URBANISM PORTFOLIO Selected works SRIVARDHAN RAJALINGAM
srivardhan.rajalingam@gmail.com
am architect and urbanist by qualification and practice with more than 4 years of experience working in India.
Resolving urban issues through a sustainable approach excites me and I wish to work on developing realistic and holistic plans of action to make lasting, impactful changes in our urban environments. A firm believer in the importance of a people-centric approach adhering to the fact that cities are for the people and a holistic impact can be achieved only with holistic participation. As well as starting with small changes for bigger impact.
This portfolio is a compilation of selected works from my journey so far, exploring the opportunities to make our cities sustainable and inclusive.
srivardhan.rajalingam@gmail.com
The cover is a representation of how our cities are turning grey day by day, straining the natural environment and resulting in irreversible changes. Such changes move people and break the connection. These lost connections have ruined the sense of belonging. Dialogue, protesting and small efforts to restore the balance are piecemeal approaches. believe in the need for a multidimensional framework leading towards action and impact on the ground. I seek an opportunity to be a part of the a journey to make our cities equitable and livable.
Note: All graphics/ Pictures are sole work of the author unless mentioned otherwise
3 2 | Urbanism Portfolio 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 Where is my water ? Region City Neighbourhood Block Building Street URBAN COURTYARD Theme: Water Sensitive Urban Design 07 CITIES FOR PLAY Theme: Child friendly cities 03 LAKE REJUVENATION Theme Public space IMPLEMENTATION OF NON MOTORISED TRANSPORT STRATEGY Theme: Sustainable mobility ACCESSIBLE QUARTER Theme: Public space 04 05 06 ACADEMIC WORK PROFESSIONAL WORK Where is my right to access Why do cars have all the space ? How to balance people & nature How to balance people & profit How to plan for people and not cars CONTENTS A | Urban Strategy & Urban Design B | Other related projects STRATEGY FOR COUNCIL HOUSING REDEVELOPMENT Theme: Housing NEO – “CAMBRIDGE PHENOMENON”
Housing 01 02
Theme:
Gamification Participatory planning Assessment Publications
Where are the children in the city?
Part A Urban Strategy & Urban Design
5 4 | Urbanism
Portfolio
STRATEGY FOR COUNCIL HOUSING REDEVELOPMENT
London | Interdisciplinary team of 6 - Academic research (October 2022 to February 2023)
Church Street Ward
Church Street Ward (CSW) is a dynamic, multicultural, and complex neighborhood in North Westminster located between Edgware Road and Lisson Grove. The community of CSW, however, struggles with social and economic marginalization despite the strong feeling of community and the success of the Church Street Market.
The prevailing poor health, low education qualifications, the poor quality of built environment, high unemployment rates and inadequate access to public realm contribute to poor on the Indices of Multiple Deprivation (IMD).
Site characteristics
1. Affordability
Historically, CSW has been a site with high poverty levels, with Charles Booth’s map revealing inequalities since the 1880s. At least 20.76% of the population are benefit claimants compared to 4.40% in Westminster.
The need for affordability is currently catered by the existing businesses offering products at low costs.
Image: Market traders selling affordable products
CSW in larger context
Most deprived ward in Westminster and among the top 10% most deprived wards in the UK.
The most densely populated ward in London.
Most diverse with atleast 65% non white ethinic population
Project components/ Contribution Research, Mapping, Documentation, strategic planning, Conceptual design, public consultation strategy
Role: Researcher
Softwares used: GIS, AutoCAD, Sketchup, Revit, Photoshop, Illustrator, Indesign
The aim of this research work is to analyse Westminster City Council’s current redevelopment proposition to ameliorate the issues faced in Church Street Ward, especially that adequate housing is not fulfilling the community’s local needs. We have identified a conflict between the current proposal and the existing urban values including a possible destruction of the “village feeling” and the familiarity between local people and the site, and the unbalanced power play involved in such process. We propose an alternative strategy based on our analysis of the prevailing tensions using a mix-method approach including oral history, photography, interviews, mapping, data analysis and literature studies that advocate against concentrating primarily on largescale, high-risk solutions and increase in housing supply. The proposed startegy is routed in the prioritization of justice, gradual improvements of existing infrastructures, incremental changes and respecting the existing building environment.
2. Purality
The diversity manifests in form variety in
• Language
• Cuisines
• Products
Image: Council library name displayed in 3 languages
3. Familiarity
A strong feeling of sense of belonging that existed in the past continous to exist till date. This is reflected in the customer service provided the businesses and frequenting customers.
Doctors in church street remembered the whole family and asked how each of them were each time we visited the doctor
Church street was the highs of our childhood .A very friendly place to grow up where everyone seemed to know everyone else
7 6 | Urbanism Portfolio
Map of Westminster with CSW
Lorem ipsum dolor si
4. Accessibility and convenience
CSW, despite being well connected with the other parts of London by public transport, is geographically bounded by Regents Canal on the North, Edgware Road on the West, Marylebone station on the East and Marylebone flyover on the south. These physical barriers along with the prevailing psychological barriers have led to a sense of disconnection from the immediate neighbourhoods (Architects et al., 2021). However, with multiple places of live, work, and “third place” located within an 8-minute walking radius (figure 2.5), it is accessible and allows everyday activity within a walkable distance. “Third spaces” a term coined by Ray Oldenburg, refers to the place where people spend most of their time
Map of CSW with everyday activity areas
outside the first (live) and second place (work) (Oldenburg, 1991). The main public-owned “third places” in CSW that attract high footfall are the market, library, and neighbourhood centre that serve as hubs for various everyday activities of the community. Apart from being accessible, it provides a barrier-free physical environment and opportunities to shop, eat, and play along the commute making it convenient even for those in need of assisted mobility. With a sense of slowness in mobility due to a higher elderly population and those in need of assisted mobility, the aspects of walkability and convenience complement the demographic needs.
Proposed redevelopments
CSW was first identified for housing redevelopment in 2010 and the first detailed plan for CSW was prepared as a part of the “Future Plans” made in 2012 followed by the “Church Street Neighbourhood Redevelopment Plan 2017” which is currently in progress. The master plan aims to address the existing issues with respect to housing, heating and ventilation, toilet and kitchen malfunction, lack of options for different types of units and improve the wellbeing by refurbishing existing
public realm and create new spaces . In the current context of ongoing housing crisis and WCC recognising the key role of housing, it aims to provide “more homes of all types are at the heart of our ambition to create a City for All” . CSW with several council estates provides the opportunities to address the housing crisis, because more than 70% of the area in Westminster is marked as conservation area. The architects involved in regeneration identify the rate of high deprivation,
unemployment and percentage of people with no qualification, poor wellbeing scores and the existing social and economic exclusion due to physical and physiological barriers as their case for change.
Map of proposed regeneration projects and current condition as of 2022
Ward boundary Housing estates proposed for redevelopment as per the proposed master plan 2017 Public spaces identified for redevelopment Currently considered for redevelopment (our focus area) Current condition Completed
9 8 | Urbanism Portfolio 400metre/8 minute walkingradius Live Work/ Learn Third place Walk Walk Ward boundary Places of live / work Most used third place(s) Manufacturing & production Attractions Eating & Dining Transport Retail Education & Health Sports LEGEND Edgwareroad Marylebone road MaryleboneRS RegentsCanal Marylebone flyover Church street market Neighborhood centre Library N 0 25 50 100m Green spine Broadley street garden Churchstreet
Walk
N 0 25 50 100m LEGEND
Occupied Edgwareroad Maryleboneroad MaryleboneRS RegentsCanal Marylebone flyover Churchstreet/Market Site C Site B Site A
Vacated (by residents)
Proposed view (Image source: WCC/ Bell Phillip Architects) Existing condition
Shortcomings of the current model:
Though the council aims to address the issues pertaining to the condition of the buildings, access to open spaces the proposed redevelopment with high rise buildings has been opposed by the community for abandoning the human scale, compromised daylight in public realm and reduction in floor area of the library. The community in an open letter to the WCC dated 27th August 2021 have expressed their concerns:
“We are deeply worried that your current proposals will result in the market being completely overwhelmed and that the existing village atmosphere that we all love so much, will be totally lost by overpoweringly tall buildings looming over the street. We strongly oppose the abandonment of the human scale to over tall buildings and do not believe a busy open-air public space and market can flourish if turned into an oppressively bordered corridor robbed of sunlight”.
We find that the oppositions raised by the community are not “not in my backyard” claims but are rooted in CSW’s context. The identified gaps are discussed here
1. Housing:
The current model proposes to increase the density of the densest ward using a complete demolition and rebuild approach. In our opinion this model could lead to the following consequences:
Conceptual illustration of the existing and proposed building heights
• The proposed high-rise units apart from altering the character of the neighbourhood represent an increase in the maintenance costs. With neither the longer-term maintenance costs disclosed nor the assurance of retaining the existing aspect of affordability post redevelopment, it could end up being unaffordable for residents and businesses to return despite the council offering the “Right to Return”. High rise buildings (more than 10 floors) have been problematic and not affordable to leaseholders and social housing tenants in various instances.
• While the diversity manifests in the site with variety in language, cuisines, products, and authenticity, it has also created an additional pressure on the healthcare systems due to the lifestyle, age, and language variations of the site. The increase in density could further strain the health care needs which is already scarce on site
• With the change of funding eligibility of Affordable Housing Program, where “funding will not be available for units that replace homes that have been, or will be, demolished” could mean no GLA funding for the current model resulting in increased dependency on a private developer
• Increased ultility costs due to reduced sunlight.
2. Community assets:
Community relations, public space and other resources based on shared values and trust, also known as community assets, effectively promote cooperation and connection among community members and it is also essentially the backbone of the community. In addition to providing reading spaces, the library also provides functions such as an IT centre, workshop on skills trainings and an information exchange centre. Reducing the floor area, as the proposal suggests, does not align with the community’s needs. The library being a multi-use space and an active part of the community’s everyday activities, could need further expansion, both spatially and functionally to cater to the current and future necessities.
The market acts as an artery of the community connecting the Library, Triangle Plaza, and resident housing. The existing market consists mainly of a main street with shops and stalls; however, the market traders seemed unaware of the redevelopment timeline or the proposed plans and their future remains uncertain.
3. The process:
The council faces high risk due to the uncertainty of the development of the project that has been going on for more than 12 years and is expected to be completed in 2035. This uncertainty has impacted the resident’s confidence in the council and in the redevelopment program. Though the current regeneration doesn’t directly displace the community and its diverse characteristics, we argue that prolonged
uncertainty, the unaffordability expected post redevelopment and the lack of addressing basic needs, could lead to potential displacement.
