The Harvard Crimson - Volume CXLVI, No. 62

The Harvard Crimson The University Daily, Est. 1873 | Volume CXLVI, No. 62 | Cambridge, Massachusetts | monday, april 29, 2019

editorial PAGE 4

news PAGE 5

sports PAGE 6

Harvard must close the gender pay gap among its faculty.

The College unveiled a new public service initiative for the summer.

A senior is set to follow in his father’s footsteps and join the Dallas Cowboys.

Activists Rally During Heat Week Bacow Fights Endowment Tax By alexandra a. chaidez and aidan f. ryan Crimson Staff Writers

Seventeen-year-old climate activist Jamie S. Margolin shouts at the Flood Harvard rally Friday. Margolin attended the rally, intending to call on administrators to divest from fossil fuels, while on her spring break kai r. mcnamee—Crimson photographer By alexandra a. chaidez Crimson Staff Writer

Nearly one hundred students, alumni, and Cambridge residents braved the cold and rain to rally for fossil fuel divestment in Tercentenary Theatre Friday, bringing Heat Week to a close.

Heat Week first began in April 2015 as a week-long protest organized by Divest Harvard — a fossil fuel divestment advocacy group. At the time, students and faculty members blockaded Massachusetts Hall for a week, occupied the Harvard Alumni Association headquarters for two days, and

blockaded University Hall multiple times.

This year, after a week of panels, teach-ins, and civil disobedience training, ralliers gathered Friday to listen to speeches from climate change activists and Harvard affiliates; sing songs about the environment; and chant divestment slo-

gans.

Cambridge Mayor Marc C. McGovern, who spoke at the rally, called on Harvard and other local colleges and universities “to do more and to do better” and divest from the fossil fuel industry.

See divest Page 3

­ niversity President Lawrence U S. Bacow joined five other Massachusetts university and college presidents in urging United States Representative Richard E. Neal (D-Mass.) to repeal the endowment tax set to be levied on Harvard’s next filings in a letter last month.

Neal is chair of the House Ways and Means Committee, which oversees the 1.4 percent excise tax on endowment returns at institutions with endowments greater than $500,000 per student.

Harvard’s endowment, the largest University endowment in the world at nearly $40 billion, qualifies for taxation under the 2017 Republican-led Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. The University’s endowment was previously exempt from taxes because the school is a non-profit entity.

The letter stated that Massachusetts is “disproportionately” affected since the state is home to six out of the 30 schools anticipated to fall under the tax, and who are estimated to pay about 40 percent of the revenue raised by the tax.

“We anticipate the first pay-

ments under this provision are likely to be due later this year and hope that you and your colleagues will move to address it with some urgency,” the letter reads.

“The impact of this pernicious tax will grow significantly over time, as more institutions are affected, and the levy erodes our philanthropic resources,” the letter adds.

“We believe that this must be addressed swiftly and definitively to ensure that no precedent is set for such a damaging tax,” the letter added.

Signatories of the letter include Bacow, Amherst President Biddy Martin, MIT President L. Rafael Reif, Smith College President Kathleen McCartney, Wellesley College President Paula A. Johnson ’80, and Williams College President Maud S. Mandel.

The letter also projected the tax’s likely negative impact on financial aid.

“At all our schools, the neediest undergraduates receive grants that cover not just tuition but most of their other costs as well,” the letter reads. “This tax, purportedly motivated to address cost and encourage aid, will make these policies harder

See letter Page 3

Chabad Events Discuss Hosts Racial Justice in Art Vigil Post Shooting By amanda y. su

Crimson Staff Writer

By ruth zheng Crimson Staff Writer

Roughly 60 Harvard affiliates gathered at the Harvard Chabad House Sunday evening in solidarity with the Chabad of Poway, Calif., where a deadly shooting took place Saturday.

Hirschy Zarchi, Jewish chaplain and Rabbi at Harvard Chabad, organized the vigil along with his wife, Elkie Zarchi.

Hirschy Zarchi, Jewish chaplain and Rabbi at Harvard Chabad, organized the vigil along with his wife, Elkie Zarchi. Speakers at the gathering included University Provost Alan M. Garber ’76; MIT Jewish chaplain Menachem Altein; Jewish chaplain and Rabbi at Harvard Hillel Jonah C. Steinberg; Jewish chaplain and Rabbi at Harvard Hillel, and International Jewish Student Center of Boston Directors Berel Grunblatt and Esther L. Grunblatt.

On Saturday, a gunman shouting anti-Semitic slurs opened fire in the Chabad of Poway, killing one and wounding three.

Several of the victims had left Israel for America to escape regional violence.

Police took the suspect, a 19-year-old man, into custody and charged him with one count of first degree murder.

The attack took place exactly six months after the mass shooting at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh, Penn. in October.

Saturday is also the Jewish Sabbath and was the last day of Passover.

Zarchi, the first to speak, said Saturday morning’s tragedy should be an opportunity for recalling what unites the Jewish community.

He described Judaism as an affirmation of life and pledged to redouble Chabad’s efforts to promote and protect Jewish values. ­

See vigil Page 5 Inside this issue

Harvard Today 2

Hundreds of people gathered at Harvard to hear from prominent artists, scholars, and activists from across the nation about the intersection of art, race, and justice Thursday and Friday.

The Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study hosted the gathering, dubbed “Vision and Justice.” African and African American studies professor Sarah Lewis helped plan the events, which were open to the public, according to the meeting’s website.

“At Harvard we seek to bring the arts and humanities to the center of civic life, to bring them to the hardest questions, including questions of justice,” Dean of the Arts and Humanities Division Robin E. Kelsey said at the event.

Several high-level University administrators — including University President Lawrence S. Bacow and former University President Drew G. Faust — also spoke at the convening.

Prominent national political and artistic figures also spoke — including Clinton Foundation Vice Chair Chelsea Clinton, Grammy Award-winning music producer Kasseem “Swizz Beatz” Dean, and American Repertory Theater artistic director Diane M. Paulus ’88.

