Seaholm Highlander 9.25.15

Page 1

HIGHLANDER S E A H O L M

H I G H

S C H O O L ’ S

S T U D E N T

2436 W. LINCOLN RD. - BIRMINGHAM, MI 48009

V O I C E

F r i d ay,

S e p t e m be r

2 5 ,

2 0 1 5

WWW.SEAHOLMHIGHLANDER.wordpress.COM

Newsweek Ranking Incorrect Tessa Banks

regards to Newsweek was because the publication shshighlandernews@gmail.com mixed up some data that Principal Rachel Guinn sent Every year, Newsweek in, according comes out with their list to Guinn. ranking high schools across “When the the nation. This year, rankings Seaholm ranked #484 and came out, I Groves ranked #222 out of immediately 500 total schools on the list knew that released August 19. something Newsweek released two lists in regards to high school was wrong,” rankings in 2015. One of the Guinn said. Guinn lists, the one they call their then tracked “absolute” list, only ranks down the schools that perform at or person who above the 70th percentile published for their state, according to Newsweek. Their second list, the Newsweek article “Beating the Odds”, takes and spoke to into account socioeconomic them on the standing and the school’s ability to overcome it. The list phone. The journalist being discussed in the this said that the article is the former. reason for These rankings contradict with lists that have come out Seaholm’s before it, which have consis- low ranktently ranked Seaholm above ing was the school’s Groves. low college US News and World readiness Report’s list ranking high schools in Michigan (public, numbers, charter, and magnet) ranked which she Seaholm in the #5 slot, while claimed to have in her records as blank, Groves was assigned #22. Additionally, Niche K12’s list, but seemed to show in the which only took into account rankings as “0”. “I understood the clout that other public schools, put Seaholm at #4 and Groves at Newsweek has with these rankings as a new principal, #8. so when I filled out the inforOne possible reason for the difference in rankings in mation I had Mrs. Stevenson [the school secretary] check News Editor

the written portions and [Assistant Principal Ali] Hamka check over the numbers for me,” Guinn said. “We are

“[She told me] Newsweek never corrects after the article is published,” Guinn said. Newsweek will never

both human and we both could have missed it, but it seemed a little fishy to me.” Guinn then asked the journalist to rectify the report, because Seaholm has many college bound students, but Guinn did not get the answer she had hoped for.

correct the ranking that it gave Seaholm this year, so Seaholm’s ranking is not accurate. Regardless, there was a gap in rankings between the schools no matter what list was looked at. Seaholm and Groves have essentially the same curricu-

lum, with the only differences being from teacher to teacher and not school to school, both Guinn and Superintendent of BPS Dr. Daniel Nerad confirmed. Due to this fact, many are still puzzled as to why there is such a large discrepancy between the rankings of the schools. “Any type of ranking like that is going to have some sorts of nuances to it, so the fact of the matter is, there’s going to be a difference,” Nerad said. “One is going to be placed at one point and one is going to be placed at another. But at the end of the day, these are two very high quality high schools.” Nerad said that one of the main goals for the schools is to make sure young people are, “future ready,” and he believes that both schools do a very good job at that. However, he warns people to perhaps take the fact numbers of the rankings with a grain of salt. “The reality of it is that both high schools were well placed,” Nerad said. “One was placed erroneously, but both were on this list of high quality high schools across the entire country. I think that is the main message we need to take out of that. There will always be some fine-grain differences.” The Superintendent wanted to reiterate that while

there may be some differences in the actual rankings of the schools, just the fact that both schools are consistently ranked on these lists is a testament to the quality of the schools. “The statement that I use is ‘schools are more than test scores’,” Nerad said. “You can’t, through a test score, talk about all the great things that happen in a high school for the development of young people.” He adds that these rankings don’t take into account extracurriculars, co-curriculars, and other actives which allow students to grow and learn in a different way than in the classroom, which is also a very important aspect of a school. “Through these activities you get to figure out how to get along with people, what your strengths are, what areas you need to improve upon,” Nerad said. “I would think that that is the most important quality of a high school.” If young people find that their school is not only a place that offers great academics but is a place they want to be, Nerad says that those are the things that matter more in the long run. He urges everyone to keep these rankings in context. Both Nerad and Guinn agree that there is far more to a school than just the raw numbers.