The proposed redevelopment directly addresses only two out of seven categories in the Indices of Multiple Deprivation (IMD) - “Barriers to housing” and “Living environments”, while these are relatively higher than the London and Westminster average, CSW stands relatively low on Health, Crime, Income, Employment and Education (ONS, 2021) which in our opinion are also the pressing needs but have not been addressed.
The process of public consultation including the ballot system, setting up of a local regeneration base (office), involving external associates and various other methods to address the regeneration issues suggests a “Degree of Tokenism” on Arnstein’s “ladder of citizen participation” and reflects a weak democracy model.
For example, the opposition from the community regarding the survey bias was evident with members pointing out the consultation outcomes would have been different if the question was “do you have any objection for 12 storey buildings in CSW” instead of voting a “yes or no” for redevelopment. Apart from the possibility of bias the resident turnout for ballot has also been comparatively low suggesting multiple voices goes missing in the current process.
Proposed phasing and timeline (Originally proposed in 2017 was later revised in 2022)
Participation across ballots
11 10 Urbanism Portfolio Church street Library Site B Existing building heights and human scale Church street Church street Site C Site B Site A Library North South transect along site B North South transect along site A & C Existing heights Proposed heights
2026 2027 2020 2035 2032 Site C Site B Site A Delay
2023
2022 56% Participated 44% Did not participate 2013 25.5% Participated 74.5% Did not participate 2019 25.5% Participated 74.5% Did not participate Site A,B and C Site A Site A,B and C Site A Site B Site C
Repair & Maintenance approach (Proposed model)
To value, maintain and repair the current systems and infrastructure rather than merely concentrating on developing brand-new, cutting-edge ones.
Improve housing without displacement
Repair and Maintenance as a Social, Political and Economic model to
The principles of the proposed approach
Starting from breakdown
By giving permission for things not to work immediately, we can learn to appreciate the value of negative spaces and the people who inhabit them.
People over profit
Our approach focuses on the needs and well-being of communities and individuals rather than solely on maximizing financial gain.
Prioritizing collective goods
This approach recognizes that the well-being of a community is dependent on the overall functioning of its infrastructure and resources, and aims to maintain and improve them in a sustainable and collaborative manner.
Phasing strategy
Reinforce collective assets
Foster active citizen participation
Incremental change
Spaces and infrastructure are continually being created and used in certain ways and sees habitation as a process that is constantly changing.
Low risk
Focus on small, gradual changes and improvements to existing systems, infrastructure, and structures, rather than attempting to completely overhaul or replace them.
Multiple, small but quick and meaningful solutions to incrementally address all the needs
1. Housing
The proposal addresses key issues such as overhauling the services (electrics, plumbing, heating, and ventilation) and refurbishing communal areas (stairs and other facilities). We propose adding new lifts and balcony circulation to make all flats accessible. External insulation and installing renewable energy resources will make buildings more energy efficient. Roof extensions to existing buildings accommodate more housing options with different layouts.
A community participation process is necessary to understand what types of units are required, but for proposal, we have considered one- to six-bedroom typologies (excluding 2-bedroom as the most common for existing units) per the London Housing Design Guide’s area requirements for dwelling space.
Key map showing opportunity areas
Demonstration
Existing
Manifestation of the proposed model LEGEND
Network of actors and funding opportunities GLA
Ward
Westminster City Council
Sale of 50% of new units (roof extension) at GLA market price
Central Government
Office of Gas and Electricity Markets (OFGEM)
Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy
Roof extensions to accommodate more housing options. Refurbishment of all existing homes and shops and the addition of lifts with balcony circulation. Community
Energy Efficiency funds
13 12 Urbanism Portfolio
LEGEND
Developer Consultants Local Champions
Private Public Funding
Social Housing Decarbonisation Fund (SHDF) Energy Company Obligation (ECO4) - Eco energy grant
Church
and Shop Owners Other Community Stakeholders
Affordable Homes Programme 2021-2026
Street
Neighborhood Forum Church Street Residents Market Traders
Existing homes in site B & C - 255 New homes through this method in B & C - 102 (+ 40%) Proposed
Subject matter experts
The community assets play an important role in enhancing the enhance local identity and promote social cohesion. However, majority of the spaces are unused or under utilised. The proposal aims to implement physical and socio-economic interventions for areas. Additionally even the most used places such as the market and the library require optimisation and refurbishment
3. Active citizen participation
To ensure there is respect, fairness, and transparency in identifying and addressing the needs we introduce the concept of “Local Champions” (LC) as the first step to ensure no voices are left behind and to establish collective needs with a balance between the market goods (wealth, income, property) and non-market goods (rights, opportunities, power, self-respect, culture and decision making). This idea is rooted in empowering and enabling the community to participate in the process of identifying and addressing their needs. It could be used across different sectors such as built environment, overall welfare, and health & wellbeing, employment, and education.
XWhat?
A paid engagement of a set of independent individuals who will help in identifying the community needs and formulate the requirements to the council.
XWho?
1. Individuals belonging to CSW (live and work) from all the different groups across ethnicity, age, gender.
2. Could be commissioned by Church Street Ward Neighbourhood Forum, Ward councillor or the council and in instances of major redevelopment even by research institutions.
Painting :To make the floor interactive and renew the interest in sporting & other activities
Cost: £
3. Trained by subject matter experts
4. Funding - National Co-ordinating Centre for Public Engagement is one example that provides funding grants for research
institutions with public engagement. Such grants could provide the remuneration for the time spent by the local champions and those involved in training the LC.
Where?
The existing meeting spaces in the library or underused spaces like the courtyards (with minimum changes to its current condition) could provide the space for training the local champions and hosting larger engagements with the community.
When?
The LC could be commissioned at various stages to identify and address the needs of the community from conceptualisation to implementation and evaluation. It could be multiple short-term engagements or continued engagements based on the need and funding availability.
The above requirement of resources (human, finances, space, and time) suggests most of the input and activities are performed by the stakeholders with low influence, but high interests and we believe this could strengthen the community participation for various needs including preparation of neighbourhood plans. We recognise this might not result in a 100% participation or 100% consensus to start with but would improve the understanding of the diverse needs, facilitate an informed decision making and establish a partnership in addressing the needs.
Replacing the opaque roof with transparent roof to allow more daylight
Cost: £ £
Research Institutions / Think-tanks – For instance: LSE Cities and organisations such as ASH, and National Co-ordinating Centre for Public Engagement. Could be facilitated by agencies such as Involve
Linking the basement 1 of the existing library and MUGA with a transparent roof would improve lighting as well as serve as an extention of the library with space for additional activities
Cost: £ £ £
The proposed model has placed local needs as a priority, using justice as an evaluation principle to identify the limitations in the current plan. This report has identified how repair and maintenance model of thinking helps to strengthen the notion of respecting the cultural politics of the site and the necessity to make incremental changes.
This alternative model for urban regeneration to stand against the current framework under neoliberalism, using the case of the Church Street Ward could also be replicated in other housing estates across London.
15 14 Urbanism Portfolio 2. Community
XXLibrary Multi Use Gaming Area (MUGA) Unused Not well lit by daylight Not well lit by daylight
Assests
Temporary Semi permanent Permanent
space for skill trainings Existing Proposed activities Proposed transformation Type of intervention
No
Neighborhood centre Library Green spine Broadley street garden
of CSW’s community assets and their existing condition
boundary
upgraded
used but requires refurbishment
optimization
under utilised N 0 25 50 100m Medical camps Skills training Fitness sessions Sports coaching Shared workspace Council Other agencies involved in redevelopment Expert Agencies Church Street Community And local champions Formulated Need Need Training / guidance subject expertise Developer Funding opportunities Funding Community Infrastructure Levy Section 106 Central Government Department of education Art Council England GLA Idea store strategy Library funding scheme Public Private LEGEND
Churchstreet Market
Map
Ward
Recent
Most
Requires
Currently
Demonstration using library & MUGA
“CAMBRIDGE PHENOMENON”
Cambridge, England | Individual - Academic (February - March 2023)
About Cambridge
The Greater Cambridge (GC) area consists of Cambridge and South Cambridgeshire District (SCD) which have a population of 124,000 and 150,000 approx. respectively and is part of Cambridgeshire County. The historic 13th-century university town is north of London and in the southern part of England. The global significance of Cambridge is powered by the knowledge economy which consists of the worldrenowned University of Cambridge, other institutions, and various companies leading research and innovation in life science and science & technology. The explosion of companies engaging with life science, and technology since the 1960s was termed the “Cambridge Phenomenon”
Increasing car-dependency in Cambridgeshire:
by Peta Levi in a Financial Times article in 1980. Apart from the significant achievements in both the university and the industry, the economic success of this growth has also gained global recognition. Cambridge also remains committed to growth despite the introduction of the localism act in 2010. Located 60 miles or a 45-minute ride away from London by train, it is also “one corner of an economic golden triangle from Oxford in the west to London in the south”. On the other side, it is also grappled with issues of raising inequalities, congestion, and lack of affordable housing
Project components/ Contribution Research, Mapping, strategic planning
Role: Researcher
Softwares used: GIS, Illustrator, Indesign
While multiple cities in developed countries, especially those driven by the knowledge economy are beginning to see a decline in automobile dependency and Cambridge stands as an anomaly.
The increased dependency on cars has led to congestion and this possess a threat to the future growth of the knowledge economy in Cambridge. Though private automobiles are often associated with freedom it has negative impacts on the environment, and “resource-hungry cars” also lead to patterns of inequality. The project aims to elucidate the potential factors that contribute towards an increasing automobile dependency in Greater Cambridge and to recommend a development strategy that could potentially discourage automobile dependence but also allow equal access spatially. .
Census 2011 vs 2021 Mode split of commuting; Source: Cambridgeshire County Council
Atleast two third of for commuters rely on private vehicles across Cambridgeshire except for Cambridge (41%) and there is also an increase of 3-4% throughout Cambridgeshire between 2011 and 2021, while similar economies around the world have been witnessing a decline Though private vehicle includes motorcycles and vans, the proportion of motorcycles to cars and vans was 1:37 in Cambridge and 1:61 in South Cambridge as per the 2011 census. Hence a significant share of private vehicles is cars and vans. Although the number of commuters traveling might have reduced, the proportion of private vehicles in most districts in Cambridgeshire is still higher national average (73%) and public transport use across districts is lower than the national average (12%) In the same period, the trip distance to work has also increased. Overall, there has been an increase in the number
of commuters traveling more than 5kms to work between 2011 & 2021. At least one-third of commuters in Cambridge and two third of the rest of Cambridgeshire County travel to work beyond 5kms. Despite 68% of the trips to work in Cambridge occurring within a 5 km distance, which is walkable as per an “average daily travel time budget of around one hour” and with the entire city within a radius of 3.5 – 4 km, within an hour ride by bus, 41% commute to work by private vehicle. Hence, with an increase in the number of trips by private vehicles and increased distance travelled to work, Cambridge differs from other cities that continue to be dominated by cars due to a lack of alternatives but showed at least “a decline in Vehicular Kilometres Travelled (VKT) and Total Automobile Travel (TAT)”.