Throughout the covening, panelists engaged in a number of events, including “Citizenship and Racial Narratives” and “Race, Technology and Algorithmic Bias.”

During a panel on Friday, Melody C. Barnes, former assistant to the United States president and director of the Obama White House Domestic Policy Council, and Damian Woetzel, president of the Juilliard School, spoke about the White House program Turnaround Arts. Hoping to improve arts education in the country, the President’s Committee on the Arts and the Humanities founded Turnaround Arts in 2011 under the leadership of former First Lady Michelle Obama.

See justice Page 3

Naomi Wadler, Yara Shahidi ’22, and Professor Robin Bernstein discuss the experiences of black children in the U.S. during a “Vision and Justice” event. amanda y. su—Crimson photographer

UC Moves to Bar Leadership from Voting By kevin r. chen and laura c. espinoza Crimson Staff Writers

chess in cambridge

News 3

Cambridge residents play chess during the final of Community Chess Weekend in the Smith Campus Center. quinn g. perini—Crimson photographer

Editorial 4

Sports 6

Today’s Forecast

The Undergraduate Council debated and voted on two proposals Sunday that, combined, rendered the president and vice president ineligible to propose legislation and vote, overturning more than 40 years of precedent.

UC members first questioned the president’s and vice president’s voting eligibility last week, when Cabot House Representative Brandon M. Martinez ’20 pointed out that the UC’s constitution only states that “members” can vote. Both the president and vice president are considered “executive officers,” not explicitly members.

The UC sought to clarify this

partly cloudy High: 60 Low: 44

ambiguity and first voted on Sunday to create a committee to interpret the constitution. After the UC then failed to pass a proposal that would deem the president and vice president members, the newly formed committee stepped in to strip the duo of their voting powers.

The UC president and vice president have been able to vote for at least the past 40 years, according to Treasurer Jack M. Swanson ’22, who examined past UC records.

The two pieces of legislation were part of a series of acts that the sponsors called the “Great Reform.”

The first proposal, dubbed the “Great Compromise,” specified the committee to interpret

See council Page 5

Visit thecrimson.com.

Follow @TheCrimson on Twitter.

shriveled figs

THE HARVARD CRIMSON |

April 29, 2019

Page 2

Harvard today

For Lunch Popcorn Chicken Farfalle with Italian Sausage and Kale Spanish Pisto Manchego

For Dinner Chicken Piccatta Meatballs in Marinara Sauce Vegetarian Eggplant Meatballs

Today’s Events Combating Child Trafficking 11-4 p.m.

The Harvard College UNICEF Club and Harvard FIMRC have organized an info table in the Science Center Plaza to raise awareness of the widespread issue of child trafficking.

Join to support a good cause and learn how you as an individual could help combat child trafficking!

Towards Life 3.0 - Ethics and Technology in the 21st Century 5:30-6:45 p.m.

Come out to Wexner 102 at the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy to witness a talk on the intersection of ethics and technology in our modern world. As a bonus, a light dinner will be served!

A Conversation with Senator Bob Corker at the IOP 6-7:15 p.m.

Trek over to see former U.S. Senator from Tennessee discuss what he has taken away from public service and leadership. Former Secretary of Defense Ash Carter will be there as well!

in The Real World At Least 4 Casualties in California Synagogue

A synagogue in San Diego was targeted on Saturday, the final day of Passover, by a gunman.

The shooting has left a 60-year-old woman dead and three other people injured. The mayor has declared this act a hate crime.

‘Avengers: Endgame’ Shatters Box Office Records

Prospective freshmen mill around Harvard Yard on Sunday, the second day of Visitas. AMANDA Y. SU — Crimson photographer

Don’t worry, no spoilers here! “Avengers: Endgame” made around $1.2 billion at the worldwide box office on its opening weekend, being the only film in history to surpass $1 billion dollars for its debut. The previous record was held by “Avengers: Infinity War,” with $640 million earned during its debut last year.

Daily Briefing Dozens of Harvard affiliates and Cambridge residents rallied Friday, calling on the University to divest its endowment from the fossil fuel industry.

Cambridge Mayor Marc C. McGovern spoke at the rally in favor of divestment.

The event marked the end of Heat Week, a week-long protest involving panels, teach-ins, and civil disobedience training. In other news, Bacow and five other Massachusetts university and college presidents signed a letter to United States Representative Richard E. Neal, calling on him to join efforts to repeal the endowment tax that targets institutions with endowments greater than $500,000 per student.

Around the Ivies YALE

Last fall, a group of prominent Yale donors met to mull whether to remove the University’s president, Peter Salovey, the Yale Daily News reported.

The group, which included a former University Secretary and its current Chief Investment Officers, discussed concerns over whether Salovey had articulated and carried out a distinct vision during his seven years at the school’s helm. While they ultimately decided against removing him, the donors said they still have concerns about Salovey’s ability to lead the university and begin its next capital campaign.

PRINCETON

According to the Daily Princetonian, the room draw process for upperclassmen was “not completely randomized this year,” resulting in a $1000 deduction to the housing fees for approximately 220 rising seniors affected by the error. Director of Housing Dorian Johnson stated that students in the same draw group as last year “were more likely to have drawn times in the same order as last year.” The Department of Housing and Real Estate Services will continue to work on fixing the issue for next year.

CoRNELL

Cornell undergraduates will be able to print 200 pages free of charge each calendar beginning in October, the Cornell Daily Sun reported. The school’s Information Technology office announced the change last Thursday, adding that the number of pages varies slightly based on whether they are in color. Printing prices will also drop overall, a change student government representatives said they have worked to bring about for more than two years.

