! %'! 49',$::)'-36!:4'9%:>!"3J$!%#$!/K^! ,39! 6$::! %#3-! %#$)9! @'*4$%)%'9:W #'&! %#$;! =D)6+! %#$)9! %$3*:>! M?D9! '9!/]^!,'9!)-:%3-@$l!-'!*3%%$9!%#$! ! ! ! ! "#$! j-)<$9:)%;! ', ! a#'+$! H:( *3-%93! ):! kb-%)%6$+! %'! /'%#)-.CRN! 3*'D-%! ', ! *'-$;! %#3%! %$3*:! )-! 63-+! V$-R:! 03:J$%=366! %$3*! 9$49$( $E463)-:! %#$! #$3+! @'3@#>! "#$! ='%#!:4'9%:!:4$-+!'-!463;$9:C!%#$9$! :$-%:! ;$%! 3-'%#$9! 49'.93*! &#)@#! :@#''6R:! M-'($E@D:$:! 3449'3@#N! ):! 3! &$3J! @'99$63%)'-C! ), ! 3%! 366C! =$( #3:! 49'<$-! %#3%! *'-$;! +'$:! -'%! ):! %#$! 4$9,$@%!3%%)%D+$!,'9! %#$! %;4$! %&$$-!:4$-+)-.!3-+!:D@@$::>!2'-( 3D%'*3%)@366;! %93-:63%$! %'! 3%#6$%)@! ', ! #D-.9;! 463;$9:! %#$! :@#''6! 3%( :)+$9)-.! %#$! iQ>PA! =)66)'-! )-! %'%36! :D@@$::>! H-! 3! *)+(*3I'9! T)<):)'-! %93@%:! 3-+! %#9)<$:! '-! _K'9=$:X> :3639)$:!43)+!'D%!=;!366!/K^!%$3*:!

&8*0%@"8))%G#A#'2)%."0'F2P%D886)%18"='"G%28% @8FA#"#F5#%Q*'08AA) N'$$/#%1*'>#"20+,!"#$%&'()*%#$ !!!!!!!]'6;!29'::!9D.=;!_A(B(BX!)*( 49$::$+!K3*)6;!8$$J$-+!:4$@%3%'9:! 63:%! K9)+3;C! ?@%'=$9! FcC! &)%#! 3-! BB(%9;! 4$9,'9*3-@$! 3.3)-:%! 09;( 3-%! j-)<$9:)%;! _A(F(GX>! ! `6$-%;! ', ! ,9)$-+:!3-+!,3*)6;!=93<$+!%#$!@'6+! %$*4$93%D9$:! %'! :D44'9%! ]2aK2! ,'9! )%:! ZeAG! 4>*>! *3%@#! 3%! K3%#$9! SDL-)$&:J)! K)$6+C! 3-+! %#$;! &)%( -$::$+! 3! %9D$! 3--)#)63%)'-! ', ! 09;( DQW·V FOXE $IWHU WKH À UVW KDOI +RO\ 29'::! #3+! 369$3+;! $:%3=6):#$+! 3! VLJQLÀ FDQW OHDG RYHU %U\DQW Z>! ! "#$! 29D:3+$9:! @'-%)-D$+! %#$)9! 9'D%!', !09;3-%!)-!%#$!:$@'-+C!:@'9( )-.!UG!*'9$!4')-%:!,'9!3!@'*,'9%( DEOH À QDO VFRUH RI 7KH ZLQ VROLGLÀ HG WKH &UXVDGHUV DV WKH dBQ(93-J$+!9D.=;!%$3*!)-!%#$!-3( %)'-!4$9!%#$!/3%)'-36!7*366!2'66$.$! aD.=;!?9.3-)L3%)'-! 2'3@#$:!`'66>! +RO\ &URVV· RYHUSRZHULQJ À W -$::!3-+!#D:%6$!49'<$+!)-+$,$-:)=6$! %'! 09;3-%l! *3-;! 29D:3+$9! :@'9)-.! '44'9%D-)%)$:! 9$:D6%$+! ,9'*! 'D%( 9D--)-.! 09;3-%R:! +$,$-:$>! "#$! 29D:3+$9:R! +'*)-3-%! 4$9,'9*3-@$! &3:!='6:%$9$+!=;!A!%9)$:!$3@#!,9'*! :$-)'9! 0)66;! 2'D.#6)-! 3-+! ,9$:#( *3-![3@J!7&'9+:>!!]'6;!29'::R!6$3+!

