Azrieli School of Architecture and Urbanism
Graduate Seminar 1: Introduction to Critical Thought in Architecture
ARCH 5200 B - Winter 2024
Prof. Dr. Greg Andonian
Urban Tapestry: Weaving Sustainability, Heritage, and Innovation into Toronto’s Architectural Narrative

Toronto Canada
Syed Muhammad Raza
101309532
Introduction to Urban Development in Toronto
Exploring Urban Development: Toronto's Architectural Evolution and Sustainability Efforts
In this presentation, I would like to investigate the urban development of Toronto, focusing on the interplay between its historical architecture and contemporary urban planning, the city's commitment to sustainability, and how these elements influence community identity and vitality. The objectives of this study are fourfold: to trace the evolution of Toronto's architectural landscape; to assess the city's sustainability efforts; to examine the social implications of urban design decisions, particularly concerning gentrification and community engagement; and to offer insights that might inform future urban planning in multicultural cities.
To achieve these goals, my methodology encompasses a comprehensive literature review, drawing on existing research, historical documentation, and theoretical discourse related to urban design and sustainability, with particular emphasis on works by Jane Jacobs and John Ruskin, among others. I further employ case studies of significant Toronto projects like the CityPlace development and the Alexandra Park Revitalization, analyzing them through a critical lens to understand the practical application of urban design principles. Additionally, we engage in theoretical framework analysis, applying and questioning urbanist theories within the context of Toronto's development. Comparative analysis with other global cities serves to place Toronto's experiences within a wider urban design narrative, highlighting unique challenges and achievements.
This multi-disciplinary approach aims to present a nuanced view of Toronto's urban landscape, identifying key challenges and proposing thoughtful considerations for its future development, thereby contributing to the broader discourse on urban design and planning.


Slide 2:
The Historical Context
From Aboriginal Grounds to Multicultural Metropolis
Toronto's history transitions from its roots as an Aboriginal hunting and fishing ground, through the French and British colonial periods, that ended in its establishment as the city of York by Lieutenant Governor Simcoe. Initially named Fort Rouillé during the French era, the area became a significant site for the fur trade. Following the British conquest, the strategic location was renamed York, later evolving into the multicultural metropolis known today as Toronto. This journey from Tkaronto, a name reflecting its natural setting, to Toronto showcases a dynamic history of transformation, embodying a rich tapestry of cultural and historical influences shaping its identity and development.
Toronto's evolution from a humble gathering place of Indigenous peoples into a bustling, multicultural metropolis is deeply intertwined with its geographical setting, particularly its waterfront. Mike Filey (1998) in 'Discover & Explore Toronto’s Waterfront: A Walker’s, Jogger’s, Cyclist’s, Boater’s Guide to Toronto’s Lakeside Sites and History' documents the pivotal role the waterfront played in the city's early development. Initially prized for its natural resources and strategic location, this area served as a critical hub for trade, transportation, and military defense during the French and British colonial periods. Filey's work sheds light on how the waterfront's transformation over centuries has mirrored and facilitated Toronto's growth, from a small French trading post to its establishment as York under the British, and eventually, into the diverse and thriving city known today as Toronto. Understanding this historical backdrop is crucial for appreciating the complex layers of culture, economy, and architecture that define Toronto's identity, highlighting the waterfront as a geographical feature and a foundational element in the city's ongoing narrative of transformation and resilience.
1