THE UNIVERSITY DAILY, EST. 1873

The Harvard Crimson Kristine E. Guillaume President Angela N. Fu Managing Editor Charlie B. Zhu Business Manager

Staff for This Issue

Associate Managing Editor Jamie D. Halper ’20

Arts Chairs Kaylee S. Kim ’20 Caroline A. Tsai ’20

Design Chairs Elena M. Ramos ’20 Akhil S. Waghmare ’20

Associate Business Manager Amy E. Zhou ’20

FM Chairs Norah M. Murphy ’20 Abigail L. Simon ’20

Multimedia Chairs Kathryn S. Kuhar ’20 Kai R. McNamee ’21

Editorial Chairs Jessenia N. Class ’20 Robert Miranda ’20

Blog Chairs Lorenzo F. Manuali ’21 Trula J. Rael ’21

Technology Chairs Nenya A. Edjah ’20 Theodore T. Liu ’20

Night Editor Lucy Wang ’20

Design Editor Margot E. Shang ’21

Assistant Night Editors Shera S, Avi-Yonah ’21 Brie K. Buchanan ’22

Photo Editor Shera S. Avi-Yonah ’21

Story Editors Jamie D. Halper ’20 Angela N. Fu ’20 Michael E. Xie ’20

Editorial Editor Michelle I. Gao ’21 Sports Editor Henry Zhu ’20

Sports Chairs Joseph W. Minatel ’21 Henry Zhu ’20

Copyright 2019, The Harvard Crimson (USPS 236-560). No articles, editorials, cartoons or any part thereof appearing in The Crimson may be reproduced in any form without the express written permission of the President. The Associated Press holds the right to reprint any materials published in The Crimson. The Crimson is a non-profit, independent corporation, founded in 1873 and incorporated in 1967. Second-class postage paid in Boston, Massachusetts. Published Monday through Friday except holidays and during vacations, three times weekly during reading and exam periods by The Harvard Crimson Inc., 14 Plympton St., Cambridge, Mass. 02138 Weather icons made by Freepik, Yannick, Situ Herrera, OCHA, SimpleIcon, Catalin Fertu from flaticon.com is licensed by CC BY 3.0.

Corrections The Harvard Crimson is committed to accuracy in its reporting. Factual errors are corrected promptly on this page. Readers with information about errors are asked to e-mail the managing editor at managingeditor@thecrimson.com.

Page 3

THE HARVARD CRIMSON | april 29, 2019

divest From Page 1

justice From Page 1

letter From Page 1

Activists Call on Harvard Stars Speak on to Divest During Events Art, Justice “I acknowledge the groundbreaking research and scientific advancements that are happening in our city,” McGovern said.

“Those are important; those are important to further change in the world and improve things, but that’s not enough.”

“Despite the outcry, despite the science, they’re not listening to our voices. They seem to be blind to what is happening every day,” he added.

University spokesperson Jonathan L. Swain referred to his previous statements about fossil fuel divestment.

“The University’s position, as it has stated previously, is that it should not use the endowment to achieve political ends, or particular policy ends,” Swain wrote in an email.

“As President Larry Bacow has said, the University agrees with the urgent need to tackle climate change and has valued the opportunity to discuss the issues with members of the community. Harvard is committed to influencing public policy on climate change through scholarship and research.”

At the rally, Divest Harvard organizer Ilana A. Cohen ’22 outlined the group’s list of demands regarding divestment.

The list included pushing administrators to disclose the school’s investments in the fossil fuel industry, completely divest, and reinvest the endowment in “sustainable and socially responsible funds.”

Cohen also called for the University to end its ownership of farmlands in California and other areas of the world. She gave the University the deadline of Earth Day 2020 to meet these

goals.

‘This is not a question of science, it is a question of will,” Cohen said. “We cannot wait for the President Bacows of the world to wake up and decide to do the right thing.”

Divestment activists for other causes also made an appearance at the rally. Salma Abdelrahman ’20, a member of the Harvard Prison Divestment Campaign, spoke to the lively crowd about the group’s advocacy for divestment from companies with ties to the prison in-

We cannot wait for the President Bacows of the world to wake up and decide to do the right thing.

Ilana A. Cohen ’22

dustry.

“We will continue to use civil disobedience as civil discourse until our voices are heard and until the University administration commits to a vision of our community that is not financed by the caging of black and brown people,” Abdelrahman said.

The HPDC and Divest Harvard teamed up earlier this month to interrupt an event at the Harvard Kennedy School’s John F. Kennedy Jr. Forum where Bacow was slated to speak. The event was moved to a nearby classroom after protestors occupied the stage. Prior to the rally, Divest Harvard planned and executed a week of public actions and speaker events about divestment.

At a press conference kicking off Heat Week, faculty members and prominent alumni urged the administration to divest.

The group also invited former politicians, alumni, and activists to give advice to student activists on campus.

On Tuesday, Divest Harvard painted a globe in the middle of the Science Center and educated passersby about their cause.

Divestment even crept into discussions at Visitas, the College’s annual weekend for admitted students. At the President’s Welcome Saturday, Bacow fielded two questions from prospective students about divestment.

He argued that instead of divesting, the University should engage with the fossil fuel industry through its scholarship.

Bacow even mentioned that he is a vegetarian, citing this lifestyle as “one way to minimize your carbon footprint.”

Members of Divest Harvard and HPDC also hung banners in Annenberg Hall, the freshman dining hall, and passed out pamphlets about their movements to prospective students.

Cohen said she believed Heat Week was a success because it helped Divest Harvard educate more people about its mission.

“Even if they’re not going to show up at the rallies, even if they’re not the same people who are there organizing on a groundwork level, I think that we’ve brought new people into common spaces, and helped spread awareness of the work that we’re doing and the importance of divestment,” Cohen said. alexandra.chaidez@thecrimson.com

“Art and artists weren’t a decorative force. They were a productive part of society to be subsumed and part of the onward struggle that we were all putting our shoulders to,” Woetzel said about the Obama administration’s dedication to bridging the arts and policy.

During a panel titled “Race, Childhood, and Inequality in the Political Realm,” Naomi Wadler and Yara Shahidi ’22 discussed the experiences of black children in the U.S. Wadler is a 12-year-old activist who gained national recognition for her speech about remembering black women who are victims of gun violence at the National March for Our Lives in Washington, D.C. in March 2018.