ZDV VROLGLÀ HG :)'->! 09;3-%R:! ,D9%#$9! &)%#! Z! 4')-%:! @3*$! F! %9)$:! ,9'*! '-6;! ,9'*! :$-)'9! 2#9):! %#9$$! 4$-36%;! `D:3%$9$>!7$-)'9! J)@J:C! 3-+! %#$! 0)66;! 2'--'9:C! ]2a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a ) 6 $ ;! ) - .! V@5$3+;! @'-%9)=D%$+! 3++)( 3! ,'9*)+3=6$! +$,$-:)<$! 49$:$-@$! LQ D GUDZ DJDLQVW À UVW SODFH (DVW %)'-36! 4')-%:C! &)%#! V@5$3+;! %#9'D.#'D%!%#$!*3%@#>!"#$;!'<$9( $9-! 2'--$@%)@D%! 7%3%$! j-)<$9:)%;! @'*46$%)-.! %&'! @'-<$9:)'-! 4'&$9$+! 09;3-%! )-! %#$! *3I'9)%;! _U(G(BX>! "#$! 29D:3+$9:! @34)%36( J)@J:! 3-+! '-$! ,9'*! 2'D.#6)-> ', ! :@9D*:! %'! 9$%3)-! :'6)+! 4'::$:( )L$+! '-! %#$)9! :4$$+! 3.3)-! )-! %#3%!

*3%@#C! 'D%9D--)-.! b27j! ,'9! 3! %#9$$!%9;!6$3+!,'9!*':%!', !%#$!:$@( '-+!#36,>!]'&$<$9C!b27j!:%3.$+!3! @'*$=3@J! 63%$! )-! %#$! :$@'-+! #36, ! ', ! %#$! *3%@#! %'! %)$! ]'6;! 29'::> ! ! ! ! ! "#$! 29D:3+$9:! #3<$! 3! &$$J! RI SUDFWLFH WR UHÁ HFW RQ WKH SRVL %)<$:! 3-+! -$.3%)<$:! ', ! %#$)9! 43:%! *3%@#$:>!"#$;!6''J!,'9&39+!%'!%#$! /$&!b-.63-+!7*366!2'66$.$!aD.=;! ?9.3-)L3%)'-!463;',,:!%#):!D4@'*( )-.! &$$J$-+>! ]'6;! 29'::! ,3@$:! D-+$,$3%$+! j(V3)-$! K39*)-.%'-! _P(G(GX!%#$!-).#%!', !73%D9+3;C!/'( <$*=$9! AC! )-! 3-! $6)*)-3%)'-! .3*$! 3%! 2'6=;! 2'66$.$! )-! 83%$9<)66$C! V3)-$>!"#$!29D:3+$9:!#3<$!#):%'9;! &)%#! K39*)-.%'-l! 73%D9+3;R:! .3*$! ):! 3! 9$*3%@#! ', ! 63:%! ;$39R:! @'-,$9( HQFH À QDO ZKHUH +RO\ &URVV IHOO AQ(BZ! 3,%$9! 3-! D-+$,$3%$+! 9$.D( 639! :$3:'->! j(V3)-$! K39*)-.%'-! @D99$-%6;! :%3-+:! 3:! %#$! dP(93-J$+! %$3*! -3%)'-366;>! H, ! ]'6;! 29'::! ):! <)@%'9)'D:!3.3)-:%!K39*)-.%'-C!%#$! 29D:3+$9:! &)66! #'4$! %'! %3J$! %#$! @'-,$9$-@$! @#3*4)'-:#)4! @9'&-! '-! 7D-+3;! 3.3)-:%! %#$! &)--$9! ', ! %#$! 2'6=;! 2'66$.$(b3:%$9-! 2'-( -$@%)@D%! 7%3%$! j-)<$9:)%;! *3%@#D4>

