AHistoryofJewishLifeinMansfieldandSurroundingAreas
AustinReid
ImageofTorahscrollsatEmanuelJacobCongregation.
Photocourtesyofthe Mansfield News-Journal,September8,2007.
DedicatedtothemembersofEmanuelJacobCongregation whocarryonatraditionofJewishlifeintheMansfieldarea. AustinReid,February2023
Introduction:EarlyJewishFamiliesinMansfieldandPlymouth
Mansfield,theseatofRichlandCounty,wasfoundedin1808justfiveyearsafterOhio becameastate.Duringthevillage’searlyyears,mostresidentswereidentifiedwithProtestant denominationsincludingCongregationalism,Methodism,andPresbyterianism.Bythe mid-1800s,thediversityofChristiancongregationsinMansfieldhadgrowntoincludeCatholic, Episcopalian,andLutheranchurches.ItwasalsoduringthisperiodofgrowthforMansfieldthat thefirstJewsarrivedinthearea.MyerMilleristhe firstJewknowntohavelivedinMansfield.Anative ofwhatistodayGermany,Myerimmigratedtothe UnitedStatesin1845andarrivedinMansfieldin 1848afterspendingsometimeinAlabama.1 In 1851,MyermarriedBarbara,whowasalsoan immigrantfromCentralEurope.Myersupportedhis familybyoperatingaclothingstoreandhewas activeinthelocalMasoniclodge.2 Heisalso creditedwithorganizingMansfield’ssecond volunteerfiredepartment,TorrentFireCompanyno. 2,in1852.3
Plymouth,avillagelocated20milesnorthwestof Mansfield,wasalsohometoaJewishpresencebythemid-1850s.HannahandMosesBillstein arethefirstJewishfamilyknowntoliveinPlymouth.LiketheMillers,HannahandMoseswere immigrantsfrommodern-dayGermany.TheyraisedfivechildreninPlymouth.These individualswerenamedJennie,Rachel,Rena,Sarah,andWilliam.Sarah,whosenameisalso givenasStellainsomesources,wastheoldestofthefive.Mosessupportedhisfamilyby operatingabusinessthatboughtandsoldgrains,seeds,andwool.Thisbusinesswasaprecursor totheBachrachCompany,alivestockbusinessthatremainedactiveinPlymouthuntilatleastthe mid-1970s.MyronT.Herrick,whowouldserveasOhio’sgovernorfrom1904to1906,wasan earlyemployeeofMoses’.4 TwoothermembersoftheBillsteinfamily,MosesSr.andhiswife,
4 "Celebrate Golden Wedding," Daily Reflector (Norwalk), November 28, 1906
3 "Primitive Volunteers," Mansfield News, July 01, 1911
2 "Mansfield Has Many Lodge Men," Mansfield News, July 01, 1911
1
1 "The Pioneer Merchant," Weekly News (Mansfield), January 07, 1892.
TheresaalsolivedinPlymouthby1870.Anotherrelative,knownonlyasA.Billstein,operated theNewYorkClothingStoreonthesouthsideofPlymouth’sPublicSquareby1853. SolomonSpear,animmigrantwhoarrivedinPlymouthin1857attheageof14,was anotherearlyJewishresidentofRichlandCounty.SolomonwaslikelyacloserelativeofHannah BillsteinsinceitisknownthathermaidennamewasSpear 5 Solomonattendedaschoolin Plymouthforatimebeforebeginningtoworkasapeddler.Helatersoldlivestockbeforemoving intotheclothingbusinessby1868.6 Duringhis68yearsasaresidentofPlymouth,Solomonwas activeasamemberofthevillagecouncilandheservedonthelocalschoolboard.Histimein localgovernmentspanned27years.7 Solomonalsohasthe distinctionofbeingthefirstJewknowntohaveheld electedofficeinRichlandCounty.In1867,Solomonwed AugustaBillstein,acousin,andthefamilyraisedsix children.In1868,Solomonenteredabusinesspartnership withMosesShield,hisbrother-in-law,whowasalso Jewish.MoseshadmarriedBettySpearashorttime before.Thecouplehadtwochildren,EdithandLouis.
Duringthe1860s,atleastfouradditionalJewishfamilies settledinMansfieldorPlymouth.InMansfield,Abraham andBerthaHeinemanarrivedfromNewYorkin1866.At first,Abrahamfoundworkoperatingahorsestablealong whatisknownin2023asWestFourthStreet.8 Abraham bothboardedandsoldhorsesatthislocation.By1892,Abraham’sbusinesshadgrown significantlyandhewasconsideredoneofthemostsuccessfulhorsedealersintheUnitedStates, sellingover3,000horsesayear.9 AbrahamwasalsoengagedintheMansfieldcommunityasa memberoftheElks,KnightsofHonor,andMasons.10 TheHeinemanfamily’slegacycanstillbe feltinMansfieldintothetwenty-firstcenturywhenonevisitsMiddlePark,NorthLakePark,or SouthPark.Partofthelandfortheseparks,whichwereunitedasoneareawhencreatedin1887,
5 Obituary of Hannah Billstein, Mansfield News, January 21, 1910
6 "Solomon SpearAchieves a Long Citizenship Record," Mansfield News, May 06, 1923.
7 Ibid
8 Paul Kellam, "Mansfielders Justly Proud of 152Acres of Park, Mansfield News-Journal,August 02, 1950
9 "A J Heineman," The Weekly News (Mansfield), March 03, 1892
10 Ibid
2
wasdonatedbyAbrahamtotheCityofMansfield.AnotherportionwasgivenbySenatorJohn Sherman.Itwasinhonorofthesetwoindividualsthattheparkwasknownformanyyearsas Sherman-HeinemanPark.11 Inaddition,Abrahamisthe namesakeofHeinemanBoulevard, locatedbetweenWesternAvenueandRowlandAvenue.
InPlymouth,HermanAaron,IsraelBachrach,andAaronKappenbergallarrivedinthe villageby1866.AllthreeofthesemenlikelymovedtoPlymoutharoundthetimetheymarried membersoftheBillsteinfamily.HermanwasmarriedtoBettyandthecoupleraisedatleast threechildren.IsraelwasmarriedtoRosa.Inaddition,anotherrelativeofIsrael’s,Henry BachrachlivedinPlymouthby1866.By1869,HenrywasmarriedtoMollieBirkenruth.Aaron Kappenberg,thefinalindividuallisted,wasmarriedtoYette.Thecouplehadatleastthree children.Oneson,Myer,diedyoung.ItisknownthatIsrael,Henry,andAaronwereall professionallyrelatedtothelocallivestockbusinessasbutchersorproprietorsofmeatmarkets. HermanAaronlikelyalsosupportedhisfamilythroughasimilarlineofwork.Membersofthe BachrachfamilycontinuedtobeinvolvedinPlymouth’scattlebusinessintothe1970s.12 Ashland,locatedabout13milesnortheastofMansfield,wasalsohometoaJewish presencebythemid-1860s.ThefirstJewknowntohavelivedinAshlandwasJacobCahn.Jacob operatedaclothingstoreinAshlandby1864andin1872hewedReginaTillman.Thecouple hadatleastfivechildren.Oneofthesechildren,LouisCahnwouldgoontoleadtheJewish CharitiesofChicagofrom1920to1930.13 Inadditiontomanagingabusiness,Jacobwasactive intheAshlandcommunity.Mostnotably,heservedatleastonetermasthetown’smayoraround 1879.Afewyearsbeforethis,aKentuckynative,NathanStraussarrivedinAshlandandfound workwithJacob.NathanwouldbecomeapartnerintheCahnclothingstorein1878andin1909, whenJacobretiredfrombusiness,hetookfullownershipofthestorerenamingitN.Straussand Son.14 Thesonreferencedinthefirm’snamewasAlbert Strauss.N.StraussandSonwould remainafixtureonWestMainStreetuntil1991.15 Nathanwasalsoactiveinhelpingtocreate
11 Paul Kellam, "Mansfielders Justly Proud of 152Acres of Park, Mansfield News-Journal,August 02, 1950.
12 Ron Simon, "Cattle Raiser Predicts Reduced Food Supplies," News-Journal (Mansfield), July 01, 1973
13 “Managing Director of Jewish Charities of Chicago for 10Years,” Jewish Telegraphic Agency (New York),April 27, 1930,
https://wwwjta org/archive/managing-director-of-jewish-charities-of-chicago-for-10-years-tells-of-ideals-co nsummated-as-he-prep
14 “Decade by Decade,” Ashland Times, January 14, 2016, p 22,
https://issuu com/ashlandtimes-gazette/docs/decade by decade
15 Ibid
3
Ashland’svolunteerfiredepartment,whichwasorganizedin1883,andforatimeheservedas thetown’sfirechief.16
BeforemovingintothebeginningsoforganizedJewishlifeintheMansfieldarea,itis appropriatetohighlighttwootherearlyJewishfamilies.In1871,HenriettaMillerofMansfield wedAdolphDittenhoefer,anativeofCleveland.Henrietta,whowasalsoknownasEttie,was thedaughterofBarbaraandMyerMiller.In1872,AdolphjoinedMyer’sclothingbusiness locatedatthecornerofNorthMainandThirdStreetinMansfield.Thefirmtookonthename Miller&Dittenhoeferby1886.In1892,MyerretiredfrombusinessandAdolphcarriedonthe store.Atthetimeofhisretirement,MyerwasMansfield’soldestmerchant.17 Adolphcontinued toworkuntilhisdeathin1905.MortimerandSamuel,thetwosonsofAdolphandHenrietta, relocatedtoMinnesotabytheoutbreakofWorldWarI.OverinPlymouth,WilliamandBetty Schoenbergwerelivingandworkingby1870.Betty,whowasthedaughterofMosesSr.and TheresaBillstein,marriedWilliamaround1861andthecoupleraisedfivechildreninPlymouth. William,whoatthetimeofhisdeathin1902wasdescribedasoneofthearea’soldestJewish residents,supportedhisfamilybybuyingandsellinglivestock,grains,seeds,andwool.18 The Schoenbergfamily’spresenceinPlymouthwouldnotendure,however,sinceallofthe SchoenbergchildrenultimatelyrelocatedtoChicagoasadults.19
TheBeginningsofOrganizedJewishLifeinMansfield
Duringthelate1870sand1880s,afewnewJewishfamiliessettledinMansfield. IncludedamongtheseindividualswereLouisFreundlich,SamuelLowenstein,andJosephNew. LouisFreundlich,anativeofWaldsee,Germany,arrivedintheUnitedStatesaround1878atthe ageof18.20 In1888,herelocatedtoMansfieldwithhiswife,Laura,andopenedamen'sclothing storeattheMillerOperaHouse.TragedystruckLouisthissameyear,however,whenLauradied. Laura’smaidennamewasWertheimer.Arelative,DavidWertheimer,wasanearlybusiness partneralongsideLouis.FewreferencesexistmentioningDavid,however,and,inashorttime, Freundlich&WertheimerbecameknownastheFreundlichCompany.TheFreundlichCompany
16 Ibid
17 "The Pioneer Merchant," Weekly News, January 07, 1892
18 Obituary of William Schoenberg, Mansfield News, November 26, 1902
19 Ibid
20 "Louis Freundlich is Dead Veteran Leader inTrade, Civic Life Summoned," Mansfield News, October 19, 1932
4
movedseveraltimesasitexpandedand,in1928,Louisopenedanewthree-storylocationatthe cornerofWestThirdStreetandWalnutStreet.Thisbuilding,whichin2019,housedaGirl ScoutsofficeandWestfieldBank,stillstandsasof2022.In1893,Louiswedhissecondwife, RettaEppinger,whowasanativeofCincinnati.RettalivedinMansfielduntilherdeathin 1946.21 BothLouisandRettawereactivemembersoftheiradoptedcommunity.Louiswas highlyinvolvedinlocalcivicaffairsandheldmembershipswiththeElks,Kiwanis,Masons, ModernWoodman,andOddFellows.Atthetimeofhisdeathin1932,theeditorsof The Mansfield News remarked:
…ToknowLouisFreundlichwastolovehim,torespecthisintegrityofpurpose,to admirehiscourage,towelcomecontactswithhisremarkablepersonality,topraisehis generosityandphilanthropy.LouisFreundlich'slifeandcharacterstandasanexampleof whatperseverance,honesty,andkindnesscanaccomplish.22
Retta,inadditiontobeinganotedmusician,wasactivewiththelocalWomen'sCluband Woman'sFederation.ShealsoservedontheboardofdirectorsfortheFriendlyHouse,an organizationthatwillbementionedagainlaterinthiswork.23 Additionally,bothLouisandRetta wereactiveinMansfield’sfirstJewishcongregation,TempleEmanuel,whosebeginningswillbe highlightedinthecomingparagraphs.