17 16 | Urbanism Portfolio
–
NEO
Factors contributing towards car dependence in Greater Cambridge:
Apart from the low density and issues with public transport that are contributing to car dependence, mentioned below are two other significant factors in Cambridge’s case
1. Impact of the developments occurring through the “Cambridge Phenomenon”:
Cambridge was a good example of “regulative planning” showcasing the character of southern England with the significant developments restricted to the urban core without any major dispersions beyond the green belt for much of the post-war period. It was only in the 1970s, due to the pressure exerted by the universities for its interests to create employment opportunities by setting up high-tech businesses, and other businesses related to the university’s knowledge production, the growth of major employment areas started occurring in SCD, which was until then predominantly a rural district & small market town. There were tight restrictions on other economic and housing developments till the late 1990s and the green belt was largely untouched. Though the “Cambridge Phenomenon” has had positive benefits, it has also causally led to certain negative impacts such as Cambridge being the most unequal city in the UK (Donna Ferguson, 2018) unaffordable housing costs, housing supply not meeting the demand created due to increase in jobs and congestion issues. Though housing and inequalities are complex issues on their own there are implications for transportation as well.
“An increasing proportion of university staff live out of Cambridge, partly due to the lack of affordable housing close to their work, resulting in more journeys to work by car. In 2018, 56% of staff responding to the annual travel survey lived outside the city, and 51% of these travelled by single occupancy car to work, compared to only 6% of the staff who live in the city”.
This indicates that people working in the city might be forced to live outside due lack of affordable housing options and such commuters travel to work in a single occupancy car at least 8.5 times higher than those opting to travel by car living inside the city. This is also reflected in Car ownership, Cambridge has 0.9 per household while SCD has 1.55 per household. Data suggests that two third of the work trips to Cambridge are by people staying in SCD (23%), Huntingdonshire District (HD), and East Cambridgeshire District ECD, while only 40% of people are working in workplaces located within Cambridge stayed inside the city.
While many of the institutions are located within the city, the other major employment areas are distributed across the Greater Cambridge area and are not limited to the Central Business District or the city. This is a major deviation in planning since the businesses boom in the 1970s. Half of the people working in SCD commute from Cambridge, HD, and ECD.
Hence the increasing housing costs in the city and dispersed developments of major employment areas could be contributing to the heavy inflow-outflow patterns. Due to the lack of suitable alternate options, there is an increase in VKT, and this has resulted in congestion around the major employment areas
The planning for car dependency could be seen spatially through Right of Way configurations, grade separators, parking, etc. Catering to the existing demand for automobile infrastructure, Cambridge continues to make provision for parking lots at every individual site and neighbourhood/ city level through the provision of Park & Ride.
• City level
The 5 major Park & Ride facilities are located along the periphery near the major employment areas. Occupying a total area of 49 acres cumulatively it caters to 5653 cars. In addition to the existing facilities, Greater Cambridge Partnership (GCP) is also proposing to add another 10,000 parking spaces. This shows how with the increasing number of cars, the cities are shaped and reshaped for high automobile use, this continues to encourage automobile use further.
• Individual sites
The 152-acre Cambridge Science Park (CSP) employing 7250 people has a building footprint of approx. area of 30 acres and an equal parking footprint. While the cars take away almost one-fifth of the space, there is not a single residential unit within the site. To encourage the use of electric cars, provisions for charging were made in 2021. However, this doesn’t discourage the use of private cars. The proposed phase 2 of CSP expected to create 3000 jobs, also does not include provision for homes within the site. CSP demonstrates a case of how developments as a part of the Cambridge Phenomenon are dependent on cars and encourages car use by providing car-friendly infrastructure. A similar pattern can be observed in most of the major employment areas.
• Local Plan
The local plan for GC encourages shifting to alternate modes and other measures such as car clubs. But it also recognizes parking as a necessary amenity and mandates the provision of parking as part of business developments in new and existing sites.
Category SCD Cambridge
Inside controlled parking zone Outside controlled parking zone 1 space per Business < 2500 sq.m 100 sq. m Gross Floor Area plus disabled car parking
40 sq. m Gross Floor Area plus disabled car parking > 2500 sq.m
The variation could be due to public transport accessibility, or located at a walkable or bikeable distance from the city centre, etc. However, these indicative figures are permissible, and this is a provision that could encourage car use. High levels of parking encourage car usage and provisions in Central Business District (CBD) is one of the major factors that “determine the modal split for trips”. There has been a decline in parking supply across the world between 10-19% / 1000 jobs. This has resulted in encouraging public transport use to the CBD even during off-peak times. But for it to improve further there is a need for parking to be reduced in sub-centres as well. Thus, the provision of parking is another factor that encourages car dependency.
19 18 | Urbanism Portfolio
2. The provision of car-friendly infrastructure in developments occurring through the “Cambridge Phenomenon”
Map showing the major employment areas and congestion zones
Map showing the vehicular inflow & outflow patterns
Hence, unaffordable housing within the city pushing people out, indicating the lack of opportunities to live near work and infrastructural provisions for cars in suburbs also contribute to an increased car dependence apart from issues with public transport, lower density, culture, lack of provisions for active mobility and “hitting the traffic wall”
Proposed development strategy:
People centric Car centric
Infill & Roof extension
Phasing out parking
The idea is to discourage car use within the existing infrastructure and create opportunities to live, work, and other everyday needs within a distance that is comfortably accessible through active mobility (under 5 km) through re purposing the existing car-friendly infrastructure in individual sites.
Manifestation of the strategy in Science Park’s case
152 acre
30 acre
Total parking footprint
The area considered for homes is only parking lots and doesn’t include any green spaces. *This number is conceptual based on available area and what has been achieved in similar sites in other cities.
The proposed strategy could complement the current proposals of GCP and allow equitable spatial access by reducing the impacts of the proposed congestion pricing. Replicating this in all the possible site could increase the opportunities to live closer to work and ultimately reduce the need to commute. It could be guided with a vision of minimum of 1 home for every 2 jobs within site for large developments and within 400m radius for small developments
By permitting roof extension and infill with housing in all existing major employment sites without any mandates for car parking provisions except for essential use.
Phasing out existing parking in major employment areas except for essential uses such as blue badge holders and loading/ unloading activities by 2030 and restricting parking on new developments catering only to the essential users.
PThe GCP currently proposes to improve active mobility infrastructure, and public transportation systems, and introduce a policy fix in the form of congestion pricing. Though road pricing has been successful in reducing car dependency to a certain extent, it may “not be the first best instrument for tackling the congestion externality although it may be the first best standards more closely than any other instrument” It could further widen the gaps of inequality. The proposed strategy doesn’t dismiss the need for road pricing but aims to focus on how to reduce the impact arising from a utilitarian idea. Although the problem of car dependency is complex and interconnected at a city level, there is the opportunity for major employment areas to address this through a spatial fix at every site level.
21 20 Urbanism Portfolio
Total site area Existing homes 0 Jobs provided 7000 Homes
strategy
as per proposed
3825*
Site plan of Cambridge Science Park
CITIES FOR PLAY
Chennai, India | Professional work (January 2020 - August 2022)
Client: Residents of Kannagi Nagar, Greater Chennai Corporation, Tamil Nadu Urban Habitat Development Board
Project components/ Contribution Research, Mapping, Documentation, Visioning, Master planning, Conceptual design, detailed design, Stakeholder Engagement Plan, Detailed Project Report (DPR), estimate
Role: Project Architect
Softwares used: AutoCAD, Sketchup, Photoshop, Illustrator, Indesign, MS Excel
CITIES FOR PLAY is a vision rooted in the realization that very little has been done in the public realm to fulfill the needs of children in our cities.
Children typically spend 16 hours or more in a day in their homes and community settings. Effecting change in the public realm through play not only contributes positively to their cognitive and motor skills and eventually their overall holistic development but also encourages ownership and responsibility towards maintaining our public realm. CITIES FOR PLAY is an initiative that places children as catalysts for reimagining our urban commons. Investing in children today for a better tomorrow.
Play
The spaces & routes that are required to be safe and accessible for a child to be able to access them independently as a part of his/her daily routine
Pockets with garbage dump
Places under the flyover
Street
Unused parking spaces
Corridors in between buildings
Unprogrammed open spaces
23 22 Urbanism Portfolio
“
is not a luxury, Play is a necessity.
- Kay Redfield Jaminon
Bus stop School School Convenience store Parking lot Park Play ground Learn Play Live Gated community Low income housing (High density) Apartments (High Density) Residence A child’s city
a typical day in the life of a child
Mapping
Opportunity areas within the city’s existing fabric
Residue
Reimaging the child city’s in a transect
Scalability
25 24 | Urbanism Portfolio
Places of live Places of live / learn / play
Learning based play pockets filled with garbage
Active fitness corridors abandoned corridors
Foot ball practice underutilised open spaces
Fun based play street residue
2 1 400m around places of live / learn / play Entire neighborhood 3 4
Child friendly streets unsafe streets
Adventure based play abandoned spaces under flyover
Basket ball arena abandoned open spaces
Playground with fitness unprogrammed open spaces
Methodology
Neighbourhood context
Generalconsiderations
Design
Holistic development of a child
Fine motor skills
The ability to make movements using hands and wrists. Eg: Throwing & catching activities, Hand eye coordination
Gross motor skills
The ability to do tasks involving the whole body movement - large muscles, legs & arms. Eg: Walking activities, Balancing activities
The ability to do something difficult for a long time
Kannagi Nagar is one of Chennai’s earliest and largest resettlement colonies. It is actually comprised of 3 resettlement sites - Kannagi Nagar, Ezhil Nagar and Tsunami housingimplemented in a phased manner since the early 2000s. Most of the people living in the tenements are slum dwellers who were rehabilitated between 2000 and 2010 by the state government. Following the 2004 tsunami, fishermen who were living along the coast in different parts of the city were also moved here. As a result, Kannagi Nagar has come to house people who were previous inhabitants of several different parts of Chennai. Residents of the neighbourhood face several civic issues and social issues on a daily basis for nearly two decades now owing to deficits in the physical and social infrastructure. Growing up in such an environment, children of Kannagi Nagar end up becoming the most vulnerable demographic.
While several indicators of development are found lacking in Kannagi Nagar, the Cities for Play initiative seeks to address the aspect of child development as a way to bring about social sustainability to the neighbourhood and reimagines Kannagi Nagar as Chennai’s first Sports District
Site for intervention
Suitable sites for the pilot intervention were identified after a detailed mapping of all the open spaces in the neighbourhood. In addition to the two designated Children Play Space pockets, the chosen site also has a school, a park and a proposed sports ground suitable for the entire Cities for Play concept to be demonstrated here.