The Spire

SPORTS

November 2, 2018

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Ã&#x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

2")+)&>5&?4#&0#&&@&AB

+DOO RI )DPHU %RE &RXV\ DQG DXWKRU *DU\ 3RPHUDQW] LQ 6HHORV 7KHDWHU RQ FDPSXV

LQ WKLV Ã&#x20AC; QDO VWDJH RI KLV OLIH LV QRW 1#$!'015/(!&8 !5,#0$L$-$/1+!1#$!3.&! 5-5++$3C! V51#$*:! )&.+(R+! 3$,0+0&/! 1&!251,#!03'(!5+!V.++$'':!5/!&.1+A&B NHQ Ã&#x20AC; JXUH LQ FLYLO ULJKWV DGYRFDF\ $/3.*$3! ($5*+! &8 ! *5,05'! A*$E.30,$! 5/3! 57.+$! #5+! '$81! 5! 2&./3! 0/! )&.+(R+!+&.'!1#51!/&!75+6$175''!8$51! ,&.'3! #$5'C! %5L0/?! +15**$3! 8&*! 1#$! )$'10,+!8&*!+0M!($5*+!7$8&*$!V.++$''! E&0/$3!1#$!1$5-!5+!5!*&&60$!8&*!1#$! ;<=PB;<=\! ,5-A50?/:! )&.+(! 25+! 2$''!525*$!1#51!#$!#53!1#$!-$305R+! $5*C!Z]!25+!1#$!-5/:[!)&.+(!E&6$3:! 1#$! 8530/?! '5.?#1$*! ?0L0/?! 25(! 1&!

5/! ./3$*'(0/?! +$/+$! &8 ! *$-&*+$C ! ! ! ! )&.+(:! 2#&! #5+! /$L$*! -&L$3! &.1!&8 !G&*,$+1$*!+0/,$!$/*&''0/?!51! %&'(!)*&++!0/!1#$!85''!&8 !;<^P:!,*$3B 01+!1#$!F$+.01+!201#!0/+10''0/?!5!+$/+$! &8 !*0?#1!5/3!2*&/?!0/!#0-C!]/3$$3:! #0+! L0$2+! &/! *5,$! *$'510&/+! 2$*$! A*&?*$++0L$!8&*!#0+!10-$!5/3!A'5,$C! %$! *&&-$3! 201#! 1$5--51$! 5/3! FORVH IULHQG &KXFN &RRSHU WKH Ã&#x20AC; UVW T8*0,5/BT-$*0,5/!A'5($*!3*581$3!0/! 1#$! X4TC! "#$*$8&*$:! #0+! 0/5,10&/! 2#$/! 01! ,5-$! 1&! 1#$! ,5+$! &8 ! +.AB A&*10/?!V.++$''!25+!/&1!03$&'&?0,5'B '(B3*0L$/C!)&.+(:!6/&2/!5+!5!_.0$1!

5/3!0/1*&L$*1$3!-5/!0/!#0+!A'5(0/?! 35(+:!+503!1#51!#$!A*$8$**$3!1&!'$53! 7(!5,10&/+!*51#$*!1#5/!2&*3+:!2#0,#! -53$!#0-!./,&-8&*157'$!201#!&8B 8$*0/?!5!A.7'0,!3$8$/+$!&8 !V.++$''C! `$5*+! '51$*:! #$! 2&.'3! ,&-$! 1&! *$B ?*$1! Z/&1! 8$$'0/?! #0+! A50/! -&*$C[ !!!!!!I&-$*5/1J!3$150'+!0/!7$5.108.'! IDVKLRQ KRZ &RR]Â·V XQVHOÃ&#x20AC; VK SOD\ 0/?! +1('$! W#$! 0+! 1#$! &/'(! A'5($*! 1&! '$53!1#$!X4T!0/!5++0+1+!$0?#1!3088$*B $/1!10-$+Y!-0**&*+!#0+!5AA*&5,#!1&! #0+!A$*+&/5'!'08$N!'0L0/?!8&*!5/3!201#! &1#$*+:!5+!1#$!F$+.01+!2&.'3!+5(C!]/! KHU Ã&#x20AC; QDO \HDUV &RXV\Â·V ZLIH 0LV