SamuelLowensteinandJosephNewwere,likeLouis,involvedinMansfield’sclothing business.BothalsooperatedstoresalongNorthMainStreet.SamuelresidedinMansfieldby 1883,whileJosepharrivedby1888.Thissameyear, allsixoftheclothierslistedinthe Herald’s Directory to Mansfield, Ohio wereJewish.24 TheprominenceofJewsinlocalclothingretailwas partofalargernationalpatternthatwasaproductofthetimingofthesector’sdevelopmentand thebeginningoflarge-scaleJewishimmigrationtotheUnitedStates.Clothingretaildeveloped onanationallevelduetotheinventionofsteam-poweredloomsandothermachinerythat allowedfortherapidproductionofclothes.Bythemid-1800s,thesemachineswerebecoming morecommonintheUnitedStates,andboththemanufactureandretailofclothingwererapidly
21 "Civic Worker Dies atAge 78," Mansfield News-Journal, October 19, 1946
22 Obituary of Louis Freundlich, Mansfield News, October 19, 1932
23 "Civic Worker Dies atAge 78," Mansfield News-Journal, October 19, 1946
24 Ritchey andAlbertson, The Herald’s Directory to Mansfield, Ohio 1888-1889 (Mansfield, Ohio:The Herald Company, 1888), p 214
5
expandingjustasawaveofJewishimmigrationfromCentralEuropewasoccurring.Facedwith limitedjobprospects,manyJewsfoundworkintheburgeoningclothingmanufacturingand retailsectorsandtheirdescendantscontinuedtoplaykeyrolesinthearea.Returningto Mansfield,unliketheFreundlichfamily,bothSamuelandJosephleftRichlandCountyby1900. SamuelrelocatedtoCantonandJosephleftforYoungstown.Itisofnote,however,that TheodoreNew,Joseph’sbrother,andbusinesspartner,remainedinMansfielduntilafter1904. Whilemodestinsize,theJewishcommunityofMansfieldandsurroundingtownswas largeenoughbythe1870sthatmembersbegantoorganizereligiousservicesinprivatehomes. Mansfield’scurrentJewishcongregation,EmanuelJacob,tracesitsrootstotheseintimate gatherings.25 Nocontemporaryrecordofthesegatheringshasbeenlocated,however,andsome sourcesinlateryearsplacedthebeginningofMansfield’sorganizedJewishcommunityin1886 whenagroupofwomengatheredtosewarticlesofclothingforEuropeanrefugees.26 Bertha Heinemanisoneindividualwhoisknowntohavebeenassociatedwiththisearlygroupof Jewishwomen.27 Duringthe1890s,theJewishpopulationofRichlandCountycontinuedtogrow slowlywiththearrivalofMosesGoldberg,JosephGoldberger,BerthaandDavidGoldsmith,and AnnaandIsraelSchoenfield.MosesGoldberg,anativeofPoland,arrivedinMansfieldby1900 andfoundworkasajewelerandpawnbroker.JosephGoldbergerworkedasascrapmetaldealer inShelby,12milesnorthwestofMansfieldby1900. BerthaandDavidGoldsmithlikelylivedinMansfieldby1890andthecouplehadfour children,Aaron,Carrie,Julius,andLouis.Davidsupportedhisfamilythroughhisworkwiththe FreundlichCompany,wherehewasemployedforabout40years.28 Asourcefrom1922, however,statesthattheGoldsmithfamilydidnotarriveinMansfielduntil1894.29 Aaron GoldsmithwastheonlychildofBerthaandDavidtoremaininMansfieldpast1923.Carrie relocatedtoNewark,NewJerseyfollowinghermarriagetoJacobMarderin1907.Juliusspent timeinbothSt.LouisandChicagobeforeultimatelysettlinginAtlantaby1930.Louislivedin Brooklynby1923andworkedinrealestate.AarontoospenttimeoutsideofMansfield.During the1910s,helivedandworkedinIndianapolisbeforereturningtoMansfieldtotakea
25 “History of Emanuel Jacob Congregation,” Emanuel Jacob Congregation, accessed September 30, 2022, https://emanueljacob org/about-us-2/
26 “KnowYour ChurchesTemple Emanuel,” Mansfield News-Journal, November 23, 1957
27 Jayson Schlechty, “Two Jewish Congregations Become One,” Mansfield/Richland County Public Library, December 04, 2021, https://theshermanroom wordpress com/author/theshermanroom/
28 "Merchant Here 46Years Dies," Mansfield News,August 05, 1932
29 “Dean of Salesmen Now 70Years Old,” Mansfield News, January 04, 1922
6
managementpositionwithFreundlich’s.30 In1924,Aaronopenedanewclothingstore, Goldsmith’sMen’sStoreonNorthMainStreet.31 Hisfather,David,alsoleftFreundlich’sto workinthenewstore.
MovingtotheSchoenfieldfamily,IsraelSchoenfieldwasoneof16childrenraisedby DorettaandMosesSchoenfield.32 WhilemostmembersoftheSchoenfieldfamilyresidedin easternOhio,Israelandhiswife,Anna,livedinMansfieldby1880andmayhaveleftforatime beforereturningtoRichlandCountyaround1891.Thecoupleraisedatleastfivechildrenand Israelsupportedhisfamilybyoperatingaclothingstoreandlaterahotel.Shortlyafter1907,the familyleftMansfield.Sixyearsearlier,AnnaSchoenfielddied.IsraelSchoenfielddiedin1914 whileinPittsburghandisburiedalongsidehiswifeatMansfieldCemetery.Mostofthe24 Jewishhouseholdsprofiledsofarinthisworkshareacommonexperienceasfirstor second-generationAmericanswithrootsinGerman-speakingJewishcommunitiesinCentral Europe.Asthetwentiethcenturybegan,however,anincreasingnumberofJewsintheMansfield areatracedtheirroots,nottocommunitiesinCentralEurope,butrathertolocationsfurthereast includingHungary,Lithuania,Poland,Romania,Russia,andUkraine.Thisshiftlocally coincidedwithanationalchangeinJewishimmigrantpatterns.Between1880and1924,an estimatedtwomillionJewsimmigratedtotheUnitedStatesfromEasternEuropeinresponseto limitedeconomicopportunitiesandviolentpersecution.Thesemorerecentimmigrantsandtheir descendantswouldplayanimportantroleinthedevelopmentofMansfield’sJewishcommunity
InJanuary1904itwasreportedbythe Jewish Review and Observer,anewspaperoutof Cleveland,thataJewishcongregationwasformedinMansfield.33 MyerMillerwaselectedthe congregation’sfirstpresident.TheotherofficersofthecongregationwereLouisFreundlich,first vicepresident,IsraelSchoenfield,vicepresident,WilliamFoust,secretary,andSolomonLoeb, treasurer.34 Inaddition,SamuelDittenhoefer,MosesGoldberg,AbrahamMarks,HenryWeil,and AlexWeissagerwerealsoamongthegroup'sinauguralmembers.Intotal,thenewcongregation hadabout20members.Whileseveralofthenameslistedhavealreadybeenprofiled,fiveofthe surnamesarenewandmeritfurtherdetail.Movinginorderofreference,WilliamFoustand SolomonLeobwerebusinesspartnerswhooperatedaclothingstoreat80NorthMainStreet.
7
34 Ibid 33 “Circuit Work in Ohio,” Jewish Review and Observer (Cleveland), January 08, 1904 32 "Ohio," Daily Ohio State Journal (Columbus), January 07, 1879 31 "Mall Draws Heavily from WoosterArea, Poll Shows," News Journal, December 13, 1969 30 "Manager of Store," Mansfield News, May 19, 1919
Thisfirm,whichopenedshortlybefore1904,alsoengagedSolomon’sson,Benjamin,and sister-in-law,Friedainitsearlymonths.AbrahamMarks,wholivedinMansfieldby1899, operatedaclothingstorealongNorthMainStreet.HewasmarriedtoIdaandthecouplehadat leastthreechildren.HenryWeil,animmigrantfrom Alsace,openedtheGlobeClothing CompanyinMansfieldin1902.35 By1904,Henry’sson,Manuel,whowasalsoknownas Monnie,workedalongsidehisfatherandtheclothingbusinesstookonthenameHenryWeil& Son.36 Thefinalindividuallistedabove,AlexWeissager, movedtoMansfieldwithhiswife, Mollieshortlybefore1904.HeworkedasmanagerofthePeople’sClothingCompany,which waslocatedinsidethePurdyBuildingonSouthMainStreet.
OneearlyactiontakenbythemembersofMansfield’snascentJewishcongregationwas toorganizeareligiousschoolfortheinstructionofyouths.HenryHaupt,RuthLoeb,Doris Marks,HaroldMarks,MortimerMarks,andLeonSchoenfieldwereamongtheearlieststudents enrolledintheschool.Thecommunityalsohiredtheservicesofarabbiwhocouldvisit Mansfieldwhenneededtoleadreligiousservices.RabbiAlfredGodshawisthefirstordained personknowntohaveministeredtotheMansfieldJewishcommunity.37 RabbiIsadorPhiloof Akronwasanotherearlyvisitingministerforthecongregation,whichhadadoptedthename MansfieldReformedJewishCongregation.38 Thisnamesymbolizedtheidentificationofthe congregationwiththeReformmovementofJudaism.ReformJudaism,whichtracesitsoriginsto earlynineteenth-centuryCentralEurope,emphasizesJudaism’sethicalpreceptsoverreligious lawsand,intheAmericancontextduringthelatenineteenthandearlytwentiethcenturies,its adherentssoughttomakeJewishpracticemorecompatiblewiththerealitiesoflifeintheUnited States.LiturgicalchangesadvocatedbymanyReformJewsduringthelate1800sincludedmixed seatinginsynagogues,theintroductionoforgansandotherinstrumentsintoreligiousservices, andtheabolitionofheadcoveringsduringservices.
35 "Death Claims Henry Weil, 82," Mansfield News-Journal, December 22, 1937
36 "Has Long BeenActive inAffairs of the Retailer," Mansfield News, September 28, 1922
Duringitsearlyyears,themembersoftheMansfieldReformedJewishCongregationmet inavarietyoflocations.ThesesitesincludedtheformerY.M.C.A.buildingat45WestPark Avenue,thebasementoftheMansfieldPublicLibraryat45WestThirdStreet,andaroom locatedabovetheKnightsofColumbusHallatthecornerofFourthandMainstreets.39 By1910, 39 Ibid 38 “Temple, Synagogue Serve Jewish Congregations,” Mansfield News-Journal,August 02, 1950 37 “Circuit Work in Ohio,” Jewish Review and Observer (Cleveland), January 08, 1904
8
however,thecommunityseemstohavebecomemoresettled.Accordingtothe1910-1911 MansfieldCityDirectory,whichwasthefirstcitydirectorytolistthelocalJewishcongregation amongthevariousmunicipalchurches,the“JewishCongregation”waslocatedintheBowers BlockatthecornerofFourthandMain.By1922,thissamecongregationhadadoptedthename TempleEmanuel.