Kannagi Nagar
Map of Chennai with Kannagi Nagar and localities from where they were relocated
Religious places Amma Unavagam Shop
Ration shop Market
Nursery school Schools Parks
Map of Kannagi Nagar
Two
27 26 | Urbanism Portfolio
Strength
gym equipments
Endurance Skating Calisthenics Basketball Mound Outdoor
principles
functionality of space Using locally available skills/ expertise for construction Lighter Quicker Cost effective approach Using recyclable materials Using locally available materials Juxtaposition of play spaces for different age groups to encourage cross-learning Tactical & Sensory based play Sports based play Fun based play Imagination based play Fitness based play Adventure based play
of play
Multi
Types
played and interests in the locality Design Principles Types of play Requirements for holistic development of a child
site condition Existing usage of site Sitespecific cond i t o n s Project brief
Sports
Existing
Population 125,000+ Total area 114 acres
Kannagi Nagar
N
Corporation Park Towards Police station Towards Bus terminus Children Play Space - 1 Children Play Space - 2 Sports Ground School N 0 25 50m Map of demonstration area based on a child’s usage Learn Play Live
land Amenities
Vacant
storey tenements
Tsunami
Unit size 250 - 400 sq.ft Number of households 24,057 Typology Low income settlements
Three storey tenements Four storey tenements
rehabilitation tenements
Site specific analysis
Football
Badminton Silambam Basket ball Karate
Proposed design intervention
STRENGTH PAIN TOLERANCE
Tennis Volleyball
Learning Silambam has helped me gain confidence in general and also improve my performance in school.
Kho - Kho
Marathon Kabaddi
Analysis on currently played sports and interests on a sports matrix
Swimming 100m sprint Cycling
5.7 m wide road A
Skating
Currently played in site
Currently played in Kannagi Nagar
Played in site and accommodated in design
Played in Kannagi Nagar and accommodated in design
Currently not played but accommodated in design
View of the Silambam / Karate / Kabaddi zone & outdoor gym*
+/- 0 mm +/- 0 mm
C
CPS 1 - Proposed Layout
D Key plan (Not to scale) SDAT ground
layout of CPS1
+100 mm
B Building number 11661 11714
3 5
CPS 2 CPS 1
Outdoor Gym Equipment (compacted red soil) A - Arm and Shoulder Wheel B - Double Cross Walker C Twister and Leg Trainer D - Arm and Leg Strengthener All dimensions as per GCC playfield SOR SDAT sports ground 5.7 m wide road
LUNG POWER TECHNIQUE Cricket Boxing CITIES FOR PLAY (Pilot project) Basket ball court - 30m X 17m (Cement flooring with paint finish)
Building number 12417 - 12470
+100
+100 mm +100 mm
TowardsPolicestation Legend: Existing
2 Proposed Fencing (chain link) 17m X 5m & 30m X 5m 6 Proposed Storm water drain 55m length X 0.69m wide Proposed Fencing (chain link) 17m length X 5m height 2 Proposed
5 Fitness Corridor - 46.20m X 1.2m (Cement flooring with paint finish) Fitness Corridor - 46.20 m X 1.2m (Cement flooring with paint finish) Silambam/ Karate/ Kabbadi Zone (compacted red soil) 15.70m X 19m
View of the basketball court & fitness corridor*
29 28 | Urbanism Portfolio
Currently not played but not accommodated in design Table Tennis
Proposed
I am a state-level basketball player and my days are incomplete without 4 hours of practice everyday. got a job last year through sports quota.
* Graphic made collaboratively
This place was only used by men for drinking but today it is beyond my imagination, with people of different ages using the space. We feel safe walking here.
Layout of the multipurpose baskectball court (30m X 17m)
The basketball court is painted with simple floor patterns that are supplementary to playing basket ball and other floor based fun activities that makes it vibrant and engages different user groups at different times. 14 activities have been incorporated as a part of the design
Painting concept
Drawing a parallel to the ground situation where people of Kannagi nagar need new opportunities to thrive, the painting is an abstraction of the ball coming out of the ring.
31 30 Urbanism Portfolio K ANNA G I NAGA R K ANNA G I AGAN R 10xLUNGES 10xSQUAT JUMPING JACKS 10x PUSHUPS 10x JUMP 0 1 2 3 4 5 (10) Kids basket ball
(12) Fitness (i) Push
(ii)
(iii) Lunges (iv)
(2) (i) 2
(ii) 2
(iii) Icky
*For adults (3) Side flutter hops *For adults (4) Cone drills (i) Lateral
(ii) Coach
(iii) Zig
(iv)
(5) Happy feet (1) Running
Ladder
(9) (i) 2 foot
(ii) 2 foot
& out (iii) Icky
*For children (11) Single leg inside & out (6) Hopscotch (7) Flexi balls (8) Jump (13) Basket
board
ups
Squats
Jumping jacks
foot inside
foot inside & out
shuttle
sides
says
zag drill
Close out to lateral sides
track (14)
& Hurdle
inside
inside
shuttle
ball
CITIES (Pilot 1 Badminton Court 8.56m X 15.86m (Clay court) 2 Mound10m X 6m (Brick & Ferro cement with paint finish) 3 Cube16.20m X 11.62m (MS structure on compacted earth floor) ASwing Corridor BRope Climber CCalisthenics DParallel Bar EBalancing Beam FRing Bar Existing SWD Shop 5.7 m wide road 16m wide road 6 Proposed Fencing (sports net) 23m length X 3m height 5 Proposed Storm water drain 45m length X 0.69m wide Proposed Fencing (sports net) 23m length X 3m height 6 B A E C D CPS 2Proposed Layout 4 Fitness / Skating Corridor46.20m X 2.50m Cement flooring with paint finish 4 Fitness / Skating Corridor (Cement flooring with paint finish) 46.20m X 2.50m Towards Police station Towards Bus stand F Key plan (Not to scale) SDAT ground CPS 2 CPS 1 busTowards stand PoliceTowards station Building number 1166111714 Building number 1160711660 +100 mm +/0 mm +100 mm +/0 mm +100mm + 80mm +80mm +80mm + 80mm SWD Manhole Legend: Trees Existing Light pole Inspection Chamber +900mm +900mm
Proposed layout of CPS2
Major design components in CPS2
I had never even stepped into this pocket previously because of the mosquitoes and garbage, but now I skate here everyday with my younger brother.
<< Cube (16.2m X 11.6m)
A combination of play that facilitates activities such as calisthenics, parkour, climbing, swinging, jumping and caters to multiple age group. Can also be used for warm-up activities and is made in mild steel.
Mound (10m X 6m)>>
A heaped pile of debris with slope one side acting as a natural slide and integrating seating resembling a rock cut step. Primarily focused on kids as a fun element for climbing, sliding, crawling and seating for adults.
want to represent India in Olympics in badminton. I love watching Saina Nehwal and PV Sindhu but my parents never let me play because there was no facility nearby. With this court & coaching I can play in front of their eyes. like playing with my friends here. The slide is my favorite one in which I play catching games with my friends.
<< Skating corridor ^ (2.5m X 50m)
Currently filed with over flowing sewage and dumped garbage has been programmed into a skating and fitness corridor using the existing levels of inspection chambers.
33 32 Urbanism Portfolio
View of the badminton court & mound*
View of the cube & skating corridor *
* graphic designed collaboratively with an intern
^ Designed collaboratively with an intern
LAKE RESTORATION PROJECT
Chennai, India | Professional work | January - June 2022
Zoning strategy
Existing site condition
Based on access & function
Two
Based on activity & noise
Client: State Industries Promotion Corporation of Tamil Nadu (SIPCOT)
Project components/ Contribution Mapping, Review of the existing master plan, Revised Master plan, Conceptual design, detailed design, Detailed Project Report (DPR), estimate
Role: Project Architect Softwares used: AutoCAD, Sketchup, Photoshop, Illustrator, Indesign, MS Excel
CITIES FOR PLAY is a vision rooted in the realization that very little has been done in the public realm to fulfill the needs of children in our cities.
Children typically spend 16 hours or more in a day in their homes and community settings. Effecting change in the public realm through play not only contributes positively to their cognitive and motor skills and eventually their overall holistic development but also encourages ownership and responsibility towards maintaining our public realm. CITIES FOR PLAY is an initiative that places children as catalysts for reimagining our urban commons. Investing in children today for a better tomorrow.
Sensory Zone
35 34 Urbanism Portfolio
Farm land Vacant land Residential
on circulation & distance Farm land Vacant land Residential
Based
Active Zone Circulation path 1 along the property edge Circulation path 2 along the lake edge Circulation path across the commercial zone Access roads to lake N
2: Commercial zone - Containing cafe, co-working space.
1: Recreation zoneContaining activies and spaces related to waterfront development and parks
Anchor
Anchor
anchors
Entry point 2 - Secondary entrance Farm land Vacant land Residential School Farm land Vacant land Residential School Entry point 1 - Primary Entrance
creating 2 independent zones within the lake that may function independently
37 36 | Urbanism Portfolio Walkway Cycle lane External road Trees 20m 10m 0 Master plan Legend N
Detailed designs (sample)
Garden Cafe & Co working space
Large openings to facilate views of the lake and surrounding landscape
Conceptual idea
39 38 | Urbanism Portfolio Kitchen Dining Area Outdoor Workspace Indoor Workspace +0.45m +/-0 +0.45m +0.45m UP Outdoor seating 19.40 5.00 2.00 12.40 5.00 2.00 12.40 19.40 0 3M
Plan
Proposed view of the outdoor seating
Proposed view of the co working space
Proposed view of the indoor seating
Jack Arches for roof
Bird watching & intrepretation centre
41 40 | Urbanism Portfolio +0.45m +0.45m +0.30m UP
Ramp Corridor Corridor
Greenhouse
Jali Wall Jali Wall
UP 0 2 6M
Jali Wall Jali Wall Jali Wall Jali Wall
idea
Conceptual
Ground floor plan
Proposed view of ground floor
Proposed view of first floor
Amphitheatre
Key Plan
43 42 | Urbanism Portfolio
Plan
Located along the water edge, the amphitheatre was designed to facilitate the function of storing water to delay the run off as well as serve as a semi private space for celebrations and parties.
View
View Aerial view towards the lake
Proposed view
IMPLEMENTATION OF NON MOTORISED TRANSPORT STRATEGY
CONSERVE
The strengths
CONNECT
The dots
CHANGE
What
CREATE if
Context
CELEBRATE
The
Short
Long
In the city context, Big Bazaar Road is located in the Town Hall Area. The Town Hall area forms the core city area and is geographically located in the southern end of the metropolitan area. The core city area of Coimbatore, an area that is characterized by its fine grain urban fabric with a highly permeable street network facilitating several alternate routes for movement in and out of the neighbourhood.