Seaholm Students Sills Fun Run A Success Give Reaction to Kim Davis

Mullen, Sills has been working closely with Jo Rosen, shshighlanderfeatures@gmail.com the Relay Life Ambassador in West Bloomfield, as well as a On September 19, Junior volunteer on behalf of ACS. Stephanie Sills and the “Stephanie impressed me,” American Cancer Society Rosen said. “She was putting (ACS) hosted a run to raise forth so much effort to make a money for lung cancer difference in Lung Cancer. research at Seaholm High Rosen was most impressed School. The run raised alwith the most 20,000 immense dollars, with support all proceeds given by the going directly Seaholm to the ACS. community Sills’ mother to Sills, and is currently in turn fighting lung Sills to her cancer. mother. “She’s done “The with radiaschool tion, but still supports has to get these young chemotherapy people, and treatments in addievery week,” tion their Sills said, “It’s families and an aggresPhoto Courtesy of Gwyneth Lietz friends have sive form of From left to right: Stephanie Sills, Mary Kate Mullen and Tess been donatcancer, and it Collins. The three girls raised almost 200 dollars for lung never really cancer research. ing to the Lung Run goes away.” to ensure the run. Despite being in remission, great success,” Rosen said. The run went off without regular chemotherapy treat217 runners showed up to a hitch. Despite adverse ments now must be a weekly support the cause, as well as weather conditions, many ordeal for Beth Sills, a fifty33 volunteers. people came out to show their five-year-old mother of two. One of these runners, junior Sills’ motive for the run was support of the Sills’ family. Audrey Ladd, was extremely "Although the weather was fairly straightforward. proud of her fellow cross not in our favor, the turn out “I just wanted to help my country teammate. was amazing! So many people mom,” Sills said. “It was awesome that she came out to support this great According to the Ameriput this whole thing together,” cause” Mullen said can Lung Association, lung Ladd said. “The whole team is Mullen and Collins played cancer is the disease with the really proud.” intricate roles in the success most fatalities for both men The team is just one fraction of the run. and women in America. In of the Seaholm supporters “I was just really proud of order to honor her mother, Ladd has. According to Rosen, Stephanie, and wanted to do Sills came up with the idea to the support of the Seaholm anything I could to help,” Colhave a run to raise money for community has been staggerlins said. the cause. In addition to Collins and There was a lot to be done See RUN / Pg. 3

Caroline Owens Features Editor

Charlotte Hoppen

shared that although he does support same-sex marriage, shshighlandereditorinchief@gmail. he does believe that Davis had Annamarie Wehby the right to preform the acStaff Writer tions she was in support of. shshighlanderstaff@gmail.com “Everyone has the right to their own opinion,” Fritz said. Kimberly Jean Bailey Da“She has the right to her own vis, a country clerk of Rowan opinion and she stood by it.” County, Kentucky made naHowever, social studies tional news when she refused teacher Bob Carleton believes to issue marriage licenses that due to her position of to both gay and straight couples. Davis Davis was ar- power, Davis has a duty to rested on September 3, 2015 preform all actions granted by the federal law. He believes with the charge of contempt that she should put her opinof court. After spending five days in ions aside and do what she was hired to do. jail, Davis was released on “She’s in violation of the law September 8, 2015. Accordand she’s depriving someone ing to The Washington Post, Davis was allowed to resume of their rights,” Carleton said. Claiming religious freedom her job as long as she agreed in order to deny marriage not to interfere with the marlicenses can blur the lines beriage licenses. tween what is federally manAfter the Supreme Court dated and what is part of basic ruled in favor of gay marconstitutional rights. Flex riage on June 26, 2015, gay teacher Peter Smith believes and lesbian couples have that Davis was incorrect in her the right to marry in all 50 defense using the first amendstates. However, Davis bement because she was taking lieved that the action of distributing marriage licenses to away the rights of others. “I think she did deserve to gay couples went against her go to jail because she was religious beliefs. in violation of the rule of Seaholm is a community filled with different opinions law,” Smith said. “When she claimed religious freedom, surrounding the Davis case, I thought it was ironic that and a mixture of students people use the first amendand teachers allowed the ment to deny the first amendHighlander to hear their ments of others.” thoughts on the situation. Some believe that jail as a Sophomore Noah Fritz Editor-in-Chief

result of Davis’s actions was a harsh price to pay. However, senior Maclane Paddock believes that Davis should be treated as equally as any other law-breaking citizen. “Not only was she disrespectful to the judge but she also was disobeying a federal law,” Paddock said. “Just like any other law, she should be sent to prison for that.” There was speculation from the general public if Davis should be able to return to her job as county clerk. Each day Davis will have to issue marriage licenses, and some of these will be given to samesex couples. Davis claims she doesn’t plan on changing her opinions or actions based on the law, but Smith believes she should follow what is federally mandated. “I think she should resign because if she’s not willing to enforce the law, then she’s not willing to do her job then she should resign or be fired,” Smith said. “If I didn’t do my job or I refused to preform my job, I would get fired.” Senior Eric Ruthruff believes that Davis shouldn’t have been given her job back in the first place. “I don’t think that anyone who just declines to do their job should just have it handed See DAVIS / Pg. 2

in order for the run to be a success. Donors had to be contacted to support the run with food, water, shirts and other necessary materials. Sills was in charge of it all. Sills also enlisted two of her good friends and fellow juniors, Tess Collins and Mary Kate Mullen, to help her plan

Inside the Highlander Contents News

2

News

Opinion Features

4 Seaholm students and teachers plan a 5

Features In-Depth Sports

6 7 8

trip to Cuba.

See Page 2

Opinion

Features

In-Depth

Sports

The Highlander provides insight on college meetings.

Coby Moscowitz travels to the Olympic Trials for Archery.

The Highlander asks students and teachers about their opinions on samesex marriage.

New boy’s tennis coach brings his philosophy to Seaholm.

See Page 4

See Page 5

See Page 7

See Page 8


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.