Shahidi is an actress and activist, known for her starring role in the sitcom “Black-ish” and its spin-off series “Grownish.” “[For black children], there’s a temporariness to being an adult. You are placed in the category of adult when it’s convenient and can be quickly taken out when you’re then in a position to defend yourself,” Shahidi said about the idea that black children are inappropriately seen as adults and disciplined more harshly.

Bryan A. Stevenson, founder of the Equal Justice Initiative, said during a Friday panel titled “Mass Incarceration and Visual Narratives” that he supports the Harvard Prison Divestment Campaign’s efforts calling on Harvard to divest from the prison industry.

“Does ‘Veritas’ mean we must lead? I think it does,” Stevenson said.

Stevenson concluded the two-day convening with a keynote speech in Sanders Theater. He shared personal stories from his childhood and urged the audience to pursue justice through art and storytelling.

“You don’t have to be the most talented and gifted artist. You don’t have to be the best sculptor. You don’t have to be the best photographer. You may not have the skills of some of the people who have gotten on this

If you have a heart and a mind and a willingness to change narratives, if you’ve got some hope, if you’ll do some uncomfortable things, you’ll contribute to the justice quotient we’re trying to create in this country.

Bryan A. Stevenson Equal Justice Initiative Founder

stage. You may not or have all of the answers,” he said.

“But if you have a heart and a mind and willingness to change narratives, if you’ve got some hope, if you’ll do some uncomfortable things, you’ll contribute to the justice quotient that we’re trying to create in this country,” he added. amanda.su@thecrimson.com

The T closes. We don’t.

Breaking news, 24/7.

The Crimson thecrimson.com

Bacow Pens Letter on Finance the tax for years before it became law.

Bacow has also traveled to Washington, D.C. several times since he took office last year urging legislators to repeal the tax.

Both Bacow and his predecessor, former University President Drew G. Faust, have objected to the tax, often citing the increase in cost of higher education and threat to financial aid.

In a March interview, Bacow indicated that Neal’s appointment as chair of the Ways and Means Committee and Rep. James P. McGovern’s (D-Mass.) appointment as chair of the House Rules Committee provided Harvard a “better shot” of getting Congress to revisit the endowment tax.

“This tax disproportionately affects Massachusetts and I think both Congressman Neal and Congressman McGovern understand that,” Bacow said at the time.

“They’re in a position now to be helpful in ways that they weren’t before.”

Even with the endowment tax’s first filing drawing near, Harvard is still awaiting federal guidance on how to file the endowment tax under the new law.

Endowment returns from fiscal year 2019 will be the first taxed under the new code. alexandra.chaidez@thecrimson.com aidan.ryan@thecrimson.com

THE HARVARD CRIMSON | APRIl 29, 2019

Page 4

Editorial The Crimson Editorial board

column

Full Transparency, Full Equality

Know Yourself, Know Your Worth

A

ccording to a recent nationwide survey on compensation in higher education, tenured female professors at Harvard make 92.5 cents for every dollar earned by their male counterparts. Harvard’s pay gap ranked roughly in the middle of the Ivy League The gap is worse than those at Brown and Yale, where tenured female faculty receive 95 cents on the dollar, but better than Dartmouth’s 82.5 cents.

While we acknowledge that Harvard’s pay rate is for female faculty is decently above the national gender pay gap of 85 cents per dollar and is only a few cents shy of the most equal paying schools in the Ivy League, we are still far from content. The gender pay gap at Harvard, other universities, and all employers across the nation should have been closed long ago.

Though 92.5 cents per dollar is marginally better than the 2015 surveyed figure of 92.3 cents, this gap is still egregious merely by virtue of the fact that it is not parity.

We will not be satisfied until all female faculty members — tenured, associate, assistant, and instructor — are making one dollar for every dollar earned by male faculty.

But this statistic tells only part of the story. We are still more disappointed by the fact that that only 27 percent of current tenured faculty are female.

That female professors constitute only slightly over a quarter of tenured faculty at the University while about half of the College student body is female is both practically and ideologically unacceptable.

Female students will be looking for role models who can speak to the specificity of their experiences, and a narrower pool of female professors puts them at a disadvantage in this search and may adversely impact their education.

In order to better understand and tackle this problem, we wish to see the gender pay gap data from this survey stratified by discipline to see if certain

Harvard must work towards full transparency in pursuit of full equality. fields have worse pay gaps than others.

We would also like to see the average pay data for all professors stratified by discipline, as we are concerned that professors in typically male-dominated departments like STEM could be making more than professors in departments that are unfairly associated with “feminine” occupations, such as the humanities, and that this trend could be used to justify the existing pay gap.

Even if females are paid comparably

to men within the same discipline, professors in a typically male-dominated disciplines could be earning more than a female-dominated disciplines.

If this were the case, the problem at hand would take on a different form: namely, lifting up the women who do good academic work in these disciplines to bring them to the highest levels of academia.

We would also like to see professor compensation stratified along other types of diversity, such as race and sexuality, so that any pay gaps in those respects can be both observed and rectified — particularly for women of color or for professors who are BGLTQ-identifying.

The gender pay gap and pay gaps affecting other minority groups at Harvard and beyond are a multidimensional, systemic problem that cannot be analyzed with only two columns of numbers.

Harvard must work towards full transparency in pursuit of full equality.

This staff editorial solely represents the majority view of The Crimson Editorial Board. It is the product of discussions at regular Editorial Board meetings. In order to ensure the impartiality of our journalism, Crimson editors who choose to opine and vote at these meetings are not involved in the reporting of articles on similar topics.

Submit an Op-Ed Today!

The Crimson

op-eds@thecrimson.com

Op-ed

Does Harvard Have a Conscience?

By Elijah T. Ezeji-Okoye

C

limate change is happening. This we know. There is no longer time to deny the facts.

Last year we saw flames engulf coastal California; hurricanes ravish the Carolinas; temperatures climb to new heights in Southern California; floods and droughts imposing themselves across the globe.