Toronto Map in 1800s

Toronto 1908 Map
Toronto's urban fabric is a testament to its remarkable evolution from historical roots into a bustling global metropolis. The architectural landscape, marked by iconic skyscrapers like the CN Tower and enriched by historic structures, mirrors the city's rich cultural tapestry. This blend is further enhanced by green spaces and mixed-use neighborhoods, embodying Michael Noble’s insights on the role of creativity in city building.2
These elements underscore Toronto's dedication to inclusivity, sustainability, and cultural expression within its urban design, aligning with Jane Jacobs' principles on urban vitality and the importance of vibrant communities. Together, they foster a sense of belonging and illustrate the city's commitment to innovative strategies that address the diverse needs of its residents. This approach not only solidifies Toronto’s status as a dynamic, multicultural hub but also showcases how the integration of historical and contemporary elements contribute to the city’s unique urban fabric.
Deepening Critique of Jane Jacobs:
Jane Jacobs famously championed the value of 'eyes on the street,' mixed-use development, and the organic evolution of city districts, principles she outlined in 'The Death and Life of Great American Cities.' When we apply Jacobs' vision to Toronto, we see a city that largely embraces these ideals, especially in neighborhoods like Kensington Market and the Distillery District. These areas thrive on their mixed-use character, vibrant street life, and community engagement, embodying Jacobs' vision of urban vitality.
However, the challenge in Toronto arises in balancing these principles with the pressures of modern urban development. The city's intense condo development, particularly along the waterfront, raises questions about the sustainability of Jacobs' ideals in the face of vertical living and the potential for 'tower isolation.' While Jacobs critiqued the urban renewal projects of her time for destroying community fabrics, Toronto faces a contemporary dilemma: how to sustain community engagement and mixed-use vitality in the shadow of skyscrapers. This presents an opportunity to question how Jacobs' principles can be adapted or expanded to ensure they remain relevant in the context of high-density urban growth.


Toronto's dedication to sustainability manifests in its investment in green infrastructure, expansive public transportation system, and pioneering smart city projects, all aimed at marrying ecological responsibility with urban practicality. Initiatives such as green roofs and an extensive public transit network serve not only to boost biodiversity and curtail the urban heat island effect but also to facilitate efficient movement across the city and purify the air, thereby elevating the quality of urban life. Moreover, the city's integration of smart technologies and affordable housing showcases a comprehensive urban planning strategy
that equally values environmental guardianship and social inclusivity. A prime illustration of this commitment is the Toronto Region Sustainability Program (TRSP), which fosters small and medium-sized enterprises' engagement in pollution prevention practices. Highlighted in the Journal of Cleaner Production, the TRSP has successfully driven significant environmental impact reductions, showcasing how Toronto's economic and environmental goals can align seamlessly.


The Role of
Identity
Toronto’s architectural heritage preservation is deeply informed by the principles of John Ruskin, emphasizing the intrinsic value of historical buildings in maintaining the city’s cultural identity and urban landscape. Ruskin advocated for the preservation of architectural beauty, truth, and the historical significance of structures, underscoring the importance of maintaining a tangible connection to the past . In line with these principles, efforts in Toronto to preserve its architectural heritage, from Victorian-era buildings to modernist landmarks, illustrate a commitment to Ruskin’s ideals. Michael Seaman and George Duncan’s research supports this approach, highlighting the significance of local heritage matters in sustaining the urban fabric . Their findings suggest that preserving Toronto's architectural heritage is not merely about maintaining aesthetics but also about fostering a sense of community and continuity. By leveraging Ruskin’s theoretical framework alongside practical insights from Seaman and Duncan, Toronto's preservation initiatives demonstrate a harmonious blend of respecting historical integrity while embracing the city’s dynamic growth, thus bridging the theoretical and practical aspects of heritage preservation.
An exemplary instance of this commitment is the restoration of the Shoppers Drug Mart at the corner of Yonge and Charles, Toronto, housed in the Robert Barron Building from 1889. This project notably preserved two original facades while integrating modern elements, showcasing Toronto's dedication to maintaining its cultural identity through architectural heritage. Such efforts align with Ruskin’s principles, demonstrating the city’s endeavor to uphold historical significance and beauty while fostering urban continuity amidst dynamic
growth. The use of sustainable materials in the restoration further reflects a modern approach to preserving the past, mixing the historical with the contemporary in Toronto’s urban landscape.

Toronto's commitment to architectural preservation is epitomized by the story of 46 Spadina Avenue. Designated under Part IV, Section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act, this Edwardian Classical-style building, constructed in 1907 by Horwood and Burke, showcases the city's dedication to retaining its historical fabric amidst urban development. Once home to Business Systems Limited, it now stands as a testament to Toronto's rich industrial past within the King-Spadina neighborhood, a district known for its significant contribution to the city's fashion industry. This example highlights the importance of John Ruskin’s principles in contemporary urban planning, advocating for the intrinsic value of preserving historical buildings to maintain Toronto's cultural identity and urban landscape. By preserving such landmarks, Toronto demonstrates a harmonious blend of respect for historical integrity and dynamic growth, embodying Ruskin's ideals of architectural beauty, truth, and the historical significance of structures.
7 8
My Argument for Protecting Spadina Avenue's Heritage
In my observation and investigation, the preservation of heritage buildings along Spadina Avenue is crucial for maintaining the rich tapestry of Toronto’s history and culture. These structures not only embody the architectural beauty of past eras but also serve as tangible links to the diverse stories of those who have shaped the city. Safeguarding these landmarks from demolition or unsympathetic reconstruction ensures that future generations can access, appreciate, and learn from these historical narratives, fostering a deeper connection to the city’s shared heritage.