WomenhaveplayedanimportantroleinMansfield’sJewishcommunitysinceitsearliest beginnings.Asnotedearlier,somesourcestracethebeginningsoforganizedJewishlifein Mansfieldtoagroupofwomenwhofirstgatheredin1886tosewarticlesofclothingfor Europeanrefugees.40 By1890,thisgroupofwomenhadadoptedthenameJewishLadies’Aid Society.Membersofthesocietysupportedlocal,national,andinternationalcharitablecauses. Forexample,in1900membersraised$5tosupportvictimsoftheGalvestonhurricane.41 This sumisequivalenttoapproximately$176in2022.EarlymembersoftheJewishLadies’Aid SocietyincludedBessieBein,MarieHaupt,SelmaLoeb,andBerthaWeil.BessieBein,who livedinNewYorkCityandChicagoforatime,arrivedinMansfieldwithherhusband,Joseph, andtheirsevenchildrenin1911.ThefamilywassupportedthroughJoseph’sworkwithThe Model,awomen’sclothingstoreonNorthMainStreet.42 Thisstoreinitsearlyyearswasowned byJoseph’srelativeAbrahamBein.AbrahamresidedinAkronandlaterPortsmouth,Ohio,while JosephmanagedtheMansfieldshop.By1922,Josephpurchasedthestoreandwasinbusiness forhimself.MarieHaupt,anativeofBrooklyn,arrivedinMansfieldby1902alongwithher husband,JosephHaupt.Josephworkedasasuperintendentatacigarfactoryatthecornerof NorthAdamsandEastFifthStreetownedbytheAmericanCigarCompany Thecouplehad threesonsArthur,Chester,andHenry.AllthreewouldeventuallymoveawayfromMansfield. Marie’stimeasamemberoftheJewishLadies’Aid Societywasparticularlynoteworthy becausesheservedasthegroup'spresidentforovereightyearsbeginningin1925.43 SelmaLoebwasmarriedtoSamuelLoeb,thesonofLenaand Solomon.In1907,Samuel workedwiththeOhioBrassCompany.Around1918,SamuelandSelmarelocatedto Racine, Wisconsin,wheretheylivedfor15years.In1933,thecouplereturnedtoMansfieldafterSamuel acceptedapositionwiththeFreundlichCompany 44 Thesociety’sfinalmemberlistedabove,
44 “On Store Staff,” Mansfield News-Journal
25, 1933 43 "Sisterhood PlansAffair Honoring Mrs Joseph Haupt," Mansfield News-Journal, May 03, 1933 42 "RitesArranged for Joseph Bein," Mansfield News-Journal, August 01, 1946 41 “Help the Sufferers,” Mansfield News, September 20, 1900 40 “KnowYour ChurchesTemple Emanuel,” Mansfield News-Journal, November 23, 1957 9
, July
BerthaWeil wasthewifeofHenryandthemotherofManuel.In1938,shortlyafterthedeathof Henry,BertharelocatedtoCincinnati.Shepassedawayin1942.45 By1920,theJewishLadies’ AidSocietywasrenamedtheTempleSisterhoodofMansfield.Twoyearslater,thegroupwas knownastheTempleEmanuelSisterhood.Thisnamechangesignifiedtheorganization'sclose tiewithTempleEmanuelanditseffortstosupportthegrowingcongregation.Sisterhood membersalsotookaleadingroleinmaintainingthecongregation’sreligiousschooland organizedoutingssuchaspicnicsforitsmembers.46
DevelopmentsDuringWorldWarIandthe1920s
In1907,itwasestimatedthataround50JewslivedinMansfield.47 Thenext20years wereatimeofsignificantgrowthforthecity’sJewishcommunityandtheperiodwasmarkedby severalmajorcommunaldevelopments.ThesemilestonesincludedthecreationofaB’naiB’rith lodgeandtheformationofasecondJewishcongregation,B’naiJacob.AmongthenewJewish familiestosettleinMansfieldbetween1902and1927wereRobertandShirleyBlock,Henry andStellaCominsky,JacobandGussieCousins,HannahandIsraelFineberg,EffieandSamuel Fox,EdgarandSelmaJoseph,GertrudeandSamuelKrosinsky,EstherandHymanMosberg, AbrahamandRebeccaRappaport,MosesandRebeccaRatner,BessieandPhilipRosenbaum, andCarlandMarySternbaum.RobertandShirleyBlock,thefirstcouplelisted,arrivedin Mansfieldaround1924.Robertworkedasamanageratthe MansfieldDryGoodsCompany.By 1928,however,thefamilyhadleftthearea.Eightyearslater,in1936,theMansfieldDryGoods CompanywassoldtoKobacker's,achainwithstoresbasedinNewYorkandOhio.48 Henryand StellaCominskylivedinMansfieldby1922.Henryworkedasadriveratthe DeLuxeCab Companybeforestartinghisowncabbusiness.49 JacobandGussieCousins,wholivedin Mansfieldby1902andwerewithoutchildren,werebothhighlyengagedintheircommunity. JacobwasactiveinmanycivicandsocialorganizationsincludingtheChamberofCommerce, Elks,KnightsofPythias,Masons,andOddFellows.50 Hewasalsorememberedafterhisdeath
45 "Ex-Mansfield Resident Dies," Mansfield News-Journal, April 13, 1942
46 “Jewish Sunday School HoldsAnnual Picnic,” Mansfield News, July 20, 1922
47 American JewishYearbook Vol 16, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society ofAmerica, 1914: 373, https://ajcarchives org/AJC DATA/Files/1914 1915 7 Statistics pdf
48 “Plan Building,” Mansfield News-Journal,April 28, 1936
49 "Cab Owner Dies," Mansfield News-Journal, May 13, 1937
50 S B Goodkind, Eminent Jews of America (Toledo: TheAmerican Hebrew Biographical Company, 1918), 54
10
forthediscreetwaysheaidedthoseinneedlocally.51 Jacobmadealivingasanentrepreneurwho createdtheJ.M.CousinsScrapIronCompany.Thisscrapyard,laterknownasCousins Incorporated,remainedinexistenceuntil2002whenitmergedwithMetalConversionsLimited Company 52 MetalConversionscontinuestooperateinMansfieldasof2022.GussieCousins,a nativeofToledo,wasactiveintheEasternStar,KnightsofPythias,andRedCross.53 HannahandIsraelFineberg,thenextcouplelistedabove,operatedaclothingstoreon NorthMainStreetby1917.Thecouplehadthreechildren Charles,Bertha,andMinnie.Effieand SamuelFoxmovedtoMansfieldin1922afterSamueltookajobwith RodgerJewelryCompany. In1940,Samuelopenedhisownstore,SamFoxJewelryat12WestParkAvenue.54 Edgarand SelmaJosephlivedinMansfieldby1917andEdgaroperatedthe ConardExtractCompany. SelmawasthemotherofatleasttwochildrenandwasactiveintheJewishLadies’AidSociety. GertrudeandSamuelKrosinskylivedinMansfieldby1908andSamuelworkedinavarietyof rolesincludingasaclothier,cobbler,andtailor.EstherandHymanMosbergarrivedinMansfield in1911andHymanatfirstfoundworkasatailor.Laterhewentintotherealestatebusiness.55 AbrahamandRebeccaRappaportarrivedinMansfieldin1911.LikeJacobCousins,Abraham foundworkasascrapmetaldealer.56 MosesandRebeccaRatneroperatedtheRodgerJewelry Companytogetherfrom1923until1945.57 In1945,thestorewassoldtoHarryMorris.Harry wasrelatedtoMosesandRebeccathroughhiswife,Mildred,whowasRebecca’ssister.Mildred andHarrywerewedin1930,andHarryhadworkedwithMosessince1943.Beforethis,he operatedMorris'Ready-to-Wear,ashopat54NorthMainStreet,from1914to1930.58 Between 1930and1943,HarryworkedoutsideofMansfield.BessieandPhilipRosenbaummovedto MansfieldfromCincinnatiin1913.Philipoperatedthe CincinnatiMerchandiseStoreat222 NorthMainStreet.
CarlandMarySternbaum,thefinalcouplelistedabove,arrivedinMansfieldin1917. BothhusbandandwifewereborninWarsawandwedbeforeimmigratingtotheUnitedStates.
51 "Few Knew of His Benefactions," Mansfield News-Journal, May 11, 1950
52 “Four Metals FirmsAnnounce Merger,” Recycling Today (Valley View, Ohio),August 05, 2022, https://wwwrecyclingtodaycom/article/four-metals-firms-announce-merger/
53 S B Goodkind, Eminent Jews of America (Toledo: TheAmerican Hebrew Biographical Company, 1918), 54
54 "Samuel V Fox, 72, Jeweler, Succumbs," News Journal, January 20, 1970
55 "Hyman Mosberg, 73, DiesAfter Brief Illness," Mansfield News-Journal,August 03, 1955
56 "A Rappaport Dies at 72," Mansfield News-Journal, March 08, 1949
57 "Founder of Store Dies," Mansfield News-Journal, January 02, 1950
58 Virginia Lee, "Salesman for 68Years - so Far," News Journal, December 14, 1975
11
DuringhisearlyyearsinRichlandCounty,Carlsupportedhisfamilybyoperatingameat market.Bytheearly1950s,thissmallbusinesshadgrownintooneofOhio’slargest family-ownedsupermarketchains.59 In1953,SternbaumCompleteFoodMartshadlocationsin Ashland,Fremont,Mansfield,andWillard.Atleast250peoplewereemployedbythe company 60 CarlandMarywerealsonotedphilanthropistsinMansfield.Morewillbewritten abouttheSternbaumfamilyinthesectionofthisworkcoveringthe1950s.
OnApril6,1917,CongressvotedtodeclarewaronGermany,markingtheentryofthe UnitedStatesintoWorldWarI.AlongsidemillionsofAmericans,Jewsandnon-Jewsin RichlandCountydidtheirparttosupportthewareffort.AtleastfivelocalJewsareknownto haveserved.TheirnamesareLouisBachrach,MauriceBachrach,RoyalBein,Jerome Freundlich,andBenjaminLoeb.LouisBachrachopenedadentalpracticeinMansfieldshortly beforetheUnitedStatesenteredWorldWarI.Duringhisenlistment,Louisservedinthedental corps.Afterthewar,hereturnedtoMansfieldandpractiseddentistryforover40years.61 Hewas alsoactiveinthelocalAmericanLegionpostandTempleEmanuel.62 In1917,LouiswedSara Rosenblatt,anativeofMissouri.SarawasanactivememberoftheTempleEmanuelSisterhood.
MauriceBachrach,thesonofHenryandMollieBachrachwhowerementionedearlyin thiswork,returnedtoPlymouthafterthewartocontinueworkinginthelivestockbusiness. RoyalBein,thesonofBessieandJoseph,servedintheArmy.Followingthewar,heresumedhis studiesattheUniversityofPennsylvania.JeromeFreundlich,thesonofLouisandRetta,served intheArmy.Followingthewar,heresumedhisworkwiththeFreundlichCompany.Inthisrole, JeromewasknowntoassistindividualscomingoutoftheOhioStateReformatorybyproviding themwithjobsandothersupport.HealsoledreligiousservicesattheReformatoryforJewish inmates.63 BenjaminLoeb,thesonofLenaandSolomon,servedwiththe29thUnitedStates RegimentalBandduringthewar.AfterreturningtoMansfield,heresumedworkingwithhis fatheratLoeb&Son,aclothingstoreat80NorthMain.ThisstorewasasuccessortoLoeb& Foust.OnthehomefrontJewsalsocontributedtothewareffort.Forexample,themembersof theJewishLadies’AidSocietysupportedtheRedCrossbysewingneededarticlesandraising
59 “Company Head Dies,” Mansfield News-Journal, March 03, 1954
60 “250 Will Get Bonuses,” Mansfield News-Journal, December 14, 1953
61 "Dr Bachrach DiesAfter Long Illness," Mansfield News-Journal, November 17, 1958
62 Ibid
63 "J J Freundlich, Mansfield Merchant, Dies," Mansfield News-Journal, February 14, 1935
12
fundsforwarbonds.64 Inaddition,LouisFreundlichservedaschairmanofseveralLibertyLoan committees.LibertyLoanswereonewaytheUnitedStatesgovernmentraisedmoneytosupport thewareffort.
In1917anewJewishorganization,B’naiB’rith,wasorganizedinMansfield.65 This group,whichhad33membersinitsinauguralyear,wasaffiliatedwiththenationalB’naiB’rith organizationandwasgiventhelodgenumber797.66 Shortlyafter,in1919,planswereannounced detailingeffortstobuildasynagogueinMansfield.67 Atthetime,itwasestimatedthat approximately75peopleweremembersofthelocalJewishcongregation.68 Inadditiontoserving asaplaceofworship,itwasenvisionedthatthenewbuildingwouldincludemeetingspacesfor thenewB’naiB’rithlodgeandJewishLadies’AidSociety.Inthe Mansfield News piece highlightingtheplansforthenewsynagogue,itwasemphasizedthatthisspacewouldwelcome notonlyJewsfromMansfieldbutalsothoselivinginnearbytownsincludingAshland,Bucyrus, Crestline,Galion,andShelby.SeveralJewishfamiliesarrivedinthesesmallertownsbetween 1895and1919.ThesefamiliesincludedNathanandNettieFliegel,BelleandWilliamGlick, AnneandLouisGoodman,SamuelandSophiaGrundstein,EstellaandLouisKomito,Hattieand SolomonMeyers,MaryandMaxOxman,andIdaandJacobRoth.
NathanandNettieFliegeloperatedtheFashionCompany,awomen'sclothingstorein Ashland,beginningin1914.Thestorewaslocatedat116WestMainStreetuntil1930whenit movedtoEastMain.69 BelleandWilliamGlicklived inWillard,atownlocated25miles northwestofMansfield.BellewasthedaughterofIsraelandRosaBachrachofPlymouth. WilliamoperatedaclothingstorealongsideAbrahamBachrach,whowasBelle’sbrother The partnerswereinbusinesstogetherby1910.AbrahammovedtoWillardfrom MissouriValley, Iowain1901.DuringhistimeinMissouriValley,Abrahamboughtandsoldlivestockandfora timeservedasthetown’smayor.70 AnneandLouisGoodmanarrivedinGalion,atown17miles westofMansfield,in1919.Louiswasassociatedwitha manufacturingplantknownastheOhio OvercoatCompanyandworkedasthefirm’ssecretaryandtreasurer.TwootherJews,Harry
64 “Aid Society Members Sew for Red Cross Society,” Mansfield News, May 14, 1918.
65 “Israeli Official to Speak at B’nai B’rith Celebration,” Mansfield News-Journal, November 04, 1966
66 Nina Liston, “Jews of Mansfield EnjoyTheir Small-Town Life,” Cleveland Jewish News, February 01, 1974
67 “Modern JewishTemple to be Errected [sic] in Mansfield Soon,” Mansfield News, October 05, 1919
68 Ibid
69 “Ashland Main Street,”Ashland on the Margins, accessed October 02, 2022, https://sites google com/site/ashlandonthemargins/ashland-main-street
70 "Plymouth," Mansfield Weekly News, March 10, 1892
13
FellenbaumandMartinGoodman,werealsoamongthecompany’searlyleaders.Louisretired fromthebusinessin1959andmovedtoShakerHeights,OhiowithAnne.71 SamuelandSophia GrundsteinlivedinAshlandby1918.Samueloperatedascrapmetalbusiness.
EstellaandLouisKomitomovedtoBellville,avillagelocatedabout11milessouthof Mansfield,in1903.Here,LouisoperatedabranchofRichmanBrothers,aclothingchainbased outofCleveland.In1918,LouisandEstellamovedtoMansfieldafterLouisacceptedaposition withtheRichmanBrothersstoreat17NorthParkStreet.In1926,Estelladiedandwasburiedin Cleveland.By1930,LouishadmarriedHannahFineberg.Hannah’sfirsthusbandwasIsrael Fineberg,whohasalreadybeenmentionedinthiswork.By1935,Louisoperatedhisclothing storeonNorthParkStreetunderthenameKomito’sClothes.HattieandSolomonMeyerslived inCrestline,avillageabout13mileswestofMansfield,by1910.Solomonsupportedhisfamily byworkingasascrapdealer.MaryandMaxOxmanlivedinShelbyby1917and,likeSolomon Meyers,Maxworkedasascrapdealer 72 Asoccurredinclothingretail,thenotablepresenceof Jewsinthelocalscrapindustrywasduetotherecentdevelopmentofthetradeandits accessibilitytocontemporaryimmigrantslivingintheUnitedStates.Operatingascrapyardwas alsoparticularlyattainableformanyJewishimmigrantsbecauseofthelowstartupcosts associatedwiththesector.ReligiousJewscouldalsocreatetheirownworkschedulesaround holidaysandotherobservanceswhichwouldnothavebeenpermittedinlargerfactories.By 1930 Fortune magazineestimatedthat90percentof scrapmetalyardsintheUnitedStateswere ownedbyJews.73 IdaandJacobRoth,thelastcouplelistedamongthenewerarrivalsinsmall townssurroundingMansfield,livedinAshlandby1910.Jacobworkedasaclothingsalesman. While$10,000wasraisedtosupportthecreationofanewMansfieldsynagoguein1919, theprojectwouldnotbeaccomplisheduntil1929whenthemembersofTempleEmanuel purchasedthehomeofThomasBarnesat132WestSecondStreetandconverteditintoa synagogue.74 ThomaswasthepresidentandtreasureroftheBarnesManufacturingCompany, whichproducedpumpsandotherplumbingsupplies.Twokeydonorswhosupportedthe communityinpurchasingtheBarnespropertywereJacobCousinsandJeromeFreundlich.75 Five
71 "Retires fromActive Role in Galion Firm," Mansfield News-Journal,August 28, 1959
72 “DeathTakes Max Oxman at Shelby,” Mansfield News-Journal, June 04, 1946
73 Joe Eskenazi, “Junkyard Jews,” Jewish News of Northern California (San Francisco),August 20, 2004
74 Jayson Schlechty, “Two Jewish Congregations Become One,” Mansfield/Richland County Public Library, December 04, 2021, https://theshermanroom wordpress com/author/theshermanroom/
75 “News in Brief,” Jewish Telegraphic Agency (New York), December 08, 1929, https://wwwjta org/archive/news-in-brief-9
14
yearsearlier,in1924,TempleEmanuelreceiveditsofficialcharterasareligiousorganization fromtheStateofOhio.76 AfterthepurchaseoftheBarnesproperty,TempleEmanuelwas sometimesreferredtoinMansfieldastheSecondStreetTemple.In1927,aseparateJewish congregationformedinMansfieldthatpracticedOrthodoxJudaism.Thisnewcommunity adoptedthename,B’naiJacob.ThirteenfamilieswereaffiliatedwithB’naiJacobwithinitsfirst year 77 Itislikely,however,thatOrthodoxreligiousserviceswerebeingorganizedinMansfield atleastfiveyearsearlier.The1922MansfieldCityDirectoryrecordsa“JewishCongregation” meetinginthePurdyBlockat24SouthMainStreetthatwasdistinctfromTempleEmanuelin theBowersBuilding.DuringtheearlyyearsofB’naiJacob,serviceswerealsoheldatthe AmericanLegion,BowersBuilding,Eagleslodge,andMooselodge.78 In1930,B’naiJacob’s membersmovedtheirservicestotheDixonbuildinglocatedatthecornerofFourthandMain streets.
