Prof Mollaert tensioned surface structures clever roof

Tensile Surface Structures

Technical textiles 

Tension forces in textile architecture



Introduction to form-finding, possible shapes, equilibrium of forces and structural behavior of tensioned surface structures

Coated woven materials Only resist to tension

Marijke.Mollaert@vub.ac.be

1

2

Tensile Surface Structures

Tensile Surface Structures

Hanging cables + tensioning cables opposite curvature = Stable construction

Form-active structures = Depends on the external load Large deformations can occur

3

4

Tensile Surface Structures

Tensile Surface Structures

Anticlastic surface =  

Synclastic surface =

Double curvature Positive in 1st direction + negative in 2nd direction

 

Double curvature Positive in 1st direction + positive in 2nd direction

Inflated systems

5

6

1

Tensile Surface Structures

Tensile Surface Structures

F2

Pretension stabilises the system: can carry downward loads

F2

F1

F2

Pretension stabilises the system: can carry upward loads

F2

F1

F1

7

F1

8

Tensile Surface Structures

Tensile Surface Structures

Typical anticlastic shapes Pretension in the surface stabilises the shape

 

Saddle Conical with high or low points in the surface

Annick Schotte DEGRE2 9

10

Tensile Surface Structures

Tensile Surface Structures

Formfinding

Primary structure  Transfers loads and pretension to the foundations  Can consist of

Geometry of the equilibrium form + Internal forces in this equilibrium form

● ● ●

11

Struts + tie cables Beams Arches…

12

2

Clever roof?

Tensile Surface Structures

Consist of    

Disaster relief Plastic tarp?

Structurally stable set-up?

supporting structure curved tensioned surface connections anchorage

13

Clever roof? Avoid ponding and wrinkling?

14

Clever roof concept  New type of shelter!  To be used during the first hours after disaster  Material & components pre-positioned  Shelter for rain, heat and cold  To be used for different functions: first aid, meeting zone …

15

Clever roof concept

16

Clever roof concept ‘Simplistic design with natural materials to meet basic needs … nothing fancy, nothing complicated, as architecture was just being born as a utility’

 Structurally stable  Cheap

Clever roof

http://landarchs.com/tick-vs-tockarchitecture/

http://www.unrefugees.org.au

17

18

3

Clever roof concept

Clever roof concept Designs by architect Frei Otto  Based on ‘traditional’ tents

Existing shelters Well ‘tensioned’ tent: Sahrawi tent Aousserd refugee camp 2002 http://www.flickr.com/photos/simonjames/2676927132/in/photostream/

http://www.ragdollfoundation.org.uk/ wmmhdiaries/saharafilm.html

IL29 19

20

Clever roof concept

Clever roof concept

Designs by architect Frei Otto

Designs by architect Frei Otto  Flexible  Modular  Robust Not made from flat sheets IL29 21

Clever roof concept

22

Clever roof concept

Design by architect Shigeru Ban

Ban’s practice proposes a return to first principles – exploring the necessity of shelter and its crucial role in the formation and preservation of human society

PAPER in Architecture

www.shigerubanarchitects.com

23

24

4

Clever roof concept

Clever roof concept

25

Clever roof concept

26

Clever roof concept Ban’s experiments in temporary shelter do not only serve craft, but is dedicated to an ease of use that invites the participation by anyone – skilled or unskilled – at any time PAPER in Architecture

27

Clever roof concept

28

Clever roof concept A group of students and graduates from the Architectural Association School in London produced a kit that can help turn unused spaces into public amenities

‘For me, I believe a structure made with materials light enough to be constructed by just one person serves the purposes better’ Shigeru Ban PAPER in Architecture

29

30

5

Clever roof concept

Clever roof concept

Asif Khan, Omid Kamvari and Pavlos Sideris produced the Public Space Shading Canopy kit after their successful experience erecting a 15m-long lycra canopy in the slum of Favela do Pilar in Recife, Brazil

The bright yellow awning was slung from telegraph poles and buildings using cables It was erected in just four hours with the help of locals It immediately turned the neglected thoroughfare into a vibrant public space 31

32

Clever roof concept

Clever roof concept

The new kit, which provides shelter from sun and rain, contains all the materials and tools people need to create their own canopies

It comes in S, M, L and XL sizes Robustness?

http://archithoughts.wordpress.com/ 33

34

Clever roof concept

Clever roof concept

Elementary shelter:  Water tight  Strong

How to obtain a safe Clever roof kit?

http://www.survivalspot.com/survival-blog/the-a-frametarp-shelter-simple-lightweight-andeffective/

35

36

6

Clever roof concept

Clever roof concept A kit solution: different forms with the same elements

 A well tensioned membrane  Compression elements  Ropes or belts  Anchorage  Made from tarps 37

38

Clever roof concept

Clever roof prototypes

A kit solution: Combined with other structural sub-systems

Cable strut model: - 4 poles - 8 ropes - 2 high, 2 low points in the roof (4mx4m) L

H

H

L

39

40

Cleverand roofwrinkling!

