Volume 50 Number 2
Menlo School, Atherton, California
Thursday, December 7, 2023
The Coat of Arms serving Menlo’s upper school since 1973
by JACOB REICH
Peyton to protect their identity, found themselves entangled in a web of temptation. It was late at night during their freshman year, and Peyton had been working on their computer science project for a week. Part of their code didn’t work. “One of the problem sets, I couldn't finish it, and so basically, I copied and pasted code from [...] online,” Peyton said. A few days later, Peyton’s CS teacher asked to meet with them. Confronted by their teacher with what they found, Peyton
It was the day before a math test. Math teacher Chrissie Walters printed out the answer key, tucked it in a folder in her desk and went to grab lunch. When she got back, the answer key was gone. Because a student — whose identity remains unknown to Walters — apparently stole the answer key, she had to rewrite the test that night. Opting not to inform her classes about the missing answer key, she sought to ensure that the potential thief would have the answer key for the wrong test. In a separate incident of academic dishonesty, a sophomore, referred to as
Staff illustration: Amber More
admitted to cheating. Because this was Peyton’s first time cheating, they were not punished. According to Upper School Assistant Director Adam Gelb, instances of academic dishonesty at Menlo increased slightly from the 2021-22 to 2022-23 school year. However, the number of cases has decreased so far in this school year. When cheating occurs at Menlo, it often takes more subtle forms than
outright theft, as recounted by Walters. “The most common thing is that in the hallway, I can hear students prattling on when they walk out of a test, telling each other what the questions were on the test and how they approached it,” Walters said. “And it’s every grade, every class and every level.” Reflecting on the consequences of such actions, English teacher Jay Bush believes plagiarism is the most severe form of cheating in his English classes. “I’ve only encountered that a couple of times since I’ve been at Menlo. And one time, it was largely a mistake; it wasn’t necessarily intentional. The unfortunate thing is that it is still plagiarism either way,” he said. The most prevalent form of cheating observed by Bush involves students consulting online summaries and analyses without providing proper citations.
Academic Integrity, pg. 3
Students Draw Up Portfolios for College by AMELIE GIOMI
Senior Lucinda Schafer didn’t want to be an astronaut, a doctor or a veterinarian as a child. She wanted to be an architect. “When I was younger, I would just sketch floor plans for fun, and I didn’t realize that could be a job,” she said. Schafer has since taken summer courses in architecture and her passion for the craft has grown. The application process for students majoring in disciplines within the arts varies, ranging from in-person auditions to submitting pictures of sculptures. Schafer chose to only apply to colleges that offer a separate architecture major. “I felt like I couldn’t see myself [at a college] without architecture being a major,” she said. Originally, Schafer only wanted to apply to universities that offer a five-year undergraduate degree in architecture known as a Bachelor of Architecture. However, these programs are typically only offered at larger universities. Schafer
What’s Inside?
is now leaning towards attending a small liberal arts college that offers an architecture major and then pursuing a Master of Architecture. “I didn’t really want to go to a big university. It was a bit of a dilemma,” Schafer said. “Now I’m leaning more towards liberal arts [colleges] and then going into grad school and getting an architecture degree.” As part of her application, Schafer is required to submit a portfolio showcasing her skills in the arts. Because colleges don’t expect students majoring in architecture to have already developed projects related to architecture, they want to see other aspects of the arts in their portfolio. “My portfolio is just another part of who I am,” Schafer said. “I’m trying to show the colleges that part of me.” Schafer said that the portfolio takes up as much time as writing a supplemental essay. Most schools have a maximum of 20 pieces and a minimum
of five that students can submit as part of their portfolio. Schafer’s portfolio mixed a variety of mediums and themes. “I pulled together art from a couple of years ago, and then this summer, where I made a bunch of 3D pieces like ceramics,” she said. “Then I also just have some that are kind of windows into my life to show the admissions officers. They might not be my strongest pieces, but they have a lot of meaning to me.” Senior Katie King does not have to submit a portfolio to every college she applies to because she is planning on majoring in either design or communication design, which is interdisciplinary. “What I’m majoring in is kind of a business-arts intersection, so it depends. For the colleges that do want a portfolio [...] they want five to 10-ish images or short videos of what you have done and then a little write-up,” she said. She noted that some colleges even want a
ARTS & LIFESTYLE
OPINIONS
Evan Arcilla Gives Cuts Above the Rest in Locker Room
For Our Sake and Your Own, Stay Off The Senior Quad
READ MORE ON PAGE 19
READ MORE ON PAGE 8
Staff illustration: Amber More
written portfolio instead of a visual one. King feels that the portfolio could bring a lot of stress to students majoring in one of the fine arts because so much of their application is based on their portfolio. “You want to give some of your most recent work, but also you want your best work. So you know, a fun little doodle isn’t going to cut it,” she said. King is submitting a range of art pieces, including sculptures, paintings and clips of her singing.
Arts in college, pg. 10
Check out The Coat of Arms website!