Egyptian Archaeology 55

THE LONG NILE CRUISE

‘THE GOLDEN AGE’ WITH DR KENT WEEKS

T TWINHREE AVAILCABINS ABLE

Exchange: Egypt and beyond Study Day, 16 November 2019

CAIRO TO ASWAN - THE JOURNEY SOUTH SS Misr exclusively chartered for AWT

DEPARTING 1st MAY 2020 This spectacular cruise is accompanied throughout by Kent Weeks, one of the most celebrated archaeologists in the world. Known for his work on the Theban Mapping Project and his re-discovery of KV5, the largest tomb ever found in the Kings’ Valley.

Our privately chartered 5-star deluxe vessel, the SS Misr was built in 1918 and was once owned by King Farouk. She boasts exquisite public rooms and the friendliest, most efficient staff on the river. Our Luxury cruiser has just 24 cabins, including 8 suites, offering the very highest standard of comfort, service, cuisine and hygiene.

Join us on this wonderful cruise leaving Cairo on 1st May, ending two weeks later in the lovely southern city of Aswan. We travel in true AWT style. There are no galabeya parties; there is no musak;

there are no quizzes; only AWT like-minded passengers enjoying the serene beauty of the River Nile.This fourteen night cruise is full board throughout and this wonderful itinerary sailing the length of the Nile will be remembered for years to come.

On our journey we will visit some of the most important sites of Ancient Egypt. We begin with the Pyramids at Giza and the mighty Sphinx and the more remote Meidum Pyramid, then continue in to Middle Egypt where we will explore the tombs of Beni Hassan, Tuna el Gebel and Ashmunein.

A full day at Amarna, the capital city of Pharaoh Akhenaten and Queen Nefertiti, including entry to the Royal Tomb.

At Abydos we can view some of the finest reliefs in Egypt within the Temple of Seti I, and at Dendera we see the beautiful astronomical ceilings recently restored to their original glory.

On to Ancient Thebes with in depth visits to the major sites in Luxor, including the Valley of the King’s, before sailing to the Ptolemaic Temple at Kom Ombo. In Aswan we make visits to the Temple of Isis at Philae, the huge Unfinished Obelisk and the Nubia Museum.

All the while sailing along the River Nile relaxing in style on our luxury cruiser. Time for birdwatching, reading, taking in a lecture or two and generally just having a wonderful time.

STANDARD TOUR PRICE: £5,450

(per person based on sharing a twin or double cabin) Cabin upgrades are available: Standard Suites & Upper Deck.

CALL NOW TO BOOK: 0333 335 9494 OR GO TO

www.ancient.co.uk

ancient world tours

The Distillery, Dunton, Norfolk NR21 7PG UK e-mail janet @ancient.co.uk

JULES VERNE AWT is an agent of Jules Verne. These Air Holiday packages are ATOL Protected by the Civil Aviation Authority. VJV’s ATOL No.11234

Egypt is often presented in isolation, as a stable and almost stagnant cultural and geographic region.

This study day considers Egypt in its wider context, as an interrelated and integral part of the Late Bronze Age Mediterranean world. Through investigating Egypt’s economy, foreign relations, and trade, our four experts will present Egypt in a different light and show that things are far more interesting when you consider the bigger picture:

•

Scarab and Seal Amulets: How one of the smallest artefacts highlights trade, exchange, and more in the second millennium BCE Stephanie Boonstra, Egypt Exploration Society

• •

The Amarna Letters: Gifts or economic exchange?

Mahmoud Ezzamel, Cardiff University

•

Egypt’s Long-distance Trade Relationships in Context at the End of the New Kingdom: Reflections on the world of the Gurob ship-cart model in light of recent Eastern Mediterranean multidisciplinary scholarship Carol Bell, British School at Athens and UCL

Goods from the Wine-Dark Sea: Eastern Mediterranean ceramic imports in Egypt during the Late Bronze Age Valentina Gasperini, British Museum

Event details Where: Brunei Lecture Theatre, SOAS, University of London, 10 Thornhaugh Street, London, WC1H 0XG. When: 16th Nov 2019, 9:30 a.m. – 7:00 p.m.

Book your ticket through our website:

www.ees.ac.uk/Event/exchange-egypt-and-beyond

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY No. 55 Autumn 2019 www.ees.ac.uk

Editor Jan Geisbusch Editorial Advisers Aidan Dodson John J Johnston Caitlin McCall Luigi Prada Advertising sales Phone: +44 (0)20 7242 1880 E-mail: jan.geisbusch@ees.ac.uk Distribution Phone: +44 (0)20 7242 1880 E-mail: contact@ees.ac.uk Website: www.ees.ac.uk Published twice a year by the Egypt Exploration Society 3 Doughty Mews London WC1N 2PG United Kingdom Registered Charity, No. 212384 A Limited Company registered in England, No. 25816 Design by Nim Design Ltd Set in InDesign CS6 by Jan Geisbusch Printed by Intercity Communications Ltd, 49 Mowlem Street, London E2 9HE © The Egypt Exploration Society and the contributors. No part of this publication may be reproduced without prior permission of the publishers.

The opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the aims or concerns of the Egypt Exploration Society.

ISSN 0962 2837

Editorial Nile Delta, central Egypt or Sudan, New Kingdom or Late Period, field archaeology or archival research – the discipline of Egyptology again presents itself as astoundingly rich and varied.

Our autumn issue again shows the breadth of work done or supported by the EES, geographically – from the Delta to the Third Nile Cataract in Sudan – but equally in terms of subject matter, ranging from fieldwork to archival, conservation and training activities. It also demonstrates the support of our members and friends: More than £25,000 in donations were given to the Society in response to a call for support of our project to rehouse the EES’ collection of glass-plate negatives.

Five thousand of these fragile and irreplaceable photographic artefacts from the earliest days of the Society’s fieldwork in Egypt have now been preserved for future generations. A big and heartful ‘thank you’ for your generosity!

We are just as delighted to report on other teams’ and researchers’ work done in recent months: Carina van den Hoven for the Leiden Mission offers a fascinating account on tomb reuse in New Kingdom Thebes; Christian Leitz and Hisham el-Leithy bring the pronaos of the temple of Esna back to splendidly colourful life; Bérangère Redon delves into the history of wine-making at the Late Period / Ptolemaic town of Plinthine; Dietrich Raue and his colleagues summarise the archaeological and iconographic research done on the colossal statue of Psamtik I discovered two years ago in Heliopolis; and Paola Davoli presents an intriguing and rare artefact from the oasis site of Dimeh es-Seba – an architectural model of the Soknopaios temple, found in the very temple it represents.

Jan Geisbusch

Above: Luca Perfetti and Alessandro Mandelli (3D Survey Group) of the joint LeidenTurin Expedition to Saqqara working at the site. See Digging Diary p. 25. (Photo: Nicola Dell’Aquila) Cover: Column 7 of the pronaos of the Esna Temple, with its capital recently cleaned. See pp. 20-23. (Photo: Ahmed Amin) EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

1

Conservator Bianca Madden working on a conservation survey of the painted decoration in Theban Tomb 45. See article pp. 14-19.

2

Contents 4 New investigations on the Third Cataract in Sudan Cédric Gobeil and Stephanie Boonstra

9 The sixth Delta Survey Workshop Penelope Wilson

10 The Delta Survey: recent work in Kafr el-Sheikh and Beheira Israel Hinojosa-Baliño, Elena Tiribilli and Penelope Wilson

14 Space and memory: tomb reuse in New Kingdom Thebes Carina van den Hoven

20 The ancient colours of Esna return Hisham el-Leithy, Christian Leitz and Daniel von Recklinghausen

24 Digging Diary 2019 28 An Egyptian grand cru: wine production at Plinthine Bérangère Redon

34 Psamtik I in Heliopolis Aiman Ashmawy, Simon Connor and Dietrich Raue

40 The contra-temple of Soknopaios and its architectural model Paola Davoli

44 Rehousing the EES glass-plate negatives Stephanie Boonstra and Alix Robinson

Photo: TT 45 Project / Carina van den Hoven

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

3

New investigations on the Third Cataract in Sudan In 2018, the Egypt Exploration Society was granted a concession by the Sudanese National Corporation of Antiquities and Museums (NCAM) for an area of roughly 4 km2 along the eastern bank of the Nile’s Third Cataract. Cédric Gobeil explains the results of the topographical survey and preliminary excavation of the stone settlement within the concession, Stephanie Boonstra discusses the wider survey of the concession and the future potential for the Third Cataract region.

Map: GoogleEarth

Above: map delineating the EES concession to the east of the Nile third cataract in Lower Nubia.

4

The Third Cataract Project The Third Cataract Project concession is located in Lower Nubia, roughly 20 km north of Tombos. It is bordered on the west by the Nile along the rapids of Foogo (image above) and is situated south of Arduan Island.

The area is also intersected by a palaeochannel of the Nile on its eastern side.

Previous surveys (such as that conducted by Ali Osman and David Edwards) identified several archaeological features throughout the region, including desert walls [HBB024026], a stone settlement [HBB017], hieratic

graffiti [HBB011], and cemeteries [HBB001, SDK018].

In February 2019, the EES team conducted a surface survey of the region with a more thorough topographical survey of the stone settlement HBB017, as well as an exploratory excavation of a discrete area, discussed here.

Life on the edge – the position and role of HBB017 Previous surveys of the Third Cataract region have identified a cluster of archaeological sites between the modern villages of Habaraab and

Uraaw, but their dating and function within the wider geographical context of the region remains largely unknown. No signif icant Egyptian settlements of the New Kingdom are known between Nauri and Tombos, 50 km further downstream, with the exception of the stone settlement identified as HBB017 by Ali Osman and David Edwards (2011) during their survey of the area. Their investigations revealed ‘a type of site that cannot easily be paralleled elsewhere amongst New Kingdom settlements in Middle Nubia’ (2011: 87). Its posi tion on the wes ter n side of the palaeochannel may be evidence of a role in trade routes around the rapids of the Third Cataract. This transitional zone, between Lower Nubia and the Kerma basin to the south, is already known to have held some strategic position for New Kingdom rulers as evidenced by inscriptions dated to the Thutmoside Period

focused attention primarily on HBB017 (image below centre). The objectives in this season were to create a topographic plan of the site, conduct a surface survey of material finds to indicate a broad occupation period, and to initiate a test excavation of one of the areas of the site.

HBB017 measures roughly 160 x 150 m (24,000 m2) within which are several clusters of archaeological features built on and around the uneven natural rock. No defensive surrounding wall is apparent, though a level ter r ace on the eas t side abut ting the palaeochannel is clearly visible.

Individual occupational structures within the settlement are constructed from roughly cut dry stones of schist, quarried or gathered from the local area. Despite many collapses, it was possible to recognise subcircular walls separating several groups likely to be household

at Tombos (as well as the later stela of Sety I at Nauri). A holistic investigation of the wider landscape may provide significant information regarding events in this region during the early Eighteenth Dynasty conquest of Upper Nubia.

To better understand this situation as well as the perceived cultural exchange between occupying populations, the Egypt Exploration Society created the Third Cataract Project in February 2019.

Following an initial survey of the concession area with careful checks against the published survey of Osman and Edwards, the work

units surrounded by small enclosure walls or courtyards (map above). From the plan created this season, twelve units, some containing several rooms, were identified. The centre of the settlement is more densely constructed than the outlying structures, which suggests that the settlement grew outward over time, also occupying higher land.

Following the initial topographic survey, a surface survey was conducted in and around the settlement. Diagnostic surface finds, mostly ceramic sherds and evidence of stone tool manufacture, were mapped, collected, and

Below centre: the stone structures of the settlement HBB017.

Below: map of stone settlement HBB017 indicating the minimum number of complete ceramic vessels in each area, as well as the proportion of which were Classic Kerma/ New Kingdom in date based upon the surface survey.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

5

Right centre: plan and photograph of Room A of Area 3, which contained firepits and was likely a courtyard.

Below: plan of Area 3 of HBB017 showing Rooms A-E and where they were sectioned in the test excavations.

6

recorded. As expected, the survey revealed concentrations of ar tefac ts within the occupational structures and in areas of waterflow out of the settlement.

Surface pottery revealed possible cultural exchange owing to a dominance of Classic Kerma Nubian pottery and New Kingdom Egyptian pottery. This gives further credence to the suggestion that this area played a role during the early New Kingdom reconquest of Nubia and perhaps hints at an earlier foundation for the site during the Kerma Period. Pottery dating to Roman and Christian periods of occupation were found in smaller quantities, particularly in the structures furthest from the centre of the settlement (Areas 1, 2, 4, 5 and 13), and may be evidence of later settlement phases. Findings from these initial surface observations already provide a complex picture of occupation in this borderland between Lower and Upper Nubia, particularly during the Kerma Period and early New Kingdom.

Area 3 – life on the Third Cataract In order to affirm the archaeological potential of HBB017 and its level of preservation, it was decided to excavate a small area. Area 3, a single occupational unit was selected due to its smaller size (roughly 200 m2) and clearly defined layout (plan bottom left). The interior space is divided into five delineated rooms named A to E. Initial results obtained indicate that Area 3 was a domestic household and each room had a specific function. In order to

assess the stratigraphic levels preserved in Area 3, and by extension perhaps also the rest of the site, one half of each room was excavated. In room E the stratigraphy descended as far as 1 m, a depth that may be echoed elsewhere in HBB017.

Though unidentified at present, the entrance to Area 3 was probably into room A which, from the layout, appears to have been a courtyard fronting the household (plan centre page). Its width indicates that it was most likely not covered by a roof. Suppor ting this conclusion, a series of three firepits containing black ashes (contex ts 18 and 31) were discovered along the south wall of the room,

which could only have worked properly in an open-air set ting to allow smoke to be evacuated. Near these firepits is an L-shaped stand (context 26) constructed from smaller loose stones that seems to have been used to hold ceramic jars. This is demonstrated by two shallow holes built into the stand each with a diameter of 30 cm. However, the exact use of these features is unclear.

Room B is the smallest of the five rooms identified and is located at the end of a narrow corridor linking it to Room A. Contexts 19 and 20 here contained deposits of loose sand mixed with dark grey and white ashes (plan top of facing page). The peculiarity of this level is that it contained a high quantity of animal bones, especially fish bones. This appears to indicate that the function of this space included the storage, processing, or discarding of food and gives evidence toward the diet and food supplies of the community living here.

NEW INVESTIGATIONS ON THE THIRD CATARACT IN SUDAN

one stone tool left in the middle. In connection with both contexts 11 and 12, context 29 was defined by a set of three stone tools (round pounders/grinders) left close together (image p. 8, centre). This evidence may suggest work related to food production.