Clever roof? Avoid ponding Cable strut model: - 4 poles - 8 ropes - 2 high, 2 low points in the roof L

H

H

L

Clever roof prototypes Cable strut model: Material strength?

41

L

H

H

L 42

7

Clever roof prototypes

Clever roof prototypes

Bending active model: using slender curved beams

Bending active model: using slender curved beams

250 TE Work Tent â‚Ź535

43

44

Woven material!

Clever roof prototypes Bending active model: - 2 bended beams - 5 poles Appropriate bending stiffness needed!

H

L

H

H

L 45

Clever roof analysis

46

Clever roof analysis

Hypar: fibers aligned with the edges High stresses in the boundaries, low in the central part

47

Align the weave directions with the directions of highest curvature // with the edges (6mx4m)

48

8

Clever roof analysis

Clever roof analysis

Uniform upward wind loading 0.6kN/m2: Deflection > 0.5m

‘Light’ set-up for light weather conditions Improve performance when needed:  Increase the pre-stress  Add/reinforce poles and tie down ropes

49

50

Clever roof analysis

Clever roof analysis

 Reinforce the membrane by additional belts or ropes:

SLS: Self weight: 2.6 N/m² Wind pressure: 180.3 N/m² Deflection without reinforcement: 45cm

 Tensioning down for uplift  Increasing stiffness/strength in the hanging direction

 Assure anchorage  Change the shape (fold down)

51

Clever roof analysis

52

Clever roof analysis SLS: Self weight: 2.6 N/m² Uplift wind: 360.6 N/m² Deflection with reinforcement: 59cm Provide stiffer ropes or belts

SLS: Self weight: 2.6 N/m² Wind pressure: 180.3 N/m² Deflection with reinforcement: 26cm Ponding…

53

54

9

Clever roof connections

Clever roof connections

‘God is in the details’ Nic Goldschmidt

A structure is as strong as the weakest link …

55

56

Clever roof connections

Clever roof connections Connections

An appropriate pretension is crucial

Low-tech Cheap Light To be assembled by hand building  Robust    

57

Clever roof connections

58

Clever roof connections

Connections Typical connections - Rope-rope - Rope-membrane - Membrane-membrane - Pole-pole - Pole-membrane - Pole-rope - Rope-anchorage - …

 Polyethylene sheets  PVC-coated polyester sheets  Polyester ropes  Polyester belts  Wooden poles

59

60

10

Clever roof connections

Clever roof connections

Several solutions Membrane-rope

Several solutions Membrane-rope

Robustness?

Robustness?

61

62

Clever roof connections

Clever roof connections

Several solutions Membrane-membrane

Several solutions Pole-membrane

63

64

Clever roof connections

Clever roof connections

Several solutions Pole-rope

Several solutions Rope-anchorage

65

66

11

Clever roof Strength?

Clever roof connections How to introduce the pretension?  Easy in use  Strong  Safe

‘God is in the details’ Nic Goldschmidt

http://www.self-sheltering.org

67

Clever roof connections

68

Building with textiles

Optimisation according the use in the kit:  Connections  Poles  Ropes  Materials  Dimensions  Transport …

69

70

Example

Building with textiles

Temporary pneumatic Modern Tea House Museum für angewandte Kunst (MAK), Frankfurt 2007 The inflatable Tea Pavilion is as a kind of a sculpture to be used as a temporary room for ceremonies

71

72

12

Example

Example

Already on his first drawings Kengo Kuma showed a smoothly shaped double-bowl structure The design was modified adjusted during monthly meetings of the team

Membrane HF weldable Gore Tenara 630 gr/m² PTFE-fabric coated with fluor foil with 38% translucency

73

74

Example

Example

At the footprint the 2 covers are air-tightly welded + 3-4 times per m² point-wisely joined with thin synthetic ropes which leads to a golf ball shape when the air is blown in

The organic shaped structure with membrane cover became a self-carrying double-wall pneu with minimized assembly and dismantling times

75

Example

76

Example

The Modern Tea House was very concisely designed: form, material and structural analysis were one The details were tested and optimized

77

From 10mbar internal pressure the ‘Peanut’ stands up and with 15mbar the flexible bowl is stable enough to face a storm

78

13

Clever roof Clever roof: complex constraints!

Example

‘God is in the details’ Nic Goldschmidt

The Modern Tea House is a thin-skinned simple room

http://www.self-sheltering.org

79

80

Clever roof Constraints!

Clever roof kit

‘God is in the details’ Nic Goldschmidt

http://www.self-sheltering.org

Holistic approach!

Marijke.Mollaert@vub.ac.be 81

82

14