At the neighbourhood scale, Big Bazaar Road is located west of the Coimbatore railway station and east of the city’s commercial hub. In terms of its urban structure, it is a compact mixed use neighbourhood and this is also the reason why it has retained its importance despite the city growing outwards in the northern direction from
this core. It is also home to the Coimbatore City Municipal Corporation, Public Works Department, District Library and Town Hall. Big Bazaar Road serves as the shortest connecting spine between the Coimbatore Railway Station and the city’s commercial/ trade district and is hence a primary arterial road in the city’s street network. However, over the years some of the traffic volume crossing east-west through Big Bazaar Road has been dispersed onto the Ukkadam Sungam Bypass road which runs almost parallel to Big Bazaar Road in the southern side. This is especially the case for commuters who may not have a need to come to the core city areas but are moving towards Ukkadam or other neighbourhoods in the southwestern side of the city.
45 44 | Urbanism Portfolio Coimbatore, India | Professional work (June 2019 to December 2021
Recreational Commercial Public Amenity Healthcare Religious Institutional Transit Major landmarks Neighbourhood context Connections to wider networks Block structure
N N
A 5c framework to catalyze change through tactical urbanism
there is a need
is not working
past, present and the future
term action
term change
Site for demonstration
Street Character
Big Bazaar Road has several prominent visual markers that lend themselves to the legibility of the street.
Bigbazaarroad
Shopping
~316 vehicles parked on Big Bazaar Road as recorded on 4th
8 am on 19th July 2019
2 pm on 19th July 2019
10 am on 19th July 2019
4 pm on 19th July 2019
Big Bazaar Road’s orientation is the reason there is very less shading from the buildings on the street; the street runs in the east west direction. As revealed by the shade analysis, 4 PM is the only time when the buildings cast a shadow on the footpath on the Clock tower side of the road. Also, since the building heights are also mostly ground or ground + 1 floors high, there is less chance of shading the entire right-ofway even at this time of the day. There is hence a higher need for trees on the street for providing shade to its users.
What do users want from Big Bazaar Road? What are the existing inconveniences ?
47 46 | Urbanism Portfolio
Nawab Hakkim road Town Hall Rajastreet Clock Tower Types of commercial retail On street parking Building heights and orientation Showroom/ Exhibition Clothes / Shoes / Accessories 23 Service Jewelry Electronic/ Electrical Medical General Stores Food and Beverage 22 2 1 1 2 2 2 55 Shops 42 buildings front the two sides of Big Bazaar Road and their heights Ground + 5 Ground + 3 Ground + 1 Ground floor 41% Ground + 2 15% 2% 2% 2% Ground + 6 38% Percentage distribution of ground floor uses 79% 15% 4% 2% Commercial Religious Public Institutional
289 10 17 Two-wheelers Cars Autos Easwaran Kovil St. District Library N 0 25 50 Traffic flow pattern
July 2019
Street
Temple Shopping street Temporally use by different user groups 6-7 7-8 8-9 9-10 10-11 11-12 12-1 1-2 2-3 3-4 4-5 5-6 6-7 7-8 8-9 9-10 10-11 11-12 12-1 Working Population (Govt. Offices) Shopkeepers Students Homeless People Office Visitors (Government) Vendors Temple Visitors Shoppers Cinema Visitors AM PM
Public consulation Activity based More 5 minutes Working Population (Govt. Offices) Shopkeepers Students Homeless People Office Visitors (Government) Vendors Temple Visitors Shoppers Cinema Visitors Survey Less than a minute Interview Mobile cart Stakeholders User Engagement Duration Type Medium Location Inquiry Opinion poll Intersection Pedestrian Crossing Bus Stop Entire street 1 to 5 minutes Mobile Standees Pedestrian crossing ROW changes for vehicles Parking changes Shade Intersection Sidewalk Information Panels Streetmix section game NMT path game NMT choices game Activities Pre & post implementation user engagement strategy
implementation
Koniamman Temple Clock tower District Library
Pre
engagement outcomes
Existing street condition
Left: Existing ROW configuration in street section;
Aerial view of the existing condition
1. Inadequate pedestrian infrastructure
2. Lack of shading and seating
3. Irregular street parking
4. Varying carriageway widths along the street
Proposed interventions
Right: Proposed ROW configuration in street section; Down: Aerial view of the proposed condition
1. Reducing carriageway width
2. Intersection redesign
3. Adding pedestrian crossing points
4. Seating and shade structures
5. Games for children on the sidewalk
49 48 | Urbanism Portfolio P
(A) Clock tower intersection (B) Bus stop (C) - Sidewalk
A C B
Down:
P
(A) Clock tower intersection (B) Bus stop (C) - Sidewalk
51 50 Urbanism Portfolio Post implementation Aerial view credits: Akash Muralidharan
Clock tower intersection
Street - aerial view
Pedestrian crossing Games along the sidewalk
implementation user opinion survey
Reclaiming excess carriage way for pedestrians
Post
Image credits: GIZ
Seating & shaded walkway
Sensitisation on NMT infrastructure
(left) City officials using the Pedestrian Environment Audit kit to observe and understand the needs & challenges faced by NMT users through a hands on exercise; (right) City officials playing the game designed to develop an understanding about the different modes of transportation and the pros and cons associated with each mode.
Capacity enhancement for implementation of NMT infrastructure
Innovative components (sample)
• Mapping user groups and their needs
Game play
A player has to select any one mode of transport in each turn.
They can move in continuous steps in any direction.However, every mode of transport has its own speed and pollution fee. The pollution fee has to be given to the bank every time a person chooses to move based on the chosen mode of transport for that round of play.
The player with all (6) or maximum destinations covered and with the most money at the end wins the game.
Game was designed and developed collaboratively with an intern
Game board as an abstract map of Coimbatore city
Role play exercise followed by mapping the different user groups as identified during the pedestrian environment audit to understand their needs and issues.
• Pedestrian environment audit - Technical
Providing an in depth understanding of the street through systematic data collection including detailed mapping of site condition.
• Redesigning the street ROW & intersection
The activity uses all the data collected from the on-site audits and verifications to design a reconfigured street section. Various street elements are provided in the form of cut outs which participants use to design a street section.
• Testing the designs on the ground
This activity introduces tactical urbanism* as a quick and effective approach to test designs before actually finalising them for construction.
53 52 Urbanism Portfolio
Tamil Nadu Agricultural University Narsampathy lake 4x 4x 4x 4x 4x SBOA School Corporation School Gandhi Park Selvachinthamani Kulam Kabarsthan Sunnath Jama-ath Masjid Ganga Bakery PSG College Of Technology Coimbatore girls school Forest college Campus Shri Nehru Vidylaya Matric Hr.Sec School KG Hospital Racecourse Park Café Totaram Racecourse G. Kuppuswamy Naidu Memorial Hospital Thandu Mariamman temple Coimbatore Corporation Perarignar Anna Park Gandhipuram Bus stand Coimbatore Central Jail CSI Church Brookefields Mall Sree Annapoorna Lodging And Restaurant Ramar Kovil Sri Masaniamman Temple Kovai Medical Center and Hospital Town hall Children’s park Chinna kulam Kumaraswamy lake Selvampathy lake Valan kulam Fuel station Repair shop Intersection Mode of transport Speed Pollution Fee Police station Baba Cinemas Post office Bank Railway station Senior citizen & Memorial park Hotel Junior Kuppanna Children Traffic Park The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board & Corporation Office Central Theatre Sree Annapoorna Hotel Bharathi Park 4x 4x Tamilnadu Towheed Jamath Ukkadam Post office Ukkadam New Wholesale Fish market Walk 1x 2x 3x 5x 5x 4x Nil Nil 3x 10x 5x 20x Cycle Bus Bike Auto Car 60 minutes Duration Board game Type 2-6 Players 6 modes of transport 6 destinations for each player to reach ONE RUPEE 1 1 FIVE RUPEE 5 TEN RUPEE 10 10 ONE RUPEE 1 FIVE RUPEE 5 TWO HUINDRED RUPEE 200 ONE RUPEE 1 1 FIVE RUPEE 5 FIFTY RUPEE 50 50 TEN RUPEE 10 10 ONE HUNDRED RUPEE TWO HUINDRED RUPEE 200 200 TEN RUPEE 10 ONE HUNDRED RUPEE 100 200 ONE RUPEE 1 FIVE RUPEE 5 FIFTY RUPEE 50 50 TEN RUPEE 10 10 ONE HUNDRED RUPEE 100 100 TWO HUINDRED RUPEE 200 200 Pollution fees Green signal cards Parking cards Chance cards Your health condition deteriorating and the doctor has advised you to only walk for the next rounds Chance Card There is global fuel crisis and all the players are forced to use only non motorized transport for the next rounds. Chance Card You are late to work and you are required to travel only in car for next rounds. Chance Card Being responsible citizen you You can only travel by two wheeler for the next rounds. Chance Card Parking available only for wheelers. No Parking for 100M (10 squares) incase you are in car Parking Card Parking available only for 4 wheelers. No Parking for 50M (5 squares) incase you are on two wheeler Parking Card No Parking Zone for 100M (10 squares) around your destination Parking Card Paid Parking Pay 10 INR to park your two wheeler. Pay 25 INR to park your car Parking Card No Parking Zone for 100M (10 squares) around your destination Parking Card Premium parking Pay 20 INR to park your two wheeler. Pay 50 INR to park your car Parking Card Paid Parking Pay 10 INR to park your two wheeler. Pay 25 INR to park your car Destination cards Bharathi Park Tamil Nadu Agricultural University Shri Nehru Vidylaya Matric Hr.Sec School Forest College Campus Sree Annapoorna Hotel Central Theatre Baba Cinemas The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board & Corporation Office Brookfield’s Mall Sree Annapoorna Lodging And Restaurant Sri Masaniamman Temple SBOA School Gandhi Park Corporation School Town hall Kumaraswamy Lake Narsampathy Lake Ganga Bakery Kabarsthan Sunnath Jama-ath Masjid Periya kulam Bharathi Park Tamil Nadu Agricultural University Shri Nehru Vidylaya Matric Hr.Sec School Forest College Campus Sree Annapoorna Hotel Central Theatre Baba Cinemas The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board