Room E may have been built as a later extension to the household, as it is located outside of the main perimeter of the unit and abuts its west side (plan p. 8, bottom). Its rectangular shape is markedly different from the other rooms of the household, which are more circular. Beneath a layer of collapsed building stones (context 3), an event that presumably occurred sometime after the

Many structures within the settlement had rounded walls. Room C in Area 3 is unusual in its circular shape and seems to have been constructed abutting, and therefore probably after, Room D (plan above right). The section partially excavated this year revealed only a few layers of loose sand mixed with some dark grey ashes. The low number of finds in this room may indicate that it was cleared by the occupants during abandonment or had been emptied during a later reoccupation of the site.

Room D seems to have been constructed at the same time as the whole household unit, as the main enclosure wall of Area 3 deviates to coincide with the eastern wall of the room (image p. 8, top). This room contained many contexts relating to a probable production space. For example, context 11 comprised a small firepit associated with a stone tool and possibly a quern stone, while context 12 had flat stone slabs arranged in a semicircle with

abandonment of the room, was a level of collapsed mud bricks (context 9). It is possible that these mud bricks are the remains of either part of the roof of this room or part of a structure standing either in the room or on top of the lower courses of building stone.

At this time, it is not clear which of these potential scenarios is correct. Context 9 covered a thick horizontal layer of soft sand mixed with ashes that contained a significant quantity of animal bones and small bivalve shells (context 22). It is probable that this room was used as a storeroom or even as an animal pen, par ticularly as it has no adjoining doorway into the main structure of the household unit.

The promising results of this survey and test excavation demonstrate the potential of this site for future investigations on the purpose and use of this unique settlement and its surrounding region.

Left: plan of Room B of Area 3, which contained a high concentration of animal and fish bones, particularly in contexts 19 and 20.

Above: Room C of Area 3 was somewhat unusual in both its circular shape as well as the lack of finds or features within.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

7

Above: plan and photograph of Room D in Area 3, which was likely a production area as it contained many flat stone slabs as well as stone pounders and grinders.

Right: close-up of context 29 in Room D with pounder / grinder stones.

Future potential for the Third Cataract region After an exciting season, the EES team was able to gain a greater understanding of the potential of the Third Cataract region for research.

As well as the findings at HBB017 outlined above, the team were able to identify several features worthy of further investigation in the region. Many were known from previous surveys, notably that by Osman and Edwards (2011), but several others including cemeteries containing hundreds of graves (HBB031-032), rock ar t, and possible production areas (HBB029) can now be added. By working together with the local community of Uraaw, the team were able to gain a bet ter understanding of the geography of the concession and to find these further areas of interest.

A further survey utilising hand-held GPS to conduct a systematic examination of the region will allow the proper recording of each feature now known. The sur vey will allow the identification of areas that can be outlined for discrete research projects allowing multiple experts (ceramicists, palaeographers, geoarchaeologists, osteologists, etc.) to contribute towards greater under standing of this transitional zone of intercultural communication between Lower and Upper Nubia.

Plan of Room E, a likely later extension to Area 3, which contained a level of collapsed mud brick.

Further Reading: A. Osman and D. Edwards, The Archaeology of a Nubian Frontier. Survey on the Nile Third Cataract, Sudan (Khartoum, 2011).

• Cédric Gobeil was Director of the EES at the time of the Third Cataract Project. He is now a curator at the Museo Egizio in Turin and adjunct professor at the Université du Québec à Montréal.

Stephanie Boonstra is the Collections Manager of the Egypt Exploration Society and the Managing Editor of the Journal of Egyptian Archaeology. She was a team member of the Third Cataract Project in 2019 and has previously worked on EES concessions in the Nile Delta of Egypt.

8

The sixth Delta Survey Workshop The Delta Survey, initiated by the EES in the 1990s, aims to document the hundreds of archaeological sites in the Nile Delta and to encourage further research on them. Since 2009, the Delta Survey Workshop has offered a bi-annual opportunity to catch up on the latest work done in the region.

Penelope Wilson reports on its sixth instalment.

Top right: Dr Mohamed Kenawy giving his paper on mosaics in Jordan with Delta place names.

The sixth Delta Survey Workshop (DSW) took place in Mansoura from 11 to 13 April 2019, sponsored by the University of Mansoura along with the British Academy / Egypt Exploration Society and in cooperation with the Ministry of Antiquities (MoA). Over three days, 22 papers and five posters provided updates on established and new archaeological work in the Nile Delta.

Key papers were given by Prof So Hasegawa on Kom el-Debaa, Dr Cristina Mondin on Kom el-Ahmar, Dr Ayman Ashmawy on Kufur Nigm and Dr Sayed Abd el-Halim on Tell Hebua.

Further reports came from Dr Slawomir Rzepka and Lukasz Jarmusz on Tell Retaba, Dr Anna Wodszinka on the Wadi Tumilat and Prof Jay Silverstien and Stacey Baghdi on Tell Timai.

In addition, there were reports on new work at Tell Tibilla by Mansoura University, at Sais, Buto and Quesna by the Ministry of Antiquities, and Delta Survey projects in Kafr el-Dawar.

Other papers explained the importance of tannur-ovens, discussed retrogressive analysis of photographic archives for gaining a understanding of the site of Naukratis, and addressed the gathering of information on private collections in Alexandria. Tea / coffee breaks and the evening meals gave opportunity for attendees to meet colleagues, make new contacts and catch up on the progress of projects in the north of Egypt.

Mansoura was an ideal and welcoming host for the workshop, with the lectures attended by many of the local students as well as archaeologists from all over the Delta. On the final day of the workshop, a number of delegates and MoA colleagues made a trip to Tanis (Sa el-Hagar) to visit the site and the newly opened royal tombs. We are grateful to the authorities at the University of Mansoura and in particular Prof Maha el-Seguini and Dr Ayman Wahby for

Centre right: attendees Map data ©2019 Mapa GISrael, ORIONand speakers of the sixth Delta Survey Workshop.

Bottom right: (l.t.r.)

Prof Maha el-Seguini, Prof Reda Sayed Ahmed (both University of Mansoura), Essam Nagy (EES), Dr Nadia Khedr, Dr Ayman Asmawy, Dr Hisham el-Leithy (all Ministry of Antiquities).

50 km their help in organising the workshop. As always, Essam Nagy in the EES Cairo office was very proactive in making the event a success, and we are grateful for the support of Prof Khaled elEnany, Dr Hisham el-Leithy and Dr Nadia Khedr of the Ministry of Antiquities. We are now working on the publication of papers from DSW 5 in Alexandria and DSW 6 in Mansoura.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

9

The Delta Survey: recent work in Kafr el-Sheikh and Beheira

Photos and maps: Israel Hinojosa-Baliño, Elena Tiribilli and Penelope Wilson

In spring and autumn 2018, the EES Delta Survey, in collaboration with Durham University, investigated 14 little-known selected sites of the central and western Delta belonging to Kafr el-Sheikh and Beheira governorates. Israel Hinojosa-Baliño, Elena Tiribilli and Penelope Wilson describe the main results of the most recent EES fieldwork which aimed to reconstruct the history and the ancient environment of remote sites around Lakes Mareotis and Burullus.

Delta waterways and landscapes The Delta landscape has changed considerably since ancient times. As shown in the reconstructed map there were significant bodies of water such as the Lakes Mareotis and Edku in the western Delta as well as swampy border areas of Lake Burullus in the north. The lakes were fed by waterways and tributaries, which offered excellent lines of communication through the field basins, swamps and complex networks of water systems. Settlements were sustained by agricultural land and proximity to the waterway system, and it is these networks from the Ptolemaic to Late Antique Periods (300 BC to AD 700) that the project aims to investigate by collecting information from the chosen sites (see maps p. 13).

In 2018, two survey missions led by Penelope Wilson and Elena Tiribilli were carried out in ten selected sites of Kafr el-Sheikh governorate and four sites in Kafr el-Dawar province of Beheir a governor ate. The infor mation concerning the dating and archaeological material found at the sites was added to the Delta Survey project database, a special project funded by the British Academy and administered by the EES. As little information was known about the sites selected for survey, the objectives of the missions were to collect topographic and photographic information, to record surface pottery and material and, where possible, to carry out geophysical investigation of sub-surface

10

features using a fluxgate gradiometer (Bartington Grad601). The overall objectives of the work are to monitor the current preservation of the sites as well as to interpret the ancient landscape and environment of the Delta regions and make the information about the sites available through the online database of the Egypt Exploration Society’s Delta Survey for research and future archaeological excavations (www.ees.ac.uk/ delta-survey).

Lake Mareotis area Sites in Beheira province relate both to the ancient Lake Mareotis as well as the Alexandrian hinterland, supplying the Ptolemaic-Roman capital city with food and access to the wider resource base of the Delta and Nile Valley. Kom el-Ghasuli was part of a much larger group of settlements or one large settlement in antiquity.

The remaining site presents an irregular shape, characterised today by two sandy mounds of which the highest is 2.14 m above the field level.

The northern area of the kom has been levelled to two flat areas (image above). There is no archaeological material visible on the surface, but sections at the side of the kom show clear stratified sequences of layers, including brick and pottery deposits. The surface pottery indicates an occupation range from the 2nd century BC to the 7th century AD, and there was a high presence of imported amphorae and table wares from Cyprus, the Levant, and

View of the northern, levelled area of Kom el-Ghasuli.

Asia Minor. Similarly, Kom Abdu Pasha has been levelled for the reclamation of agricultural land over time and nowadays only a small part of the tell is preserved, surrounded by irrigation ditches and fields and partially overbuilt by the modern village of Ezbet Abdu Pasha (image right). The surface pottery shows a high percentage of material of local production, such as Egyptian amphorae and vessel stands, dated mainly to the Early and Late Ptolemaic Period. It, too, was probably part of the supply chain between the lake and the Canopic Nile branch.

Kom el-Magayir I, II and III were originally part of one settlement but are nowadays separated by a modern road and the Shereishra canal, partially overbuilt by the modern villages of Baba el-Koupra and elHilbawi and by a modern cemetery. The sites may have lain along a waterway extending into the ancient lake, as their linear arrangement suggests. The surface pottery collected mainly consists of Egyptian table wares, local and imported amphorae coming from the eastern Mediterranean. It suggests a long period of human activity, from the 3rd century BC until the 7th century AD. Tell el-Mahar is surrounded by fields and irrigation ditches, and its eastern part has a modern cemetery that is gradually extending towards the west side, on the top of the mound. The name of the site means ‘mound of shells’, derived from the fact that the surface of the site is covered in many shells. They may have come from the nearby Lake Mareotis in antiquity, when mud from the lake was used to make bricks. As the bricks decayed they released the shells that now lie on the surface. Pottery from previous surveys indicates that the site was a Ptolemaic foundation, and that it was abandoned around the time of the Arab invasion in the 7th century AD. A geophysical survey has been proven to be particularly effective in reconstructing the settlement layout of this site. Indeed, the magnetic map showed that there were clear structures with rectangular plans and of different sizes on the eastern side of the flat area and on the top of the mound (image right, bottom).

Image: GoogleEarth

Image: GoogleEarth

Above centre: Kom Abdu Pasha.

Topographic map of Abdu Pasha overlaid on satellite imagery.

Above: Tell el-Mahar.

Magnetic map of Kom el-Mahar showing rectilinear features and area without features, overlaid on satellite imagery.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

11

12

Image: GoogleEarth

Above: satellite image of Kom Garad showing gridded settlement pattern.

Photo: Israel Hinojosa-Baliño, Elena Tiribilli and Penelope Wilson

Lake Burullus area In Kafr el-Sheikh province, the area is dominated by Lake Burullus to the north, the silted-up Sebennytic branch of the Nile to the east, and many lost waterways to the west as far as the Rosetta Nile branch. Many settlements attest to the vitality of the area in the Roman and Late Roman periods in particular (1st-7th century AD).

Kom Garad lies on the western side of a bend in an ancient river channel that linked Kom el-Khawalid to the south with the double site of Kom Nashawein on the edge of Lake Burullus. Satellite imagery indicated that Kom Garad had a gridded settlement plan on the northeastern side of the existing mound (image right). Pottery on the surface was mostly of Late Roman date (4th-7th century AD), and other archaeological material including metal fragments and glass also confirmed this date. Due to the presence of a great amount of fired brick and pottery the magnetic survey was not so useful in identifying the settlement area, but did confirm that to the south-east there was most likely a water channel contemporary with the settlement.

Two sites were surveyed along the edge of Lake Burullus: Kom Dishimi and Kom Eid el-Ghash, now mostly surrounded by fish farms and only accessible by boat or narrow dykes. Both sites have a flat surface and pottery dating mostly to the Late Roman period, although Kom Eid el-Ghash is relatively high at 6 m above the level of the surrounding water and with steep sides. The geophysical survey was hindered by the great amount of brick and pottery lying on the site, but in the case of Kom Dishimi the magnetic map shows the presence of a south-north waterway through the site with structures oriented along/facing it. To the north, Mastarouah on the coast was also bisected by a channel which eventually reached the sea, indicating that perhaps it had been a port on the sea-shore. The Late Roman part of the site was located to the east, while a medieval set of structures lay to the west, dated according to the fine glazed wares and imitation Chinese celadon pottery fragments (image right, bottom). According to historical sources the port of Nastaraouh was sacked by Crusaders and abandoned in 1415. Tell Daba-Shaba, Kom Quleia and Kom Sheikh Ibrahim may all have been important settlements along a waterway to the south, feeding goods and produce through the lake to the north coast. The pottery from the sites shows that the area was flourishing in the Late Roman-Coptic period. Kom el-Qassabi perhaps lies on another set of waterways but the site was covered by a modern cemetery and further drill augering may help to throw light on the nature of this ancient mound in the future.

Tell Daba-Tida is a large ancient site with a strategic central position in the north Delta. The north part of the site has been dug away and there were a few limestone blocks in this area, perhaps suggesting that a large structure such as a temple building may once have stood here.

There were substantial settlement areas to the west and east of a central low-lying pathway running north-south from the ‘temple’ area.

To the north-west the cleared football field yielded excellent magnetic results showing structures with a gridded pattern in this area. The earliest pottery at the site is from the Ptolemaic period, but further work could be fruitful here.

The brief descriptions of the sites shows that each individual site has its own characteristics but can be woven into the narrative of the vibrant settlement and waterway history of the Ptolemaic to Islamic periods in the Egyptian Delta.

Above: medieval glazed ceramics from Kom Mastarouah.

Right: maps of the area showing the location of the sites.

