Forward! Bперёд! Framåt!
Essays in Honour of Prof Dr
Kaj Hobér
Forward! Bперёд! Framåt!
Forward! Bперёд! Framåt! Essays in Honour of Prof Dr Kaj Hobér
Editors’ Preface
Editors’ Preface
In August 2019 our dear friend and colleague Professor Dr Kaj Hobér retires from his position as Professor of International Investment and Trade Law at the Faculty of Law at Uppsala University. In order to honour Kaj’s extensive commitment to academia and his successful career as a lawyer and partner of Mannheimer Swartling, a group of friends and colleagues have come together to present this collection of essays. The editorial committee has been composed of the undersigned, with Victoria Bùi serving as editorial secretary. Forward! – Bперёд! – Framåt!, the title of this book, is Kaj’s motto in English, Russian and Swedish, respectively. This motto is felicitous indeed. Kaj has a lengthy and successful international career in law. His legacy ranges from international commercial and investment treaty arbitration to Russian studies. Many of us have had the opportunity and pleasure to work with and learn from Kaj. In 2012, Kaj was appointed by nomination as Professor of International Investment and Trade Law at Uppsala University. By Kaj’s return to his alma mater, the circle was closed. After Kaj’s many years as a first-class international arbitration lawyer, being generally considered as one of the true greats of his generation, his colleagues and students at the university have had the immense fortune to benefit from everything that Kaj has had to offer as a faculty member. Kaj has founded and for several years been the director of an international master’s program in investment treaty arbitration at the Faculty of Law at
7
Editors’ Preface Uppsala University. Needless to say, his reputation precedes him and he has over the years attracted many bright students from all over the world to the Faculty. Besides his teachings in international investment and arbitration law, Kaj has initiated and taught courses in Russian law. In his imperative effort to enhance and promote Russian studies, Kaj launched the Uppsala Yearbook of Eurasian Studies in 2016, as well as its forerunner, the Uppsala Yearbook of East European Law in 2003. Kaj is unique in many ways. Few have the ability, strength and motivation to entertain two demanding professions – that of a highly thriving practicing arbitration lawyer and partner, and that of a university professor. Kaj’s impressive list of publications reflects his wide and profound expertise in Russian law, international arbitration, and trade law. He has published in Swedish, Russian, English and German. His books are frequently relied upon by practitioners and students alike. No doubt Kaj will continue to be active in both academia and the arbitration community for years to come. The editors would like to extend their sincere gratitude to Victoria Bùi, student amanuensis Amalia Ydrefelt Hanell, Olof Blixt and Ronja Österud, and to Iustus, especially Pia Wahren, and eddy.se, especially Jenny Norden ankar, who have all been essential in the process of finalizing this collection of essays in honour of Professor Dr Kaj Hobér. Eric Bylander Anna Jonsson Cornell Jakob Ragnwaldh Uppsala July 9, 2019
8
Contents
Tabula Gratulatoria
5
Editors’ Preface
7
Foreword 9 Charles N Brower and Daae Kim Kaj Hobér and Stockholm. Ensuring that East and West Ever Shall Meet
15
C Mark Baker and Cara Dowling Resolving Climate-related Disputes. The Role of International Arbitration
29
W E Butler Catherine the Great, William Blackstone, and Comparative Law
43
Iain Cameron Russian Constitutional Law and Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
57
Mattias Dahlberg Russian Tax Treaty Relations. The Examples of Sweden and Cyprus
69
11
Contents
Joel Dahlquist Cullborg Challenges of Treaty-Based Arbitral Awards in Swedish Courts
83
Rudolf Dolzer International Law and English Law. Res Judicata and the Henderson Doctrine
101
Nils Eliasson Some Reflections on Hong Kong from an Investment Treaty Perspective
111
Ulf Franke and Annette Magnusson The Emergence of an International Arbitral Institution for the 21st century
127
Anna Jonsson Cornell Revisiting Old Ideas in the Quest for New Ones
143
Neil Kaplan The Perfect Chair
155
Herbert Küpper Economics in the Hungarian Constitution
163
Julian D M Lew Determining Relevancy of Facts in International Arbitration
179
Otto Luchterhandt Historical Experience and the Lessons of Armenian Statehood. Taking a Detached View
193
Kristoffer Löf A Story of Corruption. A Case Study of How Bribery Affects the Validity of Performed Commercial Contracts
201
Katlijn Malfliet Ruxit. A Turning of the Plot in Europe-Russia Relations
217
Christoph Schreuer The Active Investor
237
12
Contents
Patrik Schöldström Massive Evidence in Arbitration. A Case with Food for Thought
253
Patricia Shaughnessy The Renaissance Arbitrator. The Multi-Tasking Model
263
Daniel Stattin Some Comments on Directors’ Duties and Cross Border Activities
275
Eva Storskrubb Navigating EU Law and the Law of Arbitration. From the Horizon of Commercial Arbitration in Sweden
285
Howard S Sussman Kaj Hobér and Clinical Teaching
309
John M Townsend The Empty Chair. Arbitration with a Non-participating Party
313
V V Veeder A Swedish-British Story. The “Charente” on State Immunity
323
Maria Berg Andersson Bibliography of the Writings of Kaj Hobér. 1978–2019
349
Presentation of Contributors
361
13
Forward! Bперёд! Framåt!
Essays in Honour of Prof Dr
Kaj Hobér