Corporation Office Brookfield’s Mall Sree Annapoorna Lodging And Restaurant Sri Masaniamman Temple SBOA School Gandhi Park Corporation School Town hall Kumaraswamy Lake Narsampathy Lake Ganga Bakery Kabarsthan Sunnath Jama-ath Masjid Periya kulam Selva chinthamani kulam Post Office Bank PSG College of Technology Kovai Medical centre and hospital Ramar Kovil G. Kuppuswamy Naidu Memorial Hospital Senior citizen and Hotel Junior Kuppanna Coimbatore Corporation Perarignar Bharathi Park Tamil Nadu Agricultural University Shri Nehru Vidylaya Matric Hr.Sec School Forest College Campus Sree Annapoorna Hotel Central Theatre Baba Cinemas The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board & Corporation Office Brookfield’s Mall Sree Annapoorna Lodging And Restaurant Sri Masaniamman Temple SBOA School Gandhi Park Corporation School Town hall Kumaraswamy Lake Narsampathy Lake Ganga Bakery Kabarsthan Sunnath Jama-ath Masjid Periya kulam Selva chinthamani kulam Post Office Bank PSG College of Technology Kovai Medical centre and hospital Ramar Kovil G. Kuppuswamy Naidu Memorial Hospital Senior citizen and Memorial park Hotel Junior Kuppanna Coimbatore Corporation Perarignar Anna Park Children Traffic Park Gandhipuram Bus Stand KG Hospital Race course Park CSI Church Bharathi Park Tamil Nadu Agricultural University Shri Nehru Vidylaya Matric Hr.Sec School Forest College Campus Sree Annapoorna Hotel Central Theatre Baba Cinemas The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board & Corporation Office Brookfield’s Mall Sree Annapoorna Lodging And Restaurant Sri Masaniamman Temple SBOA School Gandhi Park Corporation School Town hall Kumaraswamy Lake Narsampathy Lake Ganga Bakery Kabarsthan Sunnath Jama-ath Masjid Periya kulam Selva chinthamani kulam Post Office Bank PSG College of Technology Kovai Medical centre and hospital Ramar Kovil G. Kuppuswamy Naidu Memorial Hospital Senior citizen and Memorial park Hotel Junior Kuppanna Coimbatore Corporation Perarignar Anna Park Children Traffic Park Gandhipuram Bus Stand KG Hospital Race course Park CSI Church Coimbatore girl’s school Police station Thandu Mariamman temple Railway station Café Totaram Singanallur lake Children’s Park Valan kulam Ukkadam new wholesale fish market Ukkadam post office Bharathi Park Tamil Nadu Agricultural University Shri Nehru Vidylaya Matric Hr.Sec School Forest College Campus Sree Annapoorna Hotel Central Theatre Baba Cinemas The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board & Corporation Office Brookfield’s Mall Sree Annapoorna Lodging And Restaurant Sri Masaniamman Temple SBOA School Gandhi Park Corporation School Town hall Kumaraswamy Lake Narsampathy Lake Ganga Bakery Kabarsthan Sunnath Jama-ath Masjid Periya kulam Selva chinthamani kulam Post Office Bank PSG College of Technology Kovai Medical centre and hospital Ramar Kovil G. Kuppuswamy Naidu Memorial Hospital Senior citizen and Memorial park Hotel Junior Kuppanna Coimbatore Corporation Perarignar Anna Park Children Traffic Park Gandhipuram Bus Stand KG Hospital Race course Park CSI Church Coimbatore girl’s school Police station Thandu Mariamman temple Railway station Café Totaram Bharathi Park Tamil Nadu Agricultural University Shri Nehru Vidylaya Matric Hr.Sec School Forest College Campus Sree Annapoorna Hotel Central Theatre Baba Cinemas The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board & Corporation Office Brookfield’s Mall Sree Annapoorna Lodging And Restaurant Sri Masaniamman Temple SBOA School Gandhi Park Corporation School Town hall Kumaraswamy Lake Narsampathy Lake Ganga Bakery Kabarsthan Sunnath Jama-ath Masjid Periya kulam Selva chinthamani kulam Post Office Bank PSG College of Technology Kovai Medical centre and hospital Ramar Kovil G. Kuppuswamy Naidu Memorial Hospital Senior citizen and Memorial park Hotel Junior Kuppanna Coimbatore Corporation Perarignar Anna Park Children Traffic Park Gandhipuram Bus Stand KG Hospital Race course Park CSI Church Coimbatore girl’s school Police station Thandu Mariamman temple Railway station Café Totaram Singanallur lake Children’s Park Valan kulam Ukkadam new wholesale fish market Ukkadam post office Trip sheet Colour: Destinations: 1) ___________________________ 2) ___________________________ 3) ___________________________ 4) ___________________________ 5) ___________________________ 6) ___________________________ Pollution Level: Colour: Destinations: 1) ___________________________ 2) ___________________________ 3) ___________________________ 4) ___________________________ 5) ___________________________ 6) ___________________________ Pollution Level: Colour: Destinations: 1) ___________________________ 2) ___________________________ 3) ___________________________ 4) ___________________________ 5) ___________________________ 6) ___________________________ Pollution Level: Colour: Destinations: 1) ___________________________ 2) ___________________________ 3) ___________________________ 4) ___________________________ 5) ___________________________ 6) ___________________________ Pollution Level: Colour: Destinations: 1) ___________________________ 2) ___________________________ 3) ___________________________ 4) ___________________________ 5) ___________________________ 6) ___________________________ Pollution Level: Colour: Destinations: 1) ___________________________ 2) ___________________________ 3) ___________________________ 4) ___________________________ 5) ___________________________ 6) ___________________________ Pollution Level: Target audience Municipal Engineers School kids Citizens Students Game overview Innovative components (sample)
Game contents 4x 4x 4x Hospital Racecourse Park Café Totaram Racecourse G. Kuppuswamy Naidu Memorial Hospital Gandhipuram Bus stand Coimbatore Central Jail Valan kulam Fuel station Repair shop Intersection Mode of transport Speed Pollution Fee Senior citizen & Memorial park Hotel Junior Kuppanna Children Traffic Park Ukkadam Wholesale market Walk 1x 2x 3x 5x 5x 4x Nil Nil 3x 10x 5x 20x Cycle Bus Bike Auto Car
ACCESSIBLE QUARTER
Chennai, India Professional work (2019 - 2022)
Project components
Accessible pathway
Access to the waters using Eco friendly materials
Exact contribution to the project: Research, DPR, Conceptual design , detailed design, tender drawings, estimate, stakeholder engagement, capcity enchancement, site supervision Timeline: May 2019 to November 2022
Status: Completed
Magizhchi Cafe
Museum of Possibilities
Demonstrating alternative living across the domains of Live work and play
Exact contribution to the project: Conceptual design, detailed designs, estimate and site supervision
Timeline: Dec 2019 to June 2022
Status: Completed
Graphic: Vidhya V
Vocational skills training centre cum rooftop cafeteria
Exact contribution to the project: Conceptual design, detailed designs, estimate
Timeline: February 2020 to June 2022
Status: Completed
Accessible quarter
Currently accessible
Currently inaccessible
Accessible office
Optimization of space and universally accessible
Exact contribution to the project: Conceptual planning & design
Timeline: February 2021 to Ongoing
Status: Awaiting funding approval
Graphic: Nawin S
State Commissionerate for the Differently-abled & Proposed Museum of possibilities & Roof top cafeteria
Plaza
Bus stops
Skating ring
Proposed beach access pathway Gandhi Statue plaza
Accessible public toilet
Right of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016, mandated that all the government buildings and public spaces be made accessible for persons with disabilities to be able to navigate on any day. Marina beach being one of the most preferred recreational spaces in the city, the project aims to make a 400 metre stretch fully accessible as a pilot project. The pilot stretch also has various other amenities, both existing and proposed and hence making this quarter accessible will serve its fullest potential to persons with disabilities.
View of site with the proposed circuit and broken links
Provide the seamless and safe transition between the existing promenade and proposed pathway
Exact contribution to the project: Conceptual planning & design, detailed designs, tender drawings, Estimate
Timeline: March 2020 to November 2022
Status: Inprogress
55 54 | Urbanism Portfolio
Accessible pathway
Detailed
BEACH ACCESSIBILITY PROJECT, CHENNAI
Before implementation
Proposed
Photographs of PwD facing barriers in accessing the waters till 2022; Image source: Vaishnavi/ DRA
With no such projects existing in the entire country the proposed design was made taking into consideration several aspects such as requirements from global practices, local stakeholder needs, site
Post implementation
A conceptual representation of the proposed wooden pathway for PwDs to access the waters
specification considerations such as loose soil, olive ridley nesting, coastal zone regulations, and environmentally sustainable materials & construction techniques.
57 56 | Urbanism Portfolio
Timber Balustrade Babool wood (50mm X 50mm X 1150mm) Timber frame Red Maranti (92 mm X 65 mm) at equal spacing Timber pegs TYPE B Babool wood (92mm X 92mm X 1000mm) VIEW Handrail - WPC (40mm X 70mm Handrail WPC (75mm X 20mm) Edging strip - WPC (75mm X 20mm) Decking IPE 19mm thickness at 6mm spacing (1000mm to 2000m varying length & 65mm 115mm width) 3000 Timber peg TYPE A Babool wood (92mm X 92mm X 1970mm) eq eq eq 900 700 Timber frame Red Maranti (92 mm X 65 mm) at 1000mm c/c spacing Timber peg TYPE A - Babool wood (92mm X 92mm X 1970mm) 1000 1000 1000 1000 A C B Timber frame Red Maranti (92mm X 92mm X 300mm) Timber balustrade (50mm X 50mm X 1150mm) Timber frame Red Maranti (92 mm X 65 mm) Timber frame - Red Maranti (92 mm X 65 mm) DETAIL AT B - ISOMETRIC VIEW EXPLODED ISOMETRIC VIEW Timber peg TYPE B Babool wood (92mm X 92mm X 1000mm) Timber frame - Red Maranti (92 mm X 92 mm X 300 mm) Timber balustrade (50mm X 50mm X 1150mm) Timber frame Red Maranti (92 mm X 65 mm) 50 50 180 25 Timber peg TYPE B Babool wood (92mm X 92mm X 1000mm) Timber frame Red Maranti (92 mm X 92 mm X 300 mm) Timber frameRed Maranti (92 mm X 65 mm) 21 x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Detail at B - Isometric view Exploded isometric view x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x View
design drawings (sample)
Aerial view
source: Greater Chennai Corporation
; Image
With the implementation completed in November 2022, Marina Beach in Chennai is now India’s first accessible beach.
