Volume 7, Issue 23

Page 1

TBL bottomlineucsb.com

THE

Associated Students, UC Santa Barbara Volume 7, Issue 23 | May 15 - May 22, 2013

BOTTOM LINE

Divestment Resolution Heard Again by Senate,

Ultimately Fails 12-11-1

Violent Altercation Breaks Out in IV, Provoked By Homophobic Remarks

by MARISSA PEREZ Staff Writer Violence broke out in Isla Vista on Trigo Road Friday, April 26, following one student directing homophobic comments toward another, reminding the campus community of the importance of creating a safe climate in and around campus. Noor Aljawad, a fourth-year double major in Middle Eastern studies and feminist studies, and Clarissa Bitar, a secondyear ethnomusicology major, both witnessed the incident. Aljawad explained that the altercation began when a man she described as “white, cis-gendered, and non-queer” began directing homophobic comments and slurs towards a friend of hers, a queer man of color, and telling them to “get off of his street.” The man also made derogatory comments toward the women of the group. Aljawad, Bitar, and friends continued down the street in an effort to avoid the individual, but he pursued, persisting in shouting comments in slurs and stepping in to “get in the faces” of members of their group, said Bitar. The violence began when Photo by John Clow | The Bottom Line one of the students being provoked took a swing at the student who was making comments. Third-year Middle Eastern studies major Hani Tajsar voices his support for the resolution at the last AS Senate meeting. In the ensuing altercation, the student who threw the first on her math education. punch was knocked unconscious and the student who had made by LILY CAIN “Like I said initially, I would’ve rounded up, and it wasn’t the homophobic comments began “kicking his head repeatedly AS Beat Reporter until I felt that people were lobbying or telling me differently and started stomping on him,” said Aljawad. “I just wanted him After approximately five hours of public forum and discus- that I would think to change my decision,” said Segovia. “I’m to not kill the guy, so we called the cops.” sion the Associated Students resolution, “A Resolution to Divest sorry for anyone that this has hurt, but it would’ve needed 13 The individual who had been using slurs fled after he realfrom Companies that Profit from the Military Occupation of yesses but that’s not what happened. So I’m sorry, and it fails ized the cops had been called. When the police arrived, Bitar Palestine” failed early in the morning on Thursday, May 9, in and that is my final interpretation, and I hope that you all still said they were unresponsive to their concerns. a contentious vote that required a majority of 50 percent plus 1. can see us as students.” “I went up to him to try and tell him about the comments The resolution, authored by University of California, Prior to her final decision was an aspect of the discussion the guy was making, he didn’t even write it down, he didn’t seem Santa Barbara AS Sens. Miya Sommers and Genesis Herrera, that made it more questionable: Sen. Lauren Moissiy referenced to think it was relevant. I felt like we weren’t being taken seriwas revised twice after an early resolution of similar nature en- the 8-7 vote which removed the resolution from the agenda last ously,” said Aljawad. “We tried to tell him it was a hate crime and titled “A Resolution to Divest from Companies that Profit from week. Since that was out of 15 votes, if they had been going by a provoked attack and he started talking to the friend of the guy Apartheid” failed during the second week of spring quarter, and the same way of counting and rounding up, it would’ve required [who had been making homophobic comments] instead, he was a resolution under the same name was taken off the agenda on 9 votes (50 percent of 15 is 7.5; 7.5 rounded up is 8, plus 1 is 9), a white male talking to another white male.” Wednesday, May 1, in a vote of 8-7. but instead Segovia rounded down and thus the motion passed. Aljawad also spoke further about the issues of police reThe contentious aspect of the vote did not come from the “Seeing this [12-11-1] vote in front of me and not having sponsiveness to people of color and the queer community. way in which people were voting, but rather from which way done that [rounded up] to take it off the agenda, that was my “Whenever you talk about an emergency, what to do in this the vote leaned. There were 24 senators and proxies voting, so fault, and I realize that,” said Segovia. “I make mistakes, people kind of situation, they tell you to call the cops, but that doesn’t normally it would need 13 favoring votes to pass. make mistakes.” really take into account certain communities,” said Aljawad. However, according to AS Legal Code, abstentions are not Segovia was forced to interpret how the vote turned out “That’s not a group that keeps us safe, it’s obvious that cops counted in the total number of voters, so the vote was out of 23. because the AS Legal Code was not clear in regard to what con- prefer to protect certain communities over those like people of Fifty percent of 23, 11.5, plus one is 12.5. Because 12.5 is not a stitutes a majority in a case like that. Moissiy spoke about how color and the queer community. It just gets more complicated in whole number, and there cannot be partial votes, it was up to she disagreed with the decision based on the confusion. situations like this, just because someone being threatened threw Internal Vice President Mayra Segovia, who does not partake in “I respect the fact that legal code is sometimes up to inter- the first punch doesn’t mean it’s not a hate crime.” voting except in cases of a tie, to figure out whether to round pretation, because we’re all human and we make mistakes someRJ Thomsen, a fourth-year sociology and feminist studies 12.5 up to 13 or down to 12, and whichever she decided was the times in how we write things in not making things clear,” said double major and co-chair of Associated Students Queer Comnumber of votes in favor the resolution needed to pass. Moissiy. “Personally, I would’ve made an objection at the time, mission, voiced further concern. If she rounded up, the resolution would fail, and if she but it got kind of crazy in terms of where we were and it was “From my personal experience and from a lot of discussion rounded down, the resolution would pass. Because this was such very emotional. I don’t know if it’s still open to possibly object- with queer students at [the University of California, Santa Bara controversial vote, she felt pressured on both sides to choose in ing to the position but I just wanted to put that out there. And bara], our campus does feel like a fairly safe place...IV is comtheir favor. However, she ultimately decided to round up based see HOMOPHOBIA | page 8 see SENATE | page 8