AkeyfigureintheestablishmentofB’naiJacobwasJacobCousins.Jacobservedasthe congregation’sfirstpresidentandthecommunityadoptedthename,B’naiJacobtohonorboth thebiblicalpatriarchandJacobCousins.79 From1934to 1942,B’naiJacobheldmanyofitsreligiousservicesand othercongregationalactivitiesat132WestSecondStreet, sharingthespacewithTempleEmanuel.80 Inadditionto sharingphysicalspace,B’naiJacobandTempleEmanuel alsosharedreligiousleadershipatvarioustimes.DavidRub, anativeofHungary,wasthefirstrabbitoministeratB’nai Jacob.HewashiredbythemembersofMansfield’s OrthodoxJewishcommunityin1925.81 By1932,Davidwas alsoministeringtothemembersofTempleEmanuelon ferentoccasions.Healsoservedasachaplainatthe Ohio StateReformatoryduringhis24yearsasaresidentof
81 “Mansfield Personalities in News During Past Week,” Mansfield News-Journal, December 22, 1946 80 “Temple, Synagogue Serve Jewish Congregations,” Mansfield News-Journal,August 02, 1950 79 "PayTribute to Founder," Mansfield News-Journal, May 19, 1951 78 Ibid 77 “Temple, Synagogue Serve Jewish Congregations,” Mansfield News-Journal,August 02, 1950 76 “Temple, Synagogue Serve Jewish Congregations,” Mansfield News-Journal,August 02, 1950 15
APeriodofChallengesandGrowth,EventsFrom1930
to1945
Theyearsbetween1930and1965wereatimeofgrowthfortheMansfieldJewish community.Nationalandinternationalevents,includingtheGreatDepression,WorldWarII,and thepost-warbabyboomallimpactedMansfield.Tokeepthisworkbetterorganized,thisperiod ofgrowthwillbeexaminedintwodistinctparts.Thefirstportionwillconsidercommunal developmentsduringtheGreatDepressionandWorldWarII.Thesecondsectionwillprofilethe yearsfollowingWorldWarIIupuntiltheJewishcommunityofMansfieldbegantoexperience demographiccontraction.In1937,itwasestimatedbytheUnitedJewishAppeal,anational philanthropicorganization,that270JewslivedinMansfield.82 Thisrepresentsaremarkable increaseof260percentfromtheJewishpopulationestimategivenin1919.Forcomparison, between1920and1940,theCityofMansfieldasawholegrewby9,330people,or33percent accordingtocensusrecords.WhileitshouldbenotedthatobtainingexactstatisticsforJewish populationsintheUnitedStatesisdifficult,andthatthe1919estimatebythe Mansfield News includedonlyJewswhowereaffiliatedwithTempleEmanuel,itisstillindisputablethatthe localJewishcommunitygrewsignificantlyduringthe1920sand1930s.
IncludedamongthenewfamilieswhoarrivedinMansfieldandsurroundingareas betweentheyears1925and1935arethesurnamesBerick,Booksbaum,Chernoff,Ellison, Frankel,Goldman,Goldstein,Goler,Hayfer,Klein,Levant,Marcus,Meisel,Mintz,Munster, Post,Preis,Selfman,Silverman,andStern.BeatriceandMeyerBerick,whowereboth immigrants,livedinMansfieldby1932.Meyersupportedhisfamilybyoperatingthe Mansfield FishCompany.BenjaminandRoseBooksbaumarrivedinMansfieldby1928andoperatedthe MansfieldPantsStore,whichwaslocatedalongNorthMainStreet.In1958,theMansfieldPants Storeclosed,andBenjaminandRoseopenedanewstore,MainSurplusSalesat144NorthMain Street.83 HowardChernoff,whodoesnotseemtohavehadawifewhilelivinginMansfield, workedastheadvertisingmanagerofthe Mansfield News-Journal duringthe1930s.84 Davidand SadieEllisonlivedinMansfieldby1927andoperatedtheOhioBrokerageCompany,aclothing storeonNorthMainStreet.AfterDavid’sdeathin1957,SadieremarriedFrankSchuster.85 Frank
82 American JewishYearbook Vol 50, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society ofAmerica, 1949: 681, https://ajcarchives org/AJC DATA/Files/1948 1949 18 Statistics pdf
83 "Mrs Booksbaum Stricken atAge 72," News Journal, July 27, 1970
84 "Howard ChernoffAddresses Group," Mansfield News-Journal, February 13, 1936
85 Karen Eagleston, interview by Nancy Shimer, 2022
16
andSadiecontinuedtooperatetheOhioBrokerageCompanyuntil1961.In1925,Adaand SamuelFrankelmovedtoMansfieldfromBridgeport,Connecticut,whereSamuelhadworkedin theglassindustry.Onceestablished,SamuelopenedtheMansfieldPlateandWindowGlass Company Adaassistedherhusbandinrunningthebusiness.86 Originallytheshopwasbasedout ofamodeststorefrontat213NorthMainStreet.By1963,however,thebusinesshadgrownto employ12peopleandoccupyanapproximately15,000-square-footpropertyat301North MulberryStreet.87 Thefamily’sbusinessinterestsalsoexpandedintorealestate.88
HarryandMyraGoldmanlivedinMansfieldby1931.Duringthissameyear,Harry foundedtheMansfieldBag&PaperCompanywhichcontinuestooperateasof2023.Bernice andLouisGoldsteinarrivedinMansfieldby1932.Louisworkedinadvertising.Leonardand MiriamGolerresidedinMansfieldby1933.Louiswaspresidentofthe IndependentBarberand BeautySupplyCompany,whichopenedabranchinMansfieldin1935.Thiscompanysold equipmentforbarbershopsandbeautysalons.89 BettyandDavidHayferlivedinMansfieldby 1929andwereoperatingamen’sclothingstoreat159NorthMainStreet.90 AndrewKlein,a nativeofUngvár,Hungary,arrivedinMansfieldin1934.91 Onceestablishedintown,Andrew operatedtwostoresthatsoldfursandprovidedclothingrepairattheOhioTheateronPark AvenueWest.92 Around1941,Andrew,alongwithhis relativeandnewbusinesspartner,Elmer Klein,openedtheKleinFurShop.Thisbusiness,whichwasalsoknownasKleinFurs,was locatedat39NorthMulberryStreet.In1946,AndrewwedEsther,whowouldbecomehighly activeinMansfield’sJewishcommunityasamemberofB’naiB’rithWomenandtheB’nai JacobSisterhood.Laterinhislife,Andrewwasknownforfrequentlyvisitingthesickat hospitalsinAshlandandMansfield.93
DenaandMaxLevantmovedtoGalionshortlyafter1934.Beforethis,theyresidedin Crestline.OncesettledinGalion,Maxbeganacompanyknownas GalionAutoWrecking.94 HelenandWilliam MarcusmovedtoMansfieldfromClevelandin1931.Thefamilyrelocatedto MansfieldduetoWilliam’sworkwiththe CityProduceandCommissionCompany.Whilein
Obituary of Max Levant, News Journal
Stricken," News Journal, March 29, 1976
Ibid 91 George Constable, "Andrew Klein," News Journal, February 22, 1976 90 "Illness Fatal," Mansfield News-Journal, February 13, 1942 89 “Opens Branch,” Mansfield News-Journal, November 22, 1935 88 "NewApartment," Mansfield News-Journal, September 09, 1940 87 Ibid 86 “Plate Glass Firm Plays Major Role in Building,” Mansfield News-Journal, July 08, 1963. 17
94
, February 23, 1970 93 "Andrew Klein
92
RichlandCounty,WilliamwasactiveinsupportingtheCommunityChestcampaign,whichlater becameknownasUnitedWay.95 MaxMeisel,likeWilliam Marcus,alsomovedtoMansfield around1932toworkwiththeCityProduceandCommissionCompany.Hewouldgoonto establishanaccountingserviceunderthenameMeiselandAssociates.Maxwasmarriedto Blanche,whowasactivewithboththeB'naiJacobandTempleEmanuelsisterhood organizations.JackMintz,wholivedinMansfieldby1927,wasassociatedwiththeBarnes HoldingCompanyandtheBarnesManufacturingCompany.96 TheBarnesManufacturing Companywasfoundedin1895byThomasBarnesandthefirmspecializedinthemanufactureof handpumps.DonnaandIrvinMunsterarrivedinMansfieldby1932.IrvinoperatedtheBig ThreeMaltCompanyonNorthMainStreet.
AnnaandMorrisPostlivedinMansfieldby1926.Morrismadealiving sellingfruit.By 1946,hisbusinesswasknownastheCutRateFruitMarket.Thisstorewaslocatedat205East FourthStreet.BessieandDavidPreismovedtoAshland in1931andopenedaclothingstoreat thecornerofCenterandMain.AfterDavid’sdeathin1943,Bessiecontinuedtorunthestore alongsideherson,Morton.97 In1963,PreisApparel wasdestroyedinafireonlyafewmonths beforeBessiedied.98 ThebusinesswasrebuiltbyMorton,however,andcontinuedon.Idaand SolomonSelfmanarrivedinMansfieldin1934andoperatedastore,PublicDryGoods,along NorthMain.Thebusinessoperatedfor18yearsbeforeclosingin1952.99 BenjaminandLillian SilvermanmovedtoMansfieldin1931andopenedBen’sUsedAutoPartsat180WestSixth Street.BernardandMildredStern,thefinalfamilylistedabove,livedinMansfieldby1934. BernardwasadentistwhopracticedinMansfieldforover40years.Mildredwasactiveinboth B’naiJacobandTempleEmanuel.Thisexampleofoneindividual’sinvolvementintheactivities ofbothcongregationsagaindemonstratesthecloserelationshipB’naiJacobandTemple EmanuelenjoyedduringtheiryearsasseparatereligiousbodieswithdifferencesinJewish practice.
OtherJewishorganizationswerehighlyactiveinMansfieldduringthe1930sand1940s. By1939,threeJewishwomen’sorganizationsexistedwithinthecity WhiletheB’naiJacob Sisterhood,whichlikelyformedaroundthesametimeastheB'naiJacobcongregationin1927,
95 "Retired Businessman Dies of HeartAilment," Mansfield News-Journal,August 28, 1954
96 "Pryor Gives Barnes Rule to Hout, Mintz," Mansfield News-Journal, October 03, 1957
97 "David Preis, 70, PassesAway atAshland," Norwalk Reflector-Herald, November 24, 1943
98 "Work Begins on Store," Mansfield News-Journal, May 04, 1963
99 "Solomon Selfman, 75, DiesAfter Long Illness," Mansfield News-Journal, January 02, 1954
18
andtheTempleEmanuelSisterhood havealreadybeenreferenced,the thirdorganization,theB'naiB'rith Women’sAuxiliary,isnewtothis work.ThelocalB’naiB’rith Auxiliarywasfoundedin1938,and by1957thegroupwasknownas B’naiB’rithWomen.100 Itsmembers collaboratedwiththemen’sB’nai B’rithlodgetosupportavarietyof civicandphilanthropiccauses.The organization’sannualdonorluncheon wasanespeciallynotablesocialeventontheJewishcommunity’scalendar Themen’slodge, whichby1934wasknownastheLouisFreundlichlodge,wasalsoactive101 Louis,whowas highlyengagedinB’naiB’rith,diedin1932.ItshouldalsobenotedthattheMansfieldlodge supportedayouthgroup,knownasAlephZadikAleph,by1934.102
InGalion,17milestothewestofMansfield,anewB’naiB’rithlodgewascreatedin 1938with32members.103 Around200peoplewerereportedtohaveattendedthegroup’s installationservices.104 Theneworganizationwasrecognizedaslodgenumber1276bythe nationalbodyofB’naiB’rith.LouisGoodmanservedasthelodge’sfirstpresidentandIrving Meckler,alongwithMiltonZucker,weretheorganization’sinauguralvicepresidents.
