Two of the most widely used elevators used in the construction industry are hydraulic and traction elevators. For this reason, in this blog, we have examined the differences between these two elevators. By reading this article, you can choose the best elevator according to your elevator needs. At the very beginning, it should be mentioned that the source of this article is the difference between hydraulic and traction elevators
Comparison of hydraulic and traction elevators
First, we want to compare hydraulic and traction elevators. Hydraulic and traction elevators have different similarities and differences. They are also superior to each other in different situations. In the following, we will compare these two elevators with different criteria.
Is the energy consumption of hydraulic or traction elevator less?
If we want to answer this question in one word, we must say that the energy consumption of the hydraulic elevator is less than the traction one. With their mechanism, hydraulic elevators consume less electricity than traction elevators with gearboxes .
Comparison of hydraulic and traction elevators in terms of cabin speed
The speed of the traction elevator is generally higher than the hydraulic elevator. Hydraulic elevators cannot move between floors, and due to security issues, their speed cannot be increased more than hydraulic elevators.
Which elevator is better to use at high altitudes?
Due to the equipment used in each of the elevators, the traction elevator is suitable for tall and medium buildings. Even traction elevators are used in towers. But hydraulic elevators are mostly used for low-rise buildings and are not suitable for tall buildings.
Comparison of hydraulic and traction elevators in terms of balance
Traction elevators are more balanced and therefore more efficient compared to hydraulic elevators due to their balance weight.
Which elevator is less noisy?
Traction elevators are usually noisy and produce annoying noises during movement. On the other hand, hydraulic elevators do not produce a lot of noise when moving and are superior to traction elevators in this regard. It should also be noted that traction elevators, unlike hydraulic elevators, vibrate at the moment of stopping and moving.
Is the capacity of traction elevator cabin more or hydraulic?
The capacity of traction elevator cabin is less than hydraulic. For this reason, hydraulic elevators are usually used to carry heavy loads.
Which one is easier to install?
Traction elevators have complex systems, and this issue makes their installation and operation a little more difficult than hydraulic elevators. You can install and operate a first-class hydraulic elevator by spending less time than the traction elevator.
Service and maintenance cost of hydraulic lift against traction
The service and maintenance of the hydraulic elevator is much less than the traction elevator. In general, the hydraulic elevator does not need to spend a lot of money for maintenance.
Motor house construction site
The place of construction of the engine room for the traction elevator is limited to the top of the shaft and you cannot choose another place to install the engine room of the elevator. However, the location of the hydraulic lift motor does not have many
restrictions, but to reduce service and maintenance costs, it is usually placed at the bottom of the well.
Does the traction lift need more space to install compared to the hydraulic lift?
Yes, we need more installation space to install the traction lift . Installing a traction elevator in a building takes up much more space. Unlike the traction elevator, the hydraulic type takes up less space for installation.
Which elevator is dirtier?
Traction elevators do not have dirty work, but hydraulic elevators, because they work with hydraulic fluid oil, may experience oil leakage, dirt and pollute the space.
The number of hydraulic lift starters is more or traction?
The start of the hydraulic lift is 90; But the traction elevator can have more than 150 starts.
The price difference between hydraulic and traction elevators
Undoubtedly, one of the most important comparisons between hydraulic and traction elevators is the price comparison between the two. The question that probably arises is whether the hydraulic lift is cheaper or the traction one? To answer this question, I must say that the hydraulic elevator is 15-25% cheaper than the traction elevator.
Which elevator is right for you?
After the complete comparisons above, the question that probably arises for you is, which elevator is more suitable for my building? This question cannot be answered definitively. Because in addition to hydraulic and traction, we also have several other types of elevators that may be a better option than traction or hydraulic elevators in certain situations.
If you could not choose the best elevator for your home with the above comparisons, or you want to consult with a reputable company to buy a suitable elevator, you can call 02188766739 so that you can make the best choice for your apartment. Technonata Company, having all the necessary licenses and quality management system certification, is definitely the best option for buying an elevator.