All of these incidents of climate extremes had been, and continue to be, foreshadowed by science — they were not without the scope of human knowledge nor vision.

And yet, in the midst of tragedy, environmental degradation, and human suffering, Harvard remains silent, hiding behind the notion that the University’s research efforts are the best way to combat the foe we humans have created.

Such rhetoric that absolves the University’s nearly $40 billion endowment of any responsibility in the discussion of climate change is not only naïve, but cowardly.

The United Nations declared climate change one of the most pressing social issues of our time, and Harvard’s investment in fossil fuel companies belies all notions of moral stewardship the University boasts all while illuminating the University’s true intentions: Profit. Regardless of the expense.

Research alone will not allay the repercussions of global climate change, which will exert disproportionate effects on low-income communities, those of color, and those of the Global South.

To hide behind the notion that the endowment should be apolitical is not only historically false, but morally reprehensible.

The way in which we allocate our money is of course political: It is a demonstration of what we — as people, as institutions, as societies —are willing to support and what we are not.

Surely, Harvard’s ultimate 1990 divestiture from tobacco companies was inherently political, coming in tandem with a letter from then-University President Derek C. Bok stating that the decision was motivated by the “unjustified risk of harm to other human beings.”

Similarly, Harvard’s decision to only partially divest from companies doing business in apartheid South Africa was equally political. Such a decision demonstrated Harvard’s commitment to growing its endowment, regardless of the

consequences its remaining holdings produced in maintaining an insidious governmental system of racial classification and discrimination which had undoubted effects on the black and brown lifecourse in South Africa.

Thus, every move Harvard makes with its endowment is political. Believing in and reacting responsibly to scientific truths, however, should not be construed as such.

Focusing on the question of politics ultimately obscures Harvard’s moral suasion in fostering a just society. While ensuring the longevity of the endowment for future Harvard students and scholars is important, it is not mutually exclusive from cultivating a just Harvard — and more importantly — a just world.

Climate change is inherently an intersectional issue that bleeds into all facets of society. Already its effects are pushing people out of their homelands, placing their lives in limbo. Already it is harming communities of color to a greater extent than their white counterparts. And already it is affecting poor and developing countries to a greater extent than wealthy and developed nations.

The trial on divestment that Harvard then faces is not about the political leanings of the University, but rather on the morality of holding investments that propagate human and environmental suffering.

It is not a revolutionary vision to strive to construct a world, an endowment, that does not hierarchize our education, our institution, above the very livelihoods of others.

Nor is it revolutionary to see that the challenge of climate change is inherently linked to the private prison industry’s profiteering off the caging of human beings and Puerto Rico’s looming debt resulting from colonial rule.

With the resource and privilege to weather the most extreme effects of climate change when they hit Cambridge, Harvard must now ask itself: Is growing the endowment worth being complicit in the destruction of our very world — our very future, as we know it — regardless of Harvard’s own ability to adapt to a new climate order?

With a nearly $40 billion dollar endowment, Harvard possesses immense weight in the conversation of divestment. To forget the extreme level of influence the endowment and Harvard

name holds is to engage in a dangerous pattern of selective memory.

Already, universities across the world have committed to divesting from fossil fuels. Should Harvard choose the moral high road, it will not assume the role of leader, but it’s moral stance on the issue will still bear weight.

The time to divest is not now. The time to divest was not when student activists first started their calls for the University to utilize its endowment in a responsible manner.

The time to divest was immediately when knowledge surfaced that the burning of fossil fuels largely contributes to climate change, that the prison industrial complex largely profits from holding black and brown bodies, that Puerto Rican debt is a direct result from modern-day colonial practices.

All Harvard can do now is evaluate its principles and decide to hold itself, as an institution, to the same standards it holds it students to in its motto and mission statement: truth and being the leaders of our global, interconnected societies.

Harvard’s Climate Action Plan has established the goal of becoming fossil fuel-free by 2050. This ambition is merely performative should Harvard not include its indirect carbon emissions in this goal.

On Friday, activists “flooded” Harvard to call on the University, once again, to divest its holdings from companies that profit off suffering as a part of Harvard “Heat Week”. Should Harvard choose to divest, it will be thanks to the work of the activists involved in the three divestment campaigns on campus who have poured their free labor into the project of creating a more just world — a project Harvard claims to be involved in, too.

But in order for the selfless labor of student activists to be fully realized, they will need cooperation from the administration. Should University President Lawrence S. Bacow continue to rely on the faulty notion of listening to reason not demands, then only two questions remain regarding divestment: Does Harvard have a conscience? And if so, will Bacow listen to it?

—Elijah T. Ezeji-Okoye ’20, a Crimson Editorial Comp Director, is a Sociology concentrator in Lowell House.

Laura Veira-Ramirez a wild tongue

I

felt like I was running on autopilot for the majority of my freshman year. I look back at pictures and try to remember what I spent all my time doing.

I slept very little. I didn’t leave room for doubt as I went from class to meeting to lab to event to rally.

I tried to balance my life in STEM while feeling an obligation to get involved in Act on a Dream, Fuerza Latina, and The Crimson. I didn’t have enough time to even consider that the place I was in was not working for me.

I see them getting overworked and remember myself in their same spots when I felt empty as I spread myself so thin I didn’t have enough time for myself.

I give advice to first-years now that I wish I had been able to give to myself two years ago. I see them getting overworked and remember myself in their same spots when I felt empty as I spread myself so thin I didn’t have enough time for myself.

Harvard promotes this culture as students get involved in multiple things and the pressure often falls on multiply-disadvantaged students as we feel responsible to take on all of the issues.

It took a huge reality hit as I realized I was not going to have the same financial security my sophomore year that I had my first year with the start-up grant of $2,000.

I panicked at the thought of having to get a job and knew something was going to have to give. I felt immense guilt as I prepared to drop one of my board positions only to be surprised at how easy it was.

The organization went on without me. The hit wasn’t as large for the organization as it would have been for me had I stayed.

