It’s tourney time
On stage
Student group to debut play on campus this week
MSU has close ties to Volleyball head coach Cathy George MAC foe Ohio
Graduate student Aggie Marchel and telecommunications sophomore Colin Rahn
Julia Nagy/The State News
statenews.com | 12/5/13 | @thesnews
Khoa Nguyen/The State News
features, PAGE 5
sports, page 6
Michigan State University’s independent voice
stars aligned Total Big Ten NFL Draft picks by year, ‘07-‘12
Using unheralded recruits, Dantonio, MSU achieve stellar results
Michigan State Recruiting Class Nat’l Ranking, ‘07-‘12 (Including season records: WIN-LOSE)
Michigan State
#17
Michigan
6-7
Penn State
finances
Students on lookout for scam with rent deals By Geoff Preston
Minnesota Iowa
#30 11-2
KEY
Indiana
gpreston@statenews.com THE STATE NEWS
#31
11-3
nn
2007
Purdue
2008
Wisconson
#42 7-6
2009
Nebraska Illinois
2010
Northwestern
2011
Ohio State
2012
MSU Recruit Ratings (in ‘stars’)
Big Ten Average Season Records, ‘07-‘12
#41 9-3
Average Big Ten Recruiting Class Ranking, ‘07-‘12
W
L
1 10
8.5
4.5
Michigan
7.16
5.5
Penn State
9.16
3.67
Minnesota
4.33
8.17
Michigan State
7.5
5.16
Indiana
4
8.16
Iowa
2007
7
12
3
X
2008
7
13
1
X
30
2009
3
10
10
X
40
2010
4
12
4
1
Purdue
5.67
6.83
Wisconson
9.33
4
Nebraska
8.83
4.5
5.5
7
2011
2
17
2
X
7.67 10.33
5.17 2.5
2012
1
14
3
X
Illinois Northwestern Ohio State
7-6
#47
20
50 60 70 80 Infogr aphic by paige grennan | sn
By Stephen Brooks sbrooks@statenews.com THE STATE NEWS nn
L
es Brown is credited with coining the phrase “Shoot for the moon. Even if you miss, you’ll land among the stars.” For college football coaching staffs coast to coast, landing stars — as many as possible — is the lifeblood of the business. Not star players per se, although that’s the ultimate goal, but rather players with the most five-sided shapes attached to their online recruiting profile. More stars means better players. Better players means more wins. More wins means more money and job security for said coaches. With the advent and evolution of national recruiting analysis services such as Rivals. com, Scout.com and ESPN’s Recruiting Nation
in the past decade, any potential prospect worth a Division 1 coach’s time is promptly listed, evaluated and assigned a “star rating” from one to five based on skill. A five-star-rating represents the most elite high school athletes. It seems simple enough in theory, right? In reality, hundreds of players get undervalued, ignored and shut out in the cold of the increasingly chaotic recruiting world every season. In some cases, the oversight is as simple as a player’s inability to attend the right camp, not living in the right region of the country or, most puzzling, not receiving ample attention from rival schools. During his seven seasons in East Lansing, head coach Mark Dantonio and his staff have demonstrated a unique ability to not only identify, but develop, so-called diamonds in the rough. The ascent of the Spartan program absolutely has been aided by infusions of topshelf talent throughout Dantonio’s tenure,
but being geographically triangulated by traditional powers Ohio State, Michigan and Notre Dame can leave the already-slim offerings in the Midwest even slimmer for MSU. Ironically, this dynamic has proven beneficial to both parties. For the most part, MSU has to work harder than the bluebloods, but the overlooked players they uncover tend to be hungrier, more driven and determined to prove themselves after receiving middling recruiting interest. These players arrive on campus with a point to prove — that the stars lied. Sophomore defensive end Shilique Calhoun and senior cornerback Darqueze Dennard were honored this week by the Big Ten as the top players at their positions. Add their ratings together as high school recruits and you’ve got one five-star player. Combining the profiles of current NFL players Kirk Cousins and See RECRUITS on page 2 u
men’s basketball Head coach Tom Izzo kneels by injured senior guard Keith Appling during the game against North Carolina on Wednesday at Breslin Center. Khoa Nguyen/The State News
NO. 1 SPARTANS FALL TO UNC AFTER SLOW START
By Matt Sheehan
msheehan@statenews.com THE STATE NEWS nn
The No. 1 men’s basketball team walked onto the court in kryptonite-colored socks for their highly-anticipated Big Ten/ACC Challenge matchup against North Carolina. However, t he Superman of college hoops walked off the court with their first loss of the season to UNC, 79-65.
The Spartans never led during a game that showcased some of MSU’s most troubling tendencies on the season thus far. The game started just as poorly as it possibly could have for MSU and had the packed Breslin Center in a restless frenzy almost immediately. Junior forward Alex Gauna, who got the start in place of ill sophomore forward Matt Costello, started the game by committing two fouls and a
turnover within the first 90 seconds. MSU went on to turn the ball over eight times, four of which came in the first five minutes, and allowing UNC to grab 10 offensive rebounds on the half. Senior guard Keith Appling silenced the crowd when he went down with an unspecified injury in the first half, but later checked back in. He fin-
See GAME on page 2 u
Khoa Nguyen/The State News
Senior forward Adreian Payne dunks the ball during the game against North Carolina on Wednesday at Breslin Center.
Alyssa Berger thought she finally had solved her housing dilemma by finding a subleaser online for her offcampus house for spring and summer 2014. Instead, she now is $2,200 poorer than she was last week. Berger, a graduate student, was a victim of a scheme that could be costing several MSU students thousands of dollars. A scammer using the alias “Wendy Woodgate” who claims to be from Guam, has been responding to posts about subleasing on allMSU. com. The scammer’s identity remains unknown. If a student responded to the scammer’s initial contact, the scammer would send the first month’s rent and a deposit, as well as an additional $2,000, an amount the scammer said they accidentally overpaid. The additional amount varied for some students, including Berger. Berger received a check for $2,950. Berger said she was instructed to use a prepaid card called Green Dot Moneypak to pay $2,200 to the unnamed financier of the check. Berger sent the numbers of the card through email to the scammer. “There were many times I should have realized what was going on,” she said. “I pictured an international student with no place to live.” The problem arose when the check sent to Berger for $2,950 bounced because it was a fraudulent check. The $2,200 — the amount Berger agreed to send back — already was sent to the scammer through the cards, and Berger was out of luck. “The biggest thing to do is sit back and analyze everything,” she said. “I know I’m not getting my money back, but I want to spread awareness about this and help catch whoever did it.” When The State News tried to contact the scammer with the phone number given, the Gainesville, Fla. area code number would redirect to a number with a 248 area code. The person who answered the phone said the scammer was using his number erroneously and said he’d received numerous calls from students hoping to reach Wendy, but declined to comment further. Berger since has filed two police reports: one with the East Lansing Police Department and one with the police department in her hometown of Huron, Ohio. East Lansing police Capt. Jeff Murphy said he personally was not aware of this incident, but said such fraud scams are not uncommon. “All it takes is someone who is convincing,” he said. “This kind of thing happens a lot, not just here.” Some students were lucky to back out of the agreement before they got involved too deeply. Elementary education senior Kiersten Kelly said the typos in the original message tipped her off. "(The scammer) used many errors in her writing,” Kelly said. ”She always demanded that I respond to her emails quickly. It got to the point where it got rather annoying.”
See SCAM on page 2 u