105 Other membersoftheGalionlodgeincludedHarryCohen,LouisGarfinkel,IrvingHorwitz,Myron Morganstern,andHarrySilverman.B’naiB’rithmembersmeetinginGalionutilizedaspace abovetheWistermanclothingstoreat109-111HardingWayEastandworkedtosupportlocal organizations,includingtheGirlScoutsandRedCross.Membersalsocontributedtonational
100 “B’nai B’rith Chapter Honors Several at Donor Luncheon,” Mansfield News-Journal, November 12, 1953
101 “Officers Named,” Mansfield News-Journal, December 11, 1934
102 Nina Liston, “Jews of Mansfield EnjoyTheir Small-Town Life,” Cleveland Jewish News, February 01, 1974
103 “200Attend Installation of Galion B’Nai B’Rith Lodge No 1276 Sunday,” Galion Inquirer, March 28, 1938
104 Ibid
105 Ibid
19
Jewishphilanthropicefforts.106 TheGalionB’naiB’rithlodgeexisteduntilatleast1944before mergingwiththeMansfieldlodge.B’naiB’rithdoesnot,however,havethedistinctionofbeing thefirstJewishorganizationinGalion.ThistitlelikelybelongstotheJewishSundaySchool, whichwasformedby1923.107 Insomesources,theschoolisknownastheMenorahSunday School.108 StudentsfrequentlytraveledtoMansfieldfortheirconfirmationservices.Forexample, in1932eightchildrenfromGalionwereincludedintheconfirmationclassatTemple Emanuel.109 In1937,sevenGalionchildrenwereconfirmedatTempleEmanuel.110 Inadditionto theSundayschool,aJewishsocialclubexistedinGalionby1936.111 Thisorganizationwas likelyaforerunneroftheB’naiB’rithlodge.
ReturningtoMansfield,in1941themembersofB’naiJacobpurchasedtheirfirstpiece ofproperty,ahomeat50SturgesAvenue,andconverteditintoaparsonageandsynagogue. Previously,thehomewasownedbyClemieFrance.ClemiewasthewidowofIraFrance,anoted businessmaninMansfieldwithinterestsinconstruction,dredging,andquarries.112 Iradiedin 1910,29yearsbeforehiswife.Thefirstreligiousservicesheldat50SturgesAvenuetookplace inMay1942.Approximately200peoplecouldbeseatedinthenewsynagogue.113 In1944,the membersofTempleEmanuelsoldtheirsynagogueonWestSecondStreetandbegantosharethe spaceat50SturgesAvenue.114 JewswhoarrivedintheMansfieldareabetween1935and1945 includedtheBloom,Cogen,Doppelt,Glattke,Goettinger,Hurwitz,Lapine,Lewis,Lifson, Lockshin,Mandel,Mittman,Negin,Shaffer,Shapiro,Shuster,Tuber,andZavelsonfamilies. AbrahamandZeldaBloommovedtoMansfieldfromClevelandin1935afterAbrahamtooka positionwiththeDominionElectricCompany 115 Thissamecompany,whichwasfoundedin Winnipeg,Canada,alsobroughtLeonardandRiviaHurwitz,LeoandSaraKirschner,Nathan andSarahLifson,FlorenceandSamuelLockshin,AlanMandel,BenjaminandMarthaShaffer, andRuthandSamuelShapirotoMansfield.DominionrelocatedtoMansfieldin1935aftera
115 "Abe Bloom Succumbs," News Journal, July 25, 1965
Jayson Schlechty, “Two Jewish Congregations Become One,” Mansfield/Richland County Public Library, December 04, 2021, https://theshermanroom wordpress com/author/theshermanroom/ 113 “Temple, Synagogue Serve Jewish Congregations,” Mansfield News-Journal,August 02, 1950 112 “Death Calls Ira F France,” Mansfield News, January 03, 1910 111 “Jewish Social Club is Organized Here,” Galion Inquirer, April 28, 1936 110 “7 From Galion Confirmed Sunday,” Galion Inquirer, June 05, 1937 109 “Confirmation Jewish Children at Mansfield SundayA M , ” Galion Inquirer, June 17, 1932 108 “Instructive, Interesting,” Galion Inquirer, December 17, 1928. 107 “Story of Queen Esther Charmingly Presented,” Galion Inquirer, March 05, 1923 106 “One Hundred Guests at B’nai B’rith Dinner,” Galion Inquirer, December 02, 1940. 20
114
periodinMinneapolis.116 NathanLifsonandBenjaminShafferfoundedthecompany16years earlierin1919.117 Dominionproducedelectrichomeappliances,andin1959anestimated400 peoplewereemployedbythecompany.In1971,however,theMansfieldDominionplantwas closed.
BerthaandJackCogenarrivedinMansfieldin1941fromCleveland,andJackworkedas abuildingcontractor 118 BerthawashighlyactiveinB’naiB’rithWomen.119 RuthandSaul DoppeltmovedtoMansfieldin1938.SaulwasthefounderofPennAutoandSportingGoods Store,whichwasoriginallylocatedonNorthWalnutStreet.By1954,thebusinessmovedto SouthMainStreet.120 RuthDoppeltassistedwiththebusinessandwasactiveinthelocal Hadassahchapter.HadassahisaJewishphilanthropicorganizationforwomenthatfocuseson medicalneedsinIsrael.Mansfield’sformerHadassahchapterwasfoundedin1948.121 Fannie andJuliusGlattkelivedinMansfieldby1943.JuliusworkedwiththeJ.M.CousinsScrapIron Companyuntilhisretirement.122 BothFannieandJuliuswerehighlyactiveinlocalJewish organizations.CarlandDorisGoettingerresidedinMansfieldby1940.Duringhistimein RichlandCounty,CarloperatedtheRoyalCrownColaCompanyatthecornerofWestThirdand Bowmanstreets.123 BothCarlandDoriswereactivewithB’naiB’rith.
DavidandLillianLapinelivedinMansfieldby1940andwereassociatedwiththe MansfieldHardwareandSupplyCompany.In1955,however,thecompany,whichhadbeen renamedMansfieldHousewaresIncorporated,wasdeclaredbankrupt.Notably,Davidand Lillian’sson,James,enjoyedsuccessonBroadwaybeginningin1984.Hisfirstwork Sunday in the Park with George wasacollaborationwithStephenSondheim.124 Laterworksincluded Falsettos, Into the Woods,and Passion.Jameswasnot,however,thefirstJewfromMansfieldto findsuccessontheGreatWhiteWay.Twenty-twoyearsbefore Sunday in the Park with George wasfirstperformed,LeeAdams,thesonofFlorenceandLeopoldAdams,receivedaTony Awardforhismusical Bye Bye Birdie.OthernotableworksbyAdamsinclude Golden Boy and Applause.Lee’sfather,LeopoldwasadoctorinMansfieldby1924.
116 "Benjamin Shaffer, Dominion Head, Dies," Mansfield News-Journal, November 13, 1957.
117 "Dominion Founder Dies at 87," News Journal, June 28, 1975
118 "J R Cogen Dies at 51," Mansfield News-Journal, June 12, 1952
119 "B'nai B'rith Installs," Mansfield News-Journal, May 26, 1948
120 "Local Store Sends Birthday Cards toYoung Customers," Mansfield News-Journal,April 25, 1954
121 “First Hadassah Meeting Oct 6,” Mansfield News-Journal, October 03, 1948
122 "Jules Glattke Dies at 77," News Journal,August 26, 1968
123 Obituary of Carl Goettinger, News Journal, January 24, 1967
124 "Sunday in the Park with George Mansfield was His First Stage," News Journal, September 02, 1984
21
ElsieandMartinLewisarrivedinMansfieldin1938.Martinwastheownerof Fashion LaneClothiers,whichbeganat84NorthMainStreet.By1957,asecondlocationopenedatthe JohnnyAppleseedShoppingCenter.125 BelleandSamuelMittman,whowerebothimmigrants fromPoland,livedinMansfieldby1937.Thefamilyoperatedthe MittmanGrocery,alsoknown asMittman'sMarket,at362BowmanStreet.Mittman’sMarketspecializedinsellingfruits.126 ArthurandSylviaNeginarrivedinMansfieldby1940.Arthur,whoworkedasanattorneyinthe city,washighlyactiveinRichlandCounty.WithintheJewishcommunity, heservedaschairman oftheexecutivecommitteeoftheOhio-KentuckyregionoftheAnti-DefamationLeagueand waspresidentofbothB’naiJacobandthelocalB’naiB’rithlodgeforatime.Hewasalsoactive withtheElks,MalabarHighSchoolMusicParentsClub,Masons,andtheYMCA.Sylviaserved aspresidentofB’naiB’rithWomenandwasactiveintheB'naiJacobSisterhood. FrankShuster, whohasbeenmentionedpreviously,livedinMansfieldby1936andoperatedFrank'sBargain SpotonNorthMain.127 JeromeTubermovedtoMansfield in1939andoperatedtheMansfield
Wrecking&MaterialsCompany
128 LesterandMaxineZavelsonresidedinMansfieldby1940, andLestersupportedhisfamilybyworkingattheIndependentTowelSupplyCompany.
OnDecember7,1941,theUnitedStateswasattackedbytheEmpireofJapanatPearl Harbor.SoonmillionsofAmericanswouldenlistinthearmedforcesandonceagainresidentsof RichlandCountyfromallbackgroundsdidtheirparttosupportthenationalwareffort.Atleast 29localJewsareknowntohaveserved.TheirnamesareAlvinBachrach,RobertBachrach, PhilmourBein,GertrudeBooksbaum,RalphCobey,JosephEdelstein,JosephEllison,Jerome Fellenbaum,GordonFliegel,JulesFrankel,JeromeGans,LeonGoettinger,JeromeGoldman, MyronKalish,LionelLevant,AlanMandel,RobertMittman,MorrisMosberg,SarahMosberg Owings,SamuelRosenbaum,SheldonShaffer,AlfredSilverman,JacobSternbaum,Morton Stern,NathanStrauss,HaroldZucker,JosephZucker,MiltonZucker,andWillardZucker.Oneof theseindividuals,JacobSternbaumdiedoverseasandanother,JeromeFellenbaumdiedfrom Hodgkin’slymphomawhilestationedinHawaii.129 Jacobwasservingasafirstlieutenantinthe AirCorpswhenhisairplanecrashedwhilecrossingtheHimalayasinnorthernIndia.Inmemory
125 "Selling Clothes His Way of Life," Mansfield News-Journal, September 04, 1957
126 Obituary of Samuel Mittman, News Journal, May 31, 1966
127 "Frank Shuster, 73, Fatally Stricken," Mansfield News-Journal, October 09, 1969
128 Obituary of Jerome G Tuber, Snyder Funeral Homes, January 23, 2001, https://snyderfuneralhomes secure tributecenteronline com/obituaries/Jerome-G-Tuber?obId=22968970
129 “Pfc Jerry Fellenbaum Dies in Hawaiian Is Relatives Here Learn,” Galion Inquirer, December 04, 1942
22
ofhisson,CarlandMarySternbaumdonatedthelandforMansfield'sFriendlyHouse.130 This communitycentrecontinuestoexistinMansfieldasof2023andislocatedat380North MulberryStreet.Itisalsoofnotethatoneindividual,StanleyCowanrelocatedtoMansfieldin 1942andservedduringthewar AfterWorldWarII,severalotherJewishveteransarrivedin Mansfield.ThelistpresentedaboveprofilesservicemenwholivedintheMansfieldareabefore thewar’send.
Aroundtheyear1942,themembersofB’naiJacoborganizedthefirstJewishcemeteryin RichlandCounty.Thiscemetery,knownastheB’naiJacobCemeteryorB’naiB’rithCemetery, islocatedonthenorthsideofParkAvenueWesttotheeastoftheOntarioCommunityCemetery. Thecemeterycontinuestobeactivewellintothetwenty-firstcentury.Includedinthecemetery isamonumenterectedtohonorfourservicemenwhoservedinWorldWarII.Inadditionto JacobSternbaum,thememorialalsoliststhenamesAlvinBachrach,MorrisChasin,andHoward Weinberg.Alvin,thesonofLouisandSarahBachrach,diedofanillnesswhilewaitingtobe deployedoverseas.HeisburiedattheUnitedStatesMilitaryAcademyCemeteryatWestPoint, wherehewasagraduate.MorrisChasin,whoisburiedattheLuxembourgAmericanCemetery andMemorial,livedinToledobeforeenteringtheservice.ItislikelythatrelativesinMansfield includedhisnameonthememorial.Howard,thesonofAlexandEstherWeinberg,livedinNew London,Ohio,beforeenteringtheservice.HisparentsmovedtoWilliard,26milesnorthwestof Mansfield,afterWorldWarII.TheinclusionofMorrisChasinandHowardWeinbergonthe memorialcreatedattheB’naiJacobCemeterydemonstratesthetiesMansfield’sJewishfamilies hadwithfamiliesinotherpartsofOhio.