• Penelope Wilson is Associate Professor in Egyptian Archaeology at Durham University, Director of the EES Delta Survey Project. Elena Tiribilli is a postdoctoral Marie Curie Fellow in Egyptology at Durham University and field director of the EES/Durham University survey to Kafr el-Dawar province. Israel Hinojosa-Baliño is a doctoral candidate at Durham University and mapmaker, sponsored by Conacyt. The seasons were funded by the British Academy through the Egypt Exploration Society and through Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (project no. 744977). The authors would like to thank Dr Khaled al-Enany (Minister of Antiquities), Dr Mustafa Waziri (Secretary General of the SCA) and Dr Nashwa Gaber (Director of Foreign Missions). Thanks are due to Directors Khaled Farhat in Damanhur and Gamal Selim in Kafr el-Sheikh for their assistance and help, as well as Essam Nagy in Cairo. We are also grateful to our teams: Rabea Reimann, Mahmoud Ali Arab, Reda Said Ibrahim Ali, Yahya el-Shahat Mahmoud, Walid Abd el-Bary Attia Zalat.

THE DELTA SURVEY: RECENT WORK IN KAFR EL-SHEIKH AND BEHEIRA

Name

EES numbers

Dimensions

Date

Kafr el-Sheikh 1. Shaba (Tell el-Daba)

332

420 x 300 m, 12 ha

Late Roman

2. Tida (Tell el-Daba)

277

500 x 350 x 4 m, 30 ha

Ptolemaic - Late Roman

3. Kom Dishimi

240

570 x 370 m, 21 ha

Late Roman

4. Kom el-Garad

264

200 x 170 m, 3.4 ha

Roman - Late Roman

5. Mastarouah

501

1000 x 800 m, 80 ha

Late Roman, Medieval

6. Kom el-Nisf

123

280 x 250 m, 7 ha

Late Roman, Islamic

7. Kom el-Qassabi

248

300 x 175 m, 5.25 ha

Late Roman

8. Kom Qeid el-Ghash

256

400 x 300 m, 12 ha

Roman - Late Roman

9. Kom Quleia

245

450 x 220 m, 9.9 ha

Late Roman

10. Kom Sheikh Ibrahim

244

660 x 521 x 10.4 m, 34 ha

Roman, Late Roman, to 10th c.

1. Abdu Pasha

621

52 x 38 m, 0.22 ha

Ptolemaic - Late Ptolemaic

2. Kom el-Ghasuli

362

Ptolemaic - Late Roman

3-5. Kom el-Magayir, I-III

395, 697, 698

6. Tell el-Mahar

398

125 x 180 x 2 m, 1.25 ha I: 280 x 300 m, 8.4 ha II: 40 x 24 m, 0.12 ha III: 127 x 85 m, 0.97 ha 440 x 240 x 12 m, 10.5 ha

Kafr el-Dawar

Ptolemaic, Roman, Late Roman

Maps: Israel Hinojosa-Baliño, Elena Tiribilli and Penelope Wilson

Ptolemaic, Roman, Late Roman

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

13

Space and memory: tomb reuse in New Kingdom Thebes In November 2017, Carina van den Hoven launched a new fieldwork project in Theban Tomb 45, a beautifully decorated tomb dating back to the Eighteenth Dynasty around 1400 BC. It serves as a case study for the practice of tomb reuse, interpreted through the theoretical concepts of ‘space’ and ‘memory’.

Right: Theban Tomb 45, originally built and occupied by Djehuty, an Eighteenth-Dynasty official.

Opposite page: the area of Sheikh Abd el-Qurna – view on TT 45 and the Ramesseum.

Photo: TT 45 Project / Matjaž Kačičnik

TT 45 and its surroundings Theban Tomb 45 is situated in the Theban necropolis, on the west bank of the Nile, opposite modern Luxor. The Theban necropolis is a UNESCO World Heritage Site and constitutes one of the largest ancient burial sites in the Near East. It comprises numerous monuments, including the famous royal tombs of the Valley of the Kings and the Valley of the Queens, but also more than 400 private elite tombs, as well as memorial temples and remains of royal palaces and domestic

14

communities. Theban Tomb (TT) 45 is situated in the area of Sheikh Abd el-Qurna, which has a large concentration of private elite tombs, most of which date to the Eighteenth Dynasty (c. 1539–1292 BC). TT 45 is situated close to the Ramesseum and the well-known tombs of Ramose (TT 55), Userhat (TT 56) and Khaemhat (TT 57) which are open to the public (image opposite page).

The plan of TT 45 shows a classical inverted T-shape. It has been quarried along a southnorth axis, with the arms of the T being roughly

SPACE AND MEMORY: TOMB REUSE IN NEW KINGDOM THEBES

in line with the east-west course of the sun.

Only the transverse hall has been decorated.

The longitudinal hall was quarried, but remained undecor ated. The easter n side of the longitudinal hall features two openings that were closed off in modern times and may lead to other tombs. At the end of the longitudinal hall a further room has been cut to the left, leading to a sloping passage (image next page, top). After Robert Mond discovered the tomb in 1903–04, the tomb was not further explored archaeologically. The original layout of the courtyard is unknown as it is partially covered by modern retaining walls. In his excavation report, Mond mentions a shaft in the forecourt, the location of which is unknown at present.

The shaf t in the transverse hall is not documented in any of the old ground plans of

scenes and texts during the reign of Amenhotep II (c. 1425–1400 BC) for a man named Djehuty and his family. He was overseer of the household of Mery, the high priest of Amun (and owner of TT 95), as well as of the weaving workshop attached to the temple of Karnak.

Djehuty is depicted in the tomb with an unnamed woman, probably his wife, as well as with his mother, also named Djehuty (image next page, bottom). Several hundred years later, during the Ramesside period (c. 1292– 1069 BC), the tomb was reused by a man called Djehutyemheb. Like his predecessor, he was overseer of the weaving workshop at Karnak. His family members are also depicted in the tomb: his father Wennefer, overseer of the weavers of the temple of Amun, his mother Isis, songstress of Amun, his wife Bakkhonsu,

Photo: TT 45 Project / Carina van den Hoven

the tomb and seems to have been unexplored so far. One of the aims of the TT 45 Project is to carry out for the first time a full archaeological study of the tomb to enhance our understanding of its usage history, from its original construction in the Eighteenth Dynasty until today, and its position within the larger mortuary landscape of the Theban necropolis.

The two owners of TT 45 TT 45 is a fascinating case study of tomb reuse. It was built and decorated with painted

also a songstress of Amun, and their children and grandchildren (image p. 17).

Even though the practice of tomb reuse may call to mind images of usurpation, tomb robbery and destruction, TT 45 was reused in a non-destructive manner and with consideration for the memory of the original owner. Instead of vandalising and whitewashing its walls in order to replace the original decoration with his own, Djehutyemheb left most of the existing decoration in its original state. He added his own only to wall sections EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

15

decoration, but here we clearly see a number of changes made at a later date: the Ramesside tomb owner added a text in red cursive hieroglyphs, transforming the original Eighteenth Dynasty painting into a scene presenting himself as the son who offers a bouquet to his parents, Wennefer and Isis. Furthermore, the furniture, garments and the lady’s wig were retouched in order to update them to Ramesside style.

The garments of all three figures have been widened and lengthened, struts and bars were added to the furniture.

Photo: TT 45 Project / Matjaž Kačičnik

Above: undecorated areas of Theban Tomb 45 leading to the sloping passage.

that had been left undecorated by Djehuty, and he retouched a number of the original paintings. For example, the garments, wigs and furniture depicted were altered to conform to contemporary style and taste. The image on p. 18 shows an example of the numerous repaintings that were carried out in TT 45 in the Ramesside period. The upper scene depicts the first tomb owner with his mother. He is dressed in a white garment with fringed edges and a plain kilt. His mother wears a simple tight dress. These paintings were left untouched in the Ramesside period. The lower scene also belongs to Djehuty’s original programme of

The first tomb owner Djehuty and his mother receiving offerings.

Photo: TT 45 Project / Matjaž Kačičnik

16

The Leiden Mission: document and preserve The first three fieldwork seasons of the Leiden University Mission to the Theban necropolis took place under the direction of the author in March and November 2018 and February-March 2019. The international team is undertaking a wide range of activities, from conservation and documentation to publication, archaeological study, art historical analysis, heritage preservation and site management.

The project also provides opportunities for the fur ther training of Egyptian staff in conser vation, site documentation and archaeological research. Site management activities are carried out in close cooperation with the Egyptian Ministry of Antiquities with a view to make the tomb publicly accessible.

A full conservation programme aims to preserve the painted decorations for future

SPACE AND MEMORY: TOMB REUSE IN NEW KINGDOM THEBES

generations. The team is also undertaking research in preventive conservation, especially in regard to protection from flash flooding.

The entire decorative programme of TT 45 is recorded as precisely as possible, using the most recent tools and developments in the field of digital humanities, such as photogrammetry, 3D-technology, as well as digital epigraphy, reconstruction and imaging technology (image p. 19). In this way, we aim to contribute to the development and application of non-invasive digital technologies to Egyptological site documentation and publication. The ar t historical and material analysis of the wall paintings is carried out with the help of ultraviolet and infrared photography as well as with the software application DStretch. These technologies can enhance the traces of poorlypreserved pigments, thus improving the legibility of wall paintings that have faded over time, and detect repaintings – such as those done by the second tomb owner – that would not be identifiable with the naked eye.

Theorising tomb reuse The double occupation of TT 45 and the way in which its second occupant dealt with its original decoration make it an excellent starting point for a research project on the mechanisms and motives behind tomb reuse in New Kingdom Egypt, which is carried out by the author at the Netherlands Institute for the Near East, Leiden University.

Tomb reuse was a widespread mortuary practice in ancient Egypt. Consequently, much information is available in terms of archaeological data. However, there is a surprising lack of academic research on this topic. Traditionally, studies of burial monuments have mainly been concerned with their original construction and decoration, and with their original owner(s).

The continued use and reuse of tombs has long been of marginal interest to researchers. This is indeed surprising, because the continued use of monuments clearly forms part of their ‘life history’. Another problem in the study of tomb reuse is that the phenomenon is generally

The Ramesside tomb owner Djehutyemheb and his wife Bakkhonsu depicted in both registers, with seven of their children in front of them.

Photo: TT 45 Project / Matjaž Kačičnik

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

17

18

Photo: TT 45 Project / Matjaž Kačičnik

SPACE AND MEMORY: TOMB REUSE IN NEW KINGDOM THEBES

documented only as part of the life histories of individual tombs, i.e. detached from its wider historical, cultural, and geographic context.

This research project takes a new approach and explores tomb reuse in terms of the theoretical concepts of ‘space’ and ‘memory’.

Its underlying premise is that the ancient Egyptian necropolis should not be considered merely as a random collection of individual tombs, but as a dynamic, internally coherent landscape. This landscape was shaped physically by the existing monuments and processional routes, and cognitively by the mortuary and commemorative practices that took place in it. Conversely, the landscape also structured mortuary practices, such as tomb reuse. Exploring tomb reuse from this perspective will enable us to go beyond the investigation of apparent motives associated with individual cases and to present an innovative understanding of the collective way in which the ancient Egyptians used and inter ac ted with the landscape and its monuments in order to connect with their own past and ancestors. This new approach offers an oppor tunity for cross-cultural comparisons of the ways in which societies view the dead and their own past, an important aspect of the wider phenomenon of cultural identity still relevant today.

• Carina van den Hoven is Research Fellow at the Netherlands Institute for the Near East, Leiden University, and Collaborateur Scientifique of the Research Unit UMR 8546 AOrOc ‘Archéologie et philologie d’Orient et d’Occident’ at the École Pr atique des Hautes Études (EPHE/PSL), École Normale Supérieure (ENS), and Centre National de Recherche Scientifique (CNRS). Since 2017, she ha s been Dir ec tor of the Leiden University Mission to the Theban Necropolis.

More information on the TT 45 Project at www.StichtingAEL.nl. Donations to the Luxor A r chae ologic al H e r i t age Fou nda t ion to support the project and help preserve Egypt’s her i t age can also be made t hr ough t he website. The fieldwork project would not be possible wi thou t the gener ous f inancial suppor t of the Gerda Henkel Stiftung (www. ger da- henkel-s tif tung.de) and academic, administrative, and logistic suppor t by the Netherlands-Flemish Institute in Cairo and the Netherlands Institute for the Near East at Leiden University. A proof of concept study on the digital documentation of the tomb paintings is funded by the Leiden University Centre for Digital Humanities. We closely cooper ate with the Eg yptian Minis tr y of Antiquities and the Luxor Inspectorate of Antiquities. We thank all the members of the M inis t r y of A n t iq ui t ies , t he Pe r ma ne n t Committee and of the Luxor Inspectorate for permissions, advice and assistance.

Opposite page: an example of original Eighteenth Dynasty wall paintings and later Ramesside repaintings in TT 45.

Photo: TT 45 Project / Carina van den Hoven

Left: photographer Matjaž Kačičnik and rais Azab Taie Osman working on the digital photographic documentation of the tomb.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

19

The ancient colours of Esna return The temple itself vanished in medieval times, but its surviving pronaos is still a beautiful and much-visited specimen of late Egyptian architecture.

Hisham el-Leithy, Christian Leitz, and Daniel von Recklinghausen report on recent conservation work done at the structure that has revealed decorations hitherto invisible.

The temple of Esna in March 2019.

The pronaos of Esna, one of the last examples of ancient Egyptian temple architecture, was decorated mainly during the Roman period (1st to 3rd century AD). It is, in fact, only the front part of the original temple complex, which – unlike the (Ptolemaic) temple proper – survived because it was used as storage facility for cotton during the nineteenth century (image below). The extant walls and columns are famous for their complex hieroglyphs as well as for the topics of the scenes and iconography. Serge Sauneron published the texts of the Esna temple between 1963 and 1975 (wi th the f inal volume r ealised posthumously only in 2009).

In 2018, the University of Tübingen, in co-operation with the Egyptian Ministry of

Antiquities (MoA), launched a project to document the temple decoration. Its main objectives are twofold: f irst, it aims to continue the cleaning and conservation work started by the Department of Conservation (MoA) under the auspices of Gharib Sonbol some years ago. At the moment, this work focuses on the inscriptions and images of the ceiling, the columns as well as the upper registers of the lateral wall of the northern section of the temple. These activities are c a r r i e d o u t b y a t e a m of E g y p t i a n conser vators led by Ahmed Imam. The results of the first campaign (autumn 2018 to spring 2019) have been highly promising, as the complete and original colouration is now visible again in many parts.

Photo: Ahmed Amin

20

Photos: Ahmed Amin

Ceiling (‘Travée A’), moon phases, detail.