It was with that first drop that I began learning how to manage my time. I learned how important it was to quit things that weren’t sustainable.

Being passionate about organizations I was involved in was not enough.

You can’t live your life in the service of others unless you learn to serve yourself first.

I felt guilty and selfish for shifting my focus to myself, but doing so has been one of the most important things I’ve learned in my time here.

This is what gave me enough freedom to switch my concentrations as I shifted my focus to what I wanted, not what I thought my family would want for me.

It’s taken a lot of steps and development of the relationship I have with myself to recognize that my rest is also resistance.

It’s taken relationships where I was putting in too much emotional labor and unpaid positions for me to recognize that my time is valuable.

It feels great to say no to requests that I would have only agreed to because I felt guilted into them.

It feels great to now be able to say I’m getting compensated for most of the work I’m doing — and that it’s work I’m passionate about.

We must recognize our worth, give ourselves time to rest and heal, and get back out there when we know we can give the world our best selves. With radical resistance comes radical self-love.

I get compensated for my job in the admissions office reaching out to first-generation students.

I get compensated for my research thanks to Mellon Mays Undergraduate Fellowship Program.

And I get compensated for writing these pieces thanks to The Crimson’s Financial Aid program.

I look back to the Audre Lorde quote and realize how simple it seems.

It seems so instinctual that you should always be putting yourself first.

I had assumed I was already doing that. It took too long for me to recognize I actually wasn’t.

Our oppressions and hardships have been transferred to the individual to the point where it becomes our responsibility to lift ourselves up from the anxiety, depression, and constant selfdoubt and pain created by a system built for its own selfish motives.

But we can’t fight that system if we keep tricking ourselves into believing we can do it all.

We shouldn’t have to put on a brave face at all times.

We must recognize our worth, give ourselves time to rest and heal, and get back out there when we know we can give the world our best selves.

With radical resistance comes radical selflove.

—Laura S. Veira-Ramirez ’20, a Crimson Editorial editor, is a joint concentrator in History and Literature and Studies of Women, Gender, and Sexuality in Leverett House. Her column appears on alternate Mondays.

Page 5

THE HARVARD CRIMSON | april 29, 2019

College Funds Community Service By shera s. avi-yonah and delano r. franklin Crimson Staff Writers

Harvard College unveiled a summer public service stipend for incoming freshmen in the Class of 2023 at an event Sunday morning.

Participants in the program — called “Service Starts with Summer” — will receive a $1,500 stipend to pursue 100 hours of community service in their hometowns, both in the United States and abroad.

College Dean for Administration and Finance Sheila C. Thimba, who currently serves as the interim dean for public service, said she expects to accept all applicants to the program.

In addition to their main projects, participants will join webinars and discuss their individual projects in online sessions facilitated by Kevin L. Ballen ’22 and Nicholas C. Hargis ’19.

Ballen wrote in an email that he joined the summer service project as a result of other work he has done with administrators on “civic engagement initiatives.”

He added that he thinks the project’s focus on service work in students’ own communities is important.

“One of the most meaningful components of this program is its hometown focus. On Campus, students (including myself ) are so excited about exploring new places in their summers, during breaks, and after graduation,” Ballen wrote.

“The emphasis on serving at home pushes us to think about how we can use our Harvard education/degree and all it comes with to strengthen our roots,” he added.

Thimba said in a Friday interview the program comes as part of a broader effort to expand public service opportunities at Harvard.

She said the idea for the program stemmed from University President Lawrence S. Bacow’s inaugural speech in October 2018.

“The program started as a response to President Bacow’s call at the inauguration that Harvard should be ready to provide summer internship opportunities in service for students — any student who wants one,” she said.

The program will ask participants to find “high impact” public service projects in their hometowns.

It will also provide participants with faculty and staff support over the course of their pursuits, according to Thimba. Each of the public service projects is expected to last five weeks.

The program started as a response to President Bacow’s call at the inauguration that Harvard should be ready to provide summer internship opportunities in service for students.

Sheila C. Thimba College Dean for Administration and Finance

Participants must complete the full 100 hours in order to receive College funding, which will be pulled from Dean of the College Rakesh Khurana’s dis-

cretionary fund.

Thimba said that students who complete fewer than 100 hours can still participate in the online component of the program and events the College plans to hold for participants once they arrive on campus in the fall. They will not, however, receive the stipend.

The announcement comes as the College searches for a new Dean of Public Service following Gene A. Corbin’s decision to step down from the post more than a year ago.

In the months since, administrators announced a review of public service initiatives aimed at undergraduates and began a search for an assistant dean for civic engagement and service, a newly minted role.

Thimba said the College would launch a website for the program and reach out to all accepted students with more information about the program this week.

She added that applications for the program are slated to open Friday and are due by May 31. shera.avi-yonah@thecrimson.com delano.franklin@thecrimson.com

vigil From Page 1

Chabad Hosts Vigil Post-Shooting “Poway, Pittsburgh, or Jerusalem, when Jews are targeted simply for being Jewish, those who hate us do not differentiate based on other labels. But at the same time, we must not give into panic or bitterness,” Zarchi said.

We’re here in sorrow and outrage and anger, and I want to say that I’m here in joy at what this community is and what we can be.

Rabbi Jonah C. Steinberg Executive Director of Harvard Hillel

Several speakers acknowledged Saturday’s proximity to recent acts of violence in Sri Lanka and New Zealand.

Garber said he thinks recent

council From Page 1

hate-driven massacres of Muslims and Christians in addition to anti-Semitic acts “have contributed to a feeling that this is a time of deep division.”

“There has never been a more important time to show what resilient and loving communities can do,” Garber said.

He added that Chabad represents the “best of what we are.”

Garber also read out loud a statement on behalf of University President Lawrence S. Bacow, who could not attend due to a conflict, extending his support to members of Chabad and those affected by the shooting.

Both Zarchi and Steinberg said the tragedy could turn into an opportunity to celebrate faith.