ItshouldalsoberememberedthatsomemembersoftheMansfieldJewishcommunity lostrelativesduringtheHolocaust.OneoftheseindividualswasEugeneKlein.Anativeof Hungary,EugenemovedtoMansfieldby1935andopenedaclothingstore,Gene'sMen'sShop, at105NorthMainStreet.131 In1948,EugenevisitedrelativeswhoremainedinHungary. Followinghisvisit,thelocal Mansfield News-Journal highlightedtheHolocaust’simpactonthe KleinfamilyandHungary’sJewishcommunitymorebroadly 132 Eugeneandhiswife,Jolanleft Mansfieldby1957.Theirtwosons,OscarandRobert,bothremainedinMansfield,however,and eachopenedamedicalpracticeafterservingintheUnitedStatesArmedForces.Oscarwasa
130 “Company Head Dies,” Mansfield News-Journal, March 03, 1954
131 "E J Klein Dies in Budapest," News Journal, June 05, 1974
132 Dwyer Clay, "Mansfielder Visits Family in Europe," Mansfield News-Journal,August 06, 1948
23
physicianspecializingininternalmedicine.133 Robertwasadentistwhoopenedhispracticein 1959.134
ThePost-WarYears,1945to1960
JewishlifeinMansfieldflourishedintheyearsfollowingWorldWarII,alongwiththe CityofMansfieldasawhole.In1947,itwasestimatedthat308Jewsresidedinthecity 135 This numberequalledaround0.70percentofthetotalpopulationofMansfield.Additionally,families fromoutsidethecitycontinuedtoparticipateinMansfield’sJewishorganizations.Asan example,in1948tenchildrenwereconfirmedatB’naiJacob.AlongwithMansfield, confirmandsalsolivedinAshland,Greenwich,Mt.Vernon,andWestSalem.136 WestSalem, located29milesnortheastofMansfield,wasthefarthestcommunityrepresentedamongthe membersofthereligiousschoolclass.Ahandful ofJewishfamilieslivedinWestSalemduringthe mid-twentiethcentury 137 Ofthesefamilies,the LillianandMyerSwackhousehold,withten children,wasthelargest.Beforehermarriageto Myer,LillianlivedinAshlandandwasthewifeof ArthurGrundstein,ascrapdealer.138 Arthurdied in1933afteranexplosionoccurredwhilehewas workingathisscrapyard.Myer,animmigrant fromPoland,livedinClevelandbeforerelocating WestSalemforwork.139 Intime,Myerbuiltup hisownbusinessesincludingtheMyerSwack ruckCompanyandtheM.SwackIronandSteel Company.140 MyerandLillianraisedtheirfamily
133 "Dr. Oscar Klein Dies in California," News Journal, January 22, 1969.
134 "Dr Robert Klein to Open Dentistry Office," News-Journal, September 01, 1959
135 American JewishYearbook Vol 50, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society ofAmerica, 1949: 681, https://ajcarchives org/AJC DATA/Files/1948 1949 18 Statistics pdf
136 Nita Branson, “Confirmation Rites Mark Pentecost,” Mansfield News-Journal, June 12, 1948
137 Bernard Swack, interview by Nancy Shimer, 2022
138 Ibid
139 Ibid
140 Nancy Pratt, “Of People and theTimes,” Times Recorder (Zanesville), May 14, 1967
24
onafarmthatproducedbothdairyproductsandavarietyofcrops,includingcorn.Thisfarm remainedinthefamilyuntil1988.141 Asadults,theSwackchildrenrelocatedtoavarietyof placesincludingCalifornia,Georgia,Mansfield,NewJersey,NewYork,andZanesville.
ReturningtoMansfield,twonewJewishorganizations,Hadassah,mentionedearlierin thiswork,andtheB’naiJacobMen’sClub,wereformedbefore1950.TheMen’sClubaffiliated itselfwiththeNationalFederationofJewishMen’sClubs.142 OlderJewishorganizationsalso flourishedintheyearsfollowingWorldWarII.Anestimated116peopleweremembersofB’nai B’rithandB’naiB’rithWomenin1951.Onephilanthropiceffortundertakenbythetwoallied groupsduringthistimewastofurnisharoomattheMansfieldhospital.143 TheB’naiB’rith organizationsalsosupportedHiddenHollowCampsoutheastofMansfieldbydedicatingacabin onthegrounds.144 In1949,anestimated75peopleweremembersoftheB’naiJacob Sisterhood.145 TheTempleEmanuelSisterhoodalsocontinued toexistasaseparateorganization. Bothorganizationscontinuedtosupportavarietyofcharitablecausesbothwithinandoutsideof theJewishcommunity
BothB’naiJacobandTempleEmanuelexperiencedsignificantdevelopmentsin1946.At B’naiJacob,thecongregationelected,after19yearsasanOrthodoxJewishsynagogue,to formallyadoptaConservativeJewishpractice.ConservativeJudaism,whichbeganasa movementinthemid-nineteenthcentury,maintainsthatJewishpracticeandtheologyevolve overtime.Yet,Conservativereligiousleadersemphasizethatchangesinreligiouspracticeought tobedonewithcareandwithdueconsiderationforhistoricalprecedent.B’naiJacob’sformal changefromOrthodoxtoConservativeJudaismsignifiedshiftingreligiouspracticesamongits membersandagrowingconvergencewiththepracticesofmanyTempleEmanuelmembers. DavidRub,thefirstrabbiatB’naiJacob,leftMansfieldin1946forChicago.Hewas succeededin1947byRabbiMosheGoldblum,whoarrivedinMansfieldfrom Minneapolis alongsidehiswife,Evelyn.Moshewasthecongregation’sfirstConservativerabbi.DuringWorld WarII,heservedasachaplainintheUnitedStatesArmy.146 MoshedidnotremaininMansfield forlong,however,and,in1949,heleftthecongregation.HewassucceededbyRabbiZelig
141 Elmer Swack, “Fond Memories ofAFarm No Longer Ours,” Cleveland Jewish News, September 06, 1991
142 “ClubAffiliates with U S Unit,” Mansfield News-Journal, February 23, 1949
143 “Installation Dinner, Dance Held at Leland,” Mansfield News-Journal, June 08, 1951
144 Yolanda Kirschner, email to Nancy Shimer, November 16, 2022
145 “B’Nai Jacob Sisterhood Honored with Luncheon,” Mansfield News-Journal, June 24, 1949
146 “To Speak Here,” Mansfield News-Journal, December 20, 1946
25
Chinitz,agraduateofYeshivaUniversityinNewYorkCity.Aboutoneyearlater,however, ZeligleftMansfieldtoserveasamilitarychaplainattheScottAirForceBasenearBelleville, Illinois.147 In1951,RabbiIsraelBotwinickarrivedatB’naiJacob.LikeMoshe,Israelservedasa chaplainduringWorldWarII.Duringthistime,hewasawardedaBronzeStarforhisworkto supportHolocaustsurvivorsinGermanyfollowingthewar 148 Israel,whoremainedinMansfield until1952,livedinLebanon,PennsylvaniabeforemovingtoOhio.
Movingbacktodevelopmentsin1946,themembersofTempleEmanuel,aftersharing spacewithB’naiJacobfortwoyears,votedtopurchaseaplotoflandatthecorner ofCookRoad andLexingtonAvenuetobuildanewsynagogue.Thisstructure,whichin2022isoccupiedby theCovenantOrthodoxPresbyterianChurch,wasthefirstbuildingbuiltinRichlandCountyto beusedasasynagogue.149 OnJuly28,1947,thecornerstonewaslaidforthesynagogue.Nearly 14monthslater,onSeptember26,1948,thenewsynagoguewasdedicatedbyRabbiBertram KornandRabbiEugeneLipman.Anestimated200peopleattendedtheceremonies.150 Bertram servedasastudentrabbiatTempleEmanuelfrom1946to1947.Eugenebeganministeringat TempleEmanuelasastudentrabbiin1948.HedidnotliveinMansfield, butrathercommutedto towntoleadservicesandteachatthecongregation’sSundaySchool.In1949,Eugenetooka positionwithHillel,aJewishcampusorganization.Thefirst,andonly,full-timerabbiatTemple EmanuelwasMiltonGreenwald.MiltonarrivedinMansfieldfromBrunswick,Georgia,withhis wife,Ruthin1957.151 BythetimeMiltonarrivedinMansfield,hehadalreadyservedasarabbi for29years.By1962,MiltonandRuthlivedinIndiana.
In1950,itwasestimatedthatB’naiJacobhad80memberfamilies. TempleEmanuelhad anestimated52families.152 BothcongregationssponsoredactiveSundayschoolsanda community-wideJewishyouthgroup,AlephZadikAleph,restarteditsactivities.153 AtTemple Emanuel,startingaround1959,studentsfromKenyonCollegewerehiredbythecongregationas teachers.154 Someoftheseteachers,includingMurrayHorwitz,aplaywright,andRichardBaehr,
147 "Rabbi Chinitz to Report for Duty as Chaplain," Mansfield News-Journal, November 25, 1950.
148 "Guest Rabbi Speaks Friday," Mansfield News-Journal, March 08, 1951
149 Jayson Schlechty, “Two Jewish Congregations Become One,” Mansfield/Richland County Public Library, December 04, 2021, https://theshermanroom wordpress com/author/theshermanroom/
150 Ibid
151 "Dr Greenwald will ServeTemple Emanuel," Mansfield News-Journal,August 10, 1957
152 “Temple, Synagogue Serve Jewish Congregations,” Mansfield News-Journal,August 02, 1950
153 Al Budin, interview by author, phone, 2023
154 Howard Edelstein, interview by Nancy Shimer, 2022
26
aconservativecommentator,havegoneontohavenotablecareers.155 SomeMansfieldfamilies, includingBlancheandMaxMeiselandBeatriceandHaroldOxman,weremembersofboth B’naiJacobandTempleEmanuel.BeatriceandHarold,whohavenotbeenmentioned previously,werewedin1941.Atthetime,HaroldoperatedtheMaxieTire&SupplyCompany inNorwalk,Ohioalongsidehisbrother,Philip.By1953,Haroldwasassociatedwithboth MansfieldSteelandSupplyCompanyandtheShelbyIronandMetalCompany,whichwas foundedbyhisfather,Maxin1918.Philip,whomovedtoRichlandCountyby1946,also workedwiththetwocompanies.156 In1951,themembersofB’naiJacobpurchasedahomeat 237WoodStreetforuseasaparsonage.157 Thishomewasaboutaten-minutewalkfromthe synagogue.Foratimebeforethecongregationpurchasedthehome,rabbisatB’naiJacobstayed atanapartmentlocatedat160WestSecondStreetthatwasrentedbythecongregation.158
InAugust1955,RabbiAvramHartsteinbeganhistimeatB’naiJacob.159 Avramwould beoneofthelongest-servingrabbisinMansfield,remaininginhisrolefor20years.Anativeof Hungary,Avram,whowasalsoknownasAndre,marriedDeborahFeuerwerker,anativeof Geneva,in1936.160 In1939,thecouplearrivedintheUnitedStatesandAvramfoundworkasa rabbiinAkron.Heremainedinthisroleuntil1952,whenheacceptedajobwithBethJacob SynagogueinRegina,Canada.161 HearrivedinMansfieldfromCanada.Duringhistimein RichlandCounty,AvramalsoservedasachaplainattheOhioStateReformatory.OnMarch3, 1957,thegroundwasbrokenbytherepresentativesofB’naiJacobforanewsynagogueatthe cornerofCookandLarchwoodroads.162 Alittleover sixmonthslater,onSeptember25,1957, theholidayofRoshHashanah,thenewsanctuarywasopened.163 Thestructureincludedspacefor aB’naiB’rithmeetinglounge,akitchen,nineclassrooms,whichwereutilizedbythe congregation’sreligiousschool,arabbi’sstudy,andasocialhall.Lateradditionsandrenovations includedalibrarywing,whichalsoservedastheheadquartersforthelocalB’naiB’rithYouth
155 Ibid.
156 "Philip W Oxman, 74; Headed Mansfield Steel Co," Cleveland Jewish News, July 05, 1985
157 “Buys House to Use as Parsonage,” Mansfield News-Journal, July 20, 1951.
158 Ibid
159 "New RabbiArrives," Mansfield News-Journal,August 20, 1955
160 Obituary of Deborah Hartstein, Cleveland Jewish News, November 11, 1983
161 "RabbiAndre Hartstein, 83, Led Congregations in Ohio, Canada," Cleveland Jewish News, May 28, 1993
162 Jayson Schlechty, “Two Jewish Congregations Become One,” Mansfield/Richland County Public Library, December 04, 2021, https://theshermanroom wordpress com/author/theshermanroom/
163 Ibid
27
Organization,andmodernstainedglasswindows,whichwerefundedthroughabequestinthe willofMarthaShaffer.164 TheB’naiB’rithYouthOrganization wasasuccessortoAlephZadik Aleph.