Since these results offer a completely new approach to the temple decoration, the second objective of the project is a full photographic documentation of the current state of preservation, undertaken in co-operation with the Documentation Center (MoA), represented at the site by Mohamed Saad. In the long term, we intend to publish plate volumes of the entire decoration of the pronaos in order to set them next to the text volumes of the temple inscriptions so meticulously edited by Sauneron and thus to complete the publication of this famous temple.

In the following, we want to provide an insight into some of the most remarkable results of this f ir s t campaign. Recent conservation work began at the western part of the northern row of the ceiling decoration (Sauneron’s ‘Travée A’), much of which is taken up by the representation of the lunar phases (image above). Thanks to the cleaning efforts, the different phases of the completion of the wedjat-eye (indicating the different phases of the moon) can now be clearly distinguished.

Apar t from the moon, the solar bark and some constellations are also now visible in Travée A (image above right). In Sauneron’s publication, these images are not accompanied by inscriptions. It was therefore quite a surprise to find nearly every figure followed by a short caption. Executed not in relief but only in paint, they were not visible to Sauneron and hence not incorporated into his publications.

Turning to the columns, the cleaning and conservation of the northern columns has steadily progressed in recent months. Of

particular interest is the capital of the ‘midnorthern’ column (Sauneron’s ‘Column 7’).

It represents a kind of orchard – a rare type of a column capital – apparently composed of a combination of grapevines and date palms (with a large quantity of dates hanging from the trees). Subtly intertwining, both plants are depicted with great accuracy. The capital is a good example from which to glean information on the colour system of the temple decoration: opaque red and yellow visually dominate, offset by the palms, painted green, and the grapes in blue (image next page, top left).

Beneath the capital of Sauneron’s ‘Column 1’ runs a frieze of alternating cartouches and winged scarabs (images next page, top centre and right). Again, the execution of the decoration is extremely detailed and accurate.

Her e , the dung beetle appear s a s a representation of the morning sun. At the same time, it can also be under stood emblematically and be read as ‘live like Ra’, as is clearly suggested by the hieroglyphs. In

Ceiling (‘Travée A’), constellations, detail.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

21

Photos: Ahmed Amin

connection with the cartouches it can be read ‘May NN live like Ra’. The names given in the cartouches alternate between those of KhnumRa, Lord of Esna, Neith, Lady of Esna, the child-god Heka, and the emperor Trajan.

Conservation also made significant progress along the inner wall decoration. In the 4th (top) register of the nor thern par t of the west wall, the goddess Neith is depicted in an offering scene (image opposite page). The recovered painting reveals many features that emphasise the character of the goddess. First, the goddess’s red dress is covered by a bead net made of blue and green beads set in a rhomboi pat tern (this interpretation is supported by yellow round beads between the rhomboi). In this case however, the horizontal aspect is clearly accentuated as the blue and the green beads respectively form a zig-zag pattern, each in the shape of a waveline (with the phonetic value ‘n’). This is a ‘graphic pun’ referring to the name of Neith but perhaps also to the Primeval Water (Nun), in which Neith – in her manifestation as the cow Mehet-weret (‘the Great Flood’) – sets creation in motion. Furthermore, the pedestal of her throne is decorated with nine bow-and-arrow-pairs, at tributes of the goddess (also shown in her left hand). At the same time, this also clearly refers to the concept of ‘stamping down the Nine Bows’, a traditional reference to the enemies of Eg ypt , a motif t aken up again in the emblematic depiction on the throne. Here,

22

Top left: Column 7.

The decoration of the capital is composed of depictions of date palms and grapevines.

Top centre: Column 1.

Upper frieze, detail.

Top right: Column 1.

Detail of the text columns facing west.

Right: the emperor Trajan offering a crown.

Inner northern wall, 4th register.

Opposite page: the goddess Neith in an offering scene.

Northern part of the inner western wall, 4th register.

Photos: Ahmed Amin

THE ANCIENT COLOURS OF ESNA RETURN

two enemies – one a man from the Levant, the other a Nubian – are bound at a stake.

The depiction observes geographic directions, as the Nubian is looking south, the man from the Levant north.

Next to this offering scene, in the 4th register of the northern wall, Khnum-Ra, Lord of Esna, receives a crown offering together with his consort Menhit. Here, the colouration of the pharaoh (image left) – the emperor Trajan offering – is extremely well preserved, retaining even such details of crown and kilt that were only painted, rather than carved.

This short overview presents some initial results of the exciting new work taking place at Esna temple, demonstrating its potential in future years.

• Hisham el-Leithy is head of the Documentation Center of the Egyptian Ministry of Antiquities (MoA), Christian Leitz holds the chair of Egyptology at Tübingen University, Daniel von Recklinghausen is scientific collaborator of the project ‘The Temple as a Canon of Religious Literature’ of the Heidelberg Academy of Sciences and Humanities. All photos were taken by Ahmed Amin to whom the authors owe many thanks.

The project on the decoration of the Esna temple and its conservation is kindly suppor ted by Santander Consumer Bank and the Ancient Egypt Foundation.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

23

Digging Diary 2019-20 Summaries of archaeological work undertaken in Egypt since spring 2019. Sites are arranged geographically from north to south. Field directors who would like reports of their work to appear in EA are asked to e-mail a short summary, with a website address if available, to the editor: jan.geisbusch@ees.ac.uk | Jan Geisbusch LOWER EGYPT Kom el-Gir Naukratis Tell Basta Athribis Deir al-Surian Saqqara

Deir el-Bersha Tell el-Amarna

Karnak Thebes

Berenike

24

Kom el-Gir and surroundings: From 8-19 Apr, the DAI Cairo mission under Robert Schiestl (Ludwig-MaximiliansUniv Munich) carried out a small-scale test excavation at Kom el-Gir, c. 4 km NE of Buto (Tell el-Fara’in) in the NW Delta. At the same time, colleagues from the Dpt. of Geography / Goethe Univ Frankfurt (Main) continued investigations of the landscape around the site, in particular with regard to the location of the course of the adjacent Nile branch. Five trenches were dug in the E part of the ancient settlement, where magnetic prospection had suggested the existence of a LR fort. This was confirmed by excavations of the SW corner revealing a projecting angular tower. The top of the ancient walls lies only about 7-10 cm below the current surface. The area around the fort was filled with settlement rubbish, mainly pottery and animal bones, dating from the PP to LR periods. Investigations into the ancient landscape continued 50-100 m N and NE of the settlement site. Auger cores confirmed the existence of a Nile branch running past the settlement in this area. www.dainst.org/ projekt/-/project-display/51318 Tell Basta: Work of the Tell Basta-Project

(Univ of Würzburg), led by Eva LangeAthinodorou, continued at the site of the royal ka-temple of Pepy I (see EA 53). In the NW corner of the temple, levels of an impressive monumental building dating to an earlier period were discovered. The existence of spacious columned halls in that building, of which several phases from the middle of the 4th to the end of the 5th Dyn were identified, allow a preliminary identification as a provincial palace. If this identification is correct, Tell Basta would hold the earliest palatial building of the Nile Delta and probably all Egypt identified so far. At the same site, the remains of an administrative building with storage and food-processing facilities of the 6th Dyn were revealed. This structure belongs to the substitute buildings of the ka-temple.

Geoarchaeological investigations around the temple of Bastet now provide firm evidence for the sacred canals of the temple described

by Herodotus. In spring 2020, both sites will be investigated further. The project is currently sponsored by the Gerda-Henkel-Stiftung.

Athribis: The Athribis Project (Univ of Tübingen, MoA), led by Christian Leitz and directed in the field by Marcus Müller, continued its work in the Repit temple of Ptolemy XII and in a large trench outside the temple. The latter revealed more than 6,000 ostraca. In the 17th season (Oct 2018Apr 2019) the excavation of the pronaos was finished, proving that the columns and ceiling collapsed most likely during the 8th century AD. After clearance, a stone-tiled floor was laid for re-use of what is now an open-air space.

A representative corridor with small columns of fired bricks gave access to two rows of mud-brick rooms, some of which would have served as working spaces, kitchens, and storage areas. At least two massive fires destroyed these buildings the ruins of which were then mainly used as animal shelter and rubbish dump, the latter revealing objects of daily life from the 8th to 11th centuries AD. The foundation fill underneath a completely destroyed room showed that the foundation platform at a depth of 5.4 m was not endto-end, unlike other rooms. Epigraphic work focused on finishing texts in various rooms for publication and the recording of newly discovered texts, e.g. dating the reliefs of the pronaos to Tiberius. A big conservation project, generously financed by ARCE, focused on two major walls with important reliefs and hieroglyphic texts.

rebuilding. Work on the E wall of the nave revealed paintings from the 7th, 8th, 10th and 13th centuries and previously concealed niches with decorative painted crosses, dating back to the 10th century. The project is run by the Univs of Warsaw and Amsterdam and led by Karel Innemée. www.facebook. com/DeirAlSurianConservationProject

Naukratis (Kom Ge’if): The port of Naukratis, founded during the 26th Dyn in the late 7th century BC, was the earliest, and for a period only, Greek port in Egypt. The BM’s seventh season in Mar/Apr 2019 under Ross Iain Thomas, with the generous support of the Honor Frost Foundation, excavated three areas of the settlement: 1) the E area of the ‘Hellenion’, in the Greek sanctuary precinct to the N of the settlement; 2) the river front to the W of the site; and 3) the ‘South Mound’ in the SW corner of the sanctuary of Amun-Ra (‘Great Temenos’).

This was supplemented by geophysical work within the previously submerged lake area of the old town of Naukratis. Fieldwork was carried out with the assistance of local MoA inspectors who were trained in the use of survey equipment, excavation supervising, recording and find processing. The 2019

season produced significant new data on the layout of ancient Naukratis, enabling the precise location of all previous excavations undertaken. We also uncovered important stratigraphic, dating and topographic evidence for the settlement’s earliest phases. www.britishmuseum.org/research/ research_projects/all_current_projects/ naukratis_the_greeks_in_egypt.aspx

Saqqara: During Mar/Apr 2019, the

joint Leiden-Turin Expedition to Saqqara (Museo Egizio, Turin; National Museum of Antiquities, Leiden) led by field directors Christian Greco, Lara Weiss and Paolo Del Vesco (deputy), continued excavations N of the tomb of Maya, treasurer of pharaoh Tutankhamun. The main concern was the removal of very large spoil heaps, originating from the 1980s and 90s fieldwork seasons, in order to prepare the area for the exploration of the new tomb discovered in 2018. These deposits were carefully excavated and the numerous finds retrieved will be studied further by specialists during the 2020 season.

Similar to the previous season, the team included members of the 3D Survey Group of Politecnico di Milano who carried out a great number of photogrammetric surveys.

Dome in the Church of the Holy Virgin at Deir al-Surian with 10th century paintings. Photo: Karel Innemée.

Wadi al-Natrun (Deir al-Surian): During the Mar 2019 season, work concentrated on the uncovering of paintings and conservation work in the E part of the Church of the Holy Virgin in the Coptic monastery of Deir al-Surian, especially the sanctuary. The dome over the altar, which was believed to have little or no surviving decoration, turned out to possess an almost completely preserved, 10th century painting.

Its composition, divided into eight fields, contains theophanic scenes from the Old and New Testaments. Stripping the dome and walls below of the blank 18th century plaster also produced considerable new information on the history of the building.

Parts of the original 7th century apse were found, carrying fragments of the Ascension scene that was here before the 10th century

Kom Ge’if: area of the South Mound within the sanctuary of Amun-Ra. Photo: Penny Wilson / Naukratis Project.

This season, the aims of the Politecnico group were threefold: 1) to support the excavation activities, recording the area, contexts and finds in line with the previous season; 2) to produce a digital surface model of the entire concession; and 3) to record previously excavated monumental tombs both on the surface and underground. Lastly, beside the restoration of the new finds, the monumental tombs, which had been heavily damaged by recent rainstorms, were carefully consolidated and covered with new protective layers. www.museoegizio.it/en/ explore/news/team-saqqara-2019/ • www. rmo.nl/onderzoek/opgravingsprojecten/ sakkara/

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

25

UPPER EGYPT Deir el-Bersha: The KU Leuven mission

under Harco Willems continued excavations from late Feb to late Apr to the S and W of the tomb of the nomarch Djehutihotep.

Beside Djehutihotep’s tomb shaft, a second shaft with the same orientation and possibly belonging to a close relative or collaborator was excavated. The tomb had not reached a great depth as it hit upon an older tomb shaft during construction. 3D scanning of the area of the MK nomarch tombs continued.

Several shafts that had been excavated earlier were re-opened to facilitate scanning.

Geomorphological research continued on the W bank of the Nile in the el-Ashmunein region, in an endeavour to produce a cross section of augerings of the Nile Valley, with the objective to reconstruct the dynamics of the floodplain in past millennia.

Tell el-Amarna: On account of a delayed start, work by the Amarna Project under Barry Kemp and Anna Stevens (May/ Jun 2019) was largely confined to the Great Aten Temple. Further additions were made to the modern stonework that marks the outlines of the building, and more of the drift sand and other debris was cleared from the N and S wall trenches, allowing plans to be made of what is left of the original foundation layer of gypsum. A day was spent taking photographs at the North Harim of the Great Palace, sufficient to allow a photogrammetric record to be made.

Jacquelyn Williamson continued her study of architectural and relief fragments from the earlier excavations at Kom el-Nana. www. amarnaproject.com Karnak (precinct of Amun-Ra): The

archaeological and epigraphic studies of the CFEETK continued under the supervision of Abd el-Sattar Badri and Luc Gabolde between Sep 2018 and Jun 2019. The restoration and conservation programme of the S magazines of the Akhmenu was implemented under the supervision of Laura Bontemps, with the support of the Kheops Fund for Archaeology.

Thanks to the same sponsor, the restoration of the quartzite statue of Amun of Tutankhamun was undertaken under the supervision of A. Garric, L. Antoine and M. Abd er-Radi with the aim to replace the concrete bust and left leg beam by copies of indurated sandstone shaped after original statues of the same reign. The background of the statue will be enhanced by the rebuilding of a portion of the Annals of Thutmose III, blocks of which were gathered and restored.

In the ‘cachette courtyard’, A. Garric and his team have achieved the reconstruction of the E wall and implemented the rebuilding of the W wall. In the Osirian sector, the Ifao team led by L. Coulon and C. Giorgi continued the epigraphic study: archaeological research focused on the mud-brick walls and the surrounding structures. As part of the restoration activities, a secondary gate of the chapel of Osiris Wennefer Neb Djefau was rebuilt. The Karnak documentation programme, the online archive and lexical database continued under the supervision of J. Hourdin and S. Biston-Moulin. www. cfeetk.cnrs.fr

Karnak (precinct of Mut): The Brooklyn

Museum Mut Expedition’s 2019 season in Feb, led by Richard Fazzini, concentrated on the First Court of Temple A, in the NE corner of the site. The S side of the court was cleared, revealing what are probably the remains of five sphinx bases with later structures built over them. The front two rooms of the Nitocris Chapel in the court’s SE corner were fully cleared, revealing the original paving in the first room. Five of the eight columns on the N side of the court were re-erected on new bases. The rear half of a sphinx on the W side of the court was restored; together with the upper half of a statue of Ramesses II, it was placed on mastabas, and the badlydeteriorated lower halves of two granite royal statues were protected from windblown soil.