To analyze how Toronto's architectural heritage and contemporary developments contribute to its identity and urban landscape, and to explore Toronto's approach to sustainability, inclusivity, and innovation in urban design.
Slide 6:
Heritage and Development: Balancing Act
Heritage and Development: Crafting Toronto's Future Urban Landscapeancing Act
Toronto's architectural narrative is a testament to the delicate balance between preserving its rich heritage and embracing contemporary development, exemplifying the city's evolution from its historical roots to its status as a global metropolis. This interplay between the old and the new not only defines Toronto's unique identity but also reflects the enduring principles outlined in John Ruskin's “The Seven Lamps of Architecture.” Ruskin's advocacy for the integration of beauty, truth, and memory in architecture finds a modern embodiment in projects like CityPlace, which marries innovative urban planning with respect for community and livability. Similarly, the Toronto Urban Design Awards highlight projects that embody Ruskin's principles, recognizing developments that harmonize architectural innovation with environmental and historical stewardship.


Art Gallery of Ontario

Slide 7:
Ruskin vs. Jacobs in Modern Toronto
A Modern Dialogue in Toronto's Cityscape
John Ruskin, in 'The Seven Lamps of Architecture,' advocated for truth to materials, respect for the past, and the moral purpose of architecture. Toronto's architectural heritage, including the preservation efforts for Old City Hall and the adaptive reuse of Victorianera buildings, reflects Ruskin's emphasis on historical integrity and the aesthetic value of architecture.
Yet, the application of Ruskin's principles in a rapidly evolving cityscape like Toronto invites a refined critique. The development of contemporary structures such as the TorontoDominion Centre or the OCAD University building presents a closeness to Ruskin's ideals, emphasizing modernity, innovation, and sometimes, a departure from historical styles. This closeness raises questions about the balance between innovation and preservation, and the role of modern architecture in contributing to or detracting from the city's historical narrative. It prompts us to consider how Ruskin's principles can be interpreted or adapted in planning future developments to honor Toronto's rich architectural legacy while accommodating modern needs and expressions.
Old City Hall, Toronto Royal Ontario Museum

Deepening Critique of John Ruskin


For instance, the intricate designs of Old City Hall and Casa Loma symbolize Ruskin's Lamp of Sacrifice, showcasing a commitment to craftsmanship and historical values. The transparency and structural honesty in the design of the Art Gallery of Ontario (AGO) and the Royal Ontario Museum (ROM) echo the Lamp of Truth, revealing the authentic use of materials in a manner Ruskin would admire. The CN Tower, as a symbol of strength and innovation, represents the Lamp of Power, standing as a marvel of engineering and a beacon of the city’s ambition.
Moreover, the Lamp of Life is glowingly represented in the adaptive reuse of historical buildings and the vibrant street life around areas like the St. Lawrence Market, where the past and present merge to create dynamic urban spaces. The Distillery District and the University of Toronto's buildings, especially the pharmaceutical building, where form, function, and decoration harmonize to showcase architectural beauty show the Lamp of Beauty by John Ruskin. The preservation of landmarks such as Fort York and St. James Cathedral underlines the Lamp of Memory, ensuring that Toronto's architectural heritage remains a living testament to the city’s history. Finally, the coexistence of skyscrapers with historic architecture demonstrates the Lamp of Obedience, adhering to a vision of urban planning that respects architectural diversity and the city's historical narrative.
9
Through these examples, Toronto’s architectural development and urban design initiatives showcase a profound respect for Ruskin's visionary principles, demonstrating how the city successfully navigates the complexities of honoring its past while fostering an inclusive, sustainable future. This approach not only maintains Toronto's distinct character but also prepares it for a vibrant future, where heritage and innovation coexist to enrich the urban environment.
(Ruskin 1849)
Toronto's urban development strategy, exemplified by projects like the Alexandra Park Revitalization and the accolades from the 2023 Toronto Urban Design Awards, demonstrates a balanced appreciation for its architectural heritage and a vision for future growth. These initiatives highlight the city’s commitment to fostering community involvement and sustainable development, thus preserving Toronto’s historical essence while embracing modern urban needs. Such endeavors not only enrich the city’s diverse urban identity but also underscore the importance of creating inclusive spaces that reflect its rich history alongside contemporary innovations.