In1954,aneworganization,theMansfieldJewishFederation,wascreatedtoserveasa centralphilanthropicagencyfortheJewishcommunityofRichlandCountyandsurrounding areas.ThelargesteffortsponsoredbytheFederationwasanannualcampaigntosupportthe UnitedJewishAppeal.165 Thisorganization,whichexistedinMansfielduntil2004,supported charitableeffortsbothintheUnitedStatesandIsrael.Individualswhowereleadersinthe FederationovertheyearsincludedMorrisBerer,AlbertCousins,Myron Kalish,ArthurNegin, andAbrahamSenser.AsidefromArthur,noneoftheindividualslistedhasbeenreferenced previouslyandsoeachwillbehighlightedbriefly.MorrisBerer,thefounderofthePepsiCola BottlingCompanyofMansfield,arrivedinRichlandCountyaround1934.Hisbottlingbusiness didnot,however,begintooperatelocallyuntilaround1965.166 MorriswasmarriedtoDorothy, whowasactivewithbothB’naiB’rithWomenandtheB’naiJacobSisterhood.Morris’former company,nowknownasthePepsiBottlingGroup,continuestoexistinRichlandCountyasof 2023.AlbertCousins,thebrotherofJacobCousins,livedinMansfieldby1937.Heworkedwith JacobattheJMCousinsScrapIronCompany.Inadditiontohisinvolvementwiththe Federation,AlbertwasalsoactivewithB’naiB’rithandB’naiJacob,servingeachaspresident foratime.HewasmarriedtoEvelyn,whoservedaspresidentofB’naiB’rithWomenfora period.MyronKalish,whomovedtoMansfieldwithhisparentsaround1942,operatedarepair shopalongsideAlMecurio.MyronwasknowntohisfriendsasMike.167 AbrahamSenser,like AlbertCousins,workedwiththeJMCousinsCompany.AbeandhiswifeLillianlivedin Mansfieldby1961.Theirsons,BrianandSteven,werealsoactiveintheJewishcommunity. AmidtheseexamplesoftheJewishcommunity’sgrowth,itisimportanttonoteone tragedythatvisitedtheCityofMansfieldandtheJewishcommunityin1952.InDecember1952, LeahSternbaum,thewifeofMaxSternbaum,wasmurdered attheSternbaumCompleteFood Martsofficeat169ValeAvenue.168 Leah,whowasthemotherofthreeandamemberofthe
164 “SynagogueAdds Sacred Panes,” Mansfield News-Journal, September 05, 1964
165 “Jewish Federation Calls Meeting to Raise Israel Funds,” News Journal, June 11, 1967
166 "Morris J Berer Dies at 86," News Journal,April 22, 1971
167 Obituary of Myron ‘Mike’Kalish, News Journal, reprinted by Legacycom, accessed October 4, 2022, https://wwwlegacycom/us/obituaries/mansfieldnewsjournal/name/myron-kalish-obituary?id=11557479
168 "Mrs Max Sternbaum Slain," Mansfield News-Journal, December 04, 1952
28
B'naiJacobSisterhoodandHadassah,workedatthegroceryalongwithherhusband.Maxwas lateraccusedofmurderinghiswifeandwasputontrialin1953.Thistrial,whichwouldat becomethelongestmurdertrialinOhiohistoryatthetime,wascoveredextensivelybythe Mansfield News-Journal andreceivedattentionfromaroundthestate.OnMarch5,1954,shortly afterthedeathofhisfather,Carl,Maxwasdeclarednotguiltybythejury 169 In1955,Sternbaum MarketswassoldtotheTracy&AveryCompany,whichwasalsobasedinMansfield.170 After thesale,theSternbaumfamilyleftMansfield.Bytheearly1970s,manyothersfollowedthe SternbaumsindepartingRichlandCounty.
TheMergerofB’naiJacobandTempleEmanuel
In1967,theAmericanJewishYearbook,anannualpublicationprintedinPhiladelphia, reportedthat480JewslivedinMansfield.171 Inthe1962through1966editionsoftheyearbook, however,ahigherestimateof615Jewsisgiven.Yet,thisestimatewaslikelyanovercount.In the1961editionoftheAmericanJewishYearbook,only525Jewsarereportedtohavelivedin Mansfield.172 Intheopinionofthiswriter,the1961estimateisthemostaccurateassessmentof howlargeMansfield’sJewishpopulationgrewbeforeenteringintoasustainedperiodof contraction.ManyoftheJewslivinginMansfieldduringthe1950sand1960swerebaby boomerswholaterwentawaytouniversity.Findingjobsinothercities,manyyoungpeopledid notreturntoMansfieldaftercompletingtheirstudies.In1974,the Cleveland Jewish News ranan articleprofilingtheMansfieldJewishcommunitythathighlightedthistrend.173 Thissamearticle statedthatin1974About65familieswereaffiliatedwithB’naiJacobandaround30families weremembersofTempleEmanuel.Mansfield’sentireJewishpopulationwasestimatedby RabbiAvramHartsteintonumber90families.174 Asoccurredin1950,somefamiliesheld membershipsinbothB’naiJacobandTempleEmanuel.
169 Jim Bruss and Frank Howard, "Jury Frees Sternbaum," Mansfield News-Journal, March 05, 1954
170 "Tracy-Avery Makes Purchase Sternbaum Markets Sold," Mansfield News-Journal, November 04, 1955
171 American JewishYearbook Vol 68, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society ofAmerica, 1967: 240, https://ajcarchives org/AJC DATA/Files/1967 6 USDemographic pdf
172 American JewishYearbook Vol 62, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society ofAmerica, 1961: 60, https://ajcarchives org/AJC DATA/Files/1961 4 USDemographic pdf
173 Nina Liston, “Jews of Mansfield EnjoyTheir Small-Town Life,” Cleveland Jewish News, February 01, 1974
174 Ibid
29
JewswhodidarriveinMansfieldafter1940weremorelikelytobewhite-collar professionals.ExamplesincludeAlvinBales,BernardBarton,StanleyCowan,HaroldCohen, RobertFagin,RobertGarber,FlorenceandLeoLevin,PhilMarcus,SeymourSchlossman,Bettie andErwinSherman,andEugeneSherman.AlvinBales,anativeofPittsburgh,firstarrivedin Mansfieldin1948toworkasageneralpractitioner.Hesoonleft,however,in1950toobtain postgraduatetraininginsurgerybeforereturningtoMansfieldin1956.175 Alvincontinuedto practicesurgeryuntil1979andservedaschiefofsurgeryattheMansfieldGeneralHospital.176 BernardBarton,whoarrivedinMansfieldaround1958,workedwiththe StateofOhioas directorofprisonsandlaterservedastheexecutivedirectoroftheRichlandCountyMental HealthBoard.StanleyCowan,whoasmentionedpreviouslyarrivedinMansfieldduring1942, workedasvicepresidentofMansfieldPlateandWindow GlassCompany.Hebecameinvolved withthecompanyafterhismarriagetoSylviaFrankel,whowasthedaughterofthecompany’s founderSamuel.StanleyandSylvialaterrelocatedtoOberlinandthenCleveland.177 Harold Cohenopenedanophthalmologypracticeat49WestSecondStreetin1960.In1966,Harold performedthefirst-evercornealtransplantinMansfield.178 RobertFagin,anativeofYoungstown wholivedinMansfieldby1963,operatedapharmacyonGlessnerAvenue.179 RobertGarber, wholivedinMansfieldby1948,wasaradiologistattheMansfieldGeneralHospital.Hewas marriedtoEstherandwasalongtimememberoftheTempleEmanuelBoardofTrustees. LeoLevin,anattorney,movedtoMansfieldfromMinneapoliswithhiswife,Florencein 1954.FlorencewasanativeofCorning,Ohio,andagraduateofWesternReserveUniversity ShetaughtbiologyatMansfieldSeniorHighSchoolaftermovingtoRichlandCounty Thirteen yearslater,shebeganworkingasaprofessorattheMansfieldbranchcampusofTheOhioState University.180 In1975,shebegantoteachatAshland College,whichwasrenamedAshland Universityin1989.181 In1993,FlorenceretiredandleftMansfieldalongwithherhusband.Phil Marcus,anativeofCincinnati,movedtoMansfieldin1956totakeajobwiththeCityof Mansfieldengineer'soffice.In1957,hewasappointedassistantcityengineer.182 Later,inthe
175 Obituary of Dr Alvin Bales, News Journal, October 04, 1980
176 Ibid
177 Obituary of Stanley M. Cowan, Cleveland Jewish News, January 24, 1997.
178 Virginia Lee, "Hospital's First CornealTransplant Returns Sight," News Journal, February 10, 1966
179 "New Gray Drug Store Set to Open," News Journal, November 08, 1964.
180 "Four Mansfielders Join Faculty," News Journal, October 02, 1967
181 Obituary of Florence Sarah Levin, Tribute Archive, December 13, 2021, https://www tributearchive com/obituaries/23387124/florence-sarah-levin
182 "Mansfield Personalities in the News," Mansfield News-Journal, September 15, 1957
30
1960s,PhilservedontheMansfieldCityCouncilforthe7thWard.SeymourSchlossman,a physicaltherapistandhealthadministrator,arrivedinMansfieldduringthemid-1950sfromNew York.HeplayedasignificantroleinraisingfundstocreateTheRehabCenterat270Sterkel Boulevard,andservedasthecentre’sdirectorfor18years.ErwinSherman,anativeof Cleveland,openedadentalpracticeinMansfieldin1950.Hiswife,Bettie,taughtmathematicsat MadisonJr.Highforover30yearsuntilretiringin2009attheageof79.183 EugeneSherman,a nativeofElizabeth,NewJersey,arrivedinMansfieldin1958andworkedwithRobertEllison, thesonofDavidandSadie,asagynecologist.184 Theirmedicalpracticeremainedinbusiness until1976,whenRobertrelocatedtoCalifornia.ItisalsoofnotethatRobert’sbrother,Joseph, wasaprominentattorneyinMansfieldwhoopenedhislawpracticein1939.185 Josephwasalso activeinlocalpoliticsasamemberoftheDemocraticParty.186 WhilemanyJewsinMansfieldfoundworkoutsideofretailafterWorldWarII,itshould benotedthatseverallocalbusinesseswerefoundedbyJewishfamiliesafter1945.Thesestores includedDunkinJewelers,FiveCousinsDiscountStore,Sid’sCameraShop,Sid'sFurniture Store,andTodd’sJewelryStore.DunkinJewelerswasco-foundedbyOscarandShirleyDinkin in1948.187 Asof2023,DunkinJewelerscontinuestooperateat2291W4thStreet.FiveCousins wasfoundedin1959bysixhouseholds,fiveofwhomwererelated.188 Someofthebusiness partners,includingIreneandJerryFriedman,relocatedtoMansfieldfromChicagowhileothers, includingLeonardandSylviaFriedman,movedfromCleveland.189 FiveCousinsremainedin businessuntilthemid-1980s.190 Sid’sCameraShop,locatedat73NorthMainStreet,wasopened in1954bySidYellen.191 Sid'sFurnitureStore,locatedat118NorthMainStreet,wasin operationby1957.Thestore’sowners,EdithandSydneyLiebermanmovedtoMansfieldfrom Brooklyn.192 Todd’sJewelryStorewasopenedatthecornerofThirdStreetandMainin1948by
183 Obituary of Bettie S Sherman, News Journal, reprinted by Legacycom, accessed October 04, 2022, https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/mansfieldnewsjournal/name/bettie-sherman-obituary?id=11556817.
184 Obituary of Dr Erwin E Sherman, News-Journal, July 08, 1990
185 "Atty. Ellison's Services Set," News Journal, January 28, 1976.
186 Ibid
187 Obituary of Oscar B Dinkin, News Journal, October 27, 1995
188 Notes from Karen Stallsmith, email from Nancy Shimer, January 2023
189 Ibid
190 Ibid
191 "Sid's Camera Shop Now on Main St , " Mansfield News-Journal, April 11, 1954
192 Notes from Karen Stallsmith, email from Nancy Shimer, January 2023
31
NormanLakin.AnothermemberofthelocalJewishcommunity,DanielMarkowitz,ownedthe MansfieldRangers,asemi-profootballteaminMansfield,duringthelate1940sand1950s.193
In1979,aftersupportingtheirownsynagoguebuildingfor31years,themembersof TempleEmanuelelectedtosellthebuildingat473CookRoadtotheSouthwoodBaptistChurch andmovetheirservicestotheB’naiJacobsynagogueat973LarchwoodRoad.194 Eightyears later,afterexistingasautonomouscongregationssharingthesamespace,B’naiJacoband TempleEmanuelmergedintoonecongregation.Thisnewcongregationtookonthename EmanuelJacobCongregation.AsoccurredformanyJewishcommunitiesinOhiothatwere locatedinsmallertownsandcities,however,Mansfield’sJewishpopulationcontinuedtodecline duringthelatetwentiethcentury.By1990,anestimated250JewsresidedinMansfield.195 This representedanapproximately52percentdeclinesince1961.By1999,theAmericanJewish Yearbookestimatedjust150JewslivedinMansfield.196
Conclusion,IntotheTwenty-firstCentury
Since1970,Mansfieldhasbeenexperiencingapopulationdeclineaccordingtofederal censusrecords.In1970,thecity’spopulationwasestimatedat55,047.By2020,however,an estimated47,534peopleresidedinMansfield.TheJewishcommunity’sdemographicdecrease hasbeenlargerthantheapproximately14percentdecreaseforthecityasawhole.Factors contributingtothisgreatercontractionincludetherelocationofalargerpercentageofyoung peopletolargercitiesandtheclosureofmanybusinessesthatoncesupportedlocalJewish families.ThemodestnumberofJewswhoarrivedinMansfieldafter1970wereevenmorelikely thanthoseinthe1950sand1960stobewhite-collarprofessionals.Twomedicalprofessionals whomovedtoMansfieldbetween1970and1980wereRonaldGoldbus,asurgeon,andRobert Mohl,agastroenterologist.Inaddition,severalJewsrelocatedtoMansfieldafterfindingwork withTheOhioStateUniversityatMansfieldcampus.Examplesinclude,CassFoster,whotaught
193 "BoardAgrees to Rent Field to Rangers if Bill is Paid," Mansfield News-Journal, July 20, 1950
194 Jayson Schlechty, “Two Jewish Congregations Become One,” Mansfield/Richland County Public Library, December 04, 2021, https://theshermanroom wordpress com/author/theshermanroom/
195 American JewishYearbook Vol 90, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society ofAmerica, 1990: 289, https://ajcarchives org/AJC DATA/Files/1990 6 USDemographic pdf
196 American JewishYearbook Vol 99, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society ofAmerica, 1999: 223, https://ajcarchives org/AJC DATA/Files/1999 6 USDemographic pdf
32
theater,EvelynFreeman,whoresearchedearlyandmiddlechildhoodteachingandlearning,and MarkNadler,whowasaprofessorofeconomics.
ItshouldalsobenotedthatJewscontinuedtobeengagedwithvariousbusinessesinthe Mansfieldareaafter1970.Forexample,in1969AlBudintookovermanagementofarestaurant knownastheGourmetRoom.Thiseaterywaslocatedat1313SouthMainStreet.Alwastheson ofLeoandMildredBudin,whowerebothactivemembersofMansfield’sJewishcommunity.In Galion,RalphCoby,thesonofHarryandMinnieCohen,continuedtoplayaprominentrolein localmanufacturingaspresidentoftheEagleCrusherCompany.197 Duringthemid-twentieth century,theCohenfamily,whicheventuallychangedtheirsurnametoCoby,wasassociatedwith thePerfectionSteelBodyCompanyinGalion.198
RalphCobywasalsoamemberofEmanuel Jacob.Thisdemonstrateshowthecongregation continuedtodrawmembersfromareasoutsideof Mansfield.Additionalmembersincluded includingFredandThelmaGersonandAlvinand SelmaKastenwhowereresidentsofAshland.