The study of the site’s Sekhmet statues and the Montuemhat Crypt in the Mut temple continued. www.brooklynmuseum.org/ features/mut (site description, reports); www.brooklynmuseum.tumblr.com/tagged/ mutdig (dig diary)

Karnak (precinct of Amun-Ra): bust of the statue of Amun of Tutankhamun lifted up for restoration.

Photo: E. Saubestre / CNRS-CFEETK (June 2019).

Dra Abu el-Naga North (TT 1112): The Spanish mission (CSIC) at Dra Abu

el-Naga North, directed by José M. Galán, continued the excavations SW of the tombchapel of Djehuty (TT 11) in Jan/Feb 2019, at the open courtyard where an early 12th Dyn funerary garden had been brought to light in 2017 (see EA 54). Archaeologists and geologists focused on the documentation of the layers of thin sand that had sealed the garden and protected it from human activity taking place in the area during the SIP. At this time, several funerary shafts and mud-brick offering chapels were built. One of the shafts was excavated and, despite the fact that it had been robbed in antiquity, a pair of engraved leather sandals was found, next to a pair of

Karnak (precinct of Mut): the south side of the First Court of Temple A at the end of the 2019 season of the Brooklyn Museum mission. On the left: the Nitocris Chapel, with the five newly-found sphinx bases (partially covered by later construction) to its west. Photo: Brooklyn Museum Mut Expedition.

26

DIGGING DIARY 2019

leather balls tied together by a string. A new mud-brick chapel was unearthed, together with six inscribed stick-shabtis dedicated to Ahmose. One of them, still wrapped in linen, bears the name Ahmose-Sapair. www. excavacionegipto.com

Asasif (TT 414): The principal aim of the Ankh-Hor Project of Ludwig-Maximilians Univ Munich is the complete analysis of finds excavated under the directorship of Manfred Bietak 1969 to 1979 in the Asasif, first of all from TT 414, the monumental tomb of Ankh-Hor (26th Dyn). Large

about the possible burial place of MeritNeith within TT 414. www.ankhhorproject. wordpress.com

Valley of the Kings: This season’s work

in Jun 2019 of the Amenmesse Project (KV 10 / KV 63) (MoA and AUC) had four foci: 1) finishing the documentation of the ceramic materials from KV 63; 2) continuing the organisation and documentation of the ceramics from KV 10; 3) recording the different phases of decoration and re-use of KV 10; and 4) cataloguing and studying the material from KV 63. The team, led by Salima Ikram, managed to accomplish its goals, with the recording of the tomb walls being particularly interesting. The original decorative scheme of the tomb when it was cut for Amenmesse is slowly being

Left: Dra Abu el-Naga: pair of SIP (?) leather sandals with red dye and engraved decoration.

Photo: Proyecto Djehuty / J. Trueba.

Below: Asasif (TT 414): a new fragment (top) and the already published side board (bottom) of the qrsw coffin of Merit-Neith, daughter of Ankh-Hor. Photo: Ankh-Hor Project.

ceramic vessels as grave goods. One had a silver ring with decorated intaglio. There was new information about 4th to 5th centuries AD activities. Evidence for religious functions in the ‘Northern Complex’ included sculptural and epigraphic testimony for cults of Horus and Isis-Serapis, the latter appearing on an inscription recording a Blemmye king.

Excavations continued at the 4th century or later tetrastylon at the intersection of major N-S/E-W streets. Excavations in the main Isis-Serapis temple exposed most of the interior, the propylon and areas abutting the temple exterior. Additional epigraphic evidence in Greek and hieroglyphs, and sculptural remains in wood, bronze and stone now augment the knowledge of this major structure for the period from the 1st century AD until late antiquity. Excavations in the propylon documented fragments of a life-sized stone statue of the Meroitic deity Sebiumeker. The inscription mentioning a Blemmye king, statue fragments depicting Sebiumeker and images of other Meroitic deities indicate a more complicated history of Berenike than previously assumed.

Abbreviations: Technical terms: PD Predynastic; EDP Early Dynastic Period; OK Old Kingdom; FIP First Intermediate Period; MK Middle Kingdom; SIP Second Intermediate Period; NK New Kingdom; TIP Third Intermediate Period; LP Late Period; PP Ptolemaic Period; GR Graeco-Roman; ER Early Roman; LR Late Roman; ERT Electrical Resistance Tomography; FTIR Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy; GPR Ground Penetrating Radar; pXRF portable X-ray fluorescence.

numbers of finds from these excavations are still unpublished and were left on site in the mission’s storeroom. This material holds rich potential for understanding the funerary customs in the LP, the Ptolemaic and Roman era. During the 2019 season in Feb/Mar, led by field director Julia Budka, the documentation of the finds continued, with a focus on coffins, including a large scale conservation programme. The wooden coffins belong both to primary burials of the family of Ankh-Hor and to secondary burials of Amun priests, mostly dating to the 4th and 3rd centuries BC. Some pieces were identified for the first time and linked with documentation from the 1970s, as illustrated by the side board of the qrsw coffin of Merit-Neith, daughter of Ankh-Hor, published in 1982. A new small fragment from the vaulted lid was found in the magazine, offering fresh information

reconstructed, while the removal of most of this carving can also be recorded, including the identification of different tools as well as different artisans. Some of the schema of decoration for Queens Baketwernel and Takhat are also being identified, with the hope that the whole schema will be reconstructible.

Berenike: Excavations by the Univ of

Delaware (USA) and the PCMA (Univ of Warsaw) under the direction of Steven E. Sidebotham and Iwona Zych took place in Jan/Feb 2019 in five locations: 1) a PP hydraulic area / ER cemetery; 2) a pet necropolis; 3) the ‘Northern Complex’; 4) the tetrastylon; and 5) the main Isis temple.

After abandonment, the PP hydraulic facility became a cemetery in the ER era. Portions of a wooden sarcophagus partially made of teak have survived. Some burials contained

Institutes and Research Centres: AEHAF Ancient Egyptian Heritage and Archaeology Fund; AUC American University in Cairo; BM British Museum; CEAlex Centre d’Études Alexandrines; CEFB Centro di Egittologia Francesco Ballerini; CFEETK Franco-Egyptian Centre, Karnak; CNRS (USR) French National Research Centre (Research Groups); CSIC Spanish National Research Council; DAI German Archaeological Institute, Cairo; IAJU Institute of Archaeology Jagiellonian University, Cracow; IFAO French Archaeological Institute, Cairo; MEAE Ministère de l’Europe et des Affaires Etrangères; MMA Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; MoA Ministry of State for Antiquities, Egypt; NCAM National Corporation for Antiquities and Museums of the Sudan OI Oriental Institute (University of Chicago); PCMA Polish Centre of Mediterranean Archaeology, Cairo; SwissInst Swiss Institute for Architectural Research and Archaeology, Cairo.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

27

An Egyptian grand cru: wine production at Plinthine Recent archaeological discoveries as well as archaeobotanical and environmental studies in Plinthine shed new light on wine production at this small village on the taenia ridge between the Mediterranean Sea and Lake Mareotis, writes Bérangère Redon. Viticulture was practised here from the New Kingdom to the Ptolemaic period. For the first time, we gain information on the grape varieties and winemaking process in an area whose wines were once famous but are still little known within archaeology.

View from Kom elNogous to the west, with fig trees now replacing the ancient vineyards.

The Osiris temple of Taposiris is visible in the background.

Photo: MFTMP / B. Redon

28

Wine production in ancient Egypt Wine in ancient Egypt? The country is not renowned for its wines in Pharaonic times, and in the classical literature the Egyptians are considered as beer drinkers. The famous historian of the 5th century BC, Herodotus, even states that the inhabitants of the country did not grow vines on their soil (II, 77). Winemaking and -consumption in Egypt is usually associated with the arrival of wine-drinking populations in Egypt after the conquest of Alexander the Great in 331 BC, for which there are indeed numerous papyrological and archaeological data (dozens of wineries have been excavated, mainly of the Roman and Byzantine periods).

However, viticulture is evidenced in Egypt from the Predynastic period and the Old

Kingdom onward, especially on the fringes of the Nile delta where the first vines might have been imported from the Near East. While mentioned in written sources, represented on paintings adorning the tombs of the Theban valley, and evoked by the thousands of labels found with the jars that contained the precious liquid, the production of wine in pharaonic Egypt has never been studied in the field. This is because until recently, no archaeological evidence of a pharaonic winery has been found, other than a very poorly preserved example at Tell el-Dab’a One of the most famous Egyptian vintages was grown on the territory called ‘the Western River’, mentioned on a few dozens of jar labels found in Tell el-Amarna (representing more than 70 percent of the jar labels ever found at the

Thonis/ Herakleion

an

ne

a err dit

s

Me

Alexandria

tae

r

Cano Bran pic ch

Mareotis Lake

e idg

10/08/2019

Marea Peninsula

Saïs

Google Maps

Taposiris Magna Kom Bahig

Kom Firin

Naukratis

Below: plan of Kom el-Nugus / Plinthine and its vicinity, with the find spots of wine-production remains.

Plinthine (Kom el-Nugus -

)

N

2012-2018 Seasons General Plan - scale 1/3000e Architectural survey: M. Vanpeene - Th. Fournet CAD: M. Vanpeene Topographican survey: Th. Arnoux - O. Onézime - M. Vanpeene Kom el-Nugus (from Late New Kingdom to Roman period)

Saite grape grinder

(sect.SIO, 6) Imagery ©2019 Landsat / Copernicus, Data NOAA, U.S. Navy, NGA, GEBCO, Map data ©2019 Mapa GISrael, ORIONAbove: map of northern ME

Egypt, showing the Mareotis region.

Map: MFTMP / M. Vanpeene, Th. Fournet

Map: BingMap image adapted by B. Redon

nia

Plinthine/ Kom el-Nogous

Location of the site of Plinthine, on the taenia ridge, in the Mareotis region.

ea

Ptolemaic town

New Kingdom pottery (and ovens?)

Ptolemaic grape grinder

Ptolemaic Necropolis

Wine-production evidence (certain, uncertain)

Modern buildings

New Kingdom Remains

site). The ‘Western River’ probably merged with or included the Mareotis region, on the shores of Lake Mareotis (nowadays Maryut), located at the gates of Alexandria and well known for its wine production in Roman and Byzantine times.

The quality of the Mareotis wine is praised by Latin poets, such as Virgil and Horace. According to them, it was white, sweet, and aromatic.

Strabo even says that the ancients let the Mareotis

Roads

Ancient buildings

0

50

100

200

400 m

wine age (XVII, 1, 14). Among the vintages produced in the region, the wine of the taenia, the sandstone ridge separating the Mediterranean Sea from Lake Mareotis, was judged of better quality than the wine from the southern Mareotis area by Athenaeus, an Egyptian author of the 2nd century AD. According to him, ‘the taeniotic wine, in addition to being sweet, [was] somewhat spicy and slightly astringent’ (I, 33).

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

29

Photogrammetric image of the Saite grape grinder at Plinthine.

Grape pips, skin, pedicel and stalk fragments found in the Plinthine samples dated to the Saite period.

Image: MFTMP / M. Vanpeene

Right: the entrance to the Saite grape grinder of Plinthine.

Plinthine – a wine-producing village With the support of the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the French Institute of Oriental Archaeology (Ifao), and the Arpamed fund, the French mission of Taposiris Magna and Plinthine (MFTMP) recently launched a project dedicated to the study of the wine production of a taeniotic site – Plinthine – over the longue durée from the pharaonic period to the end of Ptolemaic era. Coupling soil analyses, the study of grape varieties and excavations, the analysis focus on the whole production chain, from the grape seed to the jar.

Plinthine is remarkably situated on the shores of the Mediterranean Sea and Lake Maryut, 2 km east of Taposiris Magna, a well-known city occupied from the Ptolemaic period to early medieval times, in the extreme north-west of what Herodotus considered as the territory of Egypt. The site consists of a large, horses h o e - s h a p e d ko m ( K o m e l - N u g u s) , 11 m high, atop the ridge. Our excavations have shown traces of occupation from the Late New Kingdom to the Late Ptolemaic or Early Roman period. It overlooks a village, built on the southern slope of the ridge, looking toward Lake Mareotis, whose last phase of occupation – the only one we have studied so far – dates back to the Hellenistic period. Dated to the same period, the necropolis of Plinthine is situated 500 m to the west. Between the kom

30

Photo: MFTMP / G. Polin (Ifao)

and the necropolis, scattered pottery dated to the New Kingdom is visible on the surface.

Three phases of viticulture at Plinthine Interestingly, Hellanikos, a Greek author of the 5th century BC (quoted by Athenaeus I, 60), reports that viticulture was invented at Plinthine. This is likely a legend, but our recent finds show that wine production began well before the mention of Hellanikos, probably during the New Kingdom, and that this tradition lasted for more than a millennium, with unexpected intensity.

First evidence was discovered in 2015, during a survey in the ‘New Kingdom area’, where several ovens and ceramics, including a wine jar stamped with the name of the eldest daughter of Akhenaten, Merytaten, were found. Besides other artefacts (among them a limestone stela of Sety II) that attest a royal presence on the site during the next dynasty,

AN EGYPTIAN GRAND CRU: WINE PRODUCTION AT PLINTHINE

the stamped wine jar may suggest that a royal vineyard was cultivated at Plinthine during the Eighteenth Dynasty.

After a period not well-documented on the site so far, wine production clearly intensifies again during the Twenty-sixth Dynasty, as

Photo: MFTMP / G. Polin (Ifao)

Other tomb paintings show that the men were singing while pressing the grapes, and hold poles or strings attached to the roof or to the hips or shoulders of their neighbours in order not to slip on the grapes. Treading was indeed not all that easy, as the quick onset of fermentation while grapes were being pressed meant that workers were probably a little drunk while pressing.

The third period of wine production evidenced at Plinthine dates to the Ptolemaic period. A few decades after Alexander the Great’s conquest of Egypt, a community of new inhabitants of Hellenic origin settled on the site, as shown by their funerary customs Left: detail of the treading platform, built from limestone slabs and covered with mortar.

Below: a reconstruction of the Saite grape grinder.