+0$!+1*.??'$3!201#!3$-$/105!7$8&*$! A5++0/?! 525(! 0/! a>;UC! b.*0/?! 1#0+! 10-$:!)&.+(!1&&6!,5*$!&8 !#$*!$L$*(! /$$3! W2#0,#:! #$! +5(+! 0/! 1(A0,5'! *$B 3.,10L$! 85+#0&/:! 25+! 75+0,5''(! E.+1! Z156$B&.1!5/3!A0''+[YC!%$!+10''!,&-B PXQLFDWHV ZLWK KHU HYHU\ GD\ Ã&#x20AC; OOLQJ #$*!0/!&/!#0+!/&2!_.0$1!'08$C!]/!a>>U:! #$! +&'3! &88 ! #0+! A'$/108.'! -$-&B *570'05! 8&*! 57&.1! c^=>:>>>:! 2#0,#! #$!1#$/!?5L$!1&!#0+!12&!35.?#1$*+C !!!!!!4.1!)&.+(!+10''!#53!&/$!1#0/?! '$81! 1&! ?0L$N! 5/! 5A&'&?(! 1&! #0+! &'3! 1$5--51$:! 40''! V.++$''C! @&! 0/! 9$7B *.5*(!a>;P:!-&L$3!7(!1#$!A*&,$++! &8 ! 2&*60/?! &/! 1#$! 7&&6:! )&.+(! A$//$3! 5! =$1& 948(1! '$11$*! 1&! V.+B +$'':!&88$*0/?!.A!5!7$'51$3!5A&'&?(C! G#0'$! 1#$! /&1$! 2$/1! ./5/+2$*$3! 8&*!12&!5/3!5!#5'8 !($5*+:!)&.+(!*$+1! 5++.*$3! 1#51! #$! 5,1$3! &/! 5! 3$$AB +$51$3! *$?*$1:! 7(! 7&1#! 2*010/?! 1#$! '$11$*! 5/3! ?0L0/?! #0-+$'8 ! 1&! 1#0+! 7&&6C! "2&! -&/1#+! 5?&:! V.++$''! FDOOHG &RXV\ XS IRU WKH Ã&#x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