EmanuelJacobattimessupportedafull-time rabbiuntil2000.BernardBloomstone,the congregation’slastfull-timerabbi,beganhistime inMansfieldin1991.Beforehearrivedin RichlandCounty,BernardlivedinSpringfield,Massachusettswhereheworkedasan adjunct professoratSpringfieldCollegeandservedasarabbiatSinaiTemple.199 AnativeofMontreal, BernardwasalsoactiveininterfaithworkduringhistimeinMansfield.Foratimeheservedas presidentoftheMansfieldMinisterialAssociationandheoftenvisitedChristianchurchesand schoolstotalkaboutJudaism.200 RabbiBloomstonewasalsoachaplainattheMansfield CorrectionalInstitutionandtheMarionCorrectionalInstitution.
Bernard’sdeathin2000occurredsuddenlywhilehewasvisitingfamilyin Massachusetts.WhileburiedinMassachusetts,around300peopleattendedamemorialservice
200 Ibid
199 Lou Whitmire, "Mansfield Loses Rabbi," News Journal, August 02, 2000
198 "Galion IndustrialistTells of Search for Happiness," Mansfield News-Journal,August 30, 1951
33
197 Obituary of Ralph Coby, Columbus Dispatch, January 19, 2009
organisedatEmanuelJacobforBernard,includingmanynon-Jews. ReverandGregoryKirkof St.Joseph'sCatholicChurchinGalionremarkedinalettertotheeditorofthe News-Journal:
IwillalwaysbeextremelygratefulforRabbi[Bloomstone]'spresenceintheMansfield area,forhisworkwithpeopleincarceratedinprison,forhisloveofchildren,forhis tirelessworkonbehalfoftolerance,peaceandjustice,andforhisloveforChristian clergydespitethemanysinsofanti-Semitismourchurcheshavesadlybeenresponsible for.ManywordscometomindformeasIreflectonRabbiBloomstone'slife,among themintegrity,holiness,compassion,mercy,andlove...Rabbi[Bloomstone]madea tremendousdifferencetoallofuswhoknewhimandlovedhim.
RabbiBloomstone’seffortstopromoteHolocausteducationarestillrememberedinMansfield, andvisitorstothecity’sHolocaustmemorialalongParkAvenueWestwillfindthatitis dedicatedinmemoryofRabbiBloomstone.In2001,SheilaCase,anordainedcantorandnative ofKansas,succeededRabbiBloomstoneasEmanuelJacob’sreligiousleader 201 Sheila’stimein Mansfieldwasnotlong,however,and,afteraboutayear,shedepartedRichlandCounty
EmanuelJacobagainsearchedforareligiousleader WhileMansfield’sJewishpopulationwas notgrowingintheearlytwenty-firstcentury,EmanuelJacob,astheonlysynagogueinRichland County,attractedcongregantsfromvariousbackgrounds.Forexample,atleastonecontemporary member,BettyHarsh,wasaconverttoJudaism.Thisconversiontookplacein1998afterBetty studiedJudaismalongwithotherfaiths.202
In2002,EmanuelJacobretainedtheservicesofavisitingrabbi,MichaelOppenheimer. Michael,whowouldprovidethecongregationwithreligiousleadershipuntil2017,workedat Emanuel Jacobeightmonthsoutoftheyear.203 Reflectingin2017,Michaelestimatedthatwhen hebeganhistimeinMansfield,75familiesweremembersofEmanuelJacoband40to50 childrenwereenrolledinthecongregation’sreligiousschool.204 AsourcefromAugust2001, however,estimatedjust66familiesweremembersofthecongregation.205 BythetimeMichael retiredfromthecongregationin2017around30familiesweremembersofthesynagogueandan
201 Karen Palmer, “New Job SuitsYoung Cantor,” News Journal,August 04, 2001
202 Karen Palmer, “ANew Focus on Faith,” News Journal, March 09, 2002
203 Jane Kaufman, "Rabbi Michael Oppenheimer, Former Rabbi of MansfieldTemple, Dies at 77," Columbus Jewish News, September 04, 2019
204 Ed Wittenberg, “Rabbi Retires -Again,” Cleveland Jewish News, July 07, 2017
205 Karen Palmer, “New Job SuitsYoung Cantor,” News Journal,August 04, 2001
34
estimatedtenpeoplewereattendingatypicalShabbatservice.206 Despitethedeclineinthe Jewishcommunity’ssize,EmanuelJacobcontinuedtohostimportantlifecycleeventssuchas weddings.Oneofthemorerecentweddingstooccuratthecongregationwasthemarriageof DavidOppenheimer,thesonofCarolynandMichael,andMichelleMeyersin2006.207 Michelle, anativeofRichlandCounty,isthedaughterofSamuelandSandraMeyers.AnannualHolocaust commemorationatthesynagoguealsocontinuedtobeanimportanteventengagingtheJewish andnon-Jewishcommunities.
AfterMichaelretiredin2017,NancyShimertookoverhisresponsibilitiesatthe congregation.NancyhadalreadybeenactivewithEmanuelJacobbeforeMichael’sdeparture.In 2017,itwasestimatedthatEmanuelJacobhadunder100members.208 Nancycontinuestoserve asEmanuelJacob’sreligiousleader,ormorahasof2023.Inthespringof2022,themembersof EmanuelJacobrecognizedthattheirbuildingat 973LarchwoodRoadnolongerfittheneedsof thecongregation.ThesynagoguewasputupforsaleandsoldbeforeOctober.Somereligious articlesfromthecongregationweredonatedtoJewishcommunitiesaroundtheworld. DestinationsincludedCôteD’Ivoire,Ghana,the Philippines,andElPaso,Texas.Inaddition, recordsfromB’naiJacob,TempleEmanuel,andEmanuelJacobCongregationweredonatedto theColumbusJewishHistoricalSociety,wheretheywillbepreserved.TheColumbusJewish HistoricalSocietywasalsoentrustedwithdocumentsfromotherhistoricJewishorganizationsin MansfieldandJudaicaitemsfromthethreecongregations.PaulHyman,aprofessorofbiologyat AshlandUniversitysince2010,servesasthepresidentofEmanuelJacobasof2023.While Mansfieldisnolongerhometoasynagogue,aJewishcommunityremainsinRichlandCounty
ThecurrentmembersofEmanuelJacobcarryona174yeartraditionofcontinuousJewishlifein RichlandCountythatbeganwiththearrivalofMyerMillerin1848.Whilenevernumbering morethanonepercentofthecounty’soverallpopulation,Jewshavemadeameasurableimpact onthecivic,economic,andsocialfabricofRichlandCounty.Thisimpactmeritspreservation andremembrance.
208 Bob Jacob, “MansfieldYom Hashoah Service to Feature Kol Israel Speaker,” Cleveland Jewish News, April 21, 2017
207 "Oppenheimer-Meyers," Cleveland Jewish News, February 24, 2006
35
206 Karen Palmer, “New Job SuitsYoung Cantor,” News Journal,August 04, 2001
Bibliography
PrimarySources
Branson,Nita.“ConfirmationRitesMarkPentecost.” Mansfield News-Journal.June12,1948.
Bruss,JimandFrankHoward."JuryFreesSternbaum." Mansfield News-Journal.March05, 1954.
Clay,Dwyer."MansfielderVisitsFamilyinEurope." Mansfield News-Journal.August06,1948.
Constable,George."AndrewKlein." News-Journal.February22,1976.
“FourMetalsFirmsAnnounceMerger.” Recycling Today (Valley View, Ohio) August05,2022.
https://www.recyclingtoday.com/article/four-metals-firms-announce-merger/.
Jacob,Bob.“MansfieldYomHashoahServicetoFeatureKolIsraelSpeaker.” Cleveland Jewish News.April21,2017.
Kaufman,Jane."RabbiMichaelOppenheimer,FormerRabbiofMansfieldTemple,Diesat77." Columbus Jewish News,September04,2019.
Kellam,Paul."MansfieldersJustlyProudof152AcresofPark. Mansfield News-Journal August 02,1950.
Lee,Virginia.“Hospital’sFirstCornealTransplantReturnsSight.” News Journal.February10, 1966.
Lee,Virginia."Salesmanfor68Years-soFar." News Journal.December14,1975.
Liston,Nina.“JewsofMansfieldEnjoyTheirSmall-TownLife.” Cleveland Jewish News. February01,1974.
“ManagingDirectorofJewishCharitiesofChicagofor10Years.” Jewish Telegraphic Agency (New York) April27,1930.
https://www.jta.org/archive/managing-director-of-jewish-charities-of-chicago-for-10-year s-tells-of-ideals-consummated-as-he-prep.
Pratt,Nancy.“OfPeopleandtheTimes.” Times Recorder (Zanesville).May14,1967.
“NewsinBrief.” Jewish Telegraphic Agency.December08,1929. https://www.jta.org/archive/news-in-brief-9.
Palmer,Karen.“ANewFocusonFaith.” News Journal.March09,2002.
36
Palmer,Karen.“NewJobSuitsYoungCantor.” News Journal.August04,2001.
RitcheyandAlbertson. The Herald’s Directory to Mansfield, Ohio 1888-1889 (Mansfield,Ohio: TheHeraldCompany.1888).
Simon,Ron."CattleRaiserPredictsReducedFoodSupplies." News-Journal.July01,1973.
Swack,Elmer.“FondMemoriesofAFarmNoLongerOurs.” Cleveland Jewish News. September06,1991.
Whitmire,Lou."MansfieldLosesRabbi." News Journal.August02,2000.
Wittenberg,Ed.“RabbiRetires-Again.” Cleveland Jewish News.July07,2017.
NewspapersUtilized
Ashland Times (Ashland,OH).
Cleveland Jewish News (Cleveland,OH).
Columbus Dispatch (Columbus,OH).
Columbus Jewish News (Columbus,OH).
Daily Ohio State Journal (Columbus,Ohio).
Daily Reflector (Norwalk,OH).
Galion Inquirer (Galion,OH).
Jewish News of Northern California (SanFrancisco,CA).
Jewish Review and Observer (Cleveland,OH).
Mansfield News (Mansfield,OH).
Mansfield News-Journal (Mansfield,OH).
Mansfield Weekly News (Mansfield,OH).
News Journal (Mansfield,OH).
Norwalk Reflector-Herald (Norwalk,OH).
Recycling Today (ValleyView,Ohio).
Times Recorder (Zanesville,OH).
Weekly News (Mansfield,OH).
37
SecondarySources
AmericanJewishYearbookVol.16.Philadelphia:JewishPublicationSocietyofAmerica.1914: https://ajcarchives.org/AJC_DATA/Files/1914_1915_7_Statistics.pdf.
AmericanJewishYearbookVol.50.Philadelphia:JewishPublicationSocietyofAmerica.1949: https://ajcarchives.org/AJC_DATA/Files/1948_1949_18_Statistics.pdf.
AmericanJewishYearbookVol.62.Philadelphia:JewishPublicationSocietyofAmerica.1961: https://ajcarchives.org/AJC_DATA/Files/1961_4_USDemographic.pdf.
AmericanJewishYearbookVol.68.Philadelphia:JewishPublicationSocietyofAmerica.1967: https://ajcarchives.org/AJC_DATA/Files/1967_6_USDemographic.pdf.
AmericanJewishYearbookVol.90.Philadelphia:JewishPublicationSocietyofAmerica.1990: https://ajcarchives.org/AJC_DATA/Files/1990_6_USDemographic.pdf.
AmericanJewishYearbookVol.99.Philadelphia:JewishPublicationSocietyofAmerica.1999:
https://ajcarchives.org/AJC_DATA/Files/1999_6_USDemographic.pdf.
“AshlandMainStreet.”AshlandontheMargins.AccessedOctober02,2022.
https://sites.google.com/site/ashlandonthemargins/ashland-main-street.
“DecadebyDecade.” Ashland Times.January14,2016.
https://issuu.com/ashlandtimes-gazette/docs/decade_by_decade.
Eskenazi,Joe.“JunkyardJews.” Jewish News of Northern California (San Francisco).August 20,2004.
Goodkind,S.B. Eminent Jews of America (Toledo:The AmericanHebrewBiographical Company.1918).
“HistoryofEmanuelJacobCongregation.”EmanuelJacobCongregation.AccessedSeptember 30,2022.https://emanueljacob.org/about-us-2/.
ObituaryofBettieS.Sherman. News Journal.ReprintedbyLegacy.com.AccessedOctober04, 2022.
https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/mansfieldnewsjournal/name/bettie-sherman-obituar y?id=11556817.
ObituaryofFlorenceSarahLevin.TributeArchive.December13,2021.
https://www.tributearchive.com/obituaries/23387124/florence-sarah-levin.
38
ObituaryofJeromeG.Tuber.SnyderFuneralHomes.January23,2001.
https://snyderfuneralhomes.secure.tributecenteronline.com/obituaries/Jerome-G-Tuber?o bId=22968970.
ObituaryofMyron‘Mike’Kalish. News Journal.ReprintedbyLegacy.com.AccessedOctober 4,2022.
https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/mansfieldnewsjournal/name/myron-kalish-obituary ?id=11557479.
Schlechty,Jayson.“TwoJewishCongregationsBecomeOne.”Mansfield/RichlandCounty PublicLibrary.December04,2021.
https://theshermanroom.wordpress.com/author/theshermanroom/.
39