Photo: MFTMP / G. Polin (Ifao)

shown by the discovery of an exceptionally well-pr eser ved gr ape gr inder, whose construction can be securely dated to the second half of the 7th century BC. It is located in a vaulted room that belongs to a complex building still only partly excavated, and is built in a very fine local limestone, covered with mor tar. The grinder consisted of a raised treading platform (1.89 x 2.14 m) where the grapes were pressed underfoot by several people, and a monolithic vat of 9 hl into which the juice flowed from the platform through a drain. A unique example in pharaonic Egypt, its closest parallels can be found in the paintings that adorned the tomb walls of the Valley of Nobles in Thebes, in particular in the tomb of Nakht (TT 52). It is also very similar to the winery depicted in the Petosiris tomb, dated to the early Hellenistic period, except for the lion-head drain, which becomes common only during the Graeco-Roman period in Egypt.

Image: MFTMP / M. Vanpeene

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

31

The New Kingdom grape grinder shown in the tomb of Nakht at Thebes (TT 52) (after Davies 1917, pl. XXIIIB, XXVI).

32

and offerings, and some rare inscriptions. They clearly perpetuated the wine tradition of Plinthine, as shown by the discovery of the only wine-producing villa in Mareotis that can securely be dated to the Ptolemaic period. It is located at the fringes of the necropolis and is organised around a grape grinder, similar to the earlier, Saite one (with a treading platform and a deep vat for the juice), but larger. The work conducted by Olivier Callot (CNRS, Lyon) and then Louis Dautais (Université Montpellier III) show that it was abandoned in the second half of the Ptolemaic period. Like the Saite one, the Ptolemaic wine factory was housed within a larger building, which might have been a private residence, indicating that wine production occurred in a domestic context. The Saite treading platform of the 7th century BC could likley produce 400 l in one go, the capacity of the Ptolemaic platform might have been twice as much. Both represent significant quantities, though, of course, they are small compared to the later large-scale production of some villas of the Roman world.

Soil analysis and wine quality Such continuity in the Plinthine wine production is due above all to the quality of the terroir and the composition of soils that seem to be partiularly suitable for viticulture, as demonstrated by the geomorphological analyses conducted by Maël Crépy (post-doc CNRS): the soil is composed of a mix of substratum fragments, fine siliceous sand coming from the deser t to the south and coarse calcareous sand originating from the seashore, with a proportion of silt and clay that is lower in the upper part of the ridge than nearer the lake, resulting in good drainage characteristics and making the soil easier to work. It is also significant that the samples taken at Plinthine are less alkaline than those coming from Taposiris Magna. Plinthine was definitely the best place in the area to produce wine of quality.

This undoubtedly stimulated the central role played by viticulture at the site, in particular during the Saite and Ptolemaic periods, as demonstrated by the discovery of thousands of grape pips, stems or fragments of grape skin and vinegrape charcoal fragments during our excavations (no New Kingdom levels have been sampled so far ; probable Third Intermediate Period layers with grape seeds

Image: MFTMP / M. Vanpeene

Sections and plan of the Saite grape grinder.

and charcoal have been studied, but their chronology is not well established and they were not taken into account for this article).

All the soil samples analyzed by Charlène Bouchaud (CNRS) and Menna el-Dorry (MoA and IFAO), and dated to these two periods contain grape remains, while other species grown at the site are few and derive solely from inhabitants’ food and wood requirements.

The raison d’être of the village seems indeed to have been the production of wine, at least under the Saite and Ptolemaic dynasties.

Was the Plinthine wine a grand cru or a piquette? Archaeobotanical research has not yet made it clear. The morphometric study conducted by Clémence Pagnoux (post-doc École fr ançaise d’Athènes) shows that numerous grape varieties were grown and

AN EGYPTIAN GRAND CRU: WINE PRODUCTION AT PLINTHINE

Photo: J.-Fr. Gout (Ifao)

pressed at Plinthine during the Twenty-sixth Dynasty and in the Ptolemaic period, with, respectively, 28 and 15 different grape varieties identified so far, ranging from species close to the wild vine to varieties well-known elsewhere in the Middle East or Greece. The cépages assemblage change between the two periods may perhaps reflect the evolution of the customers’ taste, though it could also be due to technological and techno-biological transfers that took place after the Greek conquest, when many Hellenes (in the broad sense of the word) came to settle in Egypt and especially in Alexandria and the nearby Mareotis area. However, the evolution of the diversity of the cultivated grapes is also a manifestation of attempts to adapt varieties to the Plinthine terroir.

• Bérangère Redon (CNRS, Lyon) is director of the French mission of Taposiris Magna and Plinthine (MFTMP). More information on the mission can be found at: www.taposiris.hypotheses.org

Image: MFTMP / M. Vanpeene

Trading networks Thanks to the production of wine on its slopes during pharaonic times, Plinthine was at the heart of commercial networks since the precious beverage was first produced, initially for consumers living in the Nile Valley. While not yet identified with certainty, the Plinthine cru is likely to be one of the wines well-known from Egyptian sources, drunk at the tables of the pharaohs and the social elites as ‘wine of the Western River’. Probably favoured by its location on the Mediterranean coast, Plinthine was also part of Mediterranean trade during the Saite period, and the local production of wine in Plinthine is contemporaneous with massive impor ts of wine amphorae from eastern Greece (Samos, Chios, Lesbos, Clazomenes, Athens, etc.), Cyprus and the Phoenician world that are currently studied

by Mikaël Pesenti. This raises many questions about the techno-biological transfers these exchanges might have facilitated before the Ptolemaic period and about the interface role that Plinthine certainly played at a time when Egypt was opening up to the Mediterranean.

This is one of the questions the next campaigns will try to answer.

Top: the early Hellenistic grape grinder of the Petosiris tomb at Tuna el-Gebel.

Above: photogrammetric image of the Ptolemaic villa and its grape grinder, near the necropolis of Plinthine.

Photo: MFTMP / G. Polin (Ifao)

Left: detail of the Ptolemaic grape grinder of Plinthine: the lower vat.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

33

Psamtik I in Heliopolis On 7 March 2017, the Egyptian-German Mission in Heliopolis found fragments of a colossal quartzite statue in the area of Suq el-Khamis, the western perimeter of the temple precinct of Matariya, where once stood a temple of Ramesses II. These fragments show an exceptional quality of manufacturing. They belong to the largest statue known so far of a king of the Twenty-sixth Dynasty, write Aiman Ashmawy, Simon Connor and Dietrich Raue.

Torso of the colossal statue of Psamtik I found at Matariya.

Photo: S. Connor

34

The Egyptian-German Joint Archaeological Mission at Matariya continued the investigation of the great sun temple’s structure and chronology in three areas: the first temple along the dromos after entering the temple precinct from its western monumental gate, the immediate surroundings of the temple close to the obelisk of Senusret I, and the south-eastern fringe of an approximately square structure that had been first discovered by the Italian Mission under Ernesto Schiaparelli in 1903–06. The latter was mapped by Petrie and has been identified by now as a large enclosure of the 16th–15th century BC. This tremendous construction was designated by Petrie as a ‘Hyksos Fort’, while it most probably has to be identified with a large enclosure or embankment that is mentioned on several stelae of Thutmose III in his 47th regnal year (1432 BC).

Ongoing construction projects forced to resume the work in the westernmost part, the so-called Suq el-Khamis. Due to risen groundwater, drains had to be dug to document the statue bases that were found there between 2006 and 2009 by the Supreme Council of Antiquities.

In 2017, the workmen of our team reported a quite unexpected discovery: a large polished stone that soon turned out to be the colossus of a pharaoh made of beige-brown quartzite (image B, following page).

Its location in front of the remains of a Ramesside gate left at first several options for the identification of the represented king. With ongoing work and after the extraction of two major fragments (9 tons in total) from about 3 m under groundwater, more observations became possible.

Later work in 2017 and 2018 produced 6,500 fragments in a radius of about 15 m all around the statue base (A) – the colossus once stood on a rectangular pedestal consisting of a mass of limestone blocks, framed by slabs of quartzite. This podium was part of the series of statue bases installed in front of the Ramesside pylon.

The statue’s back pillar provided us with the complete titulature of Psamtik I (664–610 BC). However, in the first days after the torso’s discovery, the colossus had been the object of intense discussion concerning the identification of the represented king, and doubts still remain in the mind of some scholars. Due to the colossal size of the statue and the archaeological context (in front of a Ramesside temple, according to all the inscribed blocks found in the area), one would have expected this to be a statue of Ramesses II (1279–1213 BC). Furthermore, the granite statues whose fragments were also found in front of the pylon’s remains can by their style be quite clearly attributed to the early Twelfth Dynasty (1991–1802 BC). They were probably ‘usurped’ or ‘re-activated by Ramesses II. This presence within the same context initially suggested that the newly discovered colossus, too, might have been such a Middle Kingdom piece reused by Ramesses II. Nevertheless, the untouched and exquisitely carved inscription on the back pillar, as well as the stylistic analysis leave no doubt that the colossus is a Twentysixth Dynasty monument, which makes it the largest sculpture ever found from this period of Egyptian history.

Relatively few royal statues are preserved from this period. They are rarely complete and usually quite small, which makes it difficult to securely date this mighty colossus through comparison with securely dated pieces. Various stylistic elements may point out to different phases of Egyptian art history. Considered individually, they would indicate contradictory dating, but their combination allows us to identify these features as ‘archaisms’ and ascertain that the statue is indeed contemporary to the back pillar’s inscription.

The king’s white crown (E) bears two characteristic features that might give dating criteria: the absence of uraeus and the shape of the lappet around the ear. As far as we know, the white crown is without uraeus in the Old Kingdom and on most of the early Middle Kingdom corpus. It then systematically appears on royal statues of the following dynasties, with some exceptions during the reign of Amenhotep III (between 1391 and 1351 BC). The Late Period white crowns all attest a uraeus, but they are too few to provide statistics. On the Suq el-Khamis colossus, the front lappet ends with a straight horizontal line, while the rear one draws a curve surrounding the whole lobe.

This motif (with variations in the shape of the lower lappet’s curve) is also specific to the Old and early Middle Kingdom. In the New Kingdom, the rear part of the crown draws a regular, almost horizontal, curve from an ear to the other. This combination (absence of uraeus and form of the lappets) suggests, therefore, that the crown of the Heliopolis colossus is stylistically closer to the Old and early Middle Kingdom. Nevertheless, the lappets’ shape is again attested on some reliefs of the 1st millennium BC and may therefore have appeared also on this sculpture.

The torso (image opposite page) shows a par ticularly developed musculature. The accentuated modelling of the pectoral muscles, the wide shoulders and the deep ver tical depression on the abdomen make this statue a proper colossus, in all senses, expressing the supernatural strength of the pharaoh. Such massiveness, with prominent pectoral muscles and shoulders, is reminiscent of the body shape of the colossal statues of the Fourth (c. 2613– 2494 BC) and of the early Twelfth Dynasties.

The colossi’s bodies of the Thirteenth Dynasty kings, of Amenhotep III and of Ramesses II show the same monumentalisation, but less naturalism in the musculature’s rendering. The massiveness and naturalism come back in the musculature of the Twenty-fifth Dynasty’s style (744–656 BC), with a deep median line, clear referent of the Middle Kingdom, and is very well-attested by numerous (particularly non-royal) examples.

On the colossus, the clavicles are inclined and prominent, a feature which is common in Late Period sculpture, while in the earlier periods, they remain almost horizontal. A striking peculiarity is the strongly developed proper left nipple. There are no known parallels, perhaps EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

35

A: Fragments of shoulder and other body parts south of the base.

B: Torso and crown of the colossus of Psamtik I north of the base.

C: Fragment of the face.

D: Offering scene on the back pillar, the king presenting wine to Atum.

E: Right ear and lappets of the white crown.

F: Detail of the offering scene, showing the king’s head.

G: An iconographic detail so far unparalleled: the left hand of the king placed under the navel.

due to the fact that no other colossus has been preserved, but smaller sculptures of the Twentysixth Dynasty usually show well-defined nipples, linked to a particular attention to the rendering of the torso’s modelling.

The face shows an oval and elongated shape, with rounded cheeks, smiling lips and two deep circular holes to mark the corners of the mouth, in line with Twenty-sixth Dynasty styles. Despite the damage to the lips, the characteristic Late Period smile is still clearly noticeable. The ear is carefully modelled and detailed, again a frequent feature in the Late Period’s refined style. The left eye and eyebrow are preserved on a large fragment and show the most characteristic elements of the style of Psamtek I’s period: both are in sharp relief and run almost horizontally towards the temples after a slight curve. The concavity of the eye socket is also particularly emphasized at the level of the inner corner of the eye. The facial shape, the affected smile with deep corners of the mouth and the sharp make-up lines (C) are all characteristic of the Twenty-sixth Dynasty style and fit with the dating provided by the back pillar’s inscription.

Several elements speak against a reuse of a Middle or New Kingdom colossus. The preserved surface does not show any evidence of modification, nor any irregularity in the polishing. Fur thermore, if some features, considered individually, may refer to earlier periods, their combination creates unavoidable anachronisms, while they all fit with the Saite period’s style. The absence of uraeus on the crown and of holes in the lobes argue against an identif ication of this colossus as a representation of Ramesses II, while the

A

B

Photo: D. Raue

36

musculature is far too developed for a colossus of Amenhotep III. The noticeable absence of a collar also argues against an identification as Amenhotep III or Ramesses II. An early Middle Kingdom dating must be rejected too, since the make-up lines of the eyes and the shape of the face and of the smile do not fit with the stylistic features of that period but clearly point to the Twenty-sixth Dynasty. The apparently early Middle Kingdom characteristics have therefore to be considered as archaising features, common in the ‘renaissance phase’ of the beginning of the Late Period, but not as evidence of reuse.

Despite the massiveness of the torso and the large dimensions of the piece, the statue is striking for the extreme care given to refined anatomical detail (ear, eyebrow and eyelid, clavicles, nipples) and the high quality of the hieroglyphs on the back pillar and the admirable polishing of the surface. All testify to the search for formal perfection that strongly characterises the style of the Twenty-sixth Dynasty. The Matariya quartzite colossus will have to be considered a landmark of Late Period sculpture.

Like other dynastic founders, Psamtik I probably sought the blessing for a long reign through the support of the sun and creatorgod at Heliopolis. A desire to demonstrate legitimacy clearly shines through the revival of a 550 year old type of colossal statuary (image p. 38). Nevertheless, for his 10.5 m high colossus (or colossi, since they usually function by pairs), Psamtik did not only use archaisms, but introduced also a striking, not yet understood new feature: the position of the left arm, with the hand placed under the navel, in a gesture not attested in Egyptian

PSAMTIK I IN HELIOPOLIS

statuary so far (G) – the closest examples are two statues of Amenhotep III in a heb-sed garment and an embonpoint (Cairo 33900 and 33901), but in those cases both hands are placed under the abdomen.

