February 2022 Index

Page 1

the index The student voice since 1888

The Haverford School · Haverford, PA 19041 · February 2022· Volume 89, No. 5 · thsindex.org

Mitav Nayak ’22

Basketball approaches final stretch, eyes EA rematch

D

uring a difficult yet exciting season, Fords Basketball has overcome a number of challenges including injuries, player transfers, and misfortune. In many games, they have been a bounce or two away from a win. The players have maintained their poise, hoping to end the year strong. “We have a really good team this year. We all work hard,” Sixth Former Ryan Rogers said. “We all play for each other and move the ball. And it’s been fun to watch us succeed in getting better as teammates and individuals.” Sixth Former Matt Kearney discussed his excitement for the final push. “​​I’m really looking forward to our senior night,” Matt Kearney said. “We left a lot on the table against EA in the first game. I think we can play a lot better than that, and I think we will. There’s a good atmosphere there. We missed that last year and I value that a lot. That’s something I really want to experience.” In the last matchup, Episcopal went ahead early. Although the Fords clawed their way back in the fourth quarter, their comeback fell short by one point. On Friday, during their last home game of the season, they will have a chance to play them again. “They beat us the first time, so we need to get them back,” Rogers said.

David Kearney ’22 shoots over Cardinal O’Hara in a 42-53 loss, December 15, 2021

COMMUNICATIONS

con’t on p. 16

Community opposes Tennessee school board’s attack on free speech, banning of Maus Joey Kauffman ’23

M

aus, a Pulitzer Prize-winning graphic novel that recounts a Jewish family’s story in the Holocaust, is summer reading for the Fourth Form World History course. It is a remarkably engaging way to expose students to Holocaust history. Thus, community members were shocked to see the national news that a school board in McMinn County, Tennessee, unanimously voted to remove Maus from their classrooms (specifically an eighth-grade curriculum) because of the book’s “unnecessary use of profanity and nudity and its depiction of violence and suicide.” “When I first read [Maus] in the 1990s, I thought it was fantastic,” World History teacher Mr. Kevin Tryon said. “[Maus] is such a good story; it’s such an accessible story.” Mr. Tryon has seen Maus’s effectiveness in engaging students in the complicated sub-

Encanto, p. 13

DISNEY

ject of the Holocaust, especially through its depiction of the character of Vladek, a father and a Holocaust survivor. “For some students, there’s a lack of knowledge about the Holocaust. And Maus is so easily accessible… Like any text, I think it’s just a lens, or a window, into a past that [students] might not have clarity on,” Mr. Tryon said. While Mr. Tryon didn’t pin the banning of Maus explicitly on antisemitism, he couldn’t see validity behind the reasoning of banning the book based on obscenity. “I just am flabbergasted by that idea that profanity or nudity is the standard by which they’re basing this,” Mr. Tryon said. Community members beyond the history department have also come to oppose the ban. When Ms. Brown, Director of Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion, first read the news of Maus’s banning, she responded by going to the library and reading the book.

Mr. Arthur King, p. 6

MITAV NAYAK ’22

JOEY KAUFFMAN ’23

The Severinghaus Library exhibit on Maus “The first thing I thought about was, ‘I should read it,’ because I don’t think you can comment on something that you haven’t read, and I wasn’t familiar with the text,” Ms. Brown said. She went into the reading unbiased, purposefully having not looked at the rationale behind Maus’s banning, so as not to influence her reading of the book. What she found, after reading the book, was that the ban didn’t make sense. “I wonder if the folks who banned the book actually read the book, and I don’t think they did,” Ms. Brown said.

Dr. Callie Ward, p. 6

DR. CALLIE WARD

The conversation she had been reading from the people who banned the book was based on Maus’s use of a specific set of bad words. But after reading the book, Ms. Brown couldn’t recall any obscene language in Maus. “And so if I can’t think about what [the bad words] were, that means they couldn’t have changed the story drastically, or they were appropriate in the placement as to where they were,” Ms. Brown said. con’t on p. 7

Squash, p. 14

COMMUNICATIONS


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.