“We’re here in sorrow and outrage and anger, and I want to say that I’m here in joy at what this community is and what we can be,” Steinberg said. ruth.zheng@thecrimson.com

UC Votes to Cut Out President, The T closes. We don’t.

Vice President from Voting the constitution comprises the rules committee chair, the parliamentarian, and the secretary.

The current rules committee chair Michael Y. Cheng ’22, parliamentarian Rachel L. Reynolds ’22, and secretary Cade S. Palmer ’20 — who is also a former Crimson sports chair — co-sponsored this piece of legislation along with Martinez.

The proposal passed 23-6-4.

The other piece of legislation, which designated the president and vice president as full members with voting powers, failed to pass with a vote of 270-7. Because 7 people abstained, the proposal could not pass. Any amendment to the UC’s constitution requires two-thirds of the entire council — 31 students — to vote either in favor of or against the legislation.

Many representatives said they voted for the proposal because they think the president and vice president need the ability to propose legislation in order to carry out the platform that they ran on.

Dunster House Representative Victor C. Agbafe ’19 said

that the UC president and vice president have special meetings with administrators.

He added that he thinks insight gained from these meetings can then influence the legislation they propose.

Some of the representatives who abstained said they believe the president’s and vice president’s ability to vote represents an imbalance in power.

Because the president and vice president lose their seats in their houses, they do not count towards the three representatives that each House typically receives.

Some said this policy overrepresents the president’s and vice president’s houses on the Council.

Others countered the idea that enfranchising the president and vice president creates a power imbalance. They said the pair represent the student body at large because they were elected by the entire student body.

“The president and vice president are voted on by the entire student body,” Mather House

Representative Sanika S. Mahajan ’21 said.

“Their platform is held accountable to the entire student body.”

Some representatives also said they are concerned that a president could essentially receive two votes in the case of a tie because the president can both vote and break a tie.

Because the legislation failed, the committee to interpret the constitution made their first ruling.

They decided that the president and vice president are not members of the council, codifying that the pair will be ineligible to vote on and propose legislation at future meetings. The president will still be able to break ties.

The other piece of the Great Reform, which would have delegated all powers not explicitly given to the members of the Executive Board to the general members of the UC, failed 7-197.

Breaking news, 24/7.

The Crimson thecrimson.com

kevin.chen@thecrimson.com laura.espinoza@thecrimson.com

Transformative coverage.

The Crimson thecrimson.com

Sports

Weekly Recap

SCORES

BASEBALL vs. COLUMBIA W, 10-9 ___________________________________________________________

SOFTBALL

L, 7-5 ___________________________________________________________

woMen’s Water POLO Vs. BUCKNELL L, 11-9 ___________________________________________________________

WOMEN’S LACROSSE Vs. PENN L, 17-9 ___________________________________________________________

Men’s HEAVYWEIGHT CREW W ___________________________________________________________

men’s LACROSSE vs. YALE L, 22-11 ___________________________________________________________

FOOTBALl

Senior Larry Allen Jr. Signs with Dallas Cowboys

By Henry Zhu Crimson Staff Writer

Regarded as arguably the best offensive lineman in Dallas Cowboys history, NFL Hall of Famer Larry Allen proudly represented “America’s Team” for 12 seasons.

In his final three seasons with Dallas, the 11-time Pro Bowler was teammates with a blossoming young tight end named Jason Witten.

Now, Witten is officially teammates with Larry’s son.

On Sunday afternoon, the Dallas Cowboys announced the signing of Harvard senior and undrafted free agent Larry Allen Jr.,.

A 2018 first-team All-Ivy selection, Allen Jr., has been a stalwart offensive guard for the Crimson since 2015, starting in 30 out of 30 possible games in that span. “[I was] just kind of stunned and had a lot of emotions,” said Allen Jr., after the signing was finalized.

“Not just getting a shot to play, but I lived in Dallas for a long time so if there was one team to get a chance with it, it was them.”

Allen Jr.’s father was quick to congratulate his son on social media, stating succinctly, “Proud of Son” in a tweet soon after the news broke.

“I’m very happy for Larry but not at all surprised,” said fellow senior classmate and offensive lineman Matt Jones. “He has worked hard for this moment for years and it’s great to see it finally happen.”

Allen Jr., is one of about 15 unsigned free agents chosen by the Cowboys after the conclusion of the 2019 NFL Draft on Saturday.

The bioengineering concentrator will head down to Frisco from May 9-11 to attend Cowboys rookie minicamp before graduation, and commented on the familiarity both with The ­

Lone Star State but also with numerous current members of the Cowboys organization.

“There are still a fair amount of people there that played with [my father],” Allen Jr., said. “Jason Garrett was the quarterback there when my dad played there...the offensive line coach Marc Colombo, he played with my dad.”

Allen Jr. also commented that he will have the opportunity to reunite with some members of the organization who “as a teenager, was a coach” as well as the aforementioned Witten, who returns back to the field after spending a year in the broadcast booth for Monday Night Football.

The Danville, Calif., native is the most recent Crimson offensive lineman to be signed to a NFL professional contract since Max Rich ’17 and will reunite with center Adam Redmond ’16, who was claimed off waivers

by Dallas on Sept. 2 after stints with the Buffalo Bills and Indianapolis Colts.

Other Crimson linemen currently in the NFL include Cole Toner ’16, Anthony Fabiano ’16, and Nick Easton ’15, all of whom have played with Allen Jr., in his time in Cambridge.

“It has meant so much,” Allen Jr., said. “The people I have met, the coaches. It’s been rocky at times, but it’s been some of the best football I have ever played.

I had some of the best teammates I have ever had here.”

Coach Tim Murphy commented in particular on the accomplishments and off-thefield contributions of the senior class.

“I don’t know when I’ve been more proud of a football team in my 25 years as a head coach here,” said head coach Tim Murphy following the Crimson’s 45-27 victory at Harvard-Yale on Nov. 17. “Extraordinary senior leadership, and that is absolutely, positively what drove the team this year.”