Mitigating
Through Urban Design Toronto's Approach to Inclusivity and Diversity
The city's focus on mixed-use developments and the revitalization of public spaces play a crucial role in mitigating the adverse effects of gentrification and promoting social inclusion and diversity. By integrating both market and affordable housing while prioritizing the preservation of community fabric, Toronto showcases a model for urban planning that values social interaction and accessibility. This approach, supported by evidence from Takahashi and Hawkins, illustrates how strategic urban design and development can enhance community building and placemaking, making Toronto a metropolis that champions inclusivity and connectivity among its residents.


Slide 10:
Case Studies of Toronto's Urban Design
Toronto's Urban Design and Architectural Heritage
Toronto's urban landscape is a testament to its rich architectural heritage intertwined with modern developments, embodying a commitment to sustainability, inclusivity, and resilience. This fusion not only defines the city’s identity but also underscores its aspiration to be an environmentally conscious metropolis that prioritizes social cohesion. Mohamad Kashef’s comparative analysis sheds light on the broader challenges faced in urban design, emphasizing the necessity of integrating diverse architectural elements while maintaining a focus on community welfare and environmental sustainability. This approach aligns with Jane Jacobs' critiques, which argue for urban development that emphasizes the importance of vibrant public spaces and cultural institutions as pillars of community life and social interaction.
11

11:
Creating Inclusive Public Spaces

Old City Hall
Cultivating Community Spirit: Toronto's Inclusive Public Spaces
Toronto's dedication to creating inclusive public spaces—from the historic Hanlan's Point to the bustling Nathan Phillips Square and the culturally rich Distillery District— exemplifies its commitment to fostering a community spirit that celebrates heritage and diversity. These areas are not merely recreational spots but are central to Toronto's social fabric, offering spaces for cultural exchange and civic engagement that enhance the city’s livability. Jacobs’ vision of cities that thrive on the diversity of their public spaces and the active participation of their communities is evident in Toronto’s efforts to balance tradition with modernity. Through thoughtful urban planning that prioritizes accessible, engaging public areas, Toronto continues to demonstrate its commitment to building a dynamic, inclusive cityscape that reflects its unique character and meets the evolving needs of its residents.


Toronto's architectural diversity and its approach to urban design. Some elements contribute to the city's sense of place and community vitality
Slide 12.
The Essence of Toronto's Urban Identity Architectural Diversity and Community Vitality
Toronto's urban identity thrives on architectural diversity, blending historic and modern elements to foster community vitality. The commitment to heritage preservation alongside innovation is evident in its dynamic public spaces and cultural venues, enhancing social engagement and cohesion. Notable areas like High Park and the revitalized Alexandra Park, along with accolades from the Toronto Urban Design Awards, highlight the city's pursuit of inclusive and vibrant environments.
Critical Issues
The city’s urban development combines heritage preservation with modernization through strategic planning, evolving from a colonial outpost into a diverse metropolis. Policies like the Official Plan have guided this growth, balancing residential, commercial, and industrial needs. Key projects like the Toronto waterfront revitalization and CityPlace development embody the city's embrace of high-density living and public amenities, reflecting a commitment to sustainable growth, inclusivity, and architectural diversity amidst challenges like housing affordability.