One long pending dream of many made a reality
Image credit - Sarveshwaran Ganapathy
Accessible quarter
Existing issues
Access
Lack of accessible kerb drop ramp
Lack of accessible kerb drop ramp at intersections
Lack of Pedestrian refugee Islands
Lack of Ramp for access Over speeding of vehicles Existing
Barriers along the circuit
Obstruction caused by existing toe wall
Obstruction caused by existing bollards
Abundant provision for parking
ramp
View of site with the location and nature of issues
Recommendations (Sample)
Lack of accessible kerb drop ramp
Obstruction caused due to existing bollards
The key challenge was to restrict motorcycles but also allow wheelchair users. The proposed design was based on multiple iterations tested
Photograph
61 60 | Urbanism Portfolio
A1 A2
Table top Pedestrian crossing
Photograph of the issue on site
Proposed intervention
A1 A2 C1 A4G2G1 A5 A6 D1 G3 D2 I1 E1 C2 A7 J1 F3H3 B1 A3 H2 H1 B2 B3 C3 A8 C4 F2 F1 L1 K1 L2 I2
Table top Pedestrian crossing
corrected A1 B1 C1 D1 F1 A8 B3 C4 D2 E1 F3
Level Difference to be
to the quarter
Insufficient
G1 H1 I1 L1 G3 H3 I2 J1 K1 L2
Steeper
ratio Existing Free left turn
sidewalk width
2100 (Min 900) Existing toe wall Side walk Planter box All dimensions in millimeters (mm) 900 Carriage way Existing toe wall (In wire-frame) 900 900 900 900
of the
on site Proposed design
issue
on the
H1 H3 Kerb Kerb 6000 mm I1 I2 Abundant provision for parking E1 Over speeding of vehicles
ground.
of the issue on site Reorganised Parking layout Dedicated parking for PwD Table top Pedestrian crossing Dedicated lane for pedestrians/ PwDs demarcated with thermoplastic paint and separated with kerb Beach access pathway
parking Dedicated parking For PwD Table top Pedestrian crossing Dedicated lane for pedestrians/ PwDs demarcated with thermoplastic
Photograph
Reorganised
paint
Credit - Nawin Saravanan
View of the proposed intervention
View of the site plan
Udaeceatem. Ita sim ipientibust, serum liquati busaepr ehendignis ium, cum repudant aut aborem dignimet am ilis ero que sequam et, sume illes aliquas volum quos event, quo beatent liquiae labor aturero doluptaspita dolorem dolorumqui quam coreictatem eost lant fugia porestis expernam invenis dionsedit doluptis volorep eribusandae officid quam volupist, sandipitas ea dus, sum ipsant la pe cuptat volupta tiistion nam repre volore corias minctiumquo maxim et rerro bea di con nobis siment animus sum reratur re volorem vidundi tatqui sinis et vollest ionectiae. Nequibu scimus que sam ad mosam et verum aut endent, odis molorate moluptur, omnias nos doloritibus cum ut quia voloren dandige
The rapid urban growth
Towards Chennai Towards Bengaluru
Palar river
Palar river
1500s - Historic settlement
The original settlement was comprised of the market town, the casbah and the fort. Water needs were met from the bunded tanks and natural streams that carried water down the Sathuvachari Hills.
Towards Chennai
1700s
- Colonial era
The British colonial settlement added a cantonment area as well as several regiment areas to the existing fabric. To meet the additional water demand, they lined several nalas to carry the water to various parts of the city.
A
Palar river
Palar river
1872 - The Great floods
The Great floods of 1872 was the first instance of cloud burst that caused a breach in a series of tanks that resulted in the flooding of the settlement and severe loss to life and property.
2017 - Post Independence era
With the Sathuvachari Hills restricting development in the southern end, postindependence Vellore grew along the expressways that were built to connect Chennai and Bangalore as well as along the northern axis towards Katpadi station. Unregulated development patterns caused further depletion and degradation of water bodies and resulted in water imbalances for this growing city.
63 62 | Urbanism Portfolio
Vellore, India | Group documentation & Independent Proposal - Academic (July - Nov 2017) URBAN COURTYARD
Towards Arani
Sathuvachari hills Towards Katpadi
Towards Arani
Towards
Sathuvachari hills Towards Katpadi
Bengaluru
Towards Arani Towards Chennai Towards Bengaluru Sathuvachari hills NationalHighway Towards Katpadi
Towards Arani Towards Chennai
Bengaluru Sathuvachari
Towards Katpadi
Towards
hills
Spatial manifestation of water security issues in 2017
Water supply &
systems
Drinking water sources have either dried up or have been contaminated through solid and liquid waste dumping thereby rendering them unfit for use.
Acute water shortage and inadequate water supply infrastructure continually stress Vellore residents
Types of degradation of water bodies
The rapid urban growth has led to degradation of water bodies along the city and the graphic shows the impact of degradation along the city through a transect
ENCROACHED
DRIED UP
Sathuvachari hills
Urbanisation pressures have caused depletion of agricultural lands along the flood plains of the Palar river and compromised the urban ecology associated with the river system.
CONCRETED DUMPED
Increase in area of non-permeable surfaces increases runoff and further reduces groundwater percolation.
Inadequate green cover has aggravated the urban heat island effect. This in turn has contributed to the failure of monsoons. Since 2016, summer temperatures recorded have been consistently 5 to 6 degrees higher than the average for these months.
Despite official reports on groundwater conditions calling out the entire district of Vellore for over exploiting the water table, illegal extraction continues including along the flood plains of the Palar river
Palar r ver
Cana Canal
National Highway
LOST Transect along A
Impact
Source: mediaistock
distribution
Natural
Source: Google Satellite Map
Lake
Palar river
Cana
What if aiming for a BLUE - GREEN surplus by 2047 could guide Vellore’s development trajectory?
Proposed strategy
Restore. Store. Reuse
Guiding principles (Marco level)
COMMUNITY-LED URBAN GREENING
The vision is to have water security for every individual plot, street and neighborhood through a decentralized multi-stakeholder approach covering design, planning, and policy-based solutions.
Neighbourhood Scale
SHIFTING TOWARDS DEWATS
Setting up of decentralized wastewater treatment system (DEWATS) units to curb and treat discharge at the neighbourhood level and to reuse the treated water to revive water bodies and their ecosystems.
CREATING BIOSWALES
Protecting existing green cover and planting native species like Peltophorum and Raintree to help combat rising temperatures and enable water percolation to enrich the water table.
MANDATING SLOPED ROOFS FOR ALL BUILDINGS
A sloped roof with clay tiles for all buildings helps to harvest more runoff even in shorter spells of rain. This must be mandated through a revision to the city’s development control regulations.
CREATING SPONGE PARKS
A water body restoration program must be prioritised to revive the city’s system of reservoirs. In addition, low lying areas across the city should be redeveloped to incorporate sponge parks to capture runoff and improve groundwater recharge. Wherever required development rights can be transferred along transit corridors.
Replacing the conventional concreted storm-water drain pipes with bio-swales to capture surface runoff and also recharge the groundwater. The planting of native vegetation along these swales can also reduce the heat island effect along the streets.
INCREASING PERMEABILITY
Mandating the maximum non-permeable surface for all properties through the city’s development control regulations to ensure maximum groundwater recharge.
RAIN WATER HARVESTING & GREY WATER RECYCLING
In 2005, the State government had mandated rainwater harvesting in every plot. A revised policy making it mandatory for all plots to harvest rainwater as well as recycle greywater will ensure optimum storage and reuse.
67 66 | Urbanism Portfolio
Regional Scale
City Scale City Scale
Street Level
Block
Level
Building Level
Testing Ground
One of the canals located on the foothills of Sathuvachari was chosen as a demonstration site for a water-secure Vellore. This 500 metre stretch of the canal runs through a low-density residential neighbourhood. On its northern end, the canal runs below the national highway and truncates beyond without any clear delineation of its edges. The approach for demonstrating the macro level strategies for a water secure Vellore at this site combines with a reading of the challenges and opportunities presented here at the micro level to derive water sensitive urban design proposal.
Site-specific challenges
Design principles (Mirco)
Streets for all
Prioritizing the most vulnerable users of the street by reducing the width of the carriage way to streamline the vehicular movement, calming traffic and reclaiming space for pedestrians, cyclists and related amenities.
The Urban courtyard
A courtyard is a multi-functional, multi-use space placed between rooms in a traditional house unit. The street is re imagined as a public space similar to the courtyard in a house. Allowing various activities for all age groups, encouraging eyes on the street, and creating opportunities to socialise and interact with water. All this is aimed at enabling a connect with water, the street and its inhabitants.
Nature based solutions
Retaining the existing trees and increasing the green cover by planting native species. Creating sponge parks, bio swales and recharge wells to improve the micro climate and facilitate ground water recharge. Also reviving the cemented canal by softening
its edges with vegetation and flushing treated water from the DEWATS unit into the canal. Setting up composting units, MRF, RRC to facilitate source segregation and reduce waste sent to dump-yards.
69 68 Urbanism Portfolio
Towards Chennai
Sathuvachari
National Highway N
Palarriver
TowardsBengaluru
hills
Road safety concern
Dumping & Accidents Continuous obstacles Lack of seating spaces, waste disposal system and sidewalk Mobility-related conflicts Environmental pollution/ degradation Lost opportunities for place making Highway
Sidewalk Sidewalk Multi-use zone Multi-use zone Restored canal Carriage way Carriage way Recharge pit
Vending Seating Rain gardens Outdoor gym Urban Farming Sculptures Play areas Eateries
Canal Pedestrians Pedestrians Pedestrians Pedestrians Vehicles Vehicles Cycle path Cycle path
Vision for Demonstration area for 2047
The core vision for the demonstration site is to enable every user to develop a sense of belonging by accommodating all the user requirements and making it a completely self sufficient and sustainable neighbourhood. In a way, this vision is a path to absorb the traditional practice in a modern day.
Increased green cover
Constructed wetlands Improving biodiversity
Sidewalk Bioswale
Marathadi (seating space)
Streamlined carriage way
Street sectional view from the reclaimed carriage way
71 70 Urbanism Portfolio
Sloped roof Increased green cover Sidewalk Bioswale
Pathway (Permeable paver) Micro level design principles Holistic solution
Other activity spaces Macro level guiding principles
Approach City’s vision based Demonstration area’s vision based outcomes N 0 50 100 200 Metres
Restored canal with constructed wet lands Streamlined carriage way
Households harvesting rain water and recycling greywater Seating under trees
Rain garden
Permeable paver
73 72 | Urbanism Portfolio Urban farming
Vending zones Farmer’s market Composting unit
of the street market and farm
of the plaza Urban markers - statue Games City’s vision based outcomes Demonstration area’s vision based outcomes Marathadi (seating space) Vending zones Street sectional view from the property edge Increased green cover Outdoor gym Bioswale Sidewalk Kids play area
URBAN COURTYARD
View
View
Part B
Other related projects
75 74 | Urbanism
Portfolio
PARTICIPATORY PLANNING
Cities for Play, Ayodhya Kagar Chennai, India | Profession work
AREA: 2 Hectares
DENSITY: 1634/Hectare
LAND-USE: Residential
USER-GROUP: 1000 + children & other residents
STRENGTH: Strong sense of community & inhert skill set of fishing folks
Willingness to take up active play and sports
WEAKNESS: Limited opportunities for economic & personal growth
OPPORTUNITY: Plenty of unprogrammed open spaces
THREAT: Poor solid waste management coupled with lack of awareness
Ayodhya Nagar is a fishing colony located at the heart of Chennai right across from the Marina beach. In 2017, the Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board (TNSCB) undertook an in-situ resettlement project here and built 4-storey tenements in a gridded layout to house the 730 odd families who were native residents of this fishing village. Despite a fairly smooth resettlement effort, the design of the public realm here was left unaddressed; apart from the vacant parcels of land in the periphery and centre of the site, all corridors between the tenement blocks were also left unprogrammed. The Cities for Play project aims to reimagine these shared commons through the needs of the 1000+ children who live here but were not accounted for in the design of both the built and unbuilt spaces.
