The Coat of Arms
Volume 44, Number 2
Menlo School, Atherton, California
Thursday, November 9, 2017
serving Menlo's upper school since 1975
Menlo releases pamphlet about grading by EVA HERR
Pamphlet contains comprehensive analysis of academics, college admissions, health and wellbeing
The title page of the recently released pamphlet regarding grades, well-being, and rigor. Image from the Menlo pamphlet.
On Oct. 5, 2017 the Menlo administration sent out a pamphlet to the school’s families and teachers regarding grading, rigor and wellness titled “Preparing Students for Success in College and Life.” The report outlines Menlo’s mission and values along with the steps that have been taken to improve the quality of life of students and the school's academics. On May 10, 2017, two Menlo parents sent out a letter to Head of School Than Healy and Upper School Director John Schafer titled “Menlo’s Grading Policy.” It compared Menlo’s GPA and SAT scores to the data of peer schools Harker,
Sacred Heart Preparatory, Choate and Castilleja. It suggested that a Menlo student would get a higher GPA at these peer schools. This letter was passed around by parents and students who were concerned by the information. While Menlo’s pamphlet does respond to many of the assertions made by the report, Schafer made it clear in an interview with The Coat of Arms that the pamphlet was part of a long-standing series of initiatives that Menlo had been working on prior to the report. “The school’s been working on balance, stress reduction, standards, grades, college admissions and appropriate expectations [...] for a long time,” Schafer said. “From our perspective, we have been working on this stuff for many years, the [content related to the letter sent by Menlo parents] is just one piece of it.” Included in the pamphlet are Menlo’s conclusions about college admission success based on an in-depth study comparing Menlo students’ GPA’s and standardized tests scores to those of neighboring schools. This study was headed by AP Statistics teacher Lauren Lax. “We asked some peer schools for their Naviance data from [the past] three years,” Schafer said. Menlo was able to create a detailed report by looking at thousands of data points rather than just a few averages, which was what the parents' letter did. “Naviance will show you GPA, SAT
scores, ACT scores, number of honors and AP classes, and the verdicts at each of these colleges, which is pretty radically different than what [the letter by Menlo parents] did, which was they looked at average by quintile at various schools,” Schafer said. With this information, the college acceptances of peer schools were also compared to Menlo’s success in admissions. According to the school’s report, Menlo students’ college acceptances are equivalent to peer schools or better. “What we concluded was Menlo students are not disadvantaged. Menlo grades are slightly lower than the peer schools we looked at, and it doesn’t seem to be detrimental to our students because we do extremely well, better than these peer schools, in a lot of these super-competitive schools' admissions,” Schafer said. The study was also a way for Menlo to evaluate the college admissions process in general. “The other thing we learned is there [is] no magic formula of GPA and SAT scores […] there is way too much noise in the data for that,” Schafer said. “We also learned that applying early decision, as an on-target student, was a much better predictor of success in college admissions than SAT scores and GPA.”
Continued on page 2
Smoke from fires in Napa and Sonoma drift South Menlo community responds to fires with bake sales and canned food drives
AHEAD Nov. 16 - Nov. 19: "Heathers" The upper school play “Heathers” opens the Weekend of the 16th. Shows on Thursday, Friday and Saturday start at 7:30 p.m. with a Sunday matinee playing at 5 p.m.
Nov. 19: Upper School Open House
Be an ambassador for Menlo on Saturday, Oct. 19 at the Open House for prospective Menlo students.
Nov. 22 - Nov. 26: Thanksgiving Break Spend time with family and friends to celebrate Thanksgiving during this five-day break.
Download the CoA App Stay updated with our CoA iPhone app. Search "Coat of Arms" on the app store today!
by CLARA GUTHRIE
Smoke from the Northern California wildfires caused poor air quality in the Atherton area, temporarily halting all outdoor student activities and triggering relief efforts among the students. On Oct. 11, students and families received a letter from school nurse Joan Barada regarding air quality. “If your student has a history of asthma or another respiratory condition, and if they have a prescription inhaler for said condition, we ask that they keep that inhaler on their person throughout the day,” Barada said in the letter. For two days following that, Dean of Students Tony Lapolla sent out one email per day keeping the student body updated on the smoke levels and asking students to stay inside as much as possible. “Please go to a classroom, Student Center, library or Dining Commons during all free times,” Lapolla requested in his Oct. 12 email. “[Menlo has] some consulting pediatricians [...] and we were using this chart that shows different air quality levels. [...] When you get to over 150 [in the air quality index], you have to start restricting activities,” Lapolla said in an interview discussing the process that the administration underwent to handle the decrease in air qual-
Photo of the Issue
The smokey haze over the 280 highway. Staff photo by Bella Scola.
ity. The air quality index measures the concentration of unhealthy substances in the air; when the index exceeds 150, it is deemed “unhealthy” for those with respiratory issues and all others, especially children. Additionally, outside sports practices and games were either canceled or rescheduled for the athletes’ health. According to varsity boys water polo coach Jack Bowen, since Oct. 9, the team had five games and two practice cancellations, including practice the day before the Sacred Heart game. “As a coach, it's always a bit unsettling going into a game without taking the time to prepare for one's opponent. I'm sure the players felt this as well. But this unique experience has been just one of many that can't be predicted and make a sport season so rich and such a journey,” Bowen said. As of Oct. 19, varsity boys water polo had not trained regularly
in two weeks. “It blatantly set us back, but every team in CCS has been set back. [...] We're all in this together, with the athletes’ safety as our primary concern,” Bowen said. Similarly, varsity girls golf had to postpone two matches until the end of the season. “[The postponements] put a lot of academic strain on our girls because all league matches have to be concluded by a certain date for them to count,” senior Sophie Siminoff said. “Our first match back after a week off definitely didn't go as well as we had hoped [...] I'm sure [canceled practices due to the air quality] played a fairly large role in everyone being semi-rusty.” The Menlo administration continues to keep a close eye on the air quality, but for now, outside athletics have resumed. “Yes, they’re getting the fires under control, yes, the wind patterns are more favorable, and there’s also
rain coming. All of those are indications that the air quality will get better,” Lapolla said. While following rules to stay inside during free times, seniors Lauren Creamer and Kathryn Wilson ran a bake sale, raising close to $200 for a Santa Rosa school district after going to Nike Tennis Camp this past summer with students from that area. “They were sending us pictures and updates of what was going on. We have a few friends whose houses actually burned down and our counselor works at a school, and half of the school burned down,” Creamer said. “As [Creamer and I] spoke to our friends [who had been evacuated], they were distraught, and one of them even compared it to being ‘like an apocalypse,’” Wilson said, noting the devastation in Santa Rosa.
Continued on page 3
After a spirit week dodgeball match the freshmen class (in green) and seniors (in gold) stormed the court to celebrate. Staff photo by Bella Scola.
News: 1-3 A&L: 4-6 Spread: 7-10 Opinions: 11-13 Sports: 14-16