The back-pillar is another exciting combination of innovation and classicism from the rulers of the Twenty-sixth Dynasty and their claim to a renaissance of Egypt’s territorial unity and regional hegemony. The top shows a unique symmetrical distribution of the hieroglyphs of Psamtik’s throne name (image p. 39). It is followed by a ritual scene carved with the highest refinement (D, F), showing the king kneeling in front of the creator-god Atum, lord of Heliopolis. The ancient main deity of the sun temple receives wine from the king, a motif known from other colossi of the Ramesside era. Two parallel columns display the five names of Psamtik I. Two follow-up seasons in autumn 2017 and spring 2018 brought further insights into the

original setting of the monument and the history of its destruction. The statue was placed on a solid stone foundation of six layers of limestone blocks. They were originally designed for another building and reused by Psamtik I for his monument. Near this, another G

Photo: S. Connor

E

F

Photo: S. Connor

D

C

Photo: D. Raue

Photo: D. Raue

Photo: S. Connor

Photo: S. Connor

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

37

Right: a reconstruction of the statue.

38

pedestal of Ramesside date was discovered close to a modern residential area at the limit of the excavation site to the east. It is interesting to note that the base of Psamtik’s statue was set up intentionally between two statue emplacements of the later second millennium BC in front of the stage of a large Ramesside festival temple.

Eight sections were dug, again up to 3 m below the groundwater level. Most fragments were found on the rear side of the base in a foundation trench that was deprived of its stone layers at an unknown date. The fill of this trench contained several hundred fragments of a seated colossus of red granite. An inscription at its pedestal names Ramesses II but it cannot be excluded that it once carried an earlier sculpture, e.g. of the Middle Kingdom. All in all, four colossal royal representations can be located in front of the western pylon wing of a temple that followed a north-south orientation.

A number of other fragments were found together with the quar tzite fragments of Psamtik’s statue and the fragments of the Ramesside red granite colossi. The earliest pottery finds date to the Early Dynastic Period, the youngest part of this assemblage are no later than the early Roman era. Together with vast amounts of potsherds, other items from the temple were found, among them a head of a private sculpture of a Twelfth Dynasty official as well as a number of fragments of a 4th century BC healing statue. In association with Psamtik’s statue, a pit contained the paw of a sphinx as well as fragments of a colossal falcon, both of red granite. The sphinx’s length can be estimated at up to 18 m, and it might have been up to 10 m high. Such monumental representations were still seen by early travellers in that part of the temple. Their sketches show the name of Ramesses II on the sphinx’s shoulder. Four teen years ago, an Egyptian-German joint venture discovered a large fragment of such a sphinx in Suq elKhamis with a cartouche of Merenptah. It can therefore not be ruled out that more than one sculpture of this size was placed in front of the Ramesside temple.

The quartzite colossus of Psamtik I, the first monument of that size ever found from the 1st millennium BC, revives the idea of the divine nature of pharaonic kingship by performing its ritual presence in the temple of the creator god in supernatural format.

Images: Chr. Breninek

Slightly smaller statues of about 6–7 m are described by Herodotus and Diodor in the temple of Memphis. The statue of Matariya is of far-reaching interest for another area of the cultural history of Egypt and its neighbours: most scholars have agreed that Egyptian statuary of the 2nd millennium BC gave the decisive impulse for the innovation of Greek sculpture in life-size and in hyper formats in the Archaic Period during the late 7th century.

We may therefore suggest that Greek merchants and mercenaries, attracted by the possibilities of the Nile Valley, not only saw colossal representations of the past but also of their own current commander-in-chief, pharaoh Psamtik I. The dismantling of the pylon cannot yet be precisely dated. Several of the temple blocks and statue fragments found in Suq el-Khamis bear clear marks of intentional cutting, in preparation for reuse in later constructions.

PSAMTIK I IN HELIOPOLIS

hieroglyphs are beautifully preserved. Should we incriminate invaders of Heliopolis, perhaps the Persians, considering the destruction of Psamtik’s statue, as a war symbol?

Many questions currently remain. The early Roman finds from the deposition context do not give a precise date for the destruction of the statue that may have taken place many decades or even centuries earlier. For the burial of the fragments, the finds from the trenches offer merely a terminus post quem. It cannot be ruled out that this mixture of debris was discarded at an even later date in Late Roman or early Islamic times, using open trenches left by later stone robbers. Indeed, the subsequent covering layers of debris contain Late Roman material. If the burial of all these fragments took place at the archaeologically earliest possible occasion, one might consider the transport of obelisks to Rome by Augustus as a par t of destructions in the precinct of Heliopolis. No major royal investment in the great precinct of the sun god has yet been identified for the Ptolemaic Period. While other temples of Egypt continued to flourish in the Roman era, in Matariya the national solar cult had come to an end. Its monuments were available for transportation to Alexandria as furnishing and construction material, while they can also be found in other cities of the Roman Empire and especially in Rome itself.

As is often the case with statues found in sacred pits (see the Karnak cachette), the statue was mutilated before being buried, perhaps in order to ‘de-activate’ it: the mouth shows clear traces of systematic pounding.

The reason for the statue’s breaking may have been an intentional de-sacralisation during the abandonment of the temple and the gathering of construction materials. However, no parts of the body seem to be missing and no tool marks could be identified on the breaks, perhaps because the hardness and weight of its material made it unsuitable for reuse. Another interpretation could be war damage, perhaps by fire. If the upper part of the s t atue is vir tually completely re constructible from large fragments, the legs were found reduced into several thousands of small quar tzite chips, many of them apparently burnt. Let us note that there is no trace of damnatio memoriae and that all

Left: a reconstruction of the back pillar.

• The Egyptian-German Mission is grateful for

the continuous support, attendance and interest in our fieldwork at Matariya by the Minister of Antiquities, Dr. Khaled el-Enany and the General Assembly of the Minis tr y of Antiquities.

Representing the archaeologists and restorers of the Inspectorate of Antiquities of Matariya and Ain Shams, we would like to thank Khaled Abu al-Ela, Hoda Kamal Ahmed, and Iman Riad.

Extractions and transpor ts to the Egyptian Museum at Tahrir Place were undertaken by specialists from that institution (Moamen Othman and his colleagues) and the Grand Egyptian Museum (Osama Abu Kheir, Eissa Zeidan, and Nassef Abd el-Wahed), and by the workmen from Quft in Upper Egypt under reis Ashraf elAmir Kamil Seddiq. We owe the illustrations for the reconstruction of the sculpture to Christopher Breninek. The mission is grateful for funding by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, the Fondation Michela Schiff Giorgini, the Fonds Khéops pour l’Archéologie, the Egyptology Forum of the University of Zurich, Mr. Sameh Sawiris and the European Foundation for Education and Culture of the Rahn Dittrich Group.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

39

3D reconstruction: M. Limoncelli Photos and plans: Soknopaiou Nesos Project

The contra-temple of Soknopaios and its architectural model A team from the University of Salento has been working at the Fayyum site of Dimeh es-Seba – known in antiquity as Soknopaiou Nesos – for 15 years. The most recent field seasons brought to light a remarkable object: an architectural model of the contra-temple to the main sanctuary of the god Soknopaios. Paola Davoli describes the rare find.

Top left: photogrammetry and 3D virtual reconstruction of the three sanctuaries.

Top centre: general view of the temple area looking south-west. The contra-temple is in the foreground.

Top right: virtual reconstruction of the contra-temple.

40

Soknopaiou Nesos The Soknopaiou Nesos Project of the University of Salento (Centro di Studi Papirologici), has been working in Dime esSeba in the Fayyum since 2004. The site is located north of Lake Qarun and was founded in the 3rd century BC and abandoned in the middle of the 3rd century AD. The main focus of our excavations is the temple of the god Soknopaios, in which hundreds of papyri were found at the end of the 19th century, concerning the life of the sanctuary and the rituals from the House of Life and its library. The temple

precinct is well preserved in every part and it was never properly excavated in the past.

Soknopaios was considered a universal god of fertility with cosmic and solar aspects. He was closely related to kingship and the creation of the world, with a public oracular function.

People addressed questions to him written on papyrus during the annual festivals in which the god came out of the temple in procession on a monumental dromos , a ceremonial walkway, still well preserved. The public feasts at Soknopaiou Nesos ran over more than 150 days a year, according to the papyri. In addition

to Soknopaios, several other associate gods, such as Isis Nepherses, Soknopiais, Horus, Osiris, Amun and other local gods, were worshipped in the temple.

The sanctuary consists of three buildings organized along a single axis: ST 18, a temple of Hellenistic times; ST 20, a temple built between the end of the Ptolemaic and the beginning of the Roman period; and ST 203, the contra-temple, probably built in the 1st century AD (see top images).

The contra-temple The contra-temple was the focus of the last two excavation seasons. This kind of sanctuary usually functioned as a public space where common people could approach and pray to the deity. In Dime, the building (14.66 x 12.30 m) has a somewhat unusual architectural shape, similar to a kiosk but roofed and with inside columns. It is preserved to a maximum height of 2 m, but otherwise demolished for the recovery of the limestone blocks from which it was originally constructed. The building was restored and modified probably during a phase of general renovation of the sanctuary in the 2nd century AD, recognisable by the use of harder local stones in gates and floors and also by the combination of different stones and colours in the same monument, like black basalt together with beige to red nummolitic limestone. At this time, the

contra-temple was divided into two main areas by screen walls and doors: a wide hypostyle hall (with two columns) serving as an entrance hall, and, in the inner part, three rooms delimited by four columns and further screen walls. In the central room of these a pseudo-peripteral chapel was built from local limestone and basalt blocks in an Alexandrian mixed style, with two frontal Hathoric c a p i t a l s ( i m a g e a b o v e) . I t s v i r t u a l reconstruction by M. Limoncelli has been possible thanks to the recovery of several architectural elements that sur vived the spoliation. The quality of the work done during the renovation of the building was

Above: a 3D virtual reconstruction of the pseudo-peripteral chapel, based on recovered elements.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

41

Left: a winged solar disc on a cavetto cornice.

Photo: Soknopaiou Nesos Project

Photos and plans: Soknopaiou Nesos Project

Right: the architectural model of the contratemple re-assembled.

very high as can be seen from the chapel itself and the gate in front of it, decorated with a cavetto cornice and a winged solar disk in high relief (image above top).

Two complete altars have been recovered among the filling debris, together with the lower part of a naos, the upper part of which was found in 1914 by Ahmed Kamal and which is now in the Egyptian Museum in Cairo. All the monuments are finely worked but bear no dedicatory inscriptions.

The temple model A remarkable discovery is a rare threedimensional architectural model representing the contra-temple in its original shape (image above). In total, some 50 pieces of it have been recovered so far. It is of even greater

42

archaeological value as it was found in connection with the actual building. The use of 3D architectural and votive models is wellattested in Egypt: the first known of these maquettes dates back to the Twelfth Dynasty, the reign of Amenemhat III (1860–1814 BC).

The most famous model is that of a gateway donated by Sety I (1290–1279 BC) to a nowlost temple at Heliopolis, today in the Brooklyn Museum. There are many architectural models from the Graeco-Roman period, such as single columns and capitals, so far considered models for sculptors. Most of these, however, show construction lines, mortises and tenons used to fix them to other elements, as is also the case of our contra-temple model, which is made from numerous pieces assembled from the base to the ceiling.

THE CONTRA-TEMPLE OF SOKNOPAIOS AND ITS ARCHITECTURAL MODEL

Bottom: plan of the contra-temple (left) and of its model (right).

3D reconstruction: M. Limoncelli

Below: a 3D reconstruction of the west side of the contratemple and its model.

The use of three-dimensional architectural models is also wellattested for Roman times through written sources, but few of them have been found so far: example are the Adyton of temple A in Niha (Lebanon), par t of a monumental altar of the temple of Jupiter Heliopolitan at Baalbek (Lebanon), a theatre also at Baalbek, the base of a temple found in the Collegio degli Augustali in Ostia, and a stadium found at Villa Adriana (Tivoli). It is commonly accepted that such 3D models were used not only during the building of the structure but also to present the project to the clients before its building.

The model of the Soknopaios contra-temple is in limestone and reproduces the building faithfully at a scale of 1:12. It once consisted of several parts: the base and the roof, constructed from separate pieces that were connected by white plaster, while the columns and the door jambs were held together by mortises and wooden tenons.

The screen walls were fixed with white mortar (image above top).

So far, the few fragments we have of the capitals suggest a composite type, probably with three overlapping orders of flowers.

As the contra-temple was of an unusual architectural form, the model might have served as a demonstration shown to the client before construction. On the model there are no annotations of variants or measurements, but it is clear that a change in the proposed decoration of the roof was made. At first, a series of dados were set below the cavetto corniche, but they have been cut away and covered by plaster. Only a few cubes were left on one of the corniches. After completion of building works, the model was kept inside the temple, perhaps as a votive gift.

Conclusions The lack of inscriptions means that we cannot determine to whom the contra-temple was dedicated, though the presence of Hathoric capitals in the pseudo-peripteral chapel points to Isis. Isis Nepherses was worshipped in Dime alongside Soknopaios and Soknopiais. Its architectural form and decoration make ST 203 an example of an unconventional sanctuary. For this reason, we may consider the building as further evidence in a series of architectural innovations of the Hellenistic and Roman periods that continued the Egyptian temple tradition, maintaining functions and general appearance while adding strong innovative elements.

The contra-temple maquette is unique among the architectural models as it was constructed from separate elements, of which a large number has been found; because it was realised at scale; and, last but not least, because it has been found in close connection with the building represented. The model and its contextual discovery strongly calls for a reconsideration of the function of other comparable specimens beyond the sculptor’s atelier and asks to examine the possible role of these models in Egyptian architecture and temples rituals.

• Paola Davoli is professor of Egyptology at the

University of Salento, Italy, co-director with Mario Capasso of the Soknopaiou Nesos Project and archaeological director of the Amheida Project (main sponsor: New York University Project directed by R. S. Bagnall). The Soknopaiou Nesos Project is funded by the University of Salento, the Italian Ministr y of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation, and by private sponsors. Sincere thanks are due to all these individuals and organisations, the Ministry of Antiquities, the Fayyum Inspectorate and the archaeological team.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

43

Rehousing the EES glass-plate negatives Stephanie Boonstra and Alix Robinson discuss the EES’ archive project that saw the rehousing and preservation of over 5,000 glass-plate negatives from some of the Society’s earliest excavations in Egypt.