Adults playing Kids playing
77 76 Urbanism Portfolio
Sitting Vending Parking Drying clothes Usage Highly used Used partially Unused
79 78 Urbanism Portfolio Activity Number of votes Badminton 51 Slide and rock climbing 26 Cricket practice corridor 22 Cricket 17 Volley ball 17 Outdoor gym 12 Monkey bar 12 Hopscotch 8 Basketball 8 Swing corridor 8 Rock climbing 6 Leisure corridor 5 Hanging bridge 3 Adults Fitness trail 3 Heaving hoops 1 Kids Fitness trail 1
Map showing potential spaces of intervention
Unprogrammed/ residual open spaces
Service alleyways
Access corridors
Inference: C2 & C3 are the unprogrammed/ residual spaces that majority want to be transformed.
With respect to service alleys and access corridors the kids want those immediately next to their individual houses activated with play.
Outcome
81 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 A1 A2 A4 A8 A3 B1 A10 A11 A12 A5 A6 A7 A9 B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7 B8 B9 B10 C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C9 C8 C7 C6 Corridor Number of votes B9 50 C2 40 B2 29 B1 27 B2 27 C5 26 A1 24 A11 24 C4 23 A4 21 B8 21 A8 20 A12 20 B4 19 A6 18 A10 17 B5 17 B6 16 A9 15 C3 15 A3 15 C8 14 A5 12 B7 9 A7 9 C6 6 B10 4
83 82 | Urbanism Portfolio TYPE OF ACTIVITY INDIVIDUAL GROUP GENDER PROPOSED FOR MALE FEMALE COST ESTIMATE(IN INR) ₹ 5,000 - 24,999 ₹ ₹ 25,000 - 74,999 ₹ ₹ ₹ 75,000 - 1,49,999 ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ 1,50,000 - 2,49,999 ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ >/= 2,50,000 LAND OWNERSHIP TAMIL NADU SLUM CLEARANCE BOARD GREATER CHENNAI CORPORATION SERVICE ALLEYWAYS MAJOR STREET CROSSINGS UNPROGRAMMED TRAFFIC ISLANDS ACCESS CORRIDORS UNPROGRAMMED/ RESIDUAL OPEN SPACES NATURE OF ALL PROPOSED INTERVENTIONS AT AYODHYA NAGAR D1 D2 CHILD FRIENDLY CROSSING DESIGNS for ages 8-80 52 sq.m ₹ ₹ 40 sq.m Competition ID: B14 | 4 of 4 BASKET BALL for ages 13 to 30 B6 ₹ ₹ FITNESS CORRIDOR for ages 13 to 24 B5 ₹ HOP SCOTCH WALL CLIMBER for ages 5 to 13 BRIDGE for ages 5 to 13 B8 HEAVING HOOPS for ages 5 to 13 ₹ ₹ B7 BADMINTON PRACTICE for ages 13 to 24 ₹ ₹ B2 ₹ ₹ OBSTACLE COURSE for ages 5 to 13 B1 KIDS ZONE for ages 2 to 5 ₹ B9 SWING CORRIDOR for ages 5 to 13 ₹ ₹ B10 CRICKET PRACTICE for ages 8 to 13 ₹ ₹ 56.8 sq.m each ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ E1 E3 E2 785 sq.m 168 sq.m 128 sq.m OUTDOOR GYM for ages 13-59 ₹ ₹ ₹ A11 A9 BALANCING BAR for ages 5 to 13 SKATING / FOOTBALL / HOCKEY DRILLS for ages 5 to 18 ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ A1 A4 A5 A6 A7 A8 A3 A2 A10 A12 DRYING CLOTHES SEATING BOARD GAMES SHOPS ₹ WALL ART DRYING FISH GARDENING ₹ ₹ ₹ 87 sq.m 123 sq.m 103 sq.m each 450 sq.m 93 sq.m 66 sq.m ₹ ₹ URBAN FARMING for ages 8 to 80 C2 BADMINTON COURT for ages 8 to 49 C5 KABADDI / VOLLEY BALL COURT for ages 8 to 49 C1 C4 C8 BOARD GAMES for ages 8 to 80 GARDENING for ages 8 to 59 CLIMBER, SLIDE & SAND PIT for ages 2 to 13 NATURE TRAIL & GARDENING for ages 8 to 80 C6 264 sq.m 631 sq.m 231 sq.m ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ 45 sq.m 56 sq.m ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹ ₹₹ 1101 sq.m 240 sq.m ₹ ₹ ₹₹ C3 C7 263 sq.m GULLY CRICKET for ages 8 to 30 ₹ ₹ C9 GARDENING for ages 8 to 59 2147 sq.m 22.56 sq.m each B4 ₹ ₹ B3 ₹ ₹ +
GAMIFICATION
SDG Game | Profession work (2021)
Game overview
120 minutes
Duration
Online Type 2-6 Players
22 projects
Target Audience
Designed keeping in mind holistic impact and across various sectors
10 rounds
10 years from 2021 to 2030
60 crore/ round/ player INR
Impact on SDG’s based on your choices at the end of the game
Objectives
1. Creating general awareness about SDGs and how they fall under various domains for developmental impact
2. Understanding linkages between SDGs
3. Encouraging a collaborative way of working for better developmental impact
4. Improved decision making guided by SDG performance indicators
5. Improve awareness on how projects at the ward and city level impact overall SDG performance indicators
85 84 | Urbanism Portfolio
Representatives
Bureaucrats
Students School kids Citizens
Elected
Non Governmental Organisation
Municipal Engineers
UI - Budget allocation page
Game
Game UI - Impact on SDG
RESEARCH ASSESSMENTS
A roadmap for creating livable cities | Profession work (2022)
A comprehensive manual for designing testing safe street design concept through tactical urbanism tailored to Indian context was developed based and published under the Green Urban Mobility Partnership between German Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ), GIZ along with Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA), Govt. of India. It caters to a wide range of audience who want wish to conduct a trail run of redistributing the street RoW and making streets safer for all users. Suitable for citizens, experts and urban local bodies to test the designs and accustomed to the change before permanent implementation.
Creating cities for walking and cycling | Profession work (2020)
A comprehensive manual for designing testing safe street design concept through tactical urbanism tailored to Indian context was developed based and published under the Green Urban Mobility Partnership between German Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ), GIZ along with Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA), Govt. of India. It caters to a wide range of audience who want wish to conduct a trail run of redistributing the street RoW and making streets safer for all users. Suitable for citizens, experts and urban local bodies to test the designs and accustomed to the change before permanent implementation.
A tactical urbanism guidebook | Profession work (2020)
A comprehensive manual for designing testing safe street design concept through tactical urbanism tailored to Indian context was developed based and published under the Green Urban Mobility Partnership between German Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ), GIZ along with Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA), Govt. of India. It caters to a wide range of audience who want wish to conduct a trail run of redistributing the street RoW and making streets safer for all users. Suitable for citizens, experts and urban local bodies to test the designs and accustomed to the change before permanent implementation.
Participatory Planning in the Era of Physical Distancing | Profession work (2020)
Church Street Ward (CSW) is a dynamic, multicultural, and complex neighborhood in North Westminster, located between Edgware Road and Lisson Grove. The community of CSW, however, struggles with social and economic marginalization despite the strong feeling of community and the success of the Church Street Market. The prevailing poor health, low education qualifications, the poor quality of built environment, high unemployment rates and inadequate access to public realm contribute to poor on the Indices of Multiple Deprivation (IMD).
Church Street Ward (CSW) is a dynamic, multicultural, and complex neighborhood in North Westminster, located between Edgware Road and Lisson Grove. The community of CSW, however, struggles with social and economic marginalization despite the strong feeling of community and the success of the Church Street Market. The prevailing poor health, low education qualifications, the poor quality of built environment, high unemployment rates and inadequate access to public realm contribute to poor on the Indices of Multiple Deprivation (IMD).
Church Street Ward (CSW) is a dynamic, multicultural, and complex neighborhood in North Westminster, located between Edgware Road and Lisson Grove. The community of CSW, however, struggles with social and economic marginalization despite the strong feeling of community and the success of the Church Street Market. The prevailing poor health, low education qualifications, the poor quality of built environment, high unemployment rates and inadequate access to public realm contribute to poor on the Indices of Multiple Deprivation (IMD).
Church Street Ward (CSW) is a dynamic, multicultural, and complex neighborhood in North Westminster, located between Edgware Road and Lisson Grove. The community of CSW, however, struggles with social and economic marginalization despite the strong feeling of community and the success of the Church Street Market. The prevailing poor health, low education qualifications, the poor quality of built environment, high unemployment rates and inadequate access to public realm contribute to poor on the Indices of Multiple Deprivation (IMD).
87
Waterbody restoration Safe pedestrian Public space housing Bicycle network Typology suburban neighbourhood with river edges 3 interventions such Smart schools enabling holistic child development indices. series sports and play zones to improve health and fitness levels. energy sources adopting solar technology masse. priority streets connecting major EV charging points Temple precinct Bike network Play areas promenade Canal restoration Waterfront public space Typology neighbourhood in the city core 2 network walkable streets leading multi-modal transit hubs. Ecological restoration natural systems such waterways and green open spaces. education infrastructure residents. Enhancement of culturally significant markers for neighbourhood. defined fine grain and mixed use development Riverfront park accessible sidewalks E-autos Dedicated bus furniture Bike sharing station Nature trail Underground ducting Solar powered street lights Safe crossings Smart bus stops Dedicated cycle track Street-level visualisation heritage zone with waterfront edge 1 18 metre RoW PROPOSED SECTION 18 metre RoW PROPOSED SECTION Residential use School/ College School/ College 24 METRE RIGHT OF WAY 24 metre RoW EXISTING SECTION Existing Sidewalk Proposed Sidewalk Cycle lanes Carriage way Parking Lane Bus Lane Bus bay P November 2020
88 | Urbanism Portfolio