Law suit Filed

by SHOSHANA COHEN Staff Writer

nt e d pse u a t l l S o SB yC C n o U c f l O Ba f l a i a p h e to On B d By Del e Injur

The balcony of 6643 Del Playa — senior house of Beta Theta Pi fraternity—collapsed during Deltopia on April 6, sending Stephanie Grace and three others to the hospital.

After four students were sent to the hospital when a 6643 Del Playa balcony collapsed during the Deltopia festivities on April 6, a lawsuit was filed by Stephanie Grace, a fourth-year sociology major at University of California, Santa Barbara, against Ronald Wolfe and Associates, the property manager, and the Elliott Family Trust, the owner of the building, citing the failure to properly take care of the building. Robert Clayton, part of the Los Angeles based firm Taylor and Ring, picked up her case. His firm specializes in catastrophic personal injury due to dangerous conditions on private or public property. “She was part of Deltopia, she felt some rubble fall on her head and the next thing she knew the balcony fell on her,” Clayton said. In addition to a bump on the head, Grace sustained multiple injuries, including a fractured pelvis and bruising over the entire left side of her body, and it will take a few months for the bones

UCSB Age Diversity see page 3

[

]

Photo Courtesy of | Robert R. Clayton to re-fuse, said Clayton. Since the incident, Grace has been unable to return to her job as a lifeguard. “She cannot be active and has to use her crutches,” Clayton said. “She also has to be careful while her bones are healing.” Currently, Grace has filed a lawsuit “suing the managers and owners of the property for the dangerous condition of the property itself [and] seeking money damages for injuries resulting from the dangerous condition of the property itself,” Clayton said. They are waiting for the defendants to answer their questions within in the next 30 days. Additionally, Clayton is working on a second lawsuit against the same property managers and owners. The second lawsuit was filed by a University of California, Riverside student who also sustained injuries due to the collapse of the balcony. As a result, these two cases will be consolidated. The lawsuit has yet to be resolved.

5 Questions with Avery Voos

‘The Great Gatsby’ Review

see page 3

see page 4

[

Best Coast Concert Review see page 5

]

Hana Kitchen Review see page 5


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.