DONNING THE STAR Larry Allen Jr., played 31 games in his four seasons with the Crimson, making all possible starts in his last three seasons. TIMOTHY. R. O’MEARA — Crimson photographer

Outside of Allen Jr., defensive linemen Richie Ryan and Stone Hart as well as offensive lineman Ben Shoults participated in Harvard Football’s Pro Day in March.

The three have not heard back from NFL teams as of Sunday night, according to Allen Jr. The Cowboys signee believed that “no doubt they will

have a shot” and praised the work ethic of his fellow classmates.

Allen Jr.’s teammates were quick to reciprocate the same praise.

“He can make it at the next level,” Jones said. “Obviously he has the pedigree, but he also has the work ethic and athleticism to make it.”

This past season, 10 former Harvard players were employed by a NFL side, highlighted by current Miami Dolphins quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick ’05, San Francisco 49ers fullback Kyle Juszczyk ’13, and Tampa Bay Buccaneers tight end Cameron Brate ’13-’14.

Allen Jr. will have a substantial road ahead to join that es-

teemed list if he seeks to make a living playing football.

But for now, he can take pride in knowing he is, so far, the only senior who will walk through Tercentenary Theatre next month with “Dallas Cowboy” and “NFL athlete” to his name. henry.zhu@thecrimson.com

SoftBall

Bulldogs Bark Up Wrong Tree in Series Loss to Harvard

By JAMES JOYCE Crimson Staff Writer

“It’s windy – try it again!”

Elizabeth Shively is not one to give up easily.

After twenty-one innings of behind-the-plate sitting and pulls-her-weight hitting, the catcher in crimson was still going strong in this weekend’s series against Yale – but a an ill-fated foul-tip was about to change all that.

With Harvard up by one at the top of the seventh, Bulldog infielder Annie Tarte backlaunched the softball off her bat and straight into Shively’s hel­

met, prompting a mid-game timeout and the performance of the oh-so-dreaded concussion test. But after one failed attempt at the evaluation, Shively was not deterred; instead, she turned bleacher-wise to the trainer, shouting, “It’s windy – try it again!”

Although Shively was escorted to the dugout after failing that second concussion test, and Harvard off the field after giving up its late-game lead to Yale, Shively’s mantra of strength and perseverance defined this weekend’s series win for the Crimson.

“I think we did a really good

job with winning the series this weekend,” said senior captain Katie Duncan. “Obviously the last game didn’t go how we wanted it to, but there’s a lot of good things that we did and things that we can work on to be better next weekend.”

The only thing more nerve-wracking than watching Harvard battle the Bulldogs this Sunday was witnessing an absent-minded toddler almost promenade into the bat of a Harvard slugger during batting practice, and even that may be an understatement (for those of you following along at home, don’t worry – the teeter-

ing tot was scooped up by a concerned fan before she could be launched out to right field).

After a Meagan Lantz homer at the bottom of the fourth and a lead-taking single by the same batter during the subsequent inning, it seemed as if the Crimson were about to secure the series sweep – but then the Bulldogs growled back.

After a four-run hit-streak at the top of the seventh, Yale all but flashed V-for-victory; a bottom-of-the-inning shutout handed the win to the Bulldogs.

However, Duncan credits her teammates with making several SportsCenter-worthy plays.

A STEP AHEAD After winning the weekend series over Yale, the Crimson will have another homestand against the Big Red next weekend. TIMOTHY R. O’MEARA —Crimson photographer

“I think Meagan [Lantz’s] homerun in the last game was great,” said Duncan. “I also thought the offense in general did a really good job, and hitters one through nine were just consistently were going at it. Elizabeth [Shively] behind the plate and in the batter’s box had an unbelievable weekend too.”

On the weekend, Lantz went 4-for-9, securing three RBIs and a perfect batting average during Harvard’s final game against Yale.

Her fourth-inning homerun brought the water-logged crowd to its feet, a high point in the Crimson’s series win at home.

“I just really wanted to help my team in any way I could and get on base, whether that be by a walk, error, or hit-by-pitch,” Lantz said. “I really just wanted to bring energy for the team and do what I could to help in any way.”

However, Lantz doesn’t crown herself series MVP; rather, she credits infielder Rhianna Rich with taking the title of this weekend’s star player.

“I would just say that Rhianna Rich made some really great plays at short this weekend,” Lantz said. “There was a play yesterday where the ball tipped off Teagan Shaw’s glove and Rhianna picked it up, stepped on third, and tried to throw it home for the play. She just makes plays like that all the time, and it’s great playing next to her because she does stuff like that regularly.”

This weekend was certainly full of clutch moments for the Crimson, the majority of which came in their first two matches against the Bulldogs.

A first-inning triple by freshman Trina Hoang careened the Crimson to scoreboard during

their first game against Yale, and a sixth-inning RBI by sophomore Morgan Melito secured a 7-6 victory for Harvard.

The Crimson kept that momentum going into the second game of the doubleheader, with Harvard runs scored in five of six innings, propelling the Crimson to a 7-1 win and the series victory.

“We did some really great things this weekend,” Lantz said. “Obviously people look at the standings and its tight, but I thought we were in a really good position to do some great things and we did. We came out here and took two on Saturday, and even did some great things in [Sunday’s] game by really just focusing on every pitch and every inning.”

Looking forward, the squad is ready to make the transition from Bulldog to Big Red as they take on Cornell in next weekend’s home series.

“I think our mentality is pretty much the same every weekend,” Duncan said. “It’s just getting prepared to play our best game. Next weekend happens to be at home against Cornell, so [we] just need to go back and work on the little things[…] so that we can hopefully walk away happier next weekend.”

For Harvard, next weekend’s series against the Big Red will be near-identical to this last one against Yale: they’ll be playing on the same field, at the same times, against a team from the same conference.

However, next weekend will bring with it one big change – this time, Harvard will be shooting for the series sweep.

After all, even without the wind, the Crimson are all about trying again. james.joyce@thecrimson.com