Slide 13
Addressing Urban Growth Challenges
Urban Growth and Its Implications for Toronto
Toronto's urban growth has sparked challenges in affordability, sustainability, and heritage preservation. Rising housing prices challenge inclusivity, pushing diverse populations out of affordable living spaces. Development pressures also threaten Toronto's architectural identity and environmental goals, necessitating innovative planning to balance modernization with conservation.
To address these issues, urban planning must integrate green spaces, sustainable infrastructure, and heritage protection. This approach ensures Toronto's development respects its rich history and environmental duties, maintaining a city that values both its past and its sustainable future.
Aerial View, Toronto CityToronto's development challenges include housing affordability, sustainability, and preserving cultural heritage. Rising housing costs and development pressure threaten Toronto's social cohesion and environmental goals. Effective policies are needed to balance growth with inclusivity, environmental care, and heritage conservation, ensuring Toronto's dynamic diversity and historical richness remain intact.
In my exploration of Toronto's urban development, I critically engage with the theories of Jane Jacobs and John Ruskin, examining their relevance and application to the city's unique landscape.

Slide 14:
Jacobs' Influence and Urban Challenges Urban Challenges and Adaptations in Toronto
Jacobs champions the idea of cities as ecosystems that thrive on diversity and spontaneous interactions. We see both alignments and deviations when we juxtapose this with Toronto’s mixed-use developments and vibrant public spaces. For instance, the revitalization of the Distillery District aligns with Jacobs’ vision by fostering community interaction and preserving historical character. However, Toronto’s ongoing challenges with gentrification, particularly in neighborhoods like Little Portugal, highlight areas where the city’s development diverges from Jacobs' ideals of inclusivity and accessibility.
Similarly, John Ruskin’s emphasis on the moral and aesthetic responsibilities of architecture invites us to reflect on Toronto's approach to preserving its architectural heritage amidst modernization. While projects like the restoration of Old City Hall embody Ruskin’s principles of 'Truth' and 'Beauty,' the proliferation of glass skyscrapers raises questions about the 'Sacrifice' and 'Life' Ruskin deemed essential for meaningful architecture.
The East Harbour project serves as a contemporary example that aligns with Jacobs’ vision for vibrant, mixed-use urban spaces. This development, which is set to employ around 50,000 people across 60 acres, reflects Toronto’s ambition to foster a dynamic, inclusive urban ecosystem. It showcases efforts to balance modernization with the preservation of urban character, addressing the city’s need for new employment hubs amid growing population pressures. While East Harbour underscores progress towards a thriving urban environment, it also raises questions about inclusivity and accessibility, linking back to the challenges and ideals discussed in the context of the Distillery District and Little Portugal. This project illustrates Toronto’s ongoing negotiation between economic vitality, urban diversity, and architectural heritage, engaging with both Jacobs’ and Ruskin’s visions.


Harbour:
15
Personal Position and Recommendations - Criticism

Personal Insights and Recommendations for Toronto towards a sustainable future
My investigation into Toronto’s urban fabric underscores the necessity of a balanced approach that honors the city’s rich history while embracing the challenges of modern urban living. Based on my analysis, I propose the following recommendations to guide Toronto's future urban development:
Enhanced Community Engagement: Prioritize grassroots participation in the planning process to ensure developments reflect the diverse needs and values of Toronto's communities, aligning with Jacobs' advocacy for vibrant, inclusive urban spaces.
Sustainable and Aesthetic Urban Design: Encourage architectural projects that not only meet environmental sustainability criteria but also embody Ruskin’s ideals of beauty and moral responsibility, fostering a cityscape that is both functional and inspiring.
Strategic Heritage Preservation: Implement policies that protect and integrate Toronto's architectural heritage within new developments, ensuring that the city's history is preserved as a living part of its urban landscape, thus enriching its cultural vitality.
Addressing Gentrification: Develop and enforce inclusive zoning laws and affordable housing initiatives to combat the displacement effects of gentrification, ensuring that all Torontonians can benefit from the city's growth and prosperity.
Under Construction Proposed Design Grange park East Canada’s Largest Commercial Project SlideBy embracing these recommendations, Toronto can navigate its future development challenges by fostering an urban environment that is sustainable, inclusive, and reflective of its unique identity. This vision for Toronto not only aligns with the theoretical insights of Jacobs and Ruskin but also addresses the critical issues identified through this investigation, proposing a path forward that values both heritage and progress.
Incorporating Biophilic Design for Health and Well-being: Adopt biophilic design principles, such as Visual Connection with Nature and Material Connection with Nature, to create environments that reduce stress, improve health, and enhance the quality of urban life. These principles advocate for natural elements and materials in urban spaces, promoting a deeper connection between residents and their environment.
Fostering Connections with Natural Systems: Encourage the integration of Natural Systems within urban planning to create dynamic spaces that respond to seasonal changes and support biodiversity. This approach aligns with creating sustainable urban ecosystems that contribute to residents' physical and psychological well-being.
In conclusion, my investigation into Toronto's urban landscape reaffirms the indispensable value of heritage preservation in maintaining the city's unique cultural identity and ensuring a vibrant, inclusive future. To this end, I strongly advocate for a citywide commitment to safeguarding all heritage buildings. These structures are not merely remnants of the past; they are living embodiments of our shared history, offering invaluable insights into architectural innovation, community development, and cultural diversity. Their preservation should be a cornerstone of Toronto's urban planning policies, ensuring that every building with historical significance is recognized, protected, and seamlessly integrated into the fabric of our evolving city. This approach aligns with Ruskin's and Jacobs' visions, emphasizing that a city's soul lies in its ability to honor its past while boldly stepping into the future. By championing the preservation of all heritage buildings, Toronto can continue to be a beacon of cultural heritage conservation, showcasing to the world a model of urban development that respects its roots while embracing progress and sustainability.