G#$$5(H5,"51&$$&(>65+#,(!#+)$%(5/(>5/1&)/( I#5'*#(:259"&)$,2&", B)JJ;(K*??&)(LEF -.#+)*C#:C!"#$% !!!!!!F./0&*!F$//5!H5+A5**0/0!25+! *.//$*B.A!51!1#$!I51*0&1!d$5?.$! )*&++!)&./1*(!)#5-A0&/+#0A+! '5+1!@51.*35(!51!4.,6/$''C!H5+B SDUULQL Ã&#x20AC; QLVKHG LQ VHFRQG SODFH &L$*5''! 201#! 5! 10-$! &8 ! a;N=>C<! &/!1#$!+0MB60'&-$1$*!,&.*+$:!5+! 1#$! %&'(! )*&++! 2&-$/R+! ,*&++! ,&./1*(!1$5-!A'5,$3!+$L$/1#!51! 1#$! I51*0&1! d$5?.$! )#5-A0&/B +#0AC! H5+A5**0/0! #53! 1#$! 7$+1! LQGLYLGXDO Ã&#x20AC; QLVK E\ D &UXVDGHU 51! 1#$! I51*0&1! d$5?.$! )#5-A0B &/+#0A! +0/,$! 1#$! a>><! +$5+&/:! 2#$/!I50?$!@.1#$*'5/3!,5-$!0/! +$,&/3C! ]/! 533010&/:! H5+A5**0B QLÂ·V VHFRQG SODFH Ã&#x20AC; QLVK HDUQHG KHU Ã&#x20AC; UVW WHDP $OO 3DWULRW d$5?.$!#&/&*+C!S/!1#$!+$5+&/:! H5+A5**0/0!#5+!A&+1$3!1#$!85+1B $+1! 10-$! &/! 1#$! 1$5-! 0/! 5''! +0M! *5,$+!+#$!#5+!*./C!@#$!25+!5'+&! /5-$3! )*.+53$*! &8 ! 1#$! G$$6C! ! ! ! ! ! ! H5+A5**0/0! 25+! L$*(! #5AA(! 57&.1!#$*!A$*8&*-5/,$C!Z]!8$$'!L$*(! ?&&3!57&.1!-(!*5,$:[!+503!H5+A5*B *0/0C! Z]! 2$/1! 0/1&! 01! 6/&20/?! 1#51! 1#$*$!25+!?&0/?!1&!7$!5!70?!A5,6!.A! 8*&/1!1&!,&-A$1$!201#!5/3!]!1#0/6!]!

2")+)&9)4*+$,5&)% &D)")859*),,E9)=

(((((((((((((((G*$&)1(G#$$5(H5,"51&$$&("65+#,(,#+)$%(5/(/2#(>5/1&)/(I#5'*#(:259"&)$,2&",

303!5!?&&3!E&7!&8 !+10,60/?!201#!1#$! A5,6!5/3!$L$/1.5''(!7*$560/?!525(C[ ! ! ! ! ! "#$! *5,$! 3$L$'&A$3! 1#$! 25(! 1#51! H5+A5**0/0! 25/1$3C! Z9&*! 1#$! Ã&#x20AC; UVW WZR ORRSV RI WKH UDFH WKH OHDG 2$/1!75,6!5/3!8&*1#!7$12$$/!5!8$2! A$&A'$! 0/! 5! L$*(! '5*?$! ?*&.A! &8 !

*.//$*+:[! +503! H5+A5**0/0C! ZS/,$! 2$! ?&1! 1&! 1#$! 1#0*3! '&&A! &/$! A$*B +&/!7*&6$!525(!5/3!]!1*0$3!1&!,'&+$! 1#$!?5A!&/!#$*!5+!-.,#!5+!]!,&.'3C[ !!!!!!!!"#$!,&/3010&/+!A&+$3!_.01$! 1#$! ,#5''$/?$! '5+1! @51.*35(C! ]1! 25+! 7$'&2! 8&*1(! 3$?*$$+! 5/3! 3&2/B

A&.*0/?C! "#$! ,&.*+$! 25+! +&56$3! 5/3!-.33(:!2#0,#!'$3!1&!+&-$!+'&2! 10-$+!5''!5,*&++!1#$!7&5*3C!H5+A5*B *0/0! #5/3'$3! 1#$! ,&/3010&/+! L$*(! 2$''C! Z]! 1#0/6! 1#$! A&&*! ,&/3010&/+! -56$! 8&*! 5! -&*$! 0/1$*$+10/?! *5,$C! G$!#53!5!'&1!&8 !A*5,10,$!*.//0/?!0/!

1#$!*50/!5/3!-.3!3.*0/?!2&*6B RXWV RQ IUHVKPDQ Ã&#x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`:!5/3! WKHQ ZLOO Ã&#x20AC; QLVK RII WKH VHDVRQ 51! 1#$! ])^T! )#5-A0&/+#0A+! 51! e5/! )&*1'5/31! I5*6! 0/! X$2! `&*6! )01(! &/! X&L$-7$*! ;\1#C! &&&

The Spire

ELECTION 2018

November 2, 2018