The EES’ Lucy Gura Archive contains a vast array of materials generated from the Society’s nearly 140 years of excavating in Egypt and Sudan. Amongst this archaeological archive material are thousands of glass plate negatives from excavations at sites such as Abydos, Deir el-Bahari, Armant, Meir, Amarna, Balabish, and more. In late 2018, the Society raised over £25,000 thanks to generous donations by our supporters, which allowed a team of staff and volunteers to safely rehouse the final 5000 plates from their current home in filing cabinets into conservation grade storage boxes in order to preserve them for future generations.

The importance of the EES glass-plate negatives In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, photographic negatives were generated on glass-plates. Film technology during this period was still in its infancy and glass-plate technology provided highly detailed reproductions. Thus, the EES’ Lucy Gura Archive contains thousands of glass-plate negatives from our earliest excavations, including Naville’s 1890s excavation of Deir el-Bahari, up until the excavations at Saqqara in the 1960s.

The glass-plate negatives rehoused during the summer of 2019 are from the EES excavations predominantly at Abydos and Armant, but also a few smaller collections from Meir, Tell el-Amarna, and Balabish.

The EES at Abydos The EES has a long history of work at the vast and varied Upper Egyptian site of Abydos.

The large sub-archive of Abydos material at the EES reflects the nearly 100 year span of work at the site and includes thousands of glass-plate negatives.

Similar to many other excavations in Egypt, the EES’ work at Abydos began with Flinders

44

Petrie who first started working at the Umm el-Qaab area of Abydos in 1899. Auguste Mariette and Émile Amélineau had already identified Umm el-Qaab (meaning ‘Mother of Pots’, a reference to the vast quantities of surface potsherds) as the location of the Early Dynastic Period royal burials.

While clearing the tomb of King Djer, Petrie discovered a linen wrapped arm stowed in a niche that had survived the looting and fires that had ravaged the tomb. Petrie unwrapped the arm and took a photo of the remains, which were draped in elaborate bracelets. After giving the arm to Mariette (the head of the Museum of Egyptian Antiquities in Cairo at the time), Petrie was dismayed to learn that the arm had been discarded by the museum in favour of keeping only the bracelets (JE 35054). Therefore, this photograph (as well as a few small fragments of the resin soaked linen bandages now at the Petrie Museum, UC35716) (image p. 47) is all that remains of possibly the earliest evidence for royal ‘mummification’ in Egypt.

Petrie later moved to the ancient town site of Abydos called Kom el-Sultan. Here is where one of the most famous discoveries was made - the 7 cm tall ivory statuette of the pyramid builder Khufu, currently on display at the Egyptian Museum in Cairo (JE 36143).

Abydos has long been linked with the cult of Osiris, in fact, the tomb of Djer was considered to be the burial of the god. In 1901, Petrie first discovered a monument behind the temple of Sety I which he called the Osireon based on accounts of classical travellers, such as Strabo.

Work resumed at the Osireon in 1912 by Naville who wor ked to clear the full substructure. However, it was not fully cleared until 1925 under the direction of Henri Frankfort and Herbert Felton using a water

A glass-plate from Armant (ARM. NEG.2107) in the process of rehousing.

pump to remove the groundwater in the temple (image p. 46). The Osireon is still visible at Abydos; however, shor tly af ter the groundwater was drained from the structure, it refilled and has remained so since.

The EES at Armant The small Upper Egyptian modern town of Armant is surrounded by a wide array of archaeological monuments – this region includes the ancient city of Hermonthis, dedicated to the god Montu. The region of Armant was excavated by the EES in the 1920s and 30s.

In the spring of 1926 while excavating the Theban tomb of Ramose, Sir Robert Mond,

a B r i tish che mis t w i t h a pa ssion for Egyptology, was told about a bronze bull and inscribed stonework by his rais Moussa Abdel Maluk and Sheikh Omar at a site near Armant that was subject to looting during the First World War. Mond, excited by the prospect of finding the burial place of the Buchis bulls of Hermonthis hurried south. He was joined

by Emery for the first seasons to create a large sur vey of the region during which Emery discovered a large necropolis on the desert edge.

The team initially discovered the burials of the mothers of the Buchis bulls. The site became an EES concession in 1929 and employed Henri Frankfort and later William EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

45

Green and Oliver Myers to assist in the location and later excavation of the Bucheum, the burials of the Buchis bulls themselves.

Within the Bucheum, the team, led by Mond and Myers at this point, discovered the mummies and monumental sarcophagi of the Buchis bulls, along with offering tables and stelae dedicated to the bulls. Very little of the Bucheum is visible on the surface today and much of the ancient remains of Armant have been lost due to encroachment or have been reburied (image opposite page).

The rehousing process After raising £25,000 from generous donors and a grant from the Friends of the Petrie Museum, the glass-plate rehousing project began in June 2019.

Above: the large main chamber of the Osireion after it was cleared in 1925. The chamber includes a space for an inset sarcophagus and canopic chest symbolically to represent the burial of Osiris. Around the platform was a moat filled with groundwater and trees planted at ground level mirroring the primordial mound (AB.NEG.25.011).

Right: the beginning of the clearance of sand and rubble covering the structure on 9 January 1914 with the walls of the Sety I Temple in the background (AB. NEG.13.013b).

46

When rehousing glass-plate negatives, the two most important factors are the size of the plates, and the quantity. In the case of the EES collections in need of rehousing, the plates numbered over 5,000, and the sizes varied widely, from 80 mm2 (the same size as glass lantern slides) up to 250 x 300 mm.

Each plate was rehoused in a four-flap paper enclosure and placed in a box with plates of the same size. The boxes were padded with Plastazote to provide a protected home for the plates, and the enclosures labelled with numbers and other information. If a plate is later required for study (though most have been digitised) it can easily be found. With the use of a light-table, the plate can be viewed by merely unfolding the flaps; there is no need to remove it from its enclosure.

This all results in a time-consuming rehousing process. In order to accomplish this in a timely manner, our intern Archive Assistant Alix Robinson was hired to supervise the project, and a call sent out for volunteers, which led to the formation of two teams of volunteers, mainly composed of recent graduates in the areas of museum conservation, history and Egyptology. The project was designed to provide the volunteers with useful new skills and experience, while enabling more than

REHOUSING THE EES GLASS-PLATE NEGATIVES

5,000 negatives to be rehoused in just 18 days, spread over two three-week sessions.

To begin with, Alix received training from a professional conservator, in all aspects of rehousing, from box-building to creating the templates for the Plastazote liners, to rehousing

A thorough search of drawers and shelves of the EES Lucy Gura Archive produced some very interesting results. Perhaps the most satisfying of these was a small collection from Tell el-Amarna. Its items were numbered, but not otherwise labelled. A search of the stored scans which, as far as anyone was aware, contained digitised images of the entire EES glass-plate negative collection, revealed that these numbers corresponded to gaps in the numbering of the digital copies for the Amarna negatives. This means that these plates had never been digitised, but now can be, completing the online collection and reuniting the physical one. This was an unexpected outcome for the project, but a very fortunate one.

Impact This project has had a tremendous impact on the EES’ collections, staff and volunteers, peers of the EES, researchers and others. The funds raised allowed us to employ an archive assistant to oversee the project as well as a conservator to provide training for staff, who in turn trained seven volunteers as well as staff from the Palestine Exploration Fund and Petrie Museum.

Most importantly, the Society has now safely rehoused over 5,000 glass-plate negatives, allowing the preservation of this invaluable resource for researchers in years to come.

the plates in their enclosures. In practice, the work went more quickly than anticipated, mainly due to the enthusiasm of the volunteers.

Some plates, however, required the use of further resources for identification, including existing digital copies of the negatives, published site memoirs, and lists of plates created by long-departed EES staff and excavators.

Find the gap Although archivists have been said to love tidy rows of boxes on shelves, nothing is more exciting than finding the items which fill gaps in a list. Like early chemists searching for the elements they knew had to exist in the periodic table, archivists search the backs of cupboards and the depths of drawers, for errant bits of their collections.

Above left: Petrie can be identified as the photographer of this image thanks to his ‘Turkish slippers’, visible at the bottom of the frame (AB-II.NEG.308).

Left: the ‘arm of Djer’ found by Petrie in 1901.

Unfortunately, this photograph is all that remains of the entirety of this find (AB-RT. NEG.II.005).

Above: a monumental Buchis bull sarcophagus with an offering table and stela (ARM. NEG.0133).

• Stephanie Boonstra is the Collections Manager of the Egypt Exploration Society and the Managing Editor of the Journal of Egyptian Archaeology.

She oversaw the ‘Glass-Plate Negative Rehousing Project’. Alix Robinson worked as the intern Archive Assistant supervising the ‘Glass-Plate Negative Rehousing Project’ at the EES. She has been a long-time EES volunteer and is completing her MA on the role of archives in preserving Egyptian cultural heritage.

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY ISSUE NO 55 AUTUMN 2019

47

Egypt’s heritage is your passion

What legacy

will you leave?

We rely almost entirely on the support of people like you: interested individuals who care about the heritage of Egypt and want to see it preserved for future generations.

Contact Carl Graves to request an information pack about how you can support Egypt’s unique cultural heritage by leaving a gift in your will to the Egypt Exploration Society.

48

Tel: 020 7242 1880 Email: fundraising@ees.ac.uk

Thanks to your help, we’re able to continue our mission to support and promote Egypt’s cultural heritage. Throughout our long history, some of our greatest work was made possible by legacies.

If you choose to leave us a gift in your will, you will become part of this generous philanthropic tradition, and become part of Egypt’s history too.

THE LONG NILE CRUISE

‘THE GOLDEN AGE’ WITH DR KENT WEEKS

T TWINHREE AVAILCABINS ABLE

Exchange: Egypt and beyond Study Day, 16 November 2019

CAIRO TO ASWAN - THE JOURNEY SOUTH SS Misr exclusively chartered for AWT

DEPARTING 1st MAY 2020 This spectacular cruise is accompanied throughout by Kent Weeks, one of the most celebrated archaeologists in the world. Known for his work on the Theban Mapping Project and his re-discovery of KV5, the largest tomb ever found in the Kings’ Valley.

Our privately chartered 5-star deluxe vessel, the SS Misr was built in 1918 and was once owned by King Farouk. She boasts exquisite public rooms and the friendliest, most efficient staff on the river. Our Luxury cruiser has just 24 cabins, including 8 suites, offering the very highest standard of comfort, service, cuisine and hygiene.

Join us on this wonderful cruise leaving Cairo on 1st May, ending two weeks later in the lovely southern city of Aswan. We travel in true AWT style. There are no galabeya parties; there is no musak;

there are no quizzes; only AWT like-minded passengers enjoying the serene beauty of the River Nile.This fourteen night cruise is full board throughout and this wonderful itinerary sailing the length of the Nile will be remembered for years to come.

On our journey we will visit some of the most important sites of Ancient Egypt. We begin with the Pyramids at Giza and the mighty Sphinx and the more remote Meidum Pyramid, then continue in to Middle Egypt where we will explore the tombs of Beni Hassan, Tuna el Gebel and Ashmunein.

A full day at Amarna, the capital city of Pharaoh Akhenaten and Queen Nefertiti, including entry to the Royal Tomb.

At Abydos we can view some of the finest reliefs in Egypt within the Temple of Seti I, and at Dendera we see the beautiful astronomical ceilings recently restored to their original glory.

On to Ancient Thebes with in depth visits to the major sites in Luxor, including the Valley of the King’s, before sailing to the Ptolemaic Temple at Kom Ombo. In Aswan we make visits to the Temple of Isis at Philae, the huge Unfinished Obelisk and the Nubia Museum.

All the while sailing along the River Nile relaxing in style on our luxury cruiser. Time for birdwatching, reading, taking in a lecture or two and generally just having a wonderful time.

STANDARD TOUR PRICE: £5,450

(per person based on sharing a twin or double cabin) Cabin upgrades are available: Standard Suites & Upper Deck.

CALL NOW TO BOOK: 0333 335 9494 OR GO TO

www.ancient.co.uk

ancient world tours

The Distillery, Dunton, Norfolk NR21 7PG UK e-mail janet @ancient.co.uk

JULES VERNE AWT is an agent of Jules Verne. These Air Holiday packages are ATOL Protected by the Civil Aviation Authority. VJV’s ATOL No.11234

Egypt is often presented in isolation, as a stable and almost stagnant cultural and geographic region.

This study day considers Egypt in its wider context, as an interrelated and integral part of the Late Bronze Age Mediterranean world. Through investigating Egypt’s economy, foreign relations, and trade, our four experts will present Egypt in a different light and show that things are far more interesting when you consider the bigger picture:

•

Scarab and Seal Amulets: How one of the smallest artefacts highlights trade, exchange, and more in the second millennium BCE Stephanie Boonstra, Egypt Exploration Society

• •

The Amarna Letters: Gifts or economic exchange?

Mahmoud Ezzamel, Cardiff University

•

Egypt’s Long-distance Trade Relationships in Context at the End of the New Kingdom: Reflections on the world of the Gurob ship-cart model in light of recent Eastern Mediterranean multidisciplinary scholarship Carol Bell, British School at Athens and UCL

Goods from the Wine-Dark Sea: Eastern Mediterranean ceramic imports in Egypt during the Late Bronze Age Valentina Gasperini, British Museum

Event details Where: Brunei Lecture Theatre, SOAS, University of London, 10 Thornhaugh Street, London, WC1H 0XG. When: 16th Nov 2019, 9:30 a.m. – 7:00 p.m.

Book your ticket through our website:

www.ees.ac.uk/Event/exchange-egypt-and-beyond

Who Was Who in Egyptology

EGYPTIAN ARCHAEOLOGY

Who Was Who in Egyptology Hardcover, 538 pages, Many b/w images ISBN 978-0-85698-242-2

ISSUE 55 • AUTUMN 2019 • £5.95

Fifth Revised Edition Edited by Morris L. Bierbrier

The civilisation of ancient Egypt has been a source of fascination for explorers and scholars for centuries, and has occupied a special place in the imagination of the public ever since the early travellers’ accounts of this culture of temples, tombs and hieroglyphs began to circulate around the world.

Who Was Who in Egyptology remains one of the most important reference works for understanding the characters that contributed to the field of Egyptology and Egyptian archaeology from the 17th century through to the present day.

This fifth, revised and expanded edition brings entries up to 2019 while information and images have also been added to numerous previous entries.

New investigations on the Third Cataract in Sudan Page 4

Our books are available from Bloomsbury at www.bloomsbury.com and, in North America, from ISD at www.isdistribution.com

Space and memory: tomb reuse in New Kingdom Thebes Page 14

The ancient colours of Esna return Page 20