11.8.11 p1-17 & 20

Page 1

BASKETBALL TEAMS PREPARE FOR SEASON | Basketball Season Preview Section University of Denver student newspaper since 1899

Vol. 118, Issue 24

nov. 8, 2011

www.duclarion.com

photo illustration By ryan lumpkin

Editor-in-chief

A watchdog organization from Washington D.C. sent a letter to Chancellor Robert Coombe last Friday charging that the actions by DU administration against Arthur Gilbert, a professor in the Josef Korbel School of International Studies, have threatened free speech and academic freedom. The organization was the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), which, according to its mission, “defends and sustains individual rights” at American universities, including DU. In April, Gilbert, 75, was removed from the graduate class he was teaching, The Domestic and International Consequences of the Drug War, because of allegedly creating a “sexually harassing hostile environment” and was also banished from campus for more than 100 days. The charges arose after Korbel administration received two anonymous letters by female grad students regarding his teaching methods in the class. In an extraordinary move, the Drug War class was taken over by three professors, including the dean of Korbel, Christopher Hill. At press time, Coombe and Hill have not repsonded to the criticisms by FIRE.

According to case documents and letters obtained by the Clarion last week, the ruling in the case could change the learning environment in classrooms across the DU campus - by setting precedence for the way professors may conduct themselves in the DU classroom, what topic material they may teach to students and the way in which they teach it. There is concern that DU’s commitment to academic freedom and tenure for professors is in jeopardy. According to DU’s Faculty Personnel Guidelines Relating to Appointments, Promotion and Tenure, approved by DU’s Board of Trustees on June 8, tenure is awarded by DU to recognize “excellent performance in teaching and scholarly research and/or creative activity.” The guidelines also state one of the purposes of tenure is “to assure academic freedom in both teaching and research.” Arthur Gilbert has held tenure, and correspondingly academic freedom, for 42 years, since Josef Korbel - for whom the Josef Korbel School of International Studies is named - gave Gilbert tenure in 1969, eight years after Gilbert started teaching at DU. As it relates to classroom teachings and discussions, the 1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure by the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) stresses that

Don’t know what to buy for your grandma this holiday season? See the Clarion’s Holiday Shopping Guide for gift ideas SHOPPING | Page 18-19

professors are entitled to full freedom in research, in the publication of results and freedom in the classroom in discussing the subject. However, professors “should be careful not to introduce into their teaching controversial matter which has no relation to their subject.” It is the relevancy of Gilbert’s academic freedom to his course’s content that has DU administrators, including some in the Korbel School, concerned, and it is the relationship of the controversial matter to Gilbert’s course subject that is the heart of this case.

Under FIRE According to the letter sent by FIRE to Coombe, DU has threatened free speech and academic freedom through its “punishment and finding of sexual harassment against Professor Arthur N. Gilbert after roughly 50 years of teaching.” Six months ago, Gilbert allegedly created a “sexually harassing hostile environment” in his Drug Wars class. Allegations against Gilbert arose on April 1, when two female graduate students wrote anonymous letters about Gilbert’s conduct in the spring quarter 2011 class. During one class session early in the quarter, Gilbert brought in a vibrator to

QUOTABLE

by cory lamZ

| clarion

illustrate points he was making during the teaching unit “Drugs and Sin in American Life: From masturbation and prostitution to alcohol and drugs.” The unit was listed on the course syllabus, along with required published readings, which included two by Gilbert: “Doctor, Patient, and Onanist Diseases in the Nineteenth Century” and “Masturbation and Insanity: Henry Maudsley and the Ideology of Sexual Repression.” The previous teaching unit in the class was listed on the syllabus as “Bread of Dreams: On the relationship between food, legal drugs and illegal drugs.” Gilbert said that any student who read the syllabus had the option, ability and time period to drop the course without affecting his transcript or registration if he or she felt classroom lecture regarding food, sex, prostitution and masturbation made him or her uncomfortable. Following the allegations against Gilbert, none of the 24 students in the class withdrew, Gilbert said. The professor was only four class sessions into his syllabus when the two students submitted their letters to the Korbel administration.

SEE gilbert, PAGE 4

“There is no accurate way to look at the overall sexual health on campuses.” NEWS | Page 2

days left

47

TIL UN CHRISTMA

S


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.