White, James T., and John Punter. 2023. Condoland: The Planning, Design, and Development of Toronto’s CityPlace. UBC Press.
Kashef, Mohamad. “Architects and Planners Approaches to Urban Form and Design in the Toronto Region: A Comparative Analysis.” Geoforum 39, no. 1 (2008): 414–437.
“The Toronto Region Sustainability Program: Insights on the Adoption of Pollution Prevention Practices by Small to Medium-sized Manufacturers in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA).” Journal of Cleaner Production 14 (6–7): 572–79. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2005.07.008.
Ruskin, John. 1849. “The Seven Lamps of Architecture.” Bulletin of the American Art Union 2 (6): 11. https://doi. org/10.2307/20646641.
Seaman, Michael, and George Duncan. 2023. Local heritage matters. Municipal World 133, (2) (02): 7-9, https:// proxy.library.carleton.ca/login?qurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.proquest.com%2Ftrade-journals%2Flocal-heritage-matters%2Fdocview%2F2922844620%2Fse-2%3Faccountid%3D9894 (accessed March 7, 2024).
“Toronto Community Housing.” 2021. Toronto Community Housing. August 17, 2021. https://www.torontohousing.ca/news-and-updates/torontos-alexandra-park-community-revitalization-wins-urban-land-institute-global.
“Toronto Urban Design Awards 2023 Recognizes Two Years of Citybuilding | UrbanToronto.” n.d. https://urbantoronto.ca/news/2023/09/toronto-urban-design-awards-2023-recognizes-two-years-citybuilding.53841.
Noble, Michael. 2009. Lovely Spaces in Unknown Places: Creative City Building in Toronto’s Inner Suburbs.
Filey, Mike. 1998. Discover & Explore Toronto’s Waterfront: A Walker’s, Jogger’s, Cyclist’s, Boater’s Guide to Toronto’s Lakeside Sites and History. Dundurn.
Takahashi, Koki. 2016. “Toronto’s Little Portugal: Gentrification and Social Relations Among Local Entrepreneurs.”
Urban Geography 38 (4): 578–605.
https://doi.org/10.1080/02723638.2016.1176695.
Hawkins, Jason, Usman Ahmed, Matthew J. Roorda, and Khandker Nurul Habib. 2022. “Measuring the Process of Urban Gentrification: A Composite Measure of the Gentrification Process in Toronto.”
Cities 126 (July): 103708.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2022.103708.
Jacobs, Jane. 2015. “The Death and Life of Great American Cities.” In John Wiley & Sons, Ltd eBooks, 94–109. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119084679.ch4.
City of Toronto. “46 Spadina Avenue - Notice of Intention to Designate a Property under Part IV Section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act.” December 20, 2022.
Webadmin. 2018. “Spadina Heritage.” The Grange Community Association (GCA). November 15, 2018. https:// www.grangecommunity.ca/en/spadina-heritage/.
“East Harbour | UrbanToronto.” n.d. https://urbantoronto.ca/database/projects/east-harbour.6817.
“14 Patterns of biophilic design.” 2014. September 12, 2014. https://www.terrapinbrightgreen